에스파가 보컬도 진짜 짱짱하다는걸 아는 팬 입장에서 이번 활동에는 꼭 잇츠라이브 나가서 맘껏 실력을 보여주라고 계속 글을 달았었는데 드디어 ㄷㄷㄷㄷ 이번 원테이크 라이브 무대를 통해서 멋진 라이브를 보게돼서 너무나 감사하고 에스파 친구들 실력이야 말할 것도 없고 여유있게 부르는게 너무 보기 좋네요 👋👋
You really think these are actually "live"? I never believe anything is actually live anymore. It can so easily be a studio live with minimal editing to make it sound live but there is always still autotune in these.
@@enda19 there are still many real live signings . Just because a group or a person sounds very good doesn’t mean it has corrections. But I agree with you that some correct their voices and it is not totally live . Then it is up to you.
I don't liked overrated things, and here we have overrated vocals aespa. Is this what you call top tier? Strange how so called top tier sounds so normal in standard, they just sounds like so many others, no wonder they have to lipsync when performing with dance because they don't even capable to sounds stronger or better even when just standing. I think people just mistaken their better tones as better vocals, they have members with top tier tones but that doesn't mean they all have top tier vocals. Btw, karina should has less lines next time, her vocal tones are so nasal, it hurt my ears.
@@o.o4200 like nasality to a certain extent and Karina's didn't bother me at all, the others are better on vocals but Karina's rap technique is great, this song just isn't focused on that. I also think that when it comes to singing, others should sing more, but as Karina is the most popular, because this she sings a lot. and yes, compared to most kpop ggs, aespa is at the top of the list, they are not WOW but they are good yes, performing and the vocals are nice to hear, especially winter's voice, it invades your head and takes up space.
i never want to hear anyone say they can’t sing live again. this is a group where every member is a vocalist, but i didn’t expect anything less from a sm group
Do people think they don't sing live? I've watched a lot of thier live performances and they always sing. Maybe some of the really difficult lines they drop out but they sing 98% of every song I've watched.
Guys, this is ONE TAKE version, mean that something was recorded only once, and how cool is that aespa able to deliver it even praise by PD.. usually this one take version mainly by senior artist, the other idol/group just go with the band version but aespa, not just band but with one take..u know what it’s mean? Yeah their vocal is totally worth to be here 😊
I really hope SM would consider having a live band for aespa's upcoming concerts because it makes such a huge difference having a live band playing, also aespa's songs such like Black Mamba, ICONIC, I'll Make You Cry, Girls, Spicy etc... has a banger 💥beats so I really think it would be perfect with a live band ❤
@@wingofwinter888shut up you're under all the comments discrediting ningning and giselle you literally are so annoying ! they announced their fixed positions and giselle is main rapper and ningning is main vocal. don't stan aespa if you can't accept it.
After watching KIOF cover thristy and Nmixx cover Spicy, I think we should more apreciate Aespa vocal. Their voice are sooo good, their skill are no joke.
woah, I never expect to hear SPICY sound more spicy with the Live Band 😱 their vocal, their everything was so so so good. thanks æspa for giving us this comeback, fighting!! 🫶🏻
Same! I only notice it when they performed it on the music show, can you believe it? I always play the unreleased version like every time since they perform it in their concert, but I never noticed it tf.
I love Winter's vocal color so much 😩 how she can go from soft and sweet to strong and charismatic, + her vocal growls and high notes 😩 her voice is very versatile indeed
The best vocal group of 4th generation. They all have different vocal tones and colours and all of their voices complement each other so well, something that I have yet to see from other newer groups.
I’s actually so emotional right now! THIS it what aespa should get to do since their debut, being able to showcase their amazing talents and hard work. I’m so grateful that SM 3.0 has changed the way the company manage their activities and giving them more exposure.Kudos to the company and aespa for working so hard in this comeback! Hoping to see you again soon for the full album!!!!
@@wingofwinter888 You are funny. Coachella was the FIRST ever time they SUNG LIVE in front of live audiences (as u know they debuted in the middle of COVID). It is understandable that they got nervous and excited, which result in shaky voice. Winter was amazing. But don’t forget that Giselle hyped the crowd up with her higher pitched rap. Karina remained so stable throughout the performances. And Ningning nailed her low notes as well as her energy. You should be fair in your judgement and dont even think of discrediting the other members. Anyway, they should’ve sing live since their comeback to build up confidence and vocal abilities as a whole. So what if some of them may lack in vocal abilities in the beginning? Even lesserafim who used to be criticised for their unstable vocal performance for their debut song got lots of praise and appreciation for their courage to sing live. So if other groups can showcase their vocals since their debut, why can’t aespa? They are from SM. And did they look happy and energetic on stage when they were forced to lipsync? HELL NO! Can’t you see the way their stage presence has improved when they actually sing live? Anyways, I’m glad that aespa is finally able to do what they should have done and all the members deserve the praises and recognitions for their abilities. Period.
Ooh I'm glad someone else noticed and mentioned it too! So happy SM kept their word with the new system. Hopefully future comebacks will go just as well (also for other SM artists) 🥰
Agree like I know it hard to dance while singing but this live performance is just too good its such a waste wonderful performance if SM didn't put that in to their next concert like just 1 or 2 song is enough to shock the audience
there are many good vocalists in 4th gen but you dont see a group with all members consistent like in aespa. They literally have 4 vocalists atp 👏 and if you disagree argue with your mom
From the comeback this time, you can say none of these 4 girls left behind. They are averagely perfect, which makes the whole group stands out from the 4th gen gg so much.
I rewatched it rn, Natty was struggling a lot. She sounded weak and out of breath but for a non vocalist she did really well. Belle did good, but the song lacked that stronger more stable sound that Aespa has.
One thing about sm is that they don’t rely too much on auto tune hence why their artists sound the same as the recording when they sing live. They harmonize with each other and layer their own voices for their songs.
에스파는 4명 다 보컬에 힘이 있고 쫀쫀한? 느낌이라 확실히 들을때 안정감이 있더라구요. 이전 앨범까지는 잘 몰랐는데 이번엔 특히 라이브도 굉장히 안정적이고 노력 많이했다 싶어요. 다른그룹은 메인급 한두명만 돋보이고 그마저도 고음에서는 불안정하거나 가성을 섞어서 쓰는 경우가 많은데 확실히 sm이 보컬은 참 탄탄하다는 생각이..
It is really puzzling to see certain members of a group receive more praise despite others seeming more talented or better performing. is it some sort of underdog syndrome or would that boost your self-esteem?
@@undistortedmeansit’s really puzzling to see people on the internet put down others for giving a member praise. is it your own inferiority complex or do you dislike less popular members being praised?
I’m so happy the girls are getting so much love for their talents this comeback, people are being so nice in the comments which is so refreshing to see
If this doesn't prove they are one or the best female vocal group of their gen, I don't know what to tell you. The harmonies together, no shouting high parts, the synchronization between them..
@@spoiled.cheddar nmixx is so talented, full of all rounders too but their concept and discography isn’t allowing their talent to be showcased fully yet which i blame jype
The difference of this Live performance to other Its Live performances of other groups is, they are not trying to prove here that they can sing, Aespa just simply performing Live ❤
Aside from their impressive singing abilities, I sincerely admire how appreciative they are of the staff around them. They are humble and sweet. I love them for that!
![[#2024MAMA] aespa-Bored!+Spark+Dopamine+UP+Supernova(MAMA ver.)+Whiplash(MAMA ver.)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_LyRdiHwyFA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#2024MAMA] aespa-Bored!+Spark+Dopamine+UP+Supernova(MAMA ver.)+Whiplash(MAMA ver.)](/img/tr.png)
![[4K] Red Velvet - “Cosmic” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] K-POP live music show](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ycZ0sHLLEJA/mqdefault.jpg)
*💞에스파의 잇츠라이브💞*
00:00 Welcome aespa
01:26 Thirsty LIVE
05:50 Spicy LIVE
Thank u for having aespa♡♡♡
let them sing every tracks on the album next time!!!! 😭
aespa best performance of It's Live❤️👏
Hey it's live 😊thanks for inviting aespa mics it's on I love there live vocals and it's better with band!
Thanks for inviting Aespa we love it
The PD confirming this is 100% live and only took 1 take. Even he is amazed by aespa. 🎉
where??
@@ll2960don't ya see thumbnails
@@ll2960 - he confirmed through his instagram's story
where?
@@小谢-j2nthe cover of the vid (the thumbnail)
에스파가 보컬도 진짜 짱짱하다는걸 아는 팬 입장에서 이번 활동에는 꼭 잇츠라이브 나가서 맘껏 실력을 보여주라고 계속 글을 달았었는데 드디어 ㄷㄷㄷㄷ
이번 원테이크 라이브 무대를 통해서 멋진 라이브를 보게돼서 너무나 감사하고 에스파 친구들 실력이야 말할 것도 없고 여유있게 부르는게 너무 보기 좋네요 👋👋
긴장하지 않고 점점 무대를 즐기는 모습 너무 좋아요.에리 닝닝 여유있게 부르니 넘 좋네요
라이브 맞죠? 넘 듣기가 좋네요
겨울이랑 리나는 말모~~
몇번을 반복해서 듣는건지
에스파 ~~멤버들 건강 잘 챙기시길
코첼라알고리즘이 여기까지보여주네ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 참고로 해당영상은 PD가 인스타에서까지 인증한 원테이크 라이브임ㅋㅋㅋ
ㄹㅇㅋㅋ
에스파 영상 댓글에 안티 개많았는데 요즘엔 뉴진스 민희진땜에 시끄러워서 에스파 공사치러 못오나봄 ㅋㅋㅋ
@@열럽지들 쉴드 치는것도 인력 모자라서 에스파 못밟음 ㅅㄱ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
라이브 아니고 더블링임
@@bangeyy 화음을 더블링이라니 힙합아닙니다~
WHO'S HERE AGAIN TODAY??? LOVE AESPAAA'S VOCAL OMG SO TALENTED😭😭😭🤟💌💌💌
the fact that they are one of the few artists that successfully recorded this live in one take really make me a proud My
How do you know?
@@monnneeterr its writen in thumbnail + @ 0:10 10 mins one take or nothing, means they only do 1 take & its already perfect☺️
You really think these are actually "live"? I never believe anything is actually live anymore. It can so easily be a studio live with minimal editing to make it sound live but there is always still autotune in these.
@@enda19 its up to you then
@@enda19 there are still many real live signings . Just because a group or a person sounds very good doesn’t mean it has corrections. But I agree with you that some correct their voices and it is not totally live . Then it is up to you.
aespa singing live accompanied by a live band is the top tier slayage in kpop.
Trully top tier omg i still can't believe it
She needs a collaboration duet with a real band 🎉🎉
@@alawysyaiful3673 yaa setujuu bgt😢
I don't liked overrated things, and here we have overrated vocals aespa. Is this what you call top tier? Strange how so called top tier sounds so normal in standard, they just sounds like so many others, no wonder they have to lipsync when performing with dance because they don't even capable to sounds stronger or better even when just standing.
I think people just mistaken their better tones as better vocals, they have members with top tier tones but that doesn't mean they all have top tier vocals.
Btw, karina should has less lines next time, her vocal tones are so nasal, it hurt my ears.
@@o.o4200 like nasality to a certain extent and Karina's didn't bother me at all, the others are better on vocals but Karina's rap technique is great, this song just isn't focused on that. I also think that when it comes to singing, others should sing more, but as Karina is the most popular, because this she sings a lot. and yes, compared to most kpop ggs, aespa is at the top of the list, they are not WOW but they are good yes, performing and the vocals are nice to hear, especially winter's voice, it invades your head and takes up space.
they wanted to be on this program so badly im glad they finally got the chance to sing here WITH TWO SONGS
Now that's how idols should sing like.
얘들아 라이브 미쳤다ㅠㅜㅜ 밴드신운드라서 새롭게 들리고 라이브 음질도 좋아서 애들 라이브 더 디테일하게 들려서 더 좋았어!!!ㅠㅜㅜㅜ
진짜 4명다 음색 장난없다.. 잘들었습니다
i never want to hear anyone say they can’t sing live again. this is a group where every member is a vocalist, but i didn’t expect anything less from a sm group
They are finally allowed to enjoy singing live in Korea and joining lots of variety/youtube shows after LSM left. 👍😊
@@frittlethank god that punk left
@@frittle they were singing live when he was there
@@frittle wait has LSM left?!
@@kpophq5844 yep
코첼라듣다가 이거드니까 귀가 정화되노
no one else in 4th gen has done it's live in ONE TAKE... this is legendary
wait rly? i had no idea, i thought other artists did it in one take
@@jhavvv aespa being the first for group to do one take, it usually only happens on solo singer and ofc senior.
@@heyheyhey2041 got dreamcatcher but they are 3rd gen? if not mistaken?
@@irene_3999 ah thank you for correcting. Dreamcatcher debuted early 2017, i think 3rd gen?
@@Sarah-nk7tx oh i see, 2017 already 4th gen? Thank you
이번 활동으로 에스파 진짜 호감되었음 스파이시 노래 자체는 쏘쏘였는데 목소리 합이 좋고 잘부르니까 계속 듣게됨
저두요.
이번 노래로 진짜 진가 제대로 보여준듯해요😊😊
이번 노래가 제일 좋은 듯 여름에 맞기도 하고 다들 라이브 지리네 ㅋㅋ
립싱크같음
@@이우-n6h응 립싱크 아냐~
@@이우-n6h얼마나 음원이랑 똑같으면 립싱크랑 구분도 못할 정도냐
@@이우-n6h 이거 칭찬이지?ㅋㅋ
진짜 얘들이 팀원들 전체 보컬, 미모에 구멍도 없고 다 잘해서 좋다. 확실히 라이브라니까 안무 없이 서서하네.
winter giving me goosebumps, her vocals are so effortless
보컬 실력이 이렇게 뛰어난데 왜 아꼈을까 마음 반하게 할 정도로 감미롭고 맑은 음색 음악 전체의
탄탄한 화음도 완벽하고 모든 음악 장르를 소화할 수 있는 뛰어난 그룹이라 느껴짐
the whole thing was "10 OUT OF 10 HONESTLY !!"
한 명도 빠짐없이 진짜 본인 매력을 너무 잘 뽐내서 눈이 귀가 진차 바쁘다.. 너무 행복캄.. ㅠ
Aespa should take part in this kind of show they sing soo good
spicy makes so much sense as a rock song, that arrangement was awesome!! and their vocals are perfect as always
The Band members make the song Thirsty and Spicy to NEXT LEVEL
They should perform Thirsty with this style...
I love this version for both spicy and thirsty
@@abx4662 agree
@@pillipr8185 agree
That's y I back to kpop and stand them only
I really like when they perform live and get the title "One Take or nothing"😭 oomgggg this song sounds really cool to my ears ❤
The “thEy cAn’t siNg liVe” crowd have been real quiet these days. I love it!
Since Savage Encore they have been shut down
Do people think they don't sing live? I've watched a lot of thier live performances and they always sing. Maybe some of the really difficult lines they drop out but they sing 98% of every song I've watched.
i thought they became quiet after coachella
@@russellward4624 a lottttt, especially from Indonesia.. So many black mamba there..
@@ezaminem you call them black mamba? lmao i think it make sense
Guys, this is ONE TAKE version, mean that something was recorded only once, and how cool is that aespa able to deliver it even praise by PD.. usually this one take version mainly by senior artist, the other idol/group just go with the band version but aespa, not just band but with one take..u know what it’s mean? Yeah their vocal is totally worth to be here 😊
should be pinned
righhhht? they didn't put that ONE TAKE for nothing
@@taengoonim they put it
@@aezahra it means they put the "one take" for a reason😭
@@taengoonimTHEY PUT
I really hope SM would consider having a live band for aespa's upcoming concerts because it makes such a huge difference having a live band playing, also aespa's songs such like Black Mamba, ICONIC, I'll Make You Cry, Girls, Spicy etc... has a banger 💥beats so I really think it would be perfect with a live band ❤
That would be 100% perfect
yessss
Yeess !!!
Agree and more of their songs have eletric guitars
It applies to other groups too. The live drums especially
sm jyp yg가 괜히 근본있는게 아니야
기본적인 실력은 갖춰서 나오자나
01:18~04:32 aespa Thirsty
05:50~09:10 aespa Spicy
와 귀가 행복하다 진짜............. Thirsty 너무 좋아서 계속 들었는데 라이브가 더 좋네.. 이 노래는 듣고 있으면 뭔가 몽글몽글하고 마음에서 울컥하는게 올라옴 ㅠ 아 너무 좋다 에스파 최고 ㅠㅠ이것만 반복 재생해야지
I know right 🥺 thirsty hit different when using band..They should using band in their concert 😭😍
진짜 밴드버전 최고.....
@@yoonj8713 🥺🥺
애기들... 처음에 예에에에
와아아앙아ㅏ 거리는것도 너무 기여워 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
The PD said it was one take video. WOWWWW... Aespa member vocal ability is on the next level
The main rapper has such a beautiful voice, same as the main dancer. Aespa as always don't disappoint vocally.
aespa had no main rapper nor main dancer, who do u talking about?
But sometimes versatiles group
@@wingofwinter888shut up you're under all the comments discrediting ningning and giselle you literally are so annoying ! they announced their fixed positions and giselle is main rapper and ningning is main vocal. don't stan aespa if you can't accept it.
@@wingofwinter888 If they don't have a position then what's the meaning of their synk video they release before debut
@@wingofwinter888 they have lmao
After watching KIOF cover thristy and Nmixx cover Spicy, I think we should more apreciate Aespa vocal. Their voice are sooo good, their skill are no joke.
Exatamente
One take or nothing just proved how confident aespa with their live vocals ~ so proud of my girls
Their vocals were all stable even for the rap line. Never doubt an SM Artist indeed🤙💕
woah, I never expect to hear SPICY sound more spicy with the Live Band 😱
their vocal, their everything was so so so good.
thanks æspa for giving us this comeback, fighting!! 🫶🏻
Thirsty 이노래 진짜너무 좋음 뭔가 신비로운 느낌이 물씬 남 특히 밤에 들으면 너무 좋음
에스파 진짜 말하는 톤이 뭔가 다 침착한 느낌이여서 라디오같이 듣기도 너무좋음
ㅇㅈ...
That’s real VOCAL!!!
SM artist sound natural without forcing to change their voice unlike others company.
they all got natural autotune vocals, they don't need to add mechanical autotune 😍😌
잇츠라이브 피디도 인정한 라이브 가창력
그것도 원테이크로 ㅎㄷㄷ
Omg.. 😮❤
Giselle's voice is so versatile, she can be soft, airy, deep and sometimes husky like in the Illusion.
no one understands how much i love their adlibs, especially gigi's adlibs, in thirsty
I really love it tooooo
You are so wrong
Because I understand you too!
ME TOOOO I LOVE IT SO MUCH THE FIRST TIME I'VE HEARD IT
Same! I only notice it when they performed it on the music show, can you believe it? I always play the unreleased version like every time since they perform it in their concert, but I never noticed it tf.
same .. i really love it
I love Winter's vocal color so much 😩 how she can go from soft and sweet to strong and charismatic, + her vocal growls and high notes 😩 her voice is very versatile indeed
They've been slapping haters who say they can't sing live left and right 😌 aespa, my vocal queens 👑
진짜 짱스파❤❤❤ㅠㅠㅠ♥♥ 아이돌라이브는 음정떨어지는거 싫어서 안듣는데 처음 찾아보네 역시 짱스파
와 밴드버전 맛깔난다 도랏네......
아이들도 콘서트에서 밴드라이브 미쳤던데 에스파도 밴드라이브 콘서트 해도 잘어울리고 멋있을 듯 잘한다..ㅋㅋㅋ
떨스티 밴드편곡 미쳤다.... 진짜 너무 내취향❤
진짜 이음원 없나 하고 찾아보게 만드는 하
와 밴드사운드 미쳤음 원래도 좋은 노랜데 벅참이 추가되니까… 그냥 행복해요ㅠㅠ
A+ live performance+
The best vocal group of 4th generation. They all have different vocal tones and colours and all of their voices complement each other so well, something that I have yet to see from other newer groups.
Thirsty 라이브 미쳤네....음원보다 더 좋아ㅠㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅠ
ㄹㅇ
I’s actually so emotional right now! THIS it what aespa should get to do since their debut, being able to showcase their amazing talents and hard work. I’m so grateful that SM 3.0 has changed the way the company manage their activities and giving them more exposure.Kudos to the company and aespa for working so hard in this comeback! Hoping to see you again soon for the full album!!!!
@@wingofwinter888 You are funny. Coachella was the FIRST ever time they SUNG LIVE in front of live audiences (as u know they debuted in the middle of COVID). It is understandable that they got nervous and excited, which result in shaky voice. Winter was amazing. But don’t forget that Giselle hyped the crowd up with her higher pitched rap. Karina remained so stable throughout the performances. And Ningning nailed her low notes as well as her energy. You should be fair in your judgement and dont even think of discrediting the other members.
Anyway, they should’ve sing live since their comeback to build up confidence and vocal abilities as a whole. So what if some of them may lack in vocal abilities in the beginning? Even lesserafim who used to be criticised for their unstable vocal performance for their debut song got lots of praise and appreciation for their courage to sing live. So if other groups can showcase their vocals since their debut, why can’t aespa?
They are from SM. And did they look happy and energetic on stage when they were forced to lipsync? HELL NO! Can’t you see the way their stage presence has improved when they actually sing live? Anyways, I’m glad that aespa is finally able to do what they should have done and all the members deserve the praises and recognitions for their abilities. Period.
@@wingofwinter888 you are everywhere lmao just say you hate the three girls and go 💀
@@wingofwinter888i always see you everywhere lol. Always shading other members just to lift up your bias.
Ooh I'm glad someone else noticed and mentioned it too! So happy SM kept their word with the new system. Hopefully future comebacks will go just as well (also for other SM artists) 🥰
SM 2.0: “we’re following the right trajectory just like Blackp..”
SM 3.0: “FOH LSM.”
Please do invite them more they're so good 😩 Their vocals are so beautiful
에스파 사랑한다 어떤 시기와 질투를 받아도… 니들은 더 오를거야 이번 컴백 화이팅이요🥺❤️❤️❤️
NingNing and Winter sang with total confidence. They should use live band in their concerts
@♥bunny♡ yes🎉
I'm hoping they do this setup when they play in America. I'm seeing them in LA
Agree like I know it hard to dance while singing but this live performance is just too good its such a waste wonderful performance if SM didn't put that in to their next concert like just 1 or 2 song is enough to shock the audience
This.
@@SpencyP92 same, I’m going to the Miami concert! So excited
😭밴드 사운드랑 너무 잘 어울린다…축제같은 곳에서 이렇게 보컬만 보여줘도 좋을 것 같네요
진짜 미치겟다 ㄹㅇㅋㅋ
에스파 뽕 일주일째 차고있다 너무 행복 ㅜㅜ
라이브 목소리가 선명해서 듣기 너무 좋다..4명 다 음색이 너무 좋아
@@호에에엥 릇저씨 ㅋ
@@호에에엥 ㅋㅋ웃겨 잘 웃고 갑니다~
@@호에에엥 태연 : ???
이 영상에서 지젤 음색에 반함… 톤 자체가 너무 좋아서 랩할때도 좋은듯 지젤 음색이랑 이노래랑 찰떡
the fact that people were doubting their vocal skills when i think we can say they are one of the best vocal groups in 4th gen 우리 짱스파
more like the best in 4th gen not one of the best😂. THE BEST❤ take note.
Not only 4th generation but best among ggs
there are many good vocalists in 4th gen but you dont see a group with all members consistent like in aespa. They literally have 4 vocalists atp 👏
and if you disagree argue with your mom
From the comeback this time, you can say none of these 4 girls left behind. They are averagely perfect, which makes the whole group stands out from the 4th gen gg so much.
I mean like, in terms of vocal in sm, I'm already sure that AT LEAST the group would be able to sing their own song well
이런 분위기를 에스파가 불러주다니 너무 좋아 다들 음색이 미쳤네
닝닝 음색 정말 좋다..떨스티 들었을 때 좋아하는 파트 다 닝닝이었네ㅠㅠ무대 즐기는 듯한 여유 넘치는 제스춰들도 좋다 아 물론 에스파 음색 다 좋음ㅠ
Just realized how hard Thirsty is to sing after watching Kiss of Life’s cover.. They did well though
need a full version of kiof though, dang they ATE that
@@ryleraquepo2748for me kiof did it better
I rewatched it rn, Natty was struggling a lot. She sounded weak and out of breath but for a non vocalist she did really well. Belle did good, but the song lacked that stronger more stable sound that Aespa has.
라이브 이렇게 자연스럽고 편안하게 잘하는지 몰랐어요 ❤에스파 더더 빛나길
오오
@Jay9 누가 모르나요.. 어차피 앵콜 쌩라이브로 잘하는거 다 앎
@@jay9 후보정해도 이미 라이브 잘하는 거 알 사람은 알아서 뭐 ㅋㅋ
@Jay9 비추까지야~ 후보정 안하는 요즘 걸그룹 없을걸요?
이미 실력 입증되어서 ㄱㅊ음 에스파는
에스파는 진짜 라이브 여신들다!!!! 너무 잘 해 ㅠㅠ
Suka banget sama tone vocal mereka. Harmonisasinya mantep banget. Aespa emang juara dah.
This is what happens when REAL SINGERS come on the show, you get 10 minutes worth of pure talent 🙌🏻
If I am hearing it right, ning and win added more vibrato to the enjoy joy joy part. They were so feeling the song. That was so beautiful
Finally someone who also noticed it😂😂😂I just love that so much...
Wow thank u! So glad that some heard it!!!
닝닝이가 서서하는 무대인데도 제스처랑 표현력으로 참 세련되게 무대매너를 잘친다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ풀로 봤는데 심심하지않게 잘살림
ㅋㅋㅋ 표현력 너무 좋네요 콘서트 볼 맛날듯..
이 글 보고 다시 닝이 봤는데 진짜 라이브 맛깔나게 잘한다🎉
표정도 여유롭고 가사맞춰서 안무해주는것도 센스 쩌네
닝닝ㄹㅇ 비범함… 오마깟마이겨드랑이때부터 무언가 느낌이 왓음
닝이가 진짜 그런 거 전문이에요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
팬미팅이나 콘서트 보면 시선처리도 완벽쓰
에스파는 딱히 보컬 랩 담당 따로 없다고 느낄만큼 다들 잘하네 어쩜 이럼~? 진짜 쵝오임
For real!!
Giselles adlibs at the end of thirsty have me ascending😫
They’re so confident. Im so proud of these girls, they deserve more recognition
One thing about sm is that they don’t rely too much on auto tune hence why their artists sound the same as the recording when they sing live. They harmonize with each other and layer their own voices for their songs.
when they use it, it's more about stylistic choice.
Nct does it for 90% of their songs
@@ckizzat1632 as if 😂
@@y0ung5one Yeah, like The Great Escape by Girls Generation
다 보컬 아니어도 표준 이상은 해서 불안한 멤이 없당.... 라이브 넘나 잘하는것
순수 보컬라이브를 위한 무대라면
녹음되었던 MR제거 해줘야죠
노래 실력 다 아는데 딴죽을 걸고 있노 ㅋㅋ
@@hc.hms.327.c 힘내
@@hc.hms.327.c밴드가 바로 뒤에서 치고 있고 밴드 편곡인데 뭔 개솔이지
@@hc.hms.327.c그렇게남까시면기분좋으세여?;;
I couldn't count how many times did I watch this performance, this is perfection.
Giselle's adlibs in thirsty just sounds so heavenly 😩
ㄷ
ㄷ
ㄷㄷ
ㄷ
ㄷ
ㄷㄷ333333ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ
댄브 때 댄스 애드립도 헤븐리하지. 랩도 카리나가 다 하는데 얘는 뭘 듣고 이러는 거야. 두 곡 다해서 분랴 20초도 안 되는구만
thirsty is her song
@@clerith wdym it's her song ? 😅.. it's aespa's song , they sang together & everybody sang perfectly..
@@Ciceliacousta they meant is thirsty is such Giselle coded that's why....
We're so lucky, we get TWO songs from these magical ladies.
에스파는 4명 다 보컬에 힘이 있고 쫀쫀한? 느낌이라 확실히 들을때 안정감이 있더라구요. 이전 앨범까지는 잘 몰랐는데 이번엔 특히 라이브도 굉장히 안정적이고 노력 많이했다 싶어요. 다른그룹은 메인급 한두명만 돋보이고 그마저도 고음에서는 불안정하거나 가성을 섞어서 쓰는 경우가 많은데 확실히 sm이 보컬은 참 탄탄하다는 생각이..
Giselle has such a beautiful voice, she should get more chances to show it like in Thirsty, she's great in general but she truly shined in that song.
this and lucid dream are some of my favorite vocalist giselle moments 🖤🖤
you should listen to I'm Unhappy, Giselle has so many parts in that song, and yess, she slayyyy
It is really puzzling to see certain members of a group receive more praise despite others seeming more talented or better performing. is it some sort of underdog syndrome or would that boost your self-esteem?
@@undistortedmeansit’s really puzzling to see people on the internet put down others for giving a member praise. is it your own inferiority complex or do you dislike less popular members being praised?
스파이시 편곡 너무 좋네요 떨스티도 듣고 있으면 맘이 몽글몽글해지는 느낌! 훌륭한 편곡과 연주, 에스파의 멋진 라이브까지 잘 들었습니다😍
I’m so happy the girls are getting so much love for their talents this comeback, people are being so nice in the comments which is so refreshing to see
This comeback make us happy
Aespa really be showing us they are true vocal Queens of this gen!
Karina's Voice can pass as a Main Vocal in other groups. Girl on Fire. 😎
Giselle is literally a main rapper, but look how she's handling those adlibs in Thirsty! Her voice is so *versatile* yet so *beautiful*
She was phenomenal so proud of her!
Ikr, I'm also addicted by her heavenly-sound adlibs in Thirsty. It just soooooo good🥺
aespa never had fix position, what is main rapper even mean?
@@wingofwinter888 I see you everywhere here in comment section. Like never even acknowledging Giselle???
@@wingofwinter888You're giving racist... They announced the positions long ago and everytime they introduce themselves Giselle is main rapper.
If this doesn't prove they are one or the best female vocal group of their gen, I don't know what to tell you. The harmonies together, no shouting high parts, the synchronization between them..
One of the best, but not the best. There are still groups like Nmixx in which Lily alone could outsing aespa as a whole
@@spoiled.cheddarwell for individual Lily is better, but for harmonization? Aespa is much way better than NMIXX.
@@spoiled.cheddar outsing aespa as a whole?
@@spoiled.cheddar nmixx is so talented, full of all rounders too but their concept and discography isn’t allowing their talent to be showcased fully yet which i blame jype
@@spoiled.cheddar in your dream only
녹음인지 라이브인지 헷갈릴 정도의 뛰어난 보컬 실력! 앨범 초동 판매량 1위를 차지할 정도의 수준!
에스파와 뉴진스 팬이 되게 만들어준 방시혁씨께 감사를.
에스파 이번 컴백 멤버들 보컬 능력이 더더 성장한거같아요 닝닝이는 정말 아이돌 외국인 멤버 중에 탑이다... 다들 음색이 너무 달라서 더 좋은거같아요 thirsty 노래 진짜 좋다.. 웰컴 투 마이 월드도 좋은데 수록곡들이 다 좋아서 정규앨범도 기대돼요~
민니 : ?
@@Sohotwinter 꼭꼭 이런애들이 있어~ 민니도 음색 좋죠
중국에서 온 외국인 멤버가 한국인을 이긴다 중국인이 한국인보다 목소리가 좋고 좋다는 건 인정한다
@@Sohotwinter 이런 애들 진짜 존나 비호감임 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@나자타사완 얘는 걍 무시합시다 여러분
I'm obsessed with NING's vocal tone and Winter vocal color
same
Yass
I live for WinNing vocals⭐🦋
Yes, NING’s voice is very magnetic
NINGNING! 🔥❤🔥🔥
Winter's voice is so versatile that it also suits rock-type songs.
Agree
kinda fire 🔥
Especially her high notes
her chorus part on spicy with the band sounded soo good, elevated experience
Agree
Karina has a really calming voice when she speaks.
ONE TAKE and the girls literally ATE the live and it makes me shivering ALOT WAHHH SO PROUD OF MY GIRLS
수백번 들어도 밴드 라이브가 음원보다 좋음.
The difference of this Live performance to other Its Live performances of other groups is, they are not trying to prove here that they can sing, Aespa just simply performing Live ❤
내가 이걸 지금 봤다니ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 너무 좋다
Aside from their impressive singing abilities, I sincerely admire how appreciative they are of the staff around them. They are humble and sweet. I love them for that!
이번 타이틀 곡이 멤버들 각자 보컬 장점을 엄청 잘 살릴 수 있게 잘 나온 것 같음 .. 너무나 아름다운 만남이에요
Thirsty는 내가 에스파란 그룹에 진짜 관심을 갖게 한 노래..
그전엔 컨셉이 너무 진입장벽이었는데 이 노래가 너무 좋음..
방시혁씨..... 하이브론 에스파 못밟아옄ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
염소들이 누굴밟아 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 풀이나 뜯어먹으면 딱일듯
밟는다는 표현 자체가 진짜 찐따같다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
악마의 힘을 또 빌어도 힘듦
보정 떡칠해도 에스파는 절대 못밟음..ㅋㅋ
어도어도 못밟음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 애초에 하이브+어도어엔 실력파가없음
비쥬얼이 너무 뛰어나면 실력이 좀 부족할거란 선입견이 있는데 비쥬얼만큼이나 네명 실력 장난아니네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
SM이 진짜 보컬 탄탄한게 드러남
역시 믿고보는 스엠
어이가없네 카리나 랩 박자는 또 뭐냐 어이가없네 진짜 ㅋㅋ
@@ramyundiet 칭찬이야?
@@이동윤임 그런듯ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
라이브가 음원보다 좋아 에스파 현실세계로 와서 행복해
저거다 후보정한거임
@@ssss-gk4mc대 보정 시대 라지만 원판이 별로면 이정도 즐대 불가
@@ssss-gk4mc 음방앵콜 쌩라이브 보면 아무말도 못할텐데 ㅋㅋ...
@@hong_cha.앵콜무대잘하던데
@@ssss-gk4mc ㅈ문가 납셧구요
winter live singing is always my favorite 💕 that ticklish tone only she has it and it suits Thirsty so well.
frr she suits Thirsty so much