What Clare Torry did for this song will go down in history as the most emotional, moving piece of lyricless vocals ever recorded. Her contribution is what you would feel and how you would react when you're told someone you dearly love is passing and there's nothing you can do about it. The epitome of hopelessness and sorrow coming from the depths of your soul. The band didn't comment after her performance because, like many of us, they were breath-taken, speechless, and probably on the verge of tears. She was absolutely irreplaceable on this track. I love Pink Floyd, but her input alone made this song what it is. My mother recently passed away, and Clare's vocals sum up how I feel exactly. The planets were perfectly aligned for this once-in-a-lifetime album.
I'm a 61 year old male, and this song still brings me to tears since the first time I heard it when it came out. Clare Torry was unarguably THE best! After her passing (R.I.P., Clare), it took THREE singers to take her place in later live concerts, and they STILL could not hold a candle to her. Here she is, live, in one of her last concerts...the crowd reaction(s) affirm her position as one of the all-time greats! ua-cam.com/video/EwsINusEWVY/v-deo.html Anyone wanting another truly heart-felt song about lost loved ones should listen to this one, and cry tears of joy and happiness (Great Gig in the Sky was my choice of funeral song until I heard this): ua-cam.com/video/ASCZ5KHX0Rw/v-deo.html
Rick Wright and Clare Torry said more in this song with a piano and a scream than most people will be able to express in a lifetime. It's just miraculous.
I bought it in 1981 at 14. I went straight back home, locked the door to my room, put on my new ear phones, drew the curtains, turned the light off, sat down, put it on. Oh, how I remember that first time...
Well done a sincere and felt reaction. I could see the pain on your face, slowly progressing towards acceptance. I liked your introduction to this video, the reading of the lyrics before the song, was well thought out.
That was a great reaction to The Great Gig in the Sky, I've known this song for over 40 years and for the first time I actually felt your moments of fear. This sad song kinda makes me happy because it's so beautiful that I want it played at my funeral❤️
When I said I felt your moments of fear, I actually meant that I got scared, I also felt your fright too! I'm an empathetic; I feel for others more than I feel for myself. I'm surprised it's not a sickness...?
This brings me to tears every time i hear it. Even after 40 years. Claire Torry did this on the first take. She takes us through all the stages of dying from denial to anger to grief and finally acceptance. My mother passed away a few months ago. I cant express with words what this masterpiece does without words.
Pink Floyd was an expensive proposition at the time. When we listened to Pink Floyd in the 1970s, they smoked more weed than any other music.😍Long live the Hammond Organ and Leslie Sound 😘 Greetings from Heidelberg / Germany
I was on a beach in San Diego when I heard this for the first time. My friends and I were getting ready to go to a midnight movie at a nearby theater. The car was pulled up on the beach and we listened to its stereo with our backs pressed up against the car while we watch the waves come in. We were smoking and enjoying the music. With the tide came millions of small silver fish. The grunion were running. It was as close as I have ever come to a mystical experience.
Just watching your facial expression i knew it took you somewhere and it was some kind of a emotional struggle . It is amazing how some music can take you places where you least expected.
I love your interpretation of this song, I agree Claire Torry does a great job of vocalizing this song, and I think you are correct that it sounds like initially she is struggling with the concept of death nd eventually succumbs to the relation that it will happen eventually
Best recap of this song yet from a reaction POV. Besides the incredible vocal performance, obviously in a class by itself, the singer, to me, was expressing the journey of death (i.e., the departure for that great sky gig) and was terrified as being propelled into the unknown. But, once on the other side, was calmed by the wonder of the new reality. Being born has the same story line as well but the song's title leads us to the other scenario. None of the other "reaction" commentators got that. This lady had an inkling. Well done.
You’re a good sweet Heart young Lady… don’t be scared. Life is FANTASTIC… this Music is just ONE of the Infinite gems We get to Experience and make our own to add to the continuous Creation of our Soul. Now that you have started your relationship with Great Gig I think you would appreciate watching the Wizard of Oz while listening to Dark Side of the Moon… start the album after the MGM Lion roars the THIRD time
This song is very powerful. It transitions from the lie we all tell ourselves about death, that is no big deal that we all have to go sometime, and then the song is taken over by the reality of death, the actual fight and terror of dying. Clare Torry just puts that lie at the beginning to rest with her reality and it's powerful.
I'm 53 and have heard this song (and album) a million times in my life. Clare Torry's performance on this song STILL give me chills! Amazing that she recorded it in one take!
Words to live by... This and 'A pillow of winds' are you my personal favorite Pink Floyd songs I listen to this song whenever a loved one dies, be it animal,human, it helps me release and come to peace
I was 14 years old when this Album came out i'm 62 now its still in my collection and i still listen to it, great reaction try listening to the whole Album 'Dark Side of the Moon'
When I first heard this song it induced panic in me, my life will end and there's nothing I can do. I think it's the unknown that I'm frightened of however, I sleep and at that time I don't realise I exist. That's what comforts me. It's okay to be scared just don't let it consume you or you won't live. Nice sincere reaction. Thanks
Processing the song is the exact same process we all go through listening to this genius work, the same reason they made it, processing life, not to scare you, but like thinking about the universe; Pink Floyd make you realise how small we are in it and how when we take time to listen and think about life that we all face the same emotional awareness about our lives as we get close to the end of it. it takes a special group of people who are passionate about life and music to come up with this song, they have always been humble for the most part and aware of life's fragility and just gave us the music to it.
Richard Wright requested this song for his funeral during his lifetime. He asked Durga Mc Broom, a backing singer from the Pink Floyd World Tour, to sing the song at his funeral. There is still an unconfirmed rumor that Durga was accompanied on the piano by none other than John Lord from Deep Purple.
Clare Torry did 2 &1/2 takes on this masterpiece. Stopped in the middle of the third take. And she left the recording studio. Never hearing this until the album hit the music stores... I still get chills after listening to this for 40 years !
never in the history of humanity has so much emotion been communicated thru so few words.its brilliance is mind blowing.how a group of 20s aged musicians could write such "beyond this world" music is completely beyond my comprehension.
Don't be frightened, because you are greater than the some of your "physical" parts. A conscious soul cannot die in the traditional sense. Your essence will carry on in other lifetimes, if that is what you seek. What I find interesting is that I'm frightened of the complete opposite, living forever in this physical realm is not something I would want. This physical universe is very harsh, it can extract a heavy toll on our lives, and that toll extends into future lifetimes, which can keep us here reincarnating for a very long time. Perhaps the universe is so old because it takes so long for our conscious souls to make that long journey all the way through.
Hi Peyemi, I've always known this song was about death, yet it's so beautiful I interprit it as a part of my soul in a happy way. When I saw your reaction I felt your fear. As time went by my daughter asked, "what's wrong Dad" I told her the differences in the way we percieved the song. She heard the song; she became frightened. I asked her to listen to the song for it's beautiful side. A few days later she had her headphones on and now she became Pink Floyded. Thanx!
To see you watches and be almost aggravated by her high pitch at first then watch you and all your emotions in your face it was a great experience to watch and listen to the music with you I feel like that every time I listen to this song their voices we're incredible crazy emotions come out
I've seen lots of reactions to this deep and emotional tune and yours is the best. You get it 100%. Good on you young lady, you have emotional intelligence by the bucket load. 🙏
Young Lady, if only you could have mimed along to this. Your expressions just fitted this tune so perfect. You are a Deep Careing person who only wishes for a better world in everyone i can tell. God bless you honey.
What a beautiful way to open your reaction video, with spoken words from Floyd's song! And your interpretation is deep too. Thanx! This song was the final song on side one of the album, and was really like the second half of the previous song, Breathe, IMO.
Such a great reaction. It's other level music. I still have recollection of hearing this for the first time when I was like 8-9 years old and knowing this was something very damn intense and very special. For me, 'Dark Side of the Moon' is one of the single most phenomenal, mind-blowing albums I have ever heard or really imagine I'll ever hear. It's four exceptional musical artists at their creative peak, with ideas for days, a state-of-the-art studio, and brilliant people involved in mixing, engineering, arrangements, backing instruments/vocals all combining to create something exceedingly close to whatever perfection is supposed to sound like, which is arbitrary anyway. It's a groove from first notes to the final ones.
Death is something so many people are scared of. We don't know anything about what happens when you die or after, so it is very scary. It's permanent and you think "How can the world go on without me in it?" It's human nature to think that way. You just have to remember that the world existed before you were in it as well. Death happens to every single one of us. Enjoy the time you have here and now. This is the message from the song "Time". You have to be sure not to waste a moment. Leave your mark in the world so that when you do finally pass on, you will always be alive in memories.
There's, or here's another of many compliments... I am so fond of your God Given qualities. I could listen to you all day long. You have a beautiful voice. I'm looking forward to your next reaction🕧⌛
Peyemi, I can understand your feelings about Pink Floyd music, that's how I feel for the 30 years I've been listening to the music of Luther Vandross. Greetings from Heidelberg / Germany
Do you have any actual evidence that supports this, as it doesn't seem to fit the spontaneous nature of Torry's contribution. For example, a quote from any of Floyd/Parsons/Torry that they knew of these "stages" and consciously applied them to the song's structure?
@@psbarrow I've looked but I cannot find anything directly from Pink Floyd stating this so I'm going with what I was taught throughout the years...it does make sense though.
@@capetowntrikeman No, given the spontaneous circumstances as described by Torry, Parsons, and the band members themselves, it makes no sense at all. Nobody I've asked has ever produced any evidence about this - it seems to be a psychological projection from someone who's read Kubler-Ross. And the myth continues.
Add this song to TIME on the same album Dark side of the Moon. It shows the passage we ALL take through life. I hope in prompts you younger people to stop and take stock of what you have done with your life thus far and make sure it counts. You will accept death much more readily if you feel you made a difference to someone else as a positive, sometime in your own life
If the human race is still around in a thousand years, people will still say this is a masterpiece.
The new classical
Facts
In a thousand years? most of us say this now. It’s amazing that this song says so much without a word actually being sung.
@@bobbynelson5306 Agree totally. And I'll still agree when I'm over a thousand years old. 🙂
You need to add a few zeros unto that Thousand..
Young lady, you GOT IT. Your analysis of what you thought the song was about is EXACTLY what it's said to be about.
What Clare Torry did for this song will go down in history as the most emotional, moving piece of lyricless vocals ever recorded. Her contribution is what you would feel and how you would react when you're told someone you dearly love is passing and there's nothing you can do about it. The epitome of hopelessness and sorrow coming from the depths of your soul. The band didn't comment after her performance because, like many of us, they were breath-taken, speechless, and probably on the verge of tears. She was absolutely irreplaceable on this track. I love Pink Floyd, but her input alone made this song what it is. My mother recently passed away, and Clare's vocals sum up how I feel exactly. The planets were perfectly aligned for this once-in-a-lifetime album.
I'm a 61 year old male, and this song still brings me to tears since the first time I heard it when it came out.
Clare Torry was unarguably THE best! After her passing (R.I.P., Clare), it took THREE singers to take her place in later live concerts, and they STILL could not hold a candle to her.
Here she is, live, in one of her last concerts...the crowd reaction(s) affirm her position as one of the all-time greats!
ua-cam.com/video/EwsINusEWVY/v-deo.html
Anyone wanting another truly heart-felt song about lost loved ones should listen to this one, and cry tears of joy and happiness (Great Gig in the Sky was my choice of funeral song until I heard this):
ua-cam.com/video/ASCZ5KHX0Rw/v-deo.html
The crazy part is they gave her nothing to go on other than "no words" and she was baffled. Yet this came out.
Even after all these yrs, this song will make me cry
Yes, Claire's vocals were totally improvised on the spot with 2 1/2 takes.
@@stephenyork7318 and anyone else that may be interested - ua-cam.com/video/mIW7xZSlZoM/v-deo.html
That's why the dark side of the moon is the greatest album ever made.
Hell yea.
♥️
It's always cool to see people's reaction the first time Clare takes them to church
The whole album from first note to last, is probably the greatest piece of art of the 20th century.
🤍
It's normal to be scared when encountering the sublime.
Rick Wright and Clare Torry said more in this song with a piano and a scream than most people will be able to express in a lifetime.
It's just miraculous.
i bought this album when i was 16 and all these decades later it still has the same emotional effect on me,
I bought it in 1981 at 14.
I went straight back home, locked the door to my room, put on my new ear phones, drew the curtains, turned the light off, sat down, put it on.
Oh, how I remember that first time...
A song like The Great Gig in the Sky is the type that forces you to get real with yourself if you are spiritually minded.
Just as it can if you're not at all spiritual, whatever that means to you.
if this song doesn't make you tear up, you're not a human being... im sorry. gets me everytime
That was a proper reaction!!!!
You didn't stop it, and just absorbed it!!!!!
That song is timeless!!!!!🧡
Well done a sincere and felt reaction.
I could see the pain on your face, slowly progressing towards acceptance.
I liked your introduction to this video, the reading of the lyrics before the song, was well thought out.
I wish I could experience Pink floyd again. It was one of the best moments in my life.
That was a great reaction to The Great Gig in the Sky, I've known this song for over 40 years and for the first time I actually felt your moments of fear. This sad song kinda makes me happy because it's so beautiful that I want it played at my funeral❤️
It will be played at mine as well
When I said I felt your moments of fear, I actually meant that I got scared, I also felt your fright too! I'm an empathetic; I feel for others more than I feel for myself. I'm surprised it's not a sickness...?
My dad said this too, for his funeral.
Song is about the 5 Stages of Grief.
Denial, Bargaining, Depression, Anger and Acceptance.
I think we've all been through that.
I think it’s about whatever you want it to be
This brings me to tears every time i hear it. Even after 40 years. Claire Torry did this on the first take. She takes us through all the stages of dying from denial to anger to grief and finally acceptance. My mother passed away a few months ago. I cant express with words what this masterpiece does without words.
I’m so sorry about your mum 🥹
Sending you love from here 🤍🤍
Respect to you for not pausing this piece, that is the right way to listen :)
The 1st time I heard this was with my ex husband💙 he died. 5 months ago I will never hear it with him again 😭 Beautiful song....
You will hear it with him again Lucy but not yet when the time is right you will hear it with him again...stay strong
The music of many progressive bands from the 70's is the most wonderful trip you can take without the need for drugs or whatever....
Pink Floyd was an expensive proposition at the time. When we listened to Pink Floyd in the 1970s, they smoked more weed than any other music.😍Long live the Hammond Organ and Leslie Sound 😘 Greetings from Heidelberg / Germany
Amen!
@@susanhall6987 I know you, I saw you at the Woodstock Festival in 1969. Greetings from Heidelberg / Germany
I was on a beach in San Diego when I heard this for the first time. My friends and I were getting ready to go to a midnight movie at a nearby theater. The car was pulled up on the beach and we listened to its stereo with our backs pressed up against the car while we watch the waves come in. We were smoking and enjoying the music. With the tide came millions of small silver fish. The grunion were running. It was as close as I have ever come to a mystical experience.
Just watching your facial expression i knew it took you somewhere and it was some kind of a emotional struggle . It is amazing how some music can take you places where you least expected.
Exactly
I get so scared whenever I listen to it
Music = Emotional language. 😎🤯😎
@@rfly9530 Music = Emotional and universal language that recognizes no
creed, color or religion. Thanks to you, and all others who "get" it.
@@peyemireacts She was only paid £30 for the session in 1972. Recently Roger settled with her a proper agreed sum for her performance.
you need the live version a must
I love your interpretation of this song, I agree Claire Torry does a great job of vocalizing this song, and I think you are correct that it sounds like initially she is struggling with the concept of death nd eventually succumbs to the relation that it will happen eventually
Best recap of this song yet from a reaction POV. Besides the incredible vocal performance, obviously in a class by itself, the singer, to me, was expressing the journey of death (i.e., the departure for that great sky gig) and was terrified as being propelled into the unknown. But, once on the other side, was calmed by the wonder of the new reality. Being born has the same story line as well but the song's title leads us to the other scenario. None of the other "reaction" commentators got that. This lady had an inkling. Well done.
You’re a good sweet Heart young Lady… don’t be scared. Life is FANTASTIC… this Music is just ONE of the Infinite gems We get to Experience and make our own to add to the continuous Creation of our Soul. Now that you have started your relationship with Great Gig I think you would appreciate watching the Wizard of Oz while listening to Dark Side of the Moon… start the album after the MGM Lion roars the THIRD time
This song is very powerful. It transitions from the lie we all tell ourselves about death, that is no big deal that we all have to go sometime, and then the song is taken over by the reality of death, the actual fight and terror of dying. Clare Torry just puts that lie at the beginning to rest with her reality and it's powerful.
I'm 53 and have heard this song (and album) a million times in my life. Clare Torry's performance on this song STILL give me chills! Amazing that she recorded it in one take!
This was the song that drew me into Pink Floyd as a youngster. So grateful it did. If you haven’t, listen to….. everything. Especially Meddle.
Words to live by...
This and 'A pillow of winds' are you my personal favorite Pink Floyd songs
I listen to this song whenever a loved one dies, be it animal,human, it helps me release and come to peace
I was 14 years old when this Album came out i'm 62 now its still in my collection and i still listen to it, great reaction try listening to the whole Album 'Dark Side of the Moon'
Peyemi a wonderful truthfull reaction. God loves you I love you and im sure many others do to, Grace and Peace.
There's an interview here with the vocalist, Clare Torry, abut how she got the "gig": ua-cam.com/video/mIW7xZSlZoM/v-deo.html
Nice reaction, got the song breakdown just about right. If you like emotional songs try pink floyd 'wish you were here ' next
When I first heard this song it induced panic in me, my life will end and there's nothing I can do. I think it's the unknown that I'm frightened of however, I sleep and at that time I don't realise I exist. That's what comforts me. It's okay to be scared just don't let it consume you or you won't live. Nice sincere reaction. Thanks
You are so right 👍
Processing the song is the exact same process we all go through listening to this genius work, the same reason they made it, processing life, not to scare you, but like thinking about the universe; Pink Floyd make you realise how small we are in it and how when we take time to listen and think about life that we all face the same emotional awareness about our lives as we get close to the end of it. it takes a special group of people who are passionate about life and music to come up with this song, they have always been humble for the most part and aware of life's fragility and just gave us the music to it.
💯 true. I completely agree
Thank you 🤍
Until we go to that great gig in the sky, Make a Joyous noise unto the lord... Jah Bless
Great reaction. You can feel her pain
I felt it deeply 😔
Yours is one of the best reactions and explanations I've heard!
tears the Soul out. So beautiful.
Richard Wright requested this song for his funeral during his lifetime. He asked Durga Mc Broom, a backing singer from the Pink Floyd World Tour, to sing the song at his funeral. There is still an unconfirmed rumor that Durga was accompanied on the piano by none other than John Lord from Deep Purple.
I am emotionally drained every time I listen to Great Gig In The Sky. What a masterpiece.by Pink Floyd.
Clare Torry did 2 &1/2 takes on this masterpiece. Stopped in the middle of the third take. And she left the recording studio. Never hearing this until the album hit the music stores... I still get chills after listening to this for 40 years !
Thanks Peyemi !! Just a warning...
The more you listen to Pink Floyd, the more your mind will
EXPLODE !!
never in the history of humanity has so much emotion been communicated thru so few words.its brilliance is mind blowing.how a group of 20s aged musicians could write such "beyond this world" music is completely beyond my comprehension.
When a mother is told her child has died, the thoughts in the mother's mind, Claire Torry put into vocals
Don't be frightened, because you are greater than the some of your "physical" parts. A conscious soul cannot die in the traditional sense. Your essence will carry on in other lifetimes, if that is what you seek. What I find interesting is that I'm frightened of the complete opposite, living forever in this physical realm is not something I would want. This physical universe is very harsh, it can extract a heavy toll on our lives, and that toll extends into future lifetimes, which can keep us here reincarnating for a very long time. Perhaps the universe is so old because it takes so long for our conscious souls to make that long journey all the way through.
Hi Peyemi, I've always known this song was about death, yet it's so beautiful I interprit it as a part of my soul in a happy way. When I saw your reaction I felt your fear. As time went by my daughter asked, "what's wrong Dad" I told her the differences in the way we percieved the song. She heard the song; she became frightened. I asked her to listen to the song for it's beautiful side. A few days later she had her headphones on and now she became Pink Floyded. Thanx!
Loved your reaction. Just an exhale with that far away look in your eyes!
What's important is what we do in the meantime. Particularly for each other. Keep smiling that beautiful smile. Nice job!
You've got it girl. It's your soul. Pink Floyd can do that to you. Clare Torry is a legend,
Wow.
In this video, I saw on your face every emotion I get when I hear this song. I still get it, just like that, 40 years after I first heard it.
To see you watches and be almost aggravated by her high pitch at first then watch you and all your emotions in your face it was a great experience to watch and listen to the music with you I feel like that every time I listen to this song their voices we're incredible crazy emotions come out
Which is why we have to live every day to its fullest.
👍
Very astute analysis of the song
I've seen lots of reactions to this deep and emotional tune and yours is the best. You get it 100%. Good on you young lady, you have emotional intelligence by the bucket load. 🙏
🤍🤍
Damn I was a teenager. Got high, laid, lost, and mesmerized to their music. As astounding today as it was when I had no idea how incredible it was
Young Lady, if only you could have mimed along to this. Your expressions just fitted this tune so perfect. You are a Deep Careing person who only wishes for a better world in everyone i can tell. God bless you honey.
Amen 🙏🏻
Thank you 🤍
Hi Sweety please don't be ready to die nobody is ready to die! What it means is to be good to others and yourself. I know you have a good soul 🙏
I'd rather be with someone scared of death other than someone that is not afraid!!!
What a beautiful way to open your reaction video, with spoken words from Floyd's song! And your interpretation is deep too. Thanx!
This song was the final song on side one of the album, and was really like the second half of the previous song, Breathe, IMO.
Such a great reaction. It's other level music. I still have recollection of hearing this for the first time when I was like 8-9 years old and knowing this was something very damn intense and very special. For me, 'Dark Side of the Moon' is one of the single most phenomenal, mind-blowing albums I have ever heard or really imagine I'll ever hear. It's four exceptional musical artists at their creative peak, with ideas for days, a state-of-the-art studio, and brilliant people involved in mixing, engineering, arrangements, backing instruments/vocals all combining to create something exceedingly close to whatever perfection is supposed to sound like, which is arbitrary anyway. It's a groove from first notes to the final ones.
A beautiful emotional song,I love it. And your hair looks fantastic!
Death is something so many people are scared of. We don't know anything about what happens when you die or after, so it is very scary. It's permanent and you think "How can the world go on without me in it?" It's human nature to think that way. You just have to remember that the world existed before you were in it as well. Death happens to every single one of us. Enjoy the time you have here and now. This is the message from the song "Time". You have to be sure not to waste a moment. Leave your mark in the world so that when you do finally pass on, you will always be alive in memories.
Wise words 👍
You explained it to a t such a beautiful young lady you are very good at explaining how this song feels to us
I love this reaction. SAY IT! It's a beautiful song.
🥰🥰🥰
Clare Torry was put on this earth for this song. Without saying a word she packed this song full of emotion.
Welcome to the club sweetheart :)
Yes you got it.
I hope it's as beautiful as this for me when I die.
You're getting the full effect. This is a defining song in my life, hope it is in yours.
Thank you for your honest and emotional reaction to amazing music. When it's my time to go, I want this played at my memorial.
🥹
I like the way you didn’t pause the song at all. Really enhanced the experience.
I first heard this track 40 years ago, it still has the same effect on me now as it did then.
Wow! Spot on interpretation! Emotional intelligence in this one! Love it!
The "Great Gig" is like a Vincent Van Goth oil painting, vibrant and magical, just amazing content..
Don’t be scared. Am not afraid because there are beautiful souls like you in the world. I am not afraid, because of your truth x. God bless you x
Amen 🙏🏻 thank you 😊
That's right. You got it girl!
There's, or here's another of many compliments... I am so fond of your God Given qualities. I could listen to you all day long. You have a beautiful voice. I'm looking forward to your next reaction🕧⌛
Awwww thank you very much ❤️❤️
You got the feels for this one. Enjoyed your reactions 😎
Another great reaction. I love how you feel the music.
Little teeny tiny Claire Torrey... Thinking of death and screaming her lungs out... Thank you, for appreciating this... Ol Sarge...
That was a wonderful reaction and poignant analysis. Thank you!
American Black Bluesman Pink Anderson and Floyd Counsil...Is where the Pink Floyd derived their name... The more you know... Ol Sarge...
This video is very special. An honour to see you having this experience. Music eh? it will keep us going all until... well... as the lady says x
BRILLIANT, YOU ARE THE FIRST REACTOR TO GET IT. WELL DONE.
restores my faith in humanity..
Timeless as the GOAT classical composers.
Peyemi, I can understand your feelings about Pink Floyd music, that's how I feel for the 30 years I've been listening to the music of Luther Vandross. Greetings from Heidelberg / Germany
This song is about the 5 stages of death...denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance. Nice reaction.
Do you have any actual evidence that supports this, as it doesn't seem to fit the spontaneous nature of Torry's contribution. For example, a quote from any of Floyd/Parsons/Torry that they knew of these "stages" and consciously applied them to the song's structure?
@@psbarrow I've looked but I cannot find anything directly from Pink Floyd stating this so I'm going with what I was taught throughout the years...it does make sense though.
@@capetowntrikeman No, given the spontaneous circumstances as described by Torry, Parsons, and the band members themselves, it makes no sense at all. Nobody I've asked has ever produced any evidence about this - it seems to be a psychological projection from someone who's read Kubler-Ross. And the myth continues.
I liked seeing how you reacted to this. A very perceptive interpretation.
I absolutely love the way you felt that
You got it 🙏👏
I never thought of the analysis you gave.
That was a great analysis.👍
Very beautiful reaction that was perfect❤
The WHOLE world is in trouble right now. The WHOLE world NEEDS to listen to this. THEN the WHOLE world will ALL be on the same wave length.
liked hw u tuned into vis song n v meaning. clare sung vis track in 1 take- amazing.
Now you know how we felt when we first heard this 50 years ago.
I knew this song was about death, yet for some reason it relieves all my stresses and anxieties. It's an anti-drug Comfortably Numb feeling!
For someone so young you really got it!!!!! Thank you 🙏
🥰🥰
what a beautiful reaction to this song. I hit subscribe, my lady!
Add this song to TIME on the same album Dark side of the Moon. It shows the passage we ALL take through life. I hope in prompts you younger people to stop and take stock of what you have done with your life thus far and make sure it counts. You will accept death much more readily if you feel you made a difference to someone else as a positive, sometime in your own life
The older you get, the better this album gets. You realize that it’s all about life being temporary. I’ve heard this a million times and I’m weeping.
🤍
You nailed it Peyemi! Not many get the whole picture without some help. Great Vid! One of the best heart felt reviews I've seen.
Hi Peyemi thank you for your thank you's.