The Deranged Queen Called “The She-Wolf Of France”

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 лют 2025
  • Isabella of France began her life as an innocent French maid, and ended it as one of the most ruthless monarchs England ever saw.
    ‪@Factinate‬Facts about everything.
    ‪@SplashTravels‬Explore the globe, uncover its secrets.
    Visit the site: www.historyexp...
    TikTok: / historyexpose

КОМЕНТАРІ • 434

  • @TheHistoryExpose
    @TheHistoryExpose  Місяць тому +14

    Cesare Borgia: Monster, murderer, Antichrist. People have called him many things-but few know how twisted his story truly is: ua-cam.com/video/mzKOsH1YQ5s/v-deo.html

  • @kathejohnson4241
    @kathejohnson4241 Місяць тому +58

    Let's not confuse cruelty, lust for power, and ruthlessness with strength.

  • @censusgary
    @censusgary Місяць тому +178

    Whether Edward and Piers Gaveston were lovers, adoptive brothers, or just close friends, it doesn’t seem to have been their intimacy that the barons objected to. Rather, it was Edward’s blatant favoritism to Gaveston in matters of patronage that led them to rebel.

    • @777CaptMark
      @777CaptMark Місяць тому

      @@censusgary Oh, they were definitely butt buddies. No serious historian I’ve ever heard about has questioned this.

    • @ZarpSterr
      @ZarpSterr Місяць тому +17

      Flamers were quite common amongst the males of the aristocracy, in the UK and Europe. Studying certain portraits of royal males, also clues us in.
      In fact, it lead to the extinction of certain Royal Houses of old, due to a lack of progeny.

    • @TomLaios
      @TomLaios Місяць тому +9

      @@ZarpSterr lol.Flamers! I haven't heard that in a while. Benders seems to have taken over.

    • @Krzyszczynski
      @Krzyszczynski Місяць тому +3

      @@TomLaios Haven't previously heard it at all! Benders, yes, plus a whole lot of other terms, but never flamers.

    • @TomLaios
      @TomLaios Місяць тому

      @@Krzyszczynski pillow biters,midnight visitors to vegemite valley, poofta, poof, but these days LGMQTI++ etc.

  • @longyx321
    @longyx321 18 днів тому +26

    The actress who played Isabella is a real beauty herself ❤.

  • @philippekogler
    @philippekogler Місяць тому +223

    She was not deranged. Isabelle was a great queen. Sent to England at the age of 12 years she was left aside, neglected and humilated. And finally they took her kids away. But she prevailed. Compared to Edward II she had the bigger balls.....

    • @laurentdevaux5617
      @laurentdevaux5617 Місяць тому +12

      Her name's Isabelle, not Isabeau ! Isabeau is the nickname of the infamous Elisabeth von Wittelsbach-Ingolstadt, wife of Charles VI, who nearly sold France to England. But i agree withe the rest of what you said. And above all, Isabelle was everything but deranged !

    • @philippekogler
      @philippekogler Місяць тому +7

      @@laurentdevaux5617 T´as raison. Ma faute. Je corrige.....

    • @mystikmind2005
      @mystikmind2005 Місяць тому +7

      "Isabelle was a great queen" Can't have been that great a queen when she pissed everyone off including her son during her rule as regent.

    • @dingodog5677
      @dingodog5677 Місяць тому

      That sounds like feminist justification of terrible actions.

    • @roberthudson3386
      @roberthudson3386 29 днів тому

      @@mystikmind2005 Not to mentioned probably played a role in Edward II's murder (or exile).

  • @klackon1
    @klackon1 Місяць тому +117

    I used to live near to where Piers Gaveston was executed by the Earl of Warwick, who he named the Black Dog of Arden, and other lords. The inscription on the memorial reads: "In the hollow of this rock was beheaded on the 17 day of July 1312, by barons lawless as himself, Piers Gaveston, Earl of Cornwall, the minion of a hateful king, in life and death a memorable instance of misrule".

    • @donnadees1971
      @donnadees1971 Місяць тому +1

      But your info wasn’t coincident with clickbait.

    • @ZarpSterr
      @ZarpSterr Місяць тому +17

      the key words >>> " by barons lawless as himself."
      Yes, just a bunch of criminals who dressed well.
      Nothing much has changed, to this day.

    • @francesdoyle1508
      @francesdoyle1508 Місяць тому +2

      In English, or French?

    • @brianpeck4035
      @brianpeck4035 Місяць тому +1

      @@ZarpSterr What a mischaracterization! Those criminals were upper management and performed many functions. Those who wish to eat the rich don't know how bad- bad can get.

    • @ZarpSterr
      @ZarpSterr Місяць тому

      @@brianpeck4035 And that excuses their behaviour because they're "upper" management and rich.....really.

  • @terrysmith4831
    @terrysmith4831 Місяць тому +132

    Blood thirsty ancient nobles or blood thirsty modern politicians, nothing has changed.

    • @steveclapper5424
      @steveclapper5424 28 днів тому +6

      that is because those guys and our guys serve the money that gives them power.

    • @SeymourButts-k2j
      @SeymourButts-k2j 25 днів тому +1

      What politicians are bloodthirsty ? Who are you talking about ?

    • @Maya_Pinion
      @Maya_Pinion 23 дні тому

      👏

    • @TheRealDeadhorse
      @TheRealDeadhorse 21 день тому

      LOL. Right. People are still living in hovels with near starvation levels of nutrition. Slavery and serfdom are everywhere. There are only three levels of society with different rules and no one can better themselves because they have zero access to education or free time. Are you ok?

    • @mikeneill6813
      @mikeneill6813 16 днів тому +1

      @@steveclapper5424 Typo? "revere" Regards.

  • @WildWestGal
    @WildWestGal Місяць тому +41

    I knew nothing about this Queen's history. Very interesting, and very well done, James. Per usual!

    • @Fairred6507
      @Fairred6507 26 днів тому +5

      On Audible, there is a book called The Three Edwards. It contains a detailed narrative of Edward II and Isabella.

  • @gloriamontgomery6900
    @gloriamontgomery6900 Місяць тому +217

    She certainly was not deranged. Her husband was irresponsible and unfit to rule. And she had a lot of support for that view

    • @ireminsel
      @ireminsel Місяць тому +11

      Also Edward is in love with Piers Gaventon. Önce Edward gave all her money to him

    • @ireminsel
      @ireminsel Місяць тому +9

      Mortimer became her lover.

  • @donaldcurtis9229
    @donaldcurtis9229 22 дні тому +10

    Braveheart might not been accurate but the story was very good was one of the greatest movies of all time for Scotland's Independence

  • @Nova-cb3fv
    @Nova-cb3fv Місяць тому +120

    Pretty stupid of her sisters-in-laws to give their knight lovers such easy identificatable gifts.

    • @ZarpSterr
      @ZarpSterr Місяць тому +7

      Especially, considering how hypocritical Isabella had her own lovers, on the sly.
      I suppose they just assumed, well she does, so can we.
      Mirror,Mirror on the Wall, who is the fairest of them all...asked Isabella.
      NOT YOU !.....but O, your Sisters-in-law are SUPER-hot.
      That's what threw her into a rage.

    • @colonelfustercluck486
      @colonelfustercluck486 Місяць тому +19

      the knights / lovers were out of their minds displaying their 'souvenirs' on top of their clothing, in either England or France.
      IT must have been done deliberately for some reason, but the plan went wrong for them.

    • @carolinejohnson22
      @carolinejohnson22 Місяць тому

      Are the 'enactments' shown part of a film or drama? If so, what was it please??

    • @jpdj2715
      @jpdj2715 Місяць тому

      @@ZarpSterr - not sure I'll sit through the video. They may be called nobility but if you describe in plain words how these royals operated, without any reference to nobility, and ask someone read that and to tell you how they would call that, I'm sure one of the descriptions would read "organised crime" or "mafia".
      Second, what your Latin teacher never told you ... "she-wolf" is a translation of Latin "lupa". Roman mythology tells that the city of Rome got founded by two guys, Romulus and Remus, who had been raised by a "lupa".
      These two are depicted as toddlers getting nursed by a female wolf.
      Well, the Latin word "lupa" was "code" and used to reference female prostitutes or nymphomaniacs. In Roman times, prostitution was forbidden but as long as it was kept below the radar, it was not prosecuted.
      Advertising it was forbidden, except in graveyards. And this is where archaeologists have found "business cards". Imagine a business card of the time that reads something like "Giulia - doggy - 200". Name, specialisation, price. When my guide and university teacher of Latin told me that on a visit of a graveyard in Rome, my response was, "ah, now I understand the deeper meaning in the bible of "what do you search the living among the dead - and the debate among theologians that women in the new testament may have been prostitutes!"
      Well, nothing new. Go to the oldest parts of Los Angeles and find streets with a woman's, girl's, name. In the migration waves to the West, gold diggers and other opportunists, there were few women there and lots of men. The streets got named after a woman that "worked a street" maybe as boss of a house where women work lying down in order to keep standing in life.
      If way back, Isabella was called "she-wolf" then she was not so subtly accused of screwing around. Considering people's attitudes towards sexuality and marriage in the Middle Ages, the question is if that was actually said in her time, or only later, by hysterians.

    • @danaeads919
      @danaeads919 Місяць тому +8

      @@carolinejohnson22 They are scenes from the Mel Gibson movie, "Braveheart."

  • @fiachramaccana280
    @fiachramaccana280 Місяць тому +37

    She didn't resort to anything. She simply reported her suspicions to her father the French King. He made his own decisions and owns the consequences.

    • @iamperplexed4695
      @iamperplexed4695 Місяць тому

      The little girl went running to Daddy is what you are saying.

    • @Tman001100
      @Tman001100 13 днів тому

      She didn't have to report anything, though. She made a choice. It's weird when people don't acknowledge or even realize how cruel and corrupt most royalty were. She's not a saint and being cruel is not "strength". Screw off with that BS. Can't stand the glorification of royals. They control the narrative and most will be too egotistical to ever paint themselves as flawed and in the wrong which they often were, including Isabella.

  • @greenmoss9079
    @greenmoss9079 Місяць тому +220

    Lets be honest Edward the second was no prize and a sorry weak ruler. I blame him for all the troubles during that period. If he had his wits together and put his kingdom first and treated his wife well, things would have been very different

    • @gloriamontgomery6900
      @gloriamontgomery6900 Місяць тому +38

      He was outrageous. He gave her wedding gifts to his current boyfriend and ignored his new wife .

    • @novallasuter5265
      @novallasuter5265 Місяць тому +29

      ABSOLUTELY, I CONCUR! SHE WASN'T MAD. SHE WAS PISSED and with good reason.

    • @ZarpSterr
      @ZarpSterr Місяць тому

      I doubt it. If it wasn't the Flamer problem, it would have been something else.
      There were the dissident Barons, problems with France, and many other Psychopathic-Narcissistic reasonings.
      These "royals" were always at each other's throats.
      Back-stabbing, plotting, for personal advancement.
      The usurpers of the Norman invasion of 1066, had created all manner of hidden and serpentine behaviour.....after wiping out the original English Royals.
      Land-grabs, and other piratical behaviour.

    • @AshleyMartin-f3x
      @AshleyMartin-f3x Місяць тому +12

      Agreed and he was flaunting his way love affair as well

    • @ianbeddowes5362
      @ianbeddowes5362 Місяць тому +3

      Check the excellent play Edward II by Christopher Marlowe.

  • @TerryElrodAB
    @TerryElrodAB 9 днів тому +4

    Don't envy those who lived back then. Not even rich royalty.

  • @asylumlover
    @asylumlover 18 днів тому +5

    KEEP THIS BRUTAL MEDIEVAL HISTORY COMING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @KarenElston
    @KarenElston Місяць тому +142

    I think the name she wolf is a compliment.

    • @Meggzilla
      @Meggzilla Місяць тому +19

      Right? I know that I'd be complimented by being called a she wolf instead of just drop dead gorgeous all the time... 😂😂😂😂

    • @ittybittykittymama7582
      @ittybittykittymama7582 Місяць тому +17

      Admirers of Queen Boudica unite!

    • @winstonelston5743
      @winstonelston5743 Місяць тому

      She has been called _The Harlot Queen._
      And no relation that I know of....

    • @altarush
      @altarush Місяць тому +2

      Why do they insult women or wolves ?

    • @eldermillennial8330
      @eldermillennial8330 Місяць тому

      @@ittybittykittymama7582
      Wasn’t she a granddaughter of Cu Chullain?

  • @janeaparis
    @janeaparis 27 днів тому +8

    People were so cruel to each other, even and especially sometimes the well-to-do. Killing your mother's lover because you want power seems pretty ruthless, along with some of the very gruesome death's these people suffered.

  • @altareggo
    @altareggo Місяць тому +24

    AWESOME narration!!!!! Kudos.

  • @SurnaturalM
    @SurnaturalM Місяць тому +22

    "Les rois maudits" give a depiction of what happened with Edwards II.
    As far as I'm concerned, being called "the she wolf of France" is awesome.

    • @KarenElston
      @KarenElston Місяць тому

      Rumours at the time say he was killed by a hot poker up the bum.not by Isabella but angry lords who disputed his favouritism to piers and homosexuality.

  • @gloriagates6976
    @gloriagates6976 18 днів тому +7

    Thank you for this wonderful information on this part of english history.
    What. What you told.
    Us was much better than what the title said. Thank you. And yes, I have been a subscriber to you for a very long time. Always look forward to your videos.❤

  • @czgator9000
    @czgator9000 Місяць тому +49

    We must not forget that Philip IV of France, (Philip the Fair), who was chronically short of money, had the Knights Templar in France arrested on October 13, 1307, had them tortured to confess to all sorts of heretical acts, then burned alive. Then he confiscated all their wealth and property. It is believed he did this because he had borrowed money from them and did not want to pay it back. So Isabella knew what he was capable of when she reported the possible affairs. Even though the husbands, who were also given embroidered purses, could have given them to the knights as gifts, they were just assumed guilty.

    • @jcf9499
      @jcf9499 Місяць тому +5

      Wouldn't the husbands have spoken up about that? ...assuming they both didn't have any clear reason to get rid of their wives or those particular knights.

    • @fiachramaccana280
      @fiachramaccana280 Місяць тому +13

      er.....there was a lot more evidence than that. They used to hang out in a tower together. La Tour de Nesle near one of the gates of Paris. And were caught doing just that. So it wasn't just about embroidered purses that Isabelle had given her sister's in law. In short the knights weren't caught in the Tour de Nesle hanging out with the princes. But rather the princesses.
      Also I have never read that she gave the same purses to her brothers. Source please? And even if she did, were they all the same design? I doubt you would give ladies and gentlemen the exact same design and colour purses in the 14th century. Any more than you would in any other century including today.
      She recognised the gifts as the purses she had given her sister's in law. And reported same to her father. Who had them all followed and gathered the additional evidence. So lets stop with the "they were just assumed guilty" nonsense

    • @fiachramaccana280
      @fiachramaccana280 Місяць тому +2

      @@jcf9499 one of the husbands did. Frankly there was too much incriminating evidence.

    • @eldermillennial8330
      @eldermillennial8330 Місяць тому +4

      He never got anywhere near a fraction of the wealth he expected them to have.
      Either they really WERE keeping their vows of poverty and only using the minimum funding to maintain their armor and weapons, or the legend of their hidden treasure is true. But IF it is true, I lean more towards the theory that the Mali sultan, Mansa Musa stumbled across it before any Templar survivors could reclaim it on an island off the coast of Spain during a raiding expedition.
      The island is known to have been an alternate rest stop for crusaders if they didn’t want to rest at Gibraltar if they had rivals there.

    • @fiachramaccana280
      @fiachramaccana280 Місяць тому +5

      @eldermillennial8330 not sure why you drag Mansa Musa into this. Other than some vaguely racist reasoning that an African King can only get rich by stealing from somebody. He owned huge mines. He didnt need Templar wealth.
      As for why the Templars didnt have " a lot of portable riches" the answer is simple. They operated as a corporation and no corporation ever has a lot of ready cash lying about. Otherwise they are not doing their job.
      Wealth is tied up in assets like land and buildings. Or lent out to creditors. And any portable valuables/relics were taken out before SHTF.
      Then the land/buildings were seized. And creditors lay low and pretended they didnt owe a penny. Its obvious King Phillip already had a sizeable portion of Templar wealth as a loan. Which he never repaid.
      To sum up corporations have assets and liabilities and rarely keep huge amounts of cash/gold or portable wealth. Because its not efficient. Its dead wealth. It only yields a return as an asset or a loan.

  • @jamesfetherston1190
    @jamesfetherston1190 Місяць тому +33

    The content of the video is better than the silly, misleading, clickbait title.

  • @jeanmartin9614
    @jeanmartin9614 Місяць тому +21

    Pink crushed velvet! Maybe in the sixties, but not in medieval England. If Braveheart got anything right, it was an accident.

    • @1BobsYourUncle
      @1BobsYourUncle 21 день тому

      Awww, a butt hurt British sympathizer…😆🤣😂

  • @deannacrownover3
    @deannacrownover3 Місяць тому +9

    Isabella was not deranged, she was fed up.
    Everything she had inherited, all of her clothes, all of her jewels and even her footstool were taken from her and given to Edwards "favorite" Piers Galveston.
    Hubby didn't understand that playing by his rules was going to end him.
    After the execution of Piers Galveston, he got even worse with the DeSpensers.
    He simply got what was coming to him.

    • @mikeneill6813
      @mikeneill6813 16 днів тому +1

      Yup the footstool would "do it" for me too.

    • @deannacrownover3
      @deannacrownover3 15 днів тому +2

      @@mikeneill6813 right? Enough is enough already!
      Losing 2 billion dollars worth of land, property, armies, jewelry, jeweled books from her uncle the Pope didn't do it. But losing that footstool.....

  • @TheLyds01
    @TheLyds01 22 дні тому +4

    She doesn’t sound deranged to me. She sounds intelligent

  • @Pakylousy
    @Pakylousy Місяць тому +28

    You all should read “Les rois modits” by Maurice Druon , you can have a more complete story of what happened to Isabelle , this is one pf my favorite serie of books

  • @isabelledetaillefer2726
    @isabelledetaillefer2726 21 день тому +4

    There's a sea of lies about Isabelle of France concoted by the British haters at court. Edward was a deviant man, a demeaning husband & a monstrous oppressor of his subjects, so much so that the populace welcomed the Queen with open arms when she came back from exile and defeated her husband to prepare the throne for her son. Her life did not become easier or less controversial in the wake of it, but we do know that she spent her latter years in piety and building churches all over England.

  • @gillianlethuillier5212
    @gillianlethuillier5212 Місяць тому +6

    Thank you for a very informative video.

  • @gilanbarona9814
    @gilanbarona9814 20 днів тому +4

    It seems that this is why queens move more powerfully than kings on a chessboard. The Isabella the chess queen is based on was the wife of Ferdinand of Spain. This Isabelle can just as easily be a chess queen as well.

    • @Lisa-x3n5x
      @Lisa-x3n5x 17 днів тому +1

      Nice analogy. And the King has to be protected. Thankyou.

    • @spaceskipster4412
      @spaceskipster4412 13 днів тому

      The King is always in Charge. 🤴🏼👑
      The Queen is always in Control. 👸🏻👑

  • @laurentdevaux5617
    @laurentdevaux5617 Місяць тому +37

    Calling the queen Isabelle deranged is an insult. If there was someone deranged in her couple, it's Edward, not her. i would even dare to say that the real man was her, at least in terms of governance and intelligence, not her husband. And she never was called "She-wolf of France" during her lifetime, this nickname was created much after

    • @kellydalstok8900
      @kellydalstok8900 Місяць тому +4

      I wouldn’t call Edward deranged either. He was just weak and probably gay as well.

    • @roberthudson3386
      @roberthudson3386 29 днів тому +2

      How can anyone justify calling Edward deranged? Give me one argument to support that.

    • @SlimKeith11
      @SlimKeith11 29 днів тому +1

      If she were a man, they'd describe her as tough, decisive or brutal but for women it's "deranged, overly emotional" yada yada bullsh-t.

    • @paulhodgetts1803
      @paulhodgetts1803 24 дні тому

      Half of these idiots get their opinions from the fact that one of them was a man and the other a strong independent powerful woman, so best ignore it​@@roberthudson3386

  • @muttley5958
    @muttley5958 Місяць тому +7

    Thanks for the history lesson. 🤔
    That was very interesting. 😃

  • @angiec1960too
    @angiec1960too Місяць тому +39

    Even today people want to speak of the sins of the woman while taking up for the weak man.

    • @kellydalstok8900
      @kellydalstok8900 Місяць тому +6

      If he screwed around because he wasn’t interested in her, I feel that she had every right to seek happiness elsewhere too. Unfortunately the world has been very misogynistic for a long time and women were treated a possessions.

    • @dingodog5677
      @dingodog5677 Місяць тому

      Well, there’s plenty of sinning women throughout history. The idea all women are angels is ridiculous. They can be just as nasty or worse than most men.

  • @ford289cid7
    @ford289cid7 23 дні тому +3

    Any archaeologists or historians get around to giving Edward II's and Edward III's remains a DNA test to make sure they were father and son?

  • @KimberlyPatton-x1n
    @KimberlyPatton-x1n 27 днів тому +3

    What a remarkable and chaos filled life she lived! If not for her greed and spending she might have retained a higher place and high esteem.That and her double standard when it came to adultery.

  • @user-adoyle123
    @user-adoyle123 Місяць тому +26

    Brilliant I so love history. Can you put up the one about the 2 boys in the tower. Hi from Ireland 😊

    • @CROM-on1bz
      @CROM-on1bz Місяць тому +2

      Hi friend, search the web for a French soap opera called "Les Rois Maudits" it is adapted from the books by Maurice Druon an excellent author and historian, the English subtitles are available if like I think you do not speak French. You have everything, the trial of the Templars, the affair of the Tower of Nesle and the end of the King of England and his method of execution. Have fun.

    • @Tman001100
      @Tman001100 13 днів тому +1

      Too bad much of history is written by "winners" and thus, often inaccurate.

  • @elizabethnasekapow6718
    @elizabethnasekapow6718 18 днів тому +9

    Thank you for the beautiful music you had playing in the video. It was so lovely ❤❤

    • @EmyDawnGenX
      @EmyDawnGenX 16 днів тому +3

      I'm so glad you mentioned this. It is very pretty 😊

    • @pamelaplumb112
      @pamelaplumb112 8 днів тому +1

      I know right!? I absolutely enjoyed the music. It wasn't too loud & overbearing like some videos do

  • @jenniferbreaux7385
    @jenniferbreaux7385 Місяць тому +42

    I had forgotten how historically inaccurate, but awesome, braveheart was.

    • @Alan-gh8X
      @Alan-gh8X Місяць тому +2

      What do you expect from Mel Gibson he is a moron

    • @ruthbennett2019
      @ruthbennett2019 Місяць тому +10

      It was a ridiculous film. The events and characters were utterly inaccurate. Weapons, clothing, hairstyles, locations all wrong too. A Holywood travesty of history.

    • @jamesfetherston1190
      @jamesfetherston1190 Місяць тому +3

      @@ruthbennett2019 Mel Gibson repeated this historical nonsense in “The Patriot”, which is just as awful.

    • @FelonyVideos
      @FelonyVideos Місяць тому +4

      It was a work of fiction, not a documentary. Just like all politics today.

    • @alexwallace5486
      @alexwallace5486 29 днів тому +3

      Braveheart was nonsense

  • @ladylunaginaofgames40
    @ladylunaginaofgames40 Місяць тому +144

    Let's be real, she went down as the woman who stepped up cus she had the misfortune to marry a gay, wussy king.

    • @NyghtDarkwatch
      @NyghtDarkwatch Місяць тому +24

      Alexander the Great conquered half the known world, he married for an heir, but set up statues of his male lover in every land he gained in war. Sexual preference has nothing to do with ambition.

    • @ladylunaginaofgames40
      @ladylunaginaofgames40 Місяць тому +32

      @NyghtDarkwatch true, but note I said "Wussy" king. It's not just the fact he's only interested in guys, it's the fact he was a pretty weak ruler who gave in to his male lovers than actually rule.

    • @MLennholm
      @MLennholm Місяць тому

      Edward II had mistresses and sired an illegitimate son, so he was clearly not gay. Possibly bi, but there's also no real evidence that his relationships with his male favourites were sexual in nature.

    • @warpedweft9004
      @warpedweft9004 Місяць тому

      @@NyghtDarkwatch he had more than one wife/concubine, at least 3 that we know of, so I suspect he was bi rather than gay.

    • @eldermillennial8330
      @eldermillennial8330 Місяць тому +10

      @@NyghtDarkwatch
      Depends on if he’s a top or bottom.
      Alex was a top. Ed was a bottom.

  • @welshpete12
    @welshpete12 Місяць тому +15

    A grizzly time to live . This was a most excellent explanation !

    • @linshanhsiang
      @linshanhsiang Місяць тому +5

      It's "grisly" not "grizzly", (a kind of bear!)

    • @maringal44
      @maringal44 Місяць тому

      @@linshanhsiangthank you! this spelling error is always one of the more annoying ones

  • @ml50486965
    @ml50486965 Місяць тому +6

    Where did the "deranged" part come in? Apparently, Isabella acted like every body else at power in her days, and for centuries to come!

    • @Tman001100
      @Tman001100 13 днів тому +1

      She probably was deranged but so was damn near everyone else. Doesn't make it right or just, though.

  • @lynnbooth7166
    @lynnbooth7166 28 днів тому +3

    The books by Maurice, Druon The Accursed Kings, are a really good insight into French History and Isabella.

  • @unrulycrow6299
    @unrulycrow6299 Місяць тому +5

    She wasn't deranged, she had to step up in place of the weak king she was married to. Her ruthlessness and political acumen are to be expected, especially considering her upbringing (she was the most Philip-like of all of Philip Le Bel's children, and his treatment of the Templars says everything regarding his own ruthlessness).

  • @aussie6910
    @aussie6910 28 днів тому +2

    Next someone will question the accuracy of Braveheart.

  • @sheebathefunnyrescuedog692
    @sheebathefunnyrescuedog692 Місяць тому +40

    Braveheart isn't historically accurate, so lets just go with it 😂😂😂😂

    • @martabachynsky8545
      @martabachynsky8545 Місяць тому +6

      Good visuals! 😀

    • @linshanhsiang
      @linshanhsiang Місяць тому

      Braveheart as history is a joke! The Scots would not have had any idea of "freedom" such as we do. They were a feudal society of loyalty to their clans.

  • @Tracey-t4n
    @Tracey-t4n Місяць тому +23

    Really enjoyed this, narrator is very good. Ill be backm 🙌🏻💚🇮🇪

    • @yts70r135
      @yts70r135 Місяць тому +2

      Is he Irish? I love his accent

    • @Tracey-t4n
      @Tracey-t4n Місяць тому +4

      @yts70r135 hi, I haven't a clue could be or maybe not. But great voice for narrating. 🙌🏻💚🇮🇪

    • @yts70r135
      @yts70r135 Місяць тому +4

      @@Tracey-t4n i absolutely agree. Take care. Happy new year.

    • @WildWestGal
      @WildWestGal Місяць тому +5

      @@yts70r135 James is a Scotsman. And, yes, he makes excellent videos. There's something about a Scottish accent!

    • @genevievedolan1288
      @genevievedolan1288 Місяць тому +4

      @@yts70r135I think his accent is Scottish

  • @philiptownsend4026
    @philiptownsend4026 22 дні тому +2

    Excellent. Subscribed.

  • @bertieschitz-peas429
    @bertieschitz-peas429 3 дні тому

    Edward and Dispenser fled to Wales, I found out in my library they sought refuge in the Llyfi Valley and the village of Llan which is 5 miles from my home. There was a tree with vee shaped trunk that was a favourite spot for Edward to sit and ponder his future.

  •  4 дні тому +1

    That overhead pic of the castle was that a 1300 model EV driving by. ? 😁

  • @scollyer.tuition
    @scollyer.tuition Місяць тому +4

    A brilliant fictionalised account of this period is Maurice Druon's "Les Rois Maudits" (The Cursed Kings) series of novels. The books cover all of the events discussed in this video, and considerably more. (as various other people have already mentioned, I see...)

  • @charlenebaganzmoore
    @charlenebaganzmoore Місяць тому +20

    17:02 She was the brother's sister, if my brother's wife cheated and I knew. I would tell him

    • @jcf9499
      @jcf9499 Місяць тому +1

      Yeah but, their father was not just a parent but also ruler of France, so had a keen interest in who was spawning babies that, on the face of it, were in the line of succession to his throne. He'd probably have been pretty angry and/or ruthlessly violent if not told first.

    • @ZarpSterr
      @ZarpSterr Місяць тому

      Philip the Fair ?....he was no Brad Pitt.
      Isabella the Vengeful.
      Mommy the Homicided.
      What a lovely family.

    • @kwentiel8452
      @kwentiel8452 Місяць тому

      I wouldn't if it was going to get people killed. And it was clear people was going to die for it. Moreover, she took her own lover later. Hipocrital is what I call it.
      I think she was a brave woman and I'm in her side against her husband. But she was prideful and she thought her french royal blood put her over everyone.

  • @foodlover2236
    @foodlover2236 5 днів тому

    So let me get this straight. She gets her sisters in law into trouble for possible affairs but has no problem carrying on one herself !
    Good documentary and thanks

  • @uppitywoman
    @uppitywoman Місяць тому +31

    King Edward ii, supposed to be killed by insertion of a red hot poker 1327. Historians not sure, but there is is.

    • @KathleenPatterson-u6y
      @KathleenPatterson-u6y Місяць тому +12

      That's what was taught in my history class.

    • @virginiashirley4139
      @virginiashirley4139 Місяць тому +8

      I heard that too!

    • @WildWestGal
      @WildWestGal Місяць тому +12

      Me. three. But let's face it, if James had put that in the video, the minions of the YT Kingdom would have banned it or forced a blackscreen during the narration.

    • @ZarpSterr
      @ZarpSterr Місяць тому

      Insertion of a red hot poker.....thus confirming he was a notorious Flamer.
      Yes, it seems appropriate.

    • @rosemaryprobert8099
      @rosemaryprobert8099 Місяць тому +6

      That's the story told in Berkely Castle too, where Edward is said to have died.

  • @nmritter
    @nmritter Місяць тому +8

    I totally understand Isabella. I gave 2 dooney Burke handbags to my sis for xmas. She sold them. Wish I could do the same Isabella did. Good for her!! Those ingrate didn't deserve the handbag gifts she gave..

    • @YeshuaKingMessiah
      @YeshuaKingMessiah 4 дні тому

      I would have sold them too
      Why would anyone keep such crazy things
      Anything trashy that I can get money for? Gone. I’m not a billboard lol

  • @apt221bbakerst
    @apt221bbakerst Місяць тому +5

    I found out that I am related to King Edward II, Queen Isabelle and her boyfriend. It would s always interesting that strong female leaders and rulers are often attacked because they weren't decorative arm candy, kept docile and had babies. She-Wolf is suppose to be a put down, but it is a compliment. The poor girl was married off at 12 to a man who was too occupied by his boyfriend and became a ruler till her son took over. She outsmarted her husband and others and figured out how to survive. I am proud of her!

    • @iamperplexed4695
      @iamperplexed4695 Місяць тому

      Don't assign 21rst century ideas to medieval peoples. You were not the same, especially if that someone was a royal.

    • @wingnut71
      @wingnut71 28 днів тому

      Grow up you silly girl. She was an extremely privileged woman who had all sorts of advantages in life and was probably not a very nice person as a result.

  • @WhiteTemplar01
    @WhiteTemplar01 28 днів тому +13

    This video is so wrong. She wasn't "deranged" and she wasn't the one who ordered the punishment of her sister-in-law and their lovers.

  • @alvashoemaker8536
    @alvashoemaker8536 11 днів тому +1

    “SHE WOLF…!” 😲😡😡

  • @Maya_Pinion
    @Maya_Pinion 23 дні тому +1

    Had it sewed shut? People tend to think women cannot be too cruel.... The story from grade school; " the lady or the tiger" says it all.

    • @sylviaburns2995
      @sylviaburns2995 15 днів тому +1

      How would they menstruate??? Infection would happen no doubt.

  • @Chance-ry1hq
    @Chance-ry1hq 20 днів тому +2

    And we think our politicians are bad…

    • @mikeneill6813
      @mikeneill6813 16 днів тому

      They are. But these days they have myriad ways of screwing each other over. "Drawing and Quartering" is messy and frowned upon. Regards.

  • @jewel65
    @jewel65 Місяць тому +4

    You can't judge the past by todays standards!

  • @konradschargel5314
    @konradschargel5314 Місяць тому +4

    Well, hell has no fury worse than….

  • @ml50486965
    @ml50486965 Місяць тому +2

    A rumor about Edward II goes, that he was impaled with a redhot spit.

  • @donaldcurtis9229
    @donaldcurtis9229 22 дні тому +1

    😮 Edward Longshanks that most brutal King that ever sat on the throne of England his son was gay and God bless her she was a great Queen

  • @tracymorgan5386
    @tracymorgan5386 19 днів тому +1

    What happened were Isabella sisters in law fault, what were they thinking betraying the kings sons & not thinking of the consequences, it’s not Isabella fault that she had a brain.

  • @Merrymangos
    @Merrymangos 27 днів тому +2

    You do a fantastic job…love the presentation and delivery 👏👏👏

  • @lesleekahler6514
    @lesleekahler6514 Місяць тому +6

    Thank you for the great video, Hugh was one of my ancestors.

    • @packard5682
      @packard5682 Місяць тому

      I am descended from Edward II and Isabella and had not heard about this piece history. Hope there are no hard feelings!

  • @linshanhsiang
    @linshanhsiang Місяць тому +2

    At the coronation of Edward II a wall collapsed killing a knight. Not an auspicious start to his reign!

  • @uncletiggermclaren7592
    @uncletiggermclaren7592 Місяць тому +1

    The knights must have known where the purses came from, the entire court would have known. The courtiers had nothing more important in their lives at court, than tokens of royal respect, purse given from a Queen, to Princesses, would have been known on sight by hundreds of people.
    For the knights to then wear them in public, at a reception the gifter was at, was no accident, it was a kind of taunt or boast, they expected them to be recognised.

  • @mariannejohnson6529
    @mariannejohnson6529 27 днів тому +1

    I recommend the biography of Isabella She-Wolf of France,Queen of England by Alison Weir.

  • @georgealderson4424
    @georgealderson4424 Місяць тому +2

    Sometimes it pays to read the comments before looking at the video!

  • @lisamariemoose9054
    @lisamariemoose9054 Місяць тому +3

    They all had it coming after what she was put through

  • @PradeepSingh-kx3lb
    @PradeepSingh-kx3lb Місяць тому +4

    One of greatest most vicious women who made history

    • @ZarpSterr
      @ZarpSterr Місяць тому

      She was a fair maiden, compared to the De Medici women.

    • @PradeepSingh-kx3lb
      @PradeepSingh-kx3lb Місяць тому

      @ZarpSterr ofcourse she was different -blood thirsty and most vindictive nature cruel woman. But a different beast of different kind.

  • @davidyendoll5903
    @davidyendoll5903 Місяць тому +3

    Edward the second was murdered at Berkeley castle and entombed at Gloucester cathedral I believe . Why Gloucester and not London ? Gloucester was and is a power house of the church , possibly the bishop of Gloucester , at the time , was more aligned with Edward;s family than other church men , all of whom had ties with powerful families . Of course the king's murder would be a state secret , that is why he so say was killed in a manner that showed no obvious wounds . Because of the secrecy we ate likely never to be completely sure of the real facts . A bit like JFK's murder more recently .
    I subbed because you have worked hard to tell us this story as well as you can . Thank you .

  • @Concreteowl
    @Concreteowl Місяць тому +4

    Jump to 16:00ish for the pertinent info.

  • @heathervt
    @heathervt Місяць тому +10

    It would be good to provide the credits for the movie used for this video.

    • @cheerfulsatanist
      @cheerfulsatanist Місяць тому +8

      He did, braveheart

    • @hildahilpert5018
      @hildahilpert5018 Місяць тому +1

      It,s from Braveheart maybe.

    • @martabachynsky8545
      @martabachynsky8545 Місяць тому +2

      @@hildahilpert5018 Definitely Braveheart. It was my favorite movie when I was in my 20s (saw it in the movie theater 5 times).

  • @leemday5731
    @leemday5731 11 днів тому +1

    This girl is Mary Poppins compared to Briggunda qween of the Frank's now she was really bad ass!

  • @Fazzieman
    @Fazzieman 7 днів тому

    She did what she needed to do. Edward II was a weak king. If she hadn’t done what she did there probably wouldnt be an England today.
    Though I wouldn't blame her for what happened to the knights and her sisters in law. She didn’t sign off on those executions or imprisonments. All she did was say her suspicions. Her father and brothers were responsible for their own responses to them.

  • @jeanmartin9614
    @jeanmartin9614 Місяць тому

    Edward could have enjoyed living somewhere where he could hang out with the kinds of men he liked, sailors, laborers, etc, and drink as much as he liked. He was quite the drinker.

  • @konsyjes
    @konsyjes 24 дні тому

    why did her son hate her? Did he resent her for how she treated his father? Or maybe he was jealous of Sir Roger, for taking all of his mother's love and attention. Perhaps he fell under the sway of her rivals at court. I would say maybe these are the thoughts that most tormented her in her seclusion - how did she lose the love of her son. Then she said f**k it, lets just make the best of it, I suppose. It seems her relationship with her father was one of considerable trust, though, despite his stern and intimidating exterior.

  • @chrisloomis1489
    @chrisloomis1489 27 днів тому

    Isabella : Just Wow,

  • @Susan-j9z
    @Susan-j9z 27 днів тому

    I know Braveheart is a movie. That being said, Isabella deserved a man like William Wallace. You said she had children, how could that have happened married to a guy who couldn't stand the sight of her? I have nothing but admiration for this bright, smart woman. I hope she did find love. We all deserve that.

    • @Catzilla931
      @Catzilla931 16 днів тому

      Many gay men have managed enough sexual relations to father children

  • @opheliadeclines
    @opheliadeclines Місяць тому

    Before i ignore this video... she couldn't order a glass of juice in France, what she told her father isn't the same as her ordering it. We don’t know what she thought her father would do, but she didn't order his officials around.

  • @nihilistic7840
    @nihilistic7840 21 день тому

    Legitimate succession is still everything just people don't understand it anymore

  • @alistairbain6149
    @alistairbain6149 Місяць тому +1

    Homosexual liaisons were not uncommon among the aristocracy. Why be coy about it?
    Isabella was not deranged - she was a great queen who kept the throne together.

  • @mutteringmale
    @mutteringmale Місяць тому +1

    Uh, how about some real history? Kids were married at very early ages, some at 1 year old, to cement alliances. The rule with women/girls was no consummation before the "first bleeding".
    There was one egregious example during those times that was so bad that it became history.

  • @CROM-on1bz
    @CROM-on1bz Місяць тому +6

    It's already dangerous to upset a normal woman these days, but to upset, flout and ignore a queen from one of the noblest houses in Europe in the Middle Ages... you had to expect certain problems.

    • @SlimKeith11
      @SlimKeith11 29 днів тому

      How many women started wars in the 20th century? How many presided over civil wars within their own country?
      It's been estimated over 180 million people died as a result of wars during the 20th century.
      Now the President elect that ran on, "no new wars" is threatening THREE before he's even sworn into office.

  • @annhenriques3520
    @annhenriques3520 Місяць тому +4

    I knew this video would have inaccuracies just from the misinformation in the teaser.
    Isabella was 19 at the time: of course she relayed her suspicions to her father. He had an investigation done before the arrests. 2 of the 3 wives were found guilty, the knights confessed. The 3rd lady was found not guilty, she was supported by her husband.

  • @jenniferboudreau9366
    @jenniferboudreau9366 6 днів тому

    Fast forward to 16 minutes for the story.

  • @WDwyer
    @WDwyer Місяць тому +5

    What a great waste of an excellent recounting of history-completely spoiled by the inclusion of clips from the insultingly stupid film-Braveheart. I found this very distracting from the voice-over narrative, which otherwise was excellent. Isabella would have been praised fir her strength if she were a man- but strong women were termed 'she-wolves'. A trend that continues even today.

  • @madbrowndog4887
    @madbrowndog4887 Місяць тому +2

    Just the nobility being jerks, as always. Still the same today, just minus the literal bloodletting.

  • @charlesteton
    @charlesteton Місяць тому

    Not sure if I’ve missed it but what film are the inserts from? C

    • @ml50486965
      @ml50486965 Місяць тому +1

      Bravehart. According to the film, Gaveston was thrown out of the window by Edward I. A dramatic effect in the depiction of these Edwards, but apparently just fiction!

  • @williamcurtin5692
    @williamcurtin5692 Місяць тому +1

    Actually She Wolf No. 1. She Wolf No.2, Margaret of Anjou (1400s) bore one of the meanest mean little kids in history and eventually made it into one of Flo's Progressive commercials.

  • @suesmith3744
    @suesmith3744 18 днів тому +2

    Brave heart visually stunning and stunningly inaccurate

  • @krisvanallen
    @krisvanallen Місяць тому

    this is the first I have ever heard of biblical verses being carved on Hugh Jr before execution. anyone else?

  • @1lthrnk
    @1lthrnk Місяць тому

    Edward II did not have children of his own bloodline

  • @Cherbear609
    @Cherbear609 Місяць тому +1

    To History Expos’e: Pls. stop with the sensational clickbait! Isabella was Not deranged. You Sir, need to apologize!

  • @TheBigLeeg
    @TheBigLeeg 19 днів тому

    Wasn’t a French maid as the description would imply.

  • @maeverlylilith9295
    @maeverlylilith9295 19 днів тому +4

    Please stop with the clickbait inaccurate titles! The history is interesting. There’s no need for such ridiculousness.

  • @stephenhall3515
    @stephenhall3515 Місяць тому +1

    Deranged in what way? This is one of most superficial features I have seen.

  • @iainsan
    @iainsan Місяць тому +4

    She was not 'deranged'.

  • @laurawenrickvinovin
    @laurawenrickvinovin Місяць тому

    What is the name of the movie you got the visuals!!