The Warning Automatic Sun reaction PART 2 (analysis and conversation) italian musician Giacomo James
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 кві 2024
- Some analysis and commentary about my yesteday's reaction to the new song, which has created a heated debate, always positive when the discussion is civil and polite, but which has also created a few too many misunderstandings which I will now try to resolve with you with the utmost clarity. ENJOY! :-)
Some analysis and commentary about my yesteday's reaction to the new song, which has created a heated debate, always positive when the discussion is civil and polite, but which has also created, i think, too many misunderstandings which I will now try to resolve with you with the utmost clarity. ENJOY! 🙂
Eres muy certero en tus comentarios y analisis como musico y entiendo completamente tu punto de vista pero las chicas de warning mismas lo han dicho que en este álbum se querian relajar en sus letras y solo divertirse tomalo como un álbum divertido ya que en estos tiempos todo es gris y oscuro solo quieren divertirse y captar mas publico joven como ellas y conectar con su musica en una forma divertida sin tanta estructura como venian componiendo felicidades sigue así y saludos desde México 👀👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾
@@cardonarodriguez5070 muchas gracias my friend !.. ua-cam.com/video/n2BCWJGIHno/v-deo.htmlsi=_Ptw4Vw25664WTtS check also this two reactions here !.. you will understand even more about my pure feelings for this girls 🫁🫶🏻💕
ua-cam.com/video/wGvO6Cx9W3E/v-deo.htmlsi=ZLBnidwQxBGNY4bh Enjoy 😃
You are the best !.. big hug from a The Warning fan. I got your speaches right also yesterday!.. this was SO CLEAR to me.❤
❤️❤️❤️❤️ Warning comment. Thank you so much
This video , from you. Is a Delight!.. Thank you so much for dedicating to us so much of your precious time
Oh Thank you !.. that’s SO nice!
Dear Giacomo.
Thanks for your time and support to the rock.
Many people thinks rock is dead. And only old people can enjoy such a thing.
But we know it isn't true.
Rock is alive!. And is (as The warning says in evolve) Evolving.
I think that is the "rock music" who talk to us in "Evolve".
These girls are prodigies. Geniuses.
They are musicians. And know what to do.
Playing and composing. They've seen the darkest side of musical industry and bringed light to us.
This new rock. 21 century rock. Is brutal, eating other genres. We are old my friend.
And our taste is vanishing with us. Face it.
But Rock stills. Powerful, noisy, rebel, wild and faster than ever. And is beautiful and sexy.
Rock will prevail in new shapes. But with the same metal DNA.
Loved your channel.
Keep moving. Evolve. Motion is life.
Solong.
🤝❤️
Only fanatic and stupid people cannot understand your pure intention. Yesterday and today 🤝💓 Thank you so much ! You are a priceless person ❤️👏🏻
Thank you for your smart approach
@@TheUnderdogDe i already answered yesterday. about music: this new style is more commercial and less original in my humble opinion, and therefore more banal, it values the three musicians less. About the lyrics it seems every song is winking to the same topic, and i prefer the texts of QOTMS (concept album) and Error for example. is that ca rime? maybe is you that didn't listen all the things i said
All My respect for you My friend. A Great person in a fake superficial world
❤️✨🤝
Lovely words .. also yesterday was pretty clear 🎉 Thank you
I supposed the same , but many people were offensive and Don’t know why . Thank you for these speaches
This was the most mature and well expressed followup that i could ever imagine. Well done!!
Thank you so much from the bottom of my heart , and again a big welcome here in my channel !.. 🤗
Lovely❤ you are SO kind!
Thank you SO MUCH!..
The Warning in an interview said in their latest interview that there first albums were made with serious intention! And this new album is made more about fun and not so serious!
Exactly!.. this is the reason why i prefer The previous albums 💿 for my personal tastes . 🤝❤️ Thank you for your comment my friend!
Thank you, sir, for your kind words to my earlier post. I'm so sorry you had to experience such negativity for simply sharing your views. Many people think that a disagreement is the same as an attack, and there's no call for that. Your respect for these ladies is more than evident in your remarks, and, judging by the other comments here, that respect is acknowledged and very much appreciated.
I love what you said about Alé's bass work. Most reactors barely mention her, which borders on criminal neglect.
Again, thank you for your kind words, your honesty, and your ongoing respect and support for "the girls".
Don't let idiots keep you from doing what you love to do. Keep up the great work.
Many more here My man!.. ua-cam.com/play/PLtxeUSYZhJdBi3buKY0-Deqt0z-kHqw23.html&si=fyXPoarhHsNqSpU1 Thank you for your kind words
You know well i am With you dude !
❤️🤝
Ey, Giacomo. Todo bien, no creo que haya que dar tantas justificaciones sobre tu opinión. Ya que es una mirada subjetiva sobre una realidad y no es una verdad absoluta. Nuestras opiniones, la tuya o la mía por ejemplo, no son tan importantes, salvo para nosotros mismos, claro está.
Sobre la etapa nueva de The Warning o este cuarto álbum, las hermanas Villarreal han dicho hasta el hartazgo y en cuanto medio de comunicación pudieron, que en esta etapa solo quieren divertirse. No quieren elaborar mucho, ni pensar sobre la realidad del mundo para escribir sus canciones. Quieren divertirse, experimentar, pasar un buen momento con otra gente.
Me parece perfecto, son jovencitas que tienen entre 24, 22 y 19 años. Es lo que se puede esperar de ellas a esa edad. Pau, Dany y Ale, desde su manera de expresarse con los medios, también dijeron que ellas en su niñez y adolescencia se han dedicado enteramente a la música.
Fíjate que Paulina dijo que una deuda pendiente que tiene es aprender a andar en bicicleta. Y que la primera vez que fue a una fiesta de amigos donde había bebidas alcohólicas fue recién a los 20 años.
Entonces, que en esta etapa ellas quieran divertirse y que se sientan sin ninguna presión al componer, me parece fantástico. La verdad que las hermanas Villarreal se lo merecen, la mitad de su corta vida se lo han pasado entre profesores de música, sala de ensayos, estudios de grabación y giras y conciertos. Una liberación no viene mal.
Por último, según los créditos, Automatic Sun fue una canción compuesta enteramente por Alejandra Villarreal. Me parece fabuloso que Ale vaya ocupando un rol más fuerte en la banda.
Y nosotros, qué podemos decir nosotros de todo ésto. Por mí parte, yo disfruto todas las etapas de The Warning, su proceso, su evolución y por sobre todas las cosas que se sientan cada vez más libres y que puedan disfrutar cada momento que les otorga vivir de la música.
Saludos Giacomo desde la Patagonia Argentina. The Warning nos une.
❤️🤝 i pretty enjoy “automatic sun” song. Thank you for this meaningful comment !🔆
Respect! I share your opinion when it comes to the lyrics (not great like the previous lyrics, I still like them though). But I think it's because the co-writing. They really don't need it. They compose all their stuff on their own, since the beginning, but they need a new producer for sure.
Thank you ❤️
Genuine reactions are essential. You can tell when someone is faking it and go over the top with their praise. So I applaud you for your honesty, keep it up.
Thank you so much My friend !..♥️🤝 much appreciated 🤝
Adoro il tuo modo di fare le reazioni e questa conversazione 🫶🏻
Eh si come tu stesso hai detto Album Error e Z x me tutta la vita ❤️❤️❤️
🌺🌹💝💋
🔆💝🔝
❤️🤝
You're all right.
Thank you so much my friend!.. ❤️🤝
Hi Giacome my friend . I will be honest . I was sad when I hear your opinion but I respect it. Really do. I Know how you love and respect the warning you are one of my favorite reactors to them . I hope you can get a opportunity and going to see them live.. I Just reminder that you trying to but in that presentation Danny was feel sick from the back and they cancel the presentation .. please try again and go to see them they are now in europe .. you will love this song when you hear alive trust me 😊.. take care my friend and saludos desde el norte de Mexico. VIVA THE WARNING🤝🤟🤟🤟
❤️❤️❤️🫂
I disagreed with your comments in the previous video but I hope I didn't come across as rude or anything. It's ok if you don't like the new album. Personally, I can't wait for June 28th.
❤️❤️❤️🤝
The Warning son tan excelentes en vivo ,sus temas están llenos de fuerza y energía son maestras de la composición ,su rock es un arcoíris al final de tantos años de mala música y decepción,el rock de TW llego para cambiar la historia del rock ,sus riffs son duros y pegadizos ,sus solos cortos y de calidad cuando el tema lo requiere ,la fuerza de TW se impone en sus temas
❤️❤️❤️🤝💪🏼👏🏻👏🏻
Basically what I didn't like about your comments in the initial video, is that you said that they're now going into or talking about subjects that they have no experience in and that you think don't fit with them because of their age. And I was wondering, and when have they ever been old enough for that, if they were under 15 and wrote a XXI Century Blood record and then wrote a Queen of ther murder concept album when they were under 17. They're not old enough, but they're more mature than they look. I found it contradictory on your part knowing what they have written even as children, from the beginning they have been inexperienced in the topics touched on in their songs but they have done it with propriety and certainty.
Sto parlando di maturità verso i sentimenti. non mi sento in contraddizione con quanto detto ieri e credo di aver chiarito alla grande
@@giacomojamesPunkRockHeadReact I wasn't referring to your message today, but to yesterday's message where you said that knowing that they have been ahead of their time since they were very young. We know you appreciate the girls as much as we do, but I thought that comment was strange since you know that from the beginning they have been inexperienced to what is written in their albums. ☺
⭐️🌟🤝✨ ❤️ Thank you
Hoolaaa amigo sobre las letras ellas sacan la letra a veces de lo mas vizarro hasta lo mas importante en su vida por ejemplo Amour es de una escena de ratatoullie y de alli la saco Pau viendo a una pareja pelear La letra de Disciple la saco en un supermercado en Canada porque estaba tarareando el ohohoh y hay muchas historias que ellas cuentan donde salen las canciones a veces ni nos imaginamos es como 23 Pau la saco de unos problemas que ellas sentia hacia su futuro, las letras de ellas suelen ser un poco bizarras a veces no todas oh pueden ser algo real depende como las interpretres por eso ellas dijeron tu puedes darle la interpretacion que tu quieras.
Thank you 🤝❤️
Rush experimento y también lo odiaron me extraña que sea músico y no conozca la palabra experimentar están bien jóvenes esa gente como tú no progresa musicalmente y tienes razón como fan pero no como músico perdóname
ua-cam.com/play/PLtxeUSYZhJdBi3buKY0-Deqt0z-kHqw23.html&si=fiqFhx9-itptJ_aj
I appreciate your honesty. I dont care if you think every one of the new songs is garbage, which i know you do not. My problem was with you saying that it was 'inappropriate' for women to write about sexuality. To imply that they are writing a certain way to just get more famous is ridiculous. Also the insinuation is that they are being forced to write certain things. I think if they were 3 young men, you wouldnt say it. Look at Green Day. When Dookie came out Billy was 22 years old talking about all sorts of 'inappropriate ' things in a much more blatent and obvious way. Im pretty sure you wouldnt hold him to the same standard because he is male. It is your opinion but im telling you its misogynistic.
I didn’t say is inappropriate for woman writing about sex . You're adding words that I didn't say. Listen to my reaction video again. I had only said that the sexual theme of this new album seemed forced to me, and that a certain sentimental maturity often develops fully after the age of 35-40 both for men and woman so please Don't say things I didn't say. listen carefully again🤝 sure i didn’t express myself so good , but i didn’t mean that at all
@@giacomojamesPunkRockHeadReact so if you knew for sure that every lyric expressed was the choice of The Warning and they weren't forced into it, then you'd have no problem with them?
No problem at all!.. 💝🎀❤️🤝 ‘cause i am the opposite of a bigot , i am open minded person, all my best friends are girls . 🤝
@@giacomojamesPunkRockHeadReact to be fair, you didn't say the word 'inappropriate' but you did say that the topic was not 'fitting' for these young girls who have not yet experienced adult emotions. Go back to your first video at 5:30 . Im not sure how I have misunderstood you. I didn't say you were a bigot, I said that your opinion about these 3 powerful young women should not discuss their sexuality because it's not 'fitting' is misogynistic. I know you love The Warning so I don't know why you would say they shouldn't write about this topic. They were writing about all sorts of dark and disturbing topics for ten years now including a full album about a psychotic serial killer when they were teenagers. Are you saying that you also think Green Day talking about whores and masturbation wasn't 'fitting' because they were only 22 when they wrote it?
@@DadQuixote7 you are stubbornly insisting. my english is not perfect, i didn't mean that. i repeat i was just saying that to me this did not sound natural, a kind of cliché Already seen would be those lyrics. the real misogyny would be if someone pushed the girls a little on this issue, done to gain ratings and consensus, I don't understand why I have to explain this again. I also said a lot of positive things about this song that no one noticed. I add, in a whisper, that I underlined this thing about the lyrics because almost all the songs have this topic in a veiled way. and it seems excessive to notice it in every song. that's all. and now it's all i hope also with this surreal kind of summary trial about nothing in which I volunteered to answer everything
Tra le tante "colpe" che vengono attribuite ai Maneskin ora ci aggiungiamo pure quella di aver rovinato The Warning.; non pensavo che fossero diventati così influenti!
Meno male che questi ragazzi hanno le spalle larghe...
Ma no , Marcello !.. ma che c’entrano loro !. Io parlavo dei produttori e degli autori dietro queste ragazze!.. semmai dicevo di loro che possono aver voluto replicare un modello. I Maneskin non c’entrano nulla !.. e poi , perché “rovinare” .. a molti piace il nuovo disco delle ragazze, quindi per molti non vedo il problema 👍🏻
@@giacomojamesPunkRockHeadReact Sì lo so, ironizzavo sull'abitudine diffusa di coinvolgere i Maneskin in qualsiasi cosa che abbia delle connotazioni negative.
Ma tornando a The Warning vorrei dire un paio di cose: la prima riguarda il discorso che fece Daniela al TEDx 2018 quando si riferiva alle persone che le avevano contattate ma che loro avevano respinto perché volevano cambiarle; ecco, credo invece che ora il sodalizio sia avvenuto e, per adesso abbia prodotto solo canzoni che vanno dall'appena sufficiente, come More, fino a quell'abominio che è il nuovo brano in spagnolo. L'alternativa, forse peggiore, è che abbiano perso l'ispirazione e la creatività.
La seconda cosa è una riflessione sul futuro della band.
Finora abbiamo conosciuto The Warning come tre giovani sorelle che spaccano i culi suonando rock. Tre sorelle che vivono nella stessa casa e che hanno girato il mondo accompagnate (giustamente) da almeno un genitore. Ora, io non ho informazioni sulla situazione sentimentale delle tre ragazze, ma Daniela ha 24 anni e, per usare un'espressione d'altri tempi, "è in età da matrimonio" e anche le altre due sono abbastanza cresciute. Mi chiedo: per quanto tempo ancora vivranno insieme con i genitori? Che impatto avrà sulla loro musica e sui loro rapporti vivere vite indipendenti? Come potrebbero conciliare un tour mondiale con fidanzati/mariti/figli?
Credo che The Warning 1.0 siano arrivate al capolinea e ho il timore (spero di no) che il futuro di The Warning 2.0 potrebbe essere più breve del previsto.
Ciao di nuovo , fratello !.. analisi interessantissima. Io direi che il problema vero e maggiore, per queste giovani band, è che spesso non hanno il tempo materiale per riorganizzarsi nella composizione valida dei pezzi per mancanza di tempo ⏱ dopo che la fama esplosa li porta continuamente in tour . E credo che questo sia il loro problema principale . Quanto alla canzone in spagnolo , atroce abominio. L’hai vista la mia reazione a quella ?.. 🤷♂️ parla da se; e sono stato molto duro.
I find you contradictory as you extol the talents of the Sex Pistols but *lament* The Warning for showing the exact same musical creativity. Johnny Rotten was also only 19 in 1975 when writing his very explicit lyrics. Women can be just as rule-breaking as men. Be careful or many people - including myself - may write you off as another misogynistic hypocrite.....(and OLD).
Ho già spiegato cosa penso, e non ho altro da dire. Sono l’esatto opposto di un misogino. Basta ascoltare le mie parole con attenzione. Non ho mai detto che le giovani ragazze non possano parlare di sesso. Stavo parlando di testi pomposi e di maturità sentimentale, che di solito sia per le donne, che soprattutto per gli uomini si acquisisce più tardi. Non sono mai stato un grande amante dei Sex Pistols, e hanno quasi zero testi sessuali. Io mi riferivo alla banalità di certi concetti che non fa onore alle The Warning; infatti SICK e MORE mi sono piaciute. E l’ho ripetuto mille volte, anche a questo pezzo ho fatto anche complimenti, non solo critiche. L’ipocrisia è in quei canali di reaction videos che vi fanno credere che tutto gli piace, solo per farvi iscrivere o prendersi l’applauso. Sono il più grande fan delle Warning tra i reactors, ma dico sempre quello che penso con sincerità ua-cam.com/play/PLtxeUSYZhJdBi3buKY0-Deqt0z-kHqw23.html&si=ux1beiuqULcSdJrU