Goku VA Comparison - Kelamis vs Schemmel
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 вер 2024
- Goku voice actor comparison.
Peter Kelamis versus Sean Schemmel.
Apparently some people have pointed out that this video may be biased and have lashed out at me because of this. However, even on unbiased videos, Funifans feel the need to bash anything that isn't part of their beloved dub, so whether it's bias or not is irrelevant among them.
![GOKU VS HIT (REDO + WITH AI VOICES) MANGA [COLOR]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vvneaBdZBuY/mqdefault.jpg)
![GOKU VS HIT (REDO + WITH AI VOICES) MANGA [COLOR]](/img/tr.png)
Damn. Kelamis sounds VERY close to the japanese actress for Goku.
Yeah
It's what he aimed for.
And He's Better Than Japanese Goku
it’s an old woman that’s why
Japanese goku sounds like a strangled cat, not a good sound for an all powerful male warrior.
You dare mock the son of a shepherd? KAIIIIOOOOOOKEEEEENNN!!
I am Ralph
Have you ever experienced the almighty 3 shoe beating???!!!????
Life has many doors vegeta
Kaio-what?
Do you live in a cave
I love how objective OP and unbiased OP is.
Alan Liang haha probably the most accurate comment on here..
@@KotoKiminama r/wooosh
@@KotoKiminama holy shit ur right lol
@@KotoKiminama is objective and unbiased mutually exclusive
@@KotoKiminama Honestly the joke is only funny when the term "Objective" is used. "Subjective" may be correct but it doesn't have the same impact for humor. However, please continue guiding us ignoramuses in the ways of proper grammar. Gracias.
Schemmel is actually very good, buy Kelamis did a better job in the other movies like World's Strongest. They are both great in their own right
Ocean got ripped off they only had like a month to record the rest of dbz when they picked it up again funimation had a whole fucking year to record that's why ocean sounds half-assed in the later seasons. It's an unfair comparison not to mention the director kept changing for ocean.
Yeah.
Agreed
@@umbrellaunderdog agreed
I agree.
With Peters voice goku sounds like Sonic the hedgehog
Ikr
God damm...
Peter Kelamis for Sonic?
He sounds NOTHING like Sonic. I don’t hear it!
Yeah, I was thinking that too.
Dear god, the bias here is insane.
That said, while I grew up more on Schemmel thanks to (shitty) Orange Bricks, I still think Peter is pretty good. He certainly captures Masako. Personally, Schemmel will ALWAYS be Goku to me, but I recognize Peter’s talent. So to sum it up, they’re both really good!
I agree.
Heard schemmel growing up. But Yeah, Peter definitely capture Masako's version in english.
@@RiRyn27 You guys mean Masako captures Peter's version right?
@@Sempermac No, Masako came first
Sempermac No, Masako is the original Goku
While Schemmel doesn't do "silly" quite as well, he actually sounds like a man in battle which is pretty important!
Correct!
That’s the thing if you’re basing it off of the Japanese original, Goku never sounds like a man
N7thegreatspy of course not...it’s a women who make the voice... but i agree Goku should sound like a man, it’s better
I think he does
Goku never really grows up though. At least in terms of his personality. He's not a manly character, he's a child at heart. I think Peter Kelamis' voice captures that well. I do like Sean Schemmel's voice for Goku, and despite what this video says, I especially love the way he sounds when Goku is more silly. Kelamis' voice just stays more true to Goku's character consistently in my opinion.
This is super bias honestly both performances are amazing
Dr
Fr*
Fr fr
Dr. Fr
You’re bias. Kelamis or what is name is does the job good. Schemmel is shittel
Kalamis is better because he was a professionally trained VA and ventriloquist. He could do amazing things with his voice. Saban made a REALLY good call hiring him and those first 3 movies are considered the most faithful adaptations of the original story by all of us older DBZ fans who have been watching since the mid 90s. Schemmel and the other in-house talent that they hired later due to not being able to afford the older Saban/Ocean cast, were all untrained amateur voice actors. Sean got better with time, but not nearly as good a fit for Goku as Kelamis.
I started watching in '98-'99 and prefer Schmmel.
@@mkhanman12345 Do you prefer him even for the first three movies? I have a hard time watching the Funimation version of those movies, though it's not just because of Sean. Almost all of the voices outside of Gohan and Krillin feel way off. It's very apparent in Tree of Might when you compare Pioneer to Funi.
wow
@@Cableguy15yes schemmel is better. kelamis sounds like a bitch
Ian James Corbett is my favourite. I'm from the UK so I grew up with the ocean dub
I see a lot of people here saying that Kelamis is much more accurate to the Japanese which is true, but its important to realize that when subbing your not just changing the language you’re also changing the voice in general to sound more like something you might hear in that country. In English speaking countries it is not common for grown men to sound like children, even in animation, so Goku shouldn’t sound like that either. Schemmel sounds light hearted and fun when peaceful but sounds like a warrior during battle. That’s how it should be.
>.> What's your opinion of the SM Dic vs Viz dubs? Or are you one of those people who are bias towards viz because they had a more accurate script to the Japanese one plus the editing and censorship.
First seeing dbz on toonami there was 3 different voice actors for dbz but Sean always hit home.
@@misspretty8969 Everyone forgets Ian. 🤷♂️
For voice acting, the characterisation should come before the design. Peter Kelamis and Masako Nozawa still sound like warriors in battle, their voices simply fit Goku's character as a childlike martial artist.
Sean Schemmel's voice more so fits with Funimation's patented Superman Goku. *insert joke about Superman Goku sucking here*
I think a good middle ground would be Kirby Morrow, his voice is higher pitched, but sounds like an adult.
Bruh do you think anyone in japan sounds like goku? Hes a fucking alien in a cartoon.
can you just upload the video without these annoying biased texts smh
Or, you could just listen to the comparisons without looking at the screen. It IS a comparison of audio after all.
Zero Fighter he made fun of schemmels voice because the goku sounded sick. Literally in that string of episodes he gets the heart virus.
There’s nothing wrong with having favor to a certain voice, there’s definitely shit that kelamis says that I like, but just because I prefer schemmel doesn’t mean I should berate kelamis’ voice.
And final point, it is an audio comparison, but interjects with text monologues. There’s nothing wrong with that but there’s no way to know when a clip will start and when it will end
@@Lordecai
Okay? So? What's your point? If you don't like it, other people have made comparison compilations. Why are you so hellbent that this one person fall in line to your wishes?
Zero Fighter I made 2 points there buddy, don’t know why you’re asking me what my point is. Just because there are other videos doesn’t mean that I can’t comment on this one. Plus this is the only video comparing the 2 that I could find. Regardless, there is a comment section for a reason. If you wanted to make everything peachy and positive then we might as well disable comments altogether.
I really don’t care about either voice actor at the end of the day, but I value opinions greatly. That being said if your opinion just defaults to “that’s bad, you suck” then the opinion loses value
@@Lordecai
I never said you couldn't comment. I only replied because you're wanting something that other people have made, yet you insist that this one person do things that way. You can say whatever you want, you just have to understand that so can anyone else.
Personally prefer the funimation dub, seans voice fits goku, especially when gokus design becomes much more muscular in the buu saga.
Fr
Yeah, only the true OGs prefer Ocean dub over funimation..
even if we are in a minority.
I’m at the weird side of UA-cam. People are really arguing about who screams better?
Its dragon ball, the fandom is just cancerous as a whole.
@@syawndarren4284 nah. this was like 10 years ago
This dude talking about HE SCREAMED NON-STOP,AND SAID THAT THE OTHER GUY HAS A MORE POWERFUL SCREAM WHEN HE REALLY WAS A HAMSTER QUACKING
Sean had a more angry yell while Peter's was a higher pitched yell
@@fatboydashredder9877Sean can also scream incredibly well if he wants to, just watch his newer “I will not let you destroy my world!” Scream from Battle of Gods movie!
VA’s get to watch what their character is doing and have some artistic freedom to make their voice fit better from their perspective. Sean likely chose the multiple breaths intentionally, though it was also still early on in his VA career and maybe he hadn’t practiced his breath control as well yet.
@@WafleEnterprisesDon’t forget the ssj3 scream too, that was glorious
@@Lunerine Particularly in Fusion Reborn, that scream is even more magnificent and epic than the one he did for the mainline series!
The video is obviously biased but as it stands currently with the current situation I’d prefer Kelamis
Rival Battle Same with me. I’d rather take the son of a shepherd over that bipolar bitch Sean.
Rival Battle even after all that, I still think schemmel is better personally
JoJo’s Bizarre Adventures Well yeah, but I’m a sub fan anyway
Rival Battle respectable. I enjoyed the subbed episodes that I watched in dbs
yeah, what a freaking asshole.
He's just a huge hater
I agree
Honestly
plush adventures reverse card
To be honest your the only comment that makes sense
Most biased crap I've ever watched, "Let's count the breaths" in what sense does breath taking make someone's voice better suited for the role?
_Are You Dumb??_ (^._.^)ﾉ
@@Fan4tune You have xX(Username)Xx, meaning your opinion is invalid.
@@ihatearashi Yeah It was so dumb too say that... That's makes me more have no regrets too abandoned the DB Comunty. becase in fact, this video is showing the maximum potential of both VAs of Goku!, sometimes on internet i sad why i like more Masako's voice (The original japanese Goku's VA) over Shiensshjshoniesimp (IDK the oficial english VA and i don't care because he is a A-Hole as person) and a random person yells ate me saying that i'm wrong without repecting the whole coment... just like you did. :-|
(Sorry If I don't said the mean of my coment before..., but yeah you still yells ate me)
@@Fan4tune You should be a writer.
@@ihatearashi why did you "eat" him 🤣
Kelamis is an overall better person that Sean Schemmel. He doesn’t act like Goku belongs to him. I’m pretty sure Sean also tried to get him banned from a convention because he didn’t like the fact Kelamis also played Goku.
Kelamis did get removed from Kamehacon, though if you watch YellowFlash2, there was at one point a consideration to have Goku Black be voiced as either Peter Kelamis here or Ian Corrlet. Though funimation might be gone if the lawsuit Vic's going through is anything to go by...
Scott E. Wolfrey He was considered to be the role, but again, Sean Schemmel had to be a pathetic little bitch boy and complain about it. He genuinely seems to believe that Goku belongs to him and it’s honestly sickening.
Yeah fuck Sean. It would have been cool to have a previous VA for Goku to come back and voice Goku Black.
It would’ve been a nice callback to the other voices of Goku.
Hi diddly Ho diddly I think I heard about how Sean is possessive over the Goku voice but I’m definitely seeing it come up a lot in this comment section.
reid lindsey He threw a fit when he saw MasakoX. He doesn’t think TFS is fair use 🙄
Personally, while Kelamis does do the silly side of Goku better, I like Sean because he can do better when Goku has to be serious. He practically shattered his lungs turning SSJ3.
"shattering" his lungs doesn't make him a better VA
@@EdDaBawsh Kelamis during the transformation screams sounds like he’s trying to be silent, I don’t like his voice as goku at all.
Imo Sean does goku way better.
@@EdDaBawsh it does, cope harder
@@remade929 Okay funimation fanboy at least Peter doesn't make screams so exaggerated and crazy that they look ridiculous like Sean Schemmel's overrated one
@@EdDaBawsh Yes, it does. It shows dedication and passion, and a fucking boatload of talent.
As someone that isn’t very interested in dbz, I find it so weird that kelamis sounds too much like a goofy teenager. He plays a great Rolf though
Ikr
Like Ben 10
He'd make a good Sonic voice honestly
I don't get the whole "nostalgia goggles" thing everyone keeps talking about. I was born in the 2000s and pretty much knew only Schemmel as Goku and I genuinely prefer Kelamis and Corlett as Goku instead. It doesn't always have to be nostalgia that makes a person like something. People can actually have different preferences from yours.
Just because the "nostalgia goggles" thing doesn't apply to you doesn't mean that it can't apply to anyone else. For other people, growing up with either one of the voices generally creates a bias towards said voice since you have more of a connection with hearing it.
@SpaceBoy They're subjectively wrong, because it's their opinion. They aren't trying to claim that Kelamis and Corlett are better than Schemmel. They're just stating what they prefer. Which in itself is a subjective opinion and not an objective fact. They're allowed to have their opinion; just like you're allowed to have yours.
Opinions are important, they allow us to gain insight to other peoples views. Which enables us to gain a better understanding of each other and the world. Presuming you're not an ignorant nobody who bashes an opinion someone has, just to hate on them.
Exactly. People need to get their heads outta their asses.
@@CodeEpsilon bro have you not seen the video title
@@remade929 Yes, I had seen the video title. If you're trying to make a point. Just say it. Instead of leaving a vague statement that leaves no context on what you're trying to say.
You know schemmel just kept getting better and better the more he played
Yeah. And he was super inexperienced when he was cast for the Funi dub
And now he sounds like he has throat cancer.
@@night-seeker666he now sounds like a real man unlike that 80yo bitch and this poser
I sense a Kelamis fanboy...get a life!
AquaThunderKnight17 I sense a Schemmel fanyboy...get a life!
***** Not a Schemmel fanboy...just think the comparison was too one sided
+AquaThunderKnight17 Very one sided. Everyone caption directed towards schemmel was an insult lol most if not all to peter is praising him.
+Nappa Carl every*
Its just his oppinion. I like his version because he shows respect to the original. But sean doesn't.
Man, how things have changed. I woulda been for Schemmel before 2018/2019 but watching the Japanese dub made me realize how accurate Peter sounded.
Same here. I actually enjoy the Japanese dub over the English Dub.
Sean's a fucking douchebag.
@Wazerwaffle I think it would be a lot funnier and a bigger insult to schemmel if they cast the teamfourstar goku as the new official goku.
@@kabob0077 that too.
@@kabob0077 The fuck does that have to do with the quality of his vocie acting?
I don't think the like/dislike ratio is representative anymore. I think it'd be flipped around after what's been going on this year. LUL
KoopaXross lmao yep
Mickobin Sotosworth Vic isn’t a pervert! He was framed.
true. i loved schemmel’s goku for years but after the whole controversy, it’s not the same.
... What's been going on this year? I looked up his name in news and there's only stuff about DBZ and interviews and stuff.
@@mikeexits Drama between the VAs.
Why are you constantly dissing on Sean?? He's amazing! :D
But Goku's character of him is kinda *Meh* if you watched in the sub version 😐
@@Fan4tune sub version is a litteral 90 year old grandma, for some reason I feel like a huff man should sound like a , uhhh idk -
MAN
@@zamasu3563 I forgot to mention that Sean is a selfish a-hole (If you know the "Beta Sean and Alfa Masako" drama) not even respecting her role as Goku itself/ how Toriyama wrote the character. and the *"Men"* think was mistake of my so thank you to say about It! (ㆁωㆁ)
@@Fan4tune you realise the creator of a series can make bad decisions right? Like plot holes and other stuff exist but bad decisions also exist. And preferably, I don't like hearing grandpa scream because it genuinely hurts my ears. Also so? Sean is an ass yes but seperate art from the artist dipshit.
@@zamasu3563 you western fans think goku should follow the western norms of how an mc should sound like. Goku isn’t a superman. Goku is based off Sun Wukong. Seans interpretation is generic and bland. Nozawa actually puts so much nuance into Goku. His voice is rather high pitched because that’s how Toriyama imagined Goku should sound like. You need to take off your nostalgia goggles and actually watch what the original dbz in Japanese. Dragon ball is a Japanese show so naturally Funimation shoud change some stuff to appeal to the west. And to be fair your opinion doesn’t really matter. Nozawa is Goku and the rest is just parody/Interpretation.
2:27 i mean.. he did have a heart virus
Idk about you...but i still prefer Schemmel 1000x times more
10000x
100000x
@@jeremy9127 its over 9000!
I don’t know what this dude is talking about Sean is a good voice actor plus screaming can mess up your throat and he can pass out
He actually did passed out before while performing those screams
I know based on the description you seem really butt hurt that people are rightfully calling out your bias, but regardless of opinion there's no need to drag down Sean Schemmel, to build up Peter Kelamis. They both have their own interpretations of Goku and I both think they do a great job.
You are clearly one side sided in this video. You're real problem is lack of focus of the directing between the two actors.
The director for the dub group Kelamis was in, doesn't make his Goku seem real and/or natural. Its more cartoony. Yes, Kelamis can nail serious moments and high tension parts but its still not convincingly real.
Now Funimation made Goku feel more realistic with Sean. The extra breaths he takes and frequent pauses he makes, makes it that much more down to earth. More believeable.
So overall it really boils down to directing. Not the voice actor themselves. You just made yourself look very biased. So good job.
Back to my actual comment I think both did a great job as goku but to me Sean scheamel is goku and Peter Kalimis is rolf Sean is the true super sayian god where as Peter is the son of a Shepard
You dare mock the son of a shepherd!?
To me it depends on the artstyle, but yes if Sean had Peter's delivery, he'd be the very best Goku from Ginyu - the End. Because of the artstyle changing during that era of the anime, Ian and Peter's voices matched the younger, lean Goku, but there's no question Sean's voice matches the bulkier, older Goku. The same goes for Drummond vs. Sabat arguments. Sabat's voice just doesn't match Vegeta during the Saiyan Saga up to mid Ginyu.
Na Goku is still very much a childlike warrior character peter fits all version
@@antoniogrady5954 hes talking about not super cause super ruined his character arc DB - GT he feels mature during the buu saga then goes back to his early buu saga childish ways
The fact that he's trying so hard to make an argument with the subtitles is kinda sad, idk if this dude is a troll or Kelamis himself but get a life man
Anybody here after the funimation thing and just seeing what we might get if ocean dub comes back
I'm out of the loop. What's this Funimation thing you speak of?
@@donnymurph The whole KickVic stupidity
It blows my mind Rolf was Goku
Kelamis sounds like hes reading the script word for word, while Sean actually has emotion in what he says
Fr
I don't hear that in sean voice did we watch the same vid
0:48 literally masako nozawa
I can't count the number of times I watched DBZ on CN go from Raditz to Recoome and then start over again with Raditz, with the voices of Corlett and Kelamis. THAT is still Goku's voice for me. When I think of lines like "I know the odds are stacked against me, but if there's a way to win, I'm gonna find it!" and "I saw an opening that seemed to scream 'ATTACK'... so, I did," I hear Kemalis's voice in my head and not Schemmel's. I remember the very first time that CN aired Goku's fight with Jace and Burter, and everyone's voice was different. I hated Goku's new voice, and I still do. I can't stand listening to Schemmel voice Goku. Everything about it is wrong on so many levels (at least to me).
Tbh kelamis is better cause he doesnt backstab fellow VAs, mock pedophiles, call his fans assholes, and Hate TFS.
@Voidaken By mock I mean he acted like one
I did like Kelamis but in some of the scenes I think Schemmel did better to portray a better rendition of exertion rather than the shrill screams from the japanese dubs. Don't get me wrong I watched the series multiple times both JAP and ENG dubbed and I think that Schemmel does a pretty good job now. When he first started he was crappy but so were the whole cast replacement when they continued it after the Ginyu Force. I miss krillin's old voice actor though **EDIT: I just realized his voice acting went up to cell saga but that must have been in Canadian version?**
Idk why people care about this so much
Because it's Dragon Ball.
Be it Z or Super, this crap is gonna happen.
It's called fanboys being fanboys. They can't be happy with both, so they tend to bitch like children.
@@epiccabbage6530 it's just crap
@@valdyrgramr salty
@@playahwon super sucks
while I don't doubt that Kelamis is good, I prefer Schemmels yells much more. he made Goku less of a screecher and more of a yeller, as real life martial artists are. Check your bias, friend. This wasn't much of a comparison due to it.
+Jimmy Notto Schemmel's screaming has become much too repetitive for my tastes. Whether he's powering up, or yelling from pain, it sounds too similar.
Bait4State It doesn’t to me. He sounds a lot more angry when he powers up, when he gets hit it’s more of a grunt. Peter Kelamis was good but not on the level of Sean Schemmel. His voice is like an English portrayal of Masako except with not much effort. Sometimes he strays from that and straight up sounds like a Mickey Mouse club house voice actor and it’s hard to take him seriously. As much as you hate the raveling in his voice when Sean Schemmel screams, I’d say it adds a lot more depth and energy into his screams. That’s the scream many DBZ fans, including myself, were trying to replicate as a child. This video is just a huge biased joke to be blatantly honest. You don’t give an objective critique or a good comparison. From what I’ve seen, Sean Schemmel is the better voice actor for Goku.
Reminder this is the same man who voiced Rolf in Ed edd and eddy
with the kamehacon news sean has reaffirmed himself as the subpar goku
Kelamis is obviously a great voice actor. But I'll always respect Schemmel more and not because I think he is better, but because he stuck to the role. In an interview recently, he did say that it's not a role he particularly likes but he wants to keep doing it so that the people watching the show don't have to go through abrupt voice change. Kelamis however left Goku's role to focus on other aspect of his career, which is fine btw. But it shows what he places above. I would've loved for him to do Goku's voice forever. But unfortunately not to be,
Videoz4u HD To be fair, part of him leaving the role was likely from being tired of the how terrible the dub was handled; They changed voice directors all the time, and it was just an inconsistent mess.
Schwarzorn Oh didn't know that. I certainly liked him better.
...huh.
Never thought I'd see a mature, collected comment stating reasons for one's respect for Schemmel being higher than that for Kelamis down here.
Thank King Kai I kept digging.
Your two cents actually has ground underneath the opinion. Thumbs up man.
"OMG TORIYAMA HAND PICKED NOZAWA!!!" This actually is both true, and untrue. There is a common misconception in this toxic fandom, and that is Toriyama hand picked Masoko Nozawa for Goku. He did, for KID GOKU. Go watch the "We Are Goku" panel on youtube, Sean Schemmel asks Masoko her straight up why she kept the role as an adult. She said that the original plan was to CHANGE THE VOICE TO A MAN WHEN HE BECAME AN ADULT. But there were instances in Japan before when a character became an adult they kept the same actor, and since she had been the only Goku up until then, Toriyama said it was okay to keep her as adult Goku.
tbh Sean can do Goofy Goku pretty well
Kelamis's laugh
"hAhaHAhaHA-"
The Ocean Dub series would have benefited greatly with the Kukuchi score. Kelamis did do a superior movie dub to be sure. To this date the first 3 DBZ movies are the only ones I like to watch in English if I am watching that dub.
“100 times gravity has many benefits Edd boy!”
Peter Kelamis screams like masako.
look i understand ur salty that u didn't grow up with obviously superior schemmel, but spitting random BS in a video to make urself feel better is kinda low, isn't it?
Schemmel did good for the Goku yells and for the serious voices while Peter did great with the more bright and bubbly voice of Goku to Mach the original Japanese voice better
Ok, but i still think its very funny that an at the time 60 year old woman was able to scream better than either of them.
That courage edit at the end got me good. Thank you for sharing your Kelamis appreciation.
schemmels voice is so much more powerful than kelamis. Kelamis sounds like he constantly has a cold and doesn't have half the intimidation of schemmel..Schemmel is the Goku we all know and love
*Wow Man that's Cool!* Goku with Masako-san's approach on his voice!?, I've Never imaginet someone can do that!!, *Thanks!!*
Sean will ALWAYS be my favorite no matter how u put it. Sean is also the only one who did a 13 second solid scream performance when going SSJ3
Exactly
So glad toriyama picked nozawa to be goku instead shows that he knew goku voice was nozawa voice and not Sean's
@@solarpoint4578 you make it sound like he picked her over Sean. He had no say in the English version lol
He just….sounds like Goku. I don’t know any other way to put it,
OP can argue the technical stuff about voice acting but he’s what (English) goku sounds like
Sean is the best Goku. No matter how u put it!
Kelmais sounds like it was the japanese actor speaking in english
2:30 he sounds like that BECAUSE HE IS GETTING BEAT UP FROM THE INSIDE BECAUSE OF THE FUCKING HEART DISEASE
I think it's just bad directing. 🤷🏻♀️ While I don't like Sean that much, I can't deny he's a good fit for Goku.
Sorry, but Schemmel is better. Not only that, but starting at 2:27, they screamed in very similar patterns, yet you criticize Schemmel and praise Kelamis.
+David Hoch Schemmel was grunting, when his body bulked up it sounded like something was hitting him, and then a short scream. Kai was just nonstop raspy screaming. Kelamis was growling, was more subtle but accurate when bulked, then had a smooth, long scream to top it off. They are EXTREMELY different, hardly any similarities. I don't know why I bother, I knew most people wouldn't recognize these small, but drastic details.
If they're so different, the details wouldn't be small. You're just coming up with descriptions that enforce your opinion. Anyone could reverse your descriptions when telling an uninformed person about the two actors, and they would agree. They're similar, so get over it.
+David Hoch Grunting versus growling, sounding like you're getting hit hard or subtle "ha!"s when transforming, that's what I intended to be the "small details", small things not many people would look into or notice. Aside from these, there of course are bigger details that differentiate them, but if you think they're too similar for you to point out these big or small details that make them distinguishable, then good day.
You're splitting hairs and trying to make two similar things sound like opposites. While it's an effective strategy to employ towards a mentally challenged crowd, it doesn't work against someone with more than a remedial understanding of the English language. So yes, good day.
"...trying to make two similar things sound like opposites". I said small and subtle, not exactly strong words geared towards making them appear opposite. Like I said, there are the small details, then there are the bigger ones. Small, like grunting versus growling. I'd consider one of the bigger contrasts being Kelamis sounding similar to Nozawa, where as Schemmel ended up with a Corlett sounding voice. Thanks for the comments.
Kelamis still has the best Kaioken yell, i wish i could hear his version of the SSJBlue +Kaioken
kaioken times ten!!!
No he does not. Goku in Kai have the BEST Kaioken yell.
0:52 Sean Schemmel taking more breaths is a good thing since the kaioken is supposed to be draining on Goku and he should be taking millions of breaths since it’s hard to pull of while Peter Kelamis takes two breaths and it seems as if the kaioken is barely draining and can be pulled out as a get out jail free card with no problems
Tbh it's less the actors fault and more so the dub director. Schemmel never even got to hear the original Japanese till much later, he had no reference. Listen to him in Kai and in Super and you'll notice how much better he's gotten.
Peter sucks he sounds like a Scooby Doo character Sean is the man.
KingJohnny 94 wdym Peter sounds closer to The Japanese Voice Of goku.
You exactly described why he sucks ;)
@@blackfoxhound6801 yep exactly why he sucked as well
@@dezgaming8871 sean is better
@@bakasta5992 sean is better (ocean dub sucks)
I’ll be honest I kind of liked Kirby Marrow as Goku myself...
I love how incredibly biased this is.
Peter Kelamis makes me feel like I'm watching Dragon tales rather than Dragon Ball Z.😂
Damn you know you just make Kelamis look bad with this.
Peter Kelamis the first one to say kaioken right.
I love Kelamis as Goku but Sean does a great job.
I'm not a big fan of Sean Schemmel as a person, but I love his work!
This video proces that you dont know what you are talking about! You keep telling us that Sean fails All the time, but tbh there are a whole team who decide what lines they use and what lines they dont use.. Get your facts together
I can't believe how much this guy hates Sean Schemmel dude Sean voice actor is amazing how do you not see it
Opinions exist
Four breathes?Its because he was said to do so.If you have watched Fusion Reborn then you should know he screamed 46sec straight forward in one breath.
I totally agree with everything your saying about Peter
he brings the emotion and power in his lines and screams
Sean is great too, He has his awesome moments
but i feel like Kelamis' Goku is more unique than Sean's
Omg Sean’s voice is amazing
I prefer Sean Schemmel, in my opinion it sounds more real for the character. :)
+Gustavo Alvarez I appreciate all the points and how in depth you went to come to this conclusion.
Taking two breaths for a scream doesn’t make someone amazing or better. It made him strain his voice and crack a little due to him losing breath which actually makes it awkward. Sean even though takes more breaths, gives goku more character and ups the intensity of what he’s actually doing. And besides, copying another actor is one thing but improvising, making it your own, and adding quality to a work makes you the better actor.
I can understand not liking Sean, especially with all the controversies he's been in, as well as how he and the others tossed Vic out of FUNimation because of Monica Rial's false allegations.
The dislikes prove you wrong.
Rahat Duary Dislikes prove nothing
Look At My Face! Yup. Except, you know...that a lot of people dislike it.
That's not how opinions work. I like Schemmel, but his and Kelamis's contemporary work are incomparable. Kelamis was way better.
Barndo M that's exactly how it works dumbfuck. Many people disliked it because they believe sean is better.
You completely missed the point. If everyone in the world but one person has an opinion, it doesn't mean those droves of people having that opinion "proves" the one person "wrong." Sean is not some infallible, amazing actor just because you watched him and not someone else play Goku as a kid. Sean's performance was simply not very good early on, and that's because he was inexperienced and poorly directed.
Sean Schemmel is a douchebag but I do prefer him as Goku. That was the Goku I would hear on Toonami midnight run. Kelamis is awesome though and he's the best son of shepard.
I think Peter Kelamis should voice Sonic the Hedgehog.
You are Dumb
Yep he sh0uld
Hell no
Peter Kelamis for me is the voice of goku
Dosent matter how many breaths he took when his voice sounds better. And also he never said kaioken wrong after that NONE CANON movie . Kelamis literally sounds like an abridged version
kelamis has the edge when it comes to energy and passion but I dont like his accent/voice as much as I like Schemmels.
Tobias Gustavsson I agree. Kelamis seems a bit better as an actor but Schemmels voice is much more memorable. In my opinion anyways.
PlayDae yes exactly! :D
+PlayDae watch rof
Holy Big Green, someone respect's others' opinions down here?!
I DEMAND TO KNOW WHAT WITCHCRAFT THIS IS!
Schemmel is superior you're just too off in your own world to see it lol
Kelamis is goofy and stilted as shit. Loved him as rolf, but not as goku.
Objectively, Peter is better.
Nuance, tonality, script, sound mixing, referencing Nozawa's performance etc. Sean found his voice for Goku, but he lacks in other areas. He doesn't sound as natural as Peter does. Toriyama picked Nozawa so she is the standard. Therefor Peter is the definitive english sounding Japanese version of Goku even over Ian corlett (did a great job too).
So, while I agree with most
2:26
"He sounds like he has a cold or is taking it up the ass"
He's got a heart dieses that is making it VERY difficult for Goku to function, going super just adds to the strain he's already experiencing so Sean actually did a half decent job conveying that strain
It doesn't, it sounds awkward. A heart disease doesn't make you sound nasally.
I like Sean better, but it's interesting that in the World's Strongest clip he sounds a lot like Nozawa. .
Masako Nozawa > all PERIOD !
Damn straight!
Sean Schemmel is the best goku voice actor .. Peter's voice sound disappointing like yamcha
..how, exactly?
Fun fact Peter is also the voice of Rolf in Ed Edd n Eddy
So this is the guy that played the weasel from Barbie Rapunzel
I do like Peter better as Goku, I feel he maintained the same spirit that Masako Nozawa created in her performance as Goku, where as Sean seemed to do his own thing and really changed the whole feel of the character for me.
Naaah , Sean's rendition of Goku's voice is EXACTLY what Goku 's voice is supposed to sound like , hands down
Ikr Goku is and will always be played by schemmel kelamis sound like a guy angry cause he started him self
Actually the creator of the series Akira Toriyama said that Masako Nozawa is how he imagined Goku to sound. It's fine if you prefer Sean but if you actually think that's how Goku should talk, I'm afraid you don't understand the character.
+David Verissimo trueeeeee
LukeMM95 He imagined kid goku.
Ripper 30 I'm pretty sure he was but when she was originally picked and imagined it was for kid goku.
Shemmel is the best voice actor, he takes breaths to make it more dramatic
Jake English Dramatic my ass
Kelamis sounds like a 12 year old skateboarder. I’m literally so thankful Schemmel is the voice actor they chose.
The big difference here is not the two voice actors performance it's the localisation.
The ocean dub here has a better grasp on the source material.
It's never been Kay-o-Ken
It's Kai-o-Ken. It's King Kai's technique not King Kay's.
Kaio-Ken being something the funimation dub sometimes gets wrong and sometimes gets right. It's just unnecessarily inconsistent.