Talk to Indians who live in India and are proud of India, who will give you more accurate views which might discomfort you but will be more reliable and accurate.
Uzair, You are doing a great job. Keep everything possible for peace between India & Pakistan by inviting as many people as possible so that our power elites have some sort of introspection & we may see even a little bit of prosperity in our lifetime. Maintaining even basics is becoming very difficult in this kind of economy. I am a firm believer that peace between India & Pakistan is the first step towards our economic development.
*South Asia has now become defunct!* It is now known as the Indian Sub-continent which is part of the larger Indo-Pacific region. *Pakistan is now part of the AfPak region!* Though it is not fair to malign Afghanistan by linking it to Pakistan...
India is part of the quad, it has signed military cooperation agreements with America. To call that cooperation is effectively lying to yourself, it's is very much a military alliance, where you interlock your interests, and capabilities, and intentions, and defined enemies. That is an alliance.
Quad is NOT a military alliance since India does not want to be part of a military alliance. That is why AUKUS has been formed which IS a military alliance. If quad were a military alliance, India would not have been able to buy S400 from Russia or abstain from the UNSC criticism of Russia.
@@gauravipal9518 please read my comment again. Quad is exactly as I described it, that's a military alliance. By your logic then NATO isn't a military alliance because America has other alliance's, you're not making sense. Voting is a none issue, 70% of Indian military equipment is Russian, you can't afford to vote against Russia. Quad is not a formal alliance, but look at it's intent and function, it is the same as a military alliance.
The Quad is focused on countering china mostly militarily, but apart from that when it comes to questions of foreign policy or economy both china and india have their own ideas which are very differnt from the US. infact at many mult national platforms india and china are on the same side. Especially when it comes to the environment and finance.
@@71espn you'll have similarities on many issues, it doesn't mean they're on the same side. Let's not play with words. Hitler and Jews ate food, drank water and breathed oxygen, it doesn't mean they were on the same side.
@@youknow6968 Your understanding of geopolitics and power plays is very immature and quite frankly stupid. You should read some books such as Full Spectrum War, Reimagining Pakistan, The Spy Chronicles to name a few to understand how these powerplays take place in geopolitics. Your attitude is classically Pakistani wherein there is no nuance there its just my way or the highway kind of approach which is why your country is largely a banana republic and a failed state
@@BabarMalik_ Imran Hashmi is known as serial k!sser in India, can a pk-stani named Akshay Kumar become a superstar or even an actor and k!sss Mahira Khan in movies in ur country? If no...then where do you get such confidance to point fingers at others while you yourself being fan-atic of premium quality!
@@prashantp2029 Onscreen kissing is your criteria? Such shallow and superficial standard has India set for itself. It sadden me that I am even responding to this comment, because it does not deserve one, seriously.
So far I found her bias 1. LOC vs LAC LOC skirmishes were result of India agression. Pakistan has the ability to respond therefore India can cross limits like it did in other neighboring countries. LOC is cool again because China forced India to look toward LAC. The current ceasefire agreement proves that it was always India who violated the agreement and it was always Pakistan who was always willing to sign peace deal. 2. She artistically navigated through your question of rise of nationalists Xi and nationalists Modi. Look all Indian writer irrespective of their association never admit Modj jingoism. 3. She said India isn't in US camp. It is like they cooperate in overlapping areas of interests. Again she is typical dishonest Indian researcher who will not admit the fact that their country is being forced to follow the US policies. Ind-US relations aren't bilateral as many Indian try to portray. US is dominant partner. What are the interests of India in south China sea? Is there any overlapping?
@@ds9173 kargil was military blunder. There was no role of state in Mumbai attacks. Uri, Pulwama and this fictitious 28 sep are all local resistence. TTP members are from Ex-FATA. India has no role in TTP. You failed to explain why after LAC engagements, India agreed for ceasefire and since then LOC is back to normal. 2. You are literally celebrating death of Indian democracy. 3. India lacks the capabilities to do any such adventure. We are more than happy to see India being stretched to far east. India isn't America. India isn't even a regional power. Anyway as I said earlier, we are fucking happy to see India expanding its military and wasting resources in areas far away from Indian Ocean. Could not have been better.
I can bust all your points but it will take too much time, and it's not worth it for me. I would like you to belive what you believe😂 but sadly things are only in favor India and it's only going to get bad and bad for pk and it's citizens.
@@mythbusterUSA Pk gdp size in 2014 - $244bn USD and now - $280bn Ind gdp size in 2014 - $2trillion and now - almost $3tn dollars It's not a dream! It's happening! C o p e !
@@Movieplaytoon306? Seems like you're crazy, laughing at yourself. Please explain what your fantasy mind was trying to say, and try to make sense, it helps with the clarity.
This guy is a joke. India is 5000 years old. I will agree with you if you are saying the name india is given by British. But this region exist from long time is a irrevocable truth.
@@t.narendra6549 you are the childish joker. Try and understand the discussion before commenting. You contradicted yourself in the same statement. Obviously I'm referring to the nation of India, the nation of India is different from India as a region. This name should not have been adopted by a country because it has confused people like yourself. The region obviously existed, just like Europe, but the country and nation of India did not exist before 1947, it's a British creation otherwise there would be dozens of countries in South Asia or Indian region. Next time spend a moment to understand before posting silly comments, and not allow emotions to rule your response.
4. "Like minded countries" Let me debunk this myth of India mother of democracy. India is not a democracy by any measure. It is majoritarian state. I'm fan of USA for many many reasons. I love their strong institutes. You can criticize USA for so many things like structural racism, imperialism etc. But USA is a very strong democracy. US courts, US senate and president all three of them are absolutely independent. Is this the case with India? No. Modi and company owns the country. Just change the name of BJP with CPC. Indian SC and parliament are in total control of Indian PM. Forget about kashmir and other separatist groups fighting against state of India. 16% of population Muslim is in danger. Forget the past even in last two days one Muslim kid killed in police station in UP. Today Indian Muslim were banned from offering Friday prayers in gurgaon, Dehli. India is on verge of committing genocide. In Indian Punjab BSF controls the 50% of total areas. Effectively governors rule. Indian human rights violations are worst then Chinese. 5. As I said I admire USA and its state institutes. But this war against China is not ideological. Early I supported USA narrative. I hate communism. I believe US resistence to Marxists ideologies was greatest services for humanity and world must be thankful to USA for this. But in this new cold war against China, all I can see is white man insecurity. China became go to manufacturing hub for American capitalist. USA was engaged in wars. In meantime China moved from low end manufacturing to advanced technology manufacturing. Though Chinese stole the technology from USA. But they have achieved so much in just few decades with their flawed system of Chinese communism. Now China entered in areas dominated by US and western countries. US is fighting back just to keep that title. US has the ability to stay ahead in this innovation game. As Bill Gates said in interview " a healthy cooperation between two power will benefit humanity" But the inherent white man insecurity of US establishment is pushing US against China. It is not an ideology war.
@Devendra Seelamneni south and eastern states showing some resistance. But falling one after another. The marxists and significant non-hindu population are reasons why south is not in control of BJP so far. The RSS ideology is already there. Can write 1000 of words on Indian SC decision favoring BJP. Many ex judges openly supporting not only BJP as political part but also Hindutva agenda. RSS is in complete control of National policies. under Section 139 of the Border Security Force Act 1968 BSF can arrest any person. May be you need to read BSF law. Punjab has history of Dehli intervention. Location were allocated by the administration because waqf masajid are in control of administration and Muslim aren't allowed to pray inside mosques. Today Muslim were banned to enter designated place allocated by administration. You deleted the comment. Otherwise I can debunk every single line you just said.
So do you have any problem with India,as in democracy, or with BJP? And I hate communism too, however the picture you portrayed of us china war isn't entirely true. Somewhat of it is ideological. End goal of China is to impose their version of governance in the world, I believe.
Talk to Indians who live in India and are proud of India, who will give you more accurate views which might discomfort you but will be more reliable and accurate.
Asaduddin Owaisi would be a good guest
@@Abdullah-uv9nk I said Indians* 😂
@@prashantp2029 Mehbooba Mufti
@@prashantp2029 Owaisi is a patriotic. He just uses his politics in muslim favour. It doesn't mean that he is not Indian 😡
@@Abdullah-uv9nk Mufti = Owaisi
I have never seen anyone talk good about intellectual ability of tanvi.
Uzair,
You are doing a great job.
Keep everything possible for peace between India & Pakistan by inviting as many people as possible so that our power elites have some sort of introspection & we may see even a little bit of prosperity in our lifetime.
Maintaining even basics is becoming very difficult in this kind of economy.
I am a firm believer that peace between India & Pakistan is the first step towards our economic development.
Why the ppl like tanvi madan goes to failed state labbaik creators ..these are bankrupt bhikhari ppl.roaming like monster in road
Uzair asked very straight forward questions.
Dr Madan gave a bit "Gol-Matol' answers, without taking a clear stand.
*South Asia has now become defunct!*
It is now known as the Indian Sub-continent which is part of the larger Indo-Pacific region.
*Pakistan is now part of the AfPak region!*
Though it is not fair to malign Afghanistan by linking it to Pakistan...
Completely agree with analysis
Lovely conversation, Uzair. Tanvi is as always, articulate
Good interview
A reasonable presentation on South Asian geopolitics and Great power interest on the region and their mutual tensions.
No subtitles
India is part of the quad, it has signed military cooperation agreements with America.
To call that cooperation is effectively lying to yourself, it's is very much a military alliance, where you interlock your interests, and capabilities, and intentions, and defined enemies. That is an alliance.
Quad is NOT a military alliance since India does not want to be part of a military alliance. That is why AUKUS has been formed which IS a military alliance.
If quad were a military alliance, India would not have been able to buy S400 from Russia or abstain from the UNSC criticism of Russia.
@@gauravipal9518 please read my comment again.
Quad is exactly as I described it, that's a military alliance.
By your logic then NATO isn't a military alliance because America has other alliance's, you're not making sense. Voting is a none issue, 70% of Indian military equipment is Russian, you can't afford to vote against Russia.
Quad is not a formal alliance, but look at it's intent and function, it is the same as a military alliance.
The Quad is focused on countering china mostly militarily, but apart from that when it comes to questions of foreign policy or economy both china and india have their own ideas which are very differnt from the US. infact at many mult national platforms india and china are on the same side. Especially when it comes to the environment and finance.
@@71espn you'll have similarities on many issues, it doesn't mean they're on the same side. Let's not play with words.
Hitler and Jews ate food, drank water and breathed oxygen, it doesn't mean they were on the same side.
@@youknow6968 Your understanding of geopolitics and power plays is very immature and quite frankly stupid. You should read some books such as Full Spectrum War, Reimagining Pakistan, The Spy Chronicles to name a few to understand how these powerplays take place in geopolitics. Your attitude is classically Pakistani wherein there is no nuance there its just my way or the highway kind of approach which is why your country is largely a banana republic and a failed state
???
Do they not have any mirrors in India?
Had Pakistan had any mirrors.....
@@sewaligoswami781 no Pakistan only have a lousy neighbor, and in comparison to these bigots on our east end, we look pretty fantastic.
@@BabarMalik_ Imran Hashmi is known as serial k!sser in India, can a pk-stani named Akshay Kumar become a superstar or even an actor and k!sss Mahira Khan in movies in ur country? If no...then where do you get such confidance to point fingers at others while you yourself being fan-atic of premium quality!
@@prashantp2029 Onscreen kissing is your criteria? Such shallow and superficial standard has India set for itself. It sadden me that I am even responding to this comment, because it does not deserve one, seriously.
@@BabarMalik_ If Akshay Kumar k!ss Mahira Khan in movies, there will r-iots all over pk-stan!! That's wht u ppl are! Don't gv me that criteria cr-ap!
So far I found her bias
1. LOC vs LAC
LOC skirmishes were result of India agression. Pakistan has the ability to respond therefore India can cross limits like it did in other neighboring countries. LOC is cool again because China forced India to look toward LAC. The current ceasefire agreement proves that it was always India who violated the agreement and it was always Pakistan who was always willing to sign peace deal.
2. She artistically navigated through your question of rise of nationalists Xi and nationalists Modi. Look all Indian writer irrespective of their association never admit Modj jingoism.
3. She said India isn't in US camp. It is like they cooperate in overlapping areas of interests. Again she is typical dishonest Indian researcher who will not admit the fact that their country is being forced to follow the US policies. Ind-US relations aren't bilateral as many Indian try to portray. US is dominant partner. What are the interests of India in south China sea? Is there any overlapping?
@@ds9173 kargil was military blunder. There was no role of state in Mumbai attacks. Uri, Pulwama and this fictitious 28 sep are all local resistence. TTP members are from Ex-FATA. India has no role in TTP. You failed to explain why after LAC engagements, India agreed for ceasefire and since then LOC is back to normal.
2. You are literally celebrating death of Indian democracy.
3. India lacks the capabilities to do any such adventure. We are more than happy to see India being stretched to far east. India isn't America. India isn't even a regional power. Anyway as I said earlier, we are fucking happy to see India expanding its military and wasting resources in areas far away from Indian Ocean. Could not have been better.
I can bust all your points but it will take too much time, and it's not worth it for me. I would like you to belive what you believe😂 but sadly things are only in favor India and it's only going to get bad and bad for pk and it's citizens.
@@prashantp2029 Indian dreaming this from 47 to date.
@@mythbusterUSA Pk gdp size in 2014 - $244bn USD and now - $280bn
Ind gdp size in 2014 - $2trillion and now - almost $3tn dollars
It's not a dream! It's happening! C o p e !
@@prashantp2029 they r youthias as opposition called them by this word "youthia",they believe in IKNiazi...let them stay like that.
There would be no India without the British, it is a British creation, that's a fact.
i think its British India not British pakistan...😂😂😂
@@Movieplaytoon306? Seems like you're crazy, laughing at yourself.
Please explain what your fantasy mind was trying to say, and try to make sense, it helps with the clarity.
This guy is a joke. India is 5000 years old. I will agree with you if you are saying the name india is given by British. But this region exist from long time is a irrevocable truth.
@@t.narendra6549 you are the childish joker. Try and understand the discussion before commenting.
You contradicted yourself in the same statement. Obviously I'm referring to the nation of India, the nation of India is different from India as a region. This name should not have been adopted by a country because it has confused people like yourself.
The region obviously existed, just like Europe, but the country and nation of India did not exist before 1947, it's a British creation otherwise there would be dozens of countries in South Asia or Indian region.
Next time spend a moment to understand before posting silly comments, and not allow emotions to rule your response.
@@youknow6968 I am not emotional you are emotional. India as whole exists from a long time. We traded with Greece and Rome long long before 1947.
4. "Like minded countries"
Let me debunk this myth of India mother of democracy. India is not a democracy by any measure. It is majoritarian state. I'm fan of USA for many many reasons. I love their strong institutes. You can criticize USA for so many things like structural racism, imperialism etc. But USA is a very strong democracy. US courts, US senate and president all three of them are absolutely independent. Is this the case with India? No. Modi and company owns the country. Just change the name of BJP with CPC. Indian SC and parliament are in total control of Indian PM.
Forget about kashmir and other separatist groups fighting against state of India. 16% of population Muslim is in danger. Forget the past even in last two days one Muslim kid killed in police station in UP. Today Indian Muslim were banned from offering Friday prayers in gurgaon, Dehli. India is on verge of committing genocide. In Indian Punjab BSF controls the 50% of total areas. Effectively governors rule. Indian human rights violations are worst then Chinese.
5. As I said I admire USA and its state institutes. But this war against China is not ideological. Early I supported USA narrative. I hate communism. I believe US resistence to Marxists ideologies was greatest services for humanity and world must be thankful to USA for this. But in this new cold war against China, all I can see is white man insecurity. China became go to manufacturing hub for American capitalist. USA was engaged in wars. In meantime China moved from low end manufacturing to advanced technology manufacturing. Though Chinese stole the technology from USA. But they have achieved so much in just few decades with their flawed system of Chinese communism. Now China entered in areas dominated by US and western countries. US is fighting back just to keep that title. US has the ability to stay ahead in this innovation game. As Bill Gates said in interview " a healthy cooperation between two power will benefit humanity"
But the inherent white man insecurity of US establishment is pushing US against China. It is not an ideology war.
@Devendra Seelamneni south and eastern states showing some resistance. But falling one after another. The marxists and significant non-hindu population are reasons why south is not in control of BJP so far. The RSS ideology is already there. Can write 1000 of words on Indian SC decision favoring BJP. Many ex judges openly supporting not only BJP as political part but also Hindutva agenda. RSS is in complete control of National policies. under Section 139 of the Border Security Force Act 1968 BSF can arrest any person. May be you need to read BSF law. Punjab has history of Dehli intervention.
Location were allocated by the administration because waqf masajid are in control of administration and Muslim aren't allowed to pray inside mosques. Today Muslim were banned to enter designated place allocated by administration.
You deleted the comment. Otherwise I can debunk every single line you just said.
China is targeting uyghurs muslim in a certain area. Unlike India, It is not outright war against Muslim. I condemn chinese crimes in Xinjiang.
@@mythbusterUSA hahaha nice, shows your hypocrisy
So do you have any problem with India,as in democracy, or with BJP? And I hate communism too, however the picture you portrayed of us china war isn't entirely true. Somewhat of it is ideological. End goal of China is to impose their version of governance in the world, I believe.
focus on your own country first dude
Uzair sb ap ka kntkt number mil sakta hy?