I wonder how much of the inner programming they had to rewrite for this game. I'd personally love to hear someone who worked on it to go into detail regarding all the platform quirks they had to fix or change to get it to work. That sort of stuff fascinates me as a hobbyist programmer. I should get this game and try it out for myself. Good video!
Thanks! I always wonder about that stuff too. There are a thousand issues and decisions in each little change made. Even things that didn't change probably took a heck of a lot of work just to make it happen on the 3DS.
My theory as to why it’s on the 3ds is because the game was always meant to be in “3D”. The GameCube was originally going to have a “3D” feature to allow some games to be in “3D”. But it was scrapped. The only game they had planned for it was Luigi’s mansion. Sue to it being scrapped, they probably remade it on 3ds to make it 3D like it was always meant to be.
@@momoman64 Yeah… that's why Nintendo scrapped it. 3D displays were not ubiquitous in 2001, they were incredibly expensive. That doesn't take away from the fact that they'd always *wanted* to make Luigi's Mansion a 3D experience. I don't know why Luigi's Mansion was brought to 3DS as late as it was, but it made perfect sense for them to bring it to the 3DS solely because it allowed them to finally give the original game that 3D experience.
@@odnorando8684except the lack of a 2nd screen that gives consoles a little more merit to exist Though to be fair that would make the switch more fragile and expensive
It's really not that complicated. The original game was planned to have stereoscopic 3D, but with 3D displays being incredibly expensive, Nintendo scrapped this idea. With 3D now being one of the 3DS's primary selling points and a baked in feature, they could now bring proper stereoscopic 3D to the original game as intended back in 2001.
A very well-made video, nice input. Luigi's Mansion is honestly a good game (and relatively cheap to buy in GameStop and some other places from around $15 and up), and it's delightful to see the Quality-of-life changes that were made for the 3DS version of the game. This game (and many others) really proves how powerful the 3DS/New 3DS line was, it was the Wii in the palm of your hand! (Though I'd say it's more of a GameCube 1.5 in the palm of your hand, but it depends on opinion.) It also proves that games on the go were actually viable, and not just separate from the home consoles. Hence why I say that the Golden year of mobile gaming was around 2011 (The launch of the iPhone 4S, where it had ports of games once considered “too intensive to run”). To 2017, Which was the year of the switch (which actually had hardware considered “obsolete,” but still powerful, and I felt the “formula” for the console in the palm of your hand was perfected at that point) Fun fact: Since the OG 3DS has 128 MB RAM, most games use a 64/64 MB split (half for the OS, half for the game), but in some special cases, games can use a 96/32 MB split (or 3/4 RAM for the game, 1/4 for the OS). This is because some games need as much power and performance as possible, like Sm4sh for 3DS. To make sure all RAM is reallocated properly, iirc the 3DS resets itself after exiting a game that has those circumstances. Running 3DS games that use the 96/32 MB split on an N3DS won't do the reset, as it has 256 MB of RAM (which means the N3DS has a 128/128 MB RAM allocation, meaning the 96 MB is already supplied to the game itself.)
I think it was to give reason to Gooigi in Luigi's Mansion 3, helping to tie stuff in. Maybe then Luigi's Mansion 2 HD will tell us how the vacuum got back into the car before 3.
The Hidden Mansion was in the original Luigi’s Mansion game on the GameCube or at least the Player’s Choice edition. I think losing coins when getting hurt was also a thing, but I haven’t played in a while so I’m less certain on that one.
Well only for the PAL version of the GameCube version. So you must be from Europe or Australia. Whereas for the 3ds remake the hidden mansion was available everywhere.
@@rohitkashyap9904 Actually the hidden mansion was available for North America. The PAL version's difference was that the hidden mansion was harder and mirror'd.
1.the original had The hidden mansion the pal just had some different things going on 2. In the original when the Ghost hit you, you did lose coins 3. The original was a lot better because you had better controls and it looks scarier 4. I think we all died at the final boss at first 5. I like the cutsences makes it more alive
Never understood why they would release this game on the 3ds instead of remastering it on the switch to garner hype for the 3rd installment. They’ll probably bring the original eventually if GameCube games get added to switch online but still that’s a rerelease and not a remaster which this game desperately needs imo.
I believe with a modded 3DS you can cast your screen(s?) to your computer and record gameplay that way. Also on the New 3DS’ you can scan Amibo by tapping them on the bottom screen.
Yeah that might be helpful, but I still like to emulate most games to upscale the resolution. And yeah I forgot the New 3DS doesn't need the NFC reader.
@@CafeCharlieYou need a “new” modded 3ds or 2ds to share the console’s screen and maker recording on pc possible. It is still possible to do this with old 3ds and 2ds but it is discouraged as these consoles are not powerful enough to do it and they will make the game run 10fps
I remember when this channel was at 2k subs, it's great to come back and see how much it's grown. Good luck to you Charlie. By the way what's the name of the outro music?
Thank you for sticking around! The outro music is 'Party In The Clouds' from the soundtrack of 'Adventure Time: Hey Ice King! Why'd You Steal Our Garbage?!!'
i played this game bc i never had a luigis mansion gamecube but always loved that game so when this one came out i was super excited! and i forgot about dark moon egadd being in the beginning, but since dark moon is my favorite game ever it was so cool
"Menus are a little different, who cares?" Me! Thy changed the "Welcome to your mansion", "Welcome to our mansion" transition - removing the "y" is supposed to be a subtle little change but now the whole formatting changes, it's way too obvious, misses the original intention and looks rubbish.
His proportions were all worng in the original,his legs from the knee down were wider then the rest of his body,he had T-Rex arms and hands,and whenever he took his hat off it revealed his dented skull.
I assume that 1) the whole 3d thing and 2) it was probably built off of lm2 engine, the lm3 engine (whether its the same or not idk) probably wasnt finished yet
They made it for the 3ds because it was supposed to be a 3ds game originally, if it wasnt for that reason i doubt they would have put effort to change all the polygons so the 3ds can handle it.
The first thing that comes to mind with this release is: "Why?" but also, Luigi's Mansion 2, which is on the 3DS also. However this game was developed by Grezzo, so that puts it more along the lines of the Zelda remakes.
In my opinion this has more purpose than the Luigi's Mansion 2 HD remake (sorry if I offended all 16 Luigi Mansion Dark Moon fans) (also don't take this seriously)
I’ve never played the original, so I really appreciate this remake (GameCube games can be hella expensive now) the model feels weird, though. I mean the original looks… well, ugly. But the new one looks out of place, like they just slapped a stock Luigi model on without changing the animations to suit it. a second analog stick sure sounds nice though, the stick on the new 3DS just will not work with this game, so I end up having to tilt the entire system all the time to look up and down (which of course is uber annoying)
Yeah I was super happy when I first saw this cause the original is like 100 bucks easy. I've played through both and I didn't really have an issue with the 3DS controls, but I might just be used to them from Dark Moon.
@PixlYFied👾 Yeah as far as I know, every type of DS (including 3DS, New 3DS, and 2DS) can play original DS games like Mario 64 DS. The 2DS is probably the cheapest option if you want to be able to play original DS games and 3DS games like the Luigi's Mansion Remaster.
0:55 I hate to be that guy... wait no I love being that guy, but the most powerful shape is a triangle. It is the most powerful structural shape known to man.
Hm, the wiki says it only came to America in 2018 with the 3DS version. But I've seen a few people say they played the secret mansion in original version in the US, so you might be right.
@Charlie's Café Well since it was in the very early days before Patch notes were a thing, could've been a very lucky distribution error or manufacturer error 😁
I hate the sequels, their not spooky enough and dont follow the same camera format as the original. The first LM had a real creepy vibe to it which is what made it so great
This was not a bad remake. But not a good one either. And I’m worried that with the recent confirmation of dark moon port they’ll just port over this one which is bad. The original game is the best one.
I wonder how much of the inner programming they had to rewrite for this game. I'd personally love to hear someone who worked on it to go into detail regarding all the platform quirks they had to fix or change to get it to work. That sort of stuff fascinates me as a hobbyist programmer. I should get this game and try it out for myself. Good video!
Thanks! I always wonder about that stuff too. There are a thousand issues and decisions in each little change made. Even things that didn't change probably took a heck of a lot of work just to make it happen on the 3DS.
Digital Foundary did a video on this
My theory as to why it’s on the 3ds is because the game was always meant to be in “3D”. The GameCube was originally going to have a “3D” feature to allow some games to be in “3D”. But it was scrapped. The only game they had planned for it was Luigi’s mansion. Sue to it being scrapped, they probably remade it on 3ds to make it 3D like it was always meant to be.
Yeah but this game came out a decade before 3D was booming and the 3ds game came out when the switch was out..
@@momoman64 Yeah… that's why Nintendo scrapped it. 3D displays were not ubiquitous in 2001, they were incredibly expensive. That doesn't take away from the fact that they'd always *wanted* to make Luigi's Mansion a 3D experience.
I don't know why Luigi's Mansion was brought to 3DS as late as it was, but it made perfect sense for them to bring it to the 3DS solely because it allowed them to finally give the original game that 3D experience.
On 3ds because switch is over rated trash
@@starman5901Man I love the 3DS but the Switch is in almost every way superior to it lol.
@@odnorando8684except the lack of a 2nd screen that gives consoles a little more merit to exist
Though to be fair that would make the switch more fragile and expensive
It's really not that complicated. The original game was planned to have stereoscopic 3D, but with 3D displays being incredibly expensive, Nintendo scrapped this idea.
With 3D now being one of the 3DS's primary selling points and a baked in feature, they could now bring proper stereoscopic 3D to the original game as intended back in 2001.
The hidden mansion was available for North America.
The PAL version's difference was that the hidden mansion was harder and mirror'd.
A very well-made video, nice input. Luigi's Mansion is honestly a good game (and relatively cheap to buy in GameStop and some other places from around $15 and up), and it's delightful to see the Quality-of-life changes that were made for the 3DS version of the game.
This game (and many others) really proves how powerful the 3DS/New 3DS line was, it was the Wii in the palm of your hand! (Though I'd say it's more of a GameCube 1.5 in the palm of your hand, but it depends on opinion.) It also proves that games on the go were actually viable, and not just separate from the home consoles.
Hence why I say that the Golden year of mobile gaming was around 2011 (The launch of the iPhone 4S, where it had ports of games once considered “too intensive to run”). To 2017, Which was the year of the switch (which actually had hardware considered “obsolete,” but still powerful, and I felt the “formula” for the console in the palm of your hand was perfected at that point)
Fun fact: Since the OG 3DS has 128 MB RAM, most games use a 64/64 MB split (half for the OS, half for the game), but in some special cases, games can use a 96/32 MB split (or 3/4 RAM for the game, 1/4 for the OS). This is because some games need as much power and performance as possible, like Sm4sh for 3DS. To make sure all RAM is reallocated properly, iirc the 3DS resets itself after exiting a game that has those circumstances. Running 3DS games that use the 96/32 MB split on an N3DS won't do the reset, as it has 256 MB of RAM (which means the N3DS has a 128/128 MB RAM allocation, meaning the 96 MB is already supplied to the game itself.)
Hey thanks! I didn't know that about the 3DS, always wondered why it reset like that on some games. Really interesting stuff, thanks for sharing.
Nintendo should have released Luigi's Mansion HD with LM2HD for the switch.
Exactly it would have given more purpose for the Luigi's Mansion 2 HD
That metal part went hard lmfao.
I think it was to give reason to Gooigi in Luigi's Mansion 3, helping to tie stuff in. Maybe then Luigi's Mansion 2 HD will tell us how the vacuum got back into the car before 3.
The Hidden Mansion was in the original Luigi’s Mansion game on the GameCube or at least the Player’s Choice edition. I think losing coins when getting hurt was also a thing, but I haven’t played in a while so I’m less certain on that one.
Well only for the PAL version of the GameCube version. So you must be from Europe or Australia. Whereas for the 3ds remake the hidden mansion was available everywhere.
@@rohitkashyap9904 Actually the hidden mansion was available for North America.
The PAL version's difference was that the hidden mansion was harder and mirror'd.
Really nice editing here! I like this style of review, not to overbearing. Rather cozy. Thank You!
Well thank you!
I was always so mad that it wasn’t on switch
Your videos are right up my alley! Subscribed
Happy this got made led me to playing the sequel and buying a switch lite for part 3. Luigi needs some love since mario is always the super star
I WANT THIS PORTED TO THE SWITCH SO BADD
Same here. I really want to replay this game again like on the game cube
Also who made that outro song Jesus that was amazing
It's called "Party in The Clouds" from "Adventure Time: Hey Ice King! Why'd You Steal Our Garbage?!!". The game's got a surprisingly great soundtrack.
This is super well edited for such a small channel, good job
Thank you!
1.the original had The hidden mansion the pal just had some different things going on
2. In the original when the Ghost hit you, you did lose coins
3. The original was a lot better because you had better controls and it looks scarier
4. I think we all died at the final boss at first
5. I like the cutsences makes it more alive
I honestly had more trouble with Boolossus than I did with King Boo. I died either 2 or 3 times since I got it.
my man tried to unlock the ace of spades via NFC
The NFC scanner is only required for original 3ds, xl, and 2ds systems. Its built into all of the "new" models
Never understood why they would release this game on the 3ds instead of remastering it on the switch to garner hype for the 3rd installment. They’ll probably bring the original eventually if GameCube games get added to switch online but still that’s a rerelease and not a remaster which this game desperately needs imo.
Because 3ds is way better then trash switch
@@starman5901240p games are not the standard.
3:27 bro I lost breath 😂🤣💀
This game exists for the exact same reason OOT and MM exist on the 3DS I would assume
I believe with a modded 3DS you can cast your screen(s?) to your computer and record gameplay that way.
Also on the New 3DS’ you can scan Amibo by tapping them on the bottom screen.
Yeah that might be helpful, but I still like to emulate most games to upscale the resolution. And yeah I forgot the New 3DS doesn't need the NFC reader.
You cant
Really its shit
The footage is low quality and it drops a LOT of frames inconsistenly
Its the worse way to capture footage on the 3ds
@@CafeCharlieYou need a “new” modded 3ds or 2ds to share the console’s screen and maker recording on pc possible. It is still possible to do this with old 3ds and 2ds but it is discouraged as these consoles are not powerful enough to do it and they will make the game run 10fps
I remember when this channel was at 2k subs, it's great to come back and see how much it's grown. Good luck to you Charlie. By the way what's the name of the outro music?
Thank you for sticking around! The outro music is 'Party In The Clouds' from the soundtrack of 'Adventure Time: Hey Ice King! Why'd You Steal Our Garbage?!!'
i played this game bc i never had a luigis mansion gamecube but always loved that game so when this one came out i was super excited! and i forgot about dark moon egadd being in the beginning, but since dark moon is my favorite game ever it was so cool
I'm pretty sure everyone is happy that they can play an old console day hub and they can get the game to play on the go
The more important question is why they didn’t remake it for the switch? Why did they make Luigi’s Mansion 2 or all things?
"Menus are a little different, who cares?" Me! Thy changed the "Welcome to your mansion", "Welcome to our mansion" transition - removing the "y" is supposed to be a subtle little change but now the whole formatting changes, it's way too obvious, misses the original intention and looks rubbish.
Personally prefer luigis model in the remake. Always thought the one on gamecube was weird
Yeah that's kind of what I thought
It was pretty much Luigi’s prototype on Gamecube, it was right when they started making the new designs we see today.
@nicwo Luigi looks alot better in mario kart double dash
His proportions were all worng in the original,his legs from the knee down were wider then the rest of his body,he had T-Rex arms and hands,and whenever he took his hat off it revealed his dented skull.
I'm glad this was made since I don't own a gamecube, plus i prefer portable consoles anyway so it was a welcome game in my book
Saw this game for sale on a shopping app, and then after a few months I went back for it and it was sold already
This was an awesome video!
Thank you!
I assume that 1) the whole 3d thing and 2) it was probably built off of lm2 engine, the lm3 engine (whether its the same or not idk) probably wasnt finished yet
Well from what I can assume is they kept releasing 3DS titles like this one just in case the Switch didn't catch on or was a "failure"
Short answer: They released it to promote Luigi’s Mansion 3 on the Switch!
Yeah it could have been a way to get people into Luigi's Mansion before releasing the 3rd. Thanks for watching!
Considering the lore tie-ins to Gooigi, most likely yes they did.
They said wanna try our new mechanic that everyone wishes we didn’t use in the game we actually got it right in?
the doom eternal music fit so well like a glove
They made it for the 3ds because it was supposed to be a 3ds game originally, if it wasnt for that reason i doubt they would have put effort to change all the polygons so the 3ds can handle it.
Kinda weird to have a remastered game in the year later the 3rd installment of the Luigi mansion was announced
Can I have a Nintendo 3DS with Luigis mansion one please
is there any way to download it for the ds AND IM NOT TALKING ABOUT THE 3DS BC I DONT HAVE ONE
Not everyone still has a GameCube or a wii thats compatible with game cube games
Sure, but the switch was out by then, and not everyone had a 3DS either. I get why they remade it, but it's a little bit odd that it happened.
You lose coins when you take damage in the original too
The first thing that comes to mind with this release is: "Why?" but also, Luigi's Mansion 2, which is on the 3DS also.
However this game was developed by Grezzo, so that puts it more along the lines of the Zelda remakes.
now we're getting 2 but not the original 💀
The biggest question is why did they release it at the literal end of the 3DS' life cycle? Why didn't they just make a Switch port instead?
I think you forgot the end cards
Yeah I totally did, thanks for pointing that out!
@@CafeCharlie
You are totally welcome
I forgot about that
Came for Luigi, stayed for Mick. Epic edit!
Thanks lol
They lie to me saying pal hidden mansion was coming back BUT I has not the best of it what is mirror mansion
In my opinion this has more purpose than the Luigi's Mansion 2 HD remake (sorry if I offended all 16 Luigi Mansion Dark Moon fans) (also don't take this seriously)
First game I ever beat on GameCube 😊
Love this game, was ready to be mad based off title. But the video was positive cx
It should've been upscaled and ported to Switch with improvement and 60fps. Still salty this game never made in on Switch in the first place
I think they had to rebuild the whole game, just like the remake of dark moon for the 3ds
Um. Hidden mansion was on ntsc Luigi’s mansion on GameCube
I just realised you sound like Nathaniel Bandy
it’s a little expensive unless you hack your 3ds…
I think this game would have worked better if you could use b and x to look up and down like in dark moon
Yeah that would be nice
I’ve never played the original, so I really appreciate this remake (GameCube games can be hella expensive now) the model feels weird, though. I mean the original looks… well, ugly. But the new one looks out of place, like they just slapped a stock Luigi model on without changing the animations to suit it.
a second analog stick sure sounds nice though, the stick on the new 3DS just will not work with this game, so I end up having to tilt the entire system all the time to look up and down (which of course is uber annoying)
Yeah I was super happy when I first saw this cause the original is like 100 bucks easy. I've played through both and I didn't really have an issue with the 3DS controls, but I might just be used to them from Dark Moon.
@@CafeCharlie in dark moon, you can look up with X, that’s probably why I had no problem there.
@@VaniRoyal ah yeah you're right.
lol I remember that glitch from dark moon in the thumbnail
Great video!!
I need to know please reply: can you play this on the DS lite or just on the 3DS?
It's just a 3DS game, sorry.
Aww man
Wait but then can you play DS games like Mario 64 DS on the 3DS
@PixlYFied👾 Yeah as far as I know, every type of DS (including 3DS, New 3DS, and 2DS) can play original DS games like Mario 64 DS. The 2DS is probably the cheapest option if you want to be able to play original DS games and 3DS games like the Luigi's Mansion Remaster.
Alright thanks
It wasn’t Nintendo it was Grezzo, they were possibly working on it many years before.
0:55 I hate to be that guy... wait no I love being that guy, but the most powerful shape is a triangle. It is the most powerful structural shape known to man.
That's just because man doesn't fully understand the power of the cube.
If you think about it for a little, the cube is made out of several triangles, therefore making the cube the most powerful shape.
Well, I have hidden mansion. I’m in North America.
The fact they removed the low Nintendo already means they fucked up. Hard. Don’t hurt the content like that.
Hidden Mansion was for the PAL only!? But mine has it and it was bought here in the US. I still replay my copy from time to time with my little sister
Hm, the wiki says it only came to America in 2018 with the 3DS version. But I've seen a few people say they played the secret mansion in original version in the US, so you might be right.
@Charlie's Café Well since it was in the very early days before Patch notes were a thing, could've been a very lucky distribution error or manufacturer error 😁
@@dreemingAlex Very true!
@@CafeCharlieIn the original for PAL only, they had the hidden mansion like we did, but it was mirrored, that's the only difference I think they had
This belongs on the switch not the 3ds
I 100% AGREE!!! 🔥💯🔥
Nintendo Switch version, WHEN!?!?!?
What are you talking about? it's a solid port.
i was playing it and i was caught off guard by gooigi and e gad from dark moon lol
I hope you didn't actually break your 2ds
I hate the sequels, their not spooky enough and dont follow the same camera format as the original.
The first LM had a real creepy vibe to it which is what made it so great
Commenting for the algorithm
Thank you, it hasn't been picking these Luigi's Mansion vids up
But it's still a good game
What a remake this is 1/3 of the price and worse graphics 😅
SUPER SHOW LETS GO!!!!! 4:48
nintendo is so a poorly administered company like why is it so hard to play gamecube games?
Why didn't they release this one for Switch? Dark Moon is an updated 3DS port, they put this on 3DS and it should be on Switch too.
The new 3ds is not more powerful than the GameCube
Not only is it more powerful, has better games then crap cube
Hi
Hola
Hey
First lol im sorry
This comment has all 5 stages of grief in it
Dark moon gave me a headache ngl, trash game
I think it was just so good that your feeble mind couldn't handle the sheer awesomeness
@@CafeCharlieright
@@CafeCharlie Dark moon on Switch proves my point hahaha
Jesus died for your sins and rose from the dead 3 days later so that you may have eternal life, believe in who He is and what He did to be saved
This was not a bad remake. But not a good one either. And I’m worried that with the recent confirmation of dark moon port they’ll just port over this one which is bad. The original game is the best one.