Dr . Manzur Ejaz and Wajid Ji. Thanks for your beautiful Punjabi way of narrating love story of Punjab. You may want set the stage of Bulleh Shah-Waris Shah time with respect to Mughal empire and revolution in Punjab relative to wake up uniting all Punjabis at time of Guru Arjan, Guru Gobind Singh, Sikh Missals impact on thoughts of Bulleh Shah and Waris Shah. Real nice listening to you Dr. Saheb.
As someone who doesn't understand Punjabi and so could never understand the beauty of the original Heer.. your analysis is wonderful. Thoroughly enjoyed
Dr. Saab why is the book titled only heer and not as heer ranjha? Another are heer and ranjha real names and what are their meanings... thank you warm regards
Pl. Make a programm on Mr. Bajwa whom i have listen in a vidio who have written a book on Heer in diffrent prospective as critic of Heer waris Shah to justifayi the social life of particular institution of that time.Pl.
Does anyone know what culture, language or religion the names of various characters of Heer came from? Names or nicks like Dheedo, Ludhan, Heer, Chuchak, Kaido, Sehti are NOT found in Punjab surrounds of today.
Damoder wali Heer kewnke apaney waqiaat te Story anosaar thdeek nahin si.. Waris Shah ne Kahani nun Darust yani thdeek keta.. Te nawein ang naal thdeek tarahan Likhia.. Kwenje Kahani Historical wi si te Punjabi Muslim Samaaj naal meil khandi si.. Qazi da asal Roop wi wakhanda ae..te Islam de wich aorat de asal Rights di gal karda ae.. Jihda haq Rab te Rasool aorat nun Sadian ton dey chukey nein.. Waris Shah aapni Kala de urooj te Qissey nun bayan karda ae te ek Lafani Art Creat karda ae..
Majha Charon to bad v.. Heer ni mili.... Economic status lai baithea ranje nu.... J ranja brabar da Hunda. Ta heer v ohdi hundi.... Society ch ajj v ta ehi chal reha...
Dr . Manzur Ejaz and Wajid Ji. Thanks for your beautiful Punjabi way of narrating love story of Punjab. You may want set the stage of Bulleh Shah-Waris Shah time with respect to Mughal empire and revolution in Punjab relative to wake up uniting all Punjabis at time of Guru Arjan, Guru Gobind Singh, Sikh Missals impact on thoughts of Bulleh Shah and Waris Shah. Real nice listening to you Dr. Saheb.
Excellently Explained.Cannot be explained any better than this👍.
"Heer waris shah" Punjabi zubaan da anmol gehna ❣️❣️
Dr sb menoo aho afsoos aa tuhade jeha koi aur v hunda allah tuhadi wadi zindagi kare
bahut khoob Ejaz sahib... tuhada bahut shukriya eh wadmulla giyaan den layi.. shukriya from punjab(India?
Amazing, once again remarkable schooling,superb
Great waris shah Great Dr manzoor ejaz i love wichaar.com
Sir u r brilliant
Osum information
Mind blowing lecture ❤❤❤
Your lectures are very helpful thank u so much ❤
As someone who doesn't understand Punjabi and so could never understand the beauty of the original Heer.. your analysis is wonderful. Thoroughly enjoyed
Very well thought and researched interpretation of poetry back ground
zabardast janb buhat khub garat 💖 💕 💖 💕 💖 💕 💕 💕 💕 💕 💕 💕 💕 💕 💕
Thanks Baba Ji...
Bhut umda
Smile bahut achhi h jnab ki
Very nice
very deep though...........greatt
outstanding analysis.
Dr. Sahib please recommend punjabi books (classical) and the edition to read and the publishers please. ❤
doing a great job
V great sir
Jitho tk mera khyal hai istrh ki mkhdoom hjoor nein v varis shah nun lkhn vaste akhiya।।।je drust hai tan roshni pauna ji,,
😇😇😇
Booot boot mubarkan, HEER WARISH SHAH , NU ETNI KHUBSURAT ANDJ WHICH BAYAN KARAN LAI. AAP JI APNA NA NAHI DASYA IS VIDIO WHICH
Shubham Kapoor His name is Dr Manzur Ejaz, well known Punjabi intellectual in Pakistan
@@UP-qr6gc sir may I get Dr. Sab phone no.very beautiful voice and accents in punjabi speaking .I want to speak with him
Gulshan Kapoor, Delhi, India
Heer waris shah original kitho mil skdi aa???
Please write a book in this subject in english :)
Heer was never complete without Waris Shah
Dr. Saab why is the book titled only heer and not as heer ranjha? Another are heer and ranjha real names and what are their meanings... thank you warm regards
magnificent
Thank you :)
Pl. Make a programm on Mr. Bajwa whom i have listen in a vidio who have written a book on Heer in diffrent prospective as critic of Heer waris Shah to justifayi the social life of particular institution of that time.Pl.
Hhhhhhhh very nic ben hor ma jahnana
Great waris sha
ਪੀਲੂ ਸ਼ਾਇਰ ਬਾਰੇ ਵੀ ਚਾਨਣਾ ਪਾਓ ਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ
Does anyone know what culture, language or religion the names of various characters of Heer came from? Names or nicks like Dheedo, Ludhan, Heer, Chuchak, Kaido, Sehti are NOT found in Punjab surrounds of today.
Seriously ? Did you not read the Heer? They were all Muslims and all these names are Punjabi
wahh
Shuker hai koi samjan wala hei
Thank you.
Sahi hhh ....pai... koi explain krrr rhy hhh.....
Damoder wali Heer kewnke apaney waqiaat te Story anosaar thdeek nahin si.. Waris Shah ne Kahani nun Darust yani thdeek keta.. Te nawein ang naal thdeek tarahan Likhia.. Kwenje Kahani Historical wi si te Punjabi Muslim Samaaj naal meil khandi si.. Qazi da asal Roop wi wakhanda ae..te Islam de wich aorat de asal Rights di gal karda ae.. Jihda haq Rab te Rasool aorat nun Sadian ton dey chukey nein.. Waris Shah aapni Kala de urooj te Qissey nun bayan karda ae te ek Lafani Art Creat karda ae..
Damodar ne akhi dekhi heer likhi si,,,,waris ne imaginary story likhi si,
Laal salam
sir ye heer ranjha sirf kiyal hai k ye real story hai
Mera bhi sawall hhh......par lagda ehi hh ki .....khiaylatt hh
Majha Charon to bad v.. Heer ni mili.... Economic status lai baithea ranje nu.... J ranja brabar da Hunda. Ta heer v ohdi hundi.... Society ch ajj v ta ehi chal reha...
Wadiya wadiya wadiya . Jumla durast ker k wakhaya j.
Please avoid speaking in english
No use English......word
Sufism's critique of capitalism and materialism.
This shit ought to be in all temples. Get some real culture right here.