Joan of Arc | Madness? OR God's Warrior

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 68

  • @missydnd1150
    @missydnd1150 Рік тому +23

    I think she is a hero and a divine leader.

    • @historyprofiles
      @historyprofiles  Рік тому +2

      Thank you for watching! I hope you enjoyed the video!

  • @thedevilluis
    @thedevilluis Рік тому +5

    She will be remembered forever in time.

  • @jared1870
    @jared1870 Рік тому +6

    Another fine one, Ollie, thanks for helping me learn about this remarkable woman from history.

    • @historyprofiles
      @historyprofiles  Рік тому +1

      Thank you for watching! I hope you enjoyed the video!

  • @-RONNIE
    @-RONNIE Рік тому +2

    Thank you for showcasing this prominent female of history ⚔️

  • @Agapy8888
    @Agapy8888 Рік тому +4

    Jeanne D’Arc. Thanks so much.
    ✝️🇫🇷💒 Saint.

    • @historyprofiles
      @historyprofiles  Рік тому +1

      Thank you for watching! I hope you enjoyed the video!

    • @Agapy8888
      @Agapy8888 Рік тому

      @@historyprofiles Your videos are great. I play them in the background when my grandkids are playing. I catch them stopping their play and watch the screen. For a few minutes then return to their playing. Hoping they absorb some of your content. At 3 and 5 years of age it’s good exposure.

  • @sandrashevel2137
    @sandrashevel2137 Рік тому +4

    She is a great warrior.

  • @deedragongirl
    @deedragongirl Рік тому +7

    Love how you cover Joan of Arc this time, she's a hero. If it weren't for her, she would not had make France great again as well as having great French leaders in the forms of Louis XIV the Sun King and Napoleon Bonaparte!

    • @historyprofiles
      @historyprofiles  Рік тому +1

      Thank you for watching! I hope you enjoyed the video!

    • @RayB1656
      @RayB1656 Рік тому

      The English were still in ''France'' for another 25 years after her tragic death, in 1431!
      Yet, Jehanne la Pucelle was certainly instrumental in bringing about a victory
      in Orléans. The timing was excellent, she came on the scene
      by the end of April 1429,
      Charles' army , all the mercenaries and all the supplies were paid by Yolande d'Anjou
      had finally arrived from Blois , an attack was ready by the first week of May.
      The Scottish troops on French soil were also ready ... and later
      ... that is why the famous ''March of Robert the Bruce'' was playing
      as Jehanne entered the city.
      Why France was able to defeat the English Aristocracy ?
      1. The War of the Roses in England.
      2. Ten of thousands of Scots on French soil.
      3. Yolande d'Anjou was able to bring in the army of the Duke of Brittany.
      4. Yolande d'Anjou used the Merlin' prophecy to recruit Jehanne la Pucelle.
      5. Burgundy changed side, the Burgundian/English alliance
      was terminated in 1435. Huge difference !
      6. The French troops used gunpower on a larger scale
      and sooner during the later part of the Hundred Year War ,
      using the ''handgoones'' and smaller mobile cannons ;
      the English still using the longbow( warbow) with the bodkin pin arrowhead.
      7. René d'Anjou (what a coincidence, another Anjou !!)
      brought in Agnès Sorel (after the death of Jehanne la Pucelle) to initiate
      a sense of responsibility to Charles VII , that depressing and depressed king !
      8. George de LaTrémoulle ( adviser to Charles VII and an enemy of Jehanne, )
      was at last removed by Yolande d'Anjou,
      and he was replaced by Charles du Maine, son of Yolande !!

  • @dianesavant2818
    @dianesavant2818 Рік тому +3

    Another great video. Thank you.

  • @ElkeMB
    @ElkeMB Рік тому +3

    Thank you for this incredible video! Wonderful history on it's perfect day. You did a fantastic job: The sound of your voice and background music, beautiful!

    • @ElkeMB
      @ElkeMB Рік тому +1

      Sorry i am late due to bad weather, no internet! Comes and goes, for 3 days now. Wish a great afternoon Ollie. Loved this video very much! Thank you

  • @carrioncrow7687
    @carrioncrow7687 Рік тому +2

    I'm familiar with the name, but I never knew what made her noteworthy in history. So this video was very enlightening

  • @rachelwilson86
    @rachelwilson86 Рік тому +2

    I enjoyed this interesting video. I have heard of Joan Of Arc, but I didn't know any of this information about her..thank you for this wonderful video!! I look forward to more!!

  • @leannelittle6067
    @leannelittle6067 Рік тому +10

    She was chosen by God. She is an inspiration, and such a brave woman.

    • @RayB1656
      @RayB1656 9 місяців тому

      Jehanne la Pucelle, a brilliant young woman from an important family from the Barrois region, was chosen by Yolande d'Anjou and her son, René d'Anjou in 1428.
      Jehanne left for France in early Feb. 1429.
      Yolande d'Anjou (with the Armagnacs) was the real mastermind behind all the scenes in this Medieval story...

  • @swedishpiggi
    @swedishpiggi Рік тому +1

    I love hearing of Joan of Arc, I think she was sain and could hear voices and she wasnt mad.
    Hugs from Sweden

    • @RayB1656
      @RayB1656 Рік тому +3

      Jehanne la Pucelle never used that particular family name d'Arc, during her lifetime. She was asked often about her name,
      she always refused to answer the question !
      Please see Prof Henri Guillemin, French historian for an explanation .
      The Maid of Orléans (a newer name by 1840) became a Saint only in 1920
      after the Paris Roman Catholic Church requested from the Vatican the Sainthood process in 1879. Why 1879 ? Your answer is there.
      Jehanne was certainly not mad, she was a brilliant, well-educated young woman,
      speaking various dialects from an important Barrois family.
      Her father was the ''prévot'' of the region under Robert de Bandricourt .
      Because of her heavy accent, she was made fun at the trial, (in 1431)
      pronouncing words from her distinctive Barrois region !
      Concerning the ''voices'' , today, this is a dilemma !
      Since the Vatican removed in 1969, both St Catherine of Alexandria and Marguerite of Antioch ... they never existed...
      how could Jehanne had a ''conversation'' with a ''saint'' who never existed ?
      If we could only asked Yolande d'Anjou ...
      As for Michael the Archangel, the other voice, he was a popular ''saint'' during the Medieval period . Numerous accounts from the population that he was ''seen'
      mostly in dreams and during daytime.
      Since the famous and small Mount St- Michel, in Normandy, resisted the English troops during the Hundred Year War, that was seen as a ''miracle'' by the general population,
      a sign from God.

    • @swedishpiggi
      @swedishpiggi Рік тому +1

      @@RayB1656 Thank you

    • @T.Truthtella-n3i
      @T.Truthtella-n3i 17 годин тому

      St. Catherine and St. Marguerite ABSOLUTELY exist and were definitely guiding St. Joan.

  • @sirsidfosse1313
    @sirsidfosse1313 8 місяців тому +2

    "by far the most extraordinary person the human race has ever produced" Mark Twain.

  • @NomadX7
    @NomadX7 Рік тому +2

    Amazing content once again!
    Please do one about the Battle of Aljubarrota! 6.000 Portuguese and English Archers against 31.000 Castillian and French Calvary! A battle still studied today by Officers/Sargents in any modern army! 14th century 3 batyles for Portuguese independence! The Square Tactic that the Inglish sugested and implemented by the Portuguese army lead by Nuno Alvares Pereira, best Knight/Monk in the kingdom! A battle for the Ages! Thanks Sir.

  • @mariaagullo5824
    @mariaagullo5824 6 місяців тому +1

    Joan of Arc communicated with the Heavenly beings which God sent to her. Do not mix truth with the lies of this modern, skeptical generation. Miracles accompanied Joan as she led the soldiers. She was even badly wounded, but continued her work. That is NOT the work of fairies. Her bravery against amazing odds lives to this day and let it be known that God still works through His people. If we remain true to His law and use our talents to help others, the stagnant, ignorant mode of living which so many adhere to shall give way to blessings, knowledge, and peace, yes even to salvation!

  • @johnpaulthomas3582
    @johnpaulthomas3582 Рік тому

    😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰💓💓💓-NIKKI88💋✌💋

  • @chrisschepper9312
    @chrisschepper9312 Рік тому +2

    Madness.

  • @jennklein1917
    @jennklein1917 Рік тому +2

    How can she hear voices that don't exist? Why as a French person would god be on her 'side', when the British are also Christians like France? She is what we call today, delusional, very interesting case!

    • @YourBoyJohnny94
      @YourBoyJohnny94 6 місяців тому

      She probably was a luciferian like her buddy Gilles de Rais. Her story sound so BS. Especially when in Christianity, women aren’t allowed to dress like man and have leadership roles in the military.

    • @T.Truthtella-n3i
      @T.Truthtella-n3i 17 годин тому

      Nope, she’s a glorious saint of God.

  • @larrysherk
    @larrysherk Рік тому

    It isn't legitimate inquiry to distinguish between madness and divine calling. Outside the realm os inquiry.

  • @Hadrada.
    @Hadrada. Рік тому +3

    We are told she communicated with angles but I’ve heard thats not true she said she communicated with fairy’s

    • @RayB1656
      @RayB1656 5 місяців тому

      No fairies , no visions nor voices, no flying angels , no mental illness,
      no flying saucers with little green men...
      ...an educated young woman of 21 who was recruited by both, René d'Anjou and her mother, Yolande d'Anjou including the Armagnacs, in early February 1429, to stop the English aristocracy to obtain the French crown, since both the Lancaster and the Valois royal families had an equal opportunity ...

    • @T.Truthtella-n3i
      @T.Truthtella-n3i 17 годин тому

      Nope.

  • @sheepdog1102
    @sheepdog1102 Рік тому +4

    Just like the Catholic Church to burn a saint 😮

    • @RayB1656
      @RayB1656 Рік тому +4

      She was not a ''saint'' yet in 1431 ;
      she became a saint only in 1920 , after WWI
      the request was made by the Paris Roman Catholic Church, in 1879 !!

    • @silverhawkscape2677
      @silverhawkscape2677 2 місяці тому

      Correction. It was a Conflict between British Clerics and the French since this was a war between The British and the French. Since, you know, she was tried by the British Clerics.
      Since her death her Trial was investigated. Found the conflict of interest. Had those involved excommunicated and Joan Absolved.
      Then she was requested to be recognized as a Saint.

  • @albertangeloro5832
    @albertangeloro5832 Рік тому +8

    of course she was a madwoman. i am surprised anyone took her seriously. why would God give a shit about England & France's problems and if he did all he had to do was his old parting of the sea-like trick. poof its done, he is God after all.

  • @truefact844
    @truefact844 Рік тому +5

    Was she not a moorish woman with a girlfriend? Or is that the Disney version…

  • @Stella77_7
    @Stella77_7 Рік тому +1

    The Cathic church ALWAYS pointed the finger of witch & lunacy at a strong able women. They could not have her go down in history as a Heretic figure as a woman.

    • @MikeHunt-fo3ow
      @MikeHunt-fo3ow Рік тому

      well its ran by the pope they been corrupt for for a thousand years

    • @ash9280
      @ash9280 Рік тому

      She wasn't killed by ''The Catholic Church'' but a corrupt bishop working for the English.

    • @MegaAnimeforlife
      @MegaAnimeforlife 9 місяців тому

      I guess Joan could be considered the first protestant 100 years before Luther.

    • @T.Truthtella-n3i
      @T.Truthtella-n3i 17 годин тому

      No. She was a loyal daughter of the Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church.

  • @frederiquecouture3924
    @frederiquecouture3924 9 місяців тому

    Money 🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑💰💰💰.

  • @ikevanrosendaal7560
    @ikevanrosendaal7560 Рік тому +5

    religion madness the same thing really😂

    • @silverhawkscape2677
      @silverhawkscape2677 2 місяці тому

      Nope. Religion and Madness are completely Different. There are more than enough Sane intelligent Religious Men of Women throughout the world to know this is pure Fallacy. Even Psychologists heavily discourage this Assumption.

  • @aurelian-ne4fy
    @aurelian-ne4fy 8 місяців тому

    I think she was a witch

    • @RayB1656
      @RayB1656 5 місяців тому

      Jehanne was not a ''witch'' !
      She was accused of heresy !
      History books are useful ... ...

  • @danalden1112
    @danalden1112 Рік тому

    Both! Doesn’t have to be either/or.

  • @emilypopovich4790
    @emilypopovich4790 6 місяців тому

    I think she was sent by God. I don’t think there was any madness there she was sent by God.

    • @RayB1656
      @RayB1656 5 місяців тому

      GOD doesn't take sides !
      Both the French aristocracy and the French aristocracy were Roman Catholics,
      the French troops and mercenaries' patron saint was Michael the Archangel and
      the Gabriel the Archangel was the patron for the English troops !!!

  • @sayagarapan1686
    @sayagarapan1686 Рік тому

    Both. I think she was inspired but went too far beyond what God intended for her role.

    • @RayB1656
      @RayB1656 9 місяців тому

      God, if he exists, doesn't take sides !
      Only mankind does !
      Jehanne la Pucelle had 4 missions.
      She was successful with 2.
      This was a Medieval political story and she was sadly ''removed''
      by the same people who she trusted.
      She was captured very easily in Compiègne,
      it was an entrapment set-up!

    • @RayB1656
      @RayB1656 5 місяців тому

      God doesn't get involved in stupid human politics!
      This was a political story !

    • @T.Truthtella-n3i
      @T.Truthtella-n3i 17 годин тому

      Nope.