guys react to the introduction to the memvers of bts by IDA S. and MMA 2019 BTS live performance. love your reactions and the interpretation is spot on!!!!
there's an explanation of all BTS PERSONA-SHADOW-EGO concept i hope you you check it out from Bookishtheories channel, shes very good,i know BTS has deep meaning but when i watch her explanation and theories im speechless coz its way more deeper than i thought and its amazes me how they put everything together and how they connect everything from the beginning 💜💜
This song is about BTS fear of losing their love and passion for music. It's inspired by the quote by dancer Martha Graham "A dancer dies twice, once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful."
Persona is the face you present in public. Ego is the sum of yourself. Shadow is the dark nature and dark urges, which you have to confront and accept to form a fully mature personality - a complete Ego. All of this is from Carl Jung, the Swiss psychiatrist that BTS loves.
This is such a good reaction vid. None of that “I don’t know what they’re saying” or “let me know who the members are in the comments” or exaggerated screams/blank stares. Yes
that's why I wouldn't finish watching those reaction videos, cause really... they can't understand smh these guys are those rare reactors that I would watch till the end cause they really read lyrics and Analyze them and give their own theories about it..
I strongly agree! It’s refreshing to see intelligence and genuine fascination with the creativity. I have wasted so much time with reactors, waiting for them to “get it” and show more interest in the boys and supporting them, rather than crowing about their own prowess in singing. I’m trying to be more selective. Also I appreciate the limited fbombs. I counted 29 in one reaction video. I mean seriously, I wanted to ask can you even construct one complete sentence without that word? It shows a very limited vocabulary and laziness in thought. (Sorry for the rant. Pet peeve) Anyway….I appreciate this duo and look forward to their journey!
@@pamelajbarber4819 I feel the same about fbombs... it's funny now and then but gets annoying real fast when it's used like every other word. I appreciate these two reactors here because they're actually having a thoughtful conversation - and they come across as interested. They're not just hyping things up but are taking in what they're watching and having a nice initial reaction/think about it.
One thing: you need to keep in mind that popular artists don't just do music. They do many things in order to promote their music: *MV shooting *Interviews *TV and radio promos *Concert tours *Photo shoots for mags and commercial ads (endorsements) *Merchandise developments *Intelectual Properties development *etc Bruno Mars once tweeted something like he should have been a model instead of a musician because that's where he seems to be heading with all the merch he has to sell in order to support his music. (Label contracts ) BTS is the same and probably do much more because their brand is worldwide and worth billions of dollars in the economy of South Korea. So their worry about their passion for music is justified and expressed in this song. Also, keep in mind that this song was produced and released before the pandemic. They finished a world stadium tours in 2019, recorded the album right after, prepared for the release in January and was scheduled to have another world tour which was supposed to start in March 2020. The pandemic, in a way, gave them a much deserved break and they were able to concentrate on music more. They released an unscheduled 2nd album for last year, which would not have come out if they went on tour. Because of the pandemic, they also decided to finally release a song in English (Dynamite). And so, with Butter, they were able to achieve 4 number ones on Billboard Hot100. And because they were not able to go on tour, they were able to realize more how precious performing on stage in front of ARMY is to them. Everything happens for a reason.
Very well said... if you watch their ON:E behind the scene drop 2days ago, you will see how much miss performing on stage.. to see that crowd who gives them so much happiness and energy. Same way goes to the army.. we miss them.. seeing each other is like "charging batteries" RM the leader said.
It's so refreshing when someone gets it right away. Also, you're both looking fiiiine! I'd love to see you react to some introductions. Analyzing becomes even more interesting when you know who is singing which part and how it fits their personality and struggles.
@@ZiahTV Some short bios⤵ by xceleste *"THIS IS BTS-Intro"* *"THIS IS ARMY"* *"HARDSHIPS 2013-2021* *"From NobodiesTo Legends2019"* *"Crash Course"* (Albums) + *"MOST BEAUTIFUL LIFE STORY"* . ▶BEST LIVE RAP>UTUBE(CC)⤵ *"OUTRO-TEAR"-Wembley* *"DDAENG"-Prom Party* *"UGH"-Live* *"CYPHER MEDLEY 1-4"* After "ColorCoded LyricVids 1-4"-BARS!! . ▶BEST LIVE HIP-HOP>UTUBE⤵ *"COME BACK HOME, MIC DROP"* *"HIP-HOP LOVER"* rapper tribute *"BORN SINGER"* a take on J COLE ➕ ▶UP CLOSE-LIVE-HIP-HOP-stools *"ARMYPEDIA-I NEED U"* 3 songs *"TINY DESK CONCERT"* 3 songs
@@ZiahTV I hope you can react to This is BTS by xceleste and An introduction to the seven members of BTS by Ida S (2021 update). She had to reupload it but it is the newest one with less stereotypes and bias than many other introductions. They are mad talented, have great personalities and I can see that your humor could match their humor 😁
I’ve always felt that the response verse of “What’s my thing… what’s my thing tell me now” is a like a desperate cry from someone who can’t find or has lost the ability to feel passion for the thing they used to love to do. Also the “Film it now… film it now” verse hits hard because it’s like a plea to take a picture of this moment because if I lose these passionate feelings for what I love doing right now perhaps I will have something that will remind me of them in the future and find a way to get those feelings back.
So now you know why fans love them so much. They are not the usual boy band. Fans fall for music and messages in the lyrics. The facts that they are good looking, good dancers, great songwriter producers are secondary. They are a package that comes only once in an era.
In BTS "universe" there's a theory that might be helpful for this types of songs and it says that each member represents an archetype or a though. - Jin is the real human (body and soul) - Jungkook represents the persona ( the one we show) - V is the shadow (the one we hide or tend to stigmatize) - jimin represents a transition or change which always implies a decision that can be surrounded by our conscience (Jhope) and our subconscious (Suga) in other to achieve some of dreams or ambitions ( RM) I don't think it's a coincidence that the chorus is a conversation between jungkook and jimin, then jimin and V and finally Jin to jimin and the verses tends to be a confrontation between Suga and RM and then Jhope with Suga ( when the song becomes more hopeful)
Wow! Thanks for this. Ive never heard of this take before. And feels like it checks out. I'm gonna have to listen again while taking this in. One of my fave BTS songs gets better everyday.
The live performance of this song in ON:E concert with Jimin solo dance is breath taking. The performance for 2020 MMA is another one for you to check out too as they use Black Swan as the opening song.
It's their fear of loosing their ability to create music but it's also about accepting their shadows, working through this fear and finding new meaning with acceptance of their shadows.I recommend you start looking into their beginning. Bts has always written music with meaning. Also they always work with the same team from the beginning.
I feel the music BTS is sharing is impactful in at least 2 major ways: 1) Being in Korean it makes people want to understand it, so they read the lyrics often searching up culturally what it means, in doing so it causes reflection upon ones own self and how it relates, and talk about it which encourages discourse. 2) This in turn encourages the state of "Woke". I feel BTS is helping to bring everyone back to self, globally. This is a feat. I feel this is profound. Their music after all is largely impacted by Carl Jung. Bravo.
So, today we have Ziah Usher and Justin Shizi Timberlake. 😄👍 👏👏👏 Good interpretation, guys.. Yes. This song is about what if we loose our passion. In BTS case of course it's all about music. Black Swan is one of my top-tier of BTS's tracks. But actually, this album, called Map of The Soul: 7, is a masterpiece. Please listen to Louder Than Bombs. I can find no words to describe Louder Than Bombs. Speechless.. It gives me an unexistence heartbreak, pain, and sorrow.
It's a must watch! I can't forget the first time I saw it.. it's a small stage but the character of the set is fitting and their performance felt monumental. It's just brilliant!
Not even going to lie. Every time I watch a reaction Channel starting to react to BTS I level my judgment on this reaction. Black Swan is one of BTS's finest hours. If people don't or can't get that I usually give up and walk away. You guys passed the test.
lookin' schnazzy fellas! thanks for sharing your reactions to BTS' Black Swan...it's among my personal favorites! it's also one of the songs that, although they were able to perform it live at James Corden's Late Late Show (pre-covid lockdown) and some award shows thereafter (socially distanced/aired online), they didn't get to perform it in concert due to the pandemic forcing the cancellation of their 2020 world tour. as you can see, Jimin's really able to showcase his background as a trained contemporary dancer, and as the Black Swan (reminiscent of the popular ballet production/movie Black Swan, where the character, Nina, also appears to dance herself to death), reinterpreted through BTS's music. in either case, BTS' rendition is a phenomenal work of art, imho, and it's fascinating to see your fresh analysis of/reaction to it.
Swan Lake is a ballet, but you were close. Fun fact: "Black Swan" is a term used for a specific life event. For an event to qualify as a Black Swan it must meet 3 criteria, 1. It must come as a shock or surprise of a negative nature. 2. It must be a life changing negative event, 3. Looking back on the event one realizes that it should have been predicted. Great reaction, stay well
Yes, yes, yes!!! 😘💜💜💜💜💜💜💜Also on another level it relates to the ballet Swan Lake. The white swan representing purity and innocence and the black swan evil or temptation. And in the ballet (usually) it is played by the same dancer, even though in reality it is two different people. Odile (black swan) is a vixen and manipulative and wears a "disguise or mask" to appear to be the white swan or Odette. So the themes of good and evil are central to the story. (Good does win but with huge sacrifice) I'll leave the rest up to your wonderful minds. And I explained it very loosely, you know how folklore can be. The symbolism of Jimin's solo dancing and indeed he is the one with the wings, makes him the swan. And in the movie Black Swan it is about your light and dark fighting within you.
I really do enjoy your reactions! I love that you not only look into the beat and film production but most importantly the lyrical content and meaning of the song! Since you mentioned J Cole BTS did a remake of his song Born Sinner to Born Singer. It’s beautiful. Hope you react to it someday. Thanks for your genuine reactions!
@@ZiahTV Check out their live performance with eng lyrics of this song please! It is way more powerful! 🙏 Here is a link ua-cam.com/video/8cUQ3lF3_O8/v-deo.html
Most of BTS songs are symbolic but they aren't every necessarily about a relationship or being in love, they talk about mental health, family, friends , life in general. They leave things open to interpretation, a lot of the newer BTS music is about Carl Jung 5 Archetypes so LY, MOTS albums specifically. A lot of their music is about discovering yourself and not trying to feel pressure , learning to love and accept all parts of yourself; have a dream and try to achieve it, have a passion, it is okay to not be okay take a break work on your self and try to make the best out of bad situations.
FUNFACT:- The person solo dancing in the dark, is Jimin. Jimin was the top student of contemporary dance in the prestigious Busan High School of Arts :]
This song says, “The dancer dies twice. The first death is when the dancer stops dancing. And this death is much more painful,” the legendary contemporary dancer Martha Graham made its motif. Just as a dancer faces his first death when he quits dancing, it contains the fear of the moment when he will no longer be able to stand on the stage as an artist
i hope you get to read this comment, you were SUPER spot on the meaning of the song, only thing i noticed you got a little mixed up is that you believe that the shadow was their most happy side that they hide from the public, but the shadow actually represents all those aspects that would seem "negative" like sadness, depression, selfhate, greed, intrusive thoughts that scare us and that we feel would make us weaker if we show them to others, thats why we hide it, its the dark side basically -->its haunting. The other side we show to the public is called our PERSONA, thats the happiness we see, all the good stuff, it works like a mask. I'm saying all this because they are going to keep on this topic with a few other songs like [intro: persona, interlude: shadow or outro: EGO] its all about accepting your shadow, trying to work with it instead of repressing it inside you, trying to become a whole, your true self by acknowledging all the good and bad aspects of oneself, because even if we dont like our dark side, its still part of us and we have to learn how to live with it. Its a whole process and i hope you find it very interesting because i do 😄
I think the part "what's my thing what's my thang tell me now" is like not only the artist lost one's passion but so troubled that he or she forget the original mindset/motive for that thang. In Intro: Persona, the shadow asked whether RM has forgotten why he started making music and told him that in the beginning he was just happy that someone's listening to his music.
Well said Marie..!! 💜These guys are a fantastic team...they really know how to break down any MV/song in an enjoyable way..! So glad to have found them...keep up the great work guys..!!💜
Please react to BTS Blood Sweat and Tears too. Blood Sweat and Tears is more like the close "dark concept" sibling of Fake Love and Black Swan. The MV is iconic and it's full of symbolism.
I really like how you take the analysis of this songs very seriously, as someone without any musical background it really helps me understand the music better! Thank you :)
ALMOST EVERYONE IS CONFUSED ABOUT THE MEANING OF THIS SONG. BUT YOU TWO CAN GET IT ALL SO EASY AND YOUR OPEN MIND CAN BE DELIVERED TO US! OMG, YOU WERE AMAZING GUYS. SO PROUD :''' THANK YOU
I love that you guys truly get it. BTS is passionate about their music and always take things a step deeper. I absolutely love everything you said - I don't skip through your talking segments. Please take as long as reactions as you want and please react to more BTS!
So glad I found your channel. Your in-depth talks about the videos is impressive. You should watch Black Swan Kinetic Manifesto video- the interpretive dance by the Martha Graham Dance Company is impressive
BTS rarely sings love songs that are only just love songs, there's always something more you can get from it. I like how you really try to understand the message and are able to see beyond the typical love song - and for that I'm gonna sub! Lol.
You guys are so awesome - i love how you guys get the message so quickly from the lyrics -- your analysis is so on point --- thanks for reacting to the mv 👍
it is indeed a love song, a love song dedicated for their passion and their fear of losing it... you guys are smart getting that on your first watch.. 👏 imagine, writing such deep words, right, but what can i say, they even wrote about the worlds saddest whale and pluto.. ☺
This is probably the best reaction I’ve ever seen for this video! Thank you guys so much for taking the time not just to listen and watch but to also try to understand the deeper facets of the song! Kudos to you!
You guys are impressive with analysis !! wondering if you are ready for BLOOD SWEAT & TEARS... that one is REALLY DEEP 🥴 can’t wait for your next reaction... BTW, your new lewwkkss are FINE! 😎😎
only found your reactions today but I'm really loving how deep you dig into what the videos/songs make you feel. It makes me go YES and reminds me of my first time experiencing certain songs. Really wonderful :')
Wow! Just from the first few lines of the lyrics and you already picked up the meaning of the song! Your analyzing skills are on another level. You're really good! Applause to you!💜
personally, I don't think it's a "what if I lose my passion" song but more of "what if I am already losing it". it kinda takes you through the whole journey of being scared of the numbness that comes with it, going deeper into this feeling but then finding your way out. And I really like what you said about it describing feeling depressed. They are obviously talking about love for music but this can apply to any kind of dark thoughts really Also, shadow isn't really a true self. It's just one of the parts of the self that people are trying to hide
Check Out "Bookish Theories Explanation" video for meaning & understanding of "BLACK SWAN" 💜 {everything links} "Map Of The Soul " book by Murray Stein {Jung's theory} PERSONA - SHADOW - EGO 💥 Shadow: "You Are Me, I Am You" {acceptance} - your sub conscious 💥
RM participated in the song writing of this song and I think it is one of his finest work. He once said in an interview that he actually cried after writing the song. The emotions are so raw here and the MV is just mind blowing. I really love how you guys go deep into these lyrics. Good job!!
This song and ON are both from the albums Map of the soul :Persona and Map of the soul: 7 it was based on a book by Psychiatrist Carl Jung [ Jung's Map of the Soul] it gives the basic principles of Jung's psychology That each person has 3 main parts to them self's The Persona, The Shadow, and The Ego. The albums go in to each part
I love how yall dissect the music so well...and the videos could be like 30 minutes long but it doesn't feel like it. I also like how you guys comment on what you understand from what you are seeing👌🏻 It's really hard to make a video not boring but guys's videos are never boring to me👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻💯💯💯💯 Thank you guys for the reaction💜💜
You guys are really good...... Youll come to find out that alot of their "love songs" are either not love songs on the conventional sence or there is a double/hidden message within the song This perticular song was inspired by a quote by a ballet dancer Martha Graham, "A DANCER DIES TWICE- once when they stop DANCING, and the first death is more painful" You'll eventually be asked to check out the BTS storyline/universe which starts with the song,"I NEED U" i dont want to spoil the song,video or storyline for you. But i will let you know that RM or BTS (leader,a writer& a producer of the group) has said they used "GIRL" in the song because it sounds better then "FRIEND" lyrically & musically.
I want to thank You to take the time to know BTS, that's what ARMY wants, then, if You don't like them it's ok. We want them to be respected as artist, and not only see Their make up, hair color, Earrings ( this things are the Essence of K-POP). They're very valuable artist. Pourple You💜 BORAHAE!!!
hi! it's actually very interesting that you mentioned how people tend to lose their passion/dreams when they're in highschool or when they graduate, because that almost exactly what BTS' songs where about then they first debuted in 2013! (references: their first ever single "No More Dream" and "N.O.", I definitely recommend both of them, even if just to see how they've grown as artists) also, seeing as you're really great at interpreting songs+MVs (like srl, wow), I recommend you check out the rap line' solo songs from their 2020 album "Map of the Soul: 7": - "Intro: Persona" by RM - "Interlude: Shadow" by SUGA - "Outro: Ego" by J-HOPE all three songs have MVs which were used as trailers for albums and are tied together by the concepts of Jungian psychology :) anyway, I hope you'll have a great day!
ah, i love your reactions so much!! you guys are so good at getting messages and catching all the small details! there are so many reactors who just scream or completely ignore the lyrics in favor of listening to the audio. and although there are many ways to enjoy music, i just love how you guys enjoy the music but also pause to kinda gather your thoughts on what's going on too. and you're absolutely right, we don't mind the length of the video lmao. btw both of you are looking so fresh!! take care guys
Alas! Two reactors worth watching👍other reactors be like "let's react to this because they're popular worldwide".. but you two? Good job! You appreciate BTS lyricism?...
I love your guys reactions and analysis!!! Could you please react to: -Persona -Interlude: Shadow -Outro: Ego I have read a lot of comments already and I am sure you have too, that already explained what persona, shadow, and ego is. So I won’t, but could you please react to these pretty close to each other? Each one of these songs are solo songs from each rapper and they describe each of these in their own way. Do whatever you want though it is your channel.
Cool! So on point! This is totally about their fear, talking about their "Persona", the "Shadow" and the "Ego"... Maybe you can check out these coz they have songs with those titles. Cheers!💜
I love this kind of reaction that makes me notice the other sides of the subject that I have not noticed before. Your interpretation actually help me appreciate this song even further as I find another aspect I did not think about before. I like how you two bounce the idea off each other too. Great team and chemistry you have going on here. p.s. this reaction is the one that seal the deal fir me to subscribe.
I recommend Persona next!!! It's a great rap song from RM. Do Persona, then Shadow, and finally Ego. It sums up our rapline really well, but also what the Jungian archetypes are!
One thing about bts song you need to remember is most of their songs are not love songs. They don't make romantic songs. 90% of their songs are about topics that has nothing related to romance.
Please react to Jimins black Swan solo behind the scenes for this music video. Its so good and can show you more of all the dancing he did for this video!!
![BTS (방탄소년단) 'Black Swan' Official MV [Brothers React]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SzLMmcqHCA4/mqdefault.jpg)
Support us by becoming a Patreon today ► www.patreon.com/ZiahTV
This is one of my favorite songs they have. I would love to suggest their songs pied Piper and UGH :)
guys react to the introduction to the memvers of bts by IDA S. and MMA 2019 BTS live performance.
love your reactions and the interpretation is spot on!!!!
there's an explanation of all BTS PERSONA-SHADOW-EGO concept i hope you you check it out from Bookishtheories channel, shes very good,i know BTS has deep meaning but when i watch her explanation and theories im speechless coz its way more deeper than i thought and its amazes me how they put everything together and how they connect everything from the beginning 💜💜
The choreography is poetry in motion.
This song is about BTS fear of losing their love and passion for music. It's inspired by the quote by dancer Martha Graham "A dancer dies twice, once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful."
Persona: the one we show
Shadow: the one we hide
Ego: the one repress
Wow I didn't know that
Persona is the face you present in public. Ego is the sum of yourself. Shadow is the dark nature and dark urges, which you have to confront and accept to form a fully mature personality - a complete Ego. All of this is from Carl Jung, the Swiss psychiatrist that BTS loves.
This is such a good reaction vid. None of that “I don’t know what they’re saying” or “let me know who the members are in the comments” or exaggerated screams/blank stares. Yes
Ikr... It's difficult to find good reactors these days as kpop is getting more popular. These guys are great 💜
that's why I wouldn't finish watching those reaction videos, cause really... they can't understand smh
these guys are those rare reactors that I would watch till the end cause they really read lyrics and Analyze them and give their own theories about it..
That's why I subbed to them ♥
I strongly agree! It’s refreshing to see intelligence and genuine fascination with the creativity. I have wasted so much time with reactors, waiting for them to “get it” and show more interest in the boys and supporting them, rather than crowing about their own prowess in singing. I’m trying to be more selective. Also I appreciate the limited fbombs. I counted 29 in one reaction video. I mean seriously, I wanted to ask can you even construct one complete sentence without that word? It shows a very limited vocabulary and laziness in thought. (Sorry for the rant. Pet peeve) Anyway….I appreciate this duo and look forward to their journey!
@@pamelajbarber4819 I feel the same about fbombs... it's funny now and then but gets annoying real fast when it's used like every other word. I appreciate these two reactors here because they're actually having a thoughtful conversation - and they come across as interested. They're not just hyping things up but are taking in what they're watching and having a nice initial reaction/think about it.
One thing:
you need to keep in mind that popular artists don't just do music. They do many things in order to promote their music:
*MV shooting
*Interviews
*TV and radio promos
*Concert tours
*Photo shoots for mags and commercial ads (endorsements)
*Merchandise developments
*Intelectual Properties development
*etc
Bruno Mars once tweeted something like he should have been a model instead of a musician because that's where he seems to be heading with all the merch he has to sell in order to support his music. (Label contracts )
BTS is the same and probably do much more because their brand is worldwide and worth billions of dollars in the economy of South Korea.
So their worry about their passion for music is justified and expressed in this song.
Also, keep in mind that this song was produced and released before the pandemic. They finished a world stadium tours in 2019, recorded the album right after, prepared for the release in January and was scheduled to have another world tour which was supposed to start in March 2020.
The pandemic, in a way, gave them a much deserved break and they were able to concentrate on music more. They released an unscheduled 2nd album for last year, which would not have come out if they went on tour. Because of the pandemic, they also decided to finally release a song in English (Dynamite). And so, with Butter, they were able to achieve 4 number ones on Billboard Hot100.
And because they were not able to go on tour, they were able to realize more how precious performing on stage in front of ARMY is to them.
Everything happens for a reason.
Their music usually has a deep meaning. Also based on movie black Swan. Good reaction. Keep it up.
So true.💜
Very well said... if you watch their ON:E behind the scene drop 2days ago, you will see how much miss performing on stage.. to see that crowd who gives them so much happiness and energy. Same way goes to the army.. we miss them.. seeing each other is like "charging batteries" RM the leader said.
You guys are soo good..you always get it...its about love toward their music..keep up the good job guys..tc stay safe💜
Thank you so much 😊
Yess the smartest reactor... 👍🏻👍🏻💜💜
It's so refreshing when someone gets it right away. Also, you're both looking fiiiine!
I'd love to see you react to some introductions. Analyzing becomes even more interesting when you know who is singing which part and how it fits their personality and struggles.
Thank you! And we will definitely have to!
@@ZiahTV Some short bios⤵
by xceleste
*"THIS IS BTS-Intro"*
*"THIS IS ARMY"*
*"HARDSHIPS 2013-2021*
*"From NobodiesTo Legends2019"*
*"Crash Course"* (Albums)
+
*"MOST BEAUTIFUL LIFE STORY"*
.
▶BEST LIVE RAP>UTUBE(CC)⤵
*"OUTRO-TEAR"-Wembley*
*"DDAENG"-Prom Party*
*"UGH"-Live*
*"CYPHER MEDLEY 1-4"* After
"ColorCoded LyricVids 1-4"-BARS!!
.
▶BEST LIVE HIP-HOP>UTUBE⤵
*"COME BACK HOME, MIC DROP"*
*"HIP-HOP LOVER"* rapper tribute
*"BORN SINGER"* a take on J COLE
➕
▶UP CLOSE-LIVE-HIP-HOP-stools
*"ARMYPEDIA-I NEED U"* 3 songs
*"TINY DESK CONCERT"* 3 songs
@@ZiahTV I hope you can react to This is BTS by xceleste and An introduction to the seven members of BTS by Ida S (2021 update). She had to reupload it but it is the newest one with less stereotypes and bias than many other introductions. They are mad talented, have great personalities and I can see that your humor could match their humor 😁
You two are so fast of the uptake. You grasped the meaning so quickly. And yes, this definitely plays into the ‘shadow’ section of Map of the Soul.
I’ve always felt that the response verse of “What’s my thing… what’s my thing tell me now” is a like a desperate cry from someone who can’t find or has lost the ability to feel passion for the thing they used to love to do. Also the “Film it now… film it now” verse hits hard because it’s like a plea to take a picture of this moment because if I lose these passionate feelings for what I love doing right now perhaps I will have something that will remind me of them in the future and find a way to get those feelings back.
I like how you guys reacted to Kpop for the first time and didn’t think at all that it would go this far. 😂
I think it’s a perfect example on why you should keep an open mind when it comes to new things!
So now you know why fans love them so much. They are not the usual boy band. Fans fall for music and messages in the lyrics. The facts that they are good looking, good dancers, great songwriter producers are secondary. They are a package that comes only once in an era.
2:45 You so right "it a love song to music"
I’m glad we got that right!
A love song to music! Yes!
Black Swan and Blood, Sweat & Tears, listen to these every day.
In BTS "universe" there's a theory that might be helpful for this types of songs and it says that each member represents an archetype or a though.
- Jin is the real human (body and soul)
- Jungkook represents the persona ( the one we show)
- V is the shadow (the one we hide or tend to stigmatize)
- jimin represents a transition or change which always implies a decision that can be surrounded by our conscience (Jhope) and our subconscious (Suga) in other to achieve some of dreams or ambitions ( RM)
I don't think it's a coincidence that the chorus is a conversation between jungkook and jimin, then jimin and V and finally Jin to jimin and the verses tends to be a confrontation between Suga and RM and then Jhope with Suga ( when the song becomes more hopeful)
Wow! Thanks for this. Ive never heard of this take before. And feels like it checks out. I'm gonna have to listen again while taking this in. One of my fave BTS songs gets better everyday.
Can't wait for you to watch Persona, Shadow & Ego (all fall in line with this theme) --there's so much!! :)
The live performance of this song in ON:E concert with Jimin solo dance is breath taking. The performance for 2020 MMA is another one for you to check out too as they use Black Swan as the opening song.
Two intellectual men reacting to BTS is just chef’s kiss! Thank you for being an awesome reactors! 💜💜💜
It's their fear of loosing their ability to create music but it's also about accepting their shadows, working through this fear and finding new meaning with acceptance of their shadows.I recommend you start looking into their beginning. Bts has always written music with meaning. Also they always work with the same team from the beginning.
I feel the music BTS is sharing is impactful in at least 2 major ways: 1) Being in Korean it makes people want to understand it, so they read the lyrics often searching up culturally what it means, in doing so it causes reflection upon ones own self and how it relates, and talk about it which encourages discourse. 2) This in turn encourages the state of "Woke". I feel BTS is helping to bring everyone back to self, globally. This is a feat. I feel this is profound. Their music after all is largely impacted by Carl Jung. Bravo.
"A dancer dies twice, once when they stop dancing, and this first death is more painful" this echoes the theme of the song
No it’s not ARMY in this MV - it’s like a puppet’s cut strings.
So, today we have Ziah Usher and Justin Shizi Timberlake. 😄👍
👏👏👏 Good interpretation, guys.. Yes. This song is about what if we loose our passion. In BTS case of course it's all about music.
Black Swan is one of my top-tier of BTS's tracks. But actually, this album, called Map of The Soul: 7, is a masterpiece. Please listen to Louder Than Bombs. I can find no words to describe Louder Than Bombs. Speechless.. It gives me an unexistence heartbreak, pain, and sorrow.
Lmao Ziah Usher and Justin Shizi Timberlake has me so dead 💀 😂
@Moesha Bradford SAME, and we've never seen them do it live :(
Yes Louder than bombs is so underrated !!! it's a masterpiece.
They did a wonderful performance of this song on the James Corden show.
It's a must watch! I can't forget the first time I saw it.. it's a small stage but the character of the set is fitting and their performance felt monumental. It's just brilliant!
Not even going to lie. Every time I watch a reaction Channel starting to react to BTS I level my judgment on this reaction. Black Swan is one of BTS's finest hours. If people don't or can't get that I usually give up and walk away. You guys passed the test.
lookin' schnazzy fellas!
thanks for sharing your reactions to BTS' Black Swan...it's among my personal favorites! it's also one of the songs that, although they were able to perform it live at James Corden's Late Late Show (pre-covid lockdown) and some award shows thereafter (socially distanced/aired online), they didn't get to perform it in concert due to the pandemic forcing the cancellation of their 2020 world tour. as you can see, Jimin's really able to showcase his background as a trained contemporary dancer, and as the Black Swan (reminiscent of the popular ballet production/movie Black Swan, where the character, Nina, also appears to dance herself to death), reinterpreted through BTS's music. in either case, BTS' rendition is a phenomenal work of art, imho, and it's fascinating to see your fresh analysis of/reaction to it.
Swan Lake is a ballet, but you were close. Fun fact: "Black Swan" is a term used for a specific life event. For an event to qualify as a Black Swan it must meet 3 criteria, 1. It must come as a shock or surprise of a negative nature. 2. It must be a life changing negative event, 3. Looking back on the event one realizes that it should have been predicted. Great reaction, stay well
Love for performing...that's the love they speak of.
Yes, yes, yes!!! 😘💜💜💜💜💜💜💜Also on another level it relates to the ballet Swan Lake. The white swan representing purity and innocence and the black swan evil or temptation. And in the ballet (usually) it is played by the same dancer, even though in reality it is two different people. Odile (black swan) is a vixen and manipulative and wears a "disguise or mask" to appear to be the white swan or Odette. So the themes of good and evil are central to the story. (Good does win but with huge sacrifice) I'll leave the rest up to your wonderful minds. And I explained it very loosely, you know how folklore can be. The symbolism of Jimin's solo dancing and indeed he is the one with the wings, makes him the swan. And in the movie Black Swan it is about your light and dark fighting within you.
You guys are so smart! This is a love song to music their passion. Every time I hear it I get reminded of Macklemore’s Glorious.
When you know who is who then you can ride the rabbit hole about their storyline through mv. Very inspiring!
Louder than bombs and Paradise is a must. Believe me!💜
I really do enjoy your reactions! I love that you not only look into the beat and film production but most importantly the lyrical content and meaning of the song! Since you mentioned J Cole BTS did a remake of his song Born Sinner to Born Singer. It’s beautiful. Hope you react to it someday. Thanks for your genuine reactions!
Ooh we will definitely have to check it out! Thank you for your support! 💜
@@ZiahTV Check out their live performance with eng lyrics of this song please! It is way more powerful! 🙏 Here is a link ua-cam.com/video/8cUQ3lF3_O8/v-deo.html
Can you check out the Carl Jung trilogy they did with Persona Shadow then Ego. they're 3 solo songs from different members songs
Most of BTS songs are symbolic but they aren't every necessarily about a relationship or being in love, they talk about mental health, family, friends , life in general. They leave things open to interpretation, a lot of the newer BTS music is about Carl Jung 5 Archetypes so LY, MOTS albums specifically. A lot of their music is about discovering yourself and not trying to feel pressure , learning to love and accept all parts of yourself; have a dream and try to achieve it, have a passion, it is okay to not be okay take a break work on your self and try to make the best out of bad situations.
FUNFACT:- The person solo dancing in the dark, is Jimin. Jimin was the top student of contemporary dance in the prestigious Busan High School of Arts :]
This song says, “The dancer dies twice. The first death is when the dancer stops dancing. And this death is much more painful,” the legendary contemporary dancer Martha Graham made its motif. Just as a dancer faces his first death when he quits dancing, it contains the fear of the moment when he will no longer be able to stand on the stage as an artist
i hope you get to read this comment, you were SUPER spot on the meaning of the song, only thing i noticed you got a little mixed up is that you believe that the shadow was their most happy side that they hide from the public, but the shadow actually represents all those aspects that would seem "negative" like sadness, depression, selfhate, greed, intrusive thoughts that scare us and that we feel would make us weaker if we show them to others, thats why we hide it, its the dark side basically -->its haunting. The other side we show to the public is called our PERSONA, thats the happiness we see, all the good stuff, it works like a mask. I'm saying all this because they are going to keep on this topic with a few other songs like [intro: persona, interlude: shadow or outro: EGO] its all about accepting your shadow, trying to work with it instead of repressing it inside you, trying to become a whole, your true self by acknowledging all the good and bad aspects of oneself, because even if we dont like our dark side, its still part of us and we have to learn how to live with it. Its a whole process and i hope you find it very interesting because i do 😄
U guys needa see Bts blood sweat and tears , y’all gonna have a time of yo life analyzing that masterpiece lol
I think the part "what's my thing what's my thang tell me now" is like not only the artist lost one's passion but so troubled that he or she forget the original mindset/motive for that thang. In Intro: Persona, the shadow asked whether RM has forgotten why he started making music and told him that in the beginning he was just happy that someone's listening to his music.
This song has helped me out of a depressive slump more than once.
jIMIN es excelencia perfección es Arte
It's like you're in BTS's brain. BTW, love how you guys work off of each other and are so respectful of each other. I am so enjoying this journey!
Well said Marie..!! 💜These guys are a fantastic team...they really know how to break down any MV/song in an enjoyable way..! So glad to have found them...keep up the great work guys..!!💜
Please react to BTS Blood Sweat and Tears too. Blood Sweat and Tears is more like the close "dark concept" sibling of Fake Love and Black Swan. The MV is iconic and it's full of symbolism.
it's so good that you guys got the message behind black swan on first try..... SO COOL
Jimin: “you are nice....keep going”😊
I really like how you take the analysis of this songs very seriously, as someone without any musical background it really helps me understand the music better! Thank you :)
ALMOST EVERYONE IS CONFUSED ABOUT THE MEANING OF THIS SONG. BUT YOU TWO CAN GET IT ALL SO EASY AND YOUR OPEN MIND CAN BE DELIVERED TO US! OMG, YOU WERE AMAZING GUYS. SO PROUD :''' THANK YOU
I love that you guys truly get it. BTS is passionate about their music and always take things a step deeper. I absolutely love everything you said - I don't skip through your talking segments. Please take as long as reactions as you want and please react to more BTS!
This is the first time I’ve seen someone analyze the song correctly right off the bat! Kudos to you guys! It’s a very deep song to analyze!
So glad I found your channel. Your in-depth talks about the videos is impressive. You should watch Black Swan Kinetic Manifesto video- the interpretive dance by the Martha Graham Dance Company is impressive
I’m glad you found us and are enjoying our content!
BTS rarely sings love songs that are only just love songs, there's always something more you can get from it.
I like how you really try to understand the message and are able to see beyond the typical love song - and for that I'm gonna sub! Lol.
You guys are so awesome - i love how you guys get the message so quickly from the lyrics -- your analysis is so on point --- thanks for reacting to the mv 👍
And thank you for the kind words!
it is indeed a love song, a love song dedicated for their passion and their fear of losing it... you guys are smart getting that on your first watch.. 👏
imagine, writing such deep words, right, but what can i say, they even wrote about the worlds saddest whale and pluto.. ☺
This is probably the best reaction I’ve ever seen for this video! Thank you guys so much for taking the time not just to listen and watch but to also try to understand the deeper facets of the song! Kudos to you!
This song, together with ON is released before they go to a new series of world tour.. but then again, COVID hits...
You guys are impressive with analysis !! wondering if you are ready for BLOOD SWEAT & TEARS... that one is REALLY DEEP 🥴 can’t wait for your next reaction...
BTW, your new lewwkkss are FINE! 😎😎
only found your reactions today but I'm really loving how deep you dig into what the videos/songs make you feel. It makes me go YES and reminds me of my first time experiencing certain songs. Really wonderful :')
they understood E V E R Y T H I N G💜 amazing job!
Wow! Just from the first few lines of the lyrics and you already picked up the meaning of the song! Your analyzing skills are on another level. You're really good! Applause to you!💜
His shadow crumbling
personally, I don't think it's a "what if I lose my passion" song but more of "what if I am already losing it". it kinda takes you through the whole journey of being scared of the numbness that comes with it, going deeper into this feeling but then finding your way out. And I really like what you said about it describing feeling depressed. They are obviously talking about love for music but this can apply to any kind of dark thoughts really
Also, shadow isn't really a true self. It's just one of the parts of the self that people are trying to hide
Check Out "Bookish Theories Explanation" video for meaning & understanding of "BLACK SWAN" 💜 {everything links} "Map Of The Soul " book by Murray Stein {Jung's theory} PERSONA - SHADOW - EGO 💥 Shadow: "You Are Me, I Am You" {acceptance} - your sub conscious 💥
RM participated in the song writing of this song and I think it is one of his finest work. He once said in an interview that he actually cried after writing the song. The emotions are so raw here and the MV is just mind blowing. I really love how you guys go deep into these lyrics. Good job!!
This song and ON are both from the albums Map of the soul :Persona and Map of the soul: 7 it was based on a book by Psychiatrist Carl Jung [ Jung's Map of the Soul] it gives the basic principles of Jung's psychology That each person has 3 main parts to them self's The Persona, The Shadow, and The Ego. The albums go in to each part
The director is Lumpens. He is a genius.
I love how yall dissect the music so well...and the videos could be like 30 minutes long but it doesn't feel like it.
I also like how you guys comment on what you understand from what you are seeing👌🏻
It's really hard to make a video not boring but guys's videos are never boring to me👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻💯💯💯💯
Thank you guys for the reaction💜💜
Another thought is that they are creative when in white, they have lost it or are struggling when in black.
You guys are really good...... Youll come to find out that alot of their "love songs" are either not love songs on the conventional sence or there is a double/hidden message within the song
This perticular song was inspired by a quote by a ballet dancer Martha Graham, "A DANCER DIES TWICE- once when they stop DANCING, and the first death is more painful"
You'll eventually be asked to check out the BTS storyline/universe which starts with the song,"I NEED U" i dont want to spoil the song,video or storyline for you. But i will let you know that RM or BTS (leader,a writer& a producer of the group) has said they used "GIRL" in the song because it sounds better then "FRIEND" lyrically & musically.
I want to thank You to take the time to know BTS, that's what ARMY wants, then, if You don't like them it's ok. We want them to be respected as artist, and not only see Their make up, hair color, Earrings ( this things are the Essence of K-POP). They're very valuable artist. Pourple You💜 BORAHAE!!!
Guys you should react to Outro:Tear live this is one of the Best song by rapline 🔥
love your comments and your earlier assumptions/theories are pretty much spot on. keep it up! look forward to your next BTS reaction! ;)
I love your analysis on BTS music and mostly on point most of the time
FIRE - BTS
NOT TODAY-BTS
I RECOMMENDED FOR WATCHING THEIR LIVE PERFORMANCE PLEASE GUYS!!
I love the jacket and floral print shirt!
hi! it's actually very interesting that you mentioned how people tend to lose their passion/dreams when they're in highschool or when they graduate, because that almost exactly what BTS' songs where about then they first debuted in 2013! (references: their first ever single "No More Dream" and "N.O.", I definitely recommend both of them, even if just to see how they've grown as artists)
also, seeing as you're really great at interpreting songs+MVs (like srl, wow), I recommend you check out the rap line' solo songs from their 2020 album "Map of the Soul: 7":
- "Intro: Persona" by RM
- "Interlude: Shadow" by SUGA
- "Outro: Ego" by J-HOPE
all three songs have MVs which were used as trailers for albums and are tied together by the concepts of Jungian psychology :)
anyway, I hope you'll have a great day!
Have you guys done BTS' Blood Sweat and Tears yet? I would really love to hear you guys' take on that one. Thanks for the great reactions!
ah, i love your reactions so much!! you guys are so good at getting messages and catching all the small details! there are so many reactors who just scream or completely ignore the lyrics in favor of listening to the audio. and although there are many ways to enjoy music, i just love how you guys enjoy the music but also pause to kinda gather your thoughts on what's going on too. and you're absolutely right, we don't mind the length of the video lmao. btw both of you are looking so fresh!! take care guys
Thank you so much! That made our day 💜
Amazing analysis! You guys go really deep into their lyrics and I look forward to more reactions!
Alas! Two reactors worth watching👍other reactors be like "let's react to this because they're popular worldwide".. but you two? Good job! You appreciate BTS lyricism?...
Best reactors to the best artists in the music industry !
Please check out BLOOD SWEAT AND TEARS, it's also a chef's kiss video...Thanks for ur reactions... 💜💜💜
Really love your reactions and breakdown guys. You got it. Good job!!
Thanks for reacting.
I love your guys reactions and analysis!!!
Could you please react to:
-Persona
-Interlude: Shadow
-Outro: Ego
I have read a lot of comments already and I am sure you have too, that already explained what persona, shadow, and ego is. So I won’t, but could you please react to these pretty close to each other? Each one of these songs are solo songs from each rapper and they describe each of these in their own way.
Do whatever you want though it is your channel.
Cool! So on point! This is totally about their fear, talking about their "Persona", the "Shadow" and the "Ego"... Maybe you can check out these coz they have songs with those titles. Cheers!💜
Also, I think they songs are based on their interpretation of the book “Demian” by Herman Hesse with especially with the shadow themes…
I love this kind of reaction that makes me notice the other sides of the subject that I have not noticed before. Your interpretation actually help me appreciate this song even further as I find another aspect I did not think about before. I like how you two bounce the idea off each other too. Great team and chemistry you have going on here.
p.s. this reaction is the one that seal the deal fir me to subscribe.
I love your reaction so much
YOU’RE BOTH SPOT ON!! Loving this breakdown 👏🏾
Guys your analyzing skills are amazing hats off to you
I recommend Persona next!!! It's a great rap song from RM. Do Persona, then Shadow, and finally Ego. It sums up our rapline really well, but also what the Jungian archetypes are!
I enjoy the way you guys analyze the video. You're pretty good with your theories.
Shiz is the doppleganger for the lead in Psyche.
I love love LOVE your reactions 😢 thank you for sharing your opinions :))
One thing about bts song you need to remember is most of their songs are not love songs. They don't make romantic songs. 90% of their songs are about topics that has nothing related to romance.
You guys nailed it! Genius👏🏻
Please react to Jimins black Swan solo behind the scenes for this music video. Its so good and can show you more of all the dancing he did for this video!!
Exactly what you said 👍🏼👏🏼💜
Amazing reaction! Looking forward to more!