Conservative motion to topple government over carbon tax fails | Power & Politics

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 бер 2024
  • The Liberal government survived a non-confidence motion introduced by Conservative Party Leader Pierre Poilievre over the carbon tax Thursday with the backing of the Bloc Québécois and NDP. The Power Panel weighs in.
    »»» Subscribe to CBC News to watch more videos: bit.ly/1RreYWS
    Connect with CBC News Online:
    For breaking news, video, audio and in-depth coverage: bit.ly/1Z0m6iX
    Follow CBC News on TikTok: bit.ly/3TnHioe
    Follow CBC News on Twitter: bit.ly/1sA5P9H
    Find CBC News on Facebook: bit.ly/1WjG36m
    Follow CBC News on Instagram: bit.ly/1Z0iE7O
    Subscribe to CBC News on Snapchat: bit.ly/3leaWsr
    Download the CBC News app for iOS: apple.co/25mpsUz
    Download the CBC News app for Android: bit.ly/1XxuozZ
    »»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»
    For more than 80 years, CBC News has been the source Canadians turn to, to keep them informed about their communities, their country and their world. Through regional and national programming on multiple platforms, including CBC Television, CBC News Network, CBC Radio, CBCNews.ca, mobile and on-demand, CBC News and its internationally recognized team of award-winning journalists deliver the breaking stories, the issues, the analyses and the personalities that matter to Canadians.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 695

  • @bobschillemore321
    @bobschillemore321 Місяць тому +204

    Are they kidding? 40 million people being taxed is going to save the planet? gimme a break!

    • @FreeManFreeThought
      @FreeManFreeThought Місяць тому +11

      The vast majority of Canadians receive more money back in carbon tax credits than they pay in tax on this initiative. Does it have its faults, yes, but repeating reactionary BS just helps the Liberals paint anyone opposed to the Carbon Tax as thoughtless reactionaries.

    • @korndog81
      @korndog81 Місяць тому +43

      ​@@FreeManFreeThoughtyou actually buy that nonsense 😂

    • @kanuduh5234
      @kanuduh5234 Місяць тому +26

      @@FreeManFreeThought The PBO completely debunks all your statements. Anyone, including the liberals talking this nonsense just looks foolish at this point!

    • @isabellacarter2863
      @isabellacarter2863 Місяць тому

      psst, 21 election . it already happened and libs won deal

    • @user-oq7lr8nc4x
      @user-oq7lr8nc4x Місяць тому

      @freeManFreeThought you wouldn’t know truth if it smacked you upside the head. #cognitiveDissonance

  • @mikereim3303
    @mikereim3303 Місяць тому +52

    This just shows how Canada isn’t much a democracy. A bunch of mps voted in to speak for their constituents, but only tow the party line for pensions.

    • @zM0NsT3Rz
      @zM0NsT3Rz Місяць тому +2

      What you want isn't democracy buddy. This actually is.

    • @charlesmtl
      @charlesmtl Місяць тому

      @@zM0NsT3Rz ndp is not voted in, the liberals are the most corrupt government in Canadian history, and the liberals are so far down in the polls that they should do the right thing and call an election.

    • @ddcc0v0
      @ddcc0v0 Місяць тому +2

      ​@@zM0NsT3Rzread a dictionary and work on that reading comprehension zM0NsT3...

  • @neilwilliams2670
    @neilwilliams2670 Місяць тому +98

    Just so you know, the Conservative Party of Canada 🇨🇦 knew the motion wouldn’t pass. But they did prove that the Liberals, NDP or the Bloc don’t care about their constituents!

    • @josefjansik3603
      @josefjansik3603 Місяць тому +1

      Neither the media. Lopok the title of the video they allpp woprking with corrupt Truddyp

    • @rachelrivard2593
      @rachelrivard2593 Місяць тому +15

      Exactly Pierre wanted to reveal who don’t care about there people

    • @tanyadueck1483
      @tanyadueck1483 Місяць тому

      Precisely, this has now given them ammunition to take over the rest of NDP votes. Someone once told me Democrat is actually the word the USA uses to describe their Liberals. This is going to give the PCs some more ammo. Right now I just want things normal then worry about the environment and take it one step at a time without worrying about people starving or not being able to bury their dead. No love one should be on ice cause you can't afford to bury them.

    • @islandwills2778
      @islandwills2778 Місяць тому

      that is the point, he wants to make sure that everyone knows that a vote for ANYTHING other than conservative is a vote for more carbon tax, crime, corruption and poverty

    • @jrmsproductions8775
      @jrmsproductions8775 Місяць тому

      So you wanted so spend hundreds of millions of dollars on a election? When we will have one in just over a year. Just wait

  • @user-rr3uf1vv8w
    @user-rr3uf1vv8w Місяць тому +140

    What a joke this CBC guy is. His first question is such an embarrassment to journalism. CBC must go with Trudeau.

  • @zackaryvaillancourt8479
    @zackaryvaillancourt8479 Місяць тому +83

    I'm not proud to be Canadian anymore

    • @gryph01
      @gryph01 Місяць тому +17

      Nothing is stopping you from leaving Canada. And don't let the door hit you on the way out

    • @jcdentonunatco
      @jcdentonunatco Місяць тому +1

      ​@@gryph01people ARE leaving canada. More and more immigrants are turning around and leaving, regretting their decision. Massive numbers of software engineers, doctors and other well educated people are leaving to go elsewhere because you get way more value for your dollar elsewhere. This country is headed downhill quickly. Just look how poor our recovery is compared to the US. Housing prices are out of control, the liberal government is making scandal after scandal, introducing censorship bills, restrictions on rights, massive overspending, printing money and causing inflation to rise, desperately trying to keep wages down in the face of inflation. It goes on and on. Canadians are sick of it, and are tired of letting it slide. Liberals wont be getting any sympathy in the next election.

    • @babayaga4355
      @babayaga4355 Місяць тому +10

      It’s an embarrassment; just like the CBC

    • @user-oq7lr8nc4x
      @user-oq7lr8nc4x Місяць тому

      Canada has to self implode before the self righteous woke see they’ve been living in the hell they created.

    • @Optimistprime.
      @Optimistprime. Місяць тому +7

      Oh settle down.

  • @janicebeare8127
    @janicebeare8127 Місяць тому +193

    I beg to differ with this commentator. Some of us were hanging on the edges of our seat hoping for an Easter miracle. Canadians want an election!

    • @ckendall67
      @ckendall67 Місяць тому +18

      Maybe Canadians DON'T want an election either, at least not now. And WHY, tell me, would somebody file a motion of non-confidence and then NOT bother to attend or cast a vote themselves? You folks always have an answer for everything now, don't you? So answer THAT question now, how 'bout it?

    • @gryph01
      @gryph01 Місяць тому +11

      Fun fact: A lot of Canadians hate early elections. And us Independents blame the opposition for calling for early elections

    • @petehalasz7547
      @petehalasz7547 Місяць тому +16

      ​@@ckendall67,, spoken like a true pathetic liberal..

    • @savi_golden1343
      @savi_golden1343 Місяць тому +13

      I would bet 75 or 80 percent of Canadian's were hoping for an Easter miracle

    • @Fe4rN4ught
      @Fe4rN4ught Місяць тому +11

      ​@@ckendall67 That's funny, weren't there several polls recently stating quite confidently that 70% of Canadians don't want this hike. 🤔

  • @sa-uz8xv
    @sa-uz8xv Місяць тому +49

    Corruption in real time

    • @johnnygoodman2003
      @johnnygoodman2003 Місяць тому

      In canada the carbon tax affects those who drive the most and who eat a lot of meat and a lot of fast food. The carbon tax doesnt affect everything equaly. That is why a lot of canadians are not affected by the carbon tax. Find me a person who eats a minimum amount a meat and drives less than 5 hours a weak who complains about the carbon tax. You wount find it.

  • @Eminetics
    @Eminetics Місяць тому +91

    I think it worked exactly as planned, a vote for NDP is a vote for Justin the message is pretty clear 😅 think long game people common you weren’t born yesterday

    • @ckendall67
      @ckendall67 Місяць тому +1

      Well, good then. Fine & dandy.

    • @bonnyc392
      @bonnyc392 Місяць тому +15

      So the NDP voters can see Jagmeet does not care about the hardships of Canadians.

    • @Tjar849
      @Tjar849 Місяць тому

      This was my thought as well. I hope people see now for sure that the NDP are just orange Liberals.

    • @NigelMK
      @NigelMK Місяць тому +4

      That's how a minority parliament works. The governing party brokers deals with the opposition to get motions passed. This is how it's always been.

    • @stratford374
      @stratford374 Місяць тому +5

      Poilievre didn't even show up for his own vote! He begged for a vote of non-confidence and then ran off to Toronto to schmooz with rich people instead of being there to vote!

  • @user-om9dp4qd8n
    @user-om9dp4qd8n Місяць тому +78

    Let Canadians decide if they want Carbon Tax or not? Call a referendum on Carbon tax. Do not shove it on their throat.

    • @MrDjohi
      @MrDjohi Місяць тому

      @@trent5555 why you think people like to pay for that BS? If you are so sure, call election

    • @ChairmanMeeooww
      @ChairmanMeeooww Місяць тому

      The Liberals were re-elected on it, genius.

    • @barrykervin4219
      @barrykervin4219 Місяць тому +1

      userom9dp probably a good idea at election time

    • @owenorourke2527
      @owenorourke2527 Місяць тому +1

      They've done that 3 times already !! Where were you?

    • @barrykervin4219
      @barrykervin4219 Місяць тому +1

      @@owenorourke2527 yes I forgot but the loser cons did win more seats than the libs

  • @snicketysnickerdoodle8484
    @snicketysnickerdoodle8484 Місяць тому +111

    No more pay to pollute schemes. No more carbon tax.

    • @747Cone
      @747Cone Місяць тому +8

      What would you suggest as an alternative? Regulations in lieu of the carbon tax? Something else?

    • @alexg9727
      @alexg9727 Місяць тому +5

      @@747Cone Tim hortons will have to pay higher wages soon now the immigration tap from india shutting off. you could apply

    • @user-cb2vb8yl1g
      @user-cb2vb8yl1g Місяць тому +1

      Actually - yes there is!……..

    • @Nicolas-Kage
      @Nicolas-Kage Місяць тому

      @@747ConeThe Liberals invested $250,000,000 in China's infrastructure expecting China to pay it back. Guess what? They didnt. So we're using tax payer dollars to fund infrastructure for the highest polluter in the world while taxing Canadians for pollution? Thats rich!

    • @roofpizza1250
      @roofpizza1250 Місяць тому +1

      The first carbon tax was in Alberta. Try harder.

  • @DianePiggot-ic5ty
    @DianePiggot-ic5ty Місяць тому +45

    Sad day for Canada

    • @robweeks1453
      @robweeks1453 Місяць тому +4

      Why? No one thought a non confidence would succeed including the conservatives which is why they motioned it. THey wouldn't have done it if they thought they might need to actually do some real work now. :)

    • @Optimistprime.
      @Optimistprime. Місяць тому

      PPs a career politician. He is just fluffing other conservatives. He knew it wouldn't pass and didn't even bother to show up

    • @Pondgodess24
      @Pondgodess24 Місяць тому +3

      Sad day for the conservatives.

  • @larryprice6195
    @larryprice6195 Місяць тому +42

    liberal and ndp are one, there is no difference what so ever

    • @ramintahouri270
      @ramintahouri270 Місяць тому +6

      Wrong! One’s crazy! And the other is even crazier! 😂

    • @asmith8947
      @asmith8947 Місяць тому

      Beg to differ. NDP is actually WORSE than the Liberals. And that's saying something.

    • @zerospace101
      @zerospace101 Місяць тому +1

      The Bloc and the Greens are just as bad

  • @CL13399
    @CL13399 Місяць тому +45

    Like premier Moe said “The carbon tax is a wealth redistribution policy.” Make the rich richer and remaining citizens poorer by eliminating the middle class that way there is more control by Government!

    • @GoHighOctane500LC
      @GoHighOctane500LC Місяць тому

      The climate propaganda is being used to enslave the population. This is the biggest hoax in human history.
      Eventually this is going to collapse, than politicians will say scientists lied to them and scientists will say politicians didn't allow them to tell the truth. And everybody will keep their money.

    • @glennmartin6492
      @glennmartin6492 Місяць тому +5

      The tax comes more from people who emit carbon more. That's usually the wealthier. The rebates come back to taxpayers equally no matter what they earn. So it favours the less wealthy.

    • @jrmsproductions8775
      @jrmsproductions8775 Місяць тому

      Keep in mind, we have the owner class and the working class.

    • @edenlu1331
      @edenlu1331 Місяць тому

      @@glennmartin6492 wrong, because the wealthier will put the tax prices on the food, wood, liquid and any shipment from truck to airplanes. And end up higher prices on everything, then since we pay the prices so the wealthier will pay nothing!!! eventually is collecting money from the poors, what a disgusting policy

    • @GanjaCafe
      @GanjaCafe Місяць тому +2

      absolutely untrue. middle and low-income Canadians receive more in carbon rebates than they pay into the system. corporations and wealthy polluters pay more, as they should. if you're middle class or low income, then why would you vote against your own interests?? A vote for Poilievre amounts to tax cuts for the rich, and no more rebates for 8 out of 10 Canadians.

  • @mikegaudin1901
    @mikegaudin1901 Місяць тому +75

    I think it is time Canada stands up and take Canada back but how do we do it?

    • @ckendall67
      @ckendall67 Місяць тому +16

      'Take Canada back!' Back from where? From what? Did Canada go away somewhere?

    • @user-cb2vb8yl1g
      @user-cb2vb8yl1g Місяць тому

      You do that by voting. REMEMBER: the conservatives will lead from Alberta, with big gas and oil telling them what to do. As with their requests to end the carbon tax - the major item for Canada to reach its pollution numbers - the Trumpers of the West have no idea how to lead Canada into the future

    • @BernieForMayor
      @BernieForMayor Місяць тому

      It's called elections. You don't like the results, well sad day for you.

    • @dantracy7314
      @dantracy7314 Місяць тому +1

      This isn't the same Canada I know. Nor is it the one I want my children to have to live in. Yes! the canada that I knew did go away. Bring the tractors and manure spreaders to Ottawa. These crooked MP's that sold out their constituents today will pay. Their days are numbered and the Conservatives will win the next election in one of the biggest wins in history. P.S. Humans causing drastic climate change is a HOAX!@@ckendall67

    • @pccougar895
      @pccougar895 Місяць тому +11

      Another MAGA brain. Move to states.

  • @user-om9dp4qd8n
    @user-om9dp4qd8n Місяць тому +42

    Hawaii had a wildfire last year but they don't have Carbon Tax. What kind of brain did you have by connecting wildfire to Carbon Tax?

    • @NigelMK
      @NigelMK Місяць тому +5

      Hawaii has it's own version of carbon pricing. They charge it per the barrel of oil (Since 1993). They also have a separate tax on non-petroleum fuel (2015). They're also looking at implementing another form of carbon pricing to be applied as a tax on tourists visiting the state.

    • @susan638
      @susan638 Місяць тому +1

      a zombie brain?

    • @janachristensen6
      @janachristensen6 Місяць тому

      If people look around like the world,the they will see how much pollution is in the air,going around the globe!!!!! Fires,volcanos,wars and if nooks will fly then nobody will be better off with clean air. One country can't safe the planet!!!!!!!

  • @ENTHUSIASTICFIFAFAN
    @ENTHUSIASTICFIFAFAN Місяць тому +10

    You wait till the next election when people go out and vote. Both NDP and Liberal will be gone. People will not forget this.

  • @Optimistprime.
    @Optimistprime. Місяць тому +7

    It always amazes me how many people don't understand how our government and parliment work! Motions of no confidences don't always work and for many reasons. Everyone calm the F down!

    • @user-oq7lr8nc4x
      @user-oq7lr8nc4x Місяць тому +3

      Why should people calm down? This country has got to the point it’s at because people here remain too calm.

    • @Optimistprime.
      @Optimistprime. Місяць тому +3

      ​@user-oq7lr8nc4x Because this is just fluff. PP knew he wasn't going to win but is playing the game anyway.
      In democracies you have elections to make changes. Not political BS.

    • @AwkwardPain
      @AwkwardPain Місяць тому +4

      @@user-oq7lr8nc4x PP, knowing this was going nowhere decided to get a bunch of canadians upset. riled up... very similar to someone south of the border.

    • @Optimistprime.
      @Optimistprime. Місяць тому +1

      @@AwkwardPain exactly!

    • @Viewpoint11
      @Viewpoint11 Місяць тому

      @@user-oq7lr8nc4x It's pretty weak that PP put this motion to the HoC and he couldn't even show up in person to vote. That's NOT a leader. It's pretty bad that we have these bottom of the barrel politicians to choose from.

  • @darrelladams4886
    @darrelladams4886 Місяць тому +24

    The BQ has no business being a federal party. The rules may allow for it but their intentions don’t align with everything a federal party should be. Without their presence the outcomes of the last election would look way different and our country would feel different. It feels like they’re just as worried about results in the next election as the ndp are with both parties just buying themselves time

  • @debbiebarrett9664
    @debbiebarrett9664 Місяць тому +14

    I have a true Canadian challenge. What would happen if we did not give a thumbs down, or comment on CBC, CTV and Global News?? Boycott is in order. ♥️🇨🇦

    • @lornarichardson5655
      @lornarichardson5655 Місяць тому +2

      Trucks could boycott Ottawa like in New York. NO FARMERS NO FOOD=NO FUTURE

    • @debbiebarrett9664
      @debbiebarrett9664 Місяць тому +1

      @@lornarichardson5655 as much as I appreciate your heart, that won't work for me. I was born in Ottawa. No longer live there, but my family is still there. Not everyone in Ottawa voted for Trudeau, my family especially. It's the ones at the top that are truly responsible. The rest are already regretting their choice. To punish the many for the few, I just will never do. ♥️

  • @peterbutz642
    @peterbutz642 Місяць тому +9

    Call a election let the people decide if they want the carbon tax I have yet to see any evidence that carbon tax has reduced emissions

    • @TheRealBadFox
      @TheRealBadFox Місяць тому +1

      It hasn't. Petrol use has gone up

  • @R_Mcfadden
    @R_Mcfadden Місяць тому +12

    NDP is going to lose so many voters, what a weak leader.

    • @stratford374
      @stratford374 Місяць тому +4

      Poilievre didn't even show up for his own vote! He begged for a vote of non-confidence and then ran off to Toronto to schmooz with rich people instead of being there to vote!

    • @nickchristoforou7850
      @nickchristoforou7850 Місяць тому

      LOL and Trudeau vacations at the Holiday Inn. @@stratford374

    • @johnconnor4749
      @johnconnor4749 Місяць тому

      Oh be quiet

    • @Viewpoint11
      @Viewpoint11 Місяць тому

      It's pretty weak that PP put this motion to the HoC and he couldn't even show up in person to vote. That's NOT a leader. It's pretty bad that we have these bottom of the barrel politicians to choose from.

    • @R_Mcfadden
      @R_Mcfadden Місяць тому

      @@stratford374 Trudeau no show too

  • @dennisheyes4561
    @dennisheyes4561 Місяць тому +3

    Premiers criticizing the Federal government on this is odd, because they are only subject to the federal tax because they were unwilling to put in a climate plan themselves.

    • @johnnygoodman2003
      @johnnygoodman2003 Місяць тому +1

      In canada the carbon tax affects those who drive the most and who eat a lot of meat and a lot of fast food. The carbon tax doesnt affect everything equaly. That is why a lot of canadians are not affected by the carbon tax. Find me a person who eats a minimum amount a meat and drives less than 5 hours a weak who complains about the carbon tax. You wount find it.

    • @dennisheyes4561
      @dennisheyes4561 Місяць тому +1

      @@johnnygoodman2003 I agree with you. In fact the provinces that have their own tax, are not even the ones complaining about the carbon tax. (despite getting no rebates.)
      The richest 1% in Canada pollute more than the bottom 66% combined according to OXFAM Canada. Canada's National Observer found that the richest 10% pollute more than the bottom 50%.
      A tax on Carbon where the bottom 80% get back most (if not all) of what they pay in seems like an all around good thing to get the rich to cut back. The problem is without implementing a windfall profits tax on the rich. Many of them just pass on the Carbon tax to the poor and are actually profiting from it.
      When you hear one party in Canada claim to be standing up for the common people by axing the tax. They simply are not. They are only interested in saving their super wealthy friends and supporters (on average) about 9 to 12 thousand dollars a year in Carbon pricing. Instead of being angry at the Federal government for the Carbon tax. People's anger should be directed at the wealthy that pollute significantly more than the rest of us... They are the reason we really need a price on pollution in the first place.

  • @Ken-MrSims
    @Ken-MrSims Місяць тому +4

    Another increase in taxes, another increase in the cost of goods. I can feel the climate getting cooler already!

    • @MrDjohi
      @MrDjohi Місяць тому

      you will need to wait few more years that increased solar activity slow down to normal

  • @Meeksballs
    @Meeksballs Місяць тому +128

    Why would they vote themselves out of a job?

    • @Jordan-lz1bj
      @Jordan-lz1bj Місяць тому +20

      The list of MP's from ndp and lib who need 2025 to get their pension is gross.

    • @JLR8988
      @JLR8988 Місяць тому +17

      But they did. When april 1st comes around and the tax begins to bite, Canadians will conclude that conservatives tried to do everything they could to prevent this tax and the liberal regime is responsible for everything that follows.

    • @stickjohnny
      @stickjohnny Місяць тому

      ​@@JLR8988 They want the NDP on the record voting for the tax and keeping Trdeau in power for another 2 years. Trudeau is toast, Jagmeet is the next target since he will be the opposition to the next government.

    • @kyletrusler4565
      @kyletrusler4565 Місяць тому +4

      @@JLR8988 The idea that this will somehow be a devastating increase in the carbon tax is laughable. Its 3.3 cents on gas per liter and far less than that on various items in store. This week alone gas has gone up 10 cents, so we should already see people panicking, and yet we dont.

    • @iggy3200
      @iggy3200 Місяць тому +14

      Lol isn't this the 4th hike? Altogether it's a massive tax. You're too ignorant to notice it slowly becomes a big effect

  • @kimschwenker155
    @kimschwenker155 Місяць тому +4

    Poilievre has told us his plan many times and Liberals and mainstream medium don't hear it because they don't listen. The money that companies have already spent is not going to be undone by not continuing to collect carbon tax. That is a false narrative. Those companies can still continue to function with the changes they have already made. AS for the Americans they don't have a carbon tax. If we don't have a tax, our playing field should be more level. The carbon tax is hurting us.

    • @MrDjohi
      @MrDjohi Місяць тому +1

      hey, how you dare to bring logic here🙄

    • @Pondgodess24
      @Pondgodess24 Місяць тому

      I don’t believe anything that comes out of Pollievre mouth. There is no common sense.

  • @kimschwenker155
    @kimschwenker155 Місяць тому +4

    The only plan available is not carbon pricing. Other countries, including the US, they are doing better than us and they have no carbon pricing.

  • @elchaposexcitingadventures1674
    @elchaposexcitingadventures1674 Місяць тому +2

    These people are so isolated. They think they can fix things with the environment with their country policies. While the rest of the world pollutes like crazy.

    • @BigDogNutz
      @BigDogNutz Місяць тому

      Children make the same argument . Other kids get to go to bed late why can't we . I guess for you that good enough

  • @pauldonovan9713
    @pauldonovan9713 Місяць тому +4

    Petro Poilievre never says the words "Climate Change "

    • @Viewpoint11
      @Viewpoint11 Місяць тому

      I agree. It's pretty weak that PP put this motion to the HoC and he couldn't even show up in person to vote. That's NOT a leader. It's pretty bad that we have these bottom of the barrel politicians to choose from.

  • @haoxus9413
    @haoxus9413 Місяць тому +24

    Great unbiased work, defund CBC

  • @grantbaechler3529
    @grantbaechler3529 Місяць тому +22

    Justin has proven to be the worst pm in canadian history but he is such a narcissist. He knows he will not get re elected so hes making it difficult for the next guy to fix it.

  • @schmitkeoriginals
    @schmitkeoriginals Місяць тому +12

    No surprise here. Canadians voted for this NDP/Lib coalition, now they will have to withstand a 23% carbon tax increase until 2025. Maybe they will vote more wisely in the future. 🙀🙀🙀

    • @jrmsproductions8775
      @jrmsproductions8775 Місяць тому

      Really.... all together, the libs, NDP, greens, and bloc share well over 66% of the voting population of Canada. The other is split between the cons, ppc and others.
      The NDP didn't have to support the libs but they chose to. To give Canadians what they have been asking for a long time. To give, pharamcare, dental care. Even now, some voting reform.
      Also, the NDP, didn't have to team up. They, the libs, could of teamed up for the bloc and had even more voting power due to how the seats are.

  • @carlyar5281
    @carlyar5281 Місяць тому +3

    I want a productive parliament NOT performative politics!
    Canadians voted in 2021 and we had our say. It takes 3+ years to get major substantive legislation through, so trying to take down the government after 2.5 years shows where the opposition’s priorities are and it’s NOT a productive parliament.
    I want outcomes before we go through another election.

    • @shamelessplug06
      @shamelessplug06 Місяць тому

      8 years of economic hardship isn't enough for you? Remember, Trudeau lost by popular vote in both 2021 and 2019. So define what "Canadians" you are referring to or maybe it's just Liberals like you?

  • @jiggycalzone8585
    @jiggycalzone8585 Місяць тому +35

    "Topple government"

    • @lornarichardson5655
      @lornarichardson5655 Місяць тому +7

      Trudeau MUST GO

    • @StankFernatra
      @StankFernatra Місяць тому +2

      Get a job and pay your own bills, then we'll talk about toppling the government. Until you stand on your own two feet within the safety of Canada as it stands, flawed as it is, keep your mayhem to yourself.

  • @bevnate6281
    @bevnate6281 Місяць тому +4

    They sound like an echo chamber. All on one side of an issue. Where is the balance?

  • @janicebeare8127
    @janicebeare8127 Місяць тому +11

    Strategic minds in the Liberal party? One of these things is not like the other!

  • @JV-qn6ys
    @JV-qn6ys Місяць тому +8

    Only a matter of time, CBC. P.P. is coming for you...

  • @paulmelanson1527
    @paulmelanson1527 Місяць тому +2

    Maybe it's time for a non confidence motion on Poilievre...he was not even there to vote on his motion.
    By the way Poilievre under Harper voted to install the carbon tax

  • @user-fx7xk5kr9i
    @user-fx7xk5kr9i Місяць тому +1

    The Conservatives should be honest and explain the costs of not addressing climate change.

  • @Iban-Underground
    @Iban-Underground Місяць тому +2

    Wait, why did PP not show up to vote on this motion? If he cared so much about ousting JT, why didn't he put in the effort to show up?
    (Hint: He had a fundraiser)

    • @Odysseus7977
      @Odysseus7977 Місяць тому

      He can still vote when he isn’t there. You must be new to this.

    • @Iban-Underground
      @Iban-Underground Місяць тому

      @@Odysseus7977 Oh no I know, but if he really cared, he would have shown up in person, right? I mean as something as important as this, you should be there.
      Or, maybe, he's just another dirty politician like the rest of them. Saying one thing, then trying to scheme money like the rest. He blew off something he said was important for Canadians to get some more money. Typical politican. He won't help Canada.

  • @rogergiddy2634
    @rogergiddy2634 Місяць тому +5

    Taxing people into poverty is going to change weather, who believes that, Sunny Ways

  • @DavidM-es9qq
    @DavidM-es9qq Місяць тому +1

    They were always going to lose this vote. Conservatives won’t have power for long unless they have a good climate change alternative. If they had one I might consider them.

  • @AUG_XZABER
    @AUG_XZABER Місяць тому +3

    Common Tory L

  • @techcafe0
    @techcafe0 Місяць тому +2

    There's a positive correlation between wealth and carbon footprint: wealthy people and corporations are responsible for disproportionately higher CO2 emissions than middle and low-income individuals and families. Wealthy polluters can and should contribute their fair share. The Liberal's climate action plan puts a price on carbon pollution. 8 out of 10 Canadians get more money back through the Canada carbon rebate than they pay into the system because the big polluters pay the most. As the price of carbon goes up, so do the rebates. Middle & lower income families count on these rebates and work them into their monthly budgets. The rebates are a NET GAIN for middle and lower-income families. If you're not rich, then don't vote for Poilievre's rage-farming Cons because the CPC does not represent our interests, and PP will cancel the rebates. Keep in mind that 'carbon pricing' was originally a Conservative Party idea under Stephen Harper, except that the Cons did not propose a revenue neutral plan like the Liberals have implemented, that also provides rebates for the majority of Canadians. Please don't be fooled by Poilievre's rage-farming and fear-mongering. PP is a political grifter and a con man.

    • @dsbarclayeng1
      @dsbarclayeng1 Місяць тому

      There is no one in Canada that has a larger carbon footprint than Trudeau.
      Yet we are supposed to shut-down our lives, when we only contribute 1.5% of global emissions and China builds a coal burning generating plant every two weeks.

  • @imnodjproductions1166
    @imnodjproductions1166 Місяць тому +1

    LOL 204 MP's afraid to have an election.

  • @georgedavidson1221
    @georgedavidson1221 Місяць тому +3

    Wake up do. Nothing. We have no. Influence

  • @basilwright8149
    @basilwright8149 Місяць тому +1

    What a move by PP, all of the mainstream media mised it. Mr. P already new it would not passed but, here is how smart he is, now canadians know which parties voted against them and, i'm one of them. Bring on 2025 we are ready for the great wind of change, it's time to take out the trash finaly, Libs, ndps, greens and the block who should never be part of the federal government. God bless Canada.🙏.

  • @denisecook5640
    @denisecook5640 Місяць тому +6

    Absolutely Disgusting...this just added fury from Canadian s against NDP...

  • @mathieucote4623
    @mathieucote4623 Місяць тому

    There was no way this was going to pass. What a waste of time and money.

  • @lenvandenberg646
    @lenvandenberg646 Місяць тому +10

    The carbon tax is criminal but harms NO ONE who just took that vote

  • @aleayawijaya2519
    @aleayawijaya2519 Місяць тому +19

    I cannot even stomache watching your news!!!! closes the video

    • @tanyadueck1483
      @tanyadueck1483 Місяць тому

      Wonder how many of CBC know they are getting more money from the government, probably for a good job.

  • @colleentombs7040
    @colleentombs7040 Місяць тому +23

    No more pozi scheme. Axe the tax. 🪓

  • @xxxx4y
    @xxxx4y Місяць тому +1

    I have never vote for Trudeau but given the choice between Trudeau and Poilievre,Trudeau wins hand down!

  • @Roguerebel297
    @Roguerebel297 Місяць тому +1

    They’re saying Polievre brought up a no confidence vote and then didn’t even bother to vote in it himself?? Like have some self respect and stand by your motions.
    Im not voting for him if he’s just going to play maga in Canada.

  • @chris4814b
    @chris4814b Місяць тому +1

    The title shouldn't be "pierre fails" - it should be "partis quebequois votes to impose a tax on everyone but themselves"

    • @BigDogNutz
      @BigDogNutz Місяць тому

      Pierre did fail , it was never going to pass and was another we going to make them lose Christmas moment .

  • @AZ-bp5zo
    @AZ-bp5zo Місяць тому +1

    We Canadians demand an carbon tax election as soon as possible!

  • @BRENDANTHERED
    @BRENDANTHERED Місяць тому +16

    #CBCMUSTGOWITHTRUDEAU

  • @pittsky
    @pittsky Місяць тому

    It didn't fail. Every MP who voted to keep the tax hikes is now on record. They can brace for impact come next election.

  • @isabellacarter2863
    @isabellacarter2863 Місяць тому +2

    He's grand standing, puttin on a show. (gong show that is)Eby said it best baloney factory . He's as empty headed as his supporters

  • @dennisheyes4561
    @dennisheyes4561 Місяць тому +1

    If the NDP is the only party that support the Liberals on this, It looks bad for the NDP.
    If the NDP, Bloc and Green support the Liberals on this... The Conservatives start to look bad, as the lone party in opposition to the rest of the government on this issue.

    • @JohnnyTightlips2007
      @JohnnyTightlips2007 Місяць тому

      No, the average citizen is going to see the other three parties as nothing more than property of the Liberals. Missed your opportunity to prove otherwise.

  • @fengwenyuan
    @fengwenyuan Місяць тому +1

    General election now. It is the time to boycott the parliament.

  • @mildntender
    @mildntender Місяць тому +1

    Motion Failed today

  • @comingle985
    @comingle985 Місяць тому +1

    CBC, Canada's propaganda machine.

  • @Viewpoint11
    @Viewpoint11 Місяць тому

    It's pretty weak that PP put this motion to the HoC and he couldn't even show up in person to vote. That's NOT a leader. It's pretty bad that we have these bottom of the barrel politicians to choose from.

  • @Kitty666EmoGoth
    @Kitty666EmoGoth Місяць тому

    I lived in a developing country for over a year and found that Canada is in NO WAY that huge of a polluter. How about people who think we need this carbon tax be sent to some of these countries and see how lucky they are to live in such a clean country. Do you see piles of garbage everywhere in the streets that aren't picked up for months on end? Do you see cars extremely old cars driving around in mass? Do you see a lack of a recycling program? Probably not in Canada. If you did, it's probably a one off. This country I had all of this in EXCESS.

  • @joeyj3349
    @joeyj3349 Місяць тому

    To the fella in the grey cardigan. You cant tell people that its about the enviroment when a gas bill to heat a home alone has over 100 dollars in carbon tax and they are trying to feed their families.

  • @Sammywammy666
    @Sammywammy666 Місяць тому +6

    We are officially doomed.

    • @WhyWorldWet
      @WhyWorldWet Місяць тому

      We are not. Just use public transit and become vegan, and you’ll be fine. Could always move to a Nordic country? Or any other country. Many options and solutions.

    • @Sammywammy666
      @Sammywammy666 Місяць тому

      @@WhyWorldWet
      Public transit doesn’t run outside of cities. Besides with 23% hike transit will be even higher than I’ve heard they are now

  • @hoganhogan952
    @hoganhogan952 Місяць тому +1

    We are so screwed

  • @shogreene9215
    @shogreene9215 Місяць тому

    No federal tax until people speak in snap election

  • @user-er8dl8cq2n
    @user-er8dl8cq2n Місяць тому

    Everyone knew it was going to fail. This was meant to show canadians what and who they are voting for. We need an election ASAP!

  • @johnny23318
    @johnny23318 Місяць тому

    Fighting against climate change should be foreign policy. The gov should impose tariff on those major emission countries instead of charging their own people.

  • @pauldonovan9713
    @pauldonovan9713 Місяць тому +1

    Pretty clear Petro Poilievre is getting a lot of oil company support for his campaign against out carbon rebate.

    • @JohnnyTightlips2007
      @JohnnyTightlips2007 Місяць тому

      Which is less then what you paid in to accomplish nothing when you could have kept the whole thing from the start.

  • @wolfesmoke
    @wolfesmoke Місяць тому

    A generation who cant afford to buy a house or eat properly agrees to give billions to the government to save turtles from plastic straws and hope the weather outside gets better🤨

  • @KevinMillard68
    @KevinMillard68 Місяць тому +2

    well there was no chance of wining this one so long as the cololoition is together we are all screwed even PP should have known better what we need is the present goverment to go for good canadains are not going to keep putting up with this crap

  • @Joshua-zw7jl
    @Joshua-zw7jl Місяць тому

    This reporter keeps mentioning Alberta wildfires but 60% were human caused... not one mention of that.

  • @sonnyyeung6060
    @sonnyyeung6060 Місяць тому

    I remember in Dec. 2008, the Libs + BQ + NDP voted non confidence vs Cons 143.
    Harpo prorogued to save his bacon…

  • @d.d.b.5228
    @d.d.b.5228 Місяць тому

    All the tax is, is a wealth transfer. Thats it.
    This government is making us poorer.

  • @VioletStorm2288
    @VioletStorm2288 Місяць тому

    Of all the things to fight about, the carbon tax is a patsy to distract from everything else we could be doing. We need to fund our government AND make sure it's investing in the infrastructure and community we all rely on. If we want to avoid being a Haiti, we need to rethink our society before Greed rules all.

  • @osk2689
    @osk2689 Місяць тому +12

    David is a mouthpiece for the liberal government, he’s way to partisan to be on this show

  • @milhouse8166
    @milhouse8166 Місяць тому

    But no one actually has confidence in Trudeau

  • @RubyVideoFan
    @RubyVideoFan Місяць тому

    CBC should ask the voters what they think about 23% increase from carbon tax?

  • @isabellacarter2863
    @isabellacarter2863 Місяць тому +1

    epic fail 3 million for image and he's still Milhouse with laser-eye surgery

  • @FionaBlacksecondhandonline
    @FionaBlacksecondhandonline Місяць тому

    We want Canadians to vote not the liberals for themselves

  • @JohnSmith-ne8ho
    @JohnSmith-ne8ho Місяць тому

    Jagmeet Singh enabled this madman. Middle class families are being punished for DRIVING to work and buying FOOD for their families.

  • @Canaduck9561
    @Canaduck9561 Місяць тому

    We contribute what? Around 1.5% of global emissions? And Trudeau expects us to believe that "putting a price on carbon" is supposed to help? All while we have in amazing oil reserves we’re not using… Trudeau needs to go back to teaching drama classes

  • @ferzadhazeri2377
    @ferzadhazeri2377 Місяць тому

    The Liberals / NDP are a big joke, there is no respect left for either Party. The quicker they are gone the better it will be for Canada and Canadians. 🇨🇦

  • @klobesclips7109
    @klobesclips7109 Місяць тому

    4:40 what is this guy thinking? 5:11, this is crazy!

  • @rabitimsina3765
    @rabitimsina3765 Місяць тому

    Political parties take chances of other fights between citizens, their government, or opposition, but there are no solutions , every leader has to ask the public how suffering from carbon finding new ideas solve carbon problems

  • @Konigkev
    @Konigkev Місяць тому +7

    FJT

    • @gryph01
      @gryph01 Місяць тому

      Snowflake

  • @Cardinnall
    @Cardinnall Місяць тому

    What the f is the carbon tax even for?!

    • @GanjaCafe
      @GanjaCafe Місяць тому +3

      8 out of 10 Canadians receive more in carbon rebates than they pay into the system. big polluters and the wealthy pay more, as they should. Poilievre would cancel the carbon rebates for middle and low income Canadians, while granting generous tax cuts for the rich.

  • @FionaBlacksecondhandonline
    @FionaBlacksecondhandonline Місяць тому

    Good god people there burning tires in most other countries giving people in Canada a small break to breath and not lose there homes

  • @frk3387
    @frk3387 Місяць тому

    This was no failure
    Poilievre achieved exactly what he wanted , which was to show Liberal and NDP voters that their MP's do not care how un-affordable life is for them , and will continue to tax them into poverty

  • @stevemeister99
    @stevemeister99 Місяць тому +4

    Canadians just got Trudeaued once again.

  • @inthesilentplanet
    @inthesilentplanet Місяць тому

    If we imagined a plan to make a country poorer, it's what Trudeau is doing. The question is why?

  • @user-xv4qn8fp9d
    @user-xv4qn8fp9d Місяць тому +1

    The Cons should be talking about how we will not have enough money to spend on climate change due to out of control liberal spending + that we have to focus on tightening the reigns.The CBC anchor boy does not seem to understand that we will not have a country if we do not zero in on the new reality.

  • @ayn8465
    @ayn8465 Місяць тому

    How to not pay tax?!

  • @neilgirvan8678
    @neilgirvan8678 Місяць тому

    Why isn't the Host wearing a "Vote Liberal" button. He's clearly bias.

  • @Sam19509
    @Sam19509 Місяць тому +1

    Hey James Moore, Kyrie Irving of the Dallas Mavericks just did a left handed skyhook within the arc to beat the NBA Champion Denver Nuggets at the buzzer this past Sunday on ABC and TSN. Miracles do happen.

  • @Plantdad780
    @Plantdad780 Місяць тому +1

    $0.13 more for fuel in Alberta for the hike!

  • @garygjl9036
    @garygjl9036 Місяць тому

    thank you for allowing comments david.

  • @lindacolley5452
    @lindacolley5452 Місяць тому +1

    We need a referendum let the people decide