I used to work for a German company. They closed 2 factories in Germany and 1 in Poland and opened new factories in India. And they boasted that they "reduced emissions".
That's what you get when you allow people in positions of power who make laws based on how the world should look like and not how it actually works. Seriously, I despair of our Green party. It's like they don't know what cynicism is.
Well if they operate in the USA with a repackaging facility, they can bulk ship items from India on pallets, repackage the items in retail containers and sell them as as "Made in the USA" per the laws and regulations.
Sabine Hossenfelder, I've been working in UK for a firm for 2 years. I must say that it's ten times worse in England than Germany! Hearing your British accent and the way you're portraying the negativities in Germany, I think you're suffering from GERMANOPHOBIA! Just like the REFEREE Anthony Taylor who stole 1 goal from Germany, not allowing them an obvious penalty! That was broad day ROBBERY! Fazit : Sport is not only sport, it's also political, a billion dollars business!
The character pointed at a broken elevator sign and said "this is the empire declining". The person he was talking to thought he was exaggerating, but he went on to explain: if low cost but highly visible repairs are being neglected, what do you think happens to the high cost invisible ones? If infrastructure is decaying, the empire is already falling. From Asimov's Foundation.
@@tedmossmy friend spoke to Asimov at a con many years ago. Asimov told him that if you want to create some great SF, take some known history and file the serial numbers off. In Asimov’s case with FOUNDATION, he set the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire in space, and mixed in some statistical mechanics (which he certainly knew from chemistry and physics), and applied it to people.
I'm afraid much of this true in the U.S. as well-- neglected infrastructure, slow responses, etc. The Democratic party in particular, for 4+ years just hoping that they could keep hiding Biden's dementia and it would somehow magically get better by 2024 instead of planning ahead.
I'm Canadian but my mother is German and my father is English, so how do I feel watching two great people I've always respected and held in high regard, destroy their countries and perform some strange form of group suicide. Don't expect people like me to come and help because I'm too busy fighting the same evil in Canada, the English and Germans will have to wake up themselves or perish. Time is running out.
Look at the amount of VC money, patents and start ups in the US. A lot of it is bs, but the rest is not. Which companies are the modern digital tech giants? Which economy still grew this and last year? The US definitely does A LOT wrong, but they are the technology leaders
@@calculuslover2078 China, Scandinavian countries, Iceland(not sure if Iceland is considered Scandinavian), Costa Rica maybe. I don't know, that's all I got.
The Germans are not victims of success but are dealing with a political class that hates them. Why put in effort when you aren't even on the list of priorities.
I visited Germany for the first time this year and this describes germans perfectly. They have no notion of how is their country in comparation with the world. How it was made that way and that they are wasting it. Simply asuming it to be the norm and that it is always that way everywhere. Nations are built when people band together to create something for them and their descendants. Being culture, institutions, goverment or wathever symbol or ideal can define a country. At this moment the common denominator in Germany that keeps it moving is money. It is no secret that Germany is one of the richest countries of the world. But let's just consider what would happen if that one day suddenly wasn't the case. Fortune is known to be a fickle mistress. So what will unite germany the day in which their industrial machine becomes so degraded that it will start breaking appart? That is something that concerns me.
As a brit living in Germany and having to work with the people here, and with the school system too for my family, it amazes me the total panic that hits the face of almost any German when something does not go to plan. In other countries i have lived and worked in, having something missing or not go to plan results in a smile and a lets see what we can do. Here it is from my perspective just hilarious the reaction. But don't get me wrong, i love living here, maybe because i am in an area with decent internet connectivity!
@ I am sadly aware having lived in other parts of Germany previously and managing a team of over 20 people here. I certainly live in a bubble at the moment here having grown up in a shit hole council estate and lived in the worst parts of London during the 90’s. Bubbles have a habit of bursting though.
We're friends with a Ukrainian family who fled to Bavaria when the war began and then returned to Ukraine, citing the abysmal internet speeds as the reason. Not joking here, that did happen.
Well things have finally taken a turn for the better in the UK these past couple of days. And we're starting to claw our way back out of our hole without filling up government seats with fascists, so there's that at least.
joking aside, but German technological debt is our common problem. It doesn't matter whether you live in Poznań or Napoli. Somehow we must overcome their hard-headedness, otherwise our children's future will be dependent on whimsical nationalists ones from Beijing and Delhi.
@@cybernetic-ransomware1485 I come from the future (Argentina) the key is not to let the government take all the decisions. Establish GOOD, SOLID channels for the private sector to take the initiative. Here in 1945 we had a great general conman, called Perón, a right winger, but greatly inspired by Mussolini, so in short with the statist interventionist heart of a lefty. To the point of dissapearing anyone resembling a commie, while he was out intervening in markets. He believed in technology advance as a way to gain an edge over our foes. The result? The enemy infiltrated, government spent BILLIONS into Cold Fusion (never got it to work, ofc) and we got a series of coup d'tats. Sad thing about Perón is he actually got the country industrialized. But his populist legacy was a bigger part than he could've ever imagined, spawning a cult of followers that more or less still impede the country from working properly. All because he from his ivory tower threw some books and mattresses to the impoverished masses. Modern peronists (kirchnerists) are full on commies, socialists that attack private property and your freedom to decide over your business, your life, etc. But still with the fascist gene attached to it. So they're willing to create narratives (with crisis actors) and use TERROR from the STATE to MANIPULATE THE POPULATION and SUBJUGATE THEM into NOT voting a right winger. They've created a culture much like Sabine here says, of being SLOW, of being overall INOPERANT when faced with their tasks. Every challenge they tackle, it makes things worse. Each thing they do "for us" ends up as another point where they meddle in the affairs of the people and decide over their lives. While they can BARELY run a country themselves. Impoverishing due to monetary emission and price controls that lead to poor stock replenishment and worse quality control. Them being slow has NOTHING to do with their intelligence though. To steal, they're always one step ahead. Look into who they contract for the Internet / Railroad / Energy improvements, and you'll SEE precisely WHY they chose them. They're all playing for the same team. The socialists that run the country like a capitalist country, but the only ones that TRULY enjoy a FREE market are the politicians and their businessmen friends. The rest of us lowlives can't compete because the government has the monopoly over violence. So if a competitor to their friends makes it big, they can always saddle them with regulation and taxes or even take legal action with penalty fees. The politicians and the caste they formed that surrounds them have a small little crown that elevates them from us, the common folk. They don't have more rights, they have more PRIVILEGES, which are SECURED by their legislation. It's time to ATTACK that system of political clientelism, populism and incresing interventionism and bring it to the ground. Let companies of men and women dedice the course. Don't let those callous with pride and arrogance, who believe themselves to be God to act on behalf of a nation. Taking the reigns of something so complex as market, which is composed by all agents and all goods/services being transferred is tantamount to heresy. To know everything about a market to take such a wild decision, you'd need to know the CURRENT, PAST, and FUTURE state of EVERYTHING AND EVERYONE in it. Including each individual's personal preferences, and plans. You'd need to be omniscient. You'd need to be God. And politicians ARE NOT GOD.
@@giovannipiacen85 I think you have to be among the dead to be able to speak German, and since you couldn't laugh, you have already become one of the dead.
Frenchman here. Sabine you most surely know better about Germany but, to be fair, most European countries have similar problems and even the UK, you cite as a reference: aging population, immigration-related issues, degraded training / education issues. Even in the USA, China have issues of their own. The entire world except Africa is facing a population collapse. Here, in France, we used to have a nice Electricity production system based on Nuclear energy but François Hollande (Socialist with "Green" friends) decided to stop the investment because it was a politically fashionable idea so in 2022 almost 50% of our Nuclear power plants were stopped because of maintenance falling behind and lack of replacement projects. Luckily this is fixed we are building new Nuclear power plants and foresee to export record levels of electricity. IMO, the trouble is people say what they don't want (UK= no more EU), Germany= no more nuclear, USA=no more Ukraine spendings, France= lets work less, etc). So, here in France the issues are different: the infrastructure is usually excellent but people have this culture of its government wasting money and have deficits all over the place. Aging population means that the working people are not the same as 20 years ago (French people replaced often with african people) meaning that the training level has deteriorated and some degree of France-hating attitude.
As a Romanian, we've always dreamed of being on the same level as Germany. Our railway system is as bad as it was 30yrs ago, so somehow our dreams of being on the same level are coming true but for the wrong reasons 🤣🤣
So that means that Ceaușescu wasn't that bad at all he was killed for what ?😅 he made the the roads the railway we produced everything ourselves and in 30 years nothing changed o almost forgot yeah no factory's thousand all shut down thousands off jobs lost everyone started after 1989 to go work outside of Romania because yeah well people lost there jobs 😅 the food now is almost poison thats how bad it is now 😂 nature destroyed Hectares of woods all cut down. the corruption is higer then ever eu funds not going where should go but in pocket of individuals in a high position (power) 😂 infected with LGBTQ drugs and violence 😅 yeah Romania did not win anny good in 30 years we did lost all our value's that we had 30 years ago
I visited Romania many times in the 90s and I loved the railway system. Trains were always on time. They were a bit old maybe but still worked as intended. No delays. I was even lucky enough to be invited by friends to work one day on the railway. We went around and did maintenance work on the electricity cables above the tracks. True, the ticket inspectors were a bit corrupt. As I learned more Romanian I realized that they always asked me if I needed a ticket. If I was leaving the train before their route was ended and they were replaced by another ticket inspector, I could buy the ticket at half the price but I did not receive a ticket. They just pocketed the money. It is not good for the state to be cheated on the money plus tax but people reasoned that they never saw any benefits from the tax anyways. Hopefully that bit has changed by now.
I am a close follower of the events taking place in Germany. I travel there quite often. In my humble opinion, the source of all the country management mistakes come from decisions being made based on ideology instead of facts, technology and common sense
Lets do a root source investigation. The mentioned topics are: 1. Privatization of the DB (1.1.1994). This was based on economical reasons and regulatory requirements of the EU. 2. Bad digital infrastructure: This is based on decisions made against glass fiber in the mid 90s based on influence of the lobbyist Leo Kirch 3. Nuclear phase-out (2011 after Fukushima, due to pressure of 70-80% of the population) 4. Hydrogen strategy (2020, called "Nationale Wasserstoffstrategy", NWS) These events are well-documented and widely known. Even all of them occured on behalf of the same political party, where is the ideology here? I can see economical reasons, lobbyism or political pressure from the people. Maybe for the NWS - I'm not familiar with this topic because of hydrogen
@@benlovell9416 mostly yes. But the extent to which a developed and reliable Germany is spoiling what used to be an advantageous and leading position in many fields is way above the average. She explains it well in the video, but the list could go on for much longer. The trend is so worrying
I visited Germany before, I am Brazilian and spent a lot of time in China too.I also visited Portugal, Spain and Italy in Europe, in Latin America I visited Paraguay, Argentina and Urugay, in Asia I visited South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Apart from China Mainland. For me it's like this: Asia is like 10x better comparing with 10 years ago, everything, cleaner, better maners, daily tech (optic fiber, 5g cover, instant payment system), airports, trains, highways, all got much better. Latin America: Slow improvements, but still improvements, mainly in the countryside things got much better (I do live in the countryside), daily tech much much better, internet everywhere, private schools and hospitals got incredible better, so even if things are slow to improve, at the end of the day, they improved. Europe: Just general decay, Apart from the historical stuff, everything felt kind of old and slow, nothing happening, visited some factories but they where not competitive, expensive stuff but nothing special, old infrastructure, flights canceled, bad airports, old hotels, depressed people. I know a lot of things still better in Germany for instance, than in Brazil and China, but specially in the regions I live and stay (which by the way and in the countryside in both countries), I can see a lot of improvements in the last decade, but I saw the opposite in Europe
The UK lowered its own carbon emmissions by selling its manufacturing base to other countries that don't care about such things, thus boosting global emmissions.
This is the dirty not so secret of the rise of China. Companies sidestep regulation by offshoring. Meanwhile politicians claim victory for declining emissions.
So did every other Western nation. Now we have low carbon emissions and no more danger of CLIMATE CHANGE!😂 Actually, we all are a bunch of suckers who believed a lie and sold what was really valuable to China, and now just like Sabina, we are noticing the effects of our long decline to poverty, and we still think we’re saving the planet. Putting manufacturing in the hands of the most incompetent countries around the world and expecting a good result is insane.
When I was stationed in Germany (79-82) the German trains were always on time. It was considered a major scandal if a train was 5 minutes late. It bothers me that things have gone to hell
@@werkzeugmann6224 I'm not surprised the military shut down most bases in Germany. A lot of the bases were leftovers from the distant past. In Wurzburg, where I was stationed, the facilities were left over from the distant past. One facility still had rings in the walls to tie up horses. The hospital where I worked started life as a Luftwaffe hospital.
Moved to Germany in 1990, and was going back in time to the US in the 60’s. So many bureaucratic systems slowed down progress and put them behind. Like the 60’s, however socializing and the living environment were very pleasant for me. Less than a forty hour work week. Pregnancy leave of 3 months both paid and a birthing bonus; mandatory one to two-week hospital stay. Much slower pace. When I moved to Austria in ‘92, time sped back up to present day.
Im British in London, the fact she thinks this means germany must be doing REALLY bad or she might have a misunderstanding of the UK. We have same issues with trains, regarding strikes and privatisation. But the infrastructure itself, though dated, its quite good, just expensive.
As an American, seeing another American mock a German for making a comparison to the U.K. seems out of pocket considering our own crumbling infrastructure and almost complete lack of public transit, owing to suburban sprawl’s congestive car based planning and the kind of political erosion which underpins a government on the verge of a geriatric smack down between two brain addled narcissists.
Does this imply that Swedes are children? As a person of Swedish decent I find this rather insulting. For me, it is more 'adult' to reach the kind of social compromises that the Swedes are famous for, understanding that life is complex and rigid rules based systems are always inadequate.
@@davefaulkner6302sounds to me like you’re romanticizing your Swedish heritage. I used to do the same with my German heritage but I learned that the greatest strength of any culture is also its greatest weakness
Late and cancelled trains are practically a Swedish trademark and broadband internet access..ah, the glorious "open infrastructure" of fiberoptic networks with one owner and maintainer and a number of actors (ISPs available within each network) that are trying to compete with each other, when the network owner and maintainer sets the rent that the ISPs have to pay and this rent increases every year (where I am, in a major city, the bit about raising prices each year is explicitly stated) and of course the ISPs charge the customers more and since all live under the same network owner there isn't a lot to differentiate the isps in terms of connection speeds or pricing.
@@svr5423 I used British trains in 1993. If I remember correctly there was only one line. From Dover to Edinburgh. It was so archaic. Trains were up to 2 hours late in London. We would have thought we were in the 19th century.
I'm in the West Mids. Trains run when they want to. An evening commute of four hours to get from Birmingham to South East Staffordshire is a regular occurrence... Cancelations and delays are a daily occurrence.
@@SabineHossenfelderi will very happy to see the decline of German economy because you so submissive and has no sovereignty 😊 you "didn't want" (as masters says you) cheap russian natural gas from pipelines so now you must buy expensive LNG from US and Russia (and russian fertilizers indeed), and your economy just can't compete against normal adequate countries. That's why your companies rushed to relocate to US or China P.s. did you hear something about "pipeline explode" investigation recently? I'm not 😂 because you can't do it against a will of your overseas masters.
Hopefully when the time comes Germans won't be so cucked to accept world government which will likely be promoted by a fake alien presense. @@SabineHossenfelder
I've been working in a German company now for 6 years. The biggest issue is that achieving goals is not the priority, but following a process. And when something is performing poorly, you like better adding more process rather than thinking what is the best way to achieve the goal. At the end you work for the process.
@@IThinkICare it depends. Public institutions are full of processes for example, it does not guarantee any success, quality, etc. Many just get comfy behind a process, or use it to hide behind. Processes are great, but not the goal.
Every country has its embarrassments. Here in Ireland we are building a National Children's Hospital that has been ongoing for YEARS, is now the most expensive hospital IN THE WORLD, EVER and is still not built. No one wants to take responsibility. As one commentator said "It's being passed around like a bag of shit that's on fire."
Well Berlin airport also took 29 years for similar reasons. If judge based on my colleagues (whos pay is above average) their top priorities are feierabend and "not my responsibilty". All our projects delayed for 3 years, and its only by current deadlines. Who knows how long will it take in reality
Ireland is still one of the best countries in the world to live. Maybe if you lived in a really shitty country for a while you'd be more grateful for what we have here in Ireland.
I remember visiting Flensburg a few years ago with my family. My son wanted to go fishing by the sea. I knew we needed a permit as we do in Denmark. Turned out we had to go to a counsil office, wait in line, fill in a long paper form with all kind of details and pay in cash. It took a couple of hours out of our short holiday. In my home country Denmark, we just go to a website and pay the fee.
The funny thing is - you could get a permit in Schleswig-Holstein - you won't get any in Lower Saxony because you need a german fishing exam. It is crasy...
I wonder if english countries do tech easier, with so much of basics being based in english. So I try to cut East and Central Europe a little slack. Most coding is in pure english, that's sorta not fair but history is not fair.
Hours to buy a fishing license? Even Pennsylvania (USA) can get it done faster than that: Walk into practically any sporting goods store or hardware store, put down your money, walk out with a hunting license, trapping license, or fishing license in about the time it takes you to write down your name, address, phone number, age, and date of birth.
When a physicist gets a speeding ticket, twice, in one journey, clearly there is something wrong with the space-time continuum. You weren't speeding Sabine, Germany was just slowing down.
I once worked with a guy who sped off on a Friday to get to his home (far from the office). He managed to get enough speeding tickets in one journey to get banned outright. They all just add up, they don't say "well you had your quota that day"!.
So climate change is a high priority for the elite? As they guzzle and fly around their private jets around the world, releasing much more carbon than a single person would release. I remember the COP conferences on climate change, 400+ private jets; literally descended in one location to preach climate change lol. Its funny how the elite can pollute at their hearts content and then preach to the common people that climate change is a big threat. Hypocrisy.
As others have said it is not just Germany. I am in the UK and with all the delays it took me 11 hours to travel 100 miles on public transport. At one point the bus driver announced he had to stop for 45 minutes as he had reached the legal limit he was allowed to drive for. This of course resulted in missing the next connection and thus another hours delay waiting for the next bus and so it went on...
Do not blame The driver and his right to ok working conditions. Blame The fact that more and more infrastructure is privatized and all not profitable routes are closed or with very few daily departures. From what I understand we are also heading towards smart-cities with all people Living in these cities and NOT in The countryside. And are supposed to stay at Home due to The 15-minutes city concept - and are not supposed to travelling around. Correct me if I am misinformed and why
That's totally inept management at work. I often see 2 bus drivers on Stagecoach buses when one driver is getting shadowed by a more experienced driver for one reason or another. I don't see any reason why the bus company couldn't simply do that and have the extra driver just snooze until there is a shift change to cover the time that a single driver can't legally wprk for.
@@BigJohnson-g3jIt's incredible to me that socialism is still tolerated in Europe after what's happened over the last 250 years. It's so obviously a bad idea. This is why I've become convinced universal sufferage democracy isn't sustainable. If people are so ignorant thay they will entertain socialism they shouldn't be involved in decision making. Sad reality...
@@BigJohnson-g3j capitalism is way worse for public transportation since it would push abandoning non profitable roads btw, and on top of that, I'd say it's mostly caused by wanting short term profit by making poor and rushed urban planning letting us with very impractical infrastructure in general
In the early 1970's I bought a machine for my factory. It was made in Germany. That machine performed flawlessly, until 2018, then it broke down. That was one heck of a machine, I am very *_very_* impressed ! So, I hired engineers from Germany to fix that machine, using all imported German parts. 3 years later, it broke again. This time, the parts that were broken were all the *NEW* parts that were installed just 3 years prior, and those *NEW* parts were all made-in-Germany. What a contradiction ! The first time the machine broke down, it had worked for more than 45 years. Yes, *_more than forty-five long years_*_ !_ The second time the machine broke down, the parts lasted 3 years. Same work. Same work amount. Same everything. Except for, the quality of the *NEW* German parts were so flimsy, if I'm a German, I would be embarrassed. We contacted the company in German, we talked to the German engineers who came to fix the machine for us, and they told us one thing, and one thing only ---- back in the 1970's, all German parts were made as if they were going to last forever. Now, all German parts are being made with *_planned obsolescence_* built in. I thanked the German engineers for telling me the truth. So, Ms. Sabine, you gotta understand, the Germany today is no longer the Germany 40 years ago.
Most of the things, if not everything, is made with planned obsolescence in mind, that's the way of the capitalism. It's not only Germany who is doing that. Just pointing that out. It's sad that planned obsolescence is even a thing. It's sad and stupid.
ms. Sabine is part of the problem i'm afraid. As a scientist you should never ever let activism cloud your scientific methods. But she does that when climate change is the topic on hand. "I'm not an expert, but I believe.....blablabla...it sound ethically blablabla" Everything is going to shit and it's because germany has accepted so many lies by so many liers it doesn't even know what truth is any longer. 200.000 bright minds leave every year and the won't come back. Rightfully so. We're leaving to. Eff that politically correct neo-socialist state
I'm avid vintage car collector, but also have a newer MB SLK 350... The quality of some components are not that good, similar to some modern American cars... Beautiful looking car though!
You've not seen 'Ja, das Hokey Kokey'. Man schteckt die linke Arm aus Ein, aus, ein, aus Man schütteln alles rund Man macht das Hokey-Kokey Und man dreht sich herum Das ist die ganze Sache
1 billion population in India but divided, disconnected, superstitious. I wish my heart turns into stone and mind freezes. Child labor, female foeticide, caste system, corruption, unemployment, illiteracy. I wish I could meet god, ask questions. Why such disparity, why such pain? Free mind freez!
@@Krn7777w At the very least India seems on the up and up. Things were so bad there before that it is better in a relative way. In Germany and many western countries the feeling is the opposite where things are going down hill. This perception has grave social consequences historically.
In Italy, we usually refer to Germany as the perfect example of punctuality and efficiency for trains. Having traveled a bit in the last few years, I can say that Spain, Italy (excluding the very south) and France are light years ahead.
@@leobe2104 the Bahn can only do as well as the politicians running the show. And let’s not act like this has only become a problem under this administration…
@@Soundbrigade nope, bald guy would rather invest in the army than the railway. Saying that the trains were on time is the stereotypical thing that the weird single uncle says at Christmas' lunch when someone points out our current problems.
The only good thing about the German railway system is that it's extremely interconnected, with a lot of branch lines to small villages, whereas in Italy many of those were closed to favor the automobile industry.
Normally, being slow is a good thing when going in the wrong direction. Anyway, our German contribution to solving the world's problems: showing everyone else how not to do it.
The US would like a word. The problems are not evenly distributed. Where I am there is no train service at all to speak of even though I live in an important regional metropolis. I do have access to fiber internet, however.
If not for the Russia-Ukraine drama, things would be comparatively more stable. Should've worked harder for peace rather than jumping into war because a certain dumdum thought that it was a good way for the local companies of *some country* to benefit.
Seriously, we have zero quality public transit in the US. The east coast at least should be covered in rail networks for easy and efficient transportation. There's so many cities that would be wonderful with light rail too. Instead we need to own our own expensive machine and take on the mind numbing task of commuting by car everywhere.
@@kylebeatty7643 regional trains absolutely need to be built in the US. Amtrak needs high speed rail for distances of 100 to 150 miles. Flying makes more sense for transcontinental travel, no need to invest in a transcontinental high speed rail line (yet). That means shit should be easier to build, but the problem in the US is the red tape, local governments, and individual NIMBYs. Look at how long it’s taken California: 20 years of planning, billions already spent, and it’s only now starting to be built.
America: Alright, bet. Green technology is now a political conspiracy and all attempts at progress will be met with armed resistance. Also, about 15-30% of the country wants the country to become a theocracy and we're willing to do anything to make it happen. Ala "Project 2025"
@@authenticbaguette6673 does it still run a single 480p youtube stream ? i had this speed up until 2014, then finally got 50 Mbit/s and now a am on GPON fiber which is a blessing
German lifehack for speeding up Internet access: Ask a friend in Belgium to download the files for you, store it on a USB stick, then you ride over there with your bike to pick it up.
Your saying that in Germany "The Wi-Fi is so slow that by the time the news is streaming it has become an historical documentary" got a good laugh out of me. It kills the notion that Germans don't have a sense of humor. Not that I ever believed it.
We do have Wi-Fi in Germany? I'm still waiting for my phone line I ordered in 1991. okay, 1st part is a joke, but 2nd part is reality, they never delivered
Howdy, Northern neighbours, Swiss-Austrian dual citizen based in Vienna here. It's funny: When I was a child in the 80s and 90s, out of the German-speaking countries Austria was the one that felt the most "backwards" and actually a bit "Eastern-blocky" as my relatives in Switzerland used to joke. The stereotype, confirmed by massive anecdotical evidence, was that, for example, international trains would inevitably start accumulating delays as soon as they had entered Austria. Back then, (West) Germany was somewhat in between - not as well-organized as Switzerland, but pretty solid. Within the last 20 years, Austria and Germany have somehow switched roles. While Austria has modernized a lot, Germany increasingly feels like Austria used to feel 30-40 years ago. What I also find quite funny is the different ways in which the Swiss and the Austrians deal with the fact that, since a lot of our trains come in from Germany, the constant delays of Deutsche Bahn are messing up our own timetables: By now, the Swiss always have a few extra trains ready at the border and, if the German train is delayed, they simply run an extra Swiss train on the Swiss part of the route. The Austrians don't do that, but they make up for it by making their announcements as passive-aggressive as possible ("Unfortunately, train so and so is still 55 minutes delayed because, once again, the hand-over by Deutsche Bahn at the border was delayed by 90 minutes. On behalf of Austrian Railways, we would like to apologize for the inconvenience caused to our passengers by Deutsche Bahn.").
Austria's technological prowess is not to be underestimated. They have revolutionized the light aircraft market in the US, with Rotax and Austro engines and Diamond airframes. It used to be that a ~150 ps aircraft engine displaced 7 liters and weighed 140kg. Now a Rotax engine produces 158 ps from 1.4 liters and I can pick it up and carry it around by myself.
Kann ich bestätigen. Österreich und Ganz besonders Wien ist wunderschön. War zum Urlaub mehrmals dort und habe n Monat dort gearbeitet. Eine der besten Zeiten meines Lebens. Liebe Grüße ans schöne Wien. ❤️
@@YogiAI To be fair though - as much as I love myself some good old-fashioned German-bashing as we are so fond of in the small neighouring countries - I think the extremely high cost of German re-unification is often under-estimated. I would not necessarily say that Austrian, Swiss, or Dutch politicians have been so much smarter than their German counterparts in the past few decades, but they could afford to make some mistakes and still have enough money to modernize infrastructure and public administration as well as to create reasonably good conditions for private enterprise.
German road works take months where other countries need just days. Seen this in the US, Spain, Portugal and just two weeks ago in Denmark. During the week we stayed, they repaved like 20km road with little impact on traffic. They also repaved the center of a small village within 2 days!
I worked with a German company in the 1970's installing automation in a continuous casting steelworks. The competence and standards were very high, they only had two standards, perfect and upwards, nothing else was acceptable. I learned a lot about German perfectionism and it was impressive. I learned a fair bit of the language as well, but that was a long time ago
This approach is still present but it has to compete with the corruption that has taken root in much of the country, both state and federal government are infected and so far, its not enough to make people actually aware of what's going on because the carefully constructed lies still hold up.
@ Die Geschichte endet jedoch nicht hier. Das Büro liegt in einer abgelegenen Gegend, in der er selbst wohnt, was ihm den Vorteil verschafft, jeden Morgen pünktlich um 08:00 Uhr im Büro zu sein - und ganz ehrlich, das ist das Einzige, was er gut macht. Die anderen Kollegen kommen aus den Städten, und leider ist die Deutsche Bahn nicht mehr zuverlässig, was dazu führt, dass viele zu spät kommen. Er hat es geschafft, eine Mitarbeiterin, die ihm in ihrer Leistung und Kompetenz haushoch überlegen war, entlassen zu lassen, indem er sich täglich bei der Geschäftsleitung beschwert hat. In Wahrheit ist die Produktivität dieses Managers sehr gering, und er besitzt unzureichende Fähigkeiten für seine Position. Ich denke, er wird dort länger bleiben als die talentierten Mitarbeiter, die es wirklich verdient hätten, dort zu sein. 🤣
Thank you very much for this video. I worked in Germany for years and enjoyed collaborating with my German colleagues tremendously. However, I learnt the following important rules: - do not commute by train (Deutsche Bahn will make you hate trains even if you loved them before); - do not hope for German politicians to raise investment in infrastructure, education, research and development, or digitalization (even if they frequently state how important doing so would be for our prosperity); - keep new ideas that would simplify bureaucracy for yourself (they are seen as offensive, even if they are intended as helpful); - do not try something new (if you fail, you will be grilled, if you succeed, someone else will claim responsibility); Anyway, I hope things will improve again at some point, so keep spreading the message as loud as you can.
I don't think these new ideas are seen as offensive, it's just that people probably already thought of them and troed it themselves, but people higher up are so slow and opposed to change that it lead to nothing, so they are just annoyed as they know how to improve the situation, they just can't do anything about it
liebe Sabine, ich bin seit 2022 nicht mehr in meinem Heimatland, als Künstlerin fehlte mir zunehmend die Luft zum Atmen, die Offenheit zu kontroversem Austausch, der gegenseitige Respekt. Es ist alles zunehmend ideologisch
So talking about trains. I am not a German citizen and came here for masters. Once I was coming from a place and the last train at Frankfurt suddenly got cancelled and the funny thing is there was no substitute service available so basically I have to sit on the station till 7am. When I told this story to my German friends they simply replied. Willkommen in Deutschland.
Rule 0: NEVER rely on the last train in Germany. The last train (or bus) only exists as a backup if the earlier train gets cancelled, breaks down or disappears in a black hole. Edit: If you think the "black hole" was just a joke, no, it wasn't. I have already been in the situation where a train hasn't been seen along any station of it's way but somehow moved itself to the end station while being displayed as "perfectly in time" in the app.
The biggest problem in Germany is all the paperwork. There are so many laws that they send you from one place to another, and you have to pay a lot of money just to find out what permission you need.
We had this paperwork 30 years ago as well. More work, better results. While bureaucracy is nevertheless a burden, the decline of Germany has other causes.
I switched from "fiber" to wireless and the copper cable for multiple km. Because my "fiber" was unusable due to having multi second lag spikes every minute.
I love your sense of humor. Every video I'll crack up at least once or twice. I love the subtle sarcasm. The biting sense of being fed up with everything.
Last year I traveled around England for 5 weeks and dealt with cancelled trains and strikes and hearing people complain about how everything in the country is falling apart. Same things in my own country, Canada. I think it's happening in many developed countries, including Germany, for a variety of reasons.
The dumbest thing the Germans ever did was almost having children way below replacement level then open the doors to mass immigration. Germany as we know it will be gone in 50 years
I fully agree with Sabines assessment. The underlying problem started earlier, though. Germans grew complacent and started living of the success of the past. This in turn led to people focusing on non-issues and neglecting crucial investments into physical infrastructure and efficient bureaucracy. Managing symptoms instead of making right but hard decisions. This has added up.
Your discussion reminds me of Canada, especially our medical care system that has a good quality of technology but is choking with paper bureaucracy. There are far too many nonsense regulations and silly repetitive rules that block getting much done each day. Procrastination is a huge problem. RS. Canada
At work here in Germany I frequently get in trouble for taking initiative and trying to be proactive, I'll foresee a potential problem and try to prevent it only to be told by my bosses to stop. I should rather come to them first and they'll put it in the schedule for next week's meeting by which time the problem has actually arisen and has built up to the point that it affects the efficiency of the whole operation. Instead of allowing me an hour to create a solution that will result in efficiencies the whole way down the line of the project (not to mention increased safety) they wait until it has built up to the point that it takes many more man hours to solve, decreases safety and efficiency of the primary project as well as the solving of the problem, still don't try and mitigate any knock-on effects and then complain that the project is running slow and people aren't working hard enough. This has happened so often that now I usually don't even try, I just catch myself and have a little internal laugh and think "Oh well, it was a nice idea"
It is all about power 😮 How embarrassing for your bosses when a “normal worker” discovers an arising problem and even has an easy solution for this, which was created in one hour! If your bosses let this pass, it would mean, their work and all of the meetings and blabla would be unnecessary. This is how companies work, this is how the health system, administrations and government work… all of the (useless) rules are made to justify and secure the existence of all of the people who could easily be replaced by a few people with common sense😕 Das ist auch ein Problem: umständliche Diskussionen, die zu nichts führen, aber Hauptsache: jeder “wichtige” Mitarbeiter hat was dazu gesagt… der gesunde Menschenverstand und die Eigenschaft Probleme zu erkennen, lösungsorientiert zu denken und die Probleme dann auch zu lösen, wird von den Vorgesetzten im Keim erstickt, weil ja dann ihre Existenz überflüssig wäre….
@@mwallace2922 Nope. not a fair assessment. In AU you have initiative and things are moving fast. I know, I live in AU, and born French. Ozzies have no idea how "lucky" they are. Yeah renting is bad, but it's the same all over the West. The rest of the country works and move fw. When I arrived I was in awe at no queues to get a driver license. So fast, so efficient, so seamless, and with a smile. Try France and go eat sand.
Crippling infrastructure is a rapidly growing disease, as is dysfunctional government both certainly have a correlation. As a New Yorker, I’ve always found it funny that the subway is seen as such a big part of its identity. But the city really seems to ever care if at all to actually get it to work well, or even just work.
Pretty much the same for all of the American electricity system. Should be unified but it is in 3 separate grids. Getting the paperwork sorted to link alternative energy sources is hell on earth.
And yet, you've got 3.6 million daily users on a weekday in 2023. So clearly it is working, even if not as well as some would like. Where I live, I can only dream of urban railway infrastructure as far reaching and as well functioning as the nyc subway. I get it that it's best to strive for more and better but it's ok to take stock of what you have already every once in a while.
back in the 80's Germany still had Coal and Nuclear power and was not run by 'Greens' now nuclear is gone coal is on the way out and all the solar, wind and other renewable sources cannot cope with demand, how stupid can German Politicians, businesses and the people be, electricity costs have gone up and up and the ordinary German is carrying the Green burden.
Other example: intelligent net meters. By wanting to make them super-perfect, being able to transmit commands to electricity-using washing machines or heat pumps from the provider, and at the same time have the highest standard of private-data-protection, we ended up having no intelligent net meters to speak of and they are more expensive at that. We lost ~ 10 years this way by trying to solve a non-problem. Demand management can be done over the internet just as good, or via 15-minute electricity pricing.
Shows you mindset where even after Nazism they still want to make the world fear them while simultaneously look up to them, I don’t think Germans are aware of how racist they are, they must have been indoctrinated so early to think in this overly superior way.
@@Hope_Boatyeah because we've been propping up your economy for decades in exchange for a cheap Europe so we can export around the globe If your people paid taxes you wouldn't have to be scared about how our economy is doing
@@LuluTheCorgi As someone from Poland, where our economy has been growing greatly and taxes have been paid we still worry about German economy. Everyone knows that if sh*t was to hit the fan Germany would use it's oversized influence on European Union to help themselves and also make situation worse for everyone else in the process. That has already happened in 2008 and when it comes to gas deals with Russia that significantly destroyed Europe's economy after 2022 so Germany could have cheaper gas earlier. That's why Poland will never buy into joining eurozone. We prefer our own currency thanks to what Germany (and to a lesser extent France) was doing. Eurozone is destroying European Union for the benefit of Germany.
I visited Germany in August 2023. I bought one month train subscription, a mistake happened and it ended up taking from me the price of 2 months instead of one. I emailed the transport company, 4 times and they took 6 months to answer me!! 6 freaking months! The issue got solved and closed in June 2024! Almost 11 months after my first email!! There is something seriously wrong with whatever is going on there!
It took so long because they already had your money. If you wanted to buy a car and mailed them that there is an error with their online payment system so you can't pay even if you wanted to - it would take only 30mins.
Similar thing happened to me and it was an airplane company. Lufthns.. Took them months (4 to 6 don't remember) to get me back my money. It did not ruin my vacation exactly but i definitely could not enjoy it thinking if I will get it back and documenting everything for them in my holiday time.
There is something in it. I'm a Pole as a kid in 1997 I lived in Germany for one year as my dad had a Humboldt Scholarship. It was another world - modern buses, modern trains (even if they were even more late than polish trains) clean cities. Everything was screaming "west", "modern", "rich" and "better". And Autobahns - it was something different compared to polish road network of 1997. And now when I visit I see dirty cities. Trains, buses and train stations so less modern than in Poland. And Autobahns? They seem narrow and uncomfortable compared to polish express roads.
@@Thematic2177 Sorry. From Statista: Since 2004, Poland has received nearly 246 billion euros from the European Union budget. During this period, membership payments to the EU budget amounted to over 83.8 billion euros.22 Apr 2024
Half of my family is German and I have a German mother. I've traveled to Germany to stay with family, usually in the Summers, for 48 years now since I was 3 years old. Seeing changes that have occurred in that regard are like turning pages in a picture book. They are more apparent and give you a better perspective of what is actually changing, and to what degree, than someone that lives there in my opinion. I took my family in 2019, and due to the pandemic and some other variables, didn't return until the Summer of 2023. The changes were stark to say the least. Most notably the different energy, or lack thereof, in the air when out in public. Almost like the country is in a emotional depression. The other were the horrible issues with trains being on time or without issue, which I thought was impossible considering my past decades of experience.
yea the whole nation is depressed and fed up. germans refuse to rescue the world with their very own money. then get blamed by media and politics for "not taking responsibility"... while they taxing your income with more than 40%, making it impossible to earn a dezent pension, impossible to buy houses. for many, childcare became a serious financially problem. so does eldercare. i'd left if not for my family and friends. thats not germany anymore. its some globalist playground but not a capable nation anymore.
Last year, the german Bundesnetzagentur started a tender for a government contract for new fax machine provider. The Bundesnetzagentur... is the federal internet department... This is not satire. A few years ago, i was in the german equivalent to the DMV. I had to look through tons of old paperwork to get some specific esoteric personal registration number (Of which each german department loves to issue several at once for different purposes. Don't think you'll get away with a simple ID number. No, no, no.). I had to go twice, because the first time, i handed the employee my government issued ID card and asked if he could just enter my name in the system to look it up. Well... i had to come back next week with the specific number he wanted, because he refused. He said, he couldn't type in the personal information of every person who came to him, because he would never get anything done that way. Which kind of sounds as if he *could have* done it, if he wanted. And then i saw something i will never forget. The guy filled a formular, rolled it up, put it in a plastic can and put it into the pneumatic tube mail behind his desk and told me to go to another office in 3rd floor for the next step. I swear, i thought i was stuck in a Kafka novel.
I saw a newspaper yesterday that had an article titled "Mythos Merkel". Yes, she is now already in the same league as legendary heroes. A shining beacon of standing still for 16 years.
Absolute awful and overhyped Person.She left us in a giant pile of mess with ruined military, infrastructure and dependend from russian gas.Not to mention her nuts migration and Euro-politics.
I'm a mineral physicist, did my PhD in German (dumb idea). Had to do experiments at DESY, at the PETRA III synchrotron. Do you know what they did starting in 2022? They have the beam off for 20% of the time now. Why? To save on energy! Yes, they turn off a particle accelerator that is incredibly competitive for beam time, 20% of the year, because energy is too expensive. There's no surprise that Germany is falling behind. Those are the kind of decisions that are made daily there. Yes, it's still, now, in 2024, 20% of the year turned off. Screwed my research up quite badly!
wait, havent they heard of company inventory management from accounting side.... if factory buys insanely expensive new machine, they better make sure it is used 99.99% to settle purchase cost in targeted time. I guess universities dont do this and thus they suck. Afterall even 50c electric is insanely cheap compared to billion euros CERN and other fancy science equipment. (I guess newest ones can be 15 billion euros range).
There was a war against nuclear power because people are ignorant now. The only failures of Nuclear were from early version plants (3 mile, Chornobyl) or hit by a tsunami. Meanwhile, it is a great source of power that is safe, green, and wonderful. Oh well.
I think their decision to shut down nuclear reactors and instead re-open coal power plants is one of the most insane decisions of modern societies. Modern day Germany is so extremely reactive to global events. I somehow doubt that any of Germany's nuclear reactors are at risk of tsunami. Frankly Japan's idea to build a low-lying coastal plant was the main cause of the Fukushima disaster. They're literally surrounded by tectonic activity
The comparison to remote villages is a bit misleading. It appears to be comparatively very easy to put fiber optic into rural areas than in suburbs or cities where there are already lots of buried utilities. Meanwhile they are putting 5G towers in cities so maybe fiber optic is not necessary for most people.
But you Americans have your own issues with infrastructure I am afraid. For example a lot of services are very expensive. Granted not everything works "perfectly" here in Germany like where we have slower conections maybe but they usually don't cost as much as in the US. And what you have is not always that much faster. Like for example, the median price for internet access is about $75 per month in the US. With Germany on average, a 1000 Mbit/s internet plan costs 56.5 € per month with discount and 69 € per month without. Slower conections can be a lot cheaper though starting at 20 euros. So 70 Euros per month would be really the extreme(!) end in Germany. Not in the US. Every nation, at the end of the day, has their very own unique problems.
Hello Dear. You deliver very smart information. I'm here in Australia 🇦🇺, Australia is in many ways far ahead..Germany 🇩🇪 is extremely slow. I moved to Australia , I love it here. I don't wanna go back. Only the Tax department is getting worse. Have a lovely day. Wuff
A very peculiar one, but they do have it. I remember when some local friends took me to try the typical snack specialty in Frankfurt. And no, it wasn't Frankfurter sausages (which they actually call Wiener). It's called "Handkäse mit Musik" - literally translated as "hand cheese with music". Weird name, isn't it? They explained: it's a kind of semi-hard cured cheese eaten with the hands (hence the name) as thick slices on buttered bread and topped with chopped raw onions and caraway seeds. It's delicious, trust me! Especially with a glass of apple wine, also typical from that area, and in the merry centuries-old taverns of the Sachsenhausen district. But then I asked about the "music" part. They just replied: "oh, that comes later..." 🤣 (It actually didn't, fortunately.)
I had visited and stayed in Germany many times and each time I find something new that shocks me. I love the country but things need to change.
5 місяців тому
@@2b_or_not_2b_4gotten Yes, our government is supporting foreign interests. US interests primarily. Nobody even talks about how the US (Baltops 22, Seymour Hersh) destroyed our most important energy supply in an act of terrorism just because US strategists do not want us to work together with Russia. They rather have us kill each other in a third world war Europe VS. Asia/Russia, while watching the whole thing from over the atlantic, eating popcorn. The Ukrainian war is also just a proxy war between NATO and Russia, funded mostly by Germany and Europe, while the US is enjoying the show. (Of course I am only talking about the government, military etc. - not my fellow American patriots)
I worked as a teacher during the pandemic. Still remember the utter disbelief of an Indian friend when I told them that our classroom didn't have running water for days. Sometimes there was no soap. Other times there was neither. As a bonus the windows - by design - couldn't be opened.
When smart people do become politicians, they get torn to shreds. I honestly believe the best way to influence politics is from the outside. I know that sounds like a cop out, but the political machine is an emulsifier. It destroys individual ideas (and the soul of the idea giver) and blends them into a bland soup. When the emulsion of an idea inevitability fails, the idea giver is made to pay the political price for its failure.
Smart means very little when willful ignorance is a thing, & people striving to crawl out of ignorance are eventually seen as too much of a threat to reach any auspices of political power except for the bare minimum of controlled opposition
In Germany half the trains are delayed. In Britain they're not even considered "delayed" unless they're at least an hour late. In America the last train left in 1952.
You have my sympathy, Sabine... welcome to England! I suspect both our countries are suffering from the same maliase - a couple of generations free-loading off the hard work of their forebears combined with ineffectual government has left an empty shell of a country. I'm pretty sure this is how Rome fell - barbarians invading were a symptom, not the cause. As an aside Olaf Scholz strikes me as a dangerous coward and a fool, for which you also have my sympathy. Here's hoping our new PM isn't the same - the inherent issue with Labour is 'hard' socialists tend to become dictators, while 'soft' socialits tend to choose 'populist' over 'sense'.
I am a doctor in India. I am thinking of doing post graduation in Germany. So I searched a few things about Germany. And now youtube suggested me this video 😂
A friend of mine is developing a chatbot for a German company. Their internal software system is so terrobly designed and hard to use and so they wanted to use AI to help users make sense of it. Along the way, the developers realized that in the past, there have been multiple other IT projects to cope with that software beside the chatbot, but none of them really helped. My friend kept wondering why they didnt go with the obvious solution, which is designing an entirely new software to replace the old ones. Instead they kept it and keep slapping new tech like AI like a bandaid over it. But since they're paying my friend, the chatbot project goes on. It's exactly the same story as not upgrading to optic cables but trying to improve copper sables instead.
no that a very different problem with tech in general, its goes like this, new less-code solution become trendy promising ease of use and being able to do 80% what more-code solution do, company switch to and start wanting to implement the 20% only to find out that the 80% is the easy part that even an intern can do, their solution grow in complexity slowly and now they are stuck in this model. dev that specialized in these less-code solution over time became so complex and fought over by the very few leftover companies that are stuck, but also in a way those dev are stuck cause if that market fail their job is gone and they so out of shape in coding in general.
I live in Thailand, about 18 km from the nearest town (Hua Hin). My internet comes through glass fiber cable with over 800 mbps! Every year I have to send a life certificate to receive my pension from the Deutsche Rente for one more year: it has to be done by post. Twice it never arrived. Now I have to send it via registered mail, so I can follow it's tracks. They don't accept it via e-mail. It has to be done on paper! In 2024! Probably because of "privacy and security" reasons, but anyone can open the envelop on the way to Germany. I retired in 2012 and before that time I took the train to Frankfurt airport from a small place called Herzogenrath. I always had to take into consideration that there would be a delay, so I had to take one or two trains before the actual time that I had to be at the airport (I used to work for Lufthansa)... Oh I can go on about it... on the whole, I'm glad that I can live in a "third world" country like Thailand.
Thailand is amazingly progressive in many areas. Most Thais use their mobiles to pay for everything. My wife comes from Kalasin (rural Northern Thailand) and even the internet in her village is faster than mine is in Australia.
in the 90s nobody in Thailand owned a computer most of the population didn't even know what it was while Germany was cutting edge now Germany has fallen decades behind Thailand
I'm from Brazil, and is very ironic seeing native people who lives in villages in the middle of the Amazon Rainforest here having better tech than a first world country.
I recently told my Vietnames coworkers that 100 mbits internet is fast in Germany (at least 5 years ago when I still lived there). They were speechless.
i live in Vietnam. It's good there's no 5G over there, as the Vietnamese are turning into zombies with their omnipresent electronic devices. The smarter the phone, the dumber the user.
i have 50mbits and i honestly don't know what i'd do with more. yes it could be faster, but it's completely sufficient for watching live streams and movies, and game downloads are a one time thing that i can just do in the background without affecting me much. my upload also exceeds the twitch bitrate limit. i guess it could be a problem with multiple people watching streams in the same household.
Hello from Taiwan。I met a German guy in Hokkaido ，Japan just two weeks ago。I told him Germany is a great country and I admire German culture and achievements a lot。Too my surprise， he told me Germany has gotten down in recent years 。I feel sad because I have considered a fan of Germany。
Dear Sabine. Once again, congratulations. I appreciate your sober way on analyzing trends, concepts and things in general. Your level of honesty is something very rare nowadays, even more so “self” (but constructive) criticism. You ARE doing your part to make many things better in this planet and civilization of ours. Commendable!
I feel like the root cause of the "slowness" or the "Technologieoffenheit" is something that - if it happened in other countries - we would point at accusingly and call it 'corruption', but when it happens here in Germany we simply call it 'lobbyism'.
It's not necessary to totally and always keep up with other countries technologically. It's better to fall behind, focus elsewhere, and then jump ahead when the time is right. The countries with the worst infrastructure now had the best 50 years ago. Other countries jumped ahead. And, when the time comes, those countries will be behind.
It's not just lobbyism. Talk to some people. Average people. And you quickly realise how "anti-technology" a lot of the population actaully are. We Germans love to sell our selfs as engineeres, techies and progressive. But that's not the reality I am afraid. Our society is, compared to other nations, relatively conservative. Conservative in the sense that we really don't like too much change or too many new things. Up to the point where we rather keep 30 year old technologies around even though we know they are complettely outdated. It's not just a political problem. A lot of it comes from our society and the stance it has to implementing technology.
@@CrniWuk I've seen in my country (Argentina) how the lefties became the conservatives, because they keep on putting useless people in places of power, where by ignorance or inoperance everything is always worse off than before. And nothing new is allowed to thrive, UNLESS YOU GET IN BED WITH GOVERNMENT. Because that's modern western socialism for you. If you're my friend you enjoy free market. If you're not, you enjoy overtaxing, overregulation. Nothing is ever allowed to change or grow. The more liberal the better usually for letting technology progress. Take that to your next election!
As a German citizen it is frustrating. You see your country falling behind and at some places literally falling apart and the government seem to does not even grasp the situation. I mean high rent and housing prices, outdated retirement system, lack of education, high level of unnecessary bureaucracy, no company friendly politics etc. I feel you Sabine.
"high rent and housing prices, outdated retirement system, lack of education" - you know why, but it's politically incorrect to say it. High level of unnecessary bureaucracy - that's because of corruption . Low lever corruption is not an issue in Germany, but the higher you go, the corruption goes up exponentially. So you need a smokescreen to protect that, that's why you got the famous, impenetrable bureaucracy. If Germany could harvest the energy of bureaucracy, they would conquer the world !
You are not missing anything, because governments are no longer governing anyway. The problems of Price gouging, social housing, healthcare & education would not be solved, inflation rate would be higher than the wages. Major parties would be either Left or Right, but not in the middle. They would be discussing about the problems instead of fixing it.
I used to work for a Dutch provincial government. We have this exchange program with a couple of Bundesländer, where they send us their most promising civil servants to do an internship for a year with us. Their first week was always a week of culture shock. Things (but not limited to) like: total lack of hierarchy; very few people wear ties; no fixed desks; astounishing level of automation; all forms are online and accessible by both mobile and the visual impaired; lot's of writing in the background is done in English. One of them said to us: "You're not a government, you're a tech company with a council". And I believe (I live near the border, do most of my shopping in Germany, etc) that is also the Achilles' Heel of present Germany: it's currently being eaten by those who actually do know how to run things like a modern tech company.
@schloesserable it means that while the likes of Elon Musk try to build a state of the art tech factory in Brandenburg, the German auto industry colludes with government and "environmental" groups to desperately slow it all down at all costs. Innovation, progress, solid engineering, ... these are the German things I learned about growing up in Belgium. Go back to that, please. Nobody wins this way.
I always explain the difference between the Dutch and Germans in this way. If you tell a dutchman and german to jump, the dutchman will say: why? the German will say: how high? A strict hierarchy organisation will always lacks a good dimension and interaction between co-workers
so she has a problem with germany becuase of this and not because they try to ban leading opposition parties on outrageous accusations and tries to throw politicians in prison for citing government statistics on twitter??
Having recently moved to Germany and experienced getting a residency permit, driving license, setting up a business, etc, I can concur that Germany is slow. Things in the UK that can be done online and take days, in Germany require multiple face to face meetings and snail mail and take months. No wonder people don't want to set up new businesses in Germany.
Conversely every crook in Europe knew, at least prior to Brexit, that if you wanted to set up a fraudulent company you registered it with Companies House in London precisely because they would hand out a registration to anyone. Whilst Germany might stand as an example of over-regulation there, the UK's overly permissive system is as bad in the other direction.
I don’t know what you are doing wrong, but setting up a business can be done online within 1 hour in Germany. Just done it last year. Nevertheless the infrastructure is declining indeed.
@@peterboneg Unternehmergesellschaft (haftungsbeschränkt) (so the little brother of the GmbH). We used the "Musterprotokoll" as article of association. This probably does not fit the most of the time, but in principal you can set up a business quickly in Germany (it is up to you and your co-founders).
It’s not just a German issue, it’s a global issue when political considerations override technological solutions. Sabine shouldn’t be embarrassed to be German, rather we should all be embarrassed to live in a civilization that places a higher value on entertainment than on seriously addressing the needs of all humans.
I had a German teacher in the 9th grade, and he was an interesting person. Maybe it was his maturity at 60 something. Don't let others brings you down. Embrace your own growth, and find others like you, whether they speak your language or not. ❤
I used to work for a German company. They closed 2 factories in Germany and 1 in Poland and opened new factories in India. And they boasted that they "reduced emissions".
r/ malicious compliance?
What's sad is that it isn't a move unique to Germany alone.
They did, in Germany.
That's what you get when you allow people in positions of power who make laws based on how the world should look like and not how it actually works. Seriously, I despair of our Green party. It's like they don't know what cynicism is.
Well if they operate in the USA with a repackaging facility, they can bulk ship items from India on pallets, repackage the items in retail containers and sell them as as "Made in the USA" per the laws and regulations.
Using Britain as a reference to a well-functioning nation from a policy/leadership perspective is kind of wild.
and very much misleading. she needs to move abroad. then she might get an idea. she talked lots of nonsense.
Sabine Hossenfelder, I've been working in UK for a firm for 2 years. I must say that it's ten times worse in England than Germany! Hearing your British accent and the way you're portraying the negativities in Germany, I think you're suffering from GERMANOPHOBIA! Just like the REFEREE Anthony Taylor who stole 1 goal from Germany, not allowing them an obvious penalty! That was broad day ROBBERY! Fazit : Sport is not only sport, it's also political, a billion dollars business!
Fair point!
Britain has some plusses, but overall Germany is better...
Not least its better geographical spread of wealth making
Well, it was a joke, right?
@@verity4917Her British accent? In what world does she sound British?
The character pointed at a broken elevator sign and said "this is the empire declining". The person he was talking to thought he was exaggerating, but he went on to explain: if low cost but highly visible repairs are being neglected, what do you think happens to the high cost invisible ones? If infrastructure is decaying, the empire is already falling. From Asimov's Foundation.
Asimov, is one of my favorite authors, he did not invent these ideas they have been true forever.
@@tedmossmy friend spoke to Asimov at a con many years ago. Asimov told him that if you want to create some great SF, take some known history and file the serial numbers off. In Asimov’s case with FOUNDATION, he set the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire in space, and mixed in some statistical mechanics (which he certainly knew from chemistry and physics), and applied it to people.
I'm afraid much of this true in the U.S. as well-- neglected infrastructure, slow responses, etc. The Democratic party in particular, for 4+ years just hoping that they could keep hiding Biden's dementia and it would somehow magically get better by 2024 instead of planning ahead.
Never expected to see a Jonathan Pie clip in one of these videos!
You have elevators!?
Embarrased to be German?
IMAGINE HOW IT FEELS TO BE ENGLISH! 🙄
I'm Canadian but my mother is German and my father is English, so how do I feel watching two great people I've always respected and held in high regard, destroy their countries and perform some strange form of group suicide. Don't expect people like me to come and help because I'm too busy fighting the same evil in Canada, the English and Germans will have to wake up themselves or perish. Time is running out.
or amerikan
Yeah, I hear the UK is having a tough go of it as of late
@@jaykay5580at least we have Trump and company.
I'm afraid the horse and buggy are no solution given their emissions!
You walk from Germany to Czech through the woods. How do you recognize that you have reached Czech Territory? Your phone has network.
😅
🤪
*Someone offers you meth
It is an exaggeration, isnt it?
@@bittasi1139 That's how comedy works my friend
I'm afraid Sabine isn't loud enough. Not only Germany, but the whole of EU is reacting far too slowly to global developments.
And which countries are reacting fast? USA? Japan? South Korea? Australia? Canada?
@@calculuslover2078 Canada? LOL... (and I'm a Canadian)
Look at the amount of VC money, patents and start ups in the US. A lot of it is bs, but the rest is not. Which companies are the modern digital tech giants? Which economy still grew this and last year? The US definitely does A LOT wrong, but they are the technology leaders
@@calculuslover2078 China, Scandinavian countries, Iceland(not sure if Iceland is considered Scandinavian), Costa Rica maybe. I don't know, that's all I got.
Have you been to the United States? It makes the EU look like the last remaining fortress of sanity.
A Cuban friend explained decay. It happens when people have been successful so long that they forget what made them successful.
The Germans are not victims of success but are dealing with a political class that hates them. Why put in effort when you aren't even on the list of priorities.
I am from Thailand. I agree.
I'm from Florida and I agree 😊
Wise words. 🙂
I visited Germany for the first time this year and this describes germans perfectly. They have no notion of how is their country in comparation with the world. How it was made that way and that they are wasting it. Simply asuming it to be the norm and that it is always that way everywhere.
Nations are built when people band together to create something for them and their descendants. Being culture, institutions, goverment or wathever symbol or ideal can define a country. At this moment the common denominator in Germany that keeps it moving is money. It is no secret that Germany is one of the richest countries of the world. But let's just consider what would happen if that one day suddenly wasn't the case. Fortune is known to be a fickle mistress. So what will unite germany the day in which their industrial machine becomes so degraded that it will start breaking appart?
That is something that concerns me.
As a brit living in Germany and having to work with the people here, and with the school system too for my family, it amazes me the total panic that hits the face of almost any German when something does not go to plan. In other countries i have lived and worked in, having something missing or not go to plan results in a smile and a lets see what we can do. Here it is from my perspective just hilarious the reaction. But don't get me wrong, i love living here, maybe because i am in an area with decent internet connectivity!
You seem to be living in a nice bubble in Germany, unaware of what is happening in the country.
@ I am sadly aware having lived in other parts of Germany previously and managing a team of over 20 people here. I certainly live in a bubble at the moment here having grown up in a shit hole council estate and lived in the worst parts of London during the 90’s. Bubbles have a habit of bursting though.
German here. My colleagues in Malaysia always laugh about my internet connection
We're friends with a Ukrainian family who fled to Bavaria when the war began and then returned to Ukraine, citing the abysmal internet speeds as the reason. Not joking here, that did happen.
@@ferocious_r Genuine war refugees eh?
@@ferocious_rFled WAR and went back because of bad/erratic internet connection? Either said war or ex-refugees not that serious.
@@c0ldc0ne jup here the family comes and goes. aint a real war like gaza
it's easier for developing countries to leapfrog with technology.. no big surprise. less baggage
Calling the UK a “healthy country” was a lesson in the finest sarcasm.
yeah uk is being held together by the fact nobody in the country can be arsed to do anytghing about it as it hasnt quite gone of the rails... yet
@@username.exenotfound2943 It has so gone off the rails.
I was abroad when Brexit happened. I think soon I'll be abroad again.
UK basket case
Well things have finally taken a turn for the better in the UK these past couple of days.
And we're starting to claw our way back out of our hole without filling up government seats with fascists, so there's that at least.
We thought that us Italians would eventually catch up with Germany. Turns out they are catching up with us.
joking aside, but German technological debt is our common problem. It doesn't matter whether you live in Poznań or Napoli. Somehow we must overcome their hard-headedness, otherwise our children's future will be dependent on whimsical nationalists ones from Beijing and Delhi.
@@cybernetic-ransomware1485 I come from the future (Argentina) the key is not to let the government take all the decisions. Establish GOOD, SOLID channels for the private sector to take the initiative.
Here in 1945 we had a great general conman, called Perón, a right winger, but greatly inspired by Mussolini, so in short with the statist interventionist heart of a lefty. To the point of dissapearing anyone resembling a commie, while he was out intervening in markets.
He believed in technology advance as a way to gain an edge over our foes. The result? The enemy infiltrated, government spent BILLIONS into Cold Fusion (never got it to work, ofc) and we got a series of coup d'tats.
Sad thing about Perón is he actually got the country industrialized. But his populist legacy was a bigger part than he could've ever imagined, spawning a cult of followers that more or less still impede the country from working properly. All because he from his ivory tower threw some books and mattresses to the impoverished masses.
Modern peronists (kirchnerists) are full on commies, socialists that attack private property and your freedom to decide over your business, your life, etc. But still with the fascist gene attached to it. So they're willing to create narratives (with crisis actors) and use TERROR from the STATE to MANIPULATE THE POPULATION and SUBJUGATE THEM into NOT voting a right winger.
They've created a culture much like Sabine here says, of being SLOW, of being overall INOPERANT when faced with their tasks. Every challenge they tackle, it makes things worse. Each thing they do "for us" ends up as another point where they meddle in the affairs of the people and decide over their lives. While they can BARELY run a country themselves. Impoverishing due to monetary emission and price controls that lead to poor stock replenishment and worse quality control.
Them being slow has NOTHING to do with their intelligence though. To steal, they're always one step ahead. Look into who they contract for the Internet / Railroad / Energy improvements, and you'll SEE precisely WHY they chose them. They're all playing for the same team. The socialists that run the country like a capitalist country, but the only ones that TRULY enjoy a FREE market are the politicians and their businessmen friends. The rest of us lowlives can't compete because the government has the monopoly over violence.
So if a competitor to their friends makes it big, they can always saddle them with regulation and taxes or even take legal action with penalty fees. The politicians and the caste they formed that surrounds them have a small little crown that elevates them from us, the common folk. They don't have more rights, they have more PRIVILEGES, which are SECURED by their legislation. It's time to ATTACK that system of political clientelism, populism and incresing interventionism and bring it to the ground.
Let companies of men and women dedice the course. Don't let those callous with pride and arrogance, who believe themselves to be God to act on behalf of a nation.
Taking the reigns of something so complex as market, which is composed by all agents and all goods/services being transferred is tantamount to heresy. To know everything about a market to take such a wild decision, you'd need to know the CURRENT, PAST, and FUTURE state of EVERYTHING AND EVERYONE in it. Including each individual's personal preferences, and plans. You'd need to be omniscient. You'd need to be God. And politicians ARE NOT GOD.
😄 I laugh reluctantly in German
@quantillaprudentia1345 There's no laugh in German
@@giovannipiacen85 I think you have to be among the dead to be able to speak German, and since you couldn't laugh, you have already become one of the dead.
Frenchman here. Sabine you most surely know better about Germany but, to be fair, most European countries have similar problems and even the UK, you cite as a reference: aging population, immigration-related issues, degraded training / education issues. Even in the USA, China have issues of their own. The entire world except Africa is facing a population collapse. Here, in France, we used to have a nice Electricity production system based on Nuclear energy but François Hollande (Socialist with "Green" friends) decided to stop the investment because it was a politically fashionable idea so in 2022 almost 50% of our Nuclear power plants were stopped because of maintenance falling behind and lack of replacement projects. Luckily this is fixed we are building new Nuclear power plants and foresee to export record levels of electricity.
IMO, the trouble is people say what they don't want (UK= no more EU), Germany= no more nuclear, USA=no more Ukraine spendings, France= lets work less, etc). So, here in France the issues are different: the infrastructure is usually excellent but people have this culture of its government wasting money and have deficits all over the place. Aging population means that the working people are not the same as 20 years ago (French people replaced often with african people) meaning that the training level has deteriorated and some degree of France-hating attitude.
You just summed up the western world in general.
You know Germany has gotten bad when the Germans start joking.
Tell me you know very few Germans w/o telling me.
Do you know a joke tho @@tablescissors
meh, stupid old clichés like yours are definitely not funny. At least for people with a three digit IQ.
@@owsie1800 He is German so he doesn't know what jokes are
stereotypes goin wild here
As a Romanian, we've always dreamed of being on the same level as Germany. Our railway system is as bad as it was 30yrs ago, so somehow our dreams of being on the same level are coming true but for the wrong reasons 🤣🤣
Be careful what You wish for 😅
So that means that Ceaușescu wasn't that bad at all he was killed for what ?😅 he made the the roads the railway we produced everything ourselves and in 30 years nothing changed o almost forgot yeah no factory's thousand all shut down thousands off jobs lost
everyone started after 1989 to go work outside of Romania because yeah well people lost there jobs 😅
the food now is almost poison thats how bad it is now 😂 nature destroyed Hectares of woods all cut down.
the corruption is higer then ever eu funds not going where should go but in pocket of individuals in a high position (power) 😂 infected with LGBTQ drugs and violence 😅 yeah Romania did not win anny good in 30 years we did lost all our value's that we had 30 years ago
actually made me laugh
Bonjour, Je suis français, bravo à la Roumanie pour son infrastructure numérique concernant le réseau internet
I visited Romania many times in the 90s and I loved the railway system. Trains were always on time. They were a bit old maybe but still worked as intended. No delays. I was even lucky enough to be invited by friends to work one day on the railway. We went around and did maintenance work on the electricity cables above the tracks. True, the ticket inspectors were a bit corrupt. As I learned more Romanian I realized that they always asked me if I needed a ticket. If I was leaving the train before their route was ended and they were replaced by another ticket inspector, I could buy the ticket at half the price but I did not receive a ticket. They just pocketed the money. It is not good for the state to be cheated on the money plus tax but people reasoned that they never saw any benefits from the tax anyways. Hopefully that bit has changed by now.
I am a close follower of the events taking place in Germany. I travel there quite often. In my humble opinion, the source of all the country management mistakes come from decisions being made based on ideology instead of facts, technology and common sense
100% true.
isn't that the truth everywhere?
Lets do a root source investigation. The mentioned topics are:
1. Privatization of the DB (1.1.1994). This was based on economical reasons and regulatory requirements of the EU.
2. Bad digital infrastructure: This is based on decisions made against glass fiber in the mid 90s based on influence of the lobbyist Leo Kirch
3. Nuclear phase-out (2011 after Fukushima, due to pressure of 70-80% of the population)
4. Hydrogen strategy (2020, called "Nationale Wasserstoffstrategy", NWS)
These events are well-documented and widely known. Even all of them occured on behalf of the same political party, where is the ideology here? I can see economical reasons, lobbyism or political pressure from the people. Maybe for the NWS - I'm not familiar with this topic because of hydrogen
Welcome to the world...
@@benlovell9416 mostly yes. But the extent to which a developed and reliable Germany is spoiling what used to be an advantageous and leading position in many fields is way above the average. She explains it well in the video, but the list could go on for much longer. The trend is so worrying
I visited Germany before, I am Brazilian and spent a lot of time in China too.I also visited Portugal, Spain and Italy in Europe, in Latin America I visited Paraguay, Argentina and Urugay, in Asia I visited South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Apart from China Mainland. For me it's like this: Asia is like 10x better comparing with 10 years ago, everything, cleaner, better maners, daily tech (optic fiber, 5g cover, instant payment system), airports, trains, highways, all got much better. Latin America: Slow improvements, but still improvements, mainly in the countryside things got much better (I do live in the countryside), daily tech much much better, internet everywhere, private schools and hospitals got incredible better, so even if things are slow to improve, at the end of the day, they improved. Europe: Just general decay, Apart from the historical stuff, everything felt kind of old and slow, nothing happening, visited some factories but they where not competitive, expensive stuff but nothing special, old infrastructure, flights canceled, bad airports, old hotels, depressed people. I know a lot of things still better in Germany for instance, than in Brazil and China, but specially in the regions I live and stay (which by the way and in the countryside in both countries), I can see a lot of improvements in the last decade, but I saw the opposite in Europe
Of course, Asia is better, they stole our jobs! 💯😡
Escalators do not break down. They simply become stairs.
that's just a descope.
I wish this was true, alas, often times they are closed for repairs...
This is way funnier than it should be 😅
Mitch Hedberg ftw!!!
Sounds like something Habeck would say.
The UK lowered its own carbon emmissions by selling its manufacturing base to other countries that don't care about such things, thus boosting global emmissions.
This is the dirty not so secret of the rise of China. Companies sidestep regulation by offshoring. Meanwhile politicians claim victory for declining emissions.
And then the stuff gets shipped around in filthy, sludge burning container ships.
So did every other Western nation. Now we have low carbon emissions and no more danger of CLIMATE CHANGE!😂
Actually, we all are a bunch of suckers who believed a lie and sold what was really valuable to China, and now just like Sabina, we are noticing the effects of our long decline to poverty, and we still think we’re saving the planet. Putting manufacturing in the hands of the most incompetent countries around the world and expecting a good result is insane.
It's been happening everywhere. Try to find a consumer good of any sort that is NOT made in China, regardless of brand or price.
Source?
When I was stationed in Germany (79-82) the German trains were always on time. It was considered a major scandal if a train was 5 minutes late. It bothers me that things have gone to hell
"Everything woke turns to sh*t."- Trump
@@stephenkalatucka6213 I don't see how that fits here
You lived there when the Marshall plan was very effective. Now the only thing American there is in Frankfurt, the military outpost...
@@oweoweowemmmmmmmmmm////mmmmmmmmmmmm//mm/m/mm/m/mmmm////mmm/mm/mmm/mmmmmmm/m//mmmmmm//mmmmm/m//mmmm//////m//m/mm////m/mmm///m/////////
@@werkzeugmann6224 I'm not surprised the military shut down most bases in Germany. A lot of the bases were leftovers from the distant past. In Wurzburg, where I was stationed, the facilities were left over from the distant past. One facility still had rings in the walls to tie up horses. The hospital where I worked started life as a Luftwaffe hospital.
Moved to Germany in 1990, and was going back in time to the US in the 60’s. So many bureaucratic systems slowed down progress and put them behind. Like the 60’s, however socializing and the living environment were very pleasant for me. Less than a forty hour work week. Pregnancy leave of 3 months both paid and a birthing bonus; mandatory one to two-week hospital stay. Much slower pace. When I moved to Austria in ‘92, time sped back up to present day.
As an American, seeing a German referring to the UK as healthy is mind bending.
Im British in London, the fact she thinks this means germany must be doing REALLY bad or she might have a misunderstanding of the UK. We have same issues with trains, regarding strikes and privatisation. But the infrastructure itself, though dated, its quite good, just expensive.
That's how bad it is here in Berlin - City and country are becoming increasing unusable
As an American, seeing another American mock a German for making a comparison to the U.K. seems out of pocket considering our own crumbling infrastructure and almost complete lack of public transit, owing to suburban sprawl’s congestive car based planning and the kind of political erosion which underpins a government on the verge of a geriatric smack down between two brain addled narcissists.
@@suoyidl2654 all of them are you cant think logically without being racist
Also completely insane. Since the British elite is systematically destroying the country.
There used to be a saying in Sweden: "Germany is Sweden for adults".
No-one says that any longer.
Does this imply that Swedes are children? As a person of Swedish decent I find this rather insulting. For me, it is more 'adult' to reach the kind of social compromises that the Swedes are famous for, understanding that life is complex and rigid rules based systems are always inadequate.
@@davefaulkner6302the new Swedes beg to differ, you've bought the package, not just the wrapping.
@@davefaulkner6302take it easy. now you can live with consequences of childish decisions. Enjoy!😅
@@davefaulkner6302sounds to me like you’re romanticizing your Swedish heritage. I used to do the same with my German heritage but I learned that the greatest strength of any culture is also its greatest weakness
Late and cancelled trains are practically a Swedish trademark and broadband internet access..ah, the glorious "open infrastructure" of fiberoptic networks with one owner and maintainer and a number of actors (ISPs available within each network) that are trying to compete with each other, when the network owner and maintainer sets the rent that the ISPs have to pay and this rent increases every year (where I am, in a major city, the bit about raising prices each year is explicitly stated) and of course the ISPs charge the customers more and since all live under the same network owner there isn't a lot to differentiate the isps in terms of connection speeds or pricing.
As a Brit, i knew things were bad as soon as a German said "you're so lucky to have trains that run on time!".
You Brits need to make more babies
I prefer British trains to German trains. But it depends on the company.
Virgin and Cross Country are nice, London Midland is a big no no.
@@svr5423 I used British trains in 1993. If I remember correctly there was only one line. From Dover to Edinburgh. It was so archaic. Trains were up to 2 hours late in London. We would have thought we were in the 19th century.
I'm in the West Mids. Trains run when they want to. An evening commute of four hours to get from Birmingham to South East Staffordshire is a regular occurrence... Cancelations and delays are a daily occurrence.
Here in America, we don't have trains.
Excellent presentation, Danke! Just finding your website and happily subscribed. American in Frankfurt.
I love it when the good Doctor goes on a rant Thanks!
Thanks for your support, really appreciate it!
@@SabineHossenfelderi will very happy to see the decline of German economy because you so submissive and has no sovereignty 😊 you "didn't want" (as masters says you) cheap russian natural gas from pipelines so now you must buy expensive LNG from US and Russia (and russian fertilizers indeed), and your economy just can't compete against normal adequate countries. That's why your companies rushed to relocate to US or China
P.s. did you hear something about "pipeline explode" investigation recently? I'm not 😂 because you can't do it against a will of your overseas masters.
Hopefully when the time comes Germans won't be so cucked to accept world government which will likely be promoted by a fake alien presense. @@SabineHossenfelder
I've been working in a German company now for 6 years. The biggest issue is that achieving goals is not the priority, but following a process. And when something is performing poorly, you like better adding more process rather than thinking what is the best way to achieve the goal. At the end you work for the process.
🤖🤖🤖
That is sooo true 😂 And they love their processes.
My brother and I like to call it The Checkliste Syndrome!
Process is how you maintain quality.
@@IThinkICare it depends. Public institutions are full of processes for example, it does not guarantee any success, quality, etc.
Many just get comfy behind a process, or use it to hide behind. Processes are great, but not the goal.
Every country has its embarrassments. Here in Ireland we are building a National Children's Hospital that has been ongoing for YEARS, is now the most expensive hospital IN THE WORLD, EVER and is still not built. No one wants to take responsibility. As one commentator said "It's being passed around like a bag of shit that's on fire."
Well Berlin airport also took 29 years for similar reasons.
If judge based on my colleagues (whos pay is above average) their top priorities are feierabend and "not my responsibilty". All our projects delayed for 3 years, and its only by current deadlines. Who knows how long will it take in reality
thats irelands embarassment? how about the ludicrous censorship bills they just implemented!?
Haha so like the Berlin airport
Honest question, are these projects built by union labor?
Ireland is still one of the best countries in the world to live. Maybe if you lived in a really shitty country for a while you'd be more grateful for what we have here in Ireland.
Thank u for ur courage to speak up. ❤ and also thank u to introduce me to planet wilde.
I remember visiting Flensburg a few years ago with my family. My son wanted to go fishing by the sea. I knew we needed a permit as we do in Denmark. Turned out we had to go to a counsil office, wait in line, fill in a long paper form with all kind of details and pay in cash. It took a couple of hours out of our short holiday. In my home country Denmark, we just go to a website and pay the fee.
The funny thing is - you could get a permit in Schleswig-Holstein - you won't get any in Lower Saxony because you need a german fishing exam. It is crasy...
Because Denmark is a functional country with people who have a sense of humor and arent insufferable moralists
I wonder if english countries do tech easier, with so much of basics being based in english. So I try to cut East and Central Europe a little slack. Most coding is in pure english, that's sorta not fair but history is not fair.
Hours to buy a fishing license? Even Pennsylvania (USA) can get it done faster than that: Walk into practically any sporting goods store or hardware store, put down your money, walk out with a hunting license, trapping license, or fishing license in about the time it takes you to write down your name, address, phone number, age, and date of birth.
You can do that in the rural US as well. You just order the license online and print it out.
Swedish politicians: Look how we ruined a country in only 4 decades!
German politicians: Hold my beer!
Yep, clearly way too late to the table for DEI to fix things.
German politicians: look how we ruined a country in 2 decades.
@@comicus6769 How exactly would DEI help the sciences /quality of life in Deutschland?
@@alex8527-w1q It's a joke. The EUnuchstan left always does the wrong thing - they are totalitarians while projecting their actions on others.
@@comicus6769lmao
When a physicist gets a speeding ticket, twice, in one journey, clearly there is something wrong with the space-time continuum. You weren't speeding Sabine, Germany was just slowing down.
🎉😂😅 Best comment
Yes, you were speeding RELATIVE to Germany.
😂😂😂
I once worked with a guy who sped off on a Friday to get to his home (far from the office).
He managed to get enough speeding tickets in one journey to get banned outright. They all just add up, they don't say "well you had your quota that day"!.
So climate change is a high priority for the elite? As they guzzle and fly around their private jets around the world, releasing much more carbon than a single person would release.
I remember the COP conferences on climate change, 400+ private jets; literally descended in one location to preach climate change lol.
Its funny how the elite can pollute at their hearts content and then preach to the common people that climate change is a big threat. Hypocrisy.
"Thinks are going seriously wrong here in Germany"
*Poland immediately starts sweating profusely*
As others have said it is not just Germany. I am in the UK and with all the delays it took me 11 hours to travel 100 miles on public transport. At one point the bus driver announced he had to stop for 45 minutes as he had reached the legal limit he was allowed to drive for. This of course resulted in missing the next connection and thus another hours delay waiting for the next bus and so it went on...
Do not blame The driver and his right to ok working conditions. Blame The fact that more and more infrastructure is privatized and all not profitable routes are closed or with very few daily departures. From what I understand we are also heading towards smart-cities with all people Living in these cities and NOT in The countryside. And are supposed to stay at Home due to The 15-minutes city concept - and are not supposed to travelling around. Correct me if I am misinformed and why
That's totally inept management at work.
I often see 2 bus drivers on Stagecoach buses when one driver is getting shadowed by a more experienced driver for one reason or another.
I don't see any reason why the bus company couldn't simply do that and have the extra driver just snooze until there is a shift change to cover the time that a single driver can't legally wprk for.
Are you going enjoying the influence of communism?
@@BigJohnson-g3jIt's incredible to me that socialism is still tolerated in Europe after what's happened over the last 250 years. It's so obviously a bad idea. This is why I've become convinced universal sufferage democracy isn't sustainable. If people are so ignorant thay they will entertain socialism they shouldn't be involved in decision making. Sad reality...
@@BigJohnson-g3j capitalism is way worse for public transportation since it would push abandoning non profitable roads btw, and on top of that, I'd say it's mostly caused by wanting short term profit by making poor and rushed urban planning letting us with very impractical infrastructure in general
In the early 1970's I bought a machine for my factory. It was made in Germany. That machine performed flawlessly, until 2018, then it broke down. That was one heck of a machine, I am very *_very_* impressed !
So, I hired engineers from Germany to fix that machine, using all imported German parts.
3 years later, it broke again.
This time, the parts that were broken were all the *NEW* parts that were installed just 3 years prior, and those *NEW* parts were all made-in-Germany.
What a contradiction !
The first time the machine broke down, it had worked for more than 45 years. Yes, *_more than forty-five long years_*_ !_
The second time the machine broke down, the parts lasted 3 years.
Same work. Same work amount. Same everything. Except for, the quality of the *NEW* German parts were so flimsy, if I'm a German, I would be embarrassed.
We contacted the company in German, we talked to the German engineers who came to fix the machine for us, and they told us one thing, and one thing only ---- back in the 1970's, all German parts were made as if they were going to last forever. Now, all German parts are being made with *_planned obsolescence_* built in.
I thanked the German engineers for telling me the truth.
So, Ms. Sabine, you gotta understand, the Germany today is no longer the Germany 40 years ago.
I have a food mixer, made in DDR , East Germany, in 1980. Still works fine to this day
Most of the things, if not everything, is made with planned obsolescence in mind, that's the way of the capitalism. It's not only Germany who is doing that. Just pointing that out.
It's sad that planned obsolescence is even a thing. It's sad and stupid.
ms. Sabine is part of the problem i'm afraid. As a scientist you should never ever let activism cloud your scientific methods. But she does that when climate change is the topic on hand.
"I'm not an expert, but I believe.....blablabla...it sound ethically blablabla"
Everything is going to shit and it's because germany has accepted so many lies by so many liers it doesn't even know what truth is any longer.
200.000 bright minds leave every year and the won't come back. Rightfully so.
We're leaving to. Eff that politically correct neo-socialist state
I'm avid vintage car collector, but also have a newer MB SLK 350... The quality of some components are not that good, similar to some modern American cars... Beautiful looking car though!
As a German I can confirm this
I’m American. When it comes to embarrassment, you are amateurs.
Well, they still hold the WWII as a joker
What's the measure of embarrassment in the imperial (US customary) system? 😅
The american economy is by far the best in the world, not an embarassment at all.
At least you can do something about it. Why not stand for president, while nobody any good is?
Feels like a humiliation ritual of some sort and inverted the joker has become king and the king a joker.
Thanks, Sabine! One of my fave channels now on youtube.
I can agree. We've been waiting for Kraftwerk to come out with another album for the last 30 years.
Maybe they've been shut down because they're a nuclear Kraftwerk?
Ha! Forgot about them..
You've not seen 'Ja, das Hokey Kokey'.
Man schteckt die linke Arm aus
Ein, aus, ein, aus
Man schütteln alles rund
Man macht das Hokey-Kokey
Und man dreht sich herum
Das ist die ganze Sache
Blame the klimaklebers /s
21 years. They made 'Tour de France Soundtracks' in 2003.
Welcome, Sabine, to the worldwide "I'm embarrassed of my Country" club, feel free to pick any flag!
1 billion population in India but divided, disconnected, superstitious. I wish my heart turns into stone and mind freezes. Child labor, female foeticide, caste system, corruption, unemployment, illiteracy. I wish I could meet god, ask questions. Why such disparity, why such pain? Free mind freez!
Same here in the USA. Billionaires rule and we all lose.
@@Krn7777w At the very least India seems on the up and up. Things were so bad there before that it is better in a relative way. In Germany and many western countries the feeling is the opposite where things are going down hill. This perception has grave social consequences historically.
Humans appear to be too stup!d to govern themselves. Maybe our AI overlords will fix that.
Yes, carry a Union Flag in London and you'll be arrested for 'being openly English'
I lived in the old West Germany in the 80s. Everything worked, trains on time, streets spotlessly clean. I loved it. What's happened?
Inept politicians are destroying the country. :(
Ironically... Maybe lack of competition after the end of communism? 😅
Unfettered immigration…
👈ism......that's what happened 🤷♂️
I blame.the zuckerberh trirbe
I love that this popped up into my feed... this week.
In Italy, we usually refer to Germany as the perfect example of punctuality and efficiency for trains. Having traveled a bit in the last few years, I can say that Spain, Italy (excluding the very south) and France are light years ahead.
That stereotype should be applied to individuals, but definitely not Deutsche Bahn, god I hate them
@@leobe2104 the Bahn can only do as well as the politicians running the show. And let’s not act like this has only become a problem under this administration…
Didn't the trains be in time in Italy many years ago when a bald "duke" ruled the country?! The situation in Sweden, where I live, is also a misery.
@@Soundbrigade nope, bald guy would rather invest in the army than the railway. Saying that the trains were on time is the stereotypical thing that the weird single uncle says at Christmas' lunch when someone points out our current problems.
The only good thing about the German railway system is that it's extremely interconnected, with a lot of branch lines to small villages, whereas in Italy many of those were closed to favor the automobile industry.
Normally, being slow is a good thing when going in the wrong direction. Anyway, our German contribution to solving the world's problems: showing everyone else how not to do it.
The US would like a word. The problems are not evenly distributed. Where I am there is no train service at all to speak of even though I live in an important regional metropolis. I do have access to fiber internet, however.
If not for the Russia-Ukraine drama, things would be comparatively more stable.
Should've worked harder for peace rather than jumping into war because a certain dumdum thought that it was a good way for the local companies of *some country* to benefit.
Seriously, we have zero quality public transit in the US. The east coast at least should be covered in rail networks for easy and efficient transportation. There's so many cities that would be wonderful with light rail too. Instead we need to own our own expensive machine and take on the mind numbing task of commuting by car everywhere.
@@kylebeatty7643 regional trains absolutely need to be built in the US. Amtrak needs high speed rail for distances of 100 to 150 miles. Flying makes more sense for transcontinental travel, no need to invest in a transcontinental high speed rail line (yet). That means shit should be easier to build, but the problem in the US is the red tape, local governments, and individual NIMBYs. Look at how long it’s taken California: 20 years of planning, billions already spent, and it’s only now starting to be built.
America: Alright, bet. Green technology is now a political conspiracy and all attempts at progress will be met with armed resistance. Also, about 15-30% of the country wants the country to become a theocracy and we're willing to do anything to make it happen. Ala "Project 2025"
I assure you, my 7.5 MB/s are not to be trifled with. (written 1 day ago)
@kti5682 well, that is 60 MBit/s.
Try being on 2Mbits/s (serious)
7.5 MB/s = 60 Mb/s thats plenty enough.
@@authenticbaguette6673 does it still run a single 480p youtube stream ? i had this speed up until 2014, then finally got 50 Mbit/s and now a am on GPON fiber which is a blessing
@@rontaylor3403 60Mb/s ? I have 270Mb/s here in Canada, and I'm in one of the poorer provinces!
Vielen Dank für diesen Beitrag!! Highly appreciated
German lifehack for speeding up Internet access:
Ask a friend in Belgium to download the files for you, store it on a USB stick, then you ride over there with your bike to pick it up.
Never underestimate the bandwidth of a bag full of USB sticks on a push bikes
except that she says Belgium has less fibre optics coverage....
Yeahh.... but you have to admit it´s very friendly to the environment......😬 🤣
Austria has good internet too
Classic high bandwidth - high latency example.
Your saying that in Germany "The Wi-Fi is so slow that by the time the news is streaming it has become an historical documentary" got a good laugh out of me. It kills the notion that Germans don't have a sense of humor. Not that I ever believed it.
We do have Wi-Fi in Germany? I'm still waiting for my phone line I ordered in 1991.
okay, 1st part is a joke, but 2nd part is reality, they never delivered
But... you don't need fast wifi to stream ...
I think she totally nails german humor is dry and very sarcastic, not for the faint hearted ❤😂🎉but if you can handle it is super fun.
News here aren't worth listening to anyway.
It's difficult for me to detect this humor 🤔, I had to re-watch and check for facial expression clues or something alike but nothing
How do ppl do it?
Howdy, Northern neighbours, Swiss-Austrian dual citizen based in Vienna here. It's funny: When I was a child in the 80s and 90s, out of the German-speaking countries Austria was the one that felt the most "backwards" and actually a bit "Eastern-blocky" as my relatives in Switzerland used to joke. The stereotype, confirmed by massive anecdotical evidence, was that, for example, international trains would inevitably start accumulating delays as soon as they had entered Austria. Back then, (West) Germany was somewhat in between - not as well-organized as Switzerland, but pretty solid. Within the last 20 years, Austria and Germany have somehow switched roles. While Austria has modernized a lot, Germany increasingly feels like Austria used to feel 30-40 years ago.
What I also find quite funny is the different ways in which the Swiss and the Austrians deal with the fact that, since a lot of our trains come in from Germany, the constant delays of Deutsche Bahn are messing up our own timetables: By now, the Swiss always have a few extra trains ready at the border and, if the German train is delayed, they simply run an extra Swiss train on the Swiss part of the route. The Austrians don't do that, but they make up for it by making their announcements as passive-aggressive as possible ("Unfortunately, train so and so is still 55 minutes delayed because, once again, the hand-over by Deutsche Bahn at the border was delayed by 90 minutes. On behalf of Austrian Railways, we would like to apologize for the inconvenience caused to our passengers by Deutsche Bahn.").
As a Brit I am by turns humbled and delighted by your witty command of English. Bravo Sir, bravo!
Das Österreichische Netz ist recht einfach, verglichen mit dem Deutschen.
Austria's technological prowess is not to be underestimated. They have revolutionized the light aircraft market in the US, with Rotax and Austro engines and Diamond airframes. It used to be that a ~150 ps aircraft engine displaced 7 liters and weighed 140kg. Now a Rotax engine produces 158 ps from 1.4 liters and I can pick it up and carry it around by myself.
Kann ich bestätigen. Österreich und Ganz besonders Wien ist wunderschön. War zum Urlaub mehrmals dort und habe n Monat dort gearbeitet. Eine der besten Zeiten meines Lebens. Liebe Grüße ans schöne Wien. ❤️
@@YogiAI To be fair though - as much as I love myself some good old-fashioned German-bashing as we are so fond of in the small neighouring countries - I think the extremely high cost of German re-unification is often under-estimated. I would not necessarily say that Austrian, Swiss, or Dutch politicians have been so much smarter than their German counterparts in the past few decades, but they could afford to make some mistakes and still have enough money to modernize infrastructure and public administration as well as to create reasonably good conditions for private enterprise.
German road works take months where other countries need just days. Seen this in the US, Spain, Portugal and just two weeks ago in Denmark. During the week we stayed, they repaved like 20km road with little impact on traffic. They also repaved the center of a small village within 2 days!
I worked with a German company in the 1970's installing automation in a continuous casting steelworks. The competence and standards were very high, they only had two standards, perfect and upwards, nothing else was acceptable. I learned a lot about German perfectionism and it was impressive. I learned a fair bit of the language as well, but that was a long time ago
This approach is still present but it has to compete with the corruption that has taken root in much of the country, both state and federal government are infected and so far, its not enough to make people actually aware of what's going on because the carefully constructed lies still hold up.
And I am working under a German manager right now who is totally incompetent and always bitch about others to secure his place. 😂
@@AaronGrady-e1o 😂 Ja, sowas in die Richtung habe ich auch schon erlebt.
@ Die Geschichte endet jedoch nicht hier. Das Büro liegt in einer abgelegenen Gegend, in der er selbst wohnt, was ihm den Vorteil verschafft, jeden Morgen pünktlich um 08:00 Uhr im Büro zu sein - und ganz ehrlich, das ist das Einzige, was er gut macht. Die anderen Kollegen kommen aus den Städten, und leider ist die Deutsche Bahn nicht mehr zuverlässig, was dazu führt, dass viele zu spät kommen. Er hat es geschafft, eine Mitarbeiterin, die ihm in ihrer Leistung und Kompetenz haushoch überlegen war, entlassen zu lassen, indem er sich täglich bei der Geschäftsleitung beschwert hat. In Wahrheit ist die Produktivität dieses Managers sehr gering, und er besitzt unzureichende Fähigkeiten für seine Position. Ich denke, er wird dort länger bleiben als die talentierten Mitarbeiter, die es wirklich verdient hätten, dort zu sein. 🤣
Thank you very much for this video. I worked in Germany for years and enjoyed collaborating with my German colleagues tremendously. However, I learnt the following important rules:
- do not commute by train (Deutsche Bahn will make you hate trains even if you loved them before);
- do not hope for German politicians to raise investment in infrastructure, education, research and development, or digitalization (even if they frequently state how important doing so would be for our prosperity);
- keep new ideas that would simplify bureaucracy for yourself (they are seen as offensive, even if they are intended as helpful);
- do not try something new (if you fail, you will be grilled, if you succeed, someone else will claim responsibility);
Anyway, I hope things will improve again at some point, so keep spreading the message as loud as you can.
I don't think these new ideas are seen as offensive, it's just that people probably already thought of them and troed it themselves, but people higher up are so slow and opposed to change that it lead to nothing, so they are just annoyed as they know how to improve the situation, they just can't do anything about it
"The world isn't afraid of us anymore"
- Sabine, 2024
Those are actually very reassuring words to every other nation.
But they're bully enough to support genocide in Gaza by the victims of Holocaust
"The world ... isn't ... afraid of us anymore."
Expected this to be about the Nazis. Instead it was just... Kinda Nazi like
@@entp_adventures You are not seriously saying this video was nazi like... now that is hella stupid.
liebe Sabine, ich bin seit 2022 nicht mehr in meinem Heimatland, als Künstlerin fehlte mir zunehmend die Luft zum Atmen, die Offenheit zu kontroversem Austausch, der gegenseitige Respekt. Es ist alles zunehmend ideologisch
Sie ist auch eine Linke...
So talking about trains.
I am not a German citizen and came here for masters. Once I was coming from a place and the last train at Frankfurt suddenly got cancelled and the funny thing is there was no substitute service available so basically I have to sit on the station till 7am.
When I told this story to my German friends they simply replied. Willkommen in Deutschland.
Rule 0:
NEVER rely on the last train in Germany. The last train (or bus) only exists as a backup if the earlier train gets cancelled, breaks down or disappears in a black hole.
Edit: If you think the "black hole" was just a joke, no, it wasn't. I have already been in the situation where a train hasn't been seen along any station of it's way but somehow moved itself to the end station while being displayed as "perfectly in time" in the app.
In this situation the Bahn will pay you a hotel room (provided you had a ticket for the cancelled train).
Moral of the story: GET BACK TO FUCKING BOMBAY! We all know how beautiful Indian trains are!
DB should do what they do in the UK. Just make the tickets too expensive to realistically go anywhere on the railways.
@@javiergilvidal1558so the declining quality of the public services in Germany doesn't bother you? You are okay if things doesn't get better?
The biggest problem in Germany is all the paperwork. There are so many laws that they send you from one place to another, and you have to pay a lot of money just to find out what permission you need.
Paperwork? Eh, try Italy.
That happens a lot in the People Socialist Republik of Kalyfornystan (a.k.a the state of California).
We had this paperwork 30 years ago as well. More work, better results. While bureaucracy is nevertheless a burden, the decline of Germany has other causes.
@@traumflug That's it. Bureaucracy is just a disguise for the real problems.
@@EngineMisfire -- I call it Commiefornia ... and the fearless leader Gov Kim Un Newsance is leading the way.
Wait, I'm from rural village in Borneo and my internet speed is much faster than Sabine's?
I switched from "fiber" to wireless and the copper cable for multiple km.
Because my "fiber" was unusable due to having multi second lag spikes every minute.
i'm from a poor neighborhood, from a poor region of brazil and my internet is faster than hers. fiber for $20usd/month 500Mb
@@bajocontinuoThat might be true but fiber is about the only thing that could be labeled fast in Spain.
My parents have 12 Mbit/s in a 1 million metropolitan area
@@shracc You really should have gotten them to fix it, it is broken.
I love your sense of humor. Every video I'll crack up at least once or twice. I love the subtle sarcasm. The biting sense of being fed up with everything.
Last year I traveled around England for 5 weeks and dealt with cancelled trains and strikes and hearing people complain about how everything in the country is falling apart. Same things in my own country, Canada.
I think it's happening in many developed countries, including Germany, for a variety of reasons.
Socialists will screw everything up. Its happening in the U.S. at an alarming rate.
Yes because all Western European nations are now run by psychopaths who hate themselves and have already transformed them into Third World nations.
What are those reasons, then?
What's falling apart in Canada?
@@oneoflokis Governments that do not represent the people, but rather, corporations and the elites.
Phasing out nuclear as an emotional response to Fukushima was the dumbest thing Germany ever did.
Oh they have done dumber
You're not very aware of History, aren't you?
It is not about fukushima. It is about tschernobyl.
it is a rejection of everything that is connected with russia.
The dumbest thing the Germans ever did was almost having children way below replacement level then open the doors to mass immigration. Germany as we know it will be gone in 50 years
@@aureliustratos3268 German nuclear power plants that used to be in operation in 2011 had nothing to do with Russia.
I fully agree with Sabines assessment. The underlying problem started earlier, though. Germans grew complacent and started living of the success of the past. This in turn led to people focusing on non-issues and neglecting crucial investments into physical infrastructure and efficient bureaucracy. Managing symptoms instead of making right but hard decisions. This has added up.
Your discussion reminds me of Canada, especially our medical care system that has a good quality of technology but is choking with paper bureaucracy. There are far too many nonsense regulations and silly repetitive rules that block getting much done each day. Procrastination is a huge problem.
RS. Canada
🇨🇦 ✋
At work here in Germany I frequently get in trouble for taking initiative and trying to be proactive, I'll foresee a potential problem and try to prevent it only to be told by my bosses to stop. I should rather come to them first and they'll put it in the schedule for next week's meeting by which time the problem has actually arisen and has built up to the point that it affects the efficiency of the whole operation. Instead of allowing me an hour to create a solution that will result in efficiencies the whole way down the line of the project (not to mention increased safety) they wait until it has built up to the point that it takes many more man hours to solve, decreases safety and efficiency of the primary project as well as the solving of the problem, still don't try and mitigate any knock-on effects and then complain that the project is running slow and people aren't working hard enough. This has happened so often that now I usually don't even try, I just catch myself and have a little internal laugh and think "Oh well, it was a nice idea"
It's the same here in 🇦🇺
It is all about power 😮 How embarrassing for your bosses when a “normal worker” discovers an arising problem and even has an easy solution for this, which was created in one hour! If your bosses let this pass, it would mean, their work and all of the meetings and blabla would be unnecessary. This is how companies work, this is how the health system, administrations and government work… all of the (useless) rules are made to justify and secure the existence of all of the people who could easily be replaced by a few people with common sense😕 Das ist auch ein Problem: umständliche Diskussionen, die zu nichts führen, aber Hauptsache: jeder “wichtige” Mitarbeiter hat was dazu gesagt… der gesunde Menschenverstand und die Eigenschaft Probleme zu erkennen, lösungsorientiert zu denken und die Probleme dann auch zu lösen, wird von den Vorgesetzten im Keim erstickt, weil ja dann ihre Existenz überflüssig wäre….
Same in France. Initiative: 0. It's all overbearing hierarchy. No ability to make the most of the new opportunities and tools.
@@mwallace2922 Nope. not a fair assessment. In AU you have initiative and things are moving fast. I know, I live in AU, and born French. Ozzies have no idea how "lucky" they are. Yeah renting is bad, but it's the same all over the West. The rest of the country works and move fw. When I arrived I was in awe at no queues to get a driver license. So fast, so efficient, so seamless, and with a smile. Try France and go eat sand.
@@b.2194Universities globally have been like this for decades. No wonder the world is getting dumber.
Crippling infrastructure is a rapidly growing disease, as is dysfunctional government both certainly have a correlation. As a New Yorker, I’ve always found it funny that the subway is seen as such a big part of its identity. But the city really seems to ever care if at all to actually get it to work well, or even just work.
What ever happened to Joe Bidens' "Biden Build Back Better"? Where did all those billions go for our infrastructure?
Or make it safe to ride.
NYC subway is spooky to say the least.
Pretty much the same for all of the American electricity system. Should be unified but it is in 3 separate grids. Getting the paperwork sorted to link alternative energy sources is hell on earth.
And yet, you've got 3.6 million daily users on a weekday in 2023. So clearly it is working, even if not as well as some would like. Where I live, I can only dream of urban railway infrastructure as far reaching and as well functioning as the nyc subway.
I get it that it's best to strive for more and better but it's ok to take stock of what you have already every once in a while.
VERY sad.. spent a few years in Germany and I loved it.. was 80's.. so clean and beautiful outside and talented people..
back in the 80's Germany still had Coal and Nuclear power and was not run by 'Greens' now nuclear is gone coal is on the way out and all the solar, wind and other renewable sources cannot cope with demand, how stupid can German Politicians, businesses and the people be, electricity costs have gone up and up and the ordinary German is carrying the Green burden.
Now it's very.. diverse
Relax. It's not like Germany is a failed state now. There are problems, but there are also solutions.
I've traveled to Germany 5 times. My ancestry is Germany, the young women are beautiful, but it wasn't the friendliest country.
@@JohnSmith-pn1vvVery...Muslim.
Other example: intelligent net meters. By wanting to make them super-perfect, being able to transmit commands to electricity-using washing machines or heat pumps from the provider, and at the same time have the highest standard of private-data-protection, we ended up having no intelligent net meters to speak of and they are more expensive at that. We lost ~ 10 years this way by trying to solve a non-problem. Demand management can be done over the internet just as good, or via 15-minute electricity pricing.
Sabine: I'm embarrassed to be German and it's my government's fault
Me, an American: "First time?"
Germans don't embarrass easily.
my faith in some Americans (i.e. you) is slightly restored :)
Try being British. I literally blush with embarrassment when I wake up every morning.
Ukrainian here. Unwillingly joining the club.
Italian here: "Hold my beer"
Hearing a German saying "The world just isn't appropriately afraid of us anymore" in that nice Germanic accent made my day.
As a Greek I can tell you that the state of the German economy is scary the hell out of all other EU countries.
Shows you mindset where even after Nazism they still want to make the world fear them while simultaneously look up to them, I don’t think Germans are aware of how racist they are, they must have been indoctrinated so early to think in this overly superior way.
@@Hope_Boatyeah because we've been propping up your economy for decades in exchange for a cheap Europe so we can export around the globe
If your people paid taxes you wouldn't have to be scared about how our economy is doing
Probably one of the scariest things we can hear, especially if you're Jewish.
@@LuluTheCorgi As someone from Poland, where our economy has been growing greatly and taxes have been paid we still worry about German economy. Everyone knows that if sh*t was to hit the fan Germany would use it's oversized influence on European Union to help themselves and also make situation worse for everyone else in the process. That has already happened in 2008 and when it comes to gas deals with Russia that significantly destroyed Europe's economy after 2022 so Germany could have cheaper gas earlier.
That's why Poland will never buy into joining eurozone. We prefer our own currency thanks to what Germany (and to a lesser extent France) was doing. Eurozone is destroying European Union for the benefit of Germany.
I visited Germany in August 2023. I bought one month train subscription, a mistake happened and it ended up taking from me the price of 2 months instead of one. I emailed the transport company, 4 times and they took 6 months to answer me!! 6 freaking months! The issue got solved and closed in June 2024! Almost 11 months after my first email!! There is something seriously wrong with whatever is going on there!
I live 300km from next town we don't even have buses. Stop complaining live in my fked up country Australia
Yeah I live here and I can tell you truckloads of stories like this. It is nothing unusual.
It took so long because they already had your money. If you wanted to buy a car and mailed them that there is an error with their online payment system so you can't pay even if you wanted to - it would take only 30mins.
Similar thing happened to me and it was an airplane company. Lufthns..
Took them months (4 to 6 don't remember) to get me back my money.
It did not ruin my vacation exactly but i definitely could not enjoy it thinking if I will get it back and documenting everything for them in my holiday time.
Why bother with your own country if that's not your country anymore.
Thanks for your honesty, Sabine.
Well since Germany's decline the German people for the first time in history have developed a sense of humour.
Actually, humour in East Germany was a lot better than in the West. It was a good cover to complain about things without being seen as a subversive.
German comedians are the best. So much material.
"german cannot into humour" - people who only know four jokes.
Quite a stupid and untrue trope that shows you have never lived in Germany.
The "forklift driver Klaus" videos from the 80's prove you wrong
That was a class A rant. 10/10 for you Sabine.
There is something in it. I'm a Pole as a kid in 1997 I lived in Germany for one year as my dad had a Humboldt Scholarship.
It was another world - modern buses, modern trains (even if they were even more late than polish trains) clean cities. Everything was screaming "west", "modern", "rich" and "better". And Autobahns - it was something different compared to polish road network of 1997.
And now when I visit I see dirty cities. Trains, buses and train stations so less modern than in Poland. And Autobahns? They seem narrow and uncomfortable compared to polish express roads.
Poland lacks much of the cultural enrichment that Germany has benefited from over the last couple of decades.
Poland is a great country
Who do you think's been financing the new stuff in Poland?
@@FoobsTon Polish taxpayers
@@Thematic2177
Sorry. From Statista:
Since 2004, Poland has received nearly 246 billion euros from the European Union budget. During this period, membership payments to the EU budget amounted to over 83.8 billion euros.22 Apr 2024
Good job lady, you’re telling the truth and I am very happy to see people like you speak out, congratulation. 👍👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Half of my family is German and I have a German mother. I've traveled to Germany to stay with family, usually in the Summers, for 48 years now since I was 3 years old. Seeing changes that have occurred in that regard are like turning pages in a picture book. They are more apparent and give you a better perspective of what is actually changing, and to what degree, than someone that lives there in my opinion. I took my family in 2019, and due to the pandemic and some other variables, didn't return until the Summer of 2023. The changes were stark to say the least. Most notably the different energy, or lack thereof, in the air when out in public. Almost like the country is in a emotional depression. The other were the horrible issues with trains being on time or without issue, which I thought was impossible considering my past decades of experience.
Frust kommt auf denn der Bus kommt nicht
yea the whole nation is depressed and fed up. germans refuse to rescue the world with their very own money. then get blamed by media and politics for "not taking responsibility"...
while they taxing your income with more than 40%, making it impossible to earn a dezent pension, impossible to buy houses. for many, childcare became a serious financially problem. so does eldercare.
i'd left if not for my family and friends. thats not germany anymore. its some globalist playground but not a capable nation anymore.
Der Song müsste nochmal neu aufgesetzt werden mit 200 Strophen für Deutschland und nicht nur Berlin.
Reichen 200 ?
Hmm glaub nicht oder😅
@@texasflooring ,the entire World is changing ,not just Germany
@@weltbuergerin2007 Ya, but it's far more stark and noticeable on a homogeneous society than a multicultural one.
Last year, the german Bundesnetzagentur started a tender for a government contract for new fax machine provider. The Bundesnetzagentur... is the federal internet department...
This is not satire.
A few years ago, i was in the german equivalent to the DMV. I had to look through tons of old paperwork to get some specific esoteric personal registration number (Of which each german department loves to issue several at once for different purposes. Don't think you'll get away with a simple ID number. No, no, no.). I had to go twice, because the first time, i handed the employee my government issued ID card and asked if he could just enter my name in the system to look it up. Well... i had to come back next week with the specific number he wanted, because he refused. He said, he couldn't type in the personal information of every person who came to him, because he would never get anything done that way. Which kind of sounds as if he *could have* done it, if he wanted. And then i saw something i will never forget. The guy filled a formular, rolled it up, put it in a plastic can and put it into the pneumatic tube mail behind his desk and told me to go to another office in 3rd floor for the next step.
I swear, i thought i was stuck in a Kafka novel.
this is crazy wtf hahahaha
Das ist einfach herrlich . Passierschein a38
You're serious? :-) I'm from the Czech Republic and it's really true that Fax is still used in Germany. :-)
Those pneumatic tubes make an incredible sucking sound, like that of hope and promise of a future exiting.....
@@blackmesa1855 Wollte es grade schreiben.
I saw a newspaper yesterday that had an article titled "Mythos Merkel". Yes, she is now already in the same league as legendary heroes. A shining beacon of standing still for 16 years.
Well, same as Helmut Kohl. And that were another 16 years. If you bother about missing fibre optics, ask him!
Absolute awful and overhyped Person.She left us in a giant pile of mess with ruined military, infrastructure and dependend from russian gas.Not to mention her nuts migration and Euro-politics.
It's incredible how these mythical figures seem to disappear before the SHTF.
Their timing is certainly mythical.
Frau Merkel was a disaster who helped all the seeds of German destruction sprout and grow worse for years.
Shining beacon of standing still!!!!
Thank You for a very humorous time just when I needed it...
I'm a mineral physicist, did my PhD in German (dumb idea). Had to do experiments at DESY, at the PETRA III synchrotron. Do you know what they did starting in 2022? They have the beam off for 20% of the time now. Why? To save on energy! Yes, they turn off a particle accelerator that is incredibly competitive for beam time, 20% of the year, because energy is too expensive.
There's no surprise that Germany is falling behind. Those are the kind of decisions that are made daily there.
Yes, it's still, now, in 2024, 20% of the year turned off. Screwed my research up quite badly!
Wind and solar over coal is five times more expensive.
wait, havent they heard of company inventory management from accounting side.... if factory buys insanely expensive new machine, they better make sure it is used 99.99% to settle purchase cost in targeted time. I guess universities dont do this and thus they suck. Afterall even 50c electric is insanely cheap compared to billion euros CERN and other fancy science equipment. (I guess newest ones can be 15 billion euros range).
There was a war against nuclear power because people are ignorant now. The only failures of Nuclear were from early version plants (3 mile, Chornobyl) or hit by a tsunami. Meanwhile, it is a great source of power that is safe, green, and wonderful. Oh well.
I can't imagine that kind of equipment likes being turned on and off frequently, either.
I think their decision to shut down nuclear reactors and instead re-open coal power plants is one of the most insane decisions of modern societies. Modern day Germany is so extremely reactive to global events. I somehow doubt that any of Germany's nuclear reactors are at risk of tsunami. Frankly Japan's idea to build a low-lying coastal plant was the main cause of the Fukushima disaster. They're literally surrounded by tectonic activity
I'm in a shack in the mountains of Idaho, and we're getting fiber today. Nearest town has a population of around 45 people.
The comparison to remote villages is a bit misleading. It appears to be comparatively very easy to put fiber optic into rural areas than in suburbs or cities where there are already lots of buried utilities. Meanwhile they are putting 5G towers in cities so maybe fiber optic is not necessary for most people.
But you Americans have your own issues with infrastructure I am afraid. For example a lot of services are very expensive. Granted not everything works "perfectly" here in Germany like where we have slower conections maybe but they usually don't cost as much as in the US. And what you have is not always that much faster.
Like for example, the median price for internet access is about $75 per month in the US. With Germany on average, a 1000 Mbit/s internet plan costs 56.5 € per month with discount and 69 € per month without. Slower conections can be a lot cheaper though starting at 20 euros. So 70 Euros per month would be really the extreme(!) end in Germany. Not in the US.
Every nation, at the end of the day, has their very own unique problems.
Who pays for it?
Thanks for Biden
that sounds lovely
Singer, songwriter, brilliant scientist and communicator. Sabine can also do stand-up comedy. I'm a fan.
Hello Dear.
You deliver very smart information.
I'm here in Australia 🇦🇺, Australia is in many ways far ahead..Germany 🇩🇪 is extremely slow.
I moved to Australia , I love it here.
I don't wanna go back. Only the Tax department is getting worse.
Have a lovely day.
Wuff
dont worry. I'm british, you learn to live with a constant state of national embarrassment.....
America:
It's bad
So bad
Until you’ve had Trump for President, you have no idea how embarrassed you can be of your country. 🙃
After living with the Biden/Harris administration for the few years we've had them, Americans ABSOLUTELY understand national embarrassment.
@@Ifuckwithtrinketsto be fair, the Brits had a knockoff version with Boris
Thanks to the GOP the United States is getting used to it as well.
"...buy a dog so you don't have to walk home alone" and who says Germans don't have a sense of humor?
A very peculiar one, but they do have it. I remember when some local friends took me to try the typical snack specialty in Frankfurt. And no, it wasn't Frankfurter sausages (which they actually call Wiener). It's called "Handkäse mit Musik" - literally translated as "hand cheese with music". Weird name, isn't it? They explained: it's a kind of semi-hard cured cheese eaten with the hands (hence the name) as thick slices on buttered bread and topped with chopped raw onions and caraway seeds. It's delicious, trust me! Especially with a glass of apple wine, also typical from that area, and in the merry centuries-old taverns of the Sachsenhausen district.
But then I asked about the "music" part. They just replied: "oh, that comes later..." 🤣 (It actually didn't, fortunately.)
How many Germans does it take to screw in a lightbulb?
One. We are efficient, and don't have humor. ;)
You will also need a dog if you happen to come across youth gangs of „guests“.
@@ichraumauf5532 I've heard them referred to as "young scholars".
They killed all the funny people.
I had visited and stayed in Germany many times and each time I find something new that shocks me. I love the country but things need to change.
@@2b_or_not_2b_4gotten Yes, our government is supporting foreign interests. US interests primarily. Nobody even talks about how the US (Baltops 22, Seymour Hersh) destroyed our most important energy supply in an act of terrorism just because US strategists do not want us to work together with Russia.
They rather have us kill each other in a third world war Europe VS. Asia/Russia, while watching the whole thing from over the atlantic, eating popcorn.
The Ukrainian war is also just a proxy war between NATO and Russia, funded mostly by Germany and Europe, while the US is enjoying the show.
(Of course I am only talking about the government, military etc. - not my fellow American patriots)
I worked as a teacher during the pandemic. Still remember the utter disbelief of an Indian friend when I told them that our classroom didn't have running water for days. Sometimes there was no soap. Other times there was neither. As a bonus the windows - by design - couldn't be opened.
For too long the smartest people have avoided politics and left it to the least capable. Thank you for embracing the challenge to reverse this
Yes, sensible people like Sabine need to be heard above the bureaucrats and politicians ..... her 1.38 million subscribers is a good start.
That issue is persistent across time and nations
When smart people do become politicians, they get torn to shreds. I honestly believe the best way to influence politics is from the outside. I know that sounds like a cop out, but the political machine is an emulsifier. It destroys individual ideas (and the soul of the idea giver) and blends them into a bland soup. When the emulsion of an idea inevitability fails, the idea giver is made to pay the political price for its failure.
Smart means very little when willful ignorance is a thing, & people striving to crawl out of ignorance are eventually seen as too much of a threat to reach any auspices of political power except for the bare minimum of controlled opposition
Unfortunately it's not enough to be smart. People tend to not vote for the smart politicians, at least not if they do smart things.
In Germany half the trains are delayed. In Britain they're not even considered "delayed" unless they're at least an hour late. In America the last train left in 1952.
because in 'america', people drive 800Km for fun.
I just drove over 1600km to deliver something and was basically in the same part of the USA the whole time
Late is also only referenced by a 1 Hour delay at the final stop - the middle are a 'free fr all'
Trains are coming back to America. It's slow getting started, but happening. Trains will remove cars from freeways.
@@daniellarson3068 Doubtful. Look at the past history of rail in the US. Now look at its present. The ICE isn't going anywhere any time soon.
You have my sympathy, Sabine... welcome to England!
I suspect both our countries are suffering from the same maliase - a couple of generations free-loading off the hard work of their forebears combined with ineffectual government has left an empty shell of a country.
I'm pretty sure this is how Rome fell - barbarians invading were a symptom, not the cause.
As an aside Olaf Scholz strikes me as a dangerous coward and a fool, for which you also have my sympathy. Here's hoping our new PM isn't the same - the inherent issue with Labour is 'hard' socialists tend to become dictators, while 'soft' socialits tend to choose 'populist' over 'sense'.
Learn Arabic
@@TeddyRumble No, he should learn "self defense" and how to get away with it.
I am a doctor in India. I am thinking of doing post graduation in Germany. So I searched a few things about Germany. And now youtube suggested me this video 😂
A friend of mine is developing a chatbot for a German company. Their internal software system is so terrobly designed and hard to use and so they wanted to use AI to help users make sense of it. Along the way, the developers realized that in the past, there have been multiple other IT projects to cope with that software beside the chatbot, but none of them really helped.
My friend kept wondering why they didnt go with the obvious solution, which is designing an entirely new software to replace the old ones. Instead they kept it and keep slapping new tech like AI like a bandaid over it.
But since they're paying my friend, the chatbot project goes on.
It's exactly the same story as not upgrading to optic cables but trying to improve copper sables instead.
sunk cost fallacy
something something -man empire.
And when they finally decide to fix it, they implement a more powerful version that is even worse in terms of user experience lol
American banks would like t[ have a chat. At least one major one still has all their back end run by cobol...
no that a very different problem with tech in general, its goes like this, new less-code solution become trendy promising ease of use and being able to do 80% what more-code solution do, company switch to and start wanting to implement the 20% only to find out that the 80% is the easy part that even an intern can do, their solution grow in complexity slowly and now they are stuck in this model.
dev that specialized in these less-code solution over time became so complex and fought over by the very few leftover companies that are stuck, but also in a way those dev are stuck cause if that market fail their job is gone and they so out of shape in coding in general.
I live in Thailand, about 18 km from the nearest town (Hua Hin). My internet comes through glass fiber cable with over 800 mbps!
Every year I have to send a life certificate to receive my pension from the Deutsche Rente for one more year: it has to be done by post. Twice it never arrived. Now I have to send it via registered mail, so I can follow it's tracks. They don't accept it via e-mail. It has to be done on paper! In 2024! Probably because of "privacy and security" reasons, but anyone can open the envelop on the way to Germany.
I retired in 2012 and before that time I took the train to Frankfurt airport from a small place called Herzogenrath. I always had to take into consideration that there would be a delay, so I had to take one or two trains before the actual time that I had to be at the airport (I used to work for Lufthansa)... Oh I can go on about it... on the whole, I'm glad that I can live in a "third world" country like Thailand.
Thailand is amazingly progressive in many areas. Most Thais use their mobiles to pay for everything. My wife comes from Kalasin (rural Northern Thailand) and even the internet in her village is faster than mine is in Australia.
in the 90s nobody in Thailand owned a computer most of the population didn't even know what it was while Germany was cutting edge now Germany has fallen decades behind Thailand
Can you justify receiving a pension when you don't live in the country that gives it to you? I know you Boomers think you deserve the world.
I'm from Brazil, and is very ironic seeing native people who lives in villages in the middle of the Amazon Rainforest here having better tech than a first world country.
Can we stop using the term "third world country"?
I recently told my Vietnames coworkers that 100 mbits internet is fast in Germany (at least 5 years ago when I still lived there). They were speechless.
i live in Vietnam. It's good there's no 5G over there, as the Vietnamese are turning into zombies with their omnipresent electronic devices. The smarter the phone, the dumber the user.
lol, in Germany 30 mbits is fast. oh. and they actually just passed a law defining what "fast internet" means: 15mbits
@@emanueley8410
i have 50mbits and i honestly don't know what i'd do with more. yes it could be faster, but it's completely sufficient for watching live streams and movies, and game downloads are a one time thing that i can just do in the background without affecting me much. my upload also exceeds the twitch bitrate limit. i guess it could be a problem with multiple people watching streams in the same household.
@@simpson6700 You don't know what you don't know. I have 600mbits, and now i finally feel i have no barriers.
50 is nothing.
Hello from Taiwan。I met a German guy in Hokkaido ，Japan just two weeks ago。I told him Germany is a great country and I admire German culture and achievements a lot。Too my surprise， he told me Germany has gotten down in recent years 。I feel sad because I have considered a fan of Germany。
Dear Sabine. Once again, congratulations. I appreciate your sober way on analyzing trends, concepts and things in general. Your level of honesty is something very rare nowadays, even more so “self” (but constructive) criticism. You ARE doing your part to make many things better in this planet and civilization of ours. Commendable!
I feel like the root cause of the "slowness" or the "Technologieoffenheit" is something that - if it happened in other countries - we would point at accusingly and call it 'corruption', but when it happens here in Germany we simply call it 'lobbyism'.
This ist exactly the problem!
It's not necessary to totally and always keep up with other countries technologically. It's better to fall behind, focus elsewhere, and then jump ahead when the time is right. The countries with the worst infrastructure now had the best 50 years ago. Other countries jumped ahead. And, when the time comes, those countries will be behind.
It's not just lobbyism. Talk to some people. Average people. And you quickly realise how "anti-technology" a lot of the population actaully are. We Germans love to sell our selfs as engineeres, techies and progressive. But that's not the reality I am afraid. Our society is, compared to other nations, relatively conservative. Conservative in the sense that we really don't like too much change or too many new things. Up to the point where we rather keep 30 year old technologies around even though we know they are complettely outdated. It's not just a political problem. A lot of it comes from our society and the stance it has to implementing technology.
@@CrniWuk And that´s the other side of the same problem.
@@CrniWuk I've seen in my country (Argentina) how the lefties became the conservatives, because they keep on putting useless people in places of power, where by ignorance or inoperance everything is always worse off than before. And nothing new is allowed to thrive, UNLESS YOU GET IN BED WITH GOVERNMENT. Because that's modern western socialism for you. If you're my friend you enjoy free market. If you're not, you enjoy overtaxing, overregulation. Nothing is ever allowed to change or grow. The more liberal the better usually for letting technology progress. Take that to your next election!
As a German citizen it is frustrating. You see your country falling behind and at some places literally falling apart and the government seem to does not even grasp the situation. I mean high rent and housing prices, outdated retirement system, lack of education, high level of unnecessary bureaucracy, no company friendly politics etc.
I feel you Sabine.
"high rent and housing prices, outdated retirement system, lack of education" - you know why, but it's politically incorrect to say it.
High level of unnecessary bureaucracy - that's because of corruption . Low lever corruption is not an issue in Germany, but the higher you go, the corruption goes up exponentially. So you need a smokescreen to protect that, that's why you got the famous, impenetrable bureaucracy.
If Germany could harvest the energy of bureaucracy, they would conquer the world !
as long as you didn´t vote for the only opposition party in Germany, stop complaining. you got what you voted for!
Germany, The EU and the west as a whole are failing states, this was a conclusion as soon as you allowed gay marriage and pronouns.
@@kamakita8698 stop talking bull, the so called opposition is bringing germany back to poutains fossile fuels
@@ThomasBomber I believe, the Government has perfect understanding of what is happening. What you describe is precisly what they strive for.
Watching this from Belgium where we in fact do not have a government at the moment, 5 months after federal elections.
You are not missing anything, because governments are no longer governing anyway. The problems of Price gouging, social housing, healthcare & education would not be solved, inflation rate would be higher than the wages. Major parties would be either Left or Right, but not in the middle. They would be discussing about the problems instead of fixing it.
I used to work for a Dutch provincial government. We have this exchange program with a couple of Bundesländer, where they send us their most promising civil servants to do an internship for a year with us. Their first week was always a week of culture shock. Things (but not limited to) like: total lack of hierarchy; very few people wear ties; no fixed desks; astounishing level of automation; all forms are online and accessible by both mobile and the visual impaired; lot's of writing in the background is done in English.
One of them said to us: "You're not a government, you're a tech company with a council".
And I believe (I live near the border, do most of my shopping in Germany, etc) that is also the Achilles' Heel of present Germany: it's currently being eaten by those who actually do know how to run things like a modern tech company.
What do you mean by your last point?
@schloesserable it means that while the likes of Elon Musk try to build a state of the art tech factory in Brandenburg, the German auto industry colludes with government and "environmental" groups to desperately slow it all down at all costs. Innovation, progress, solid engineering, ... these are the German things I learned about growing up in Belgium. Go back to that, please. Nobody wins this way.
Not sure if this video is gold or diamonds,
But this comment is pretty good.
I love when the comments teach you something
I always explain the difference between the Dutch and Germans in this way. If you tell a dutchman and german to jump, the dutchman will say: why? the German will say: how high? A strict hierarchy organisation will always lacks a good dimension and interaction between co-workers
so she has a problem with germany becuase of this and not because they try to ban leading opposition parties on outrageous accusations and tries to throw politicians in prison for citing government statistics on twitter??
Having recently moved to Germany and experienced getting a residency permit, driving license, setting up a business, etc, I can concur that Germany is slow. Things in the UK that can be done online and take days, in Germany require multiple face to face meetings and snail mail and take months. No wonder people don't want to set up new businesses in Germany.
Conversely every crook in Europe knew, at least prior to Brexit, that if you wanted to set up a fraudulent company you registered it with Companies House in London precisely because they would hand out a registration to anyone.
Whilst Germany might stand as an example of over-regulation there, the UK's overly permissive system is as bad in the other direction.
I don’t know what you are doing wrong, but setting up a business can be done online within 1 hour in Germany. Just done it last year.
Nevertheless the infrastructure is declining indeed.
@@MlonEusk-qx5xd A GmbH? How about agreeing the articles of association and the notary meeting?
@@peterboneg Unternehmergesellschaft (haftungsbeschränkt) (so the little brother of the GmbH). We used the "Musterprotokoll" as article of association. This probably does not fit the most of the time, but in principal you can set up a business quickly in Germany (it is up to you and your co-founders).
It’s not just a German issue, it’s a global issue when political considerations override technological solutions. Sabine shouldn’t be embarrassed to be German, rather we should all be embarrassed to live in a civilization that places a higher value on entertainment than on seriously addressing the needs of all humans.
We are living in The Age of Entertainment.
I am German living in the US. Agree with your input !
Exactly this!
@@gibboglemore like the Age of Entitlement
That's what the Romans did. It is a great strategy.
I had a German teacher in the 9th grade, and he was an interesting person. Maybe it was his maturity at 60 something. Don't let others brings you down. Embrace your own growth, and find others like you, whether they speak your language or not. ❤