♦️Jimin wrote the lyrics not only by himself, but was the only one to send his very first draft to the producers, and it was approved, so no need for a rewrite! The lie is the lie he keeps telling himself. Always in the past aiming for perfection and by doing so always questioning and second guessing himself! Although deep inside he knows better! The other lie is telling himself as well as everyone else that everything is alright when it's not!! Jimin has grown and changed, along with the other members since then. All learning to love themselves for who & what they are flaws and all! Jimin is now able to, as his song Promise says, shine the light on himself, as well, speaking up more when things bother him and allowing himself to laugh off whenever he makes any kind of mistake, knowing now he can always perfect or improve on whatever is lacking next time!!
An absolute must that I recommend & so needs to be reacted to ❤️BTS JIMIN BEST LIVE HIGH NOTES & RASPY VOCALS COMPILATION (UPDATED) by Jem ❤️ ua-cam.com/video/1LtSXxUN9fw/v-deo.html ❤️🔥😱😍💜❤️🙏🙏👍🐥🔥 Shows Jimin's breathtakingly amazing full vocal range abilities since the beginning in 2013 til recent, including acoustic & acappella, that shows Jimin's vocal ability that I'm not sure you guys are aware of. Since there is the title of of the song in each clip, you'll also get to be introduced to some awesome BTS songs you've yet to hear! Jimin was given the official title of not only Main Dancer, but also Lead Vocalist, since BTS debuted, for a reason! JIMIN also was awarded for 2 yrs in a row now both the prestigious title of KING OF KPOP, as well as BEST DANCER IN KPOP 3 yrs in a row as well!!
@@REDEMPTION46 If you watched voice expert reactions, you’d know Jimin’s voice actually sits naturally in the high range; I also disagree he has the smallest range…he sings very low. Did you not watch the intros to the guys? If you did, you’d also know at 15 he was doing dance battles, popping, locking - hip hop…it was the KPop style of dance he struggled with in the beginning!
It's unfortunate that this stage mix doesn't truly show Jimin's choreo for this song. To me, it's just as breathtaking as the song itself. Thanks for reacting, guys!
Very true. The edit was done very well but took away from the performance a little which shows how much of a performer Jimin is that the performance without the edits is better.
I definitely think Wings was the bridge between “old school BTS” when they were just kids and trying to figure out who they were and “new school” where they’ve blossomed into these incredible men that are much more confident and comfortable with themselves. One of the greatest albums in the history of pop music in my opinion.
@@shinjite06 yeah HYYH was definitely groundbreaking as well but I think Wings just hit harder for me, like they really let everything out and showed a lot more of themselves, especially in the solo songs
No Idol Uptil now is able to cover Jimin's Lie. This song is soo hard and difficult to perform. Park Jimin is literally the King. His talent and Hardwork , both emphasize in this performance.
"Jimin has incredible voice" FACT! Jimin wrote the lyric of the song with his fulled personal emotional. He succeeded for sharing the relatable story of each other people. He's Genius Songwritter. He's Brilliant!
Jimin actually has the highest vocal range in bts :) He hit an A5 in Let Me Know, which is way out of a male tenors natural range, and is the lead singer in the group, the second highest position. I think you guys are way underestimating Jimin's vocals because his voice is so light and soft.
i thought i heard/read that jin had the broadest vocal range? it seems that lately jin has been doing the falsetto and super high range (that’s my technical speak 😝)
@@lodeci Jimin has consistently a higher range than Jungkook and often hits the highest notes, he did let me know every concert during their tour, it is very much in his range. Jungkook has a high range, but he doesn't consistently hit notes as high as Jimin does, nor can he reach notes like Jimin's A5. Jin usually hits higher notes than Kookie too. But Jungkook is still the best vocalist on the group, because vocals aren't just about notes. Take for example the "I'll be missing you" cover, where Jin and Jimin just casually hit F5s a few times in the group singing part at the end, or ON where Jimin hits incredibly high notes in the "Na na na" part. I think you don't realise how high notes Jimin hits on every bts album, because he doesn't have as many highlighted high note moments anymore, and they are more often blended into the song. As well as Jimin already having a high voice and us just being used to Jimin hitting these incredible notes so often.
@@yeppoyou Broadest doesn't mean highest, I think Jin has the broadest because he can hit notes way lower than Jimin or Jungkook, as well as notes higher than V. But Jimin still has the highest range :)
@@lodeci Sure, Jin, JK and V can get to certain high notes but quite frankly, you can tell they strain to get there…like they really have to ‘push’ to get there - Jin’s triple high note in Crystal Snow looked very uncomfortable - painful in fact and it DID look and sound very strained; like perhaps the way he did that was not proper technique. I suspect over time, it would damage his vocal chords. Jimin’s voice, on the other hand, NATURALLY SITS in that high range: he hits those notes effortlessly. And his voice is airy, and so unique it cuts through everybody else’s - you can hear him over the other 3. V has said he’s been given high notes (from Pdogg) that he didn’t want to sing because it was so difficult and didn’t think he could do it. He often sounds like he’s straining at certain high notes. Jin also has said he sometimes struggles with those high notes and that Jimin does have the highest range. JK has tried to sing Filter and he stops because he can’t sustain those high notes through the whole song…same with Serendipity. Jimin has proven himself to be a world class singer a hundred times over and that’s evident by the amount of respect and admiration he receives from experts in the global music industry. If you can’t see his voice is one of the best and on a whole other level, that’s your problem, it’s not because of him.
For me, Lie is one of the most genius Kpop songs ever. I am always so impressed when the key goes from minor to major. It's like the major is a lie in and of itself. It's give me goosebumps whenever I thought about it. And not to mention, the lyrics too, such an extremely well-written. It's awesome that Jimin wrote the lyrics. Thank you for the reaction! I enjoy it! :)
finally ... yes...hit it correct. Jimin's vocals are unique. These guys doing this reaction do not credit Jimin where he has taken himself. Maybe they should watch reactions by vocal coaches since they are so wrong about Jimin. This song along with Promise & Filter take me to another place due to Jimin's vocals. He is singing in his norm • head vocals ... They as many don't think a man can have such vocals! They are so wrong.
@@donnal.padilla4336 yea he has a really bright tone both him and Jk are both tenors but his higher than JK and that’s ok. Not a lot of can appreciate his vocal tone but let’s not discredit his vocal ability
Bone for the new army yes but this song is not at all underrated it is the most important and most played solo of the album wings only below the main track BS&T and in fact its choreography is covered by rookie idols, what could have been A world hit of that I do not discuss it but for the time and because BTS were just becoming known globally it is really an incredible feat and it remains to this day in that position.
Jimin has a great unique tone and naturally high pitched voice that's why most vocal coaches and reactors like his voice. His voice is what most producers like too bec it's not common and gives texture to the song especially now he had developed his signature fry at the end when he sings. He is very charismatic and his stage presence is insane. He is a great singer and performer. P
This is one of my favorite songs of all time, it’s so hauntingly beautiful and Jimin’s voice was perfect for it. I don’t know that anybody else would be able to do it like him🤩👏🏾
"LIE" the live performance is the very first time I had ever heard of Jimin, and from there, BTS. I watch dance videos & it was pushed to me while recovering from COVID-19. His vocals & dancing made me find out about him, which led me to BTS. The BEST DAY OF MY LIFE, I'll have you know. It still remains my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE song from him, (them). The lie I lived with for most of my life is that "I'm Ok." No one ever suspected what I was going through; no one saw through the facade. It lasted for 40 years, and then.....I broke. It came as quite a shock to people. I think the "LIE" BTS members may live with is how they are perceived by the outside, as performers, and who they really are, (or want to be). The personas they have to maintain for the public and who they are in (real) private times. I am glad that they are able to express themselves and are real proponents of mental health. It makes it more acceptable, and, I hope, helps them as well. They are genuinely kind, talented, amazing men. Please bear in mind, this is just an opinion, I am not speaking for them....it is not my intention. It's just a thought. I loved the reaction!
Jimin has great voice it's like an untamed horse with lot of potential.. Due to this he faced lots of problem initially to understand his voice... He has with lots of struggle tamed his voice and it's sounds angelic and beautiful.. Not that it was not earlier but now it's just more trained and ground breaking.. He is really talented and an great hatdworker... Greatest artist of this timrs
Jimin's higher register is the most suited for BTS songs, as Jungkook and Tae (apart from the rappers) fill the lower registers quite well, and it is his signature sound. Jimin I'd say is a pure tenor, is range is probs between E4 and C#5 ??? probs can go a bit higher? His lower range tends to be throaty. Jimin wrote the lyrics himself, and helped with production, his first draft was approved immediately. The song is about the lies he tells himself, how he would tell himself he did bad and how he would punish himself over mistakes no one else noticed, his obsession with perfection. It's a song Jimin actually doesn't like, he wrote Promise, years later, as an answer in a way for Lie. A promise to take care of himself and be easy on himself. Also, the song is in minor, but "caught in a lie" is in a Picardy Third, the happiest sound perse, basically pretending to be happy while one is sad.
Well said! I hope they react to Promise to hear him in a paired down but beautiful song to counterpoint what was said here about Lie being out of his range.
Jimin wrote this. The lie is what his insecure self tells him about himself. It’s his struggle to break free from his insecurities the negative messages. It was suppose to be a really dark song. Thank goodness I think RM moved him away from that. His pitch is naturally high. He opens his mouth and high notes come out. He is not ruining his voice, I appreciate Lowe caring. Jimin has more control over his vocal cords and he emits notes that most men can’t. I think V who has the widest range- has to be more careful when he sings falsetto. But you hear Jimin easily transition from head to chest voice and use a mixture. In the beginning, since he did not receive vocal training it was hard on his throat for some high notes. The truth untold-there is a concert and he’s ill, but he still tries to perform. Well, the pain became so bad, he was in tears on stage. The crowd sang his part of the song. It was beautiful and sad. He’s not that Jimin anymore. He has vocal control. He’s not damaging his chords. There are about Five coaches who react and none have Indicated he is ruining his voice. They are all in awe and stop to find the key he is singing. I am so proud of Lowe, thinking of Jiminahh. Those high notes in the early days, ended up saving BTS in a way. They stood out. Jimin went from being undervalued, and kind of dismissed to essential, very necessary. RM even says to him once, thank you Jimin without you we would not have come this far. He has been voted the number idol for a couple of years. Number one dancer three years in row. Number one in brand confidence. Check out the video of how Army around the world celebrated his birthday this year. You tube. #redeemers46 🙆🏾♀️💜#BORAHAE
Jimin doesn't have the least flexibility in his voice. It's just that he's required to do the high notes because no one of the other members can go as high as him so he's rarely able to use his lower register.
What I will say tho, is that Jimin's voice is naturally high so the vocal tones and pitches he hits in both his own songs and in group and unit songs are in his natural range. I know exactly what Lo means, but singing outside of your "range" won't damage your voice if you sing correctly. I'm personally a natural alto, but in choirs, I sing as a Soprano 1. This is because I've been classically trained as a Soprano, so while my natural voice is an alto, I can hit those higher notes with ease due to how I've trained my vocal cords. Jimin has also received vocal training, which is why if you compare his high notes from older group songs to his high notes now, there's an ease to his voice that wasn't there before. They also all choose their own parts so any notes that jimin hits, he chose. But I love the fact that Lo actually knows wtf he's talking about and cares about Jimin's vocal folds. Jimin's voice is super interesting tho, because even when he was straining more in songs, he still hit the notes with a clear tone. I also think that because he has a naturally rasp to his vocal tone, he can get away with more tones. Jimin does hit more raspy notes, growls, and uses his lower register in their earlier works as well as in some of there more recent music, but he does seem to stay in the pocket of higher pitches.
👍👍👍 Sometimes, many of us forget that Jimin has never received any professional long term vocal training until this Covid pandemic break(not like all other BTS members who has received professional vocal training in advance for 2-4 years) & I think during this pandemic break, Jimin’s vocal has improved the most, especially with his new found confidence in his vocal abilities. It was shock for many Army when Earlier this year, during the interview in Korean TV show call ‘U-Quiz on the block’, BTS members & Jimin has finally confirmed that Jimin really didn’t receive any proper vocal training that all other BTS members has received because he was just a trainee. And I think during these ‘LIE’ period, Jimin was still struggling a lot with his own vocal & trying to find his own methods & vocal techniques all by himself. Around ‘Wings’ era, Jimin even have mentioned once in magazine interview that his strongest wish is to have at least 3 months break from everything so he could get professional training & prepare himself to be better idol. It makes me so upset to think how Jimin has been struggling mostly by himself with all their hectic schedules while getting all those hate & criticisms from BTS anti & toxic solo stans. It always makes me wonder what if Jimin also has received those 2-4 years of professional vocal training in advance before BTS debut, just like other BTS members. I would believe that Jimin would definitely be even more a fantastic vocalist right now!
Idk anything about singing etc. but thank you for explaining this cuz it all makes sense. Vocal abilities has greatly improved and I could sense so much more confidence in him when he is singing. Recently watched film out live and he was singing such a high note and his face was so relaxed that you wouldn’t think he just killed us with his high note 😅
I’ve seen Jimin getting help from Jungkook with his singing because for some reason he didn’t receive the training the others did. I know he was only in training for a short time but it seems strange that they didn’t train his voice when it is such an essential tool which needs to be honed. Fortunately they all know about warming up so he has protected his voice.
LIE is a masterpiece. Its melody is unique. It grabs you from start to finish. Jimin's voice has so many unique nuances that you are charmed by his voice. To all this add the choreography!! Jimin is a great artist, songwriter, and producer. GOD OF DANCER too. loved their reactions
LIE' this song makes me cry whenever I listen to it I don't know the reason can't explain & his performance just blew me away every time 🥺💛 Happy Jimin Day🥳🎈
Jimin Is Amazing with he's performance and he's Unique and Angelic voice. Song is deep with Jimins life.💜💜 Happy Birthday Jimin! 🎉🥳🎂 Like you'll reactions. 👏😎👏😎
At first I agreed to this until they said JIMIN was the 4th place vocally, there is a reason why he is lead vocalist how can you say this after this masterpiece even when he was the ONLY one who didn’t receive vocal lessons all the other members had that privilege
This song as well as, wings the album is a masterpiece both sonically, lyrically, and contextually. The boys ATE when they created this album, my gosh. It sends puts adrenaline in my veins and sends chills down my spin. I cant wait to see you’re in depth exploration of the album, even looking into the behind the scenes or explanation videos are cool.
@@suamae2049 being their first album to get 1 million sells doesn’t mean it’s the best album. It’s not their best album lyrically nor sonically. Still a good album
"I feel like he's the best singer in this group" FACT! JIMIN IS EVERYTHING! If everyone can feet in the same good things, so why Jimin can't be the best!
The guy in th checked shirt is right Jimin has the smallest range of the vocal line but his head voice is so beautiful and his singing is so unique. His is the only one that speaking voice is completely different from his singing voice. The only one amongst the group
One of the things that I love about this song is that it's in minor (sad vibes) but then switches to major (happy vibes) for the chorus. So this brighter feeling that comes with the chorus (happiness) is the lie itself, which I think is a very creative way to emphasize the concept of the song through production! As always, love your guys' reactions! Also wanna give credit to ReacttotheK for breaking the song down musically from a classical perspective, they're a great channel that everyone should check out!
He wrote the song cause he wanted to stop forcing himself to be pleasing others but him, about not being happy with himself, every word, this lyrics is Jimin life's coming out to this jimin we see now days 🥰😍
Jimin actually has the the most vocal range among the singers and he doesn’t sing out of his vocal range, it prob just sounds like that to curt because jimins voice just sounds unique and different. Jimin naturally has a high voice placement.
Good conversation guys. I was afraid in the beginning of it that you weren’t really grasping what the lyrics are about and I wanted you so much to “get it”. You exactly did and it was great to hear all of your collected input. This is my favorite Jimin song because you can see into his soul. I’m so glad that he came out of that Lie and is a much happier, wiser person. Thanks for your reaction! 💜
It's a song about lying to yourself... Negative self-talk, being hyper critical, self-hatred, confusion, not seeing yourself clearly or kindly... The lyrics are open enough to interpretation to be able to relate to it in different and personal ways, but that's the core feeling.
I love what he said about this era being when Jimin came into his own becuase honestly as someone who became a fan during the era before Wings, that is the perfect thing to say about him. As you start from the present of whatever time you discovered them and go back it almost feel as who Jimin was trying to personify to fit BTS concepts was not really comfortable for him and not trying to say he was being fake or not being hisself because I don’t know Jimin personally but the Wings era he brought this sensuality and confidence that people NOTICED!!!! when this era began, and ever since then that version of him never left. And it was really in the Wings era where ‘The Jimin Effect’ (though it has always been there since debut), really took off. You noticed the confidence even when people were checking him out on the street and it was a Jimin that we hadn’t (well I hadn’t as the wave of Army’s who came in during the Run/INU/YF era) seen before.
Strong analysis here. I am unsure if you have seen the Wings short films which interconnects all 7 Wings solo performances, but it is such a stunning piece of art that it could easily exhibited as art film at a contemporary art museum and even viewers unfamiliar with BTS would be absorbed.
After that era in a documentary jimin said his old self wasn't himself he used to pretend to be strong and mainly but that's not him and now he is comfortable in his skin he isn't pretending to be someone who isn't him and he cried after that
I LOOOOOOOOOVE LIE! It's soooo good. No wonder this is probably the track I would always recommend musicians, bc they always scratch their heads and love it. And his performances! Magic and spell bounding. Man, you guys would love the BU (Bangtan Universe) - it is confusing AF, but it SOO incredible well made. I love the shorts ... but they are SO well made, that you could easily spend an hour breaking down everything, bc nothing is coincidental, and everything is telling something. It really takes every braincell to pick up on the hints. I've rewatch it 5+ times + reaction videos by pros, and each time I discover something new. It is SO WELL MADE! If you ever decide to look at them and go all the way in, look at everything: lighting, sounds, camera angles, clothing, use of colour, camera quality, metaphors, movie/culture/art/philosophy references, pairings (who), time stamps, easter eggs etc. ... the list goes on. It's really a job for people in the film making business or analyzing bits. No wonder they use BTS music and videos at universities (e.g. Blood, Sweat & Tears).
Tbh the guy in the flannel shirt always surprises me with what songs he likes. Like sometimes I totally expect him to not like a song and he completely loves it and vice versa lmao
I've been resonating with this song for the past 3 years and it hasn't been getting better. It's something I struggle with everyday because it's how I've been raised. The only difference that was made was that I finally realized the problem, the "lie" and I'm still to this day trying to fix myself and remove the lie that I've been so used to living with. It's honestly a painful and scary journey to be in. But it's different for everyone including Jimin. Everyone struggle differently with the lie they house themselves in.
You’re right Curt, temptation is part of the concept of the whole Wings album from which Lie is taken. Its based on Herman Hesse’s novel Demian which tells a story about a young boy’s journey to self-realization, and finds himself caught up between temptation of the flesh and religious redemption. It revolves around dealing with two opposing forces within him: the good and the bad, the truth and the lie, which Jimin sings about in this track. It’s like an inner fight between his two sides. There’s so much to unpack and the context can be better understood if you know how the Bangtan Universe fictional storyline goes or at least the novel Demian. Also the orchestra part in the beginning gives off the vibe of a conflicted mind which Jimin seems to be having in the song.
Well, one of the things that always strikes me…the Wooah, sounds so very Louisiana voodoo to me. Throw that influence into having to live a lie, captured in a lie. It adds further darkness into the mix that I treasure. Yeah, Love this piece!
I agree with all the vocal ranging discussion except for Jins. Jin has the perfect voice for Ballad in my opinion, out of all the members- he does ballads the best. Like The Truth Untold and Epiphany. Its just that there isnt a lot a lot of ballads in his solo discography. V is perfect for neosoul rnb, Jimin and Jungkook both have range but their voice is versatile so they can make a lot of the songs they sing sound good by simply sticking to the appropriate range. Jin's voice is the ballad- through and through, imo. Anyways, loved this reaction and panel discussion 😊💜 Happy Jimin Day!
I'm happy guys you love this and Jimin also lol.. we are so open minded i love that! If u like music u better like some Korean pop music culture too. I'm really appreciate u hear this album WINGS one of the best ever, they are so fresh and uplifting. We better like We On also. Congratulations to your panels, and Happy Birthday to the greatest all of time PARK JIMIN we love you. Hope guys u got your tickets for the next month to see them.
I agree with both comments in this video....technically, Jimin doesn't have the strongest voice in the group but emotionally...his voice hits you hard and deep in the emotions. And for me...that's way more important. As someone who grew up around Black gospel singers who can sing a song so well it will bring you to your knees on a Sunday morning...and NONE of them would be considered technically perfect singers, I am quite comfortable saying that I much prefer a singer who can take me to place like that than one who can do perfect scales. By no means am I saying Jimin sounds like a gospel singer...I'm saying he can create the same level and type of emotion with his singing and his delivery AND he can transfer that energy to the people watching him. THAT is much harder to do than singing a perfect note.
Interesting analysis! Another iconic song by Jimin. His voice is especially incredible in this song. The lyrics just sound so dark and personal... the song's background could be about anything that he was going through, but I like the analysis from the two guys on the right a lot 👍
I would say that he used to strain before cuz you’re right Pdogg seems to love it when they sing in high notes and Jimins voice is usually high so this is what they expect from him but I have noticed I great improvement with his voice the past year and you gotta give credit.I love his voice cuz of the emotion that he is able to convey when he sings and that’s what is important to me and at the end we don’t really know his comfort range when he sings
Jimin's vocal improvement over the past year is just so amazing to me. It's not that he wasn't excellent before, but the amount of confidence his voice exudes these days is magical, it's like he has found his signature sound and he's gotten a lot more effortless! 😍
@@muse0613 you said it so perfectly ☺️ have you seen the TMA performance? He changed the note in boy with luv towards the end and it just sounded so beautiful. I can’t wait to see more from Jimin cuz he just gets better and better
@@lalapozada7834 Yes yes I've seen that performance and I loved it as well 😍 also the way I was blown away by his film out lives, the BTS room live, the adlibs in PTD, his muster performance, so good!
Mostly army comment about Jimin's vocal improvement. For me, all artist in this world have to gain their self improvement. That's good. But Jimin has beautiful voice since debut. His hibger range, but dreamy low voice. Even, he has powerful growling. Jimin has incredible voices since debut! That's why he selected as Lead Vocalist, one of most important position in group! Thanks y'all did reaction for "Lie"
If I'm not wrong the lie that Jimin is referring to in this song is the lie he keeps telling himself. I remember hearing that because Jimin was the last to join BTS, therefore had the shortest training period. He always felt insecure about his singing skills and overall training compared to the other members, and that he wasn't good enough, that was the lie Jimin and kept telling himself over and over again. He's long since overcome that feeling and now recognizes his own talent and has become more confident. He accepted himself and his own unique quality and talents that aren't like the other members. Jimin as he is amazing!!😊
I don’t think jimin sings out of his natural style most of the time. I think people have an idea of where his voice lies but him in Jin kind of go in the same range (tho Jin can go lower) but I think it’s a little stretch to be like most songs are out of his range. Jimin did in fact have a back ground in hip hop(not vocally but dance wise he did dance hip hop
I say this because listening to him randomly sing in generally I feel like his parts fit his style of voice as well as bts songs actually being in a higher key BECAUSE of jimin and Jin
I agree, I'm a relatively new army so I wasn't there for all their transformations but I did wonder why a lot of army keep claiming Jimin is singing outside his natural register and how beautiful his "true" lower voice is etc. like he said Home was totally in his comfort zone and very easy for him to sing, he lost lines in Blue&Grey bc it was too low for him, BTS have said they often have to raise keys for Jin and Jimin and when Jimin sings casually/for fun in e.g. run bts he always sings pretty high
@@lela1002 people might confuse their singing voices and speaking voices. Jimin's speaking voice is much lower compared to his singing one, but he does usually sing comfortably. Doesn't mean that he can't sing low notes (some of his lower singing is a masterpiece) or that he constantly sings only high notes and falsetto. He usually sings in tenor and head voice, which is singing-wise natural for him ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@@lightefilit Exactly. Finally a comment thread that speaks sense. Speaking voice is not equivalent to singing voice, people need to realise that. Even if Jimin's voice sounds deep it still has a really bright tone to it and so does his singing. If we listen to the studio version save me and the tiny desk save me, it's the same scale, it's just that his voice has transformed with practice over the years, it has gotten more fluid and brighter if that makes sense.
I urge you guys, since it sounds like you're possibly still unaware of Jimin's stunningly, spine chilling, amazing full vocal range. to react to ❤️BTS JIMIN BEST HIGH NOTES & RASPY VOCALS (Updated) by Jem. Link in reply. Shows Jimin's amazingly spectacular vocal abilities using his full registry, including all the breathtaking high notes that Jimin's always been known for, his mid range and lower registry as well, including his raspy vocals, since BTS debut, which is why he was given the official title of not only Main Dancer, but Lead Vocalist, since BTS debuted. I'd also would love if you'd react to ❤️VOCAL COACHES / PROFESSIONALS PRAISING JIMIN'S VOCALS by Kook Min. Link in reply. It's so interesting to watch many professionals describe technically as well as emotionally, what makes Jimin's vocals so special, unique, and what sets him apart on a different level for so many reasons!! Many have even admitted that Jimin was their fav vocalist & bias.
BTS JIMIN BEST HIGH NOTES & RASPY VOCALS (Updated) by Jem. m.ua-cam.com/video/1LtSXxUN9fw/v-deo.html VOCAL COACHES / PROFESSIONALS PRAISING JIMIN'S VOCALS by Kook Min. m.ua-cam.com/video/nhIMB7lEVKk/v-deo.html
Both this song and Jimin are completely haunting and mesmerizing. If someone isn't well-versed in music, they should definitely watch the review of Lie by classical musicians. It's almost orgasmic in a musical sense. I'm happy to hear I'm not the only one that compares him to Prince. Jimin had struggled for years with his image and his voice. And he really killed himself trying to cater to Korean beauty standards. Although I'm sure he still has his struggles, as we all do, I'm so happy he grows more and more comfortable in his own skin.
Really love this reaction. You guys gotta get into Burn The Stage...it captures BTS at such a critical time in their journey...they were performing Wings and getting ready to move into a new phase.
jimin's most comfortable range to sing in is his higher range. it tends to be at least 3 keys higher than what's let's say v is comfy in or with jk. he has a light and bright voice so i don't quite agree with the "singing out of his range" thing. like he said in the making of the BE album.it's rather more stressful to him to sing in a lower key than his higher part. wish we can get a tad bit of his lower range more thoo and jimin was always quite popular in his early days but it was stressful for him bcs he wasn't all that comfortable with showing too much skin as he was a minor at the time. i'm glad he grew and became more confident and not trying to please anyone but doing his own thing
And how you can tell that Jimin is actually singing in his range is that a lot of those high notes he sings is in head voice and not falsetto which means he can go even higher.
I urge you guys, since it sounds like you're possibly still unaware of Jimin's breathtakingly stunning', amazing full vocal range. to react to ❤️BTS JIMIN BEST HIGH NOTES & RASPY VOCALS (Updated) by Jem. Link in reply. Shows Jimin's amazingly spectacular vocal abilities using his full registry, including all the breathtaking high notes that Jimin's always been known for, his mid range and lower registry as well, including his raspy vocals, since BTS debut, which is why he was given the official title of not only Main Dancer, but Lead Vocalist, since BTS debuted. I'd also would love if you'd react to ❤️VOCAL COACHES / PROFESSIONALS PRAISING JIMIN'S VOCALS by Kook Min. Link in reply. It's so interesting to watch many professionals describe technically as well as emotionally, what makes Jimin's vocals so special, unique, and what sets him apart on a different level for so many reasons!! Many have even admitted that Jimin was their fav vocalist & bias.
I urge you guys, since it sounds like you're possibly still unaware of Jimin's stunningly, spine chilling, amazing full vocal range. to react to ❤️BTS JIMIN BEST HIGH NOTES & RASPY VOCALS (Updated) by Jem. Link in reply. Shows Jimin's amazingly spectacular vocal abilities using his full registry, including all the breathtaking high notes that Jimin's always been known for, his mid range and lower registry as well, including his raspy vocals, since BTS debut, which is why he was given the official title of not only Main Dancer, but Lead Vocalist, since BTS debuted. I'd also would love if you'd react to ❤️VOCAL COACHES / PROFESSIONALS PRAISING JIMIN'S VOCALS by Kook Min. Link in reply. It's so interesting to watch many professionals describe technically as well as emotionally, what makes Jimin's vocals so special, unique, and what sets him apart on a different level for so many reasons!! Many have even admitted that Jimin was their fav vocalist & bias.
Jimin has come into his own in singing for sure. He is the lead vocalist, so Bighit saw something to put him as a lead singer. I always admired Jimin's vocals, his vocals are one of a kind. He's not called the "It Boy" for nothing, his charisma on stage is amazing just ask Suga! You can always tell when Jimin his singing, my favorite singer besides Kim Jaehwan and Sanduel! For shame my all time favorite singer behind Jimin is Park Hyo Shin, they all have phenomenal vocals! Also his natural tone is high, as far hurting his vocals he has vocal training so he knows how to use those beautiful vocals!
♦️Jimin wrote the lyrics not only by himself, but was the only one to send his very first draft to the producers, and it was approved, so no need for a rewrite! The lie is the lie he keeps telling himself. Always in the past aiming for perfection and by doing so always questioning and second guessing himself! Although deep inside he knows better! The other lie is telling himself as well as everyone else that everything is alright when it's not!! Jimin has grown and changed, along with the other members since then. All learning to love themselves for who & what they are flaws and all! Jimin is now able to, as his song Promise says, shine the light on himself, as well, speaking up more when things bother him and allowing himself to laugh off whenever he makes any kind of mistake, knowing now he can always perfect or improve on whatever is lacking next time!!
An absolute must that I recommend & so needs to be reacted to ❤️BTS JIMIN BEST LIVE HIGH NOTES & RASPY VOCALS COMPILATION (UPDATED) by Jem ❤️ ua-cam.com/video/1LtSXxUN9fw/v-deo.html ❤️🔥😱😍💜❤️🙏🙏👍🐥🔥 Shows Jimin's breathtakingly amazing full vocal range abilities since the beginning in 2013 til recent, including acoustic & acappella, that shows Jimin's vocal ability that I'm not sure you guys are aware of. Since there is the title of of the song in each clip, you'll also get to be introduced to some awesome BTS songs you've yet to hear! Jimin was given the official title of not only Main Dancer, but also Lead Vocalist, since BTS debuted, for a reason! JIMIN also was awarded for 2 yrs in a row now both the prestigious title of KING OF KPOP, as well as BEST DANCER IN KPOP 3 yrs in a row as well!!
This song is so breathtaking every time I hear it it’s amazing
Same
@@REDEMPTION46 If you watched voice expert reactions, you’d know Jimin’s voice actually sits naturally in the high range; I also disagree he has the smallest range…he sings very low. Did you not watch the intros to the guys? If you did, you’d also know at 15 he was doing dance battles, popping, locking - hip hop…it was the KPop style of dance he struggled with in the beginning!
Talk about having the IT factor. That is Park Jimin. Such a beautiful performer and one of the best voices
It's unfortunate that this stage mix doesn't truly show Jimin's choreo for this song. To me, it's just as breathtaking as the song itself. Thanks for reacting, guys!
Very true. The edit was done very well but took away from the performance a little which shows how much of a performer Jimin is that the performance without the edits is better.
It's so irritating , they didn't show the chest popping from the front angle which is way better and same for the bbridge part
I definitely think Wings was the bridge between “old school BTS” when they were just kids and trying to figure out who they were and “new school” where they’ve blossomed into these incredible men that are much more confident and comfortable with themselves. One of the greatest albums in the history of pop music in my opinion.
Honesty I feel like HYYH is the bridge and Wings is the beginning of new school BTS.
@@shinjite06 agree
I think wings was way before it’s time, it was amazing and I think if they dropped it recently, then it would have 6 times the success it did!
@@abbiecampfield8955 but without wings coming out the time it did they wouldnt of sky rocketed to where they are now
@@shinjite06 yeah HYYH was definitely groundbreaking as well but I think Wings just hit harder for me, like they really let everything out and showed a lot more of themselves, especially in the solo songs
No Idol Uptil now is able to cover Jimin's Lie. This song is soo hard and difficult to perform. Park Jimin is literally the King. His talent and Hardwork , both emphasize in this performance.
"Jimin has incredible voice"
FACT!
Jimin wrote the lyric of the song with his fulled personal emotional. He succeeded for sharing the relatable story of each other people. He's Genius Songwritter. He's Brilliant!
Jimin actually has the highest vocal range in bts :)
He hit an A5 in Let Me Know, which is way out of a male tenors natural range, and is the lead singer in the group, the second highest position.
I think you guys are way underestimating Jimin's vocals because his voice is so light and soft.
i thought i heard/read that jin had the broadest vocal range? it seems that lately jin has been doing the falsetto and super high range (that’s my technical speak 😝)
@@lodeci Jimin has consistently a higher range than Jungkook and often hits the highest notes, he did let me know every concert during their tour, it is very much in his range.
Jungkook has a high range, but he doesn't consistently hit notes as high as Jimin does, nor can he reach notes like Jimin's A5. Jin usually hits higher notes than Kookie too.
But Jungkook is still the best vocalist on the group, because vocals aren't just about notes.
Take for example the "I'll be missing you" cover, where Jin and Jimin just casually hit F5s a few times in the group singing part at the end, or ON where Jimin hits incredibly high notes in the "Na na na" part.
I think you don't realise how high notes Jimin hits on every bts album, because he doesn't have as many highlighted high note moments anymore, and they are more often blended into the song.
As well as Jimin already having a high voice and us just being used to Jimin hitting these incredible notes so often.
@@yeppoyou Broadest doesn't mean highest, I think Jin has the broadest because he can hit notes way lower than Jimin or Jungkook, as well as notes higher than V.
But Jimin still has the highest range :)
@@lodeci even bts members said that jimin has heights vocal range 🤣
@@lodeci Sure, Jin, JK and V can get to certain high notes but quite frankly, you can tell they strain to get there…like they really have to ‘push’ to get there - Jin’s triple high note in Crystal Snow looked very uncomfortable - painful in fact and it DID look and sound very strained; like perhaps the way he did that was not proper technique. I suspect over time, it would damage his vocal chords.
Jimin’s voice, on the other hand, NATURALLY SITS in that high range: he hits those notes effortlessly. And his voice is airy, and so unique it cuts through everybody else’s - you can hear him over the other 3. V has said he’s been given high notes (from Pdogg) that he didn’t want to sing because it was so difficult and didn’t think he could do it. He often sounds like he’s straining at certain high notes. Jin also has said he sometimes struggles with those high notes and that Jimin does have the highest range. JK has tried to sing Filter and he stops because he can’t sustain those high notes through the whole song…same with Serendipity.
Jimin has proven himself to be a world class singer a hundred times over and that’s evident by the amount of respect and admiration he receives from experts in the global music industry. If you can’t see his voice is one of the best and on a whole other level, that’s your problem, it’s not because of him.
For me, Lie is one of the most genius Kpop songs ever. I am always so impressed when the key goes from minor to major. It's like the major is a lie in and of itself. It's give me goosebumps whenever I thought about it. And not to mention, the lyrics too, such an extremely well-written. It's awesome that Jimin wrote the lyrics. Thank you for the reaction! I enjoy it! :)
I really had goosebumps reading ur comment
Everyone can train their voice, and Jimin has done just that. He sings mainly in head voice, not falsetto.
It saddens me when people discredit his vocal ability
finally ... yes...hit it correct. Jimin's vocals are unique.
These guys doing this reaction do not credit Jimin where he has taken himself. Maybe they should watch reactions by vocal coaches since they are so wrong about Jimin.
This song along with Promise & Filter take me to another place due to Jimin's vocals.
He is singing in his norm • head vocals ... They as many don't think a man can have such vocals! They are so wrong.
@@donnal.padilla4336 yea he has a really bright tone both him and Jk are both tenors but his higher than JK and that’s ok. Not a lot of can appreciate his vocal tone but let’s not discredit his vocal ability
@@lalapozada7834 exactly 👏👏
Lie is a masterpiece. I can even say it's underrated. I love it.
Bone for the new army yes but this song is not at all underrated it is the most important and most played solo of the album wings only below the main track BS&T and in fact its choreography is covered by rookie idols, what could have been A world hit of that I do not discuss it but for the time and because BTS were just becoming known globally it is really an incredible feat and it remains to this day in that position.
Jimin is outstanding and one of the greatest of this era. There is no way to Jimin out, he is amazing!
I may be OT7 all the way...but Jimins solos always be hitting different.
Jimin has a great unique tone and naturally high pitched voice that's why most vocal coaches and reactors like his voice. His voice is what most producers like too bec it's not common and gives texture to the song especially now he had developed his signature fry at the end when he sings. He is very charismatic and his stage presence is insane. He is a great singer and performer. P
Jimin's lie fancam is the most must be watch. That fancam is so great.... 😭😭😭😭
This is one of my favorite songs of all time, it’s so hauntingly beautiful and Jimin’s voice was perfect for it. I don’t know that anybody else would be able to do it like him🤩👏🏾
October 13
HAPPY BIRTHDAY PARK JIMIN !!!!!!! ♥♥
💜💖
💜💜💜
"LIE" the live performance is the very first time I had ever heard of Jimin, and from there, BTS. I watch dance videos & it was pushed to me while recovering from COVID-19. His vocals & dancing made me find out about him, which led me to BTS. The BEST DAY OF MY LIFE, I'll have you know. It still remains my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE song from him, (them). The lie I lived with for most of my life is that "I'm Ok." No one ever suspected what I was going through; no one saw through the facade. It lasted for 40 years, and then.....I broke. It came as quite a shock to people. I think the "LIE" BTS members may live with is how they are perceived by the outside, as performers, and who they really are, (or want to be). The personas they have to maintain for the public and who they are in (real) private times. I am glad that they are able to express themselves and are real proponents of mental health. It makes it more acceptable, and, I hope, helps them as well. They are genuinely kind, talented, amazing men. Please bear in mind, this is just an opinion, I am not speaking for them....it is not my intention. It's just a thought. I loved the reaction!
Jimin has great voice it's like an untamed horse with lot of potential.. Due to this he faced lots of problem initially to understand his voice... He has with lots of struggle tamed his voice and it's sounds angelic and beautiful.. Not that it was not earlier but now it's just more trained and ground breaking.. He is really talented and an great hatdworker... Greatest artist of this timrs
Jimin's higher register is the most suited for BTS songs, as Jungkook and Tae (apart from the rappers) fill the lower registers quite well, and it is his signature sound. Jimin I'd say is a pure tenor, is range is probs between E4 and C#5 ??? probs can go a bit higher? His lower range tends to be throaty.
Jimin wrote the lyrics himself, and helped with production, his first draft was approved immediately. The song is about the lies he tells himself, how he would tell himself he did bad and how he would punish himself over mistakes no one else noticed, his obsession with perfection. It's a song Jimin actually doesn't like, he wrote Promise, years later, as an answer in a way for Lie. A promise to take care of himself and be easy on himself.
Also, the song is in minor, but "caught in a lie" is in a Picardy Third, the happiest sound perse, basically pretending to be happy while one is sad.
Well said! I hope they react to Promise to hear him in a paired down but beautiful song to counterpoint what was said here about Lie being out of his range.
@@angelkbear5472 they did on their Patreon
Jimin wrote this. The lie is what his insecure self tells him about himself. It’s his struggle to break free from his insecurities the negative messages. It was suppose to be a really dark song. Thank goodness I think RM moved him away from that.
His pitch is naturally high. He opens his mouth and high notes come out. He is not ruining his voice, I appreciate Lowe caring.
Jimin has more control over his vocal cords and he emits notes that most men can’t. I think V who has the widest range- has to be more careful when he sings falsetto. But you hear Jimin easily transition from head to chest voice and use a mixture.
In the beginning, since he did not receive vocal training it was hard on his throat for some high notes. The truth untold-there is a concert and he’s ill, but he still tries to perform. Well, the pain became so bad, he was in tears on stage. The crowd sang his part of the song. It was beautiful and sad. He’s not that Jimin anymore. He has vocal control. He’s not damaging his chords. There are about Five coaches who react and none have
Indicated he is ruining his voice. They are all in awe and stop to find the key he is singing. I am so proud of Lowe, thinking of Jiminahh.
Those high notes in the early days, ended up saving BTS in a way. They stood out.
Jimin went from being undervalued, and kind of dismissed to essential, very necessary. RM even says to him once, thank you Jimin without you we would not have come this far. He has been voted the number idol for a couple of years. Number one dancer three years in row.
Number one in brand confidence. Check out the video of how Army around the world celebrated his birthday this year. You tube.
#redeemers46 🙆🏾♀️💜#BORAHAE
Jimin doesn't have the least flexibility in his voice. It's just that he's required to do the high notes because no one of the other members can go as high as him so he's rarely able to use his lower register.
What I will say tho, is that Jimin's voice is naturally high so the vocal tones and pitches he hits in both his own songs and in group and unit songs are in his natural range. I know exactly what Lo means, but singing outside of your "range" won't damage your voice if you sing correctly. I'm personally a natural alto, but in choirs, I sing as a Soprano 1. This is because I've been classically trained as a Soprano, so while my natural voice is an alto, I can hit those higher notes with ease due to how I've trained my vocal cords. Jimin has also received vocal training, which is why if you compare his high notes from older group songs to his high notes now, there's an ease to his voice that wasn't there before. They also all choose their own parts so any notes that jimin hits, he chose. But I love the fact that Lo actually knows wtf he's talking about and cares about Jimin's vocal folds.
Jimin's voice is super interesting tho, because even when he was straining more in songs, he still hit the notes with a clear tone. I also think that because he has a naturally rasp to his vocal tone, he can get away with more tones. Jimin does hit more raspy notes, growls, and uses his lower register in their earlier works as well as in some of there more recent music, but he does seem to stay in the pocket of higher pitches.
👍👍👍
Sometimes, many of us forget that Jimin has never received any professional long term vocal training until this Covid pandemic break(not like all other BTS members who has received professional vocal training in advance for 2-4 years) & I think during this pandemic break, Jimin’s vocal has improved the most, especially with his new found confidence in his vocal abilities.
It was shock for many Army when Earlier this year, during the interview in Korean TV show call ‘U-Quiz on the block’, BTS members & Jimin has finally confirmed that Jimin really didn’t receive any proper vocal training that all other BTS members has received because he was just a trainee.
And I think during these ‘LIE’ period, Jimin was still struggling a lot with his own vocal & trying to find his own methods & vocal techniques all by himself.
Around ‘Wings’ era, Jimin even have mentioned once in magazine interview that his strongest wish is to have at least 3 months break from everything so he could get professional training & prepare himself to be better idol.
It makes me so upset to think how Jimin has been struggling mostly by himself with all their hectic schedules while getting all those hate & criticisms from BTS anti & toxic solo stans.
It always makes me wonder what if Jimin also has received those 2-4 years of professional vocal training in advance before BTS debut, just like other BTS members.
I would believe that Jimin would definitely be even more a fantastic vocalist right now!
Idk anything about singing etc. but thank you for explaining this cuz it all makes sense. Vocal abilities has greatly improved and I could sense so much more confidence in him when he is singing. Recently watched film out live and he was singing such a high note and his face was so relaxed that you wouldn’t think he just killed us with his high note 😅
Exactly. He knows his ability and voice better than all of us. Out of Range means Jimin can stretch out that note more. That doesn't hurt him.
I’ve seen Jimin getting help from Jungkook with his singing because for some reason he didn’t receive the training the others did. I know he was only in training for a short time but it seems strange that they didn’t train his voice when it is such an essential tool which needs to be honed. Fortunately they all know about warming up so he has protected his voice.
Jimin's voice is great one of a kind. His dancing wow
this song and epiphany really get me every time Jin and Jimin hitting those notes with powerful lyrics is so amazing
Lo isn't exactly correct about Jimin. If you watch any other their videos in their off time Jimin naturally sings high. No one is forcing him to.
LIE is a masterpiece. Its melody is unique. It grabs you from start to finish. Jimin's voice has so many unique nuances that you are charmed by his voice. To all this add the choreography!! Jimin is a great artist, songwriter, and producer. GOD OF DANCER too. loved their reactions
Lie is my favorite Jimin solo. The performance is everything especially the ending gives me James Brown vibes.
Dang talking about prince and mj here could be the biggest compliment for an artist
LIE' this song makes me cry whenever I listen to it I don't know the reason can't explain & his performance just blew me away every time 🥺💛
Happy Jimin Day🥳🎈
Lie is a legendary masterpiece. When the wings album was out lie was the most anticipated song in the album. Jimin is a phenomen
Jimin Is Amazing with he's performance and he's Unique and Angelic voice. Song is deep with Jimins life.💜💜 Happy Birthday Jimin! 🎉🥳🎂
Like you'll reactions. 👏😎👏😎
At first I agreed to this until they said JIMIN was the 4th place vocally, there is a reason why he is lead vocalist how can you say this after this masterpiece even when he was the ONLY one who didn’t receive vocal lessons all the other members had that privilege
Not Lo knowing all the songs😭 love to see it💜
He’s been studying and learning lol
@@REDEMPTION46 wings album keeping him educated. Yessir 😭💜
Which one is Lo?
@@adelinasardothien8238 tan hat
Jimin wrote part of the lyrics.......it was one of the darkest days of his life......he said whenever he performs it, the song take a toll on him
It’s like he gets possessed by a demon.
Jimin has the most unique beautiful voice. He’s so hard on himself but he’s perfection to me
Lie will always remain as one of his iconic solo songs..
This is my favourite Jimin solo song I love it so much
Man, the amount of videos for Chim! Thanks 💜
Jimin day 💜
This song as well as, wings the album is a masterpiece both sonically, lyrically, and contextually. The boys ATE when they created this album, my gosh. It sends puts adrenaline in my veins and sends chills down my spin. I cant wait to see you’re in depth exploration of the album, even looking into the behind the scenes or explanation videos are cool.
Wings isn’t their best album lyrically nor sonically.
@@RM-of2oz I disagree
@@RM-of2oz It's their first album to do really really well so obv it's the best
@@suamae2049 being their first album to get 1 million sells doesn’t mean it’s the best album. It’s not their best album lyrically nor sonically. Still a good album
@@RM-of2oz well thank you for ur incorrect opinion
"I feel like he's the best singer in this group" FACT! JIMIN IS EVERYTHING!
If everyone can feet in the same good things, so why Jimin can't be the best!
The guy in th checked shirt is right Jimin has the smallest range of the vocal line but his head voice is so beautiful and his singing is so unique. His is the only one that speaking voice is completely different from his singing voice. The only one amongst the group
One of the things that I love about this song is that it's in minor (sad vibes) but then switches to major (happy vibes) for the chorus. So this brighter feeling that comes with the chorus (happiness) is the lie itself, which I think is a very creative way to emphasize the concept of the song through production! As always, love your guys' reactions! Also wanna give credit to ReacttotheK for breaking the song down musically from a classical perspective, they're a great channel that everyone should check out!
He wrote the song cause he wanted to stop forcing himself to be pleasing others but him, about not being happy with himself, every word, this lyrics is Jimin life's coming out to this jimin we see now days 🥰😍
A beleza do Jimim é inegável e encantadora ...sem dizer o talento. Nem preciso dizer que é meu preferido ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Hypnotic, that song is a master piece.
WE LOVE PARK JIMIN SO MUCH ❤😚😘🐥🌏#JIMIN
Jimin actually has the the most vocal range among the singers and he doesn’t sing out of his vocal range, it prob just sounds like that to curt because jimins voice just sounds unique and different. Jimin naturally has a high voice placement.
Good conversation guys. I was afraid in the beginning of it that you weren’t really grasping what the lyrics are about and I wanted you so much to “get it”. You exactly did and it was great to hear all of your collected input. This is my favorite Jimin song because you can see into his soul. I’m so glad that he came out of that Lie and is a much happier, wiser person. Thanks for your reaction! 💜
It's a song about lying to yourself... Negative self-talk, being hyper critical, self-hatred, confusion, not seeing yourself clearly or kindly... The lyrics are open enough to interpretation to be able to relate to it in different and personal ways, but that's the core feeling.
LIE IS WONDERFUL 💜
KING OF STAGE PRESENCE
I love what he said about this era being when Jimin came into his own becuase honestly as someone who became a fan during the era before Wings, that is the perfect thing to say about him. As you start from the present of whatever time you discovered them and go back it almost feel as who Jimin was trying to personify to fit BTS concepts was not really comfortable for him and not trying to say he was being fake or not being hisself because I don’t know Jimin personally but the Wings era he brought this sensuality and confidence that people NOTICED!!!! when this era began, and ever since then that version of him never left. And it was really in the Wings era where ‘The Jimin Effect’ (though it has always been there since debut), really took off. You noticed the confidence even when people were checking him out on the street and it was a Jimin that we hadn’t (well I hadn’t as the wave of Army’s who came in during the Run/INU/YF era) seen before.
Strong analysis here. I am unsure if you have seen the Wings short films which interconnects all 7 Wings solo performances, but it is such a stunning piece of art that it could easily exhibited as art film at a contemporary art museum and even viewers unfamiliar with BTS would be absorbed.
After that era in a documentary jimin said his old self wasn't himself he used to pretend to be strong and mainly but that's not him and now he is comfortable in his skin he isn't pretending to be someone who isn't him and he cried after that
I LOOOOOOOOOVE LIE! It's soooo good. No wonder this is probably the track I would always recommend musicians, bc they always scratch their heads and love it. And his performances! Magic and spell bounding. Man, you guys would love the BU (Bangtan Universe) - it is confusing AF, but it SOO incredible well made. I love the shorts ... but they are SO well made, that you could easily spend an hour breaking down everything, bc nothing is coincidental, and everything is telling something. It really takes every braincell to pick up on the hints. I've rewatch it 5+ times + reaction videos by pros, and each time I discover something new. It is SO WELL MADE!
If you ever decide to look at them and go all the way in, look at everything: lighting, sounds, camera angles, clothing, use of colour, camera quality, metaphors, movie/culture/art/philosophy references, pairings (who), time stamps, easter eggs etc. ... the list goes on. It's really a job for people in the film making business or analyzing bits. No wonder they use BTS music and videos at universities (e.g. Blood, Sweat & Tears).
I love this song for so many reasons but musically, when it switches to a major - after starting and living in minor - is so shocking and magical.
Tbh the guy in the flannel shirt always surprises me with what songs he likes. Like sometimes I totally expect him to not like a song and he completely loves it and vice versa lmao
Join the club lol
I've been resonating with this song for the past 3 years and it hasn't been getting better. It's something I struggle with everyday because it's how I've been raised. The only difference that was made was that I finally realized the problem, the "lie" and I'm still to this day trying to fix myself and remove the lie that I've been so used to living with. It's honestly a painful and scary journey to be in. But it's different for everyone including Jimin. Everyone struggle differently with the lie they house themselves in.
You’re right Curt, temptation is part of the concept of the whole Wings album from which Lie is taken. Its based on Herman Hesse’s novel Demian which tells a story about a young boy’s journey to self-realization, and finds himself caught up between temptation of the flesh and religious redemption. It revolves around dealing with two opposing forces within him: the good and the bad, the truth and the lie, which Jimin sings about in this track. It’s like an inner fight between his two sides. There’s so much to unpack and the context can be better understood if you know how the Bangtan Universe fictional storyline goes or at least the novel Demian.
Also the orchestra part in the beginning gives off the vibe of a conflicted mind which Jimin seems to be having in the song.
Multi talented king jimin 🔥🔥🔥
thank u for reacting to this. Happy Bday Jiminaj
Jimin day 💜💜
This is one of my fav BTS song overall.
The lyrics his voice and his high notes made it very special.
Caught in a Lieeeeeeeeee, Thanks for the reaction😆
🔥🔥
❤❤❤ Serendipity live stage during the love yourself speak yourself tour.
Well, one of the things that always strikes me…the Wooah, sounds so very Louisiana voodoo to me. Throw that influence into having to live a lie, captured in a lie. It adds further darkness into the mix that I treasure. Yeah, Love this piece!
I agree with all the vocal ranging discussion except for Jins. Jin has the perfect voice for Ballad in my opinion, out of all the members- he does ballads the best. Like The Truth Untold and Epiphany. Its just that there isnt a lot a lot of ballads in his solo discography. V is perfect for neosoul rnb, Jimin and Jungkook both have range but their voice is versatile so they can make a lot of the songs they sing sound good by simply sticking to the appropriate range. Jin's voice is the ballad- through and through, imo. Anyways, loved this reaction and panel discussion 😊💜 Happy Jimin Day!
I'm happy guys you love this and Jimin also lol.. we are so open minded i love that! If u like music u better like some Korean pop music culture too. I'm really appreciate u hear this album WINGS one of the best ever, they are so fresh and uplifting. We better like We On also.
Congratulations to your panels, and Happy Birthday to the greatest all of time PARK JIMIN we love you. Hope guys u got your tickets for the next month to see them.
I agree with both comments in this video....technically, Jimin doesn't have the strongest voice in the group but emotionally...his voice hits you hard and deep in the emotions. And for me...that's way more important.
As someone who grew up around Black gospel singers who can sing a song so well it will bring you to your knees on a Sunday morning...and NONE of them would be considered technically perfect singers, I am quite comfortable saying that I much prefer a singer who can take me to place like that than one who can do perfect scales.
By no means am I saying Jimin sounds like a gospel singer...I'm saying he can create the same level and type of emotion with his singing and his delivery AND he can transfer that energy to the people watching him. THAT is much harder to do than singing a perfect note.
Interesting analysis! Another iconic song by Jimin. His voice is especially incredible in this song. The lyrics just sound so dark and personal... the song's background could be about anything that he was going through, but I like the analysis from the two guys on the right a lot 👍
OMG JIMIN JACKSON 😲😲😲😲😲😲😲 WTF PARK JIMIN YOU ARE THE BEST 👑👑👑👑👑👑
I would say that he used to strain before cuz you’re right Pdogg seems to love it when they sing in high notes and Jimins voice is usually high so this is what they expect from him but I have noticed I great improvement with his voice the past year and you gotta give credit.I love his voice cuz of the emotion that he is able to convey when he sings and that’s what is important to me and at the end we don’t really know his comfort range when he sings
Jimin's vocal improvement over the past year is just so amazing to me. It's not that he wasn't excellent before, but the amount of confidence his voice exudes these days is magical, it's like he has found his signature sound and he's gotten a lot more effortless! 😍
@@muse0613 you said it so perfectly ☺️ have you seen the TMA performance? He changed the note in boy with luv towards the end and it just sounded so beautiful. I can’t wait to see more from Jimin cuz he just gets better and better
@@lalapozada7834 Yes yes I've seen that performance and I loved it as well 😍 also the way I was blown away by his film out lives, the BTS room live, the adlibs in PTD, his muster performance, so good!
@@muse0613 omg yes we share the same brain cells 😂 I literally watched all those you mentioned as well 💜💜💜
@@lalapozada7834 haha yes we ARMYs do share the same brain cells 😂💜
Mostly army comment about Jimin's vocal improvement. For me, all artist in this world have to gain their self improvement. That's good. But Jimin has beautiful voice since debut. His hibger range, but dreamy low voice. Even, he has powerful growling. Jimin has incredible voices since debut! That's why he selected as Lead Vocalist, one of most important position in group!
Thanks y'all did reaction for "Lie"
Also not Lo pulling out the Korean 😭 be my study buddy.
You see him
Lie by ParkJimin is the best song and performance that ever happened to kpop industry.
Happy Birthday Jiminie!!! Borahae!
(Have a great day ya'll!!!)
Thanks for all this videos of my Chim Chim💜💜💜💜HAPPY BIRTHDAY MY BABY MOCHI🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂
If I'm not wrong the lie that Jimin is referring to in this song is the lie he keeps telling himself.
I remember hearing that because Jimin was the last to join BTS, therefore had the shortest training period. He always felt insecure about his singing skills and overall training compared to the other members, and that he wasn't good enough, that was the lie Jimin and kept telling himself over and over again. He's long since overcome that feeling and now recognizes his own talent and has become more confident. He accepted himself and his own unique quality and talents that aren't like the other members. Jimin as he is amazing!!😊
Jimin daaaaaaay
I don’t think jimin sings out of his natural style most of the time. I think people have an idea of where his voice lies but him in Jin kind of go in the same range (tho Jin can go lower) but I think it’s a little stretch to be like most songs are out of his range. Jimin did in fact have a back ground in hip hop(not vocally but dance wise he did dance hip hop
I say this because listening to him randomly sing in generally I feel like his parts fit his style of voice as well as bts songs actually being in a higher key BECAUSE of jimin and Jin
I agree, I'm a relatively new army so I wasn't there for all their transformations but I did wonder why a lot of army keep claiming Jimin is singing outside his natural register and how beautiful his "true" lower voice is etc. like he said Home was totally in his comfort zone and very easy for him to sing, he lost lines in Blue&Grey bc it was too low for him, BTS have said they often have to raise keys for Jin and Jimin and when Jimin sings casually/for fun in e.g. run bts he always sings pretty high
@@lela1002 people might confuse their singing voices and speaking voices. Jimin's speaking voice is much lower compared to his singing one, but he does usually sing comfortably. Doesn't mean that he can't sing low notes (some of his lower singing is a masterpiece) or that he constantly sings only high notes and falsetto. He usually sings in tenor and head voice, which is singing-wise natural for him ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@@lightefilit Exactly. Finally a comment thread that speaks sense. Speaking voice is not equivalent to singing voice, people need to realise that. Even if Jimin's voice sounds deep it still has a really bright tone to it and so does his singing. If we listen to the studio version save me and the tiny desk save me, it's the same scale, it's just that his voice has transformed with practice over the years, it has gotten more fluid and brighter if that makes sense.
His sound is from heaven
Park Jimin " Lie " ❤️❤️❤️
Guy in the checkered jacket is every army when we hear Jimin..
I urge you guys, since it sounds like you're possibly still unaware of Jimin's stunningly, spine chilling, amazing full vocal range. to react to ❤️BTS JIMIN BEST HIGH NOTES & RASPY VOCALS (Updated) by Jem. Link in reply. Shows Jimin's amazingly spectacular vocal abilities using his full registry, including all the breathtaking high notes that Jimin's always been known for, his mid range and lower registry as well, including his raspy vocals, since BTS debut, which is why he was given the official title of not only Main Dancer, but Lead Vocalist, since BTS debuted. I'd also would love if you'd react to ❤️VOCAL COACHES / PROFESSIONALS PRAISING JIMIN'S VOCALS by Kook Min. Link in reply. It's so interesting to watch many professionals describe technically as well as emotionally, what makes Jimin's vocals so special, unique, and what sets him apart on a different level for so many reasons!! Many have even admitted that Jimin was their fav vocalist & bias.
BTS JIMIN BEST HIGH NOTES & RASPY VOCALS (Updated) by Jem. m.ua-cam.com/video/1LtSXxUN9fw/v-deo.html VOCAL COACHES / PROFESSIONALS PRAISING JIMIN'S VOCALS by Kook Min. m.ua-cam.com/video/nhIMB7lEVKk/v-deo.html
i really loved the discussion between low nick and curtis it was interesting to hear how they received the song :))
Love your reaction 💜. I think you've touched the meaning of what the song tries to convey. Thank you
jimin the best bts member
Great discussion!
🙏🏽
I love your analyse And don't forget to praise the difficulty of singing and dancing at the same time, not all singers can do that, 😜🎶❤️
Both this song and Jimin are completely haunting and mesmerizing. If someone isn't well-versed in music, they should definitely watch the review of Lie by classical musicians. It's almost orgasmic in a musical sense. I'm happy to hear I'm not the only one that compares him to Prince. Jimin had struggled for years with his image and his voice. And he really killed himself trying to cater to Korean beauty standards. Although I'm sure he still has his struggles, as we all do, I'm so happy he grows more and more comfortable in his own skin.
I be singin my heart out to this song
Watch Reactothek review of “Lie”. Classical musicians breakdown how the music is written as a “lie”. It’s interesting.
Really love this reaction. You guys gotta get into Burn The Stage...it captures BTS at such a critical time in their journey...they were performing Wings and getting ready to move into a new phase.
really liked the reaction!! love from brazil S2
jimin's most comfortable range to sing in is his higher range. it tends to be at least 3 keys higher than what's let's say v is comfy in or with jk. he has a light and bright voice so i don't quite agree with the "singing out of his range" thing. like he said in the making of the BE album.it's rather more stressful to him to sing in a lower key than his higher part. wish we can get a tad bit of his lower range more thoo
and jimin was always quite popular in his early days but it was stressful for him bcs he wasn't all that comfortable with showing too much skin as he was a minor at the time. i'm glad he grew and became more confident and not trying to please anyone but doing his own thing
Amazing Happy birthday Jimin
💜💜💜
And how you can tell that Jimin is actually singing in his range is that a lot of those high notes he sings is in head voice and not falsetto which means he can go even higher.
I urge you guys, since it sounds like you're possibly still unaware of Jimin's breathtakingly stunning', amazing full vocal range. to react to ❤️BTS JIMIN BEST HIGH NOTES & RASPY VOCALS (Updated) by Jem. Link in reply. Shows Jimin's amazingly spectacular vocal abilities using his full registry, including all the breathtaking high notes that Jimin's always been known for, his mid range and lower registry as well, including his raspy vocals, since BTS debut, which is why he was given the official title of not only Main Dancer, but Lead Vocalist, since BTS debuted. I'd also would love if you'd react to ❤️VOCAL COACHES / PROFESSIONALS PRAISING JIMIN'S VOCALS by Kook Min. Link in reply. It's so interesting to watch many professionals describe technically as well as emotionally, what makes Jimin's vocals so special, unique, and what sets him apart on a different level for so many reasons!! Many have even admitted that Jimin was their fav vocalist & bias.
I urge you guys, since it sounds like you're possibly still unaware of Jimin's stunningly, spine chilling, amazing full vocal range. to react to ❤️BTS JIMIN BEST HIGH NOTES & RASPY VOCALS (Updated) by Jem. Link in reply. Shows Jimin's amazingly spectacular vocal abilities using his full registry, including all the breathtaking high notes that Jimin's always been known for, his mid range and lower registry as well, including his raspy vocals, since BTS debut, which is why he was given the official title of not only Main Dancer, but Lead Vocalist, since BTS debuted. I'd also would love if you'd react to ❤️VOCAL COACHES / PROFESSIONALS PRAISING JIMIN'S VOCALS by Kook Min. Link in reply. It's so interesting to watch many professionals describe technically as well as emotionally, what makes Jimin's vocals so special, unique, and what sets him apart on a different level for so many reasons!! Many have even admitted that Jimin was their fav vocalist & bias.
I'm really waiting for the day you guys are going to react to the wings album along with the short films of each member. The artistry is off the roof!
Ohh, Jimin can surprise you, he can Rap Too :) can play Tony Montana is legit, you all will love it, I promise!
Jimin has come into his own in singing for sure. He is the lead vocalist, so Bighit saw something to put him as a lead singer. I always admired Jimin's vocals, his vocals are one of a kind. He's not called the "It Boy" for nothing, his charisma on stage is amazing just ask Suga! You can always tell when Jimin his singing, my favorite singer besides Kim Jaehwan and Sanduel! For shame my all time favorite singer behind Jimin is Park Hyo Shin, they all have phenomenal vocals! Also his natural tone is high, as far hurting his vocals he has vocal training so he knows how to use those beautiful vocals!