'That s the stuff left out of your history books !'
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 лип 2022
- The above clips are excerpts from the lectures by Dr Roy Casagranda that shed light on two contrasting historical accounts of the conquering of the City of Jerusalem. The full lecture links are provided below. The purpose of the video is to encourage viewers to reflect on the exemplary and a humane leadership of the Muslim rulers thats deliberately ‘left out of the history books’. #reflekthistory.
Credit: The Austin School Prof. Roy Casagranda
Full link to the lectures below
Rise of Islam
• Rise of Islam - Roy Ca...
Profile of A Warrior
• Khalid ibn al-Walid, a...
That might be the single most moving, profoundly beautiful story I've ever heard. I'm almost crying. I've never been religious - I'm technically baptised Catholic but I'm English and... well, we aren't a religious bunch. But the sheer beauty of Umar ibn al-Khattib's character cut straight through to me. It took a man of Islam to show a man of Christianity just how low they had fallen in the holiest city in the world. Imagine thinking that you're bringing the religion of Abraham to its highest stage, retaking that city, and when you get there the Christians have massacred the Jews and turned the Holy Mount into a garbage dump... And yet that's the 'dark ages', apparently. Maybe for us Europeans...
Do watch his lecture on Saladin?
there is a reason why even after being out maned out guned out moneyed and in a state another army wont live through and still conqered all that they did
Assalamu aleikum ❤️
@@justworship0570 Assalamu aleikum☺☺
Wait till you find out about Salahuddin...
Blessing from God unto Umar Al-Khattab. Blessing from God unto Abu Ubaidah Al-Jarrah. Blessing from God unto Khalid Al-Walid.
Fun fact. Khalid b al-Walid said to his companions 'Lets convert to Islam before Muhammad takes our necks like hyenas in a cave.' 😁
@@davidzack8735 evidence?
@@eistudiesl7193 Sahih Bukhari good enough for you, bro? 😁
@@eistudiesl7193 you gonna lose some of your braincells lmao
(15, probably indian or american, liars while claiming to follow jesus christ. they are everywhere)
@@davidzack8735 no...
Do you have any idea how large sahih bukhari is?
Only about 13 kids in that Lecture hall but without a doubt, at least one heart was touched.
That's just sad. There should be MUCH MORE
most likely online lecture, now a days there are many professor that provide live stream of their class or recordings.
Islam is peaceful and it is the truth, i have proof inside my Channel,
Because it is obvious BS, read on your own, different materials and sourses, never watch one-man lection, it's same as watching UA-cam video, when somebody tells interpretations out of their head with information that can be seeked on it's own. Lazy people do that, only lazy people watch other people videos and lectures of one man, often that's how it happens.
@@sgorgardr227 u haven't given any proof against him. You've just shown that you have no proof so you resort to this
💠 The Orientalist De Lacy O'Leary says: " *History makes it clear, however, that the legend of fanatical Muslims sweeping through the world and forcing Islam at the point of the sword upon conquered races is one of the most fantastically absurd myths that historians have ever accepted* "
(Islam at the Crossroads, London, 1923, p. 8.)
The lands that suffered multiple attacks and consistently repelled them, would beg to differ. Those lands did not have their libraries burnt and history erased... they know what went down.
@@RVMTube which lands?
@@cuzimmoody6470 check Spain, Austria, big parts of Italy and Malta for starters.
(Andalusia was won over then taken back, Malta was a contested land by many throughout history)
But you can look at modern day footage of ISIS and Taliban, destroying persian and Buddhist history... it is on film. You can see at present, the horrible treatment of Hagia Sofia... archeologist are crying at present for the intentional neglect to stop.
The list goes on. Islam is a system of laws not a religion, it says this itself and the goal is world domination.
(When the book says so, when the explanations of the book says so, when the biggest scholars of the book and the law say so.... you better believe them.)
Only deceit or ignorance argues otherwise. If you doubt it, read the source materials.
@@RVMTube you are so gullible.
@@RVMTube spain?. Hmm.. and you bring isis in this?. You know what happen when christians get spain?. Dont you ever wonder why the jews in spain under islam fleed to muslim country when christians crusader come?. Go ask the jews historian about it if you dont believe what ever in favors with islam.
And btw is isis a country or a government?. Who create isis?. How many muslim country support them?. Who came and kill their families and make them hold grudge with the people who came and burn their country?. And why is that included in this medieval history?. Even the weapon they use are made from america. Who supply them?.
Speechless …. And this professor is a truth teller how I would love to be in his lecture…. He spoke to a nearly empty room with the same amount of passion like it was full ameen 🙏🏿
Of course, the caliph was a great man, but most of the Muslim invaders did destroy civilizations.
@@saumyamishra7216 not destroy. Conquer
@@ameen7538 Alexander conquered but didn't destroy civilization, unlike Muslim rulers. Killing in the name of religion is base of a Muslims even now.
I don't know what religion Roy Casagranda follows but this is my second time listening to this lecture and it falls so heavy upon me that one of the greatest Muslim leader was so humble was so human and it makes me cry looking at us Muslims right now. May Allah gives us hadayat. May we fight the evil and respect the innocent. May the Muslims in Jerusalem find peace in the bloody massacre. May the Muslims of Kashmir and India find relief from Hindu Hatred. May the victims of Burma gets the sympathy of their government. May the Uyghurs get the freedom they deserve. May the peoples of Iraq Iran Pakistan and other countries resolve the matters within their country so they can help Muslim world. May the middle eastern Arabs wake up to reality and swallow the arrogance they have because of the wealth they were given as a test.
Aameen
Aamiin
Allahouma ameen
Amin
Ameen
Learned more in 18 minutes and 8 seconds than I did through high school history
@@M.AZZAM8976 Don't be a nerd. He said he learned more in 18 minutes not the lesson lasted 18 minutes.
Islam is peaceful and it is the truth, i have proof inside my Channel,
You didn't spend enough time paying attention then lol
Funny because I am for certain that guy in the video is employed in an educational facility.
You really don’t need to hear this specific story to learn how the Europeans raped every country they had an interest in or came into contact with for any agenda imaginable.
On that note, the muslims in the ottoman times may have been more understanding towards christians and other minorities like jews, at least more than their fellow christians in some instances.
But the muslims have fallen from grace as well. Compared to Christianity and Judaism, Islam is quite young and therefore did not have as much time to be corrupted by our human nature. Which is why it might have seemed like the more human or well behaved side in medieval times. But in time we will have all abandoned our spirituality and fear of god. And not just in recent times!
Whenever a man loses his fear of god that will bring to him the idea that we ourselves are judge, jury and executioner in this world. From then on everything went into a spiral of drug abuse, money and clout chasing as well as chronic depression. (Edit: as you can imagine, all of those are catalysts for war and crime against other humans)
You just learned less. This is total leftwing pro-islamic propaganda. If Islam was benign then why is there so much sexism, strife and hatred in almost every Islamic country. Why would moslems want to leave if it was such a paradise
This lecture has moved me so much, that I want to research the religion. So, I decided tonight that I will visit a mosque and see what their religion is about and buy the Quran too just to read it and understand. btw I'm Catholic.
What did you find?
Please do tell, how was your research?
How did it go?
I’m crying
how did it go?
If any of you read about Umar Al-Khattab, he was one of the people who opposed Prophet Muhammad SAW preaching islam the most. His hatred beyond any of us here, until Allah SWT open his heart to accept islam and he turn to be the most fierce guardian for the Prophet SAW and his teachings. Everytime remembering his stories i always felt so much compassion that i teach myself never to judge or put hatred on anything in life because you will never know what to become of you if God's willing. Alhamdulillah😭
i think the only person back then that hated Rasulullah SAW much more than khalid was ikramah
Ikremah turned a Muslim actually, and prophet Mohammad forbidden every body to bad mouth ikremah’s father
Further more ikremah died fighting the romans in Syria under the islam army, and what beautiful sacrifice he gave to win the war (may god have peace upon him)
it's bnou Al-khattab, Radiya Allahu Anhu
@@kfa013 thats why i said 'hated'
Umar bin Al Khattab, Al Kattaab was his father, not his title, so it isnt correct to not put the bin (meaning son of)
Umar bin Al-Khattab's biography is one of the best I've ever read.
mashallah brother.its nice to see people studying about our old glorious ways.
mashallah brother.its nice to see people studying about our old glorious ways.
This is just what the muslims wanted, Tell the history in an honest manner.
Haq
R u a Christian?
Haqq🏴⚔️
No you don't want this, muslims always lie about history and I many Arabs don't even know that their ancestors ran huge slave trade networks with black and white slaves
@@saajiddaya2152 check my videos
So these narrations of history are being deliberately hidden to keep perpetuating a dark image of Islam. Unfortunately, even some, no. A lot of Muslims in this day and age are unaware of these beautiful and human stories in the history of Islam. This is my first time of coming across this Dr. Casagranda who went on with his lecture beautifully to an almost empty class and I say a big kudos to him. These truths need to come out more. Thank you.
Thoughts of holy sepulcher church demoted or deverisme? Thoughts on Christian persecutions by mad caliph ?
Their not deliberately hidden you just never cared enough to look it up. I'm not even Muslim and I new this story because I'm a history buff.
The dark image of Islam is perpetuated because you people don't care when your young men groom little girls, you think it's honorable to kill your daughter if she disgraces your family whatever that means. You think it's ok to kill Muslims who decide they don't want to be Muslims anymore. You go insane if someone draws a picture of your pedophile prophet. These and many more reasons are your peoples actions and they perpetuate this image because it's true!!! Fix yourself and fix your people!
Dark image read about islamic conquests of India then say beautiful history of Islam
We read this at primary schools
@@AsifSaifuddinAuvipy that's kinda scary... hey did they ever get around to paving that road or digging the well?
Pssssst little investment tip indoor plumbing it's gonna be big
Im a Christian and this is something that to me shows what straying from doctrine in its most extreme form looks like. Jesus said to love your enemy, to never repay evil for evil and that great leaders are servants to their people. I pray that ''Christians'' take the lords name in vain like this ever again.
i cry listening to this 😭😭 thank you dr roy ❤
thank you reflekt channel too ❤
me too I haven't cried for a while but this is really beautiful
I have tears too why is this so touching
the last time I cried was when I was 9 and I even faked it but THAT, didn't make me cry
I started to think that I developed a heart made of steel or something
Told exactly as I have heard it before . Well done Dr. Now let this video go viral .
@BlackCat86 In history books
Islam is peaceful and it is the truth, i have proof inside my Channel,
@@user-mz2gl7dc4b It is described among many other stories and teachings of the companions of the prophet Muhammad pbuh in Hayatus-sahaba
*Who explains to us why the Koran says Christians believe God has a biological son!*
To all Muslims! Son of God means NOT SON! What is called the son of God is the word of God = god himself! Which has nothing to do with a child (son)! Thus, the Son of God is incarnated as the human Jesus and the human Jesus is therefore referred to as a son, which does not mean a son!
Hebr 1,2 Hath in these last days spoken unto us by his Son, whom he hath appointed heir of all things, *by whom also he made the worlds;*
as everyone can see the term Son of God refers to the Word of God = god himself! For through that God created the worlds! *what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
finally, someone from the west telling the truth, as it happened. Bravo!!
Absolutely…
He is on the ottoman rises and vlad on Netflix as a historian
i love the way he give his lecture, almost feel like he was there witness the historical moments
Thank you for sharing. More people should listen to this.
Jazakallah khayr.. :)
@@reflektnow Alhamdulillah youre doing great work
Keep it up
However I have to say this why did you add music
Its forbidden as a Muslim to play music or listen to it
You couldve had a nasheed but itd be better if there was nothing
(Vocals are not a musical instrument specifically and thats the diff)
Dont put a quran recitation either as its not background anything
When Quran is recited nothing else can be done, especially others talking
I wouldve shared this if you hadnt put music
@@rsm8974 no it's not
Islam is peaceful and it is the truth, i have proof inside my Channel,
@@rsm8974 you seriously have to nit pick like this? Just be glad there's people like this willing to educate people
If you finish this video and don't get a lump in your throat or foggy eyes at any point, check your heart.
And yet you call yourself a warlord...
The lump in my throat comes from the lying Marxist professor that tries to place guilt on everything Western and whitewash the crimes of muslims. Propaganda of the worst kind. Rather expectable from a Marxist like him.
@@agoogleuser8945 I wonder what would you think of me then?
I actually got angry, angry and sad about how our muslim community became nowadays
We came, we saw, we conquered(?)
I have learned so much more about my faith. Thank you for posting, and what a speaker Dr Casagranda is.
We came, we saw, we developed.
Conquered? You mean massacred?
@@nerveinz6453 That would be the crusade.
@@nerveinz6453Proof of that in the first and second generation of muslims?
Both sides taken life, its war. But atleast the Islam has decency
About 20 people were in this lecture, 1.3K watched it here and only 82 liked this video in a world with 8.000.000.000 population.
These are from 2 different lectures by this professor. The original videos have views in millions.
Very right but problem is people like magic , fun , porn than religious history.
@@malikakajee4396 Actually, the real problem is people today want to do or have interest in thing they "like". Not everything needs to be liked to be studied, learned or practiced. You may not like working but you have to. You may not like studying but you have to. You may not like to be a decent person but you have to. So people who don't like religious history, they have to learn it no matter if they are religious or not because it is human history and billions of people practice various kinds of religions daily and you have to at least to some degree learn it enough to be respectful and decent so everyone can exist in harmony. Almost everyone is capable of malicious or evil, cruel actions and only their personal free will is holding them back from committing such acts and that free will must be strengthened by doing the shit you don't like and be stoic about it. So next time you want to do some bad stuff for fun, you hold out and resist.
@@boneybone8123 good analyse of today's human nature and psychology. Like it
Notice that the lecturer is Muslim, deliberately ignoring the fact that the Muslim warriors had just spilled out of Arabia in 633CE screaming 'Allah akbar!' and "We love death more than you love life' and laying waste to Palestine. That is why Sophronius decided to surrender Jerusalem to Omar rather than see it destroyed and plundered by the Muslim forces. 😁
And we still hearing about Islam spreading by the sword!?
Religions don't like competition.
Christians don't need to conquer Jerusalem because it had been under Romans. And Romans became Christians. And they became part of Byzantine christian. Stop telling lies as if Muslim invaders of christian lands went to these lands for a vacation. No one will believe you. From the records of Byzantines, Muslims invaded Byzantine Palestine. You were so cruel with Jews and Byzantines. You are fooling no one. Stop demonizing christians as muslims were the ones invading. Christians just got back their lands that you took from them. Most middle east were christians as well as the Iberian, North Africa, Ethiopia, Nubia, even Persia there were significant number of christians. You also invaded Zoroastrian Persians. Stop spreading your lies!
Yes, remember how Muhammad murdered Arabian Jews, christians? Your beloved Muhammad expelled them oit of their native land just like what you did when Israel was reestablished. And no one will buy the idea that Islam just casually goes there like tourists then inbitants greeted them and converted to Islam voluntarily. Lol You abduls are delusional. You are the real invaders of christian lands.
@@Warspite39 you can’t compare Constantinople to jerusalem , it was a different conquest,to understand it better one needs to study the relations between the Ottoman state and Byzantine, still it was only a fight between armies, again you can check the ottoman sultan Mehmet s speech to Christians after the conquest
@@mt2ran beautiful respond. He will look at your recommendation if he is sincere and not just emotional
The legacy of Omar ibn el Khatab is one of the most beautiful. To know that he was one of the biggest enemies and hated islam at the start, but became one of the greatest leaders of thr many leaders of Islam to spread the word of the one true God. I learnt many like this as a young child. When u learn in depth its beautiful and makes u understand the world as it is moves through time better, and humanity with all its trials and tribulations, its good and bad, and its strive for betterment.
It saddened me when i moved to the west to see none of this was taught in schools. Only thing u hear about islam is the media’s version and all the twisted narratives, but its only when one truly delves into it, abolishing any biases it holds that one sees smthg they were never told. I went to Catholic school,run by nuns in Egypt. I learnt more at that school then i ever did here, i used to go to the libraries to dive deeper into history. Another wonderful memory for me…a true geek at heart ☺️
Thank you for sharing.... I have tears in my eyes but are so grateful to learn the truth about our past whether bad or good.. ☝❤
This wasn't left out of my history books and i'll be sure to teach my classes about this too.
Well be sure to teach them all the points of view because this video is some ultra biased sht. If you teach this and only this to your students then you should be ashamed of doing a pretty bad work.
@@pr0digy76 Of course I'm gonna teach all sides. But that does include crusader brutality, wether you like that or not.
@@TheColombianSpartan yes then include muslim brutality too, wether you like that or not :)
@@TheColombianSpartan Kind of seeming defensive there. You did intend to teach them that the ancient world was horrifically brutal because _everyone_ sucked, right?
@@pr0digy76the what brutality didnt you watch the video??
We missed such leaders
the world is in desperate need for a leader with the qualities of Al-Calif Omar Ibn al Kattab
@@TheFranco49Nonsense! He's whitewashing the crimes of Muslims. The most aggressive conquerors the world has ever seen.
@@TheFranco49 insha Allah Mahdi will come and rule just as good or better than how Omar ruled
@@CompetitiveMinecraftLegacy There is no such person called Mahdi!
It's just a bogus story!
@@hasanyildiz9364 bogus story? A story is something that happened, this hasnt egen happened yet, what are you on about
This is heartbreaking. Islam truly is from our Creator.
SUBHANALLAH I'm amazed at this professor's pronunciation of arabic names
@@dani4157 you are right, another reason among all other reasons, why Islam is from our Creator.
you believe in the tooth fairy too?
@@bruhbruh2290 if you are atheist, then its more reasonable to believe in a tooth fairy than to believe 0+0=1
No it’s not 🤣
An amazing lecture, he tells it as though he was present at that time. Thank you for spreading the truth that is absent from the history books and so is absent from peoples minds today. Umar ibn Al-Khattab was a true leader in every sense of the word. Humility combined with an incredible strength. Commitment to his faith and spreading the message in a way it should be spread, with compassion for humans and with their best interest at the core. Imagine, how different today's world would be if the so called leaders had just an ounce of Umar's character and faith.
Lol, muslims be like this every now and then.
Idolizing men
@@drakusorz2007 Umm I beg to differ, it's not idolizing men, it's respecting and admiring a man for his characteristics.
I'm subscribing to support this channel. Barakallahufiik & may more people, Muslims or not, gain benefit from it.
Jazakallah Khayr :)
me too .
i feel obligated to share this resource with many people of differing views.. open and narrow alike.
knowledge liberates the gullible mind
That's the companion of the prophet (S.A.W) for you.😭
Its amazing bc we expect Umar (RA) to be this super strict person, but here just shows his religious tolerance. SUBHANALLAH that puts me to shame.
Goosebumps just goosebumps when I heard what the caliph did when he saw the garbage on the mount.
Wished this lecture just went on for eternity. Tears in my eyes. What have we made of the holy land today.
You hear this and believe all.
I hear this and recall Martel the Hammer who destroyed the loot and supply trains of the Muslim invaders of Europe and how they, in wrath, turned and left the area. I recall how in WWI Lawrence of Arabia was only able to get the Arabs to join his attacks by promising them looting rights. I recall the annual mounds of Hindu heads stacked in Northern India by the Muslim conquerors as a celebration of their victories over the Indian Hindus and Sikhs in Northern India. I recall the slaughter and elimination of Buddhists and Hindus across Asia as the Muslims passed through the areas - exterminating and destroying the Buddhist monasteries as they went. Region after region destroyed, depopulated and/or forced to convert while he portrays them as the perfectly peaceful people with humble leaders. Yeah that doesn't quite fit.
He's as biased and misleading as what we're told in other areas. BTW the Greek historians wrote of the Israelites invading Cyprus and prancing around festooned with the entrails of their defeated opposition and how this behavior disgusted and appalled the "civilized" ancient Greek. History is a fairly complex area.
We gave it back to its rightful owners.
@@levitatingpotato109 You mean a pimp cutting a deal with theives. It will go back to its rightful owners. Just a matter of time.
@@mbadi5735 the jews are the rightful owners of Jerusalem, God said so. Nice try loser.
@@levitatingpotato109 Thieves can never be rightful owners of anything they steal. They are also liars to have created lies against God by corrupting their holy scriptures.
Thank you so much for your unbiased lecture of true of history and thank you also for sharing it here, allowing us to benefit. Much respect from Australia. .
Truly amazing shows how humble and wise Muslims were back then
Bro Islam is pure and perfect muslims are not but the religion is the same
Fun fact. The early Muslims were fierce and ruthless warriors and would have plundered and destroyed Jerusalem as they were doing elsewhere. Sophronius knew this. He also knew that Omar wanted Jerusalem and the Temple Mount because of Muhammad's flight there on Buraq. That is why he insisted on surrendering to Omar and no one else. 😁
@D. Fun fact. After Muhammad's death in 632CE, the first caliph Abu Bakr spent an entire year subjugating the Arab tribes that revolted against Islam in a series of bloody battles known as the Ridda Wars. Then in 633CE Muslim warriors spilled out of Arabia screaming Allah akbar and 'We love death more than you love life!' wreaking devastation on Christian Syria and Palestine. 😁
@David Zack typical Christian that spews lies. Here's the true story that Christians and Muslim scholars have deemed correct regarding UMass conquest of Juresalam:
During the period of the Second Caliph Umar Ibn al-Khattab, the Muslim forces, under the command of Abu Ubaydah, lay siege to Jerusalem . The Patriarch of the city, Sophronius, stated that he would negotiate only with Caliph Umar and that nobody enters Jerusalem before Caliph Umar. On hearing this Caliph Umar informed that he was on his way.
Accompanied by a servant, Caliph Umar rode on camelback to Jerusalem though he could have been accompanied by an entourage that could have made the ground tremble under the hooves of horses. He did so to show simplicity and ensure that Allah alone deserves all the glories.
On reaching Jerusalem, it was the servant’s turn to ride the camel and as a mark of respect and to ensure that the people see Caliph Umar, he wanted the Caliph to ride the camel. However Caliph Umar refused and entered Jerusalem on foot while the servant rode the camel to the shock and surprise of everyone including Patriarch Sophronius. On reaching the place Caliph Umar continued the journey on foot carrying his shoes in hand under the astonished gaze of the people.
The Muslims who saw this spectacle recited the short prayers that refer to Allah’s absolute greatness and uniqueness. Caliph Umar walked to the army wearing modest threadbare clothes. The Christians who watched everything from the walls of Jerusalem were amazed at the strange simplicity, unable to believe that this simple man could be the leader of those well equipped armies.
Abu Ubaidah who could not contain himself on seeing this unprecedented show of humility rushed to Umar’s side saying” today you have performed a magnificent deed before the people, perhaps you might….? Umar slapped him on the chest and criticized him saying “I wish someone other than you, Abu Ubaydah, had said this. We were a humiliated people and Allah honored us with Islam. We were weak and He gave us strength”.
The Patriarch who saw the unfolding scenes with great admiration said to his people that nobody in the world would be able to stand up to masjidomarthese people and advisedthem to surrender to be saved. Negotiation took place and a famous treaty called 'Umariyya Covenant” was concluded .This treaty is still preserved in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem.
@David Zack The Christians requested that Jews, who were not there before the conquest, be forbidden to enter Jerusalem and Umar accepted. Yet on his part Umar offered members of all faiths safety in Jerusalem and protection for their beliefs and their holy places, forbidding them to be desecrated or destroyed.
After the treaty was signed the key to the city was formally handed over in 637 AC. The gates of Jerusalem were opened and Caliph Umar entered along a promenade that led him to the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. Caliph Umar was inside and the Patriarch said to him “pray”. However Caliph Umar declined, fearing it might establish a precedent that would threaten the church's continued use as a Christian house of worship. Instead he prayed in an area to the south of the church, now the site of the Mosque of Umar in Jerusalem.
In doing so Caliph Umar showed the world the meaning of tolerance and generosity in victory and strength. It was the greatness of Islam that shone in his spirit and was reflected in his ethics though he was a person known for his firmness and courage.
Caliph Umar then asked to be taken to the site of Masjid Al Aqsa.He could not find, but patriarch showed him the way.
On arrival, accompanied by hundreds of Muslims, he found the area covered in dust and debris. He rolled up his sleeves and began sweeping and clearing the mosque immediately. On seeing this other Muslims including army generals and soldiers joined him in cleaning the place. Once cleaned up Caliph Umar took off his cloak, prayed and left there. It was the first prayer of Muslims in the Masjid Al Aqsa after the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh).
Caliph Umar immediately ordered the restoration of the mosque. A huge timber mosque, Masjid Al Marwani, with a capacity to accommodate 3000 worshippers was erected on this site at the southernmost wall of the Noble Sanctuary. They then started praying in this holy place. This was the most peaceful manner Jerusalem was conquered and great status of this mosque was restored after the affront committed by the Christians.
Under Caliph Umar’s generosity those who wanted to leave were allowed to do so with all their possessions while others who opted to stay were guaranteed protection for their lives, property and places of worship. Later Caliph Umar reversed the four hundred year Christian ban on Jews, allowed them to return to Jerusalem and granted Christians free use of their holy sites .Thus he turned Jerusalem into a city where Jews, Christians, and Muslims lived in tolerance, peace and harmony.
This opened the doors to the Jews who were denied access to Jerusalem. Throughout the Muslim rule of Jerusalem,from 637 to 1917 except for two relatively short periods, Jerusalem maintained its rightful title of 'The Holy City'.
Under Muslim rule there were no massacres, no burning and looting and no desecration of holy places unlike being committed now by the
Kinda great to see the man explaining so passionately despite the small number of audience
And those two English fans have the audacity to wear crusaders cosplay to watch World Cup in Qatar.
Because they never heard the real
History of the Middle East.
Allah-hu-Akbar! 2 things:
1. Being a Muslim, I had heard this episode of Hazrat Umar's R.A. life from many muslim scholars. However, i was never moved as much as i did today after listening to Prof. Casagranda. Wish i had this kinda history teachers at my school.
2. Im proud and sorry!
Proud of this religion Islam and our leaders who were the true followers of Islam. Just imagine, if this is the life of his companion, what would be the case with Prophet Muhammad himself (peace be upon him).
Sorry to my fellow humans that i am not following Islam the way it was supposed to be followed!
Even after Umar ibn Khattab (r.a.) conquered almost whole middle east and other lands, he used to use brick as his pillow, he had a salary like very normal man never took advantage from national treasure.
Today we are literally being robbed by leaders in the name of their security
World leaders should learn from him
When Caliph Omar bin khattab pray side by side with the Arc Bishop.... My tears flowing through my eyes. And when Caliph Omar bin Khattab said to a Jews that Converted to Islam to find 80 families to establish new jewish population, my tears dropped for the second time..... May Allah always bring peace to humankind
Praises be to Allah swt who gave me and my family the gift of Islam , great lecture as always,،👍👍👍👍👍
what a great speaker..
his words painted a picture in my mind and humbled my heart.
i wish knowledge and peace upon everyone 💙🕊🌍
Nonsense! He's lying! His ideologicxal filters are his motives. You can tell by how he slipped in the "What are these guys Marxists?" statement. Marxists like him invented propaganda. The National Socialists just copied Marxists.
Amazing story, that's what the real Islam preaches
Islam is peaceful and it is the truth, i have proof inside my Channel,
Actually no. But you're clearly not ready for this conversation
@@greyngreyer5 🤓
@@OpenPayment Oh look that thing people with nut-sized brains allude to. Good job. Seen a lot of you. Couldn't tie their shoelaces without their momma.
@@greyngreyer5 🤓
May God bless this man for speaking the truth.
Amin
Wow this moved my heart. Thanks for posting this🙏🏾💯
This needs to be on mainstream media, not the hateful narrative we're constantly exposed to.
Correct, we need more unity, this is just healing to watch. It gives you hope.
Amazing! Looks like I have to research more history!
Does this Dr knows how many people are watching him on youtube? he needs to know he's appreciated!
Makes you tear up when hearing someone being truly Human.
One of the best clips ever. One of the most eye-opening clips I have ever seen. VERY big thanks to the channel 🙏🙏
Btw I come from Indonesia, currently the biggest Muslim country on earth. And NO Muslim army EVER conquered Indonesia. Islam came here through traders and Sufis (Muslim mystics/ascetics).
Check your history again, some parts of Indonesia were conquered
@@gamenigeria By who? Which part?
@@pakeka6175 the Hindu empire Majapahit in Java fell to the Islamised Demak Sultanate. In 1527, the Muslim ruler renamed the newly conquered Sunda Kelapa as Jayakarta which was eventually contracted to Jakarta.
The spread of islam wasn't some peaceful event , it had it violent moments.
@@gamenigeria Where you get your historical knowledge from? Missionaries?? Your description is NOT fully correct.
The fact that Islam came to Indonesia largely peaceful is an ESTABLISHED HISTORICAL FACT.
Why, you want to create FICTIONAL stories here ??
@@pakeka6175Seems you havent done any research at all. Please research the hindu empire of majapahit in java and how it was islamised. The adopted of islam in was not 100 percent a peaceful process, majority of Indonesia may have been peaceful but not the empire of majapahit
Amazing video and amazing lecture. Thank you brother for making this and spreading this. May Allah give the Christian universities more professors like these.
one thing I noticed, when the crusaders took jerusalem, there were christians and jews, there were church and sinagoge. but when the christians surrender to muslim, there were no jews, no muslims.
Guess what Salahadin did when he reconquered Jerusalem from the crusaders het let the Christian and crusader nobility and anyone who wanted to leave, leave. Now guess what Richard did when he recaptured Antioch, killed everyone inside even the Christians that opened the city gates to him (cause again they were the wrong kind of Christians) despite Salahadin army right outside the gates and having hostages. PS Salahadin spared the hostages.
Thank you for sharing this
Alhamdullillah for being Muslim 🥲❤️
*Who explains to us why the Koran says Christians believe God has a biological son!*
To all Muslims! Son of God means NOT SON! What is called the son of God is the word of God = god himself! Which has nothing to do with a child (son)! Thus, the Son of God is incarnated as the human Jesus and the human Jesus is therefore referred to as a son, which does not mean a son!
Hebr 1,2 Hath in these last days spoken unto us by his Son, whom he hath appointed heir of all things, *by whom also he made the worlds;*
as everyone can see the term Son of God refers to the Word of God = god himself! For through that God created the worlds! *what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
@Harald TV doesn’t make any sense g
John 1,1 -3 + 14 confirms the creator of all creation became human! = YHWH!
as everyone can see the term Son of God refers to the Word of God = god himself! For through that God created the worlds! *what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Exactly! the Koran writer didn't even know what Christians believe! The writer of the Koran didn't even know that God became man according to Christianity! The writer of the Koran did not even know the most important foundations of Christianity!
No... It's not crazy... It's the Truth and only the Truth... Thank you for this truthful and beautiful video. Let everybody know the true history they tried to sweep under the carpet and hide. Thank you again. Alhamdou Lillah.
Nonsense! He's spewing propaganda of the Marxist kind.
What an amazing story
Indeed it is.. subhnaAllah
@@reflektnow Congratulation on your distortions of the truth, Mr Taqiyya Man. 😁
@@davidzack8735 Shia do taqiyya not sunni
@@FirstLast-fr4mx dont worry about him
Hes a missionary who hates the truth
Watch
There was a point when *KHALID IBN WALID RA* wanted to take *30 Sahaba RA* to fight the Vanguard army of Yarmouk which was *60,000 of the other 800,000* heavily armoured romans
Abu Ubaydah RA convinced him to take 60 instead
Result: *Crushing Roman Defeat*
*5000* dead Romans*
*10 Shaheed Sahaba RA*
*25 Sahaba RA ran after the fleeing Romans*
*20 Sahaba RA managed to regroup with Khalid Ibn Walid RA to save 5 Sahaba RA taken prisoner*
@@davidzack8735 and you make more taqiya that the Muslim you accused doing taqiya
Maashallaah Brother Great video. May Allah SWT reward you fully inshallaah.
This is so Educational. Thank you Sir for you time and effort.
Can I translate this video and publish in on couple of channels for Serbian, Croatian, Bosnian and Montenegrian audience?
Please go ahead. Thank you
@@reflektnow
Here it is, if you have any friends that speak Croatian, Serbian, Bosnian or Montenegrian, , you can share it with them,
Barakallahu feek
ua-cam.com/video/gs4HXi4nEJU/v-deo.html
Truly amazing. That is true Islam.
I hope you also say that what the Crusaders did was not true Christianity.
@@firstaidsack true chrisitiantiy doesnt exist anymore
@@ximomar3020 It literaly does
@Ahmad Adnan Islam is built off of Christianity in the first place and newer doesn't equal better that's a weak argument
@Ahmad Adnan being untouched and unchanged doesnt mean its the true one. islam is a young religion in 6th century theres plenty religions older than it hinduism for one is the worlds oldest. out of lets say 3000 gods your one isnt the true one.
I'm not an emotional person by any means but the part about Omar and the bishop made me cry
Can you read about holy sepulcher church and devirisme and cry too ? Pretty please ? 🥺
Thank you for your honesty may Allah reward you for your message 🤲❤️
Honesty? You mean propaganda. The guy literally exposed himself when he threw in a pro-Marxist statement in there. Marxists are masters of propaganda. If you think that muslims differ from christians in their conquering practices, think again. The muslims were the most aggressive conquerors the world has ever seen, capturing the largest portions of land in the least amount of time. That's why the crusades started in the first place. As a response to muslim attacks. The muslims were systematically pillaging the southern parts of Italy, Greece, etc. He's lying big time. Distorting history like a good Marxist he is, trying to instil guilt in everything Western!
Its so sad that there were only 10 people attending.
This should go viral
If you are here, it means you are into history. If you are into history, you should know this will never go viral.
@@alamut6766 It will never go viral because the Muslim guy's delivery is so vague and sloppy it's as if he's telling a kid's bedtime story. 'And there was this Christian (jeering) who came out in his finery (boo, hiss) and there was our hero Omar (cheers) dressed in patched garments (bless)...' When the truth is that Khalid and Omar and other Muslim warriors had just laid waste to Christian Syria and Palestine terrorising the world with their savagery. 😁
Well he is telling the story like this so the westerners with the colonization mind like u can understand how ugly there history is 🙂
@@waltersparling8954 Fun fact. We are talking about the year 637CE, bro. When the Muslims had just spilled out of Arabia for the first time screaming 'Allah akbar and We love death more than you love life!' and laying waste to Palestine. 😁
@@davidzack8735 The guy isn't even a Muslim. Another thing is, it's clear that you've got no idea what your talking about considering the fact that you just claimed that Umar Ibn Al-Khattab supposedly laid waste to Palestine, not knowing that he never led any military campaign. He had never even participated in a single battle outside of the Arabian Peninsula. The only thing that Khalid Ibn Al-Waleed did was conquer, he was never in charge of the administration. That was Abu Ubayda Ibn Al-Jarrah, who was given the position of governing the Levant.
Another example of tolerance towards Jews by Muslims is when the Ottomans welcomed Jews fleeing Spain from the Spanish Inquisition. Hundreds of thousands of Jews were relocated in the Balkans and western Anatolia. Even to this day, there is a sephardic Jewish community in Istanbul who speak a language called Ladino which is a form of Spanish spoken by these Jewish people. Muslims never had intentions to kill Jewish people as they were a people of the book.
Of course they welcomed the Jews after annihilating the Christians someone had to actually work to feed the muslim aggressors.
@@dggmn2109 which Christians did they annihilate?
@@SlowLiterature The byzantine Greek Christians check the book The Decline of Medieval Hellenism in Asia Minor and the Process of Islamization from the Eleventh through the Fifteenth Century
@@dggmn2109 You're trying to argue a point here so I can't read the whole book on your behalf. I'm not sure what claim you're trying to make here.
@@SlowLiterature my friend is not rocket science Christians, Hindus etc became Muslims under the threat of death or to pay less tax.
This is an amazing part of history and I am glad it is being told. I live in Cambodia where Muslims here are called Cham. They are peaceful people and the women wear colorful head coverings and they do not practice genital mutilation. I have complete respect for them. So can you also lecture on when in history did Islam have a shift to the way many practice today (not like the calif you described)? I am interested to understand.
Sure, look up forced conversion of minorities in Pakistan 🥰 , look up holy sepulcher, look up devirisme 🥰🥰 it’s really beautiful and peaceful wish people could see it more
@@andryraed1635 Sepulcher was given to the muslims and is open for christian Prayer. Conversions in pakistan were small scale. Although Devisirme was larger scale the same things happened all over europe and africa - Christians forcefully converted natives and conscripted them. Your points prove nothing but the reality of huuman nature.
Top most reason would be to not know the language of their Holy scripture - Arabic
When you do not know precisely what's been revealed, it's easy for anyone to have their own comprehensions & in many cases divergent ideologies mixed in by some corrupt looking for power & fame
That's a complicated topic. As is demonstrated by religious extremists from the middle east, it arguably never changed. At the same time, not everyone was prone to violence and many would be content to just kind their business and go about their lives.
@Alamgir Siddiqui I'm glad to hear that :)
Everyone needs to watch this now more than ever before ❤
this story always gets me. whenever i listen to it, i cry.
such a great man, such a great religion. thank you for the video.
For those who don't know Caliph 'Umar bin Al-Khattab is a very very rich man. If he live today he certainly is a multi-millionaire. But he chose to live humble following the footstep of Prophet Muhammad who came from aristocrate family (Bani Hashim) which r basically rich, but chose to live a basic life. Not only that but Companions like 'Uthman bin Al-'Affan, 'Abdurrahman bin 'Auf, Zubair bin Al-'Awwam n many others were also multi-millionaires of the time but chose to live like the Prophet.
this is the most heart wrenching lecture i had ever listened to. Listening to the doctor made me more relieve getting to know the whole truth which it has been hidden away by politics itself
Literally brings tears in my eyes 😢
Everyone needs to hear this
You need to read about holy sepulcher, inter religious treatment of Christians in Islam throughout its existence and DEVIRISME
During the crusade era, muslims fought about 300 wars of conquest, Christians fought about a dozen defensive wars.
This bought tears to my eyes and made the hairs on my body stand on end. This is our legacy, our history. The justice and Imaan of our past. I saw how inadequate and how lacking my islam was. May Allah raise our imaan to these levels. True power is when you possess the ability to punish yet choose to show mercy.
Wow!! His story telling is just amazing, and Islam, what a beautiful religion.
_So it was the christian that spreaded by swords._ 💯
@@netaji-thebritishslayer4379 lol u mean the pagans that were slaughtering each other? And then the rulers invite the Muslims in to side with them? Happened all the time. Sikhs would side with hindusm. Or hindus would side with Muslims..
There has never been a such thing as India.. just a buch of waring states. And no the fantasy comic books like mahabharata dont count as history.
@Netaji-The British Slayer
Probably the best thing happened to India
There was like 9 crusades in total from the Christians. There were hundreds, thousands more invasions from Muslims into Christian lands. So you are wrong
Oskari Peurala lol get ur history right buddy. 😆
@@gordistador _Ok kid. It's like the spanish, the british, the portugese, the french and the dutch were not christians when they invaded other countries all over the world and killed millions of the local people._ 🤣😂🤣😂
To be fairm this stuff may not be 'common' knowledge and is not taught in high schools but it is not left out of modern history books. Contemporary history is extremally fair and balanced to all sides and is a far cry from the victorian historians of a hundred years ago.
I was brought to tears Because I know the beauty of Islam, Especially by the strict compliance to the authentic religion by Omar. Omar never played Politics. Unfortunately, Islaam has been misrepresented by the majority of media And by politicians worldwide. This is what brought tears to my eyes.
Speechless. I wish we had teachers like this guy and leaders like Omar Ibn Khattab RA.
How sad it is that people were getting up and walking out of this lecture.
Such a shame I would love to have had teachers like this in school etc. What a good teacher.
he is dishonest and a liar probably
@@snokehusk223 You wish.
@@mbadi5735 Considering what happened in past I am sure.
I would leave too if I heard selective history like that 🤣
@@andryraed1635 it’s a nice story and everything but as you said it is selective history and doesn’t account for the fact that Islam is the most violent religion of all time relative it’s influence and the amount of time it has been in existence. They are still graping and killing men women and children in western countries today, citing jihad.
Alhamdulillah for Islam. May God guide humanity.
I am not able to express what I feel... Reflekt Now. Thanks for uploading this video. May Almighty bless you...
Hats off to you Sir...
How beautifully you narrated the Episodes...!
My eyes are moist while listening to your lecture.
Omar bin Al Khattab..(رضي الله عنه) May the myraid Blessings of Almighty upon you and the soldier accompanying you in that humble battle.
The beauty of Islam, "We revere each and every Prophet of God irrespective of any ethnicity. Peace upon all of them. All the Prophets are the Pearls of the same String selected by the Almighty God."
And I know my Christian and Jew brothers aren't told this inevitable truth throughout their lives at any educational level.
Jesus was divine in the Bible not in the quran. Quran actively advocates for the spread of Islam through conquest. Please read a book and stop being biased
@@andryraed1635 yeah I agree, you should read the Qur'an lol, it will show you the truth
Subhanalla... Thank you for teaching the truth. 💯💯💯
#freepalestine
I'm a Muslim and haven't heard of this yet, I guess that's just western education. I knew muslims saved the Jewish faith of some sort but didn't know it was in such an amazing way.
But now they need to be wiped
Waw, how honorable was Omar, he treated Christians and jews as his brothers while the crusaders butchered everyone including other Christians, huge respect to him and Saladin for being honorable and mercifull to the Christians.
You say this about Omar when the Muslims had just spilled out of Arabia in 633CE screaming 'Allah akbar and We love death more than you love life!' and laying waste to Palestine. 😁
proud to be a Muslim alhamdulillah.. proud of my religion, my prophet (عليه أفضل الصلاة السلام) my culture, my heritage, my history, and our Khalifs (رضوان الله عليهم), this is the truth that they want to be forgotten, these are the facts they want to conceal, but they know and we know that this will never happen.. alhamdulillah.
sadly there still are people who are unaware of this.
Beautiful comment Lubna, MashaAllah 👍
its not the year 1000, its over dude
1 possitive fact in an ocean of oppression. Keep being proud, judgement day is coming
@@bruhbruh2290 even if it's the year 5000... I would still be proud! And I am not a dude 🤷🏻♀️
All the 4 rightfully guided caliphs had one outstanding virtue they were known with and Omar(r.a) was known to be the most just and fair!
Great video.
Another great story is Umar ibn Abdul Aziz (a later calif and a grandson of the calif mentioned here in the video) when the people of the city of Samarqand came complaining that the Muslim army conquered the city by surprise without offering islam or tribute before war.
Umar got angry and ordered the army to leave the conquered city. The people of Samarqand amazed by the view of the victorious army leaving the conquered city without any harm reopened the gates for them voluntarily.
Nice to see Geoff Bridges giving history lectures, he’s very good 👍🏻
The biggest Muslim country is Indonesia. What war took place there by the sword?
I am Indonesian and I lover reading history.
As far as I know, there were no religion war in Indonesia.
Some people refer to Demak (Islam) vs Majapahit (Hindu) but it was also a political war, not religion based issue. Demak Sultan was a descendant of Majapahit royalty. So he claimed the throne. Similar as British King claimed France's throne in old Europe during 100 years war.
Hindu people still exist after the conquest of Demak to (decaying) Majapahit kingdom. In the city of Kediri, the grand mosques were built with Hindu temple architecture (minus the statues and stone carvings) in respect of the Hindu community that existed at that time. They also did not use cows for Eid al-Adh (Qurban) and used buffalo instead, in respect to the Hindu community at that time. A tradition that still exist, even today although there is not much Hindu population in Kediri anymore.
Wow blown away
Thank you for sharing
I wonder if the crusaders were so brutal because they were descended from the Roman Empire who were themselves brutal and thus passed on that way of doing things to them.
Yes. They were corrupt, brutal, and saw themselves as superior to everything else.
The west is brutal.
It's a cultural thing. Romans are not Jews nor Christians (in faith) in the first place. They are pagans worshipper. Probably do blood sacrifice too. Thus the crucifixion and death is actually irrelavant, but the blood is the actual symbol in Catholics belief. They just didn't pass the memo to the layman.
Roman Empire were based, may there be a second one
Islam is peace
Umar was a relative and close associate and lived and bled with the prophet, ofcourse he got the fundamentals of islam well as were the other 3 of rashidin caliphs. there are many other stories of these caliphs which are very moving and portray the fundamentals of islam well. i so wish i could live at the time of the prophet!
I'm a moslem, i started sceptical hearing this gentlemen story toward Islam specially from the western people, then i started to cry how he deliver accademic the truth, he must have moslem reference books as as the sources. We as a moslem know these story by heart, he actually forgot to tell when crusaders cut the throat of the moslem, the head was reciting the quran.
To non moslem people, you guys need to stop hating moslem, you need to share the real truth about moslem to your family, neighbor, community. Dont listen to Fox News, CNN, BBC, all western media that have a black heart toward Islam.
Just imagine the character of prophet Mohammed (SAW) if Umar was his student!
Sadaqa Rasoolullah Sallallahu Alaihi wassallam
Ah yeah Jesus fanboy who traveled on Pegasus to Jerusalem ( great religious connection to Jerusalem 🤣 )
That's very nice to see people try to show that part of the history especially in Western and eu.
Just hope if you can add subtitles so people who can't speak English will can understand you.
Thank you.
What part of history? The part that whitewashes muslims as if they were saints and place guilt on anything Western as if they were devils? This guy a Marxist. You know what that means? Everything he spouts is filtered through his ideology. This is pure propaganda .
@@C_R_O_M________ First, I hate to play victim or such, but as u know Muslims have been treated and shown as terrorists and blood seeker for the last few decades, which make an unbalanced view of them, especially for people who don't know the history and judge everything with just feelings, so sometimes telling true hidden history (hidden especially from westerns) will help at least people to make there own research to find the truth at least from there own perspective which will lead the world to be a little bit more balanced.
and for his ideology, I think everyone filters his talk (somehow and at different levels) according to their beliefs and targets, so the point here is at least to open people's eyes to such hidden history as I mentioned so ordinary humans can have the chance for making their research not just guided with others.
I don’t know if you can read my answer. YT is playing ugly games in the free speech department.
@@C_R_O_M________ sorry if there's something i miss in your speech,i don't know your ideology so i replayed generally , but if you are talking about UA-cam algorithms that gives a biased recommendations sometimes i think you r right, but while i can't see the relation between it and between my first comment
@@mohamedelkasaby8414 No, I answered your second comment with a long comment but the answer got apparently deleted. Sorry, but I can't invest, time-wise, in an answer that faces the risk of getting wiped off by the PC crowd and their stupid censoring algorithms at YT. Some other time perhaps.
Jazaka Allahu khayran katiiran