Neil Oliver: Crusades! - Episode 42 season2

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 119

  • @wfbcwfbc7884
    @wfbcwfbc7884 День тому +45

    Neil Oliver national treasure

    • @stvbrsn
      @stvbrsn День тому +1

      But I’m not Scottish.
      Am I not allowed to treasure him?

    • @AnneLee-di6fv
      @AnneLee-di6fv 12 годин тому

      @@stvbrsn absolutely!

  • @jacquilayton2557
    @jacquilayton2557 День тому +55

    You forgot to mention that that the Muslims had already conquered Spain in 711, tried to force their way in the France, was beaten back by Charles Martell in 732, but it didn’t stop them raiding Europe’s coast for slaves and booty. The first crusade happened because the Pope sanctioned the use of force against the Muslims.

    • @normalisoverrated
      @normalisoverrated День тому

      Yes, which totally DWARFS ANYTHING the Whites did to the black Africans. So when they want to talk about reparations, how about we go right back. Not to mention, it was African MUSLIMS who captured the black Africans & sold them in the first place. How about we start to THANK the white Christians who sacrificed their LIVES to try to STOP slavery. A practice which is still done today in muslim nations as it is a fundamental part of islamic ideology.

    • @ruthcollins2841
      @ruthcollins2841 12 годин тому

      Urban II!

  • @StirlingLighthouse
    @StirlingLighthouse День тому +28

    Ah. Days of the Olde Code.
    It’s beginning to feel like we could use a revival.
    Thank you Neil 🙏
    I trust that you had a lovely Christmas.

  • @manofkent4472
    @manofkent4472 День тому +23

    to say that the crusaders 'invaded' the Holy lands equates to saying that D Day was an invasion of France.

    • @lunaridge4510
      @lunaridge4510 День тому +2

      And it was. While the western Europe is still an occupied territory, especially the defeated Germany. So unfortunate for them.

  • @Nelz-y9n
    @Nelz-y9n День тому +16

    “History is a set of lies that people have agreed upon” is a quote attributed to Napoleon Bonaparte

  • @Dickens76
    @Dickens76 День тому +8

    Massive fan of Neil. ❤️🇬🇧❤️

  • @jodifritz9456
    @jodifritz9456 День тому +3

    Thanks Neil ❤❤❤🎄🎄🎄🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿❄❄❄🙏🙏🙏

  • @poltorn4580
    @poltorn4580 День тому +15

    Hello from Oak Bay Vancouver island

    • @AnneLee-di6fv
      @AnneLee-di6fv День тому +5

      Greetings from Idaho, your neighbor to the south.

    • @mysticdr3amz170
      @mysticdr3amz170 День тому +2

      100 mile here😀

    • @michaeldean28
      @michaeldean28 23 години тому

      Oak Bay is beautiful!
      Cheers from Coquitlam

  • @karlsaxon2099
    @karlsaxon2099 День тому +2

    Thank you for that Neil. loved listening to it Richard The Lion heart is my twenty fourth great Grand Uncle. Thank You

    • @ruthcollins2841
      @ruthcollins2841 12 годин тому

      And what a farcical king he was. 1 out of 11 years on Crusades or in prison. Good job Eleanor of Acquitaine ran England instead of this failure!

  • @patrickdeckdoctorokeano9146
    @patrickdeckdoctorokeano9146 23 години тому +4

    By the time you have realized a deception, it already too late.

  • @rowlandreddick2664
    @rowlandreddick2664 День тому +5

    A moral conduct is needed to be taught to a peaceful global society

  • @HiKasandra
    @HiKasandra День тому +3

    Happy year-end Neil and the best to your family! Your videos are actually always objective despite the sensational title! 😅😅 Slightly ashamed that i didnt sign up for your patreon but guess am a bit wary about my money being tracked online, having grown up in an authoritarian country. All the best to you and happy 2025! 🎉🎉🎉 X

  • @christossaikechagias
    @christossaikechagias День тому +11

    Thank you sir

  • @dlemmo9006
    @dlemmo9006 День тому +11

    Loving your accent, goes so well with the Time Machime.....🎉❤

  • @betsyross2.065
    @betsyross2.065 День тому +11

    I'm late with my Merry Christmas 🎁

    • @AnneLee-di6fv
      @AnneLee-di6fv День тому +1

      It's the third day of Christmas, so you are not late!

    • @charlestaylor8566
      @charlestaylor8566 День тому +1

      Not really , there is 12 days of Xmas , Happy New Year 😊

  • @LindaHamilton-k1o
    @LindaHamilton-k1o День тому +7

    It is inspiring to watch your channel. Your videos are always filled with passion and energy. Keep up the good work!🏐🌱🔳

  • @amanitamuscaria7500
    @amanitamuscaria7500 День тому +8

    excellent

  • @dontdeletemeyoutube6689
    @dontdeletemeyoutube6689 День тому +15

    The first time Islam had defeated Christianity? What about the conquest of Spain and Portugal leading up to the battle at Tours under Charles Martel?

    • @CPLFoxbite
      @CPLFoxbite День тому +2

      Earlier video, I believe.

    • @luis1coelho
      @luis1coelho День тому

      Yeah, Portugal was born when with the english crusaders started gradually in the north forcing the islamic people go south, and the back to Africa.
      I'm Portuguese, I know the history of my country. For a short period of time, muslims conquered the Iberia Peninsula: Spain and Portugal.
      If it wasn't for the crusaders in general, today we would all living under sharia law... and talmudic satanic Judaism which am always supported and financed Islamic movements in order to destroy christianity: Catholicism, which built civilisation.

    • @seanleech8214
      @seanleech8214 12 годин тому +2

      Christians were always slow to respond . Remember the Mongols slaughtered their way through Europe until the Hungarians decided to take a stand. Christians always seem to be attacked by outside entities . The mid East and North African countries had majority Christian populations at one time before being overrun by Islam. Even today Christians in many countries are being persecuted and their plight ignored.

  • @williambyrnes7889
    @williambyrnes7889 День тому +2

    Nice job Neil

  • @KerryWoolley-d5l
    @KerryWoolley-d5l День тому +2

    The 1992 Rio earth summit explains all to the, " Cannon Fodder unfortunately that populates the earth ".

  • @charlestaylor8566
    @charlestaylor8566 День тому +4

    Crossing deep water with full armour is never a good idea !

  • @soniawillats4358
    @soniawillats4358 День тому

    Thanks Neil.. We ❤ your love of Truth... We'd love to pay the membership but live in Africa

  • @sherryfuzesy9030
    @sherryfuzesy9030 День тому +5

    Not much has changed in the region since 1193AD

  • @jacquilayton2557
    @jacquilayton2557 День тому +4

    If you really want to know about the crusades, read Raymond Ibrahim The Sword and the scimitar, or his recent book Defenders of the West.

  • @rowlandreddick2664
    @rowlandreddick2664 День тому +7

    Good example,,, American Civil War,,, it was not about slavery,,, control of commerce,,,

    • @fourshore502
      @fourshore502 День тому +1

      from what i understand it was the cessation. that they wanted to leave the union. that was unacceptable. which is a bit weird if you think about it. like "im breaking up with you" "like hell you are! this means war!"

    • @ralphregan1473
      @ralphregan1473 21 годину тому +1

      @@fourshore502 Lincoln’s notion of perpetual union, would nullify the American revolution; if secession was Unconstitutional, we should have remained under English rule.

  • @JonDoe50-ETA
    @JonDoe50-ETA День тому +6

    Why did richard the lionheart not eat sandwiches ? ..because they had saladin 😬😉

  • @JackieSlater_330G
    @JackieSlater_330G День тому

    How time flies

  • @johngarceau541
    @johngarceau541 День тому

    Minnesota, USA

  • @philiphumphrey1548
    @philiphumphrey1548 День тому +2

    One of the reasons the Crusades failed was the lack of support, indifference and sometimes outright treachery of the Byzantine emperors. It's probably why almost nobody came to rescue Constantinople in 1453.

  • @ShortbusMooner
    @ShortbusMooner День тому +1

    *grabs popcorn 🍿

  • @jamesgardner8048
    @jamesgardner8048 День тому

    A breath of fresh air in a world of falseness and misinformation.

  • @Hrossey
    @Hrossey День тому +8

    Deus Vult, Mr Neil ✝️😉🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
    *wake up sleeper, rise from the dead & Christ will shine upon you*

  • @williamgilchrist558
    @williamgilchrist558 День тому

    Harad al-Rashid is an interesting character within an intriguing situation, as is the 4th crusade which whilst never arriving in the holy land, nonetheless accomplished its goal.

    • @seanleech8214
      @seanleech8214 12 годин тому

      Maybe Neil could cover this as I know little of it,

  • @johnstewart3244
    @johnstewart3244 День тому +1

    Mel at Islamic origins has just been reading a 2 parter on an eye witness account of the fall of Jerusalem in 614ad!

  • @vernonfindlay1314
    @vernonfindlay1314 День тому

    Dr. Bill Warner, 1400 years why are we afraid is a good hour video.

  • @tantalisinglabrat
    @tantalisinglabrat День тому

    I was hoping for some reference to the current state of affairs in the middle east that in my opinion is amounting to crusade no 5.

  • @gerrystevens9041
    @gerrystevens9041 9 годин тому

    JUST A SUGGESTION NEIL; WHY NOT DO A PROGRAMME ABOUT THE GREAT SHIPS OF THE ROYAL NAVY? I'M THINKING DREADNOUGHT THE ARK ROYALS...WHAT HAPPENED TO THEM...?

  • @Edelweiss2075
    @Edelweiss2075 День тому +5

    Only Jesus saves from hell. The Lord Jesus Christ died for our sins, was buried and rose again the third day (1 Corinthians 15:1-4 KJV). We have redemption through the blood of Christ (Ephesians 1:7 KJV). Water baptism DOESN'T save us (1 Corinthians 1:17 KJV). We are saved by grace through faith, not our works (Ephesians 2:8-9 KJV).

  • @mariapalacios2195
    @mariapalacios2195 День тому +1

    🙌💥👌👍

  • @Godzilla-t1z
    @Godzilla-t1z День тому +2

    Happy Christmas to you sir 🎄
    🇮🇪

  • @aliceinwonderland7594
    @aliceinwonderland7594 День тому

    The siege of Zara on 10-24 November 1202) was the first major action of the Fourth Crusade and the first attack against a Catholic city by Catholic crusaders. The crusaders had an agreement with Venice for transport across the sea, but the price far exceeded what they were able to pay. Venice set the condition that the crusaders help them capture Zadar (or Zara), a constant battleground between Venice on one side and Croatia and Hungary on the other, whose king, Emeric, pledged himself to join the Crusade. Although some of the crusaders refused to take part in the siege, several prominent Crusaders, including Enguerrand III, Lord of Coucy, Simon de Montfort, 5th Earl of Leicester and Guy of Vaux-de-Cernay, among others, disagreed with the attacks on Zara and Constantinople, refused to take part in them and left the crusade.The attack on Zara, Dalmatians, began in November 1202 despite letters from Pope Innocent III forbidding such an action and threatening excommunication. Zadar fell on 24 November and the Venetians and the crusaders sacked the city. After wintering in Zadar, the Fourth Crusade continued its campaign, which led to the siege of Constantinople.

  • @jamesbodnarchuk3322
    @jamesbodnarchuk3322 День тому

    I’ll end up in limbo

  • @mhhuman3553
    @mhhuman3553 День тому

    ❤❤❤🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🕊️🕊️🕊️

  • @leetavares9482
    @leetavares9482 День тому

    ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

  • @iaincook5835
    @iaincook5835 День тому

    You started with History of Scotland, now you are in the thick of the History and Defence of Civilisation.

  • @raziel3726
    @raziel3726 День тому +1

    👍🏻👍🏽👍🇬🇧🇬🇧

  • @chriswhite-i4o
    @chriswhite-i4o День тому

    Is this true? Saladin and Richard??

  • @judithdabrow9843
    @judithdabrow9843 День тому +1

    In regards to God using the enemies of Christ to punish his own people, if one reads the bible, you see that occurring throughout

  • @DDFergy1
    @DDFergy1 7 годин тому

    I got to 5:23 and was appalled at the statement. "It was the first time East had defeated West."
    Guess you are talking from ignorance of history.

  • @What_did_u_say
    @What_did_u_say День тому +2

    The brutality of these stories are very disturbing. The history of mankind is that of unbridled savages. With all this death and destruction it’s hard to imagine how anyone survived. These wars have set the stage for mankind to bring about its own demise as war seems to be a way of life for all of humanity.

  • @dougieb777
    @dougieb777 11 годин тому

    Can you smell the next crusade? 2025! Is the year.

  • @FatherFractal
    @FatherFractal День тому +4

    How can islam know anything about jesus when there's a 600 hundred year gap

    • @andrewprettyquick2070
      @andrewprettyquick2070 День тому +1

      1,300

    • @mohmoony3918
      @mohmoony3918 День тому

      Rumours. 🤣

    • @ralphregan1473
      @ralphregan1473 21 годину тому

      Muslims me recognize Jesus being born of a virgin, and being a prophet.
      They also believe that Jesus will judge over all at the last judgement.
      From a Christian perspective, Islam is best recognized as a heresy.

  • @betsyross2.065
    @betsyross2.065 День тому +2

    I would love to see and hear,an interview with Dr. Steve Turley,it would be amazing and introduce Oliver to a wide audience.
    Best,
    From Boston,USA

  • @graciegolden2290
    @graciegolden2290 День тому

    I read some time ago that agents of the papacy initiated this religion some five hundred years ago. I wonder. Thank you, Neil. I always appreciate your posts. Oh my. "The leafy suburbs of hell". Don't think so. From Job, there has been the bad being at least as understood through the Bible. It's really strutting its stuff today.

  • @JackieSlater_330G
    @JackieSlater_330G День тому +1

    ua-cam.com/video/1no3FsPiLGU/v-deo.htmlsi=OlI9sUrFbMoJGGzd

  • @Pyjamarama11
    @Pyjamarama11 День тому

    Dozens and dozens of generations slaughtering each other in the name of their imaginary all-seeing sky-beings
    When in reality, it was just the powerful grabbing more power for themselves

    • @seanleech8214
      @seanleech8214 12 годин тому

      Only one side being attacked before saying enough is enough.

    • @Pyjamarama11
      @Pyjamarama11 17 хвилин тому

      @seanleech8214
      Christians have happily slaughtered other Christians for numerous reasons for millennia 🤣

  • @ThePhase-l2n
    @ThePhase-l2n День тому +1

    ua-cam.com/video/c7y2LRcf4kc/v-deo.html

  • @mohmoony3918
    @mohmoony3918 День тому

    A 1000 years later how many have and still are dying for this speck on the map? This is why I can never truly believe in any god. If there is one, then he’s just a mean little kid with a magnifying glass and we’re the ants 🐜.

  • @YouTuberenderingnotswearingAsa
    @YouTuberenderingnotswearingAsa День тому +1

    Peergal

  • @Alfred-m6f
    @Alfred-m6f День тому +1

    The Sufis claim to predate Islam. They also claim Mohammed was a Sufi. My understanding, from another reading of this history, is that Chivalry was learned by the Knights Templar, from Salidin. That they were amazed that when they were captured they were kept under house arrest, and otherwise treated as honored guests.

    • @playasurf1000
      @playasurf1000 День тому +1

      The templars were practising chivalry before anybody even knew of saladin

    • @seanleech8214
      @seanleech8214 12 годин тому

      @@playasurf1000 And banking with moneylending when they learned of it .

  • @williambyrnes7889
    @williambyrnes7889 День тому +3

    By the time these wars started true Christianity had come apostate. Constantine made sure of that when he ruled I believe about 325 ad.Jesus said after his return to the heavens “oppressive wolves will enter the flock {Christian Congregation} and seek glory for themselves. Jesus said Satan rules the world for now,ever since the Garden of Eden. Remember Satan offered Jesus all the kingdoms of the world if Jesus made an act of worship to him. Very soon Jesus will separate the sheep and goats during the “Great Tribulation “ under His father’s direction. {Jehovah}. The Bible say we have a wrestling with wick spirit forces in the heavens. Ephesians 6-12. War has been its biproduct. Agape

    • @ryanparker4996
      @ryanparker4996 День тому +4

      The wolves you speak of were not those who had the will to defend christendom from islam. The wolves you speak of are the ones who insist we can get along despite having 1400 years of history which says otherwise.

    • @williambyrnes7889
      @williambyrnes7889 День тому

      @@ryanparker4996Sorry,but I disagree my friend. Time will tell. Have a great day and health.

    • @ryanparker4996
      @ryanparker4996 День тому

      @@williambyrnes7889 the Golden Age of Islam was built not on the brilliance of Islamic people but on piracy. You will learn that soon enough.

  • @innominateelements1437
    @innominateelements1437 День тому +2

    I question all the "his-story" I've been taught. I know of the Tartarian Empire and the buildings they built world wide. Yet all these buildings appear in the "portraits" of all "his-story"

  • @ThePhase-l2n
    @ThePhase-l2n День тому

    ua-cam.com/video/M2EJChRdxL0/v-deo.html

    • @seanleech8214
      @seanleech8214 12 годин тому

      I know of these slave pirates as they raided Ireland also. Often they had a couple of english men on board who would be brutal. The shipping of slaves to America was conducted by Jewish owned fleets mostly English and Dutch.