Harry Potter Theory: The Origin of Moody's Eye
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 лип 2018
- Use our link www.audible.com/scb or text code scb to 500-500 to get a free book and 30-day free trial.
SCB on The Philly D Book Club :: • Video
Today Ben dives into the Wizarding world of Harry Potter to discuss the mysterious history of Mad Eye Moody's eye and if it was perhaps once owned by Gellert Grindelwald
P A T R E O N ►► / supercarlinbrothers
M E R C H ►► store.dftba.com/collections/s...
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
PLAYLISTS
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
V L O G ►► / jonathancarlin
I N S T A G R A M ►► / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K ►► / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..) - Фільми й анімація
Don't forget the Eye of Providence is featured in the MACUSA law enforcement department emblem. And what is their motto ? "Always stay vigilant"
KaiserAfini CONSTANT VIGILANCE
I swear I'm literally imagining the wizardfolk there talking about reptilians
Maybe Moody works for MACUSA and MOM at the same time and he is at a high MACUSA rank and lost an eye so they gave him the eye
:O
Omg, this is insane...
Moody helped Dumbledore because an eye for an eye
Frenzied Ferret I was gonna comment this :(
JereToon Did Eye beat you to the punch?
Eye see what you did there
eye get it lol
georgia Dann Eye eye eye, Eye'm starting to get teyered of the eye puns Eye'm deyeing now.
Missed opportunity to say "eye for an eye" when talking about Moody owing Dumbledore a favour
Eye think that would’ve been perfect
Eye think I’ve seen this before
Iris sounding cynical, but eye think that pun is a bit obvious
Eye love this
@@crescentmoon5859 Eye hate this.
This makes so much sense because J.K Rowling uses Greek mythology a lot in harry potter
not only greek mythology, egyptian mythology , norse mythology
Chimera, Centaurs, Cerberus(Fluffy) and a lot more...
Like half of the side characters who are part of the order of the Phoenix are named after greek gods/creatures/heroes.
@@jamie6673 Actually, most of the names come from names of stars and constellations. Although yes, Rowling used a lot of inspiration from different mythologies.
@@brickbot2.038 actually actually, a lot of the stars and constellations are named after the characters of the mythology!
What an eye opening theory.
PowahSlap Entertainmint Eye see what you did there?
Sadly I think it's t(eye)me to stop the eye puns
Wheye?
oh the puns
Ba dum, chhh
Why is Mad-Eye Moody such a bad teacher?
Because he can’t control his pupils 😂
Took me 5 sec to get the pun :)) nice one
No, just noooo!!!
Blink, blink, blink...
Like Brock from Pokemon.
You just made my day!!! 😂😂😂😂
The problem with connecting Moody's Eye with Grindlewald's eye is that in the Deathly Hallows and Elderly Grindlewald still has both eyes.
Maybe Grindelwald got his original eye back? Or maybe after Dumbledore took the magical eye he gave Grindelwald a new one
I Still Wanna Know What Happened to Mad Eye’s Original Eye
Jodee Rebecca Davey probably the same thing that happened to Nick fury’s eye
he lost it when he used avada kedavra in the first wizarding war(aurors were allowed to use unforgivables when its the only option).
like voldemort lost his nose good looks and hair.or he just lost it through battle.i mean its not uncommon for people to lose limbs in combat)
EmeraldJolteon ok,Thanks For Letting me Know,I Had no Clue
@@emeraldjolteon1472 Voldemort lost his nose, good looks and hair either through making horcruxes or because he possessed snakes for long periods of time
He said in the goblet of fire that he got it taken out by a death Eater
While watching your videos covering a variety of ancient artifacts (Moody's eye, the mirror, the vase, the wand, the cloak, sorcerer's stone, the DH stone, etc.) a question hit me...why have contemporary wizards become weaker than their ancestors? We are constantly told about ancient wizards who created incredible magical artifacts or did amazing things, but our own generation's greatest wizard (Dumbledore) can only create a thing that puts out lights. Even in this video, you mention how you don't believe Voldemort could create something comparable to the Deathly Hallows. And this problem seems to be a more recent problem too, because as we see in Fantastic Beasts, Queenie is a natural Legilimens, but a generation later that ability is seemingly dying off, so even a powerful wizard like Volde has to use a spell to do it, and even then he only gets flashes of thought, instead of Queenie's apparent ability to read a person's mind. Could Grindelwald and Voldemort be right? Is the mixing between muggles and wizards diluting magical abilities? Or maybe two generations of war which cost the lives of countless skillful wizards has drastically hurt the wizarding gene pool. Or could it be simply that the modern school system is too focused on test scores, and not enough on actual education. Hogwarts was created by the four founders to pass on their knowledge, but (as we are shown) the founders each created a powerful magical artifact but then did not teach their students how they were made. Even Rowena Ravenclaw who places an emphasis on knowledge (and who cheats by the way...) refuses to pass on the knowledge of her diadem. So I would like to see if the Carlin Brothers could work out this idea, why is magic dying throughout the Wizarding World?
My guess is that in ye olden days there was just a lot less control over magic. Like, think before the ministery of magic put in place all the "no minor wizardry" and stuff it was all possible, basically the wild west of magic. To create such powerful artifacts would surely require massive amounts of magic and/or sacrifices (like human sacrifices). Now when you're the only wizard in a couple hundred miles range (the world population is smaller the farther you go back, therefore, the wizard population as well) you're free to fail as hard as you like and sacrifice as many villages as you like but if there is a ministry monitoring all and every magical fart then it would be a lot harder. If you fail hard enough you go to Azkaban and if you succeed but get caught, the object gets confiscated because "too dangerous" and you go to Azkaban.
So I think the main problem is limiting bureaucracy combined with larger population both in wizards and muggles and in the advancement of muggles (as in they pose a threat now and need to be hidden from).
To the question of diluting magical abilities: We'd need to know where magic comes from. If all wizards have a universal common ancestor that had a gene that made him able to use magic then it is possible that "dilution" occurs (if the magic gene is non-dominant) but in the sense that fewer people are wizards and not that wizards are weaker.
If some god once gave the power of magic to some guy and made some arbitrary rules for how it is given to his offspring then anything possible.
If magic is some power that exists everywhere but is finite it would also be possible that as there are more wizards there is less magic for everyone or if magic is a non-renewable resource maybe it's simply being used up.
It would definitely be interesting to see what these guys can come up with as I am a filthy casual on the topic.
Damn muggles
Yeah they even mention ancient magic and its easy to see its much stronger than what exists in there time now . The Mirror was one example they know is ancient magic .
I think the problem lies in the fact that you're comparing one, or two generations of modern wizards to hundreds to thousands of years worth of ancient wizards. I don't think ancient wizards were all that more powerful, it's just that in the span of multiple millennia there ought to be a handful of extremely powerful wizards. I think the average Joe weren't really more capable than their modern counterparts.
MrLumie I am going by the artifacts that still exist and are so strong they can't be remade . I think there was a closer connection back then .
Thought I'd add one more piece of evidence tying Harry Potter to Greek mythology. Professor Trelawny is a known descendant of Cassandra, the princess of the city Troy from Greek history. She was cursed with mumbling prophecies that no one ever believed. This is the same curse that is on Sybill. Greek gods exist in the same universe as Harry Potter, and by extension, Fantastic Beasts.
If blood lines are connected, why not a powerful artifact.
Hm, this post gave me a thought. What if, when the statute of secrecy was enacted, wizards did a sort of memory charm to history? So that all magical acts and creatures were remembered as stories, myths, and legends, rather than actual history?
Creatures from Greek mythology are there too. Centaur, anyone?
Guys her great-great-grandmother's name is Cassandra. Like I checked. On Pottermore. It says she got "the gift from" her.
I don't think JK makes her character's literally descended from Greek gods, she just took a bunch of inspiration from Ancient magic (they had a full museum exhibit of everything she took inspiration from). It's more likely that Sybill's great-great-Grandmother was simply named after the Greek princess than her actually being an ancient Greek princess. The same way that Sybill's name comes from 'The Sibyls' who are Seers and clairvoyants from ancient history, and also the reason that the hallows are not the actual ancient Greek artefacts, just follow a similar storyline. But it is an interesting theory!
"I can't get past the idea of umbridge at the beach" *shudders*
UMBRIDGE IN A TWO PIECE
@@simoneritchie9203 I think I just threw up 🤭
The three sisters Graeae, who revealed the items needed.
Coming back from later videos and making connections ...
The Gray Lady. One of three sisters who shared a history that led to a crucial piece of equipment allowing the hero to defeat the villain.
I also hate when (in the movie) Luna makes the cloak fly off of Harry on the train. Right after Draco breaks his nose. IMPENETRABLE TO ALL SPELLS PEOPLE
Dragon Master yes it is annoying when your introduced to the franchise through the movies
Tonks does in the books.
its invisibility is what cant be penetrated by spells, obviously summoning a gust of wind doesnt penetrate it just moves it.
Tonks does that exactly in the book..sooooo
Harry was still stuck on the train as it “jerked” into motion on its way back to London. The movement caused him to roll over and become partially exposed. Tonks noticed he hadn’t gotten off the train and went looking for him on the train. She stoped at the compartment with the blinds (Draco had closed) because it looked suspicious. That’s how it happened. It wasn’t small beasts flying around his head that only Luna could see...
Why don't you ever hear about baby house elves?How do House elf families even work if they're always busy?Maybe there's a special school for young house elves.Who was Dobby's family?!
Been wondering that for years
Well, Kreacher had all his ancestors mounted on the wall by Sirius' mother so we know they must breed. How would it work? Would two wizards with House Elves get together and force them to breed or do the Elves meet in magic bars or do they send out dating adds in the DP?
AND WHY IS WINKIE NOT IN THE MOVIES?
And we know that elves can breed with humans, which is a whole other issue altogether.
@@fruitygarlic3601 I'm sorry what?
I always thought Dumbledore created the eye, based on having studied the Cloak and learnt how it worked, and using the Elder Wand, which allowed the eye to overpower another Hallow.
Tbh I think I read some where that this is legit canon. I don't know where tho..... But Albus and Allastor where close friends at that point already. So assuming he would do such a thing for a friend is totally not far fetched
Grindelwald had both eyes when he was in Nurmengard.
But that was in the films
@@violinphelan it's also true in real life. We confirm this eye mentioned in this muggle presentation is not the eye of Grindelwald.
I've always wondered about Mad Eye Moody's magic eye so thank you for doing a video on this!!
What if Mad Eye can't actually see under the cloak but instead he cannot see it at all.
What if when he looks at the cloak he sees a lack of something. So there is just blackness there or some form of disturbance.
He can't actually see under the cloak but he know the cloak is there and someone's under it and he just deduces it is Harry
Jonathan Bullman fan theory about ancient greek mythical eyes destroyed. *claps*
Moody season 2 The invisibility cloak we know this for a fact because he comments on the socks that Dobby made for Harry if he just dissed Harry was under the cloak how would he know what sucks Harry was wearing
Mad Eye saw Harry mouthing to him that the Marauder's map was his
Moody was able to see Harry directly, even read his lips/flapping arms when he was trying to frantically tell moody the map was his.
Good point, nice picture
"which eye? Well in Greek Mythology.."
Odin: Am I a joke to you?
Or another famous mythological eye... Eye of... Wait for it... Agamotto (JK Imean Horus)
Ha. I only got interested in Mythology because of Rick Riordan. Anyone else? No? OK...
odin sacrificed his eye to mimir... so the eye does not exist anymore
@@lokiodinson5412 yeah but he has his other eye, and iirc that eye was connected to the ravens which allowed him to have an “all seeing eye”
Though don’t quote me on the Raven thing because that may be something I mixed up with the Marvel Comics
But Odin's eye is mostly associated with wisdom and not sight as much as Perseus'.
More Greek stuff: A bunch of characters are literally named after constellations and stars: regulus Arcturus, draco, Sirius, Bellatrix, etc
All the Black family are apparently named after constellations, must say though that I have no idea where Narcisa is in the sky or if Mrs. Malloy is the one exception to the rule _shrug_
@@unavailableunPossibly because she is only married into the Black family and she isn't a blood descendant.
What if grindelwald made the eye WITH the elder wand which is why it’s so powerful and can see through a Hallow?
Aren’t the Hallows equal in power? If they are then that’s impossible
Calvin Musquez So If Its created by a hallow it can see through a hallow..
Then your implying it was made by something greater than a hallow. So how is that possible?
Calvin Musquez hallows can’t create hallows
Well... Dumbledore had the elder wand during the numerous times he saw through Harry's cloak so... possible?
Everybody knows Moody can look through walls, but just think about how Moody can look through clothes as well: "'Nice socks, Potter,' Moody growled as he passed, his magical eye staring through Harry's robes" (Yule Ball, Goblet of Fire), it's super creepy!!! Great theory by the way!
Cough moodyisapervert cough
This has always bothered me!
hmmm..... Never picked up on that. This is very true though. Wow makes you wonder considering he was in a school full of under 18 witches and wizards.
He can also see through wood and through the back of his skull
So, it could have been seven hundred times worse when the original draft read, 'Nice Yule Balls, Potter," Moody growled as he passed, his magical eye staring through Harry's robes......
The blue eye.
It scared me when i went to the movies, it kinda creeps me everytime i look at a picture of Grindy and now it scares me even more. Send help
It is freakish. I love it.
I think that the eye was the third brothers eye, the one who had the invisibility cloak. That's why the eye can see he cloak
At least that's what I've always assumed
That's great head canon!
I'm Greek. That word "graeae" is pronounced "gree-eh". It's nothing fancy. Literally just translates to old ladies. Haha
And in modern literature they're known as the Gray Ladies, just FYI
i wonder if there's any link to "the Grey Lady" Helena Ravenclaw. (when i read about them back in the 80's it was spelled graiae)
Maayan Stern 😂
]ercy Jackson fan. Just sayin'.
my son too
Moody is the only person to have ever seen a boggart when it's not changing into someone's worst fear
Ben: *mentiones how no one wants to have a magical eye instead of a normal one...*
Me: *suddenly discovers how pretty eyes Ben has and can't stop staring through the entire video*
Yes. A very eye-opening discovery!
He does have magnificent eyes
We actually have this eye in our office and we can confidently say, mostly because he never lost an eye, that it is infact not from Grindelwald.
It's actual origin is a bit murky, but it's 100% not from Grindelwald. That is a fact your Ministry of Magic is willing to stand behind. Trust your Ministry.
Seeing as you guys purposely denied the Dark Lord's return for nearly a year I'm inclined not to take your word on it.
@@BennyFireKing my thoughts exactly, I wouldn't trust those ministry guys...
The eye on the door of the office was taken after moody's death, your aguments have no basis and I won't trust people who pluck out eyes from corpses. Disgraceful.
You know, Grindelwald could just have Heterochromia.
Sᴏ ᴛʜᴀᴛ ɪs ᴛʜᴇ ʟᴏᴄᴀᴛɪᴏɴ ᴏғ ᴏᴜʀ ᴏᴛʜᴇʀ ᴇʏᴇ . Wᴇ'ʟʟ ʙᴇ ɪɴ ᴛᴏᴜᴄʜ .
Also moody is the only one to see what a boggert looks like. Right?
Reagan Orton i was wondering the exact same thing while reading OotP... he must know, because how should the boggert change it's appearance if it doesn't even know that Moody can see it? I always imagined a boggert like a black mass with no particular shape. Maybe a bit like an obscurial. I wish Moody would have told us, what it looks like...
yes and perhaps Remus's father Lyall
Mathieu Leader, tell me about Lyall. I just found out his name.
I always wondered about this. Does he? I think the boggert maybe can "feel" that Moody is looking at it and just turns into his appearence.
Mathieu Leader how does lyall know?
Wait...Dumbledore seems like he can see through the cloak too, remember chamber of secrets in Hagrid’s hut? He looks at Harry directly and says something along the lines of “help will always be given at Hogwarts to those who ask for it” what’s going on there??
If Dumbledore was in possession of the eye before it was given to Moody, he would have most certainly attempted to dissect the magic that made it so powerful. With that in mind, he seems to have succeeded. I say he succeeded because he seems to have managed to bewitch his halfmoon spectacles in the same manor. It wouldnt be the first time a pair of glasses were bewitched. And now that I think about it... Even muggles know about the idea of X-ray vision, night vision, thermal imaging, etc. I bet you anything Dumbledore took these ideas and gave his glasses those types of abilities.
I don't think Dumbledore can see through the cloak, he's just so full of all that beardy wisdom that he can often put two and two together without having any two's.
I agree with Patrick
He silently used Homenem Revelio and could tell they were in the room.
Ken Hollis no spell can detect the cloak or its occupants
Just watched this for the first time and when Ben was talking about the 3 items from Greek Mythology being like the 3 Hallows.... they're also like our Golden Trio. Invisibility Cloak for Harry, Magic Bag for Hermione, and Sword for Ron.
Oh, I love this idea!
I just reread the part of The Deathly Hallows when “Mad-Eye” just died.😢😢😢
What if Roald Dahl’s Matilda takes place in the Harry Potter universe and Matilda Wormwood is a Muggle-born witch?
Alex Downs on a scale of Umbrige to Trunchabull, how fucked up is your head teacher?
No wand :’)
Wandless Magic
That would make a lot of sense actually
It actually really is possible
Oh, so the eye used to hunt down the three magical artifacts came from three siblings?
This seems like a bit of a stretch, but at the same time, IT FITS SO INCREDIBLY WELL.
Greek Mythology comes in
Mentions perseus
Me: Oh my gods PERCY
So, if the story of the three brothers is correct, then these items were made by a single entity (entitled Death in the story). It would make sense that "Death," after being evaded by the youngest brother, would create an item with the ability to see through the cloak. It would also make sense that only a wizard who created an item would be able to find a way to counteract said items. Therefore, the eye must have been created by whomever Death is. Perhaps someone that the Peverell brothers all had a quarrel with.
Umbridge at the beach double negative
Fudge Buddy yeah i gagged
Fudge Buddy when I think about it I gag
So positive?
a double negative equals a positive.
But double negative is the same as positive. So are you saying you like the idea?
I have a theory.
Dumbledore once said, the Peverel brothers were extremely gifted wizards and had made the hallows themselves. If we take it to be true, then I am not sure that they were able to create the stone at the very first try. So, what if the eye is actually one of the failed attempts at making the stone?
The stone is supposed to let you see the people lurking in the far shore(land of the dead), right? So what if, in one of the attempts, they were able to create a stone that did allow them to see things which were not visible to the human eye?
Just imagine that you are one of the Peverel brothers, and the desparately want to make something which will enable you to see those who had died. First you would want to see if there is anything which is not visible to the human eye, right? So what if it is this eye?
Great theory. I wonder what houses the peverel brothers were in
@@aych-rn Ravenclaw. Unless they are like Hermione (who was in Gryffiondore cause she valued Bravery more than being smart) that is pretty obvious.
I think the elder wand brother was in Griffindoor due to his prid
@@aych-rn I'm guessing this was before Hogwarts
@@aych-rn I'm pretty sure they predate Hogwarts.
The eye is the eye that the god horace lost when he fought his brother Set.
I though ra’s eye
I also thought it could be the Eye of Horace
I mean think about it!
His brother was Seth.
I've heard both names.
So how was Dumbledore able to see Harry, Ron, & Hermione in Hagrid's hut when they were under the cloak?
According to JK Dumbledore used non verbal magic the *Homenum revelio* spell
@Haia Mohamed Asem Elshaer Just going by what the author said. I'd also assume that since Harry was probably the only one with an invisibility cloak it would be safe to guess who was hiding even if he couldn't see them
Tony New idk
@Haia Mohamed Asem Elshaer You have to remember it was cast by the Elder Wand, another Deathly Hallow. Maybe that's why the spell worked.
Rodrigo Romano, right, but I don’t think that Dumbledore owned the Elder Wand. You should check out the video that SCB made, but the gist of it is that Dumbledore beat Grindelwald in a duel to win this wand, but the Elder Wand can never actually lose in a duel, so Grindelwald never had it. It still belonged to the wand maker Gregorovitch. Since Voldemort killed him in the seventh book, he obtained the wand. Then Harry killed Voldemort, which was possible because it was not a formal duel, thereby acquiring the Elder Wand. The point is that I don’t think the Elder Wand had anything to do with Dumbledore seeing Harry, Ron and Hermione, because Dumbledore never truly controlled it. However, there is another theory that I am not opposed to. I don’t know how Rowling responded to it, but quite frankly, I don’t care what she responded with, because she probably just listens to the theories and decides which ones she likes and declares them true. The theory is that Dumbledore is Death. The same person who gave the three brothers the Deathly Hallows. That may explain why he could control the Elder Wand enough to use it to see through the invisibility cloak. However, if Dumbledore is not death, then the theory of the Elder Wand allowing him to see through the cloak just falls apart.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the first time Moody see's through the cloak is in the Three Broomsticks before the first task, when Hagrid tells him to meet him to see the dragons!
Alex I believe you are correct
I just finished goblet of fire last week and yes you are correct
Though that wasn't actually Moody, right?
Kyle Coleman Yes, it was Moody. He was with Hagrid at the time.
Kim Roberts It was “Moody”. It wasn’t Moody, but BTJr masquerading as Moody
They're also known as the Grey Sisters (Graeae).
P.S. Anyone thinking about Percy Jackson?
Roshni Patnaik yes
Ha Ha Ha.
Yes Percy Jackson! Like HP series better though...
Who else learned all their Greek mythology from percy Jackson
And thought of the gray sisters cab?
Me
I did! I did!
Me ...
Exactly what I thought but i thought the cap was Annabeth's cap not Hades
Me
I thought the eye was Egyptian , the eye of Hoarse or El . The pharaohs would get enlightened through receiving this eye . And I’m pretty sure that Dumbledore and Grindelwald would have visited not just Greece but also Egypt and probably many other ancient places.
Now i wanna read the Harry Potter seiries again
Fudge Buddy Do it, explore the magic again 😄
lel i read it 100 times
I can recommend the audio books! (I listen to the Stephen Fry versions).
Fudge Buddy I always wanna read the Harry Potter series again.............
I do it over and over again every time I finish it I read it again.
always keeping an *eye* out for theories
Envy Unknown I wish you capitalized eye as to further enunciate the pun
The Boy Bandana how’s bolding it?
Envy Unknown perfect
I am scarred for life.
All Percy Jackson fans screamed when the Greek mythology theory started
Seriously, what are you saying?
Im not aware of their fandom?
@@Tombud-ti7gn Percy Jackson is a book series by Rick Riordan. Based on greek mythology, there's are sequels as well based on other mythology like Roman, Norse, and Egyptian. The Percy Jackson series is getting it's own live action series on Disney+, because the first movies made from it completely changed the plot.
YUP!!!!!! SAME.
@@denve2456 I would recommend giving it a try it's great
@@ruchikhera7013 yes, I'm already a fan😅
8:03 The three sisters can be alternativelly spelled as Graiai or Graiae, vut they apperently also go by "Gray sisters" or "Phorcides". I hope this makes it a little easier.
Greek student here
It should be grie eye (pronunciation)
@@pokepokepoke64 thank you, it’s about time someone got it right
I have a theory that piggybacks off this theory: Greek mythology was based on mortals/muggles seeing the Wizarding World.
You know how stories of dragons and witches are from seeing actual dragons and witches? How stories of sphinxes and griffins made their way into muggles minds? Wait a second... sphinxes and griffins are from GREEK/ROMAN mythology (romans reskinned greek mythology). Now, we know the the Deathly Hallows are like the three magical objects from Perseus’s stories. Maybe the Greek gods were just really powerful wizards? Maybe even the FIRST wizards? It seems fitting that muggles would worship the Olympian Council, the council of the first, ancient wizards. The first wizards had children, and these are the minor gods (purebloods) and demigods (also known as... guess what... HALF-BLOODS).
This would explain how muggles know of the Deathly Hallows: they saw the Deathly Hallows but couldn’t understand what they were (remember how muggles thought sirius’s wand was a gun?) so they thought the Elder Wand was a sword, the Invisibility Cloak was a Helm of Darkness, and the stone was a bad. Ok, the last one doesn’t really fit, but maybe over the years of passing down the story it got twisted.
Maybe the three brothers the made the Deathly Hallows were in fact the Big Three, the three most powerful gods who were also brothers, sons of the Titan’s kind Kronos. The muggles named these three brothers Zeus, Poseidon, and Hades. Zeus made the Elder Wand/sword, Hades made the Invisibility Cloak/Helm of Darkness, and Poseidon made the stone/bag. The stone/bag might have been hidden from mortals so they wouldn’t try raising the dead.
Anyone here read Percy Jackson? You know how Nico (demigod son of Hades) raised the dead? The way thats works sounds an awful lot like the stone...
PERCY JACKSON/HARRY POTTER CROSSOVER SERIES CONFIRMED!,!!,!,,!,QQ!1!!1?
Tl;dr: greek mythology was muggles seeing wizards and making stories and worshipping the wizards.
Hey i just thought about something: the Greeks should be really effing mad about people HUNTING THEIR GODS.
Yes! Nico is my favorite.
How does this NOT have thousands of likes
sure, but which es and dragons are not real
Wish I could like hundreds of times, strictly because this needs more attention
This is amazing, and I wish you hundreds of likes.
Whatcha fell over for?
Potter Projects "I didn't do it on purpose"
Choo fell over for
Ben: here’s the most famous eye
Me: The eye of agamodo?
Ben: the all seeing eye
Me: pffft say that after infinity war
haha!
and it happens to look like the illuminati
Even worse after Lords of the Rings with Sauronseye
Pfff naw it is soo bill
I am absolutely in love with this theory! It makes perfect sense to me. I enjoy your videos so much for two reasons. One is your energy and enthusiasm and two is because you open Our minds to another way of thinking.
I'm surprised y'all didnt catch this, Medusa was known for turning people she looked at to stone, sound like a certain Slytherin made basilisk to anyone?
Savanna Stewart MIND BLOWWN!!
Or maybe the basilisk is based on a greek creature called the 'basilisk'.
Which has vision that paralysis it's victims as well.
The basilisk doesn’t turn people to stone though...
HOLY C@&%
Well all I know that Rocket wants it...
So so true omg 😂 Imagine Rocket & young Harry teaming up and Rocket’s like here’s the plan, I need blah, blah, blah, and THAT eye. And Harry’s like AHH okay okay AND GETS IT FOR HIM BC HE IS HARRY
Rocket: OK here's the plan I need a bomb, my gun,
*points at Moody* And that mans eye.
Moody: Your not getting my eye Racoon
MCU HARRY POTTER CONFIRMED
Racoon ? I thought he was a rabbit
RadioactiveRose moody would just call him a Ferret..cuz hes so fond of them
J and ben i absolutely love you guys! An awesome video would be you two ranking each book and just going over what you did and didnt like about them specifically
I think Dumbledore made the eye from the Elder wand,A Hallow,so that's why it can see through another Hallow
What I heard “Whatcha fell over for” I started laughing hysterically
Why did you make me imagine Umbridge at the beach??? Thanks a lot BEN, you KLONTARF!!!
I can't believe someone else remembers the klontarf joke
Tomas Tkacik #KlontarfFTW
Clontarf*
ok but the picture of dumbledore taking an eye out of his ex-lover's scull after defeating him is so deeply disturbing
There are a couple of things that I never understood about Moody/Crouch Jr. in the Goblet of Fire. First, if polyjuice potion only changes the physical appearance, how was he able to speak like Moody? Second, if he worked at Hogwarts for practically an entire semester, presumably carrying on conversations with Dumbledore during the semester, how did Dumbledore not realize that he wasn't actually Moody? Dumbledore seemed to know everything else, but he couldn't see through something as seemingly basic has polyjuice potion.
In the book the polyjuice also changes your voice, I think it's only different in the movies as to not confuse viewers.
Second is that in the books (again it's different in the movies) the real Alastor Moody, is being kept alive in his chest using the Imperius curse, so that Barty Jr. could keep stealing his hair and ask him about is past and manerism so he could impersenate him so flawlessly that he could fool even Dumbledore.
Sometimes they are just called the Three Gray Sisters.
Tri Nguyen or the Fates
I know them by Gorgon Sisters - Medusa, Euryale and Stheno.
It can get kind of confusing because Greeks were big fan of of the number three but the Gray Sisters, the Fates, the Gorgons and probably countless other trios are all separate entities with different origins.
Damn this was a hella good theory
Yeah, the amount of research...
Ephesians 4:29-
Let no corrupt communication proceed out of your mouth but that which is good to the use of edifying that it may minister grace unto the hearers.
Personally, I'd put "Man, this was a really good theory" or something to that effect :)
Ya pretty eye opening
Whoa! I absolutely LOVE that comparison to the Greek Mythology Story of Perseus to the story of the Deathly Hallows, that blew my mind! Incredible insight on your part!
I love the ways you discuss the elements of these books. New sub
Obviously it is the eye that Odin lost. MCU Harry Potter Crossover Confirmed.
bleachmon1 Odin gave his eye to Mimer and in return Mimer gave him knowledge
also Loki was Odin's blood brother instead of his adopted son. and Hela was Loki's daughter instead of Odin's. And Thor was a redhead. I said MCU not norse myths. Very different.
Laura’s Voice didn't Odin took his eyes out then dropped it in the river to prove he's worthy?
bleachmon1 oh I didn't see that :) but im glad you know the differnce, becauce alot og people dont
Da è Karu Shard not in north mythology
Something strange that I realized about Harry and Dumbledore in the Harry Potter books is that they both see almost the same thing in the Mirror of Erised. Harry sees him and his parents his parents, his family and Dumbledore sees his family all alive.
This is probably my favourite supercarlinbrothers episode ever. Ben's jokes and puns just hit right. 😂🤣
who else realised that Fluffy (Hagrids three headed dog) was a Cyberus from Greek mythology aswell?
There's only 1 Cerberus: the Guard of the Underworld
I believe that it could be a descendant of him. Wait, can Cerberus have kids if hes always at the Gates of Erebus?
YES.
I NEVER NOTICED GRINDELWALD HAD THE EYEBALL. WHOA. XD
Hi my name is_________ XD
Really, it was totally the very first thing I noticed when I first saw the cast poster. Literally the first thing. But at the time I just thought he had a weird eye because he was evil. I never occurred to me that it might actually mean something.
Its was the 1 i notist
Another thing to add about the Eye being the Graeae sister's eye: what two other things were useful in finding/destroying the horcruxes other than Harry's cloak/the Hallows? Hermione's *bag* with an undetectable extension charm on it and the *Sword* of Gryffindor.
This theory of Moody's eye being Grindelwald's is so brilliant that I'm even more angry about the recast and that Mads Mikkelsen didn't wear the blue eye.
As soon as he mebtioned Greek Mythology. Then i started geeking out.
He mentioned an invisibility cap: Annabeth
He mentioned Perseus: Percy
He mentioned Medusa: Auntie M
He mention the helm of darkness: woah that was a throwback to book one, Hades
I GEEKED OUT
Uh you mean GREEKED out
Same!
It just works
Justin! I didn’t know you watch Super Carlin Brothers too.
HOW DO YOU FOLLOW US EVERYWHEREEEEEE
Justin Y. Do you watch everyone!?
technologic
Thanks for playing
*CONSTANT CONCEALMENT!*
CONSTANT VILLIGANCE!
It’s constant villigance, wtf man
Kieren Street yeah, and they said "constant concealment" in the video, which is similar to constant vigilance
Re: Gillyweed and the Bubblehead charm - It's not that nobody has wondered whether it might be useful to travel underwater. Clearly they have, which is why those things are so plainly written out in the books waiting to be found. But they have largely decided that there is nothing there worth finding, which is why that information is "buried" in neglected places that most people wouldn't bother to look.
That's why those things are so important to the Champions, because they're able to pull up specific, seemingly "useless" knowledge in the precise obscure situation where that is exactly the only thing that will work.
man i dont know how u come up with this stuff. its amazing! great vid, and percy jackson series has a lot of things referenced in this video
So awesome! Couple notes: 1) When Moody says he's just doing a favor for Dumbledore, isn't that really Crouch Jr. talking? and 2) Doesn't Moody have the Marauders' Map? That could have helped him guess that Harry was stuck in the step, because his magic eye would have seen that the step was compressed, even if it couldn't see Harry.
He didn't have the map yet, he actually found out about the map that night. Harry was hidden under the cloak, waving to get Moody's attention as he was about to give the map to Snape. I was confused by the favour part too! I'm pretty sure it was Crouch Jr. at that point.
Ah, thanks for the clarification, Rachel! :)
Theres also another scene at the three broomsticks where moody sees harry under the cloak sitting with Hermione and he tells harry about the power of the eye. This was what lead to harry waving to get Moody's attention.
Yes that is crouch jr talking but he's talking as moody, I don't understand the confusion, sorry not trying to troll, I'm just a little confused with your confusion, please explain 😊
I don't remember how exactly, but Crouch meticulously studied Moody's behaviour and memories.
Maybe the triangular eye is referencing how there are 3 sisters sharing it.... 3 sides make up for 3 sisters, and the eye can only find magical objects in groups of threes, which explains why it could find the THREE items for Perseus', and later help find Death's THREE hallows. Response??
I would say that eye can see through the invisibility cloak because it is an ancient magical item, far more powerful than the cloak.
Yeah could be, but, it could also be that the " eye of providence" and the sisters eye could be the same in this universe.
HALF-LIFE 3 CONFIRMED!!!
Guys I just want to say I LOVE how you dig into these theories bringing a ton of mythological & other cultural references and interesting facts to light (it's practically research and I simply LOVE you for it)!!!
having that eye in would be so weird because you could see some stuff through one eye but not the other
That's normal you already do this
I think he got it from Rocket Racoon
Timeline, Moody has it in the 1990s, rocket has it in 2018. more likely Rocket got it FROM moody.
Bartist Clord true
Carter Brown *Rocket the Rabbit
Carter Brown 😂
Moody would be the sort to stick his eye up a raccoon's butt to keep it safe. Whatever it takes!
Ok so I know you guys read the Harry Potter books in like a continuous cycle, so I have a suggestion. This is what I do: use like amazon music or something to find like tons of themes form the movie. You can find so so so many themes that fit like every situation in the books and when you read them it makes the sad parts sadder and the epic parts like way more epic, it’s like watching a movie for real! Try it out ( I sort them into playlists like battle songs, forboading, quidditch, people dieing, and like happy around the palace songs)
Please, please do more Luna Lovegood theory’s and family tree!
Like so they can see!
Loved it nicely put together
I wrote this on my notes last night when I was have asleep. But reading it today did make me think.
So in Harry Potter the moving stairs... well... move. And there have been many encounters with the moving stairs. People just hanging out on the stairs finding eggs and finding escaped fat lady’s. So why did they never move when all of this was going on. BUT. They moved in the first book to bring the golden trio to the ONE PLACE where they weren’t supposed to go. Did the stairs know that Harry, Hermione, and Ron were meant to find fluffy the three headed dog? Did the stairs know that they had to wait til they were all together to bring them to the third floor? Did the stairs know that they were the ones to find the philosophers stone and defeated Voldemort’s little face head thing on the back of quirrells head?
Idk man kinda cool tho
Bria Skye in the book the stairs aren't the reason they find fluffy, the stairs aren't a major plot point in any of the books, in the books the trio (and Neville) get locked out of Gryffindor Tower at night and they hide in the third floor corridor to avoid being caught by filch and that's how they get caught - however when I first read your comment I got intrigued too before I remembered that was a movie change, would have been cool though 👍🏼😊
There was a trick step. after their first years most students avoid the step
You totally missed out on saying ‘an eye for an eye’ when talking about the favours between Dumbledore and Moody...
Matilda Sinclair
The phrase "An eye for an eye" usually means "payback" in the context of revenge, or of "justice" in a brutal manner, rather than repaying a favour to a friend, grudgingly or not.
DUDE THIS IS MY FAVORITE VIDEO ON THIS CHANNEL!!! I LOVE GREEK MYTHOLOGY AND HARRY POTTER SO THIS IS PERFECT FOR ME!!!
Thanks for that Ben. Now I can’t stop seeing Umbridge at the beach. EEEEEWWWW.
YOU DAMAGED MY BRAIN!
Eyeluminati confirmed
Viola James 😂
"let me introduce you to Perseus son of Zeus"
Boi come on you know we read Percy Jackson
Nice I'm reading Percy Jackson series right now (I literally was reading it like 30 minutes ago) so that was cool that they were talking about Greek mythology
Ben: I really can't get past the idea of Umbridge at the beach.
Me: *Pauses the video and thinks about it.*
Also me: *Runs to the bathroom cuz imma be sick!*
Egyptians were the 1st wizards in the magic world and Horus had 2 eyes 1 was never found until dumbledore got it from grindlewald credit to Harry Potter Folklore
I was sure he was gonna go with Horus' eye. It's kind of a bigger deal.
_mind blown_
(Insert meme here)
SAME
eye blown
bokeh
Again
About the bubble-head charm.. I belive that Fleur found a proper book in library but hid it after learning the spell to make things difficult for other champions. Cedric had already found it before her but didn't want to make the task impossible for the others.
Or it was mentioned twice
That makes so much sence. I always wondered why Grindlewald had one blue eye. It makes even more sence since he has two brown eyes in the Potter move when he is imprisoned. Nice theory.
Could you guys do a video on the Percy Jackson books please?
Kylie yes please
YES, I have been waiting for someone else to say this!
YES
YISSSSS
YES I'm begging
This is so f*king genious... I've always thought that Grindelwald simply has that thing, when someone has two different colored eyes, I don't know what's it called.. but that theory makes so much sense, although it's a bit complex, so it may not be true.
I honestly have no idea how you guys can come up with such theories tho.. it's just amazing.
You're thinking of heterochromia which literally means "of not the same color"
Heterochromia iridium.
Genius,
@@mischa2643 or ocular heterochromia
But it is true tho, he has had it since birth
I couldnt think of this in like a 10000000 yrs.
Like wth
Thank u ben and j
I’m rewatching this and I have to admit it’s still one of my favorite episodes