Tribal People React to KASHMIR For The First Time
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 тра 2024
- Tribal people reacting to Led Zeppelin's "Kashmir" Live Performance For The First Time
Tribal people's reaction, lyrical analysis to Kashmir (Live) Performed by Led Zeppelin in 1973
Our patreon: / trybals
Help us reach our goal: www.buymeacoffee.com/trybalse...
Request a reaction here (It's totally free) bit.ly/3kkEUvQ
Follow us on:
Facebook: / trybals-105923538317572
Instagram: / trybals_official
Twitter: / trybals1
Please note that this is a reaction video and contains commentary.
For the original video please click here:
• Led Zeppelin - Kashmir...
Trip To Thar Desert (VLOG):
• ROAD TRIP TO THAR DESE...
If you are the original copyright owner and would like this video to be taken down please reach out to me at trybalsofficial@gmail.com
All the participants in this video are from Sindh, Pakistan.
Make sure to leave a like and valuable suggestions and please support our channel by hitting that subscribe button. Thanks for watching
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.”
✔ Fair Use guidelines : www.copyright.gov/fair-use/mo...
✔ The content on this UA-cam Channel, 'TRYBALS', is transformative in nature, therefore falls under fair use. Because of this, we ask that you DO NOT strike or claim my content.
#TribalPeopleReact #ledzeppelin #kashmir
Not a word they hear can they relate, but the story is quite clear.
All the gentlemen have it right, "Kashmir" is a metaphor for that distant and exotic place we all yearn to see, but are either incapable of, or perhaps even dread, traveling to.
THIS^
to a westerner, Kasmir is an exotic place we idolize in our minds, and yearn to see such a place.
we know the real place will be different, but its the Version of Kasmir we WISH we could see..
@@ripvanwinkle2002 Led Zeppelin's version of Kashmir is in the heart
want answers ..., listen to Van Der Graaf Generators album Still Life , the notion being despite the idea of motion and movement we're static and so on...., check out other tracks like ''my room '' ''magog in bromine chambers'' and if you like that listen to peter hammells solo album ''Fools Mate'' if you're already into van der graaf i apologise for sounding off like a crass twat. laters
So could it be considered like heaven?
@@jimmyjennings4089 Kasmir happens to be an exotic, but earthly, location. But, depending on an individual's priorities, why not.
I love how the elder gentleman called Bonham Ustad. Here's a person with such a different context for this music and in just a few minutes of exposure can see what we all know Bonham was a master at his craft.
Agreed. This truly makes me want to see his reaction to some of Bonham’s other work.
If he can tell that Bonham is a master at his craft based on a few minutes of one of Led Zeppelin’s lesser live shows, imagine his opinion if he heard Led Zeppelin in their prime.
Remember: this recording was taken in 1979 at the Knebworth shows. Led Zeppelin was still a force, but they were later in their career and past their peak.
They should listen to the version with the Egyptian orchestra
1. I am going to listen to that if it exists.
2. Yeah bruv. Ensembles and orchestras who meticulously and creatively play well known pop music are often awesome. Nu Dec Ensemble doing their daft punk suite "Humans vs. Robots" is maybe one of my actual favorite yutube vids of all time.
@py_a_thon I saw page and plant perform it in 94. With an 8 piece Egyptian band. Hopefully there is footage somewhere
@@fundymentalism That is exactly what I just watched. Very cool.
Just looked there's the unledded tape... which I own. Lol
@@fundymentalism I dunno if like dance music or EDM...yet for real: Nu Deco Ensemble - "Humans vs. Robots" is just immaculate and most excellent.
"None of the others had it."
Absolutely the truth, there will never be another like the mighty led zeppelin.
I think Mashoque and Muharam are rockers at heart. Rock on my friends. 🎸❤🇨🇦
In another life, Mashoque could have been your neighbor's cool older brother who turned you on to all the great music you hadn't heard before.
Yeah they really get into it. Fantastic trio - talking of which I would love to see them react to Rush particularly Xanadu from
Exit Stage Left. Ustad would be used an awful lot I suspect but also I think the meaning of the lyrics would really appeal to their wisdom
@@RichardMathews-gv7lb I literally left a comment asking for that Xanadu performance on a previous post. Think Rush would def blow their minds if they enjoyed this so much! Great minds!
❤❤❤
omg right?! I love them!!! The first video I saw was from Disturbed, and I immediately believed that Muharam is a hippie and because of these videos, he’s got a sweet vinyl collection.
The older gentleman calling Bonham an 'Ustad' is so spot on. Even he noticed the greatness of Bonham's drumming. Love these reactions!
I love it when Bonzo is tearing it up and the gentleman says "Hit it!" I said that same thing listening to this in 1975 when I was 16...
I bought Physical Graffiti in November of 1975. I was 15.
At that time I only knew of Trampled Underfoot and Kashmir.
Muharam Khan is the most emotional and passionate of them, he gets excited at every band. If he was born in the western world, he would be front row at many live gigs 🤘
I’m positive he’s a “closeted” hippie with a solid vinyl collection 😉
Sure he would
Or maybe even the lead singer 🤔
Robert Plant has said this is his favorite of all their songs. It's one of mine as well
I want to have the privilege of discussing it with him, too bad at the time I had no idea who I was speaking to LOL
he also said he is sick of singing it
I've read his favorite was either "In the Light" or "Gallows Pole" which are both far better examples of his talent as a singer.
Goes to show that in any language Zeppelin rocks hard.
Cheers to these Noble Gentlemen!
The song _Kashmir_ is based on the book _Lost Horizon_ by James Hilton (1933). The term "Shangri-La" included in the lyrics is your first clue.
This was the perfect Led Zeppelin song to play for these gentlemen...Most people like the song but don't understand it, but they understood it. They really felt the passion in Robert Plants voice and appreciated the musicians. Led Zeppelin is the greatest Rock band "Ever"...This was a great reaction!
Abdul hit the nail on the head: We are all travelers. Wise words from a wise man.
I think, that's like going far away to come home...In thoughts as well as in real life.
I was 16 years old when I discovered this song. It was 1995 and my friend Genna was a Led Zeppelin fan so she was playing their music when we hung out and I was immediately hooked. That was 28 years ago. This song has never left my playlist.
Same here....fist time I heard a Zeppelin song (Kashmir) around 1986 and I was 13.....song and band have been a huge part of my 51 year old life!
This is my ring tone lol! I'm 64 years old!
I was 14. Back in 1994. A friend from school gave me a ride home one day with his mom driving. I remember this song came on the radio and I've never heard anything like it in my life. When they told me it was Zeppelin, I didn't believe them for some reason.
Never forgot about this song. It's really in its own class.
69 years old and will be rocking Led Zeppelin until the end
I'm the same age as you and it was similar for me. I heard someone else at school playing music on their stereo (remember those radio/tape/CD players!) in between classes, I'd never heard the song before and I really liked it so I asked who it was and they said Led Zeppelin. I asked my mom's boyfriend about them because he had a huge record collection and of course he had all of their records and he found a way to put them on tape, so for a long time I had 3 cassette tapes of their first 3 albums. I played them in my car until I finally got a car with a CD player in it. When I got my MacBook and had iTunes for the 1st time, Led Zeppelin was some of the first music I downloaded. The format may change, but the song remains the same.
I’ve listened to this music for years and years and years. It means a great deal to me, but hearing how these gentlemen feel it themselves opens up a little gap in my own knowledge. It makes me see it fresh again. Worthy insights. ♥️
Introducing them to Zeppelin is the best thing you can do!!
" The real journey is this life and this light that we are in . Like this light has its life , even its journey has to end " ... enough said ^^
Muharam is a music lover and watching him react with such passion makes me feel so happy.
Me too! I can't help but smile like a maniac watching him.
Thank Goodness!! Zeppelin!!!!..The 70's kicked serious rear! Im 70 and I am sooo happy they get to listen to something like this. They have been "ROCKED"!!
I'm also 70 yrs old. Saw Robert and Allison Krauss perform last summer. It is incredible how he continues to reinvent himself! He says he doesn't have time to write a book, but I sure wish he would.😊
I'm here for some Muharam. Commenting before I even watch the whole thing because my boy is here
Yeah, he is always so kind! He and chacha Abdul give me back hope in humanity sometimes, examples to follow.
I both truly amazed at what the elders know-and how much they don’t. Truly one of my fav channels!
My father was listening to Led Zeppelin before I was born. I have so many fond memories with him attached to Led Zeppelin. ❤
💗Good People! Abdul Aziz Eyes shined really deeply. I love this man.
He's such a beautiful soul. I'd really love to meet him.
i love these people so much
Thats right lads John Bonham was the center of Led Zeppelin
I love how that's just universal. Everyone who has heard a Zeppelin song agrees there's no Zeppelin without Bonham. Massive bummer that he died so young.
It will be nice to now share with them the version in the Celebration day concert, when they are older, wiser, more mature in their skills, certainly Robert's voice
Completely agree!
he is right, Kashmir can be a state of mind . . and maybe it is? "I'm a traveler of both time and space To be where I have been .... my shangrila beneath the summer moon, I will return again"
this has always been my favourite song from led zeppelin, its what made me aware of kashmir. here in canada we do not learn much about india, pakistan or central asia at all, even though we were in wars there, many ppl have no idea other than what news tells them, and arent aware of history or the culture of the areas. im glad to have indian and pakistani coworkers here in canada, ive learned a lot about the region through talking with them with my limited knowledge. i am not trying to compare the two countries, you both are beautifully distinct places that i hope to visit one day.
my doctor is pakistani aswell, he is my favourite doctor ive had so far as he suggests lifestyle changes and diet changes before medicine, unless its necessary. so many doctors here will not give you the time of day and just try the quick and easy approach to dealing with you, which isnt the best approach. he doesnt hide that he uses his upbringing in pakistan to suggest inclusions to diet and lifestyle, as a young man i really appreciate his input, i can tell he truly cares about his patients.
This is pretty good put Kashmir page and plant with an Egyptian orchestra on the no quarter tour is another level ... But at the end of the day it's beautiful ✌️
This is my favorite Zeppelin song. I’m so glad you chose this one. You guys are all great and intuitive men with good hearts. You guys should go on tour to do live shows and come to Southern California. People would pay good money to see you do this live with live translations both ways. You should live translate the lyrics to them using software or AI. I’d love to meet you all. Additionally, you guys speak so fast, please try to slow down the subtitles
Love when you show all three men watching together.
Precious Gift. Thank you.
Thanks for listening
I like how these guys are getting into the existentials of this song.
Led Zeppelin Lyrics
"Kashmir"
Oh, let the sun beat down upon my face
With stars to fill my dreams
I am a traveler of both time and space
To be where I have been
Sit with elders of the gentle race
This world has seldom seen
Talk of days for which they sit and wait
All will be revealed
Talk and song from tongues of lilting grace
Whose sounds caress my ear
But not a word I heard could I relate
The story was quite clear
Oh, oh
Oh, oh
Ooh, baby, I been flying
No yeah, mama, there ain't no denying
Oh, ooh, yeah I've been flying
Mama, mama, ain't no denying, no denying
Oh, all I see turns to brown
As the sun burns the ground
And my eyes fill with sand
As I scan this wasted land
Trying to find, trying to find, where I've been
Oh, pilot of the storm who leaves no trace
Like thoughts inside a dream
Here is the path that led me to that place
Yellow desert stream
My Shangri-La beneath the summer moon
I will return again
Sure as the dust that floats high in June
When moving through Kashmir
Oh, father of the four winds, fill my sails
Across the sea of years
With no provision but an open face
Along the straits of fear
Oh, oh
Oh, oh
Ooh
Oh, when I'm on, when I'm on my way, yeah
When I see, when I see the way, you stay-yeah
Ooh, yeah-yeah, ooh, yeah-yeah, when I'm down
Ooh, yeah-yeah, ooh, yeah-yeah, but I'm down, so down
Ooh, my baby, ooh, my baby, let me take you there
Oh come on, oh, let me take you there... let me take you there
Ooh, yeah-yeah, ooh, yeah-yeah, let me take you there... let me take you there
Morocco was a popular country to visit by musicians in the late 60's/early 70's. They went there to experience the music, culture, and its famous hashish.
It's such a privilege to get to witness the original "WOW" effect from all of those pearls this world and its people gifted us and we take for granted too often.
John Bonham is universal
Yes, Chacha, John "Bonzo" Bonham is definitely an Ustad - to drummers like me, one of the very most high of the very most high. Not only do we have him to thank for so much great music and so much inspiration and influence on how we play our instrument, I personally have him to thank for being a musician at all. I heard Led Zeppelin for the first time when a friend played it for me at school when I was 13, and that was it - I wanted to do what I was hearing.
Sadly, he died young at only 31 years old from the effects of alcoholism, only months after this performance was recorded in fact, and the band immediately ended. They put out a very brief statement that said that with the death of their friend, "we can no longer go on as we were."
This was a band of four Ustads, and contributions of Ustad John Paul Jones on bass, keyboards, and so many other instruments are the most underrated when people talk about them. He was the mortar that held the bricks together.
I just searched for this last week thinking it was done a couple of years ago. Apparently, someone must have done the same thing and said, "Oh, well, if we didn't do it yet, who isn't looking for it!?"
Thank you for sharing.
Awesome! Love to our Trybal friends.
Love from America to all you gentlemen.
It would be fun to see a reaction to Robert Plant and Allison Krause's work. And older Plant and totally different style. Love every single video. 💜💛
These men are beautiful souls
I love how quiet and transfixed they get when Bonham starts doing his crazy fills. Bonzo blows everyone's minds,
2:16 "The real journey is this life and it's light that we are in. Like this light has a life too, even its journey has to end." Wow, so profound and they haven't even started the music yet! I wonder what sort of philosophical wisdom the western world had missed out on because of our prejudices.
Tribal gentlemen nailed it again.
Such a joy to watch them appreciate the genius skill of drummer John Bonham.
I think a reaction on Ustad Bonham's masterpiece "Moby Dick" would be interesting
I watch quite a few interviews with Robert. He said he wished their band could be remembered for this song, rather than "Stairway to Heaven."
Yep it's his favorite of all their songs.
Oh we do...... we do!! (I almost ran away from home at like 13 or 14 to go watch them in Seattle. My mom threatened to call the sheriff on the guy that was going to take me and my friend with him. It was a different time.)
As a young kid 6 years of age (1982 something), my english was bad and when I heard this song Kashmir I was thinking it was some kind of rice, like Jasmin, Basmati. Then when the music kicked in, I was just - WOW!! Now hearing these young gentlemen talk about it it makes me feel like a kid again - in a good way. Such an wonderful and bombastic song. Great video. PEACE and prosperity to you all.
You _MUST_ show them "Panama" by Van Halen. They will be blown away by what they see and hear. 👌👌👌👌✌️
Play the song,,, Nobody’s Fault But Mine. To these gentlemen, I love that song and Zeppelin
When I was a kid, this was my favorite song I'd discovered. It's still right up there toward the top. It just has a groove and a feel to it like no other, but also feels like you've known it all your life, you just needed that band and those instruments to reveal what you already had playing in your heart.
They seem to really love guitar music, you should have them watch Steve Vai play with an orchestra his instrumental guitar song called For The Love of God. A truly magical piece of music and shows what an amazing musician he is, as he wrote all the parts, he went to school and learned to write for every instrument.
This is great! I'm so glad to hear the elders listen to a song, which to me, is about them.
One of the best songs of all time. Takes me back to a time and makes me feel that same way
Page, Plant, Jones and Jason Bonham need to see this!
It gives me chills watching these men experience something that has been a delight to me all my life. I can see them get their own chills from the music and that feeling of a thrill extends to me, letting me hear this wonderful music as if for the first time again. Thank you for making these videos and thank you to all the participants for their time, their insights and their wide open expressions!!!!! It is life-changing for us probably even more than it is for them!
I'm glad you guys like this Western music.
Wonderful reaction. This is my favorite song by them.❤ Always a great day with some Led for our heads.😂
I love all of their perspectives and beautiful insights to this, one of my favorite songs from when I was a child to the present. I had to look up what Ustad meant and I absolutely love that description. It's such a passionate song and it really does evoke a journey in the minds eye and I agree with what was said here. It does seem spiritual in nature. All of the key phrases seem to be ascending, others ebb and flow and that again just seems to make me think of traveling through some exotic place and it all sounds so dramatic. Great song, I'm glad they liked it.
I always felt like this song dragged... like you were slowly stumbling through a hot desert.
Incredible.. we share a heart!! xo
I'm so blown away by you guys and your insights!! Would love to hear their reaction to the Live version of The Song Remains The Same/Rain Song.
I love these gentlemen...❤
The one many of us have waited for :)
Music brings people together. LED Zeppelin is the hottest band of all time. These gentlemen have rhythm.
I think that Robert Plant had hidden depths in both his travels and music. His mother was a Romanichal, and I think that it is a natural part of his genetic heritage from her and her people.
Robert Plant’s lyrics here are outstanding encompassing Robert Plant’s feelings. He sings them with passion. Jimmy Page’s music is wonderful too. The changes between the different rhythmic meters are genius.
Mr. Abdul Aziz Rind Baloch always listens with his feelings and speaks from the heart.
Back in the 70s, we used to take a tape of this to stero stores to "test" rhe equipment 😅 turn it all the way up! Thanks ❤️ love y'all's reactions.
It should be mentioned that at the time Morocco and Kashmir were both famous for hash, which is exactly what this song feels like.
Great live performance, but a listen to the studio version is a must!😊
I've read that _Achilles Last Stand_ is Jimmy Page's favorite song for its guitar work.
Kashmir is my favorite riff of all time
Great timing. Im currently obsessed with Led Zeppelin
I love these reactions to western music, they have such awesome insight to the instruments & how they are played, to the lyrics & to the performance as a whole, thank you. ❤
I'm so glad to see them really see Led Zeppelin as a major band. I learn so much by listening to these gentlemen talk about what they see and understand about the performers, how they interpret the actions and expressions of Robert Plant. This is a lesson about the world and my own culture.
We need to start a fund to get these fellas a drum kit because they seem to be most impressed by great drummers in different videos they watch.
Adnan, please share my greetings with sir Muharam and with Chacha Abdul, I care so much for them, my heart fills with joy when they appear in the videos.
Suggestion: I'm from Brazil, I would LOVE to see them reacting to any of our songs, I personally recomend Elis Regina to start. Brazilian people loves to watch such reactions, it could also bring more people to the channel.
Hi, thank you so much for your kindness. We will try to discover music from Brazil too. Lots of love 🙂❤️🙏🌹
Another band that came later and is not so well known, but took a bit of the spiritual ideas of Page, was Kingston Wall in the early 1990's. Their song "Shine On Me" is something special. And "Could It Be So" feels like a spiritual journey, it ponders on the idea that what if time is not a straight line, what if humans have some kind of universal knowledge connection, what if there's more to the world than what we see and understand. The song even says "Ancient wisemen knew things that we can hardly dream about - - now we seek for that wisdom". The whole Kingston Wall II album is quite exciting and beautiful playing. They are a trio of guitar, drums and bass and all of them were experts on their instrument. There's some different level of emotion in the guitar playing I hear though, really strong passion. That searching for meaning, that yearning of something deeper.
They also combined a bit of eastern musical ideas with western rock. Psychedelic rock as people call it. The movement I guess The Beatles started in the 60's. The guitarist and songwriter Petri Walli travelled and studied some spiritualism in India, and as a kid he skipped school to play guitar and learned all of Page, Hendrix and Clapton.
Nice to see the greatness of Led Zeppelin appreciated!
Fly high airship of Gods🤟🏻🔝
I’m so happy to see you guys listening to the Led Zeppelin and Tool songs I suggested not long ago. Not sure if it was because of my email suggestion but I don’t care either way. I’m just happy for these guys to hear it.
I love watching these wonderful men, so far away, enjoy what ive loved for so long.....they absolutely get it!!!! The power of music is one of Gods biggest gift. I love that they love Zeppelin ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I love the old boy...he is my kin. X
You should show 'em the LA ska band FISHBONE now
I love to see them vibing to one of my favourite songs of all time!!!
I think I've heard about every version of this song. I got to say, my favorite version is the one that sounds very Eastern. Did change to the music with the addition of those instruments and the change in his voice was just so beautiful. It was like making a completely new song out of a song that was a very old favorite
You are likely referring to "Page & Plant Kashmir With Egyptian Orchestra Glastonbury 1995" - yes? The video is readily available and I posted the info on how to search for it directly to Adnan. Hoping they'll react to it, it's truly gorgeous.
@@karenfryberger4260 that is the exact video I was talking about. I've seen it several times and it's saved in the music section of my account. I just couldn't remember the title right off the top of my head
@@streghewitch77 Saved in my watch history as well. Here's hoping it makes it to the channel. Best wishes, kf
@karenfryberger4260 I'd love to see it make it here as well! Bright blessings to you and yours!
@22:50 for never having heard the song before, and not understanding the language Plant is singing in, he's very insightful!
The song did its job!
Awesome, I was hoping they would do this!
I can't get past the hats these guys are wearing. I LOVE the design!
These gentlemen show how to open yourself to the world - to new and different music and culture. I applaud them for the way the react with heart and soul to new and different music and culture. May we all follow their example.
Led Zeppelin never played a song the same twice. Live performances allow for ebb and flow in tempo, dynamics and of course ongoing improvisation. Many things affect musicians' performances: how much sleep they got, their moods at the moment, a recent positive or negative experience, the effect of any alcohol or intoxicants they may have consumed, a good or bad meal before the show... I prefer when musicians channel self-expression and emotion through their instruments instead of being human jukeboxes and repeating themselves over and over. As a drummer, I would get bored playing the same thing every night.
Dude love your channel so hard, these guys are so legit! Been watching for years.
Amazing! Would love to see some Beatles reaction in the future, maybe some rooftop.
Rock on Tribal Elder Dudes 🎸🎵🎶
They would enjoy hearing the studio version better..good song
Its Celtic ..deep ...we understand ...UK ...god bless ...connected
I would like to see them react from a few celebration day performances.
Greatest rock band of all time. (IMO)
charming gentlemen. i enjoyed their perspective of one of my favorite songs and bands.