NO meaning to you maybe.. 1400 Israeli citizens and their devastated relatives mostly share another view. I wonder how you'd feel if yourself or your relatives encountered a similar fate...?
@@hj1963 Given the number of Palestinians slaughtered and/or gravely injured (over 20,000 in the last 12 years, not counting the current genocidal war) I wonder how YOU'D feel if you were a Palestinian.
@@hj1963 mmm nope most of those people were killed by Israeli helicopters. And 1200 of the 1400 that were killed were active duty military NOT civilians.
David Adler nails it when he says Israel is betting on people getting tired of the images and videos of the atrocities and that people will forget. I'm sick of the images and videos of the atrocities but I will never forget, nor will the world.
Yet you have quickly forgot that Israel have never attacked its neighbours but have only ever responded to bomb and terrorist attacks which have been indiscriminate against Jews, Arabs and tourists living on Israel.
Esther McVey's lack of intelligence and depth of understanding is an embarrassment. I don't know how she had the gall to go on Question Time and think she was well informed enough to contribute anything useful.
Born into privelege or aspire to be in it, they have a disease of self obsession. I live in the south and a large portion of people are like it. Money buys self image and the safety and security to enjoy it. But peel away the layers and they are vile, cruel, violent people.
Israel does not have the right of self defence as its occupying Palestine Palestine on the other hand has the right of self defence just as france did while being occupied by German during WW2
But Israel left Gaza and effectively said, govern your self. The world then poured billions into Gaza. Did the Gazan authorities set about building a better life for Gazans? Or did they continue with their obsession to destroy Israel? 500km of tunnels is a clear answer. Today the first problem and oppressor is Hamas.
Israel has the right to defend itself as a sovereign nation recognised in the UN but has been subject to attack by militant forces since it was founded. What it does not have the right to do is to oppress the people on the West Bank and plant settlements there which are illegal. It built the separatist wall to ensure its security but in the process made it difficult for Palestinians to access things like health care as all of the main hospitals are in East Jerusalem. It forces them to obtain permits to travel which may be cancelled at anytime for security issues. No doubt that October the 7th caused a crackdown with crossing points closed. Hamas needs to stop firing rockets which it won't as well as to stop using the innocent as shields to its activity. Since gaining control of Gaza it has made it a fortress to launch attacks on Israel as well as using essential pipework from the water system to make rockets. The current Israeli action will only fuel more support for Hamas etc as it won't change hearts and minds in its favour. There is no plan for when this is over apart from a hint that Israel will totally isolate the strip and supply nothing which is what is happening now. Gaza may not have a long term future as it may be reduced to a ruin without power, water or anything else if Israel implements what I read a few weeks back. The only thing that we can be sure of is that the previous two state solution is almost certainly dead in the water.
@@lunadz81 Sam can be asked why special rules are employed for the lack of parking enforcement at Friday Prayers and Ramadaan. Why MPs will turn up for a photoshoot to break the fast, at Ramadaan, but will tell other constiuents they are too busy even if it is a life and death situation or in the public intrest, but not in thier political career! MP for East Leicester take note!
" Israel cannot claim the right of ‘self-defence’ under international law because Gaza is a territory which it occupies ". by Francesca Albanese, UN Special Rapporteur No apartheid ethno-state has a 'right to exist,' including Israel
@@sadbutterfly808 It was the ruling of the ICJ (International Court of Justice) in 2004 on the issue of the Palestinians in Gaza and Israeli's occupation. Frankly the ignorance displayed in your comment is astounding.
I will be voting Liberal Democrats now, I forgive them for giving me a Tory government back in 2010 now. I cannot vote for Kier Starmer and I used to put my Labour sign up outside my house.
In the Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
Israel isn't defending itself, its clearing land to expand Israel geographically. When this latest conflict ends the map will look very different than before.
Do Palestinians have a right to defend themselves? Is Apartheid Israel not condemnable for its ethnic cleansing and genocide? Why isn't the host not asking this minister these question?
The BBC are all bought and paid for, all sing from the same hymn sheet and are too yellow to go against the narrative because they are more interested in the money they get paid than they are in human lives.
@@anuradhavittachi On that point today's leftwing idiology inhibits many of those on the left from a deeper understanding of what's going on just as some conservatives have shallow unhelpful ideas too. The left is far from being helpful in this current war.
UN majority views Israel as a legitimate state...there are valid reasons to be annoyed at that, but it is the only valid framework so they do have the right
@@nas84payne I agree they are a lousy outfit..but unless you defer to the US's might is right hegemony it's all there is. Sorry if it hurts your feelings
@@nihilistlivesmatter This is indeed correct. Israel is a legitimate state, Palestine is not in the eyes of the UK. In fact, the State of Palestine recognized Israel as part of the Oslo Accords in 1993
Politics! Politics! Politics! This is not the time for Politics! This is the time for us to get together to stop this crisis at once that is not only killing and torturing a people & destroying their small country but also killing us all morally in the knowledge that while the rest of us are able to walk in the streets, go shopping for food, eat, drink, wash, sleep without fear, etc etc we cannot stop thinking about how this people are suffering and how this has been allowed to carry on.
@@jds614 don't be intentionally dense. This phrase is being used to defend Israel's use of disproportionate retaliation and collective punishment of Palestinian civilians.
@@jds614, 😅 wow.. So we have to explain it to you like a child.. OK.. Here goes.... NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO BOMB INNOCENT WOMEN AND CHILDREN. NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO OCCUPY ANOTHER'S LAND. NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO GO AGAINST INTERNATIONAL LAW AND MURDER ENTIRE FAMILIES BY INDISCRIMINATE BOMBING. AND NO NATION SHOULD BE FORCED TO LIVE UNDER BRUTAL OCCUPATION, APARTHEID, SEIGE AND BE TERRORISED ON A DAILY BASIS, FROM HAVING TO WATCH THEIR HOMES DEMOLISHED, THEIR HOSPITALS BOMBED, THEIR REFUGEE AND UN 'PROTECTED' AREAS BOMBED. Educate yourself on what self defence actually is.
@@jds614is it self defence if they abuse Palestinians day and daily for years and a small group of them decide they've had enough and respond? Youd have to be routing for the bullies of the world if you're on the side of poor little Israel after everything else theyve done.
@@themarkbishop when ypu pick a side and asking one sided question, then its no longer journalism, its more like inquery for the side you pick. For instance, do you condemn hamas??? specially when you first start with it. the question can be originated from the conversation but it should not be a starting question.
Israeli media and testimonies say that the IDF shoot and shelled it's own people on oct7th , testimonies from soldiers and survivors , they killed 350 people at the rave proof ? middle east eye , haaretz ,and other reports and videos also The Hannibal Directive of the IDF .
There is no country called "Palestine" nor has there ever been. The Palestinians could have had their own state several times over but they've said no every time.
In the Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
They call their ministers responsible for all sorts of bizarre shit. Distracts from fact they do nothing to run the various government departments anyway.
Omg... She said hostages. We have seen an exchange of children for soilders. That is the prisoner exchange that proud isreali has enabled barbarian nation has opened its gates.
Since when the occupier has the right to defend themselves?? And when the occupied one resist he will be called terrorist!!!!!!!!!!! What a cheos in the moralty
@@b62boom1 break up the UK it's the only way to govern our own country without the corrupt English establishment stealing all our money to fund England's richest
@waltersobchak1719 I don’t know why you feel the urge do defend piers morgan like he is you dad, relax yourself🤣 Or it is because this channel don’t bend the knee to zionism like piers do and the rest of the western media?🤔
Morgan knows how real journalism was done. As a newspaper editor he took a strong, principled stance against the illegal Bush/Blair invasion of Iraq. That's why the present stance of his program is so sad. If he still has the principles he had then his heart must not be in it.
@@lilrr1431 "Its not about sides. Its about whats right. Israel the apartheid state is wrong and is the root cause of these issues" That statement was so fantastically, unbelievably obtuse. Quite literally in the same breath - you utterly rejected your own premise.
Well she is not in a position to lecture anyone due to her participation in the PPE scandal (she referred some firms using the “VIP lane” to get the public contracts and it turns out the PPE was very costly and the material delivered unusable resulting in a waste of public money of almost £2 billions) She should be investigated ! Did she receive any consideration from the deal ? But now the fact that we have a “Ministry of Common sense” is 1) another waste of money and 2) very scary for the freedom of speech, this sounds very much like 1984 from George Orwell. It should not be a bunch of corrupted politicians to police what is “common sense” and what it is not.
Esther McVey should be investigated. Absolutely right. Nearly billions money wasted. As she sounds siding with israel makes you think where those billions travelled????
It's a horrible lie that IL is pushing down the worlds throat, it's disgusting what the Hasbara is promoting with their propaganda, any state that continues to stand behind these terrorists (IL) are complicit in all the deaths. They are as such as wrong and sick as the murderers themselves.
It’s the same shit on different names as has always been the case. Coming from Northern Ireland everyone had to condemn terrorism from the republican side, the loyalist sides terrorism was never asked to be condemned and then state sponsored terrorism like Bloody Sunday gets whitewashed and is seen as the English defending themself against the IRA and to do so they murder 14 people on a peaceful civil rights march
Gaza Marine is a natural gas field off the coast of the Gaza Strip. The Gaza Marine natural gas field is located in water about 36 kilometers (22 mi) offshore at a depth of 2,000 feet (610 m). The field was discovered in 2000 by BP Group and it is estimated to contain more than 1 trillion cubic feet of natural gas.
In the Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
The UK appoints a minister for “Common Sense”…..good GOD have mercy! Not only does this woman not have any, but the fact that this is the best they could find says a lot..
Powerful when the audience speaks up. The people by and large know what’s happening and just can’t fathom why their governments are going along and even SUPPORTING it. It’s disgusting. And the Western govts have dug their own bed here… I for one am absolutely ASHAMED of my country. I have NEVER been more ashamed to be an American citizen. Many many atrocities have been committed supposedly in “my name” or by my country, but this is so far beyond the pale. All politicians that support these war crimes should all be held accountable in the strictest means possible under law.
@@nadeemmustafa6450 I agree that it’s already too late for so so many, but awareness is growing and that’s never a bad thing. I agree; it’s too little too late… but that’s not a reason to quit or be discouraged. There are still millions that need our help and we are very much making a difference, however small at first. Like drops in the ocean, it’s together that we find our strength.
Michael and David I want to thank both of your consistent speaking of the truth. Thank you for always posting reminders of the atrocities that have happened and continue to happen in Palestine. Love from Libya ❤️❤️
The current UN Special Rapporteur on Occupied Palestine, Francesca Albanese has the clearest explanation on why Israel right to defend themselves is false according to the international law. I can feel the frustration of the British people towards their blind government on this matter.
Article 51 paragraph 139 of the UN charter says Israel cannot 'claim' self defence when an attack emanates from occupied territory, they can respond to an attack but they cannot claim the phrase self-defence.
The UN doesn’t even know International Law. For A to occupy B the B needs to exist or A is occupying A. When people speak about Israel without knowing International Law quickly fall into ignorance. International Law Lesson Israel can’t occupy Israel’s Land. Search for the Map of British Palestine. So in 1948 Israel followed the Principle of International Law called Uti Possidetis Juris and the borders of the new State of Israel were the same as the Previous Geo Political Entity the British Mandate. This includes what’s now Israel and the Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem. There’s no other State there for an occupation. Just because there was a Political Vote in the UN with the result that Palestine is a State doesn’t make it so under International Law. UN Resolutions don’t have the Force of Law. From the Law perspective Gazans are illegal inside Israeli Territory. Israel left Gaza in 2005 but didn’t sign any Treaty to give Gaza so Gaza is still part of Israel. Jordan was created under the same Uti Possidetis Juris but the UN, the International Community and Palestinians don’t say that Jordan is occupying their Land.
This "Palestine doesn't exist" argument is redundant. If Palestine doesn't exist why is it in the Balfour Declaration as the land given to israel by the British?@@luisdotgarcia
In international law it is nowhere to be found that the occupying force has a 'right' to defend itself. Instead it is explicitly written that an occupied nation has a right to fight for it's freedom. Palestine will be free.
You guys, especially Michael Walker, are making amazing videos that touch my heart. ❤️ You are speaking truth to power! 💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼 Please keep making such great content!
In the Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
This is the picture instead of a solution to the freedom of Gazans and the Palestinians all the narrative is on the destruction of Hamas, it shows how every bl*dy politician cares about the Palestinians. All they care about is for isralie to win, and then the same tragedy for another 75 years
There will be no end to this until people like you and I are both pro-Palestinian and pro-Israeli. The stand you are currently taking is fueling the fire.
@@alistair7539 I never been pro Palestinian I'm ex Muslim atheist Turk but was pro Israeli I've seen a side to them that I can't stomach so these days I'm just pro humanity. It's shocking how people I had considered decent people just repeat like robots a few phrases and ignore this high tech killing on a large scale.
I'm pro humanity too, especially when humanity embraces wisdom, understanding and kindness. There will be peace in the region once people want peace more than conflict, when there is more respect than hatred, and when Muslims and Jews alike can see the humanity in each other.
Domestic ciolence perpetrators also say 'she made me do it'. Blaming the Palestinian victim for the crimes of the Israeli barbaric army is absolutely disgusting.
@@Slowgrindtoglory... You are ignorant of the little factual detail that Gaza is not an "occupied territory" ... Show the alleged occupying PRESENCE of Israel in Gaza prior to 7 October ... please do ...
She acknowledges that the Palestinian panellist to her right is _”closer to this, than I.”_ And yet she went on to express a such an ignorant and offensive opinion.
Doesn't Palestine (Palestinians) have a right to exist? A right to defend themselves? Why does the narrative seem to exist that only one side have these rights ? You're absolutely right about the spoken language and body language that conveys a two tiered sense of humanity or lack thereof. It's disgusting.
Israeli media and testimonies say that the IDF shoot and shelled it's own people on oct7th , testimonies from soldiers and survivors , they killed 350 people at the rave proof ? middle east eye , haaretz ,and other reports and videos also The Hannibal Directive of the IDF .
This genicide is so appalling and the fact ghat the USA blocked the UN decision to call for a ceasefire i find disgusting- 6,000 children killed by israel.
As a South African, I can tell you the language, the stance etc.... Is exactly the same used to justify apartheid
...pants on fire!😂😂😂
This is far worse than apartheid,this is genocide.
Really? And your evidence is.....
Settler-colonialist propoganda is strong.
@chatham43 I'm South African too. She's 100% accurate
Since when did the OPPRESSOR have the right to defend???
Exactly. That argument has lost steam and is being exposed.
Since western logic equals to worse and worse logic.
And yet Hamas claims that right for itself!
🤣🤣🤣❤
Silly me for not coming to that conclusion...
I am so stupid...
One of the biggest mistakes people keep making regarding this ridiculous conflict is calling it a "war".
It's not a war? I think it is. Those that don't think it is is because they're side are losing
I know right, Gaza and the occupation, is like David and Goliath
So what would you call it? Hamas broke the cease fire on oct 7th, knowing full well it would lead to retalliation or war.
buddy idf has already broken the cease fire by shooting unarmed kids wayy before oct 7th stop lying @@MrRetlahcub
War is state against state. This is an oppressed group fighting for freedom. Apartheid style like in South Africa. Am from south africa
Shame on you Britain, this did not start on the 7th Oct!!!!!!
So many double standards
The hypocrisy is overwhelming and outright sick.
Exactly!
With Muslims in Britain,yes!
Yes unbelieveable
Everytime I hear "right to defend itself" I roll my eyes. This phrase has no meaning anymore.
NO meaning to you maybe.. 1400 Israeli citizens and their devastated relatives mostly share another view. I wonder how you'd feel if yourself or your relatives encountered a similar fate...?
Wow how was she allowed to carry on talking
The ignorance & denial of Israel supporters i would never have believed as I keep hearing
@@hj1963 Given the number of Palestinians slaughtered and/or gravely injured (over 20,000 in the last 12 years, not counting the current genocidal war) I wonder how YOU'D feel if you were a Palestinian.
@@hj1963 mmm nope most of those people were killed by Israeli helicopters. And 1200 of the 1400 that were killed were active duty military NOT civilians.
David Adler nails it when he says Israel is betting on people getting tired of the images and videos of the atrocities and that people will forget.
I'm sick of the images and videos of the atrocities but I will never forget, nor will the world.
💯
Yet you have quickly forgot that Israel have never attacked its neighbours but have only ever responded to bomb and terrorist attacks which have been indiscriminate against Jews, Arabs and tourists living on Israel.
I'm boycotting anything to do with Israel. 🇮🇳🇬🇧
@@micksingh6711 same. Every $ hurts them
@@micksingh6711 you therefore wish to punish the peaceful Arabs living in Israel and those crossing into Israel to work.
The hypocrisy and apartheid view of this whole situation is truly unbelievable. Michael, you hit the nail painfully on the head.
What apartheid?
@@MRW515 the westbank and the gaza strip, controlling what goes in and out
Asking citizens to "Leave" their Homeland" by an opposing country because there will be Military action IS Illegal under International Law.
@waltersobchak1719 hasbara troll
@waltersobchak1719holocaust baby you need another one so what¿
ISrael doesn't care about 'international law'... after all, it's 'goyim' law... and as such not intended for god's 'chosen ones'... 😕
@waltersobchak1719 There speaks the voice of an Israeli.
@waltersobchak1719 Mate just own up to the fact you’re bias down to the simple fact Palestinians are brown and Muslim. Own up to your racism.
Our politicians have the moral backbones of jellyfish.
💪🏽💪🏽👍🏽🙏🏽💯
No jellyfish ever told a lie!
@@rais1953 no jellyfish ever had a backbone
They simply don't care, it's all about money for them.
Lol😅😅😅😅
Esther McVey's lack of intelligence and depth of understanding is an embarrassment. I don't know how she had the gall to go on Question Time and think she was well informed enough to contribute anything useful.
Same as that Dorries. Unbelievable that they’re from Liverpool. They’re an embarrassment.
I know....minister for common sense 😅😂😅😂
I'm afraid Ester is very limited intelectually so her arguments have no gravity . Also she's 100% biased for Israel.
Like Layla Moran and the BBC being pro Palestine!
It's nice to see the audience wasn't as ignorant
They were more ignorant than the panel
What about the Palestinian children in the Israeli jails. This is a war crime .
Isn’t she in prison yet after PPE fraud?
Does she have immunity in her position?
She and the REST must be detained indefinitely for robbing the nation with their scam
@@cathjj840she is one of many.
Baroness mone is the worst crook,she's made so many millions out of the covid crisis..
...nope...we don't live in a dictatorship..don't know about your country of origin though.😊
Not one of these British politicians can speak the truth ffs 🤦♂️ disgusting 🤮
Born into privelege or aspire to be in it, they have a disease of self obsession. I live in the south and a large portion of people are like it. Money buys self image and the safety and security to enjoy it. But peel away the layers and they are vile, cruel, violent people.
Are you saying that Layla Moran is lying? if anything here is disgusting then it is your total ignorance.
They have been bought out ...sold there souls
I'm boycotting anything to do with JEWS (Israel). 🇮🇳🇬🇧
@micksingh6711 bless you my brother
Israel does not have the right of self defence as its occupying Palestine
Palestine on the other hand has the right of self defence just as france did while being occupied by German during WW2
Israel has the right to self defence of its people.
@@dave4728 As Israel is an illegal occupier of Palestine it is the aggressor so is not defending anyone
Simple facts seem to escape you
Israel left Gaza in 2005, it is NOT an occupied territory. Do some research and stop spouting this left-wing propaganda.
But Israel left Gaza and effectively said, govern your self. The world then poured billions into Gaza. Did the Gazan authorities set about building a better life for Gazans? Or did they continue with their obsession to destroy Israel? 500km of tunnels is a clear answer. Today the first problem and oppressor is Hamas.
Israel has the right to defend itself as a sovereign nation recognised in the UN but has been subject to attack by militant forces since it was founded. What it does not have the right to do is to oppress the people on the West Bank and plant settlements there which are illegal. It built the separatist wall to ensure its security but in the process made it difficult for Palestinians to access things like health care as all of the main hospitals are in East Jerusalem. It forces them to obtain permits to travel which may be cancelled at anytime for security issues. No doubt that October the 7th caused a crackdown with crossing points closed. Hamas needs to stop firing rockets which it won't as well as to stop using the innocent as shields to its activity. Since gaining control of Gaza it has made it a fortress to launch attacks on Israel as well as using essential pipework from the water system to make rockets. The current Israeli action will only fuel more support for Hamas etc as it won't change hearts and minds in its favour. There is no plan for when this is over apart from a hint that Israel will totally isolate the strip and supply nothing which is what is happening now. Gaza may not have a long term future as it may be reduced to a ruin without power, water or anything else if Israel implements what I read a few weeks back. The only thing that we can be sure of is that the previous two state solution is almost certainly dead in the water.
What has Israel got inside US and Britain that we are afraid to call Israel out on anything they do?
Israel lobby biggest lobby that influences political leaders
Epstein
The total control of the Middle East!
@@lunadz81 Sam can be asked why special rules are employed for the lack of parking enforcement at Friday Prayers and Ramadaan. Why MPs will turn up for a photoshoot to break the fast, at Ramadaan, but will tell other constiuents they are too busy even if it is a life and death situation or in the public intrest, but not in thier political career! MP for East Leicester take note!
" Israel cannot claim the right of ‘self-defence’ under international law because Gaza is a territory which it occupies ". by Francesca Albanese, UN Special Rapporteur
No apartheid ethno-state has a 'right to exist,' including Israel
💯💯💯
@@sadbutterfly808you will know who’s dreaming and who’s not, everything will be paid back to you 1000 folds.
Took the words right out of my mouth! 👍
@@sadbutterfly808Your dreams may soon be shattered. 😂
@@sadbutterfly808 It was the ruling of the ICJ (International Court of Justice) in 2004 on the issue of the Palestinians in Gaza and Israeli's occupation. Frankly the ignorance displayed in your comment is astounding.
Shame on this government and shame on Labour Party 😢😢😢
I will be voting Liberal Democrats now, I forgive them for giving me a Tory government back in 2010 now. I cannot vote for Kier Starmer and I used to put my Labour sign up outside my house.
Shame on hamas, Iran!!!
@@beatinganger shame on the west, it is the Mary Shelly of the Middle East.
Our support has created the monster which will create more wars.
In the Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
The shame is on Hamas and Islam.
Brilliant analysis & coverage as usual-thank you 🕯️
If u want Hamas gone then so should Netanyahu n his occupation policies
The ENTIRE Israeli cabinet needs to go.
Ex-Israli pm said get rid of Hamas then Bibi
Israel is NOT an occupier. Learn some history.
@@Ritawaltersssss😂😂😂😂
@@Ritawaltersssss Have you any idea how ridiculous this comment is?
Israel isn't defending itself, its clearing land to expand Israel geographically. When this latest conflict ends the map will look very different than before.
Could look something like the map Netanyahu recently presented at the UN, no?
Belgurian canal
Yup
Exactly
The Lebensraum motivation did not work in the not too distant past
The awareness and sentiments from common people is the source of light and hope.
An occupier has no right to defend itself as well as every Palestinians has the right to hate it's occupier...
There’s only one State there called Israel.
For A to occupy B the B needs to exist otherwise is A occupying A.
I'm boycotting anything to do with JEWS (Israel). 🇮🇳🇬🇧
@alexarthur9088 at least you can read it more than once hay. 🤣🤣🤣
FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸🇵🇸💪🏽🙏🏽💯. 🇮🇳🇬🇧
@alexarthur9088 That question is for you to answer.
@@micksingh6711when is Khalistan getting its independence again?
The only good thing out of all of this is people are seeing how crimes are being committed using £$.
Do Palestinians have a right to defend themselves?
Is Apartheid Israel not condemnable for its ethnic cleansing and genocide?
Why isn't the host not asking this minister these question?
Perhaps the host is more intelligent and can see the conflict in broader terms.
Because the host is a very right wing conservative
The BBC are all bought and paid for, all sing from the same hymn sheet and are too yellow to go against the narrative because they are more interested in the money they get paid than they are in human lives.
Apartheid you say?
The rights Arab-heritage people have in Israel are far greater than they have under Hamas in Gaza!
@@anuradhavittachi On that point today's leftwing idiology inhibits many of those on the left from a deeper understanding of what's going on just as some conservatives have shallow unhelpful ideas too. The left is far from being helpful in this current war.
As a Minister, she should be aware that there is no right of self defense in law for an occupying force.
True! 👍👏👏👏👏👏
UN majority views Israel as a legitimate state...there are valid reasons to be annoyed at that, but it is the only valid framework so they do have the right
@@nihilistlivesmatterAs if the UN are a great authority 🙄
@@nas84payne I agree they are a lousy outfit..but unless you defer to the US's might is right hegemony it's all there is.
Sorry if it hurts your feelings
@@nihilistlivesmatter This is indeed correct. Israel is a legitimate state, Palestine is not in the eyes of the UK. In fact, the State of Palestine recognized Israel as part of the Oslo Accords in 1993
Politics! Politics! Politics! This is not the time for Politics! This is the time for us to get together to stop this crisis at once that is not only killing and torturing a people & destroying their small country but also killing us all morally in the knowledge that while the rest of us are able to walk in the streets, go shopping for food, eat, drink, wash, sleep without fear, etc etc we cannot stop thinking about how this people are suffering and how this has been allowed to carry on.
As soon as they say "Israel has the right to defend itself" you know she's about to come out with some one-sided bullshit
Do nations not have a right to defend themselves
So true.. 😅🙏
@@jds614 don't be intentionally dense. This phrase is being used to defend Israel's use of disproportionate retaliation and collective punishment of Palestinian civilians.
@@jds614, 😅 wow.. So we have to explain it to you like a child.. OK.. Here goes.... NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO BOMB INNOCENT WOMEN AND CHILDREN. NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO OCCUPY ANOTHER'S LAND. NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO GO AGAINST INTERNATIONAL LAW AND MURDER ENTIRE FAMILIES BY INDISCRIMINATE BOMBING. AND NO NATION SHOULD BE FORCED TO LIVE UNDER BRUTAL OCCUPATION, APARTHEID, SEIGE AND BE TERRORISED ON A DAILY BASIS, FROM HAVING TO WATCH THEIR HOMES DEMOLISHED, THEIR HOSPITALS BOMBED, THEIR REFUGEE AND UN 'PROTECTED' AREAS BOMBED. Educate yourself on what self defence actually is.
@@jds614is it self defence if they abuse Palestinians day and daily for years and a small group of them decide they've had enough and respond? Youd have to be routing for the bullies of the world if you're on the side of poor little Israel after everything else theyve done.
Problem with western journalism is they first pick a side then they start asking qiestions 😂
Corporate media can never be independent.
@@themarkbishop even for that you don't need to pick a side.
All while pretending to be neutral and both-siding it.
@@themarkbishop when ypu pick a side and asking one sided question, then its no longer journalism, its more like inquery for the side you pick. For instance, do you condemn hamas??? specially when you first start with it. the question can be originated from the conversation but it should not be a starting question.
@@nohandler1493 corporate media only brainwashes so as to sell products and political agenda
David Adler totally nailed it!! Please invite him back. Thank you for what you do Michael 🙏🏼
I kind of broke today because of this war. I will never forgive Israel.
Look after yourself please. Practice some meditation and self care. It's important to speak up for oppressed people of course.
@@sohaila6086 thanks :-)
i will never forgive Hamas ,, but you could always go and live in Gaza to be near the people you love
🙄
Have you seen footage from Oct 7th?? 🤡
When they say "Israel has the right to defend itself" they leave out "but the Palestinians don't have the right to protect themselves and their land".
When has a country had a terrorist cell and a national army fought the sovereign army? Taliban?
Israeli media and testimonies say that the IDF shoot and shelled it's own people on oct7th , testimonies from soldiers and survivors , they killed 350 people at the rave
proof ? middle east eye , haaretz ,and other reports and videos
also The Hannibal Directive of the IDF .
There is no country called "Palestine" nor has there ever been. The Palestinians could have had their own state several times over but they've said no every time.
Your getting extremely confused !! ISRAEL'S war is with HAMAS & it is in GAZA ....NOT PALESTINE ! Get your geography & facts correct !
How is killing civilians attacking HAMAS?
100% spot on analysis Michael Walker! Bravo!
I can't believe how dim this Tory minister is. My goodness have the UK Government sunk deep.
Yes
Yes!!
That’s what I was thinking. She comes across totally uneducated.
@@supersurfer1 as totally uneducated...
In the Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
Israel has been invading for a lot of years but think that Palestinians are not expected to fight back.
Xppected
That blonde needs to educate herself. She thinks Israel is dropping flowers from the F15 ?
The thing that I love is the reaction of the people, the public isn't buying this bs anymore
"Minister for Common Sense" is the most tragically boomer Daily Mail reader thing I've ever heard.
Reminds me of Harry Potter when they started bringing in Dolores to manage Hogwarts.
They call their ministers responsible for all sorts of bizarre shit. Distracts from fact they do nothing to run the various government departments anyway.
Minister of Colonial Sense
Omg... She said hostages. We have seen an exchange of children for soilders. That is the prisoner exchange that proud isreali has enabled barbarian nation has opened its gates.
Please tell me that title's not real? Please?
Thank you Novara. So glad you are presenting the truth
I love how this channel points out the bull💩 and highlights the truth
Exactly! This needs to seen by more people
As a scouser, every word from her mouth hurts my ears. She is not one of us.
As a Scouser, she makes me cringe.
@@josephobi.837hey hey hey , now then, now then.. 😮
❤
People like Esther McVey make me cringe as well.
Dey do dough don't dey dough? 😁
Yes man, she can't walk down the streets of her home city, or Doris, or edwina curry, can't believe these emerged from Liverpool
Fester McVile shouldnt have a platform anywhere
👏 Audience members, totally with you. Free Palestine
..and no more anti-Semitism...good man!
Knowing the BBC probably recruited from Hamas.
Isn't that what the IDF are doing?
Since when the occupier has the right to defend themselves?? And when the occupied one resist he will be called terrorist!!!!!!!!!!! What a cheos in the moralty
We Scots stand with Palestine and we Scots need independence from the criminal English establishment
Us Welsh stand with the Palestinian people. We need our independence.
Some international lawyers are saying that you can't invoke 'self defence' as a rational for bombing, when you occupy that very territory.
@@britnatzaredemocracydenier5922As an Irishman, I would recommend that wholeheartedly.
@@b62boom1 break up the UK it's the only way to govern our own country without the corrupt English establishment stealing all our money to fund England's richest
thank you for being a constant voice of reason Novara, we need to know what is happening so we can keep fighting ✊🇵🇸
It is really depressing when a victim becomes an oppressor. 😢
Piers Morgan, I hope you read this, watch and learn how REAL journalism is done! Keep up the great work guys
@waltersobchak1719 I don’t know why you feel the urge do defend piers morgan like he is you dad, relax yourself🤣 Or it is because this channel don’t bend the knee to zionism like piers do and the rest of the western media?🤔
@waltersobchak1719Not from this joke news channel anyway!😂
Do you condemn Israel
Morgan knows how real journalism was done. As a newspaper editor he took a strong, principled stance against the illegal Bush/Blair invasion of Iraq. That's why the present stance of his program is so sad. If he still has the principles he had then his heart must not be in it.
Morgan belongs to Rupert murdoch so there’s no chance of any real journalism with him.
8,000 children is 20+ primary schools!
It is shocking to hear people saying that one side has a better argument than the other for killing innocent people.
Its not about sides. Its about whats right. Israel the apartheid state is wrong and is the root cause of these issues
@@lilrr1431You clearly think one side has a better argument.
@@noelpucarua2843 the occupied ALWAYS have the better argument for killing than the occupiers.
@waltersobchak1719it’s the other way. Please read and educate yourself.
@@lilrr1431 "Its not about sides. Its about whats right. Israel the apartheid state is wrong and is the root cause of these issues"
That statement was so fantastically, unbelievably obtuse. Quite literally in the same breath - you utterly rejected your own premise.
The occupier doesn't have a right to self defense, according to international law. Please watch Francisca...special UN representative for Palestine
@waltersobchak1719The world is not fooled by Israel's divide and rule, Palestine is more than just Gaza.
@waltersobchak1719Israel controls everything in Gaza; what goes in, what goes out.
It's an occupation.
Actions speaks louder then world, no matter what Ester say her words means nothing.
“Minister for common sense” sounds like the start of a norm mcDonald joke 😂😂😂
Of course the worst thing about Netanyahu is the hypocrisy
Imagine SNL had something smart to say 🤣
No, it's out of 1984, as in Ministry of Truth!😀
How much extra money is earned by a minister for Ha Ha common s name,?
Reminds me so much of the "common sense checklist" from the thick of it, man that show was so ahead of its time.
Omg how lower can this government get
Common sense tells me they have to go ASAP NOW
Labour won't change a thing
To many labour cultistsjustas Tory cultists
Has anyone ever brought up that the Hamas attack WAS indeed an act of self-defense in itself?
The world is full of wicked ones and a few good human beings😢
It is scary that this people are leading us! If international law doesn’t really work we are all in DANGER!
Yep.
Exactly my thoughts😳
@Anastasia...middle class opinions are welcome here...they are suffering too!
I agree, Anastasia.
@@chatham43What ???
Absolute nonsense coming out of minister of common BS!!
bravo People ❤❤❤
Well she is not in a position to lecture anyone due to her participation in the PPE scandal (she referred some firms using the “VIP lane” to get the public contracts and it turns out the PPE was very costly and the material delivered unusable resulting in a waste of public money of almost £2 billions)
She should be investigated ! Did she receive any consideration from the deal ?
But now the fact that we have a “Ministry of Common sense” is 1) another waste of money and 2) very scary for the freedom of speech, this sounds very much like 1984 from George Orwell. It should not be a bunch of corrupted politicians to police what is “common sense” and what it is not.
Esther McVey should be investigated. Absolutely right. Nearly billions money wasted. As she sounds siding with israel makes you think where those billions travelled????
In the US our politicians wouldn’t know common sense to save their own lives.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👍
Ministério da Verdade
UKay and YouS are spiralling down.....moral compass.
Am sick to death of:
Do you Condemning hamas?
Israel have the right to defend themselves!!!
It's a horrible lie that IL is pushing down the worlds throat, it's disgusting what the Hasbara is promoting with their propaganda, any state that continues to stand behind these terrorists (IL) are complicit in all the deaths. They are as such as wrong and sick as the murderers themselves.
No they don't its an occupying force 😂😂
Me too I hate these questions🤮
..and me
It’s the same shit on different names as has always been the case. Coming from Northern Ireland everyone had to condemn terrorism from the republican side, the loyalist sides terrorism was never asked to be condemned and then state sponsored terrorism like Bloody Sunday gets whitewashed and is seen as the English defending themself against the IRA and to do so they murder 14 people on a peaceful civil rights march
They said Palestinians would forget their bad experiences in 1948. They haven’t and neither have we
We will never forget, my grandparents had there land taken and were forced out of there homeland.
Gaza Marine is a natural gas field off the coast of the Gaza Strip. The Gaza Marine natural gas field is located in water about 36 kilometers (22 mi) offshore at a depth of 2,000 feet (610 m). The field was discovered in 2000 by BP Group and it is estimated to contain more than 1 trillion cubic feet of natural gas.
What was their bad experience? Trying to kill Jews during the war of independence
In the Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
@@Jesus_SOG_we believe all prophets are in paradise, the last messenger Muhammad, upon him be peace is the leader of all prophets .
THE FACT that government has Minister for Common sense shows how reduculious they are.
The UK appoints a minister for “Common Sense”…..good GOD have mercy! Not only does this woman not have any, but the fact that this is the best they could find says a lot..
Is england not good enough for you,Esther mcvey for pm
@@Connor-o9q Shalom Leah, doing what you do best are you? We’re not all thick you know luv
Fantastic parrot that lady is. Double standard again and again.
How any government can still stand by Israel is mind-boggling.
How the Left can offer the level of support to Hamas that it is, is even more mind-boggling.
@@alistair7539 exactly!
....but anti-Semitism is totally unacceptable...absolutely agree!
@@alistair7539who is offering support to Hamas?
@@alistair7539
Palestine has the right to defend itself from child killers and occupants.
Free Palestine.
Thank you guys for standing up for justice and doing amazing amazing job. God bless you. Free Palestine!
The minister for no common sense hasn’t got a clue!!!
How dare speak of our next PM in such a disrespectful manner.
Monty python Ministry for funny walks comes to mind
Esther is so cringey 😬
Definitely not Esther. Esther was right.
@@moodist1erNo she wasn't
@@jenny2tone242 for not wanting to dance naked in front of her husbands guests?
@@moodist1erwhat?
@@camelotchimp you don't know the story of Esther? She has her own book in the Bible.
# Free, Free Palestine 🍉🇵🇸🍉🇵🇸🍉🇵🇸🍉
This is appalling
We will never forget the Genocide committed by Israel
Terrorism should be condemned by all human beings. Torturing innocent people to promote any ideology is unacceptable.
Powerful when the audience speaks up. The people by and large know what’s happening and just can’t fathom why their governments are going along and even SUPPORTING it. It’s disgusting. And the Western govts have dug their own bed here… I for one am absolutely ASHAMED of my country. I have NEVER been more ashamed to be an American citizen. Many many atrocities have been committed supposedly in “my name” or by my country, but this is so far beyond the pale. All politicians that support these war crimes should all be held accountable in the strictest means possible under law.
Such a touching and human statement. Thank you for showing that there are also thoughtful people in the US.
HONEST STATEMENT BRAVO ❤❤
People are waking up
Thank you, audience ❤❤❤
@@joshmartinez6092 must wake up BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE 😒😒😒
@@nadeemmustafa6450 I agree that it’s already too late for so so many, but awareness is growing and that’s never a bad thing. I agree; it’s too little too late… but that’s not a reason to quit or be discouraged.
There are still millions that need our help and we are very much making a difference, however small at first. Like drops in the ocean, it’s together that we find our strength.
Michael and David I want to thank both of your consistent speaking of the truth. Thank you for always posting reminders of the atrocities that have happened and continue to happen in Palestine. Love from Libya ❤️❤️
I find it so hard to believe so many people are so ignorant as to what is really going on
Palestine FOREVER
The current UN Special Rapporteur on Occupied Palestine, Francesca Albanese has the clearest explanation on why Israel right to defend themselves is false according to the international law. I can feel the frustration of the British people towards their blind government on this matter.
Unbelievable, the appointment and that she is paid to do this nonsense job!
Article 51 paragraph 139 of the UN charter says Israel cannot 'claim' self defence when an attack emanates from occupied territory, they can respond to an attack but they cannot claim the phrase self-defence.
The UN doesn’t even know International Law.
For A to occupy B the B needs to exist or A is occupying A.
When people speak about Israel without knowing International Law quickly fall into ignorance.
International Law Lesson
Israel can’t occupy Israel’s Land.
Search for the Map of British Palestine.
So in 1948 Israel followed the Principle of International Law called Uti Possidetis Juris and the borders of the new State of Israel were the same as the Previous Geo Political Entity the British Mandate.
This includes what’s now Israel and the Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem.
There’s no other State there for an occupation.
Just because there was a Political Vote in the UN with the result that Palestine is a State doesn’t make it so under International Law.
UN Resolutions don’t have the Force of Law.
From the Law perspective Gazans are illegal inside Israeli Territory.
Israel left Gaza in 2005 but didn’t sign any Treaty to give Gaza so Gaza is still part of Israel.
Jordan was created under the same Uti Possidetis Juris but the UN, the International Community and Palestinians don’t say that Jordan is occupying their Land.
This "Palestine doesn't exist" argument is redundant. If Palestine doesn't exist why is it in the Balfour Declaration as the land given to israel by the British?@@luisdotgarcia
Israel left Gaza in 2005, it is NOt an occupied territory. Do some reserach and stop spouting this left-wing propaganda.
So couldn't this count as ethnic cleansing of its own people?(Palestinians)
@@luisdotgarcia 🤣
In international law it is nowhere to be found that the occupying force has a 'right' to defend itself. Instead it is explicitly written that an occupied nation has a right to fight for it's freedom. Palestine will be free.
What about Palestinian hostages? Why these biased people do not talk about them? Thanks for bringing the truth out Michael.
An occupier does not have the right to defend itself. They're full of lies!
You guys, especially Michael Walker, are making amazing videos that touch my heart. ❤️ You are speaking truth to power! 💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼 Please keep making such great content!
Thank you , thank you for good reporting .
Mohammed not British name
Is it just me or do other people find Esther McVay utterly despicable and disgusting.
.....dunno..only you would know about that and your views on anti-Semitism..😊
@@chatham43and you with your genocidal compliance
@@chatham43wats that got to do with anything,so criticising any single jew is anti semitic??
I was called homophobic once, because I said I didn't own any Elton John records@@Lindaeditz8
@chatham43 You don't sound stupid at all, do you?
Is there anything in service of the public that Esther McVey is right on?
She has to be right about common sense doesn't she, right.
I bet the people of Liverpool are ashamed
@@williamcampbell9335 yer your right they don’t take kindly to a nutty talking Tory up there,bet she don’t liv there still
Nothing but a floosie!!!!
Service of the public, no. Service to the Tory party? Yes! She makes even 30p Lee look positively average!
Anyone still saying Israel is defending itself is deluded beyond belief.
HAHA - then I am deluded. And Islamic fundamentalists aren't?
In the Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
They are defending themselves. But Netanyahu funded Hamas so they got to get rid of him first.
This is the picture instead of a solution to the freedom of Gazans and the Palestinians all the narrative is on the destruction of Hamas, it shows how every bl*dy politician cares about the Palestinians. All they care about is for isralie to win, and then the same tragedy for another 75 years
I agree. This is mass murder. And the US and UK governments ha e sanctioned it. Not in my name!!!
What needs to be brought up when pro Israel people start flapping their gums is to ask about Nokba and ask about mowing the grass.
It looks like they are not mowing the lawn this time they're turning over the soil leveling for re seeding
There will be no end to this until people like you and I are both pro-Palestinian and pro-Israeli. The stand you are currently taking is fueling the fire.
@@alistair7539 I never been pro Palestinian I'm ex Muslim atheist Turk but was pro Israeli I've seen a side to them that I can't stomach so these days I'm just pro humanity. It's shocking how people I had considered decent people just repeat like robots a few phrases and ignore this high tech killing on a large scale.
I'm pro humanity too, especially when humanity embraces wisdom, understanding and kindness. There will be peace in the region once people want peace more than conflict, when there is more respect than hatred, and when Muslims and Jews alike can see the humanity in each other.
Michael thank U much learning 🙏 ❤❤❤God Almighty bless 🙌 South Africa ❤❤❤U
Domestic ciolence perpetrators also say 'she made me do it'. Blaming the Palestinian victim for the crimes of the Israeli barbaric army is absolutely disgusting.
So we just forget Hamas was the first to launch an attack?
Technically the occupied people were defending themselves. There’s no resistance that’s not seen as terrorism.
Domestic violence analogy, very appropriate, yes ... Hamas saying: "Israel made us do it"...
@@Slowgrindtoglory... You are ignorant of the little factual detail that Gaza is not an "occupied territory" ... Show the alleged occupying PRESENCE of Israel in Gaza prior to 7 October ... please do ...
@@jsemplefelton5348the ethnic cleansing of Sheikh Jarah neighborhood and IDF incursions into al-Aqsa mosque happened before October 7 sweaty
She acknowledges that the Palestinian panellist to her right is _”closer to this, than I.”_ And yet she went on to express a such an ignorant and offensive opinion.
Enough with these lies. We stand with humanity. We stand with Palestine!
Doesn't Palestine (Palestinians) have a right to exist? A right to defend themselves?
Why does the narrative seem to exist that only one side have these rights ?
You're absolutely right about the spoken language and body language that conveys a two tiered sense of humanity or lack thereof.
It's disgusting.
Absolutely or just the west/ Ukrain?
But they don't have the right to attack Israel. Hamas has destroyed Gaza. Hamas is the only one to blame.
Israeli media and testimonies say that the IDF shoot and shelled it's own people on oct7th , testimonies from soldiers and survivors , they killed 350 people at the rave
proof ? middle east eye , haaretz ,and other reports and videos
also The Hannibal Directive of the IDF .
@@peterk7492 What a bunch of non-sense you are saying.
Too much tv,i guess
Thank you for your great coverage on what’s happening in this conflict.
No, she's lovely.
This genicide is so appalling and the fact ghat the USA blocked the UN decision to call for a ceasefire i find disgusting- 6,000 children killed by israel.
I picked my side after learning from Anna Baltzer, Norman Finkelstein, Gideon Levy and others. My prayers for Palestinians 🇵🇸
Aye!
Yes i picked my side after Listening to the irish scottish and really listening to the truth from Prof Finklestein Ms Baltzer et al
Occupation is the problem not the resistance. Remember that the USA and UK were the biggest supporters of the apartheid in SA.
South Africa is some mess now is it not.
@@marcuskingstanley9522
What western country isn't? You are all in a big sh*te...
South Africa doing better than UK US EU this day's...😂
How can an occupation exist or there only one State there since 1948 called Israel.
@@marcuskingstanley9522are you actually arguing that apartheid is good?
@@monaliza3334 they do have the resources. The westerners showed them and how to exploit it. South africa will be jungle again in another 100 years
Everything she said Israeli idf has done for 75 years but its ok they are CHOSEN but chosen for what ????
I feel like shaving her head bald. She certainly has no mind of her own. She just parroting what was instructed.
a typical Tory MP
Love your videos guys.
Keep up the great content and exposing the truth!