Does an ACL Tear Heal Without Surgery? With Dr. Bill Sterett, Orthopaedic Surgeon.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лип 2017
  • Unfortunately, an ACL tear will not heal or improve by itself.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 183

  • @yann8067
    @yann8067 2 роки тому +64

    It does heal. My acl got torn back in October 2019 (I was 15 at the time) and also my mcl got grade 2 sprain. Went to rehab worked hard everyday to prepare for surgery and until my mcl healed. Then earthquake started hitting Puerto Rico, then covid and my operation got postponed. I continued to work hard, cuz there wasn't much to do other than playing warzone with ma boys. Got another MRI in June 2020 and everything was healed. I'm running a mile and my knees don't give out but my cardio does lmao I'm also leg pressing 420lbs without any pain, I still haven't started practicing judo because of covid but in August I believe that I'll start practicing so if I remember I'll give an update

    • @svetozarslavilov808
      @svetozarslavilov808 2 роки тому +9

      I highly doubt you experienced a complete ACL tear (rupture) at the first place, it was probably partial one or sprain, hence why it may heal.
      Do you have MRI and proof at the beginning of your injury or you just assumed that it was "torn"?

    • @yann8067
      @yann8067 2 роки тому +13

      @@svetozarslavilov808 yes I got an MRI. 1 when I got injured and another 10 month's later. The readings indicate that there was a tear. Some believe that there was a small string attached and that's how it healed. My orthopedic Dr. Has had over 900 cases of acl tear and around 7-10 ocations the patient got healed without operation. The things we had in common was that we were young and athletes

    • @svetozarslavilov808
      @svetozarslavilov808 2 роки тому +6

      @@yann8067 Okay, good to know man! That is rly encouraging to hear. I am also 1 year past my ACL injury and just discovered that it's a complete tear a few months ago, so got an appointment with my orthopedic to see if the surgery will be needed. Despite that I am able to train in the gym with all effort and the instability felt on my knee is only a tiny bit compared to what most guys feel after such severe injury (ACL rupture).

    • @yann8067
      @yann8067 2 роки тому +4

      @@svetozarslavilov808 you may not need the operation at all! Evaluate your life style and you decide if it's really necessary. Best of luck bud, keep on working hard!!

    • @ruadhanconvery9429
      @ruadhanconvery9429 2 роки тому +9

      @@svetozarslavilov808 I tore my ACL completely in my left knee back in March while playing football. I was walking and running quite quickly afterwards but despite this the surgeon still said surgery was necessary to return to sports.
      Due to the pandemic my surgery has been delayed until January 2021 and in the meantime I have been doing pre hab with a sports physio to strengthen my injured leg. I have regained all range of motion and can jump and land on my ACL deficient knee and also change direction while running. My physio now recommends a conservative management plan and advises that I may not need surgery as I may be what is called an ‘ACL coper’, meaning I can cope without one. If it goes well I can return to sports even without an ACL and not needing to wear a brace. Insane!

  • @High_101
    @High_101 6 років тому +37

    The was quick honest and brutal

  • @amirand10879
    @amirand10879 9 місяців тому +9

    Lol , it can heal if you got time , patience and put in walking/running exercises . It'll heal so well you can sprint and run marathons. Im living proof

    • @Big271ne
      @Big271ne 7 місяців тому +3

      Wow this comment really gave me hope💪

  • @travelexpress9823
    @travelexpress9823 2 роки тому

    Thank You DR. William.

  • @haydenbristow91
    @haydenbristow91 Рік тому +6

    The ACL cross bracing protocol would suggest otherise. 90% of people in the trial showed signs of healing at 3 months.

    • @cautarepvp2079
      @cautarepvp2079 3 місяці тому

      what is that? what exercises i need to do in order to regrow my acl

  • @egeg4216
    @egeg4216 Рік тому +2

    ACL can heal, its more likely with partial tears but it is possible. My friend tore his ACL in 2021 and had surgery in 2022, The surgeon opened him up and saw that the ACL was fully intact and not damaged.

    • @fandefoot3511
      @fandefoot3511 Рік тому +2

      If it was intact and not damaged surgery was not necessary the doctors opening him up for no reasons.

    • @theelivv254
      @theelivv254 9 місяців тому

      @@fandefoot3511depends where they got surgery. In the UK, the nhs is too poor to do another mri to see if it’s healing, as most times it doesn’t, they won’t check

    • @jj82695
      @jj82695 4 місяці тому

      @@fandefoot3511 MRI beforehand would have prevented that.

    • @cautarepvp2079
      @cautarepvp2079 3 місяці тому

      ​@@fandefoot3511 they shoulld have done an mri

  • @paveltolmachev1898
    @paveltolmachev1898 3 роки тому

    quick and painful, however, useful

  • @aristotelisoikonomou2873
    @aristotelisoikonomou2873 6 років тому +2

    If you fix it with hamstring graph will it loosen up over the years? Say like 25% reduced elasticity? Thanks in advance.

    • @DrWilliamSterettMD
      @DrWilliamSterettMD  6 років тому +1

      Hi A, it really depends upon the patient and your particular case. If you're considering the procedure talk to your doc and see if he or she can give you an answer based on your specific case. Thanks!

    • @cautarepvp2079
      @cautarepvp2079 3 місяці тому

      quad graft is better now

  • @MarkChenMovement
    @MarkChenMovement 9 місяців тому

    This is updated information it seems

  • @stevebarbieri1399
    @stevebarbieri1399 2 роки тому +9

    Wrong! Complete torn acl 2 years no surgery. And I'm fine now and active.

    • @nithinfahumudeen1799
      @nithinfahumudeen1799 2 роки тому

      Wat abt mri does it heal or ste u living without acl

    • @stevebarbieri1399
      @stevebarbieri1399 2 роки тому +3

      @@nithinfahumudeen1799 it doesn't heal by itself. I'm living without an acl. I'm in my 30s. Still very active sports n lifting. No problems.

    • @carolbanz1251
      @carolbanz1251 2 роки тому

      @@stevebarbieri1399 But in future it may give problems, like early arthritis or worn-out cartilage

    • @stevebarbieri1399
      @stevebarbieri1399 2 роки тому

      @@carolbanz1251 my doctor told me I'm getting that most likely either way with surgery or without.

    • @ahsansarfraz7839
      @ahsansarfraz7839 2 роки тому

      hi, i have complete ACL Torn and grade 3 meniscus. can you guide me how it heal and how much time it will take. if you guide me i will be very very thankful to you.

  • @The_Harmacist10
    @The_Harmacist10 2 роки тому +16

    strange, I completely ruptured mine last june and delayed the surgery due to university exams. Had a second MRI in November and the ortho said it just looks like a partial tear and I no longer needed surgery. Fast forward to march this year and I had one final MRI and the ortho said it looks like a normal healthy ligament. Went back to playing football at the start of May and haven't had any issues so far. I guess everyone's case is highly individual, but my ortho says it does have the ability to heal depending on the person and where the tear is. Apparently, I was just very lucky.

    • @Hai2021
      @Hai2021 Рік тому +5

      no, its normal ... but surgeons hate that trick.

    • @karmjeetkaur2375
      @karmjeetkaur2375 Рік тому

      Plzz bta skte ho kese jan kon kon se treke c thik kiya mere v problem hai

    • @AnythingLounge
      @AnythingLounge Рік тому +2

      Wait so does this mean ACL ligaments can heal? Even if they’re fully torn?

    • @fandefoot3511
      @fandefoot3511 Рік тому

      @@AnythingLounge Yes

    • @fandefoot3511
      @fandefoot3511 Рік тому +1

      Great so happy for you 😊 you are so smart not like most people. No surgeries is always the best option.

  • @adityaanand2315
    @adityaanand2315 4 роки тому +3

    Good luck
    What good luck doc😢😢😢

  • @ertugrulalindumitriu9007
    @ertugrulalindumitriu9007 Рік тому +2

    I saw quite few cases of heal over last year. I had may acl tear on april last year and i didn't had surgery i just done gym to strengthen muscles and i got no problems now.. Running lifting 400 kg on leg press etc..

    • @Big271ne
      @Big271ne 7 місяців тому

      How long did it take for it to fully heal? I had a partial tear this april but it hasnt fully healed. However i can still squat a ton of weight but im instable when i run. I just started doing rehab a month ago, any tips?

    • @alindm7556
      @alindm7556 7 місяців тому

      Strength the glutes for running.

    • @Big271ne
      @Big271ne 7 місяців тому

      Any excersizes you recomend?

    • @alindm7556
      @alindm7556 7 місяців тому +1

      @@Big271ne I am using machines which target glutes at gym. I don't do exercises with body weight. I recomand do with light weight and 20 +reps for 1 set , do atleast 5 sets per machine. It will take from 3 to 6 months to get results if you do at least 3 days in a week legs. You can start slow running once you have stability. Is normal to hurt little bit at the beginning. And I problems close my leg. I could not touch the checks with the feet but I forced every day and I developed full range. You can use that think which slides on floor which is very good. You can pushit and pull back walking in reverse.

    • @Big271ne
      @Big271ne 7 місяців тому

      @@alindm7556big thanks 🙏🏾

  • @DropeVougher
    @DropeVougher 4 місяці тому +1

    There are no studies to support this claim. In fact, there are some studies indicating quite the opposite: acl can heal in some circumstances.

    • @6ymn
      @6ymn 3 місяці тому

      I wish that becose i reveus sugarey and i check mri again 😢😢

  • @karandeka1280
    @karandeka1280 Рік тому

    Sir i am dealing with acl strain. So do i need surgery or it will get fix by some exercise. My MRI report says tht I got acl strain so i would like to know your opinion wht shall I do. My doctor said it will get heal after 4 months but I am dealing this since 6month. Thi is not getting fixed.

  • @abdullahaesthetic5718
    @abdullahaesthetic5718 Рік тому +1

    Dr William thanks for your information.. can PRP heal a sprain ACL which means overstretch acl ? Just your opinion on that I will appreciate if you answer

    • @ishikaasawa1598
      @ishikaasawa1598 Рік тому

      @abdullahaesthetic5718 had you gotten prp done?

  • @aubreyjennings7135
    @aubreyjennings7135 2 роки тому +6

    That’s an utter lie, tears like this can get better with time if they’re not major. Very bookish and misinformed by old Knowledge and ignorance in medicine.

  • @karinazhu8462
    @karinazhu8462 2 роки тому +2

    I had a partial ACL tear when skiing a month ago. I am very active and hope to continue playing sports. Do you think stem cell treatment works? Where is a good place to get the treatment if yet? Thanks. Karina

    • @onetapwallah9242
      @onetapwallah9242 2 роки тому

      can partial tear heal itself???

    • @Raidenorius
      @Raidenorius 2 роки тому +1

      ​@@onetapwallah9242 @Karina Zhu
      Yes, it can, but depends on many factors. I had subtotal (close to total) ACL tear 27th march 2022. Been in brace for 1 month (immobilized)and now having rehab since 2 months.
      28 June had 2nd MRI and my ACL looks straight agian, but is 30% grey color in MRI, when healthy ACL in near black in MRI. My doc says it looks good for the future.
      As I read about it, partial ACL is using cells in clot for healing and then, 3-12 month from tear, it will use collagen cells to become stronger. So you need strong muscles (especial hamstring) to support it and avoiding any problems like hyperextension and torsion injuries (no basketball for me at least for 12 months, but I think going with surgery would resulted the same, sooo).
      So, yes - some partial tears can be heal but it needs time. My rehabs say even up to 2 years.

    • @ishikaasawa1598
      @ishikaasawa1598 11 місяців тому

      ​@@Raidenoriushow's your injury now?

    • @comdeytime3190
      @comdeytime3190 7 місяців тому

      ​@@ishikaasawa1598 Hi How are you now

    • @comdeytime3190
      @comdeytime3190 7 місяців тому

      Are you feeling better now, and please let me know what Exercises u did ?

  • @kimsanchez7211
    @kimsanchez7211 4 роки тому +7

    Mine healed just fine WITHOUT surgery. My physician told me it would and it did.

  • @stratocastermaster9
    @stratocastermaster9 6 років тому +13

    Had no reconstruction on my acl torn acl, 3 years later it's a though it never happened, I have no problem. Continued to get better and better. Playing sports as per normal with no problem now. If it doesn't heal back, what has happened to me ? It was bad for 6 months after.

    • @cheyenneharper6742
      @cheyenneharper6742 6 років тому +7

      I too had an ACL injury that is improved significantly after a year, without surgery.

    • @stratocastermaster9
      @stratocastermaster9 6 років тому +5

      Cheyenne Harper hi Cheyenne, it's been almost 3 years for me, I still think it's torn, but it's as if it didn't happen for me. I think some people's tendons in the knee are tighter or stronger than others and this is why some people may not need surgery. I was told I would be falling over a lot, not able to do sport, never happend.

    • @morshedkamal7761
      @morshedkamal7761 5 років тому

      Mr. porter i m also ACL injured, pls told me you was any medicine getting or without medicine you was improve, pls detail me.

    • @Tech_Farm01
      @Tech_Farm01 5 років тому

      Tarun Chugh aapka tear grade 3 tha kya

    • @piyushchaudhary183
      @piyushchaudhary183 3 роки тому

      I have a grade 2 tear can it will be heal itself or not?

  • @SunilKumar-hy4kh
    @SunilKumar-hy4kh 2 місяці тому

    I recovered without surgery

  • @saharanpur11
    @saharanpur11 3 роки тому +1

    Sir can I run without ACL

  • @nibussss
    @nibussss 2 роки тому

    Had a torn ligament . Saudi dr fixed it in 1 month cast. This was like in 2000.
    I think it was acl... because knee completely locked and Blood taken out.

    • @fashoyeah5826
      @fashoyeah5826 2 роки тому +1

      What do you mean by knee completely locked? How do you know when it locks

    • @heruhermawan6584
      @heruhermawan6584 Рік тому +1

      Thats meniscus

    • @brusbrus8087
      @brusbrus8087 Рік тому

      Could u pls tell me Nibu in which hospital in Saudi 🇸🇦 this Dr ?

    • @nibussss
      @nibussss Рік тому

      @@brusbrus8087 jubail new hospital?maybe

    • @nibussss
      @nibussss Рік тому

      He stuck a big needle in knee….is that meniscus…not ligament?

  • @silasben-zoheth2639
    @silasben-zoheth2639 Рік тому

    TLDW: No.

  • @otterguyty
    @otterguyty 2 роки тому +3

    Well shit...

    • @ahsansarfraz7839
      @ahsansarfraz7839 2 роки тому +1

      hi, i have complete ACL Torn and grade 3 meniscus. can you guide me how it heal and how much time it will take. if you guide me i will be very very thankful to you.

    • @heruhermawan6584
      @heruhermawan6584 Рік тому

      @@ahsansarfraz7839 it would take a year to you to back in high impact sport but in careful

    • @heruhermawan6584
      @heruhermawan6584 Рік тому

      @@ahsansarfraz7839 it need surgery

  • @asianangler
    @asianangler Місяць тому

    it's amazing there so many videos on youtube by these physical therapists saying you can "heal" an ACL without surgery by rehabbing. Yeah to drum up their business lol

  • @IggyArssie
    @IggyArssie 2 місяці тому +1

    Misinformation

  • @roshe9124
    @roshe9124 2 роки тому +1

    Well. Fukk!!!😱

  • @roddyrich2335
    @roddyrich2335 5 місяців тому

    Bulshiddo

    • @stormsumeet
      @stormsumeet 5 місяців тому

      Why

    • @roddyrich2335
      @roddyrich2335 5 місяців тому

      @@stormsumeet the second link has better results (90%) of patients showed signs of healing on 3 and 6 month mri and scored significantly higher on various traditional acl test