Does He Belong?...
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 лип 2024
- A look at the career and legacy of the first Superstar Big Man, George Mikan.
-----
Make sure to subscribe for more NBA History!
Follow Me on Instagram!
Instagram: / jonnyarnett. .
Interested in connecting more with the this Basketball community? Join up on Discord.
/ discord
______
The game of Basketball has been my passion since I was 5 years old. I grew up as a kid watching my dad's recorded VHS tapes of playoff games through the 70s and 80s, and collected all the Basketball cards. Something about the game and what it represents just hooked me from a very young age.
My love for the game only continues to grow as time goes on. I love studying and analyzing the game, with an unbiased perspective. Feel free to subscribe, follow me on social media, and celebrate this amazing game and it's rich history with me!
I post videos every week on NBA history, predictions, hypothetical scenarios and current NBA topics.
______
Intro Music: Turn On - RW Smith • Turn On - RW Smith (No...
-----
#nba #basketball #hoops - Спорт
Mikan is a guy I’ve always had a hard time ranking when it comes to the Greatest Bigs… is he top 5 all time? Top 10, 20 or 50??
Top 10
@@Hatedvariijust stop
Not even top 50 bro boi boi could beat him in his prime
@@Pablothegreat157 😂bros at least top 10-15ish
To me he is one of the 20 most important players in NBA history. As far as Centers go he’s right up there with: Chamberlain, Russell, Jabber, Hakeem, and Shaq.
Shaquille O'Neal once said "without George Mikan there is no me." When he offered to pay for Mikan's funeral
💙 greats recognize other greats
George Mikan’s contribution to the game is second to none. He is the George Washington of pro basketball. There are no Jordan drills, Kareem drills, or Kobe drills, but there are Mikan drills. These drills are done at all levels of basketball. His influence on the game will never die.
Perfectly stated!
“The George Washington of pro basketball” could never be truer.
I hate to say it but the NBA screwed up, the regular season MVP title should be named after him who never had the opportunity to win it, like the Finals MVP title is named after Russell.
I love MJ but I think that also for marketing reasons he had this honor, and that the most improved player award was named after Mikan, when as a rookie he won the NBL title and was also the best scorer in the league, it doesn't make much sense
@@stevenmichienzi9833 I never thought about naming it for him, but that's a good idea.
@@stevenmichienzi9833Personally I feel Kareem should have the award named after him as he has the most MVPs like Bill has the most rings
It's so frustrating that people tend forget who was the 1st NBA superstar.
If not for the players before, the NBA wouldn't be here today.
Like Shaq said "without no.99 there is no.34." Mikan is a pioneer of the fundamentals. The Mikan drill was utilized by Kareem to develop the Skyhook. His influence is still felt in every kid learning to play the game today.
The thing is, newer players had the luxury of copying and improving or taking inspiration from the older generation players. Guys like George Mikan didn't have that. They solely need to rely on their sheer imagination and creativeness to be that good.
Great point!
Which is also a great argument as to Cousy's greatness!! I went back and watched some of his game film and was blown away by the no look passes and ballhandling, especially considering the rules in that day!
@@trackcoachmac imagine the Cooz playing in today's era, where lifting is tolerated and the gather step is not counted.
But doesn't this argument actually hurt Mikan's case? You're basically admitting that modern players are better but using the excuse that Mikan didn't have the same luxuries. In my opinion, whatever advantage you have is fair game, and we should just judge a player by how good they were. Not "good for their era" not "good if we ignore everything that makes modern players good"...
@@MrE_This point is basically saying whoever has more skill is a better player. In this instance, mj wouldn’t even be top 10 all time, and the others like magic, Bird, wilt, Kareem would be lower because the “modern era is more skilled.” That’s not how it works
Since GM was 6'10", many people say his height was a huge advantage. That's really not the case; we need to also consider average height of players hasnt changed much in 70 years:
1952 - 6'4"
1992 - 6'6.5"
2022 - 6'6"
George was just that damn good!!
if we talk about height, Mikan played against taller centers,
Bob Kurland 7-0 (college), Don Otten 6-11, Arnie Risen 6-9,
Elmore Morgenthaler 7-0, Ray Felix 6-11
@@stevenmichienzi9833and tbh the play style now is similar to the 50's & especially the 70's
Does this factor in the fact that the measurements were without shoes back then and with shoes now. I know there was at least a 1 inch discrepancy.
@@RG-ct6qz It does not. Mikan would be billed as 6'11" or 7ft today.
The average height has been 6'6" since 1974, and 6'5" since 1955, nice try on making the numbers look much different.
I wish George played 1 decade later. Seeing him against Wilt and Bill Russell would give us a better idea how he stacks up
No he won’t he retired because of the shot clock rule why you think he could survive in the 60’s
@@Pablothegreat157he retired because of injuries
@@lilfreddy5129and also shot clock he even said it
he also played in a no SHOT CLOCK ERA...people dont understand how hard was to score points in that ERA...
@@Pablothegreat157 SHOT CLOCK RULE made players look worse...DO you understand what shot clock RULE was???
As a lakers fan I have huge respect for George Mikan because he is the leader for the lakers first dynasty
Just saying "ambidextrous hook shot" made me respect him more, and I already respect the old days. Basically a large Kyrie Irving ya know?
Nope, Mikan was a leader and a winner.
@@kostastube2010 Lucky for me, comparing them as ambidextrous super ballers has nothing to do with that
"Ambidextrous hook shot"
My man Ralph Sampson!!!!
When comparing shooting across eras, the best we can do is compare TS+ (True Shooting vs League Average). So in the 48-49 season, he had a TS+ of 127, which would have meant he as about the equivalent of Daniel Gafford last year, ie .739% true shooting, which would historically be the greatest shooting season ever had he (Gafford) made enough attempts to qualify.
Career wise, Mikan's TS+ is 114, which in the modern era comes out to about .664, which is historically great.
So, yeah, Mikan could shoot the shit out of the shot.
(Wilt also has some absurd TS+ numbers through his career)
Absolutely! He’s eighth on my personal top ten centers list. Modern hoops are not; 5 chips, a three peat, bringing bigs to hoops, being the commissioner of the ABA, he’s earned it
He was also the first NBA player to score over 10k points.
In terms of the gap between the best and 2nd best player in the NBA at any given time, I think Mikan created by far the largest gap between him and the 2nd greatest player of his era
No knock on him, but could it be possible that a gap like that is impossible in the league in later decades or now?
What about Wilt?
@@fortynights1513 I wouldn’t say impossible but it is pretty far fetched to think it’s going to happen, I mean the odds are probably the closest thing to 0
@@samuelperezgarcia I’d say the gap between Wilt, and then either Russell, West or Oscar wasn’t as large as the gap between Mikan and Dolph Schayes
Another thing is if you were to put Mikan in 2024, it's not like he would just continue to play 1950's basketball, he would adapt. Making him still an all time great. This is the mindset I believe we should use when comparing players from across different eras in general. How well could they adapt their game across the generations?
Exactly! The top players of any era are the top players mostly not because of their physical gifts, but because they work hard and figure out how to win, no matter what the competition is.
After him playing days, he also came up with the 3 point line
Yes, he was a pioneer as original commissioner of the ABA
I find it difficult to rank Mikan exactly, due to the huge difference in game style and skills between his era and the rest.
But there's NO DOUBT he was one of the greatest ever, given his accomplishments. He was also the first superstar - I'm surprised you didn't mention the "Mikan vs Knicks" episode 😂 😂
Thank you for this video, Jonny. 5 NBA championships (one was technically BAA but it's the same thing), 3 scoring titles, and a rebounding title (and possibly more if they counted rebounds earlier). Thats a truly impressive resume. Mikan was the first star of professional basketball, and he should be regarded as such, and his name should be revered. Yet for whatever reason, the basketball community mocks, belittles, and derides those who came before, so naturally Mikan is hardly known today, or if he is, he is disregarded. Such a shame.
Thanks Jonny! I respect George Mikan for being one of the first superstars in basketball but not sure if his accomplishments is recognized as there are more talented centers since then.
It’s very hard to gauge guys from the 40s and 50s. The game was still so unpolished back then. For Mikan, his status would’ve been better defined if he played in the 60s.
Yes, which is why it is much easier to consider Russell and Wilt in the GOAT conversation. For Mikan, I have to play the "What if?" game and imagine him in the 1960s. It isn't pretty...
So true and that’s a good point about him playing in the wrong era
I always repeat it,
there are only 3 dynasties in the history of pro basketball,
Minneapolis Lakers (1947-1954) 6 titles in 7 seasons
Boston Celtics (1956-69) 11 titles in 13 seasons
Chicago Bulls (1990-98) 6 titles in 8 seasons
and Mikan was by far the best player of those Lakers,
also in his rookie season he won the title with the Chicago American Gears,
if this is not enough to elevate him to the status of generational talent
I don't think it is an honest assessment compared
to the others great players of all time
@@stevenmichienzi9833not gonna count the 80s lakers who got 5 rings?
@@Christmas-gw1lu everyone has their own point of view, but if we talk about dynasty, in my opinion we are talking about a team that is better than all the others,
Mikan won 7 titles in 8 seasons, 6 with the Lakers, and the only year he missed was when he broke his leg, the Celtics lost against the Hawks in 1958 in the only final during which Russell was injured, and in 1967 when Russell played his first season as a player/coach,
and the Bulls lost in the season without MJ, and the following when MJ returned only during mid-season.
the Showtime Lakers were indeed the most successful team of that era, but they lost to Houston in '81 and '86, Sixers in '83, Celtics in '84, Detroit in '89, Portland in '90 and Chicago in '91, too many defeats to consider that team superior to all the others, same thing goes for the Warriors, they were the most successful team of the last ten years, but I don't consider it a dynasty, they lost too much to be elevated to this status
Ty Ty Ty! For this video me being a lakers fan and George being from my hometown he’s my all time favorite laker! There a statue out side the high school dedicated to him as well! You’re already one of my favorite content creators and this made me an even bigger fan of yours! Thank you!
George Mikan will always hold the 10th spot for me in the best centers ever.
1: Chamberlain
2: Abdul-Jabbar
3: Olajuwon
4: Russell (I rank Russell higher than Olajuwon in the GOAT listing)
5: Duncan
6: Shaq
7: Malone
8: Robinson
9: Jokic
10: Mikan
11: Ewing
I have a high level of agreement with this list. I'd have to think hard about the quibbles.
Anyone who played this game at the highest level of their era and DOMINATED deserves respect
Do a video for Joe Fulks, Bob Pettit, Dolph Schayes, Neil Johnston, Paul Arizin, guys who most people know about but have no idea how they look and play...
Don't forget Jim Pollard
Great Video Jonny, Sir. These are the videos that real basketball fans want. History...with context. As a long time NBA fan who grew up in the 80's, these older players are the ones I know that I am the most curious about. Some people consider this an era of "plumbers" on the court, but I believe the greats would absolutely be great in any era. #MambaForever
Been saying this! Mikan deserves more respect like the other great bigs!
The guy is up there with standardizing how the game is played. Bob Cousey did it for ball handling, Bill Russell did it for defense, and George Mikan showed what a dominant big man could do. Even if you don't put those three guys in the top five of their positions, they revolutionized what could be done and deserve credit as such.
Considering the game was genuinely in its infancy its understandable that he doesn't really make anyone's lists bit je should still be acknowledged as one of the greats.
The general consensus when people talk about other players in pretty much any sport is that the greats would shine regardless of era and i agree.
The cream always rises. And i do think that someone who was clearly so much better than all of his contemporaries, if given the advantages of the sport 20, 30, or even 60 years later, would still have come through as a fantastic player. Maybe not an all time great considering the expansion of the talent pool, but still elite.
I think goat debates are about how dominant and good you were compared to the competition, you cant compare stats from diferentes eras.
And when you talk dominance and ability in context, Mikan is up there with Bill, Mj, Bron, Kareem, Bird and Magic
He is the OG NBA GOAT. Short but dominating career
One of the best 2k players to use in the game.
He did it in chuck Taylor’s.
Mikan would still score on other centers today. And he was well versed in having to defend fast paced perimeter oriented offenses. You have to remember, Mikan invented the dominant post scoring offense. Bigs before him like LeRoy Edwards, Ed Dancker, and others were fine scorers, but they were bruising defenders first and foremost. He was also a great passer for his position.
He was an executive of the ABA and he was the one enforcing the 3 point line on his league.
He’s definitely the GOAT of his era. For his time, he dominated in every aspect and was winning. Like you said Jonny, precedents were set during his career as well. I think my bigger concern is giving him proper respect for his contributions to the game. I feel like Mikan doesn’t get it from either lack of knowledge or his era gets dissed. I believe in 2022, his jersey was finally retired. That’s way too late for the man who helped paved the way for many of the future greats. While I’m happy he got the jersey retirement but so sad that it took this long for the ceremony to happen. I’m sorry for venting but I just want to see the early players like Mikan get respected.
The issue was he wanted everyone who was part of the Minneapolis Lakers championships retired the Lakers org just wanted to retire him. Nobody ever wore his jersey # in LA that I know of either.
@@CrazyxEnigma ok, I see. I didn’t know that. I do respect that he wanted his teammates numbers retired as well. I still believe his jersey should have been retired much earlier.
greatest of ALL TIME of his era? u hear how stupid u sound? all time but his era only? people with smart phones don't think before they type acronyms
2:45
On the topic of the basketballs, one of the big things that points to this is the change to the 8 panel ball. Where we saw the single largest increase in FT% in NBA history.
There are of course other factors that play into the lower efficiency of the era. A preference for tip-ins over dunks, and the fact that early nba was played on plywood covered ice in temperatures to keep the ice frozen.
I love these videos about old players that modern people forget about
Idk why it just looks like a lot of players back then werent in game shape and couldnt hope to contend with the crazy athletes in NBA history. But as we've seen Larry played decent defense despite his "athletic limitations" and so did shorter guys like Stockton. These guys played gruelling minutes for shit money and didnt complain. They broke their legs and kept playing, they were a lot more athletic than people give them credit for. Fundamentals are very important in basketball and you'd be surprised just how strong professional athletes are, even guys like Bird. To do the things he was doing it takes real athleticism. George Mikan seemed like a Larry Bird but with longer arms. He invented so much of modern basketball you have to give him his flowers. He was like a less athletic, scoring version of Bill Russell, maybe Wilt and other guys would be tough to score on but with his finesse he would find ways. Being a smaller player than Kareem he would get more creative with his hooks and would also be a great passer and mid range shooter, on a team with good finishers Wilt wouldnt be able to guard him and control the paint at the same time. And in today's game he could probably dribble, shoot 3s play the 3-5 and be in better shape. He was a true worker and master of the game before they let players break the rules for entertainment. He helped create the 3pt line he would most definitely be like a Larry Bird with better shot blocking
I remember one starting center got hurt so his back up said he sat on the bench and studied Mikan so he could stop him.. said well all hes got is a post up hook and getting rebounds... Ill just shut down his hook shot and hit him on every box out and he wont be able to do anything, imma have his number.. that night i went out and held him to 40 points and 20 rebounds
Didn't know the guy. His numbers and accolades are amazing. A forgotten legend.
Oh my goodness how do you know all of this? This is amazing and to answer your question he does belong He's a all-time great
The NBL in general is an extremely fascinating part of basketball history to me, and the NBA's erasure of it is really frustrating. It had a longer history than the BAA, it was the birthplace of the Lakers, 76ers, Pistons, Kings, and Hawks, it was integrated, and it didn't seem drastically outclassed by the BAA in terms of talent (judging by the World Professional Basketball Tournament prior to their merger, and the first several years of NBA playoffs following the merger).
Also, the insane ambition behind the Chicago American Gears owner attempting to start a 24-team league (a wild prospect in the 1940s in general; even more ridiculous when you consider the BAA and NBL were already operating) is just so funny to me.
He had the most rules changed, behind only Wilt. Definitely a top-5 Center of All Time.
When you’re talking about GOAT, context is extremely important. Is Mikan a Top 5 center based on today’s standards? Of course not. But his contributions to the NBA in its infancy make him one of the all time greats.
All games have origins, and Mr Basketball really is the origin.
Most people have a dificulty in ranking this guy all-time. He was clearly very good but it is hard to tell if he is GOAT level
GOAT LEVEL
George Mikan
Bill Russell
Wilt Chamberlain
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
Julius Erving
Larry Bird
Magic Johnson
Michael Jordan
Shaquille O'Neal
Tim Duncan
Kobe Bryant
LeBron James
Stephen Curry
...
not hard at all....
definitely GOAT level in his time
@@itachi-kun7736 thanks bro 😄
Honestly it's stuff like this is why I don't compare eras because it was so such a different time when George competed but that doesn't mean we should diminish his legacy whatsoever. He is legendary for a reason
As always, great job, young man. Being born in '61, I'm old enough to have heard from fans older than Bill Russel, that saw him play, about how he was their GOAT. In the case of Geo. Mikan, I can't ever remember talking to someone that saw him play, even as a youngster. But in examining roundball history, how can we not call him an all-time great? Knowing he could only be born when he was, I'm wondering how he could have done better? Could any player ever born have stepped in and been more effective, if they shared his birthday of 6/18/24? Any foreigner or person of color would have faced too many obstacles. Probably Bird, maybe Mchale or Barry? All that said, don't we have to call him top 10 or 12?
Pioneering the game without big contracts, analytics, film, trainers, facilities or advanced sports medicine. Mikan brought eyes to the product. I'm sure he wouldn't sniff the NBA today, but it's an evolution.
Weird side note on Mikan I always thought was odd was that he was actually a surprisingly good free throw shooter, possibly the best in the pantheon of greatest centers. He's a bit like Bob Cousey in that it's REALLY hard to compare him to those that followed because shooting techniques, post move and such weren't as developed but they're as accomplished as almost anyone at their position. He's definitely minimum 3rd greatest Lakers of all time
I remember cranking up the Ford to go watch him play. Back then, a giant could put a grown man on their on thier shoulders. No worries about what's poking or slithering on the back of the head. I have no idea how dominant he would be now. I do know it was a different game in a different world. ( even if I wasn't really there)
Johnny stays with the heat. At 6'10 240lbs Mikan could likely play today and as a finesse player he wasn't just Shaq'ing people in the paint. So its not unrealistic to imagine he'd develop as more than a bruiser. It wouldn't be a stretch like some players from the past such as Bob Cousy. Sorry Bob, Dad loved you. Add some modern training and shooting and voila. Stretch 4 at worst.
His numbers were without question the best during his time and a lack of accolades and stats hide how dominant he was. Between rule changes, winning and being the best player every season he has the best resume in basketball history. It really is Mikan and Russell if youre looking at winning.
I am not a believer in past players keeping up with todays game, but there is no way Daniel Theis is better than this guy
I actually think Bob Cousy would be better in todays league than Mikan would be
@@arch8748 Theis catching strays out here xD
@@dylanolson4600 Idk. Cousy was short, unathletic by todays standards, short wingspan and was a pretty bad shot. He'd have to get Mac McClung levels of athleticism and steph curry efficiency and range.
Best I can see him be is like a 10/3/7/0.1/1.0 guy with 35/45/75 splits. I can see Mikan avg like 18/9/3/2/1 on 30/50/70 splits.
I'm all ears since I got a lot of respect for 60's Boston teams and what they achieved.
@@dylanolson4600 bob cousy is an unathletic, undersized point guard, that can’t shoot. In what world would any team sign him? He’s not making a G league try out
Definitely the goat of his era so he absolutely deserves his flowers. Kinda hard to judge players from the 40’s/50’s but nun the less he deserves respect for what he did in his time. I’m sure his game could translate to later eras.
He'd be a top 5-10 center today
Mikan wrote an instructional book on the "sky hook" that was recomended by Jabar.
I do the Mikan drill (and reverse) as a warm-up every time I play.
George Mikan is byfar the greatest Beta tester of all time. thanks for patching out the infinite posetion glitch for us George
He formed the mold and tradition of dominant big men that lasted for decades.
the George Mikan drill was almost something i'd practice growing up for developing my conditioning
NBA changed a lot of rules to make it harder for him...
George Mikan's skills are what literally defined the rules of basketball, yet still his rank is impossible to define with numbers
One other thing he got the league to chang jersey numbering. Rules. Until then you could only have numbers from 1-5, so the refs could signal the scorer's table using a single hand e.g. 25 was two fingers left hand five finger right hand then signal the foul.
with mikan wearing 99 he had to get special per mission. he agree to raise his arm like in college ball.
I’m a firm believer in the idea that a great athlete would be great in any era. Saying that a guy would suck today because they didn’t run as fast a 40 or didn’t bench press enough is just stupid because you’re ignoring the fact that there are years of advances in things like equipment,training,nutrition, and sports medicine that these old guys would have access too. Would a mid 1960s wilt be an average player today? Maybe but if you gave a 13 year old wilt access to our modern world imagine what he could have done. He did everything in chuck Taylor’s image what he could have done with Jordan’s
Based on this video it now feels you ranked him a bit low in your Top 50 / Top 75 players of all time videos :)
- It'd say top 40 player all time and Top 10 Center (between David Robinson and Patrick Ewing)
Real ball fans respect the ppl who made the way and study the rule changes and nuances that caused influxes of stats over time respect to mikan
Mikan absolutely belongs in the conversation. Personally I rank him as high as 9th. Centers in the NBA, unlike any other position in any other sport, are heavily rated by their ability to deliver titles. It's basically impossible to realistically name an NBA top 10 list in which at least 80% have NOT been the #1 or #2 guy on their team to win at least one title. It's the reason why Bowie & Olajuwon were drafted before Jordan & Oden before Durant. My top 10: the big 3: Kareem, Wilt, & Russell, the next 2: Olajuwon & Shaq. Followed by The Admiral & Moses. Then The Joker, Mikan, & Walton. Won't argue with those who want Ewing in that 9th or 10th spot. He'll stand out as the only one to fail in his title runs. Note: I've been a fan since I was 11 in 1963.
that's where I have him, #9 all time
After Shaq, so about 6th, this is due to injuries, it is only that the five before him had amazing careers each in their own right, so he would be the sixth in that group, ahead of great centers such as Moses, Ewing and Reed simply because he was "the man" for longer than most as he owned his era.
I don't know that much about George Mikan but he needs to be respected & people need to talk about him more.His stats looks better compare to most players.Also his '48-'54 run was crazy especially point wise.
The goat
George Mikan is an example of why it's so hard to compare players across eras. Everything was different then vs now -- no free agency, much shorter road to the Finals, different rules, lesser quality of equipment and apparel, etc.
He is the first player to patent the fundamental skills of basketball and dominate the game all together, while winning the titles and being the first superstar of the league. Regardless of how many years since his time, I would believe that George Mikan is the top 20-30 player of all time.
I grew up watching and loving the game from 1990, but always had interest in knowing the players that shaped the league from the start.
Snoop Dogg said it the best while being on Undisputed when he was talking about owning the Ottawa Senators, but it's not just the influence of having black players in the league, but as the game has evolved in all sports, handful of players have added flash to the fundamentals of the game to appeal to the fans, as I would think Maravich and ABA also brought style and flair to the basketball.
And I think George Mikan would still be a great solid to a superstar level big if he played today. He'd be like Tim Duncan and Kevin McHale type.
Might be a hot take but I think Mikan might be ranked 4th greatest Lakers of all time behind Shaq, Kobe and Magic if we use the no time machine argument. He won 5 championship (6 if we include NBL) and dominated the league so badly the rules change around him. He is the Original goat of the NBA
It's hard to give him credit for "what ifs" but I do feel like he'd be one of those older players who in a more modern era would've benefited from improvements to the game as well as more modernized training.
You almost have to break these GOAT conversations down, decade by decade, even then it's iffy.
The first nba superstar
I think it is both. Mikan is obviously not as skilled as the players of today so if someone wants to say no he isn't, I can see that argument. But he is also the best player of his era and in that context then yes he is one of the best centers of all time. I think it is just a matter of whether or not you choose to honor each era or try to compare each era against each other, which to me is almost impossible to do fairly. I think he is one of the NBA's greatest centers based on his impact on his era.
Jesse Owens' times probably couldn't win a high school track meet today, but he still has to be considered among the greatest sprinters of all time due to his dominance in the conditions he ran under. Same with Mikan. His story kind of reminds me of a pro football contemporary of his, Otto Graham, who won championships at a rate that even puts Tom Brady to shame. (7 in 10 seasons, made to the finals in all 10, but some weren't technically in the NFL so he doesn't get credit.)
Milan did end up playing in the shot clock era, he can out of retirement in 1956 and played 37 games.
Mikan deserves merit, he was the original G.O.A.T, as Bob Cousy once said "He's (Mikan) was the one who saved the league." Mikan was also the one (along with Oklahoma State's 7-0 Bob Kurland) who helped open the doors for the big man to play the game.
Mikan served his purpose in NBA history, but in today's game, I think we can all unanimously agree that he would be a Kelly Olynyk caliber, 10 minutes off the bench player at best.
no, we don't unanimously agree
The reason it's difficult to rank players from this era is the same reason why Mikan was great: no one yet knew what "basketball" was supposed to look like. Skill evolution happens because it's easier to learn an established skill than invent it yourself, and Mikan invented a lot of skills that are still instrumental in the game today.
I think he deserves way more respect. LA Lakers count the championships they won in Minneapolis towards their championship totals because it is the same organization. But, the LA Lakers won't retire his jersey number, my guess is because he didn't play for the LA Lakers. Disrespectful.
Hey but they will count his championships
Mikan has 7 titles in 8 full seasons. He’d arguably be an 8 time mvp if the BAA and NBA had the award. He’s a 4 time scoring champ. He would be somewhere between a 4-8 time DPoY. He’s a 4 time rebounding champ. He was the best passing big by a mile. Mikan is absolutely in the goat conversation, idc whatever trash argument people use to tear him down, the dominance speaks for itself.
Oh and btw the Lakers have 18 titles. Not a laker fan, actually super anti, just a truth fan.
Mikan was the Goat of his era. He shouldn't be forgotten and talked about more but comparing him to today's era is pointless the league was so different.
Mikan is one of the GOATS
@jonnyarnett, I think George belongs in a whole different category. Not saying he was better. Not saying he wasn’t as good. Just saying, his game/style, skillset, drive, etc. helped the NBA evolve. If not for him and other players who brought new things to the game, the modern professional basketball would look totally different. It’s kinda like, BC/AD. But, more like, BGM/AGM. 🤷🏻♂️
Era, position, playing style, individual requirements etc. can all vary heavily and make it impossible to put the greatness of two players in relation to each other. Even when comparing MJ to LeBron it becomes obvious, but trying to rank a superstar big man from the 50s/60s is many times more complicated.
When you have a fundamentals drill named after you, yeah you can say you're great.
On the Mt Rushmore of centers - top 4.
He was the original GOAT. In my opinion he is top 10 center of all time alongside Kareem, Bill Wilt, Shaq, Hakeem, Moses Malone, Jokic, Robinson and Reed.
top 15 all-time list
of course. he was the nba's first legend.
release the ultimate nuggets, pacers, pelicans, and pistons video already! it’s been 10days!
RIP George Mikan
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar got the idea of the hook shot from Mikan, then took it to another level as the sky hook.
Greatest of all time implies across eras you would rise above the competition.
I wonder how different each NBA record numbers would be if they actually started counting the stats the player had before the years of 1969 only had 31,000 something. My grandpa watched Chamberlain pretty much every day and off what he said he had a well over 50 to 40,000 points if they counted stats since the beginning of basketball, I wonder where George Mikan would be
If jokic can play in this era..Mikan would do just fine..facts..
Does he belong? YES.
He's one of the most important players in the history of the game, but almost impossible to compare to players like Patrick Ewing or Greek Freak.
The closet comparable to Mikan, I think, is Tim Duncan. If anything, Mikan's had more flash to his game. Entertainment is part of the sell. He would do well in any era. That's one of the measure of a great in the history of the big four North American sports. How does that does athlete rate as an any era player? That some of the greats in every sport have crossed eras and continued to succeed reinforces the argument.
does anyone know the background music of this video?