Is Jim’s Theory That The Town Is A Cruel Experiment True? - Explored

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 134

  • @mreboric8406
    @mreboric8406 2 дні тому +27

    It's an idea I had a while ago after Lost ended. You can make an entire show on just the premise and then let the fans write it for you. Just pick the best theories and have your writers do that.

    • @tsvetelin6556
      @tsvetelin6556 14 годин тому

      Is this what they made with Lost? I mean I'm really asking as I haven't watched it only the first 2 episodes but it didn't hook me like From..

  •  2 дні тому +44

    I miss the old jim that tried figuring stuff out

    • @AF564
      @AF564 День тому +6

      He realised that figuring stuff out could cost him his , or his families lives . But yeah makes for shit character development . More like character de-development

    •  День тому

      @AF564 I feel him but I just he made that more of a point to tell people he's criticizing about that maybe tell tabitha I'm afraid to start looking because entities basically said they'll kill my fam and tell her about the radios shell say no it actually fell down because they're a whole tunnel/cave under the house and I digged big enough a hole to make the whole thing collapse on me it's not your fault type stuff

    • @flexopgawdd
      @flexopgawdd День тому +1

      ​​@@AF564now he is trying to help Tabitha, I guess he does have some involvement in the s3 finale, let's just see

    • @power279
      @power279 День тому +1

      He got afraid after talking with the voice that warns him to not push the limit.

    •  День тому

      @flexopgawdd seems to convieninent bro prolly bout to die🤣🤣🤣

  • @edwardgonzalez6331
    @edwardgonzalez6331 2 дні тому +18

    Jade was very clear in season 1 episode 5, mark 21:55, he sold his company that was based on a quantum computing algorithm. In that same episode, mark 21:47, he says that people like him designs the maze and place the cheese. This means that if he sold his company, then he might have sold it to a company that design this mazes--Fromville . Now, you have to wonder why Tobby was killed the way he was killed, cutting his tongue is almost like a message.

    • @nb66nad
      @nb66nad День тому +1

      Thank you !

    • @casperthegm741
      @casperthegm741 День тому +2

      No explanation is going to please all the fans, but for me personally, this one has potential. I like it, and it feels plausible. Could be that the characters are reincarnated via repeated simulations maybe?

    • @edwardgonzalez6331
      @edwardgonzalez6331 День тому

      @@casperthegm741 That's a really good question. I don't know.

    • @devonelzy4196
      @devonelzy4196 12 годин тому +1

      This is a good point

    • @Diddyparty_6
      @Diddyparty_6 6 годин тому

      I didn't understand tbf

  • @JR-gh8lp
    @JR-gh8lp 2 дні тому +16

    NOT 1980's... 1950's.

  • @hatintheswaghuh
    @hatintheswaghuh 2 дні тому +18

    Just now realized that monster smacked the HELLLL out of the paster lol

    • @QLivin
      @QLivin 2 дні тому +2

      I always wondered what was the motive for that. They never move that fast.

    • @gonz702
      @gonz702 День тому

      @@QLivin they wanted him dead and not on that voyage with boyd sara

  • @david84ss
    @david84ss 2 дні тому +100

    This entire show is an experiment. They are trying to see how long they can drag fans along without giving any good answers, and laugh at all the wild theories put out online

    • @melterrell5724
      @melterrell5724 2 дні тому +10

      A very ancient tribe did a ritual and sacrificed their children so they can live forever so now their souls are being reincarnated over and over again. The name of the tribe is what the kids are saying over and over again ankuwe. Jade and Tabitha were originally together in the ancient tribe and sacrifice their son. Oh and Fatima's "baby is the Smiley monster that Boyd kill coming back to life.

    • @RobertDiaz-p1e
      @RobertDiaz-p1e 2 дні тому

      Thaaaank u … they tricked everyone (really good trick btw) into thinking the show was good by releasing those first few min wit grandma attacking little girl and mom n letting us know h get stuck there the town loops😂😂😭😭

    • @duncanpackham5330
      @duncanpackham5330 День тому

      ​@@melterrell5724gotta spoon feed people info so they can understand whats going on instead of using their brains

    • @BratzWorld97
      @BratzWorld97 День тому

      Im really starting to believe this 😂🙄 Im so disappointed with this show & am about to give up on it

    • @willthorson4543
      @willthorson4543 20 годин тому

      ​@@BratzWorld97the patience of a gnat. Sorry it doesn't give you answers that you want. That's is what makes a good show. Go watch cartoons if this is too much for you

  • @maria-theodorakesoglou7184
    @maria-theodorakesoglou7184 День тому +7

    The first season was sooo horrifying, I miss the atmosphere of the haunted isolated town and the mystery curling around the nocturnal residents. Now they re not that scary😢

  • @wprobe
    @wprobe 2 дні тому +9

    What happened to Boyds plan to catch a monster at the begining of season 3?

    • @saqibkhan5473
      @saqibkhan5473 День тому

      Theres one in fatimas tummy, aka smiley 2.0

    • @GrimmShadowsII
      @GrimmShadowsII День тому +1

      My best guess is he got distracted by the stuff going on with Fatima. Although Donna tried to talk him out of it if I remember correctly so maybe he listened or a combination of the 2.

    • @GrimmShadowsII
      @GrimmShadowsII День тому

      @saqibkhan5473 There's definitely something there and not a hysterical pregnancy, knowing this show, and it definitely has some connection to the town not to the people whether it's Smiley's return or something else I could see it going either way

  • @JaRonFit
    @JaRonFit День тому +3

    Ask yourself this question.....what happened to the snow......one episode while town covered in snow.....then all of a sudden no snow 😮

    • @kathleenhuddleston4954
      @kathleenhuddleston4954 День тому +2

      I was wondering the exact same thing.

    • @willthorson4543
      @willthorson4543 20 годин тому

      It melted. Lol.

    • @JaRonFit
      @JaRonFit 8 годин тому

      @@kathleenhuddleston4954 it's like it was defcon 4 no food and winter is coming.....then all of a sudden nothing....

    • @JaRonFit
      @JaRonFit 8 годин тому

      @@willthorson4543 ya don't say smh

  • @wesamazori5210
    @wesamazori5210 2 дні тому +7

    My question which I’ve been looking to see anyone is asking…the theory that this is all a dream. When Julie goes to the ruins and starts having a seizure but is in the dungeon and talks to Martin and gives Boyd the rope. We say it’s time travel or a vortex. But in reality she’s right there next to Ethan, so was she having a dream? Because if she disappeared from Ethan’s side then yes time travel/time paradox. She didn’t disappear, technically it was a dream…so what is everything is everyone’s dream or consciousness lost

    • @Oddy91
      @Oddy91 День тому +2

      Or only her consciousness went through time. More like astral projection

    • @GrimmShadowsII
      @GrimmShadowsII День тому +1

      @wesamazori5210 Reminds me one of the endings of one of the twisted metal games, 2 I think. After one of the characters wins he wakes up in the hospital to see the other contestants in the other beds and finds out they were all in a giant car accident. I suppose it could be something like that although I'm not sure that would fit with people showing up at different times.

    • @letsrock12345
      @letsrock12345 10 годин тому

      ​@GrimmShadowsII they are all in a VR escape room based on the software from Jades company. Jade himself is an AI that doesn't know he is AI.
      That's why there are so many background npc characters in the show that just wonder around aimlessly with no really point or contributions

    • @Diddyparty_6
      @Diddyparty_6 6 годин тому +2

      Maybe there's an alternate universe for specific people in the town that got affected there before. Maybe that universe is mentally and not physically

  • @travishouston130
    @travishouston130 День тому +6

    How weird would it be if Victor was a patient at some mental hospital and Boyd was his a doctor and Tabatha was his nurse. The others would be other patients with family visitors

    • @Pbrady711
      @Pbrady711 День тому +4

      Sounds really corny to be honest, glad that’s not the story

    • @tripvic7629
      @tripvic7629 День тому +1

      Shit theory. No offense brother

  • @Jeremycook_
    @Jeremycook_ 2 дні тому +10

    Man how long ago do you think the 80s were lol. Those people were dressed in 50s or 60s get ups.

    • @jeriamato08
      @jeriamato08 День тому +2

      Exactly the only people dress from the 80s were victor as a boy and those with him who died the monsters are dressed like 50s -60s

    • @kane88-e5m
      @kane88-e5m 3 години тому

      The diner looks like from the 50s

  • @CaptShriver
    @CaptShriver 2 дні тому +9

    Where are the organs? These monsters seem to be ripping out of these humans. Are they eating them? We've never seen it. Where do they go? Will wear the organs are after a kill ever be explained?

    • @metalsadman
      @metalsadman 2 дні тому +2

      They eat them like what fatima did

  • @weaponXwing
    @weaponXwing 2 дні тому +6

    have you noticed that the power cables and the sign change when the RV passes train tracks 2nd time?....

  • @CaptShriver
    @CaptShriver 2 дні тому +17

    I love Jim's character. The internet seems to hate him. They think he's a bad dad. I don't think he's a bad dad. Any of us dropped in the circumstances of the reality of fromville nobody really truly knows how they would act in that circumstance. Jim's a great character. I like him and maybe he is right except for are these nightmare monsters a military experiment for some kind of undead super soldiers. So his theory about this being an experiment as an experiment it is way way out there

    • @Johnny_Dregs
      @Johnny_Dregs 2 дні тому +3

      I feel like S3E9 was setting him up as a farewell. I would not be surprised if he offed next week.

    • @willthorson4543
      @willthorson4543 20 годин тому

      He is just super bitchy and whines all the time.

  • @heathertaylor8904
    @heathertaylor8904 День тому +1

    I think it's erroneous not to take into account that this is, after all, a show by the people who made Lost. In the end, it was about the battle between good and evil. I do have reason to believe it's holding some aspect of the seelie and unseelie courts in the world of the fae. Not my theory at first, but as I learn more about this theory others have floated, it makes a lot more sense.

  • @travelinlight1141
    @travelinlight1141 2 дні тому +2

    Yeah I buy that completely. It's like an mixture of choose your own adventure meets sick experiment. Only difference is you can't cheat by looking at the next pages...or can you?

  • @PsychoMantis308
    @PsychoMantis308 День тому +1

    Its cursed by what the people did to the children. I think they sacraficed the children to gain eternal life (in the form of reincarnation)

  • @karronmoffett4979
    @karronmoffett4979 2 дні тому +5

    Not the 1980s they look more like the 1950s or 1960s

  • @captcardwell3398
    @captcardwell3398 2 дні тому +4

    You gotta post these before new episodes drop. You mentioned a bunch that the new episode covers

  • @sarahhayyyy94
    @sarahhayyyy94 День тому +1

    Great video Just one thing. The monsters look like they were stuck in the ‘50s or ‘60s. But the ‘80s?? Guess you’re too young to remember the ‘80s.

  • @justinmanser7525
    @justinmanser7525 2 дні тому +1

    Is it a hypercube style dimension? The Cube film trilogy explains a lot, in particular how human minds would be confused by exposure to such things.

  • @HotBoiiSlime
    @HotBoiiSlime День тому

    I I think more than likely that Tree is either a metaphor or an actuality the tree of life or some type of other mythology mythology connecting to life and death, and holding the souls of the dead and the souls of the living within it, binding them to the town

  • @dayvin408
    @dayvin408 2 дні тому +2

    If anyone made this place, it wasn't Victor it was surely Jade. The clues are there in the bery first episode

    • @GrimmShadowsII
      @GrimmShadowsII День тому +2

      @dayvin408 I don't think he made it but I wouldn't be surprised if the company he sold shortly before he arrived, or the person or company he sold it too, has something to do with it or atleast knows about it.

    • @dayvin408
      @dayvin408 День тому

      @@GrimmShadowsII That'd make sense.

  • @JaRonFit
    @JaRonFit День тому

    Every single person in the town is a variation of the original towns people or related.......for example the black lady that runs the dinnner now....Elllis....Elgin....Boyd are either all related or multiple versions of Boyd........Boyd gave us a clue when he described the 🪱 🪱 worms...if you cut one worm it grows into two worms.......we already know Julie was in three places at one time........when Boyd was trapped in the well Julie was in the town.....inside the dungeon with Martin and Boyd......and on the ground having a seizure in the present...........at night the monsters dont sleep the actually are doing the astral projection thing Julie does

  • @CaptShriver
    @CaptShriver 2 дні тому +6

    This shows title FROM simply means there are people FROM all over the United States being sucked into this place somehow. Sometimes the simplest answer is the right answer

    • @JNR22B
      @JNR22B День тому

      In Brazil it’s called Origin apparently

    • @PiyeFUNKOT
      @PiyeFUNKOT День тому +2

      I think FROM and LOST are connected, it's gonna form a sentence LOST FROM and for the third word we have to wait for another show to see the message

    • @ZaMorant1733
      @ZaMorant1733 День тому

      @@PiyeFUNKOTwhat would make them connected tho ? I love lost lol

  • @jaysonmnguni5718
    @jaysonmnguni5718 2 дні тому +3

    I like Jim, don't care for the opinions of the internet.

  • @coryryder9070
    @coryryder9070 2 дні тому +3

    no real story of philly project was invisibility and it teleported place to place not time traveled

  • @jeriamato08
    @jeriamato08 День тому +3

    They look like the 1950s not the 80s

  • @davidagiel8130
    @davidagiel8130 День тому +1

    From is a place designed just to see how they would react. Because the characters are the archetypes of the collective unconscious and they are performing on the stage known as the Big Other. From is your subconscious mind, not Victor's, because we all have these archetypes and the shadow self.

  • @JaRonFit
    @JaRonFit День тому

    Julie didn't time travel......it's like Dr Manhattan doesn't time travel....Dr Manhattan perceives time all at once....past present and future.....also the monsters are not sleeping during the day.....during the day they are doing what Julie does if you want to call it astral projection..

  • @heathersteel9767
    @heathersteel9767 2 дні тому +1

    We all just find out they're in a mmorpg VR nightmare that Jade created and he was thrown into so the military could take his work and use it later. Meanwhile the vr game crosses an AI barrier that takes on a life of its own. Victor being an NPC created by his "father"s choices in a game he picked up in beta to mourn the loss of his wife and kids that also becomes game cannon due to the AI.

  • @lordteabelly
    @lordteabelly 2 дні тому +3

    monsters stuck in the 1980s?? 😅😅 they aint dressed in 1980s garb i can tell you lol

    • @BileDuctBalderdash
      @BileDuctBalderdash 18 годин тому

      I know right where are all the jean jackets that was a huge thing in the late eighties

  • @clashr2719
    @clashr2719 2 дні тому +1

    I do love this show but the more i watch the more i think irl people would do a much better job of figuring stuff out. We have had 3 seasons and no ones made a trap for the monsters or even tried throwing a Molotov

  • @HotBoiiSlime
    @HotBoiiSlime День тому

    I don’t think Julie time traveled. I think she always was in that place in time. I think that event just allowed her to see that because if she time traveled, I feel like it’s not plausible because it takes away free to be present.

  • @MarkGamble52
    @MarkGamble52 18 годин тому +1

    Nah, this ain't it Chief...

  • @moretune9759
    @moretune9759 День тому

    This whole show is that one social experiment from Community and we are all Abed

  • @emiliomanueldepedro9650
    @emiliomanueldepedro9650 2 дні тому +2

    Whoever wants videos exploring Rock & Rule, Fantastic Planet, and Time Masters, leave a like on this comment.

  • @coryryder9070
    @coryryder9070 2 дні тому +1

    i barely watched the show and it just reminded me of the beach movie but done better if you know that ending i think from will be similar

  • @coryryder9070
    @coryryder9070 2 дні тому +2

    lol i got through 1st ep then just watched some recaps got gest of it

  • @stefanvasov3843
    @stefanvasov3843 2 дні тому +7

    Best theory is that kids wanna be saved and they drag people in that place. Experimenting for no reason is a such a cliche and a stupid end of this questions.

    • @melterrell5724
      @melterrell5724 2 дні тому

      If you wanna know spoilers ask me but I will let you know your theory is wrong

    • @pandalyn2267
      @pandalyn2267 2 дні тому

      Kids wanting to be saved is boring and cliché.

    • @stefanvasov3843
      @stefanvasov3843 День тому

      @@pandalyn2267 in which show you saw that, i can name countless shows where someone made experiment

  • @4isalot
    @4isalot 2 дні тому +1

    Stuck in the 1980s??? They are dressed in 1950s or 60s clothing.

  • @tonip2979
    @tonip2979 2 дні тому

    I thought the same thing as Jim Mathews that the town was a Experiment. Turns out that Theory wasn't correct. Roku has it listed as a SURVIVAL ODYSSEY.
    So the big question is who is behind the Survival Game?

  • @mrnobody043
    @mrnobody043 2 дні тому

    Maybe the key is just to go over the tree instead of turning around.. but you'd have to get out of the car for that.. Or move the tree.. It'd be wild if this turns out to be some version of "The matrix"... where these people are hooked up to a machine and this is just all a simulation.

  • @Tina_GenX
    @Tina_GenX День тому

    LOL! Stuck in the 80s?? Try 50s/60s. The whole town's style and the monsters are a snapshot of small town America in the 50s/60s.

  • @tekservices8699
    @tekservices8699 День тому

    Or maybe due to a lack of ideas in recent years, this whole show is meant to be an idea grabbing social youtube experiment. To find the best ideas for new shows and movies,...... "From" the people!
    Haha this would really piss me off!

  • @coryryder9070
    @coryryder9070 2 дні тому +1

    the electricity is laylines area probley

  • @DappsTheProducer
    @DappsTheProducer 2 дні тому

    We cant be sure radio waves can leave the town. Cause who answred, was the town

  • @CaptShriver
    @CaptShriver 2 дні тому +3

    I want to see an episode or two where it's not the main cast of the show but a secondary cast since we have all these extra people in the fromville let's get an episode of them. Just them. No main characters, no Boyd no nobody we know from the main cast

  • @michaelanderson3601
    @michaelanderson3601 День тому

    Smiley ran to get Victor's mom.A slight jog dive I guess

    • @Diddyparty_6
      @Diddyparty_6 6 годин тому

      RIGHT? I got so confused likee

  • @tena2sweet
    @tena2sweet 2 дні тому

    Well if this is a Twilight zone esq thing then...
    Do you remember the episode with the kid who could send people to the cornfield? What if this is the cornfield 🤷🏻‍♀️ just a thought 😁

  • @vagibont1986
    @vagibont1986 День тому

    Bro what if the kid in the white was holding the other kids hostage ask your self why dont you ever seen him with any of the other kids

  • @kzpm9796
    @kzpm9796 2 дні тому

    Jim was right. Love him but he is doomed 😅

  • @richardjamesgallardojr.7584
    @richardjamesgallardojr.7584 2 дні тому +1

    I'm going to come out with a horror movie franchise called oyster face😂 it's about a monster slasher who drowned in a vat of cottonseed oil😂 the sequel will be called cotton seeds revenge😂 can someone help me come up with a backstory for this dude😂😂😂

  • @NGC0Music
    @NGC0Music День тому

    Well, I thought about that way early in the season, so I hope Jim is wrong

  • @scratchnoff7602
    @scratchnoff7602 2 дні тому +1

    Hope itz connect to lost lol

  • @anthonytyson7639
    @anthonytyson7639 День тому

    This is such a LOOONG drawn out series/ story, I'm wondering if the writers have any idea of how to finally end this 🤔?

  • @yusavelli0448
    @yusavelli0448 День тому

    victor created this place😭heard some bad theories man

  • @melterrell5724
    @melterrell5724 2 дні тому

    If you want spoilers just ask me

  • @trem5174
    @trem5174 2 дні тому

    Yep. One big experiment to me.

  • @criticalthot4179
    @criticalthot4179 2 дні тому

    They are Archons from esoteric religions an the Bible Archons feed off the negative energy and the traumatized peoples fear, Archons are real in the world our world,

  • @JNR22B
    @JNR22B День тому

    What if the Monsters are the children

    • @Diddyparty_6
      @Diddyparty_6 5 годин тому

      They helped tabitha so ghey might be on the good side.

  • @BigDavos
    @BigDavos 17 годин тому

    I give up at this point

  • @Ash.Crow.Goddess
    @Ash.Crow.Goddess 2 дні тому

    Why do you so confidently say that the genre is science fiction? Did the creators say that for sure, somewhere?

  • @kujo4388
    @kujo4388 2 дні тому +4

    These are some really weak theories

  • @bartosz9144
    @bartosz9144 День тому

    What if Boyd wife was right when they die they wake up

  • @lynbautista6341
    @lynbautista6341 День тому

    S1 and S2 is ok but the S3 it's kind boring and doesn't make sense. Their dialogs like the cursing part is out of timeng. I can't bear to watch the succeeding episodes

  • @SuDoVVooD0
    @SuDoVVooD0 День тому

    Сериал про сон собаки, у которой был хозяин Виктор

  • @scratchnoff7602
    @scratchnoff7602 2 дні тому

    Dome

  • @differentmoves
    @differentmoves 2 дні тому +1

    Simulation theory would be the only scifi theory that would make sense to me. I think outside of that, I think it must be a supernatural setting. Magic, curses, ghosts, lovecraft horror etc.

  • @s.devries4349
    @s.devries4349 2 дні тому

    what...