Dirt-cheap Chinese collets in the German Proxxon lathe. Will I regret it?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 59

  • @bobwilson7684
    @bobwilson7684 Рік тому +2

    lovely soundtrack for the ending

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  Рік тому +2

      🙂 No one sings that like Edith Piaf, she lived that song.

    • @bobwilson7684
      @bobwilson7684 Рік тому +1

      @@Michel-Uphoff loving the music and the pace, quite a contrast in these fields, don´t give up keep it comming! ))

  • @rodbutler9864
    @rodbutler9864 2 роки тому +9

    I went down the mounting plate option for the ER32 collet to allow for 20mm
    rods to go all the way through but I've really not needed that facility (yet).
    That is a very well made draw bar solution just the same.
    I loved the soft jaw magnets! Always learning on your channel, Thank you.

  • @ozyrob1
    @ozyrob1 2 роки тому +3

    Started watching expecting the usual typical Chinese product review. Very much wasn't. Impressed and subbed. Please keep going. UA-cam needs more creators like this.

  • @Sherpa199
    @Sherpa199 2 роки тому +8

    Michael, the turning test and flipping the bar was a really tough task to get to those numbers, well done.

  • @HanstheTraffer
    @HanstheTraffer 2 роки тому +3

    A lot of good solutions. Subscribed! I wouldn't have thought a Proxxon lathe was rigid enough for that kind of work.

  • @rodbutler9864
    @rodbutler9864 Рік тому +1

    Non, je ne regrette rien …….outstanding 🤣
    Although a backing plate with an ER 32 collet
    wouldn’t need a draw bar and it’d fit 20mm stock.
    But great to watch as usual……..thank you.

  • @howder1951
    @howder1951 2 роки тому +4

    Well done, and very nice proof of accuracy. This is exactly what I have been planning for my collet chuck , which presently has a solid draw bar. Enjoyed, cheers!

  • @joell439
    @joell439 2 роки тому +1

    Michel - excellent results. Your channel has definitely earned a subscription from me. I look forward to binge watching the rest of your channel's content 👍👍😎👍👍

  • @lensman5762
    @lensman5762 2 роки тому +2

    Excellent workmanship.

  • @user-bl1eh2qs9o
    @user-bl1eh2qs9o 2 роки тому +2

    That's very impressive for Dirt-cheap Chinese collets. I saved these two sellers.

  • @postiemania
    @postiemania 2 роки тому +2

    I want All German Components for my CNC, alas I have a Chinese budget. However I am pleased to state that the Chinese components in my Australian designed and built machine give me 20 micron accuracy (Good enough for me. ). Yes I know many machines from Germany have 1micron accuracy and kudos to the skilled workers who build these machines.

  • @alpha-hv9ck
    @alpha-hv9ck 2 роки тому +3

    Thank you for the good content ❤ plz do much more 😊

  • @HM-Projects
    @HM-Projects 2 роки тому +1

    Excellent build and end result, well done!

  • @colincreedtattoomachines
    @colincreedtattoomachines 2 роки тому +2

    Michel, you've made yourself a great adaptation, Congrats!!
    Had often wondered "why" Proxxon has chosen to only supply their "Euro collet" for the PD 400 but never an ER collet option?
    Curious as to why you didn't contemplate making an ER styled mounting plate like how the standard Proxxon collet version is?
    I'm assuming that by going with this MT3 option, all the ER features were there rather than having to make them from scratch.
    I own the PD 250/E which Proxxon makes a ER20 collet mounting plate option & found it to be a very good addition.

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  2 роки тому +3

      I did contemplate that but the MT3 collet chuck was so cheap that I thought: let's try that first. And the first impression is that this chuck is precise enough. Have to test it more thoroughly though including all 24 collets.

  • @jerzyszczepanski2518
    @jerzyszczepanski2518 Рік тому

    Hi. With your skill you can easily make new ER40 chuck monted with 3 or 4 bolts. Less stick out and up to 30mm through. Thank you for making these videos. I've learned new things.

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  Рік тому

      Yes I could do so. The spindle bore is 20 mm, so that is the maximum. ER40 has a max of 26 mm.

    • @jerzyszczepanski2518
      @jerzyszczepanski2518 Рік тому +1

      @@Michel-Uphoff You can get ER40 collets up to 30mm

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  Рік тому

      @@jerzyszczepanski2518
      Great! I would love to have those four extra sizes, Do you know where could I buy those 27, 28, 29 and 30 mm collets?

  • @peterirving844
    @peterirving844 2 роки тому +2

    Great saving using cheep Chinese parts, I've found some components are well worth the money and others complete dross you never know until they arrive, and some just need a little attention to improve them.

  • @EugenBadau
    @EugenBadau 9 місяців тому

    Nu vei regreta . Proxxon nu este nici pe departe asa precis si perfect pe cit este de scump si incmplect . Am cumparat produse chinezesti de o calitate pe care proxxon nu o atinge,

  • @xx-vk5ol
    @xx-vk5ol 2 роки тому

    Great video Sir!!!. Please keep making them.

  • @AndySomogyi
    @AndySomogyi 2 роки тому

    Did you have any issues milling the collet holder?
    I want to do something very similar and modify a holder to fit my spin fixture.
    You use a carbide mill right ?

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  2 роки тому +2

      Yes, I used carbide inserts for the boring bar and outside turning and a carbide four flute endmill. For the threading however I used HSS, which I touched lightly with a diamond grinder a few times during the cutting to keep it sharp.
      Don't think however, that all collet holders have the same hardness. I think the better ones are (case) hardened up to 60 or so Rockwell C. With a quality insert you can still turn that, but not with HSS.

    • @AndySomogyi
      @AndySomogyi 2 роки тому

      @@Michel-Uphoff I doubt they're case hardened because case hardeneing is lot more expensive than simply using high carbon steel and doing a basic heat and quench. I'm pretty sure they're all made out of some medium grade tool steel.
      Anyways, it's great to see a video like this and see others also modifying these.

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  2 роки тому +1

      The cheaper ones probably not, but under the more expensive ones there are certainly case hardened (to 58-60 HRC) holders. Case hardening isn't expensive. I am preparing for a video about DIY case hardening, think it will be released in a week. For case hardened chucks See:
      tinyurl.com/5fverbw6
      tinyurl.com/3xfzbbds
      tinyurl.com/y7cepe4m

  • @IM-qq3jf
    @IM-qq3jf 2 роки тому +2

    Hello Michael.
    I bumped into this video just now , I allmost switched it off, due to that dreadfull depressing horible music, and no voice over.
    But hang in with me, I put my fingers in my ears and over some time, discovered how wonderful and amazingly good your vid was.
    I then went back and looked at your other vidoes and I now admire the scientific quality research you have put into your vids.
    I feel that you have now produced the best youtube Proxxon fine tuning vids out there.
    So I now have clicked the subscribe button plus the notification bell also.
    I look foward to more of yourvids . Hopfully with more suitable music that complements your subject.
    Thanks.
    Ian.

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  2 роки тому +1

      Thank you for your valued response and compliments and criticism Ian.
      It's funny, the music that you find so horrible here in the Netherlands is a well-known and appreciated composition by Simeon ten Holt.
      It's called "Canto Ostinato", and it's an improvisation piece. If you can endure even more audio torture, you might want to look it up.
      Imagine..
      In this country, hundreds of people take a blanket or pillow and lie on the floor in a concert hall or other suitable location..
      They close their eyes..
      And they listen..
      For two to three hours straight..
      While four pianists play this hypnotic music together, reacting on each other..
      I've been there a few times myself and enjoyed it immensely.
      But this is also very true: "De gustibus non est disputandum".

    • @IM-qq3jf
      @IM-qq3jf 2 роки тому

      Thank you Michael, for responding.
      Well us australians, english and american people, must just have a different upbringing and taste.
      People from the Neatherlands have there own style and tastes, and that is good too.
      Have you considered doing voice over, as it would help with teaching the viewers on the very professional and techinical work you are doing.
      I am just trying to help you build your channel, because you are very good at your work.
      Thanks again.
      Ian

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  2 роки тому +1

      >> Have you considered doing voice over

    • @IM-qq3jf
      @IM-qq3jf 2 роки тому

      @@Michel-Uphoff Thankyou Micheal for replying.
      I see your point.
      Actually, you have Excellent written English, I would not have known that it is not your native language.
      I love watching and being inspired by your beautifully crafted videos.
      Thank you.
      Ian.

  • @the4thj
    @the4thj 2 роки тому

    Can you make those things fit my 12 x 36? ~laughing. Very nice! I Subbed, got any more sorcery to do with refind ground rocks?

  • @juanzuluaga3388
    @juanzuluaga3388 Рік тому +1

    Please tell me, what's the name and composer of the piano music?

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  Рік тому +1

      The piano music is "Canto Ostinato", an improvisation piece by the Dutch composer Simeon ten Holt. It is written for 1 to 4 pianos. The score is not what you would expect, it is more of a collection of musical building blocks in an unusual ten/sixteenth time. The pianists can use the building blocks as they wish, and the duration of the piece is not fixed. There are versions that last 3.5 hours. Like more unusual minimalist music, it fascinates or repels, you like it or hate it, there seems to be no in-between.

  • @ferb7452
    @ferb7452 2 роки тому +2

    Very very impressed
    Keep it going 👌👌

  • @robertsneddon731
    @robertsneddon731 2 роки тому

    It's possible to source Imperial ER collets to "fill in" gaps between the millimetre sizes i.e. a 3/8" collet will work well as a 9.5mm collet, better than torturing a 10mm collet by clamping it down really hard on a piece of 3/8" stock and distorting it. Sadly there are no cheap sources of hex and square-fit ER collets but then again they are kind of expensive for other collet formats such as 5C.
    I've put that soft-jaw with magnets trick in my mental toolbox, thanks.

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  2 роки тому +2

      All ER collets (except the very small ones) have a clamping range of 1 mm. You don't distort a 10 mm collet when clamping a 9,1 mm rod, they are designed for that range.

    • @AndySomogyi
      @AndySomogyi 2 роки тому

      @@Michel-Uphoff The collet set I bought came in imperial 1/32 increments which is interesting. It was about 20% more than the metric set, but came with more collets, so I'm guessing it might be grip better for in-between sizes.

  • @GeorgeGeorgalis
    @GeorgeGeorgalis 2 роки тому

    Thanks for the extra know how for my vicarious workshop! The interesting music however doesn't appear linked properly. What is it?

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  2 роки тому

      The piano music is "Canto Ostinato" by Simeon ten Holt. It's a recording of 4 grand piano's. The pianists have to improvise on guidelines ten Holt wrote down. They did so for 3,5 hours. Here you can hear a short piece. The last seconds you can hear "Non, je ne regrette rien!" (no, no regrets at all!) by Edith Piaff. I tried to be funny..

    • @GeorgeGeorgalis
      @GeorgeGeorgalis 2 роки тому

      @@Michel-Uphoff thanks! I have found several recordings of Canto Ostinato now, interesting piece! And yep, I found Non, je ne regrette rien at the end after I wrote my comment. :-)

  • @YooProjects
    @YooProjects 2 роки тому +1

    Excelent job. I like your channel 💫

  • @Watcheyes
    @Watcheyes 2 роки тому

    Amazing! Thank you!

  • @ygevalk2665
    @ygevalk2665 2 роки тому

    Wil je nu nog beter draadsnijden, zet dan het beitelsupport onder de helft van de tophoek. Geef dan de aanzet met het beitelsupport.
    De draad wordt mooier doordat nu slechts 1 kant van de beitel snijdt en zo stabieler is.

    • @Michel-Uphoff
      @Michel-Uphoff  2 роки тому +1

      Dat is mij natuurlijk bekend, maar ik gebruik een andere methode, die ik eenvoudiger vind. Ik draai de bovenslede om en om in en uit rond dezelfde uitgangspositie. De grootte van deze wissel is afhankelijk van de draaddiepte en dus mijn aanzet, maar in de praktijk bij de fijne draad die ik meestal maak is het 0,05 tot 0,1 mm. Zo snijd ik altijd een wisselende flank. Als je goed kijkt zie je mij het support af en toe verstellen.

    • @ygevalk2665
      @ygevalk2665 2 роки тому

      @@Michel-Uphoff dank voor jouw uitleg, inderdaad zo kan het ook. Was mij niet opgevallen dat je steeds het beitelsupport verstelde. Er zijn wel meer methoden, ook om in drie bewegingen een goede draad te snijden. Maar dat kan alleen op een professionele stevige draaibank.

  • @MagnetOnlyMotors
    @MagnetOnlyMotors 2 роки тому +1

    9:11 nice fit.

  • @MrXanderjanssen
    @MrXanderjanssen 2 роки тому

    Nice job

  • @356B
    @356B 2 роки тому

    well played

  • @bobweiram6321
    @bobweiram6321 2 роки тому

    Awesome!

  • @rgmveraart
    @rgmveraart 2 роки тому

    Professioneel vakwerk!!!

  • @YouTube运营咨询中心孟
    @YouTube运营咨询中心孟 2 роки тому +1

    视频很棒,做的很好。点个赞👍,订阅了。多多上传更新哦~

  • @mfs5493
    @mfs5493 Рік тому

    Toolbit - not chisel.

  • @WilliOlfen-lq5bn
    @WilliOlfen-lq5bn 4 місяці тому

    Oh no!!

  • @mftmachining
    @mftmachining 2 роки тому

    schöne arbeit