The most honrst and lucid mind of our times, let's hope he'll live at least a few years more. The first part is a masterclass on Palestine , the last one the most honest lecture on the current state and chalenges of our society. There's only to follow his advices, if we want to survive and progress as humanity
@@seifeddinefardous8813there's no Jewishness in Zionism. Judaism can be humane and universal, zionism is narrow, aggressive, oppressive and so forth. There's no national Judaism, they're opposite to each other and zionists are using being Jew and Judaism as a tool of propaganda to indoctrinate their soldiers to kill children, and radicalise the citizens to allow this to happen.
@@user-yn8jy1lt6q absolutely, he identify as a "j--ew", all he does is redirect people's attention from Israel and actual supremacy that they're running over the palestinians to US terrorism and the west is evil, well if the US and the west are evil then tell us about all the billionaires and donors that lobby politicians into supporting Israel but he rarely do that. and on the other hand, he sell you the idea that zionism is the problem, well Zionism is just a small fragment of the problem there are plenty
Mindless voice of ignorance and state indoctrination, self-serving through violence and dark secret forces, trying to obscure the voice of its most brilliant mind. Goebels would be proud his work is so well perpetuated, as much as the cited Noam's pre-war friends were scarred of the Jewish attackers during his/their conferences...
Glad to have seen this video and see young educated people in Israel have a mind and a ❤ . Had lost the hope these days, with Gaza😢. Go out there at the borders and hush away the fanatics stopping the aid trucks !!! Do something for those people dying of hunger, while food aid perishes in the blocked trucks!! Be human, as Noam is! #FoodForGaza #CeaseFireNow
Chomsky still represents an amazing voice for “truth and the American way”. Regrettably, he stands out, in comparison to others in the academy, for his singularity. Their cowardice speaks as loudly.
I dreamed that Noam Chomsky left us and that he left a will in which he confessed that all his life he was an agent under the orders of the KGB, now the FSB.
This interview conducted before 7th October is even more relevant today. I do hope Israelis try to absorb what he’s saying, do their own historical research and try to empathise with those who get pushed out of their homes and then systematically oppressed.
Nice to see Israelis realizing the truth and standing firmly against the reality that many Israelis deny. I hope to see more videos from your channel enlightening your Israeli community.
13:27 - _"How is it that we hear the loudest yelps for liberty among the drivers of negroes?"_ - Samuel Johnson, on the eve of the American "Revolution"
Poorly plagiarized from a dozen older religions, created by a ruling class to manipulate the people's perception of reality in service of the ruling class.
Chomsky has struggled hard to see some justice prevail. He always tries to convey truth to those isolated from it. It is a pity that he hasn't been able to enjoy some peace in his life time.
SETTLER. COLONIALISM, which is what this is, is by far the worst kind of imperialism because it gets rid of the native population. Other kinds of imperialism exploit them, but settler colonialism eliminates them, “exterminates” them, to use the words of the Founding Fathers. NOAM CHOMSKY
I wish there were a transcript. He said, you should read a book . . ."Keystone [something]" by Moshe [somebody.] I find it had to hear all the names he mentions.
Kisdom Hayinu: Bamidron Mimedinat Hok Lerepublikat Bananot" ["We Were Like Sodom: Down the Slope from a Law-abiding State to a Banana Republic] by Moshe Negbi I don't know if there is an English edition..
Want to tell the world my love, and respect for Blessed, Noam Chomsky, Just didn't want to use his name in the same message as the present Israeli leader, that would be a sin of God, and Ala !
Noam is an absolute inspiration, regardless of your opinions of him. At 95 years old he’s still out here having important conversations with a sharp mind. I hope to have a fraction of his energy at that age. We all should.
Sodom Is Us? "Kisdom Hayinu: Bamidron Mimedinat Hok Lerepublikat Bananot" ["We Were Like Sodom: Down the Slope from a Law-abiding State to a Banana Republic] by Moshe Negbi, Keter Publishing, 273 pages, NIS 79.
Write him at MIT or the U. Of Arizona. He wrote back to me when I wrote him in 2002. Also, if you call his office a graduate assistant might pick up the phone but he might, too. I called the prominent professor Susan Rose Ackerman at Yale and she picked up the phone
Calamity, is the only word I can think of for Netanyahu at his last breath ......(all IDF pilots too) Why, because the book of his life will be closed . If you will be able to talk to him in his grave afterward it will interesting to hear what he will have to say ?
I remember studying Chmosky during my philosophy degree and whilst he speaks a lot of sense he has been far too harsh on NATO countries for their defense of Ukraine and their resonpsiblity for the war. Nevertheless, I generally agree with him on most matters regarding the state of politics and the self destruction of capaitialist democracies (something close to what Plato has suggested, though perhaps for different reasons, Pato argues that what follows capitalism is oligarchy). Alas, my current field is physics and what I see of climate research is that much of the damage, and rate of change, is underestimated by models given that the random variables often don't include mixed correlations). Lifestyle changes and acknowledgement of responsiblity on the individual level for our lifestyles must change immediately to reduce the forthcoming instability of the climate, we don't have decades anymore. A number of tipping points have already been reached. Israel is situated in a unique geography that influences, and has consequences, geopolitically for much of the world, yet its problems are really no different from that of other nations, such as in Europe where I currently reside. The rise of the far right ideology is earily similar to that which we know historically, it is the same everywhere. There is an identity crisis on the personal level, frustrations with various origins which are often fueled by the greed that capitalism promotes, that is not met. To satisify the unsatisified wants individuals look for external identities which leaves them prone to nationalism/popularism. Thus, a key component of the long term solution is to not see our politics in isolation on national levels. Many solutions are destined to failure when we ignore the requirement of international cooperation, such as dealing with the legislaiton of multinationals. Chomsky highlights the flight of the wealthy from Norway, as their tax laws are only decided on a national level. Issues relating to the climate are also obvious examples. Therefore, political movements with an open mindedness for radiacal changes to our economy, and refrain from sense of national superiority, should unity globally and make this a hallmark of our movements. Without this too little is done on the national level which is always brief and too little.
this man speaks against the evangelical Christians, of which i be one. he will also be receiving my vote in ihis year of my lord 2024. along with David Chappelle as his vp.
I dreamed that Noam Chomsky left us and that he left a will in which he confessed that all his life he was an agent under the orders of the KGB, now the FSB.
Imagine in conversation with Noam Chomsky, hearing him say "I'm sure you know much more than me about that" Such a rare trait for such an expert to be humble enough to still recognise their blind spots
@@miriamliremberg5840 he wouldn't have a problem in speaking about it, he's been speaking about all the 7th of October that palestinians lived due to the vicious military occupation of Israel, and predicted the eventual 7th of October for Israel due to its own policies. He knows history, he's not afraid to talk about it, he never had. "The last paradox is that the tale of Palestine from the beginning until today is a simple story of colonialism and dispossession, yet the world treats it as a multifaceted and complex story-hard to understand and even harder to solve. Indeed, the story of Palestine has been told before: European settlers coming to a foreign land, settling there, and either committing genocide against or expelling the indigenous people. The Zionists have not invented anything new in this respect" Noam Chomsky a long time ago
Sadly we most likely won't, as he retired from public dialogue for health reasons about 3 months after this video was made. Making these last appearances all the more precious. @@miriamliremberg5840
What would you say now about Netanyahu and the genocide, besides the threat he posers to world peace, and how does that compare to Trump who u said was a threat to world peace when he was president?
People that are occupied don't have to justify any type of attack they commit against their oppressors.Where as oppressors any violence mistreatment they commit is to be judged as criminal.The difference is that the oppressors occupy they are in the wrong from the outset,people have to realize this.
@@briandelaney9710absolutely not. Armed resistance is a legal right under International law when under occupation. If a criminal enters your home and claims it for himself and you attack him then circumstances justify that you are correct. Context is what matters. Resistance to occupation and apartheid is legal in any entity
@@Desfleeding an atrocity is an atrocity. I don't differentiate between Israeli or Palestinian slaughter of people except in the magnitude of the crime. Hamas killed 1200 people who weren't at war with the Palestinian people. That's bad. Israel killed 30000 people and counting. That's 10x worse in terms of the people killed. There is no contradiction in standing for the rights of the Palestinian people and criticizing an anti-democratic islamist paramilitary organization and political party that utilizes terrorism to achieve its aims
Can somebody help fill my logic gap? In 1948, after the holocaust concluded and the immense surge of Jews into Palestine happened, the call for a Jewish state was incredible, though there was great opposition as well. When Britain declared the mandate would end, who was supposed to dictate what government controlled the land? If the UN suggested a division of two states and one side declared their state and the other didn’t, how can we declare Israel as occupying any portion of Palestine when the title Palestinians never existed at the time and the Arabs of Palestine didn’t officially declare a nation of any kind. Especially when the occupied land was taken as a buffer from other nations that originally ignored international law and then renounced their control of the land. I get that it’s considered illegal bc the land is supposed to be reserved for the Arabs of Palestine but those people never did or will accept the land in which they are allotted so long as it’s not the whole of Palestine. Are we arguing that Israel simply doesn’t have any claim to the land? If that’s so then that defies international law itself and creates a contradiction to Israeli resistance of Arab aggression does it not?
Its sadly very probable that its health related, he's been quiet for a while before the 7th. I think if Chomsky had been able to speak now he would have quite a lot to say, starting with "I TOLD YOU SO."
2-2,5m sea level rise in eastern Mediterranian! And only there, the water won't flow elsewhere. Sadly, sometimes the old communist speaks like an expert on issues he hasn't understood at all. But sadly, his view on rather genocidal Israeli politics is quite correct.
@@Stee4L Very easy, read any book that mentions palestinians published before 1960s. One famous example is the 18th-century Prussian philosopher Immanuel Kant, who referred to European Jews as "Palestinians living among us." Todays notion of 'the palestinian people' is the result of hard work of a Soviet think-tank, which made Yasser Arafat into the leader of the 'palestinian people'. Jews are the indigenous people of that region, always lived there and were referred to as the Palestinians for centuries. Arabs colonized Palestine (the name ancient Romas called Israel) in the 8th century during the expansion of Islam. For centuries, under their rule Jews were treated slightly better than slaves (the yellow clothes for the Jews was not Hitler's invention - jews had to wear that under the arabs, had to pay a special tax, could not take a muslim to court, cross the road if an arab was walking towards them, etc.). This is why the British were planning to give the entire region of historical Palestine to the Jews (balfour declaration), but later, under pressure from the arabs gave 75% to the arabs (Jordan is a huge arab run muslim country in Palestine). That was not enough for arabs, so the remaining 1/4 was again divided and one half oof the 1/4 finally was given to Israel (mostly sand dunes and the desert). As we know even that is not enough: arabs want ALL of it with the jews back as their slaves, which they can behead any time they like (as we just saw). Professor Chomsky is well aware of all of this and it's pretty sad to hear him support medieval barbarism.
2 Questions: 1.: Who are the three interviewers? 2.: Why don't Israelis speak better English? It's a general question, not referring to these three. Dutch has ~20 Million speakers. Almost nothing is dubbed. As a consequence it's almost impossible to find a Dutch person whose English isn't excellent. The Dutch have very little accent because they are exposed to a lot of English from birth. This video by contrast has translated subtitles. Harari and Avi Loeb for example, two educated Israelis educated in and working in English speaking countries speak with accents so strong its unpleasant.
ANSWEARS: 1/ אני לא יודע 😊 2/ אין סיבה גדולה שבן טוב של ארצו ישלוט בכל שפה זרה מלבד שפת האם שלו נכון ש"עבד" חייב לדבר בשפת ה"מתנחל" שלו, אבל ארה"ב כבר על סף נפילתה (הסוף)
I find the second question funny because I keep thinking the same about a lot of other countries (Japan the first one that comes to mind. Almost no one can speak English at all). Israelis speaks better English than most countries in the world. Maybe not as well as most European countries - on that I'm not sure. We also don't dub anything other than kid shows. I don't think any Israelis like dubs. Video games usually don't get any translations either, including subtitles. So if someone can't speak English at all they are probably not playing video games. I think you're talking about accent though? Harari has great English, so I wouldn't know what else you would be referring to. Dutch accents are way closer to American or British accents so I feel like that's kinda natural? I have great English myself too, but my accent is very heavy. Israelis would usually immediately be able to tell if the person they are listening to is an Israeli speaking in English.
A sheltered prof and book industry, Cloomsky makes up stuff as years go by. Some of us remember the Arabs of the former Mandatory British Mandatory Palestine-land of Israel (with flag and coins to prove it) who objected to be called "Palestinian." Some of us remember the "Mistanenim, in the Gaza envelope in the early days under the Egyptian occupation of Gaza. and the guns necessary every night to protect women from rape. Unlike the stories that Gazawi (or the late Sa'id) have been concocting forever in mosques, some of us know people whose Jewish Israeli sisters were raped, before they were murdered. Some of us around the world have, at long last studied the Kor'an in a Wokeversity and from liberal Muslim and exMuslim friends WE KNOW THE DIFFERENCE. I don't think Cloomsky really knows very much about the religion of "Peace," just because he spent a little time on a kibbutz with delusional dreams. In fact, if naive American and South American Jews didn't settle in the kibbutzim in the past few years, they wouldn't be dead, despite the tragic failure to protect them. Cloomsky might want to go to Ahwaz and enjoy his life there.
Chomsky quotes the slogan of the Nazis to create an analogy between Israel and Nazi Germany. That bias, at the beginning of this conversations, permeates his entire analysis.
I wouldn't say its bias, its a legitimate analogy, given that the rest of the conversation he demonstrates how true it is. Couldn't be more true, especially today.
Was Beta the worst thing Noam? It was bad, true, people handcuffed and beaten. Not for no reason, but still. But I wouldnt say its the worst. Because there was the 1929 massacre that wiped out the 3,000 years old Jewish population in Gaza. And I wouldn't even classify it as the worst. Noam was always a delusional man, adopted by the pro palestinian movement just because he's a Jew that supports them, like Finkelstein. Even in the field of linguistics he's a bore, with theories that were proven by biologists a century before he was born.
I no longer believe a ward he says. As a person who understands the suffering the suffering the Jews went through he should better relate to the Palestinian people unless he believes that Jewish suffering is unique and the suffering of others is less worthy of attention. Too many so called "great minds" seem to convey a simple message that might is right. Well might is not right and these " great minds" are not so great after all.
curiously he fits the Uriah Heep stereotype of sly and self-serving Jewish behaviour. Like Norman Finkelstein and Ilan Pappe he's become popular by siding with enemies of the Jews, most notoriously with Holocaust denier Robert Faurisson. I wonder if he thinks white Europeans like him are indigenous to America, where he lives? If diaspora Jews in Israel are receivers of stolen goods - land and other resources taken from indigenous people - then exactly the same thing could be said of him and all other non-indigenous people in every country in the Americas plus Australia and New Zealand. The Jews in 1948 agreed to a partition plan that gave them 14,100 sq kms of land to share with Palestinian Arabs and Bedouin. Pretty much 50/50. The habitable land they got was just 4,100 sq kms. How many times could you fit that into the Americas?
he is 95 years old.. still speaking for oppressed! 🥺🥺💖
and still muttering meaningless jibberesh...even his linguistic theories are no longer relevent.
chomsky is as incisive now as he was 60 years ago on both politics and the study of language acquisition, a field in which he is still a center post
Wish he did that for Cambodians under Khmer Rouge
except for Bosnians and Albanians, whose torture he systemically minimized
@@extanegautham8950
Ignoramous
It’s astonishing to me that at his age, 90s he still has strong recall of past events and articulate cogent arguments. Live long and prosper
He lives through sheer sense of life-mission.
The shaman of our society.
@@cloudfloat4179 * "The modern Socrates". 🙏🏻🙏🏽🙏
Thank you Professor Chomsky for years of great lessons and education on true justice, freedom and genuine human values
When Noam Chomsky leaves this world it will be a huge loss to humanity.
One of Jeffrey Epstein's top clients
It will be one less self hating Israel lying Jew. Chomsky is like a Chemist self pronouncing themselves as a geopolitical expert. He’s a fool
Whats a beautiful mind!
The most honrst and lucid mind of our times, let's hope he'll live at least a few years more.
The first part is a masterclass on Palestine , the last one the most honest lecture on the current state and chalenges of our society.
There's only to follow his advices, if we want to survive and progress as humanity
I wish I will have a brain that would stay that clear and active when I become 70 (let alone 95).
Thank you to everyone who speaks the truth and calls for an end to the occupation and the killing of children and women
It's not ok to kill innocent men either
Thank you for this. I needed to hear these words from this wizened sage and your timing is impeccable.
I am grateful to Professor Noam Chomsky for his guidance and commitment to the truth. Thanks from those of us at the bottom of the well.
He is old,low in energy,but still manages to convey information in a very clear way.
big love to chomsky
Listening to Chomsky talk is so fucking sobering... I'm just glad he's still in this world.
he's "controlled opposition" , he always talk about "US terrorism" and never about "jewishness" of the jewish state
@@seifeddinefardous8813there's no Jewishness in Zionism. Judaism can be humane and universal, zionism is narrow, aggressive, oppressive and so forth. There's no national Judaism, they're opposite to each other and zionists are using being Jew and Judaism as a tool of propaganda to indoctrinate their soldiers to kill children, and radicalise the citizens to allow this to happen.
@@seifeddinefardous8813 He has talked about the growing but always latent Jewish supremacist nature of the state on so many occations tho
@@seifeddinefardous8813 That's why you see him on CNN, Fox news etc all the time. He's controlled opposition 🤦
@@user-yn8jy1lt6q absolutely, he identify as a "j--ew", all he does is redirect people's attention from Israel and actual supremacy that they're running over the palestinians to US terrorism and the west is evil, well if the US and the west are evil then tell us about all the billionaires and donors that lobby politicians into supporting Israel but he rarely do that. and on the other hand, he sell you the idea that zionism is the problem, well Zionism is just a small fragment of the problem there are plenty
Aside from the briliant discussion, I find the comments equally satisfying. Thank You All.
this is an awesome Noam Chomsky conversation! thanks
Glad to see it's not illegal listening to Noam Chomsky and praying that trend keeps
not illegal, just mindless...
@@extanegautham8950S too pid
@@extanegautham8950Nasi Nazi defending Little Lebey
Mindless voice of ignorance and state indoctrination, self-serving through violence and dark secret forces, trying to obscure the voice of its most brilliant mind.
Goebels would be proud his work is so well perpetuated, as much as the cited Noam's pre-war friends were scarred of the Jewish attackers during his/their conferences...
@@extanegautham8950I'm referring to you
Prof. Noam Chomski is gem in our world❤
Noam Chomzy is a huge blessing to this World.
Love Chomsky!!
Glad to have seen this video and see young educated people in Israel have a mind and a ❤ . Had lost the hope these days, with Gaza😢.
Go out there at the borders and hush away the fanatics stopping the aid trucks !!!
Do something for those people dying of hunger, while food aid perishes in the blocked trucks!!
Be human, as Noam is! #FoodForGaza #CeaseFireNow
Just hope they're safe and possibly out of the country.
Thank you
Chomsky still represents an amazing voice for “truth and the American way”. Regrettably, he stands out, in comparison to others in the academy, for his singularity. Their cowardice speaks as loudly.
I dreamed that Noam Chomsky left us and that he left a will in which he confessed that all his life he was an agent under the orders of the KGB, now the FSB.
@@warmperson2007 I knew it!! istg
Thank you Noam Chomsky 🙏❤
Chomsky is now like a wise socialist Gandalf instilling hope, "it's getting harder in some ways, easier in others".
there was never much hope, only a MIT professor's hope ;)
Bless him
Gracias Noam.
You are brave to upload this. Admirable kids
Top man.
Never rebranded after multiple attempts to cancel him. Utterly respectful of educated opinions.
It's wonderful to listen to a brilliant mind
Norm, is my hero!
Finkelstein?
Why did you say this? do you think chomsky is not as good as norm?
@@po210 I love Chomsky!
@@po210 just a typo: norm vs noam .... not a big deal comrade
@@Brianbeesandbikes I thought they meant Finkelstein who's also a prominent pro palestinian figure
This interview conducted before 7th October is even more relevant today. I do hope Israelis try to absorb what he’s saying, do their own historical research and try to empathise with those who get pushed out of their homes and then systematically oppressed.
good & productive conversation
Noam Chomsky 💖🌷
Great man.
Noam Chomsky, I salute you.
Nice to see Israelis realizing the truth and standing firmly against the reality that many Israelis deny. I hope to see more videos from your channel enlightening your Israeli community.
Great to hear Noam speak on this and just sad that the interviewers haven't learned to mute a mic to avoid feedback.
13:27 - _"How is it that we hear the loudest yelps for liberty among the drivers of negroes?"_ - Samuel Johnson, on the eve of the American "Revolution"
Thanks for sharing that!
During WWII German SS also said, God is on our side, "Gott mit uns". Sort of wonder who this God is, who is so easily maleable
Poorly plagiarized from a dozen older religions, created by a ruling class to manipulate the people's perception of reality in service of the ruling class.
First time I'd heard the term "Arabrein' too. F***ing chilling. I mean seriously how could they even?
Chomsky has struggled hard to see some justice prevail. He always tries to convey truth to those isolated from it. It is a pity that he hasn't been able to enjoy some peace in his life time.
Speaking the TRUTH is his peace
Figures like Chamsky are like comets. Shiny Rarely occurring human beings
Comets are everywhere, they're just hard to see if you're not close to them or know where to look
SROH's!
This man is such a gem. Wish they came in that color more often.
Bruh
Excellent! Thank you for this
❤❤
Τhis man is a real genious !
It is interesting that Noam Chomsky is more wellknown among Gen Z than he is among his own peers and Boomers
SETTLER. COLONIALISM, which is what this is, is by far the worst kind of imperialism because it gets rid of the native population. Other kinds of imperialism exploit them, but settler colonialism eliminates them, “exterminates” them, to use the words of the Founding Fathers. NOAM CHOMSKY
we must protect him at all costs
God bless him for giving them his time.
I wish there were a transcript. He said, you should read a book . . ."Keystone [something]" by Moshe [somebody.] I find it had to hear all the names he mentions.
Kisdom Hayinu: Bamidron Mimedinat Hok Lerepublikat Bananot" ["We Were Like Sodom: Down the Slope from a Law-abiding State to a Banana Republic] by Moshe Negbi
I don't know if there is an English edition..
Want to tell the world my love, and respect for Blessed, Noam Chomsky, Just didn't want to use his name in the same message as the present Israeli leader, that would be a sin of God, and Ala !
Noam is an absolute inspiration, regardless of your opinions of him. At 95 years old he’s still out here having important conversations with a sharp mind. I hope to have a fraction of his energy at that age. We all should.
❤❤❤❤❤❤
ack, what about the end!?
What is the name of the book by moshe negbi that Chomsky refers to?
Sodom Is Us?
"Kisdom Hayinu: Bamidron Mimedinat Hok Lerepublikat Bananot" ["We Were Like Sodom: Down the Slope from a Law-abiding State to a Banana Republic] by Moshe Negbi, Keter Publishing, 273 pages, NIS 79.
@user-dv5qh8sl2q thank you do you know how I can purchase this book in Europe? Its difficult to find it even online
@@Abstractreference260
im afraid it might only exist in hebrew.. i cant find it either.
כסדום היינו
thats the original title^
❤
How do I reach out to him?
Write him at MIT or the U. Of Arizona. He wrote back to me when I wrote him in 2002. Also, if you call his office a graduate assistant might pick up the phone but he might, too. I called the prominent professor Susan Rose Ackerman at Yale and she picked up the phone
@@paulnejtek6588he hasn’t been seen or heard since last year when these recordings were made
Calamity, is the only word I can think of for Netanyahu at his last breath ......(all IDF pilots too) Why, because the book of his life will be closed . If you will be able to talk to him in his grave afterward it will interesting to hear what he will have to say ?
when was this recorded?
Years ago
@@moodist1er It says April 17 2023, that's less than 11 months ago.
I remember studying Chmosky during my philosophy degree and whilst he speaks a lot of sense he has been far too harsh on NATO countries for their defense of Ukraine and their resonpsiblity for the war. Nevertheless, I generally agree with him on most matters regarding the state of politics and the self destruction of capaitialist democracies (something close to what Plato has suggested, though perhaps for different reasons, Pato argues that what follows capitalism is oligarchy).
Alas, my current field is physics and what I see of climate research is that much of the damage, and rate of change, is underestimated by models given that the random variables often don't include mixed correlations). Lifestyle changes and acknowledgement of responsiblity on the individual level for our lifestyles must change immediately to reduce the forthcoming instability of the climate, we don't have decades anymore. A number of tipping points have already been reached.
Israel is situated in a unique geography that influences, and has consequences, geopolitically for much of the world, yet its problems are really no different from that of other nations, such as in Europe where I currently reside. The rise of the far right ideology is earily similar to that which we know historically, it is the same everywhere. There is an identity crisis on the personal level, frustrations with various origins which are often fueled by the greed that capitalism promotes, that is not met. To satisify the unsatisified wants individuals look for external identities which leaves them prone to nationalism/popularism.
Thus, a key component of the long term solution is to not see our politics in isolation on national levels. Many solutions are destined to failure when we ignore the requirement of international cooperation, such as dealing with the legislaiton of multinationals. Chomsky highlights the flight of the wealthy from Norway, as their tax laws are only decided on a national level. Issues relating to the climate are also obvious examples.
Therefore, political movements with an open mindedness for radiacal changes to our economy, and refrain from sense of national superiority, should unity globally and make this a hallmark of our movements. Without this too little is done on the national level which is always brief and too little.
Perfectly correct ! Beautiful reasoning and correct solution 👏
He's a Titan
this man speaks against the evangelical Christians, of which i be one.
he will also be receiving my vote in ihis year of my lord 2024. along with David Chappelle as his vp.
I dreamed that Noam Chomsky left us and that he left a will in which he confessed that all his life he was an agent under the orders of the KGB, now the FSB.
Imagine in conversation with Noam Chomsky, hearing him say "I'm sure you know much more than me about that"
Such a rare trait for such an expert to be humble enough to still recognise their blind spots
Is really January 16 2024?????
I would love to hear him about October 7 and on
1pril 2023
@@miriamliremberg5840 he wouldn't have a problem in speaking about it, he's been speaking about all the 7th of October that palestinians lived due to the vicious military occupation of Israel, and predicted the eventual 7th of October for Israel due to its own policies. He knows history, he's not afraid to talk about it, he never had. "The last paradox is that the tale of Palestine from the beginning until today is a simple story of colonialism and dispossession, yet the world treats it as a multifaceted and complex story-hard to understand and even harder to solve. Indeed, the story of Palestine has been told before: European settlers coming to a foreign land, settling there, and either committing genocide against or expelling the indigenous people. The Zionists have not invented anything new in this respect" Noam Chomsky a long time ago
Sadly we most likely won't, as he retired from public dialogue for health reasons about 3 months after this video was made. Making these last appearances all the more precious. @@miriamliremberg5840
well it didn't go the way he said in april 2023 since the US is giving Israel whatever it wants
Hope these students listened to what was being said and didn’t reactively support the genocidal mission against Gaza after Oct.7th.
They did.
What would you say now about Netanyahu and the genocide, besides the threat he posers to world peace, and how does that compare to Trump who u said was a threat to world peace when he was president?
Gnome chomsky
Wow, Howard Hughes is still alive?
Chomsky is unintentional ASMR
People that are occupied don't have to justify any type of attack they commit against their oppressors.Where as oppressors any violence mistreatment they commit is to be judged as criminal.The difference is that the oppressors occupy they are in the wrong from the outset,people have to realize this.
What ??? That’s ridiculous. An atrocity is an atrocity
Any assertion that is as black and white as this is guaranteed to be flawed
@@briandelaney9710absolutely not. Armed resistance is a legal right under International law when under occupation. If a criminal enters your home and claims it for himself and you attack him then circumstances justify that you are correct. Context is what matters. Resistance to occupation and apartheid is legal in any entity
@briandelaney9710 what are arguing about we are saying the same thing armed resistance is what the palenstians are doing .
@@Desfleeding an atrocity is an atrocity. I don't differentiate between Israeli or Palestinian slaughter of people except in the magnitude of the crime. Hamas killed 1200 people who weren't at war with the Palestinian people. That's bad. Israel killed 30000 people and counting. That's 10x worse in terms of the people killed. There is no contradiction in standing for the rights of the Palestinian people and criticizing an anti-democratic islamist paramilitary organization and political party that utilizes terrorism to achieve its aims
Great discussion, thanks. What does the plack say in the background? Something to do with "IMORAL".
So what!
Well worth a listen. Question - if USA fails ... will that be the end of Israel ?
Can somebody help fill my logic gap?
In 1948, after the holocaust concluded and the immense surge of Jews into Palestine happened, the call for a Jewish state was incredible, though there was great opposition as well.
When Britain declared the mandate would end, who was supposed to dictate what government controlled the land?
If the UN suggested a division of two states and one side declared their state and the other didn’t, how can we declare Israel as occupying any portion of Palestine when the title Palestinians never existed at the time and the Arabs of Palestine didn’t officially declare a nation of any kind.
Especially when the occupied land was taken as a buffer from other nations that originally ignored international law and then renounced their control of the land.
I get that it’s considered illegal bc the land is supposed to be reserved for the Arabs of Palestine but those people never did or will accept the land in which they are allotted so long as it’s not the whole of Palestine.
Are we arguing that Israel simply doesn’t have any claim to the land? If that’s so then that defies international law itself and creates a contradiction to Israeli resistance of Arab aggression does it not?
Noam is a man of God, not just an hero for the wise and conscious people.
Noam thinks god is a sadistic psychopath
Why mention your sky daddy? "The word god for me is nothing more than a product of human weakess." ALBERT EINSTEIN.
@@CedarRoofsOnly a guy who abandoned his family to bonk his cousin shouldn't be talking to anyone about human weakness.
Notice how we haven't heard a peep out of Noam post-October 7th.
Its sadly very probable that its health related, he's been quiet for a while before the 7th.
I think if Chomsky had been able to speak now he would have quite a lot to say, starting with "I TOLD YOU SO."
2-2,5m sea level rise in eastern Mediterranian! And only there, the water won't flow elsewhere. Sadly, sometimes the old communist speaks like an expert on issues he hasn't understood at all. But sadly, his view on rather genocidal Israeli politics is quite correct.
Tout ce qu'il dit en avril est démenti par le 7 octobre. Car il n'explique pas la haine intrinsèque de ce peuple contre les juifs.
Professor Chomsky knows very well that before 1960s the word 'palestinian' meant 'jew'. I guess I don't need to say more.
Interesting, I never heard of that nor I find any proof online. Maybe you can help?
@@Stee4L Very easy, read any book that mentions palestinians published before 1960s. One famous example is the 18th-century Prussian philosopher Immanuel Kant, who referred to European Jews as "Palestinians living among us."
Todays notion of 'the palestinian people' is the result of hard work of a Soviet think-tank, which made Yasser Arafat into the leader of the 'palestinian people'.
Jews are the indigenous people of that region, always lived there and were referred to as the Palestinians for centuries. Arabs colonized Palestine (the name ancient Romas called Israel) in the 8th century during the expansion of Islam. For centuries, under their rule Jews were treated slightly better than slaves (the yellow clothes for the Jews was not Hitler's invention - jews had to wear that under the arabs, had to pay a special tax, could not take a muslim to court, cross the road if an arab was walking towards them, etc.). This is why the British were planning to give the entire region of historical Palestine to the Jews (balfour declaration), but later, under pressure from the arabs gave 75% to the arabs (Jordan is a huge arab run muslim country in Palestine). That was not enough for arabs, so the remaining 1/4 was again divided and one half oof the 1/4 finally was given to Israel (mostly sand dunes and the desert). As we know even that is not enough: arabs want ALL of it with the jews back as their slaves, which they can behead any time they like (as we just saw).
Professor Chomsky is well aware of all of this and it's pretty sad to hear him support medieval barbarism.
@@marcdoutherd3424 Seems like my previous comment was deleted. Now tell me this talk does not attract vandals and barbarians :)
2 Questions:
1.: Who are the three interviewers?
2.: Why don't Israelis speak better English? It's a general question, not referring to these three. Dutch has ~20 Million speakers. Almost nothing is dubbed. As a consequence it's almost impossible to find a Dutch person whose English isn't excellent. The Dutch have very little accent because they are exposed to a lot of English from birth. This video by contrast has translated subtitles. Harari and Avi Loeb for example, two educated Israelis educated in and working in English speaking countries speak with accents so strong its unpleasant.
They're the chosen people. They speak their way. You must submit..
ANSWEARS:
1/ אני לא יודע 😊
2/ אין סיבה גדולה שבן טוב של ארצו ישלוט בכל שפה זרה מלבד שפת האם שלו
נכון ש"עבד" חייב לדבר בשפת ה"מתנחל" שלו, אבל ארה"ב כבר על סף נפילתה (הסוף)
I find the second question funny because I keep thinking the same about a lot of other countries (Japan the first one that comes to mind. Almost no one can speak English at all). Israelis speaks better English than most countries in the world. Maybe not as well as most European countries - on that I'm not sure.
We also don't dub anything other than kid shows. I don't think any Israelis like dubs. Video games usually don't get any translations either, including subtitles. So if someone can't speak English at all they are probably not playing video games.
I think you're talking about accent though? Harari has great English, so I wouldn't know what else you would be referring to. Dutch accents are way closer to American or British accents so I feel like that's kinda natural? I have great English myself too, but my accent is very heavy. Israelis would usually immediately be able to tell if the person they are listening to is an Israeli speaking in English.
@@gmw3083antisemite spoted 😂
I thought their accents were beautiful, and I'm vociferously pro-Palestinian. Maybe you're just being a racist shit? 🤷♀
A sheltered prof and book industry, Cloomsky makes up stuff as years go by. Some of us remember the Arabs of the former Mandatory British Mandatory Palestine-land of Israel (with flag and coins to prove it) who objected to be called "Palestinian." Some of us remember the "Mistanenim, in the Gaza envelope in the early days under the Egyptian occupation of Gaza. and the guns necessary every night to protect women from rape. Unlike the stories that Gazawi (or the late Sa'id) have been concocting forever in mosques, some of us know people whose Jewish Israeli sisters were raped, before they were murdered. Some of us around the world have, at long last studied the Kor'an in a Wokeversity and from liberal Muslim and exMuslim friends WE KNOW THE DIFFERENCE. I don't think Cloomsky really knows very much about the religion of "Peace," just because he spent a little time on a kibbutz with delusional dreams. In fact, if naive American and South American Jews didn't settle in the kibbutzim in the past few years, they wouldn't be dead, despite the tragic failure to protect them. Cloomsky might want to go to Ahwaz and enjoy his life there.
Yeap, totally agree. Chomsky ignores islamist movements in middle east, and their "democracy"
What an atrocity.
Chomsky quotes the slogan of the Nazis to create an analogy between Israel and Nazi Germany. That bias, at the beginning of this conversations, permeates his entire analysis.
I wouldn't say its bias, its a legitimate analogy, given that the rest of the conversation he demonstrates how true it is. Couldn't be more true, especially today.
NaZioN. Two sides of the same coin. Heads or tails, it always lands on Jenna side...
Was Beta the worst thing Noam? It was bad, true, people handcuffed and beaten. Not for no reason, but still. But I wouldnt say its the worst.
Because there was the 1929 massacre that wiped out the 3,000 years old Jewish population in Gaza.
And I wouldn't even classify it as the worst.
Noam was always a delusional man, adopted by the pro palestinian movement just because he's a Jew that supports them, like Finkelstein.
Even in the field of linguistics he's a bore, with theories that were proven by biologists a century before he was born.
That is what happens when you judge different actors' actions by the _same_ standards.
Did you listen to the question?
lol still kneeling to china and Russia he’s consistent at least
I no longer believe a ward he says. As a person who understands the suffering the suffering the Jews went through he should better relate to the Palestinian people unless he believes that Jewish suffering is unique and the suffering of others is less worthy of attention. Too many so called "great minds" seem to convey a simple message that might is right. Well might is not right and these " great minds" are not so great after all.
Suffering does not give you the right to commit genocide, under any circumstances. Israel is a fascist state
curiously he fits the Uriah Heep stereotype of sly and self-serving Jewish behaviour. Like Norman Finkelstein and Ilan Pappe he's become popular by siding with enemies of the Jews, most notoriously with Holocaust denier Robert Faurisson. I wonder if he thinks white Europeans like him are indigenous to America, where he lives? If diaspora Jews in Israel are receivers of stolen goods - land and other resources taken from indigenous people - then exactly the same thing could be said of him and all other non-indigenous people in every country in the Americas plus Australia and New Zealand. The Jews in 1948 agreed to a partition plan that gave them 14,100 sq kms of land to share with Palestinian Arabs and Bedouin. Pretty much 50/50. The habitable land they got was just 4,100 sq kms. How many times could you fit that into the Americas?
מראיינים פרסונה נון גרטה.. נו באמת!
Prof Chomsky is one of the rich elites. Love how these rich liberals dont include themselves
CHOMSKY'S RIGHTEOUS AND BRILLIANT MIND IS AN INTERNATIONAL TREASURE, BUT SOMEBODY SHOULD HAVE A SERIOUS TALK WITH HIS BARBER. 😀
No, hes clearly above physical appearence 😊😇
@@gaurangaful true
YOU SHOULD HAVE A SERIOUS TALK WITH YOUR CAPS LOCK
@@cavaoubien6556 IF YOU DO NOT LIKE IT, DO NOT READ MY COMMENTS. BE WELL.
This rubbish was CIA. Before?