Protestant Looks Into Catholicism: One Year Later
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 чер 2024
- This video will be released exactly one year after the release of my video touring St. John Cantius, which not only changed the trajectory of my UA-cam channel, but led me down a path of investigating the claims of Catholicism. This journey has put me in touch with some of the brightest Catholic apologists of our time, caused me to read some incredible books, and perhaps best of all it has allowed me to forge friendships with some wonderful people. After a year of thinking, praying, and wrestling, I find myself faced with some of the questions I was asking early on, albeit with greater clarity on the arguments from all sides. I'm not at a point of reaching conclusions, but I wanted to share an update with you all as you all have played such a large part in this journey. Thank you all for the love and support every step of the way.
Support Gospel Simplicity:
Patreon: / gospelsimplicity
One Time Donation: www.paypal.me/gospelsimplicity
Merch: gospelsimplicity.creator-spring.com
Austin and Eliza's Wedding Registry:
www.zola.com/registry/elizaand...
We in no way expect you all to get us anything, but the generosity of this community always exceeds my expectations, so if you'd like to support us as we start our life together, you're welcome to look at this list.
Follow Gospel Simplicity on Social Media:
Facebook: / gospelsimplicity
Instagram: / gospelsimplicity
Twitter: / gsplsimplicity
About Gospel Simplicity:
Gospel Simplicity began as a UA-cam channel in a Moody Bible Institute dorm. It was born out of the central conviction that the gospel is really good news, and I wanted to share that with as many people as possible. The channel has grown and changed over time, but that central conviction has never changed. Today, we make content around biblical and theological topics, often interacting with people from across the Christian tradition with the hope of seeking greater unity and introducing people to the beautiful simplicity and transformative power of the gospel, the good news about Jesus.
About the host:
Hey! My name is Austin, and I'm a 22 year old guy who’s passionate about the beautiful simplicity and transformative power of the gospel. I believe that the gospel, the good news about Jesus, is really good news, and I’m out to explore, unpack, and share that good news with as many people as possible. I'm a full blown Bible and Church History nerd that loves getting to dialogue with others about this, learning as much as I can, and then teaching whatever I can. I grew up around Frederick, MD where I eventually ended up working my first job at a church. They made the mistake of letting me try my hand at teaching, and instantly I fell in love. That set me on a path for further education, and I'm currently a student at Moody Bible Institute in Chicago, IL, studying theology. On any given day you can find me with my nose in a book or a guitar in my hands. Want to get to know me more? Follow me and say hi on Instagram at: @austin.suggs
Video Stuff:
Camera: Sony a6300
Lens: Sigma 16mm F1.4 amzn.to/2MjssPB
Edited in FCPX
Music:
Bowmans Root - Isaac Joel
Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction
04:58 - Things I Appreciate
10:08 - Continuing Objections
14:40 - Complicating Factors
*Links in the description may include affiliate links in which I receive a small commission of any purchases you make using that link. - Розваги
Hey everyone! I wanted to add a few thoughts here in the comments. First, thanks to all of you who have been so kind and supportive throughout this journey. The journey of investigation is by no means over. Rather, when I realized it had been a year since my tour at St. John Cantius, I thought it would be a fitting time for reflection. That is the occasion of this video, not any grand announcements. Second, there will be two more videos in this series. Next, I will make a video on one year of looking into Orthodox. That will be followed by a video on why I'm a Protestant. None of these will be conclusive. Rather, they're a glimpse into my thought process. Finally, I'd like to add that this is a very imperfect video. I have so many more thoughts than I could fit into this video. It is incomplete in both its appreciations and concerns. However, it was a video I knew I could record dozens of times and still not be happy with. In the end I decided to just upload it as it came out on the first take. Thanks in advance for your grace and kindness. With much love, Austin.
That all sounds exactly as it should be. I'd love you or anyone to give me all the answers but since that's impossible, the reflections of a wise and humble man are extremely valuable. I look forward to all these videos. God bless.
I don't think Moody would expel you for becoming Catholic would they? At least they claim to accept students from different faith traditions on their website.
Perhaps you should look more on what you can offer to our Lord rather than what can gratify yourself. I do not mean that in an uncharitable way. That is what I do when I go to Mass. As the Eucharist really meant Thanksgiving. God bless!
@@annaskele628 Even if they would, imagine rejecting known truth because you're afraid of...getting expelled from your useless humanities program? The martyrs got fed to lions.
Outside of the Catholic Church there is no salvation.
Bueno que tenga ese afan de la investigacion
We love you brother! Keep up what you are doing. We are all still "looking into Catholicism" no matter how long we have been Catholic. It's one of the best parts about it.
As a 38 year old life long Protestant I too have literally just started this journey. With great fear may I add! 😬
@@HosannaSounds “Be not afraid.”
@@HosannaSounds well here is a nice roadmap ( I disagree with this denomination in two key points so please do not think I am trying to promote them , but the work they put into this documentary and it's accuracy makes it worth looking at) may the Holy Spirit lead you
ua-cam.com/video/_DrJ8_i7giU/v-deo.html
@@travelsouthafrica5048 thankyou my friend
@@HosannaSounds if you find that too long and tedious you might find this more bearable although just as thorough
ua-cam.com/video/XmbSYq7WKDc/v-deo.html
Austin, I'm a young Catholic priest and I greatly admire your intellectual honesty. It's incredible to see how self-aware you are regarding how things around you may influence you, and how you are striving to remain in a pursuit of the Lord that is honest and true. Prayers for you, man. May the Lord bless you abundantly.
Thank you so much Father for answering the call to priesthood. We laity are so infinitely grateful. May God bless you. 🙏
Go get married, as bible teaches, tell people to stop praying rosary to lady Carmel to get souls out of purgatory that’s unbiblical
@@albusai where does your authority on interpreting scripture come from? I'll wait
Enrique Sada .. Are there any Priest in the New Testament?
@@zpacleb see what Jesus says about this supposed 'authority' in Matt 20:25-26.
His Word is for all Christians - no group has the monopoly on It.
how about showing where you believe this counterfeit 'church' has supposed 'authority' - i will wait.....
As a Catholic, I have great respect for your honest intellectual pursuit of theological truth.
I’m in the same boat. It started with “WHY do they [catholics] believe what they believe?” Now I’m on this obsessive rabbit trail, looking up answers to questions, realizing that a lot of it actually makes sense, but still having questions, etc. Praying for us who are seeking answers 🙏
Same
Good for you and those like you who are not content with isolating their ideas from criticism and ignoring the points made by others.
I pray that social pressure does not inhibit you from becoming Catholic, but also, if the hurdle is internal belief, I pray that you face every argument for how to properly worship Jesus head on, so that you will come out of the other end standing spiritually on a firm rock. Godspeed.
I recommend joining the local catholic parishes RCIA and ask your questions
I was raised Catholic. Married young, divorced young. In midlife (early 40's) went non-denominational. I saw most of the questions other Christian denominations have. This video touches on
John 6:53 Jesus says "Unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His Blood you shall not have life within you"
Then at the last supper. Jesus says "This is My Body" - "This is the cup of my blood" - "Do this (the Eucharist) in memory of Me".
Then there Paul's teachings about it in 1rst Corinthians chapter 11 Where he speaks about "Sick and infirm and some died" receiving in an unworthy manner, thus bringing condemnation upon themselves for "not discerning the Lord's body".
Then there is Hebrews 5 :4 "Speaking on the Priesthood of Aaron. "No man takes this authority unto himself but only as called by God as Aaron was"
Then on Confession Read John 20 verses 19 Through 23.
There is much more. If you're interested go to the St Helena Catholic Church website on UA-cam.
Search for Fr Mark Beard videos.
He passed away August 2nd due to a car accident. But his homilies are very educational.
On Purgatory read Matthew 18 verses 19 Through 35. But pay particular attention to verse 34 and 35 and know that it is Jesus saying it.
As well there is 1 Peter 3 : 18, 19, + 20.
And 1 Peter 4 : 6
But again really try and process John 6 : 53. Jesus words not mine
We know every word of God is true. Jesus is not a liar.
The Bible says "There is One Lord, One Faith, and One Baptism".
Then the is the words of Jesus to Peter.
"Thou art Peter and upon this rock I will build my church," (note church being singular)
But do check out Fr Mark Beard's Homilies on St Helena Catholic Church website. He dives into why we do what we do.
Also if your interested another priest you might want to look into is Fr Chad Ripperger. He is as guest on a podcast hosted by 'Chris Stefanick'.. Fr Ripperger is an Exorcist Priest.
But look up podcast titled
Q + A with an Exorcist Part 1
(There are parts 2,3, 4, 5, and 6 as well.)
Fr Chad relates his communications with the demons in those who are possessed.
I know it can be a scary topic. But I learned so much from his talks.
As a life long (for the most part,) Catholic, Listening to what he learned from the demons in those exorcisms helped me to understand Mary's place in our spiritual lives
The demons hate her,. But truly informative stuff.
Also Fr Ripperger has a three Audio Series talk on "Generational Spirits" Also on UA-cam.
The Bible tells us "He will strike at your heel. And you will strike at his head".
The devil's had full knowledge and understanding of all that would come to be. In Short they knew that one day Jesus would become a man, and Mary would become His mother. But the demons refused to bend a knee to Jesus and Mary Both. Thus they said we will rule in hell rather than serve in heaven. Why? Simply because they were more glorious than any human. They are more powerful than any human. But God's plan was known to them. We have the luxury of having been born ignorant of the bigger picture.
The fallen angels had one chance because they had full knowledge of things. Luckily for us we don't, thus God's mercy for us is not a one shot deal.
I'm a nobody. Just a Catholic who has searched for the Truth. Hopefully these things help you sort it out
God bless
@@R_manatee That is not really the best way to answer everyday questions. RCIA is for those who are actually in the process of formally converting. It is for those with the intention of joining.
It would not be fair to anyone involved. Those who are joining deserve to have fellow catechumens in class. Having the instructors diverted from the purpose of guiding catechumens would not be fair. It would not be fair to have someone who isn't trying to join be exploring his questions in the incorrect format.
I'm a convert from Protestantism to Catholicism. I cannot imagine wrestling with the complexities of conversion with an audience following me! It's a huge cultural and theological shift and then there's the dynamics of friendships and family relationships. In the end, there came to be a point where I couldn't not be Catholic (if that makes sense). Jesus called me in the Eucharist and there was no denying him. If you are called to a conversion to Catholicism, it will be hard to ignore it. So there is really no need to add pressure to it. Congratulations on your wedding! Look forward to more videos when you have time!
Couldn't not be*
@Eucharist Angel It is his story. You may not like it but you have no need to ridicule his journey. Jesus in the Eucharist does speak to people, I know, as I and others have experienced this. God bless you.
@@samuelflippin1890 thanks. That was a critical typo!
Welcome home
@Eucharist Angel Ignore EA….he is a raving antiCatholic
My spiritual journey was: southern baptist, agnostic, atheist, Buddhist, new ager, non denominational Christian, then Catholic. Finally made it home haha
Now that was a WALK, friend! As a cradle Catholic, I appreciate your journey. :)
What a journey it has been. God bless you!
Welcome home, brother.
You never did read the Bible , you would never think praying rosary 📿 to lady Carmel will get souls out of purgatory
Welcome home, my brother.
I was raised Baptist. Starting reading history and that began my journey. Now go to Latin Mass every Sunday. Such a privilege to have found it
I too attend the Tridentine Mass, but my journey in life took me from being a "Heathen" with no direction through Protestantism and ultimately to the Catholic Church. Most memorable part of my journey through the "Brethren In Christ" and the Espiscopal organizations. I am very thankful for this journey as well as being critical of it. My journey is similar but a very lite version of Father Donald Callaway's journey. I will always be a catechumen as I learn more about my faith. Coming from Protestantism our Immaculate Mother was an issue at first but over time seemed to diminished. It was once said, "God gave His Son his Divinity and His Mother gave Him His humanity". Pax tecum
I watched and listened to 2017 Easter mass in latin and noticed how they revere Lucifer.
@@justinamusyoka4986 I assume you're talking about the Exsultet. Which is a proclamation of the Lord Jesus Christ's resurrection.
Lucifer is a Latin word which translates to Morning Star. Jesus is the morning star, Revelation 22:16.
The ending of the Exsultet:
"May this flame be found still burning
by the Morning Star:
the one Morning Star who never sets,
Christ your Son,
who, coming back from death's domain,
has shed his peaceful light on humanity,
and lives and reigns for ever and ever."
Hope that cleared any misunderstanding you had about the Catholic Church and the Exsultet. God bless!
@@davidcarey7396 So Lucifer is Jesus christ? Just asking.
@@justinamusyoka4986 Depends on how you're using the word Lucifer, if you mean Lucifer as in the Morning Star/Light bringer then yes, Jesus is the Lucifer (Revelation 22:16). However, if you're using Lucifer as the colloquial term to mean Satan then no of course Jesus is not Satan.
Thank you for your honesty Austin! The first year or two after I became Catholic I often fell into the trap of thinking that it was simply a matter of people hearing/reading the right thing or finding out what the Church actually teaches (and what she is). But thankfully I have realised that conversion as well as faith is always a gift from God. I can maybe help people by rooting out misconceptions, and more importanly by living my life as a joyful witness to Christ, but at the end of the day we have to let the Holy Spirit work in the hearts of all of us and be obedient and attentive to him whereever we are at.
Grateful for this perspective
You hit in the nail ,you can learn so much , but at end of day faith is a gift and Holy spirit is the one who should guide you into truth if your honestly looking for truth.
Luke 11: 9,10
9 “So I say to you: Ask and it will be given to you; seek and you will find; knock and the door will be opened to you. 10 For everyone who asks receives; the one who seeks finds; and to the one who knocks, the door will be opened.
John16,13-15
13 But when he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all the truth. He will not speak on his own; he will speak only what he hears, and he will tell you what is yet to come. 14. He will glorify me because it is from me that he will receive what he will make known to you.
15 All that belongs to the Father is mine. That is why I said the Spirit will receive from me what he will make known to you.”
Amen
@@GospelSimplicity I don't think the calling for you is conversion. There's already enough people on the internet trying to *force* their denomination down your throat.
But since you're soft-spoken and have diplomatic skills, you would be good at *inter-faith* dialogue : bringing some catholic qualities to the protestant world, and some protestant objections to the catholic world (for instance, I think polls have shown that already more than half of Catholics think the Eucharist is actually symbolic, ..)
Also, didn't Christ mention he wanted a *united* Church ? Well, that might be your burden, who knows. 🙂
As a Catholic, I respect your decision friend, I'd still say that this is a step forward in bringing the division to unity and understanding. To GOD be the Glory!
ua-cam.com/video/20eJOl9mMFc/v-deo.html
Yes we need this division with each other to at least be peaceful and find ways to come together. Amen! 🕊
Amen
Yesss
THE TEACHINGS OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH ARE NOT IN THE BIBLE !!!!!!
Respect for you, brother. Rarely do I encounter a Protestant with an open mind like yours and who doesn’t attack Catholicism.
I’m a cradle Catholic who only just began going deeper in my faith. Not for anything but I just want to share that the conversion story of Scott Hahn has inspired me a lot in my faith journey. It’s amazing how it took a convert like him to make me appreciate the Catholic faith like never before.
Anyway, I’m glad I came across your videos. God bless you!
Scott Hahn's story was a big part of my epiphany also. Love hearing his talks.
🙏🏼
Amen!
*R Catholicism has nothing to do with God and His Words. R Catholic Church contradicts Scriptures in every possible ways!*
1. Catholics say Mary was sinless. But BIBLE says Mary offered a sinner's offering. She was a sinner. Bible says Mary needed a Saviour. Lk 2:23-24, Lev 12:6-8, Rom 3:10.
2. Catholics say clergies must be celibate. Yet BIBLE says Peter (supposed R Church first leader) had mother in law. Bible says celibacy is not a qualification for clergies. Mat 8:14-15, Mar 1:30-31, Luk 4:38-39.
3. Catholics say Mary was forever virgin. Yet BIBLE says Jesus had brothers and sisters. Mary was not perpetually virgin. Mk 6:3, Mat 13:55, Mat 27:56, Mar 6:3, Mar 15:40, Mar 15:47.
4. Catholics say confess to R priests in a box. BIBLE says nothing about confessing to priests in a box. Bible says confess to GOD only. 1 John 1:9, Mat 6, Romans 10:9-10.
5. Catholics say drink of the physical blood of Jesus. Yet OT and NT both say do not drink blood. Acts 15, Lev 7:26.
6. Catholics say pray to passed on Mary and "saints". Yet BIBLE says do not contact the dead. NT Church did not record a single case of NT believers asking passed on saints to pray for them. Deut 18:11, Isaiah 8:19.
7. Catholics make and bow down to statues. BIBLE says do not bow down to graven images (statues). Deut 4, Exo 20:4-5.
8. Catholics sprinkles “holy water”. But NT Church of the Bible mentioned nothing about “holy water”. There was no record of any Apostles sprinkling “holy water” on believers. Catholics claimed “holy water” came from OT. Yet Num 5:17 says “holy water” was water used to test adulterous women in OT temple. Hardly the same. Those were for Old Covenant Jews. Not New Testament Christians.
9. Catholics say Peter was pope - bishop of all bishops. Yet BIBLE says Peter was just a leader of the Jerusalem Church. Bible says nothing of the office of bishop of bishops. Gal 2:9, Mat 16:18.
10. Catholics say there is a seat of Peter. Yet BIBLE says nothing about it. Jesus said “not to lord over others”.
11. Catholics has clergy priesthood. Bible says clergy priesthood was done away with in New Testament. There is no clergy priesthood in NT. Heb 7:27, 9:12, 10:10.
12. Catholics preaches Works Salvation (faith + good works + partake R sacraments + submit to R pontiff + be in R Church + devote to Mary = to be saved). Yet Bible says “believe in Jesus to be saved”. Bible says Works Salvation is cursed. Gal 1:8-9. Acts 16:30-31, John 3:16, Romans 10:9-10.
13. Catholics says they must do Penance to atone for their sins. Yet Bible says repent, confess and sins will be forgiven. Catholic Bible changes the word “repentance” in NT into “penance”. Original Greek NT does not use or mean the word penance. Penance = work to atone for sins. Repentance = change of heart. 1 John 1:9, Mat 6.
14. Catholics say Mary went straight to heaven without dying. Yet Bible says nothing about it.
15. Catholics say Islam and Christianity have the same GOD. Yet Islam doesn't believe in death and resurrection of Jesus and Trinity.
@@jediv9492you need to convert to Catholicism, really urgent....you can say whatever you want but you know you wrong
Former reformed baptist. I’m getting confirmed into the Catholic Church on April 8th!!
I was 14 when I attended my first Mass. I married a Catholic and remained Protestant until I was 36. It took the Holy Spirit a long time to work on me. But, He did and I happily joined the Church. I didn’t struggle with the Papacy. I did struggle with Mary and it took another ten years or so until I could truly recognize Mary as my spiritual mother. If you are meant to become Catholic, it will happen no matter your doubts.
Tad , it should not be that hard in understanding Blessed Mary ,. The reason it is so hard that 2 dogmas about Mary are not found in Scripture.
So they should not be dogmas , just stick to the Mary of the Gospels and not spend 1900 years like the Bishops to finally come up with a dogma of the Assumption.
@tad well said!
I think Luthor actually had quite a devotion towards Mary, but then he was in the Church so long too.
@@charles2241 yeah, he was declared heretic by the church and he was supposed to be burned alive for being heretic. But he managed to escape through the help of someone who was close to the emperor. When he was about to die, he asked his closest friends to "pray for him". Funny how he taught his followers that there's only one mediator between man and God but he managed to ask his friends to "pray for him" making them intercessors or mediators between God and him.
@@mayvelynbalo8288 Yes, that's I think a worldwide problem for the Protestants, that they can't understand praying to the saints, but then don't have a problem with living people praying for them? As I've explained it, you should be thinking the other way around, after all, aren't people in Heaven much more capable since they have God's real favor, of getting your request granted, as opposed to somebody down here whom might be sinner central?
I will say though, not completely understanding the Protestant mind, that I think I can see it from a possible angle of theirs, and that is the stranger angle. IOW, all those long dead saints, never knew you, etc. whereas people down here might pray for you (IOW, strangers (saints) wouldn't pray for you). And that makes sense to me, but the problem is as I described earlier, they draw God's favor for sure, whereas you cannot be so sure about your friends. IOW, they won the battle and are up there in Heaven, so wouldn't they have much more sway in almost all cases than somebody still down here? I realize it's not a perfect argument, but as they are so wholly into God up there, how could they turn you down? If they are with God, they will do it, but it doesn't mean God will automatically grant it of course. Sheesh, probably half of our friends would mean to pray for you, and totally forget about it, especially if it were a new thing for them to pray for you.
I think also, some people concerning that issue, think too much upon the earthly scene, and just think the dead cannot help you. And yet, there's no people more alive, and more into God, than those up there. Now I'm not sure I would pray to either of my parents, no matter how well they lived, because I really don't know if they made it up there or not, but the recognized saints, there's no doubts. I'm sure the saints often take us up as sort of their children, especially considering so many of them were religious and never had children.
As far as Marian teachings go, I think sometimes it's more important, once we've done our doctrinal homework, to just focus on the relationship. She was my biggest stumbling block but she has become such a treasure.
I have the same struggles.
What pushed me away from catholicism was that Marian worship. Yes, I know technically catholicism does not teach the worship of Mary.
But somehow, every one of the women I met all they do is tell me and each other to pray to Mary and ask her to do XYZ and that if I would put her statue in a certain place in my house and pray the Rosary in front of it then she'd do this or that for me.
So much constantly about asking Mary to do specific things. Where to put the statues or paintings for her to do more for me.
It was Never Jesus.
Then the infant of Prague. Oh man. I can't tell you how many told me in needed to have a small infant of Prague in my home and to care well for it, changing it's robes and offering special prayer , and that if I pray *specifically* to the infant then he would do XYZ. Not that Jesus would, that * the infant of Prague* would.
If I don't buy the blessed beeswax candles we will die when the prophecy of padre Pio comes true.
So, in my study I really did change my mind, and could no longer adhere to I western protestantism. I accept perpetual virginity and real presence of Christ in to he eucharist, baptismal regeneration .
It's just so bizarre to me that in all instances people are told to burry saint statues in the yard to sell their house, or dress and care for and offer personal sacrifice to the infant of Prague statue to get him to do things .
Theres more, but that's the most impressed on my mind.
We became confessional Lutheran.
The Catholic view of Mary and the communion of the Saints is a richer view of Christianity than anything found in Protestantism. Our loving Father chooses to use the Saints as intercessors for us on earth. It’s the familial view of Christianity. The Church Triumphant is not separated completely from the Church Militant. We are still one body.
@@louisacapell What you are describing is a type of superstition that some may have adopted and should not be doing. As a revert to the Catholic faith I can assure you that these things are not something the Church teaches. Go to the Catechism of the Catholic Church and you will not find any of this in there. Mary is there to lead us to Jesus not to steer us away from Him.
Have courage and find the answers your self. Do not be afraid to ask any questions, but also do not be afraid to get the correct answers and also make sure your questions are directed to orthodox sources.
Put principles and Truth above personalities.
Peace and Prayers to you in your journey.
@@louisacapell I can respect what you've shared here and I offer no judgement on your religious affiliation. But I will say that those ladies you mentioned sound a bit superstitious. Of course Catholics do believe that Mary and the saints can intercede for us but the stuff about putting images or statues in certain places and connecting that to certain outcomes seems to neglect important elements of faith and a basic understanding of grace. If I met a bunch of people like that I'd probably distance myself from them a bit. It seems like they were putting more emphasis on human effort and spiritual clutter than in simply praying in faith. Thanks for sharing Louisa.
I’m a Catholic, and in a Motorcycle Ministry. However, I might leave. Simply because every one of these bikers has a huge problem with me being Catholic (I don’t keep this secret, because I’m not ashamed of it). Most feel compelled to try to “Save Me!” It’s like when people give you advice you don’t need, and never asked for. I was an alter boy, I love the mother church, cause it’s the road I traveled that caused me to fall in love with Jesus . I’m very happy with my denomination, but born again Christians think it’s their duty to literally drag you away from Catholicism , and to save you. Oh well, all I know is I will never leave Catholicism.
I’ll pray that you do not leave. Hang in there!:)
Hang in there! Maybe you can turn the tables on them. There's a UA-cam channel called, "How to be Christian" which has excellent videos that show the errors of protestantism. Maybe that will help stop those in the group who pester you. God Bless
@@brucebarber4104 thanks for understanding. It’s really one sided. Their only interested in discussing one thing, the mistakes /false doctrine of Catholicism .
100 percent agree majority of Protestants feel it’s their duty to bring Catholics away from Catholicism
@@PC-ch1md they always act a little shocked and hurt, when I start to get frustrated, on my fifth time saying, I’m secure in my religious beliefs. They just know for a fact, that they pastors interpretation of scripture is spot on, and they are simply sharing this factual knowledge . Sometimes Christians seem to worship their pastors. 🤷🏼♂️
I was born and raised as JEHOVA WITNESS, but something amazing happened to me, i found a video of a Venezuelan apologist
priest and he flipped my world, started to research and watch all conversions stories like KEITH, DR SCOTH HANN and many others in Latin America , FERNANDO CASANOVA, JOSE PLACENCIA , I converted to catholicism this year afer easter and is one of the most beautiful things that i have experimented in my life. blessings brother
Was it Padre Luis Toro? I saw his videos and he opened my eyes to the true church of JESUS. I am a life long Catholic but I never really understood my religion. Padre Toro has changed many lives. Now I love my church more than ever.
@@marcoaguilar2394 You speak Spanish?
@@jerryaguilar3939 SI, pero no muy bien.
Indeed it was father Luis Toro, he opened my eyes and I am so happy to be at the Catholic church, blessings brother
@@jerryaguilar3939 Igualmente 👍🏼
And you still don't owe anyone anything Austin. Wherever you land throughout your lifetime, I'm sure it'll be because you had a heart for Christ and were/are searching for Truth. Take care always and God Bless your journey. From a Catholic.
It took me 38 years as a evangilical before I came into full communion with the Catholic Church at the age of 60. I am 69 now. I was very involved in ministry as a lay person. I spoke in many churches of all flavors, taught apologetics at YWAM, and tried to get the churches to work together at a city level in affect the culture. Since it took me that long, I understand that the journey is long and costly. I will leave it up to you and the Holy Spirit as to if and when you enter the Catholic Church. I hope you don't mind that I pray that you do. We need minds like yours to evangelize Catholics who do not know their faith and do not have the zeal that many Protestants have.
Amen! I truly believe that God is bringing more and more Protestants back to The Catholic Church. I spent 36 years as a Protestant Christian but the last ten was spent searching for truth. I went down many paths before unexpectedly landing in The Catholic Church! I was confirmed in to the church at the Easter vigil in 2018. I continue to learn more every day, There is so much to learn! But yes, we need the enthusiasm of The Protestants to shake us up and remind us what we have.
there i was recently thinking (i grew up Protestant) is Mary the Mother of God just enjoying her mansion as any heavenly citizen ....maybe her Son visits her once a week as a good son does????? And do I really think Fatima just somehow didn't happen??? I was reading an old book with a firsthand account of Padre Pio. I pray the Rosary daily until Covid ends and then I will talk to a priest. Thanks for commenting.
@@chu88y1 The Rosary was popularised By St Dominic in 1206 and is different to the Modern Rosary now recited with its pious additions.
Did Blessed Mary appear at Fatima and show small children a vision of Hell and scare the living daylights out of them.? Definitely not Blessed Mary of the Gospels. Test all apparitions by the teaching of Christ and see if they come from God and act on your enlightened conscience.
@peter J
I had similar thoughts about Fatima as a new Catholic convert. It just felt so harsh to me! I love Julian of Norwich and her ‘all will be well’ kind of theology 😜 so visions of hell for and brimstone didn’t sit well with me. Then I was directed to the Vatican website and read an extraordinary writing by the former Pope Benedict. His understanding of Fatima completely resonated with me and I felt at peace once again. Sometimes we take things literally ( including scripture) when in fact there is a much deeper meaning behind it.
@@jacqueline1752 Thanks Jacqueline. The visions started with an Angel that prayed with the children to Believe Adore Hope and Love the Lord and be sorrowful for those that don't. I think the children were brought a long spiritual way before the vision of hell.
Please don't take this video down. Your openness and vulnerability is amazing and resonates with many people. I didn't know about your channel until this popped up on my youtube feed, but I am going back to watch more. Thank you for all you do.
I was raised Catholic, but I was never fully awake until just last year. God has revived my heart for Him and your videos will do wonders. Thank you, Austin! May God bless you and keep you!
Me too, the lockdowns gave the time to finally focus on my faith and why I believe what I believe. It was a weird journey, I went from a casual Catholic(I held many progressive Christian views and btw, during this time, I wasn't even sure if there was a God) to Agnostic to progressive Christian(I was a progressive Catholic when I was a casual Catholic but during this time, I also no longer identified as a Catholic) to Evangelical Protestant Christian and then finally back to Catholicism and this time, I accept all the moral teachings of the Church including those VERY controversial ones such as abortion (btw, I was always against abortions after 20 weeks), artificial birth control, etc..
I benefited ALOT from this journey. Now I am well equipped to defend my beliefs, everything from God's existence to very important Catholic doctrines such as purgatory, Mariology, etc..
I also now understand the logic behind the Church's SEEM LIKE stupid teachings but actually very rational teachings such as artificial broth control, homosexual acts, etc..
Now I'm very aware of all popular arguments against Christianity among the average non Christians and answers to those arguments as well as answers(at least a good answer) to those REAL objections to Christianity
open a Bible friend, It can still cure you.
@@mathewjose4753 you stated: _'Now I am well equipped to defend my beliefs....'_ - tell me , do you not believe the Ten Commandments are part of God's Truth?
because your 'church' doesn't.
@@tony1685 @Mathew Jose you stated: 'Now I am well equipped to defend my beliefs....' - tell me , do you not believe the Ten Commandments are part of God's Truth? because your 'church' doesn't.
DM-Please elaborate. Because as I see it, the Catholic Church understands the Commandments better than anyone.
@@mdechristi paragraph 1 - _'....do you not believe the Ten Commandments are part of God's Truth?'_ - we certainly do!
now - it's True there are those who are evil in every denomination - but you won't find it taught in my church that a Command is to be broken.
however, in your 'church' there are Commandments taught directly against and it's even in your own writings? - haven't you read them?
@DM - _'...the Catholic Church understands the Commandments better than anyone.'_ - please reconcile John 14:15 with Exodus 20:8-11 then please.
if you can - you'd be better than (failures like) Steve Ray, Keith Nestor, Scott Hahn, 'father' this and 'father' than - who have all failed.
thanks in advance!
Regardless of where you're at, I want to thank you for hosting all of these interviews. As a protestant with a reformed background, there is a LOT of anxiety that has accompanied me looking into this stuff, and your channel has really helped a ton. You don't know how much of blessing you've been and will continue to be. Thank you, Austin!
I'm so glad the channel has been a blessing to you!
@Chromattic xbl
Where does your anxiety come from? I’m also Reformed, but the study of Catholicism or the early church doesn’t produce any fear in me. As the Reformers were quick to note, the church fathers, by and large, are on OUR side. At least for me, reading them does nothing but bolster my Protestant faith!
@@GospelSimplicity
Austin,
Just a brief comment.
It is exemplary to see such honest and positive discernment. It is certainly a great inspiration for many.
Regarding your vicisitudes, consider God is not distant and has chosen you to go out of your comfort zone on a journey into the "unknown", which has turned out to be perhaps more known than you realize. No need to anguish; it is part of His plan just as it was for St. Paul on the road to Damascus.
Finally, I ask you to consider we are also the Church of St. Ignatius of Antioch, St. Irenaeus of Lyon, St. Jerome, S. Augustin, St. Thomas Aquinas, St. Francis of Asisi, St. Martin de Porres, St. Rose of Lima and thousands more like them. Their common bond besides God: Their love for the Catholic Church founded by our Lord Jesus.
May God continue to bless your journey.
@@joecastillo8798 Catholicism may have come from Christianity, but it is distinctly different and unbiblical in many aspects, not the least of which is changing the Ten Commandments.
@@jordazmo19
Jordan,
Just ask yourself the following questions:
1.- What came first, the Church or the Bible?
It is obvious, the Church.
To whom did Jesus promise to be with until the end of times, the Church or the Bible?
The Church!
To whom did Jesus promised the gates of hell will not prevail against, the Church or the Bible?
The Church!
Did Jesus found His Church over man or a Bible?
Over a man name Simon whose name He changed to Kepha which in Aramaic only means Rock and which the Gospel of John transliterated as "Cephas", into Greek. It is important to note that Simon is never called "Evna" in Aramaic, a word that means pebble or small stone.
JOHN 1:42
42. He brought Simon to Jesus, who looked at him and said, “You are Simon son of John. You are to be called Cephas” (which is translated Peter).
So Jesus builds His one and only Church on Peter, just as Matthew says:
MATTHEW 16:18
18. “I also say to you that you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build My church; and the gates of Hades will not overpower it.
Jesús gave a catholic mission to His One and only Church, to go to all nations, not to the Bible but to men, promising never to abandon its members, remaining with them until the end of times in spite of any imperfections of its individual members:
MATTHEW, 28:19-20
19. Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit,
20. teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you; and lo, I am with you Always to the close of the age.
May God bless your discernment.
Austin, as a Catholic, I appreciate all your hard work. Let's trust God and may he show you the way. I will pray for you. God bless you.
Raised as a catholic that went to catholic school for over 13 years, I’m still learning about my religion. I admire your approach and the fact that you have decided to not just judge us but to learn about us and what we are all about. Thank you for showing the Catholic Church in a positive line from a Protestant point of view.
As a former Protestant who converted to Catholicism and commented on your channel before, I appreciate your honesty and openness. Whichever path you take, you will always be a Christian brother. Pray for me, that I might have greater faith. I'll pray for you too!
so you never understood what the protest was/is all about.
catholicism isn't Christianity, it's not possible.
@@tony1685I am also a former protestant who is currently converting to Roman catholic. The breaking point for me was the church history and how protestantism practises the faith right now. Where I live here in Sweden they put pride flags on our churches and talk about ”equality” in church. Which has nothing to do with Christ.
@@YellowDapTop hello YellowDapTop!
i was catholic 35 yrs, then i studied Scripture without interference. see friend, 'history' can be altered in books, but God's Word proves catholicism isn't Christianity. we see His criteria in 1 Tim 3:15 - but catholicism does *NOT* uphold His Truths (His Truth = His Word - John 17:17, His Truth = His Law / Ten Commandments - Psalm 119:142, 151).
Exodus 20:4-6, they still make and bow to idols, statues and body parts. i know, i did it!
Exodus 20:8-11, they pretend the 1st day is the LORD's day, while Scripture is crystal clear, the 7th day Sabbath is His, this can't change.
(the supposed 'change' of the Sabbath was even prophesied in Scripture - and this 'church' even *ADMITS TO DOING IT!* )
there is much, much more - praying to humans (dead, like 'Hail Mary'), pretending to literally eat Jesus, pretending another sinner can forgive your 3rd party sins, while Bible shows us that God Alone does that.
where does one go if they aren't saved?
'hell' ?
the teaching of 'hell' is the most evil, vile, God hating theology ever known to man!
it makes our Loving Creator out to be worse than a rapist, Manson, Stalin and Hitler - all rolled into one!!
if you care about Truth - about God's Word - you are encouraged to ask me anything.
*Truth invites investigation!* ~ catholicism runs from It.
thanks for reading, friend.
Wud love to know what drove your conversion
@@julzee111 it couldn't have been Scripture nor Truth - those brought me to Christianity, from catholicism.
sadly, most catholics ignore the plain Truths in God's Word.
*Happy Sabbath!!!*
i pray that church was a blessing this morning!
Has it only been a year? I have learned so much about faith and humility from you in just one year. I’m a Catholic and your journey is amazing. I’ve never seen a Protestant so open to know more about Catholicism and hope you do come into the Church.
we know a lot more about your church than you know about ours ua-cam.com/video/_DrJ8_i7giU/v-deo.html
@@travelsouthafrica5048, Walter Veith's conspiracy theories are so outlandish that even his own 7th Day Adventist cult criticizes and steers clear of him. Elias Brasil de Souza, director of the Biblical Research Institute at the General Conference of the 7th Day Adventists world headquarters authored, "Apocalyptic Fiction in Times of Covid-19" a scathing article highly critical of Veith's conspiracy theories.
@@brucebarber4104 obviously a jesuit would be critical of anyone pointing out the glaring heresy of the RCC , but scripture can still be trusted
we are Bereans we look to scripture to see who is lying to us
@@brucebarber4104 off course attacking the person instead of refuting the message is an old jesuit trick
attack this man
ua-cam.com/video/R-RinxXFkS4/v-deo.html
@@travelsouthafrica5048, it's Veith's own 7th Day Adventist peers who criticize him.🤣🤣🤣
As a former Protestant I find that I was seeking the sensational rather than the Divine! I admit that the Catholic Church could do a better job welcoming strangers, but the Church is Holy and meant for prayer and reverence, not rock shows and sensationalism. Just my opinion, God bless.
The problem is not that, but the lack of any community life, or a very lifeless one.
@Northern Wolf
That’s not true, come on do some real research!
@Northern Wolf Is bowing to a lifeless Flag also an abomination / When we sing our national anthem with gusto !
it is what the object represents or points too , is the all important thing. And never the object within itself !
@Northern Wolf
It’s showing reverence, respect and not worship. You really need to scrape the scales off your eyes about this. I didn’t mean that people didn’t bow I meant it’s not an abomination to God… please do some real research!
@Northern Wolf
You sir are a fundamentalist and I will pray for you, God bless!
Hey Austin, I never comment on anything but felt the need to express my appreciation for your channel here. Your channel started to take off around the same time I started to have my own crisis of faith about my conversion from Catholicism to Protestant Christianity. I appreciate this video in particular because I have seen many debates and read a few books from people who are settled in their convictions and you can't help but feel the urgency to be as settled as they are and have all your questions answered. I confess I have been that guy who has been blown about with every wind of doctrine - going to Anglican, Presbyterian, Baptist, and Non-denom churches; visiting Catholic masses like yourself; and meeting with priests and pastors just to talk it out. It is a difficult trial to live through and if I ever saw you irl I'd buy you a beer (or coffee), shake your hand, or something. With all the polemics and polarization in the world especially on the internet, you stand as one of the few reasonable voices out there.
God bless you, your marriage, your family, and your ministry. I stand with you in your Protestant convictions. Keep up your work! I'm sure there are many like myself who watch but remain silent though your videos are a great help.
Luke 18:9-14
Wow, thank you so much for your kind words! After checking my email, I think I'm the one that owes you a beer and a coffee! Let me know if you're ever in Baltimore :)
Beautiful words and synopsis. Both this comment and the video. Brother every thing you going thru is normal and good too but While it can also feel like a crises too sometimes. I was a pastor for decades and eventually became catholic and Orthodox. But then eventually left both. so I spent my lifetime struggling with it all too. It’s very difficult living in these times while also good because we have access and knowledge to everything now. It’s good that we question our faith and beliefs and logical thinking and reasoning and not just blindly accept everything. Plus also the sincerity to find “the truth” no matter where it leads us. But here I am as an older guy have been in many churches and decades of ministry and still struggling to understand and find where exactly this “truth” is fully found.
my husband and I (both protestant growing up) just came into the Church last year! It is a journey with bumps in the road for sure but the most amazing journey of our lives! The sacraments have been the most incredible thing, I dont know how we ever lived without Our Lord in Holy Communion & being absolved in confession!! Words cant describe the abundance of graces God pours into us through the sacraments 🙏🏼 God bless you on your journey!
I will be apart of the church on April 8th. I’m so excited to have the sacraments in my life
this 'church' isn't Christianity, Ma'am.
Bible proves it can't be.
former (35 yr) catholic, now Christian and Bible teacher.
questions welcomed and encouraged.
*Happy Sabbath!!!*
@@nathanoppy why? isn't Jesus' paying the price enough?
catholicism isn't Christianity, friend.
@@tony1685 What made you decide to leave Catholicism? If you're very bible based, why can't you at least acknowledge Catholics as fellow Christian brothers? If you spent 35 yrs being one, you should understand that there are many devout Catholics. I don't want to convert myself, but I at least recognize all that.
@@saintejeannedarc9460 hi friend, thanks for your post.
i left catholicism ultimately for a few reasons.
1 - they can't answer direct, clear and revealing Bible questions.
2 - their 'church' is so clearly described in Scripture, there's no mistaking it's apostasy.
3 - Bible says this 'church' doesn't not know God, love Christ nor walk in Truth - unambiguously this is proven.
4 - the teaching of 'hell', shows this 'church' truly hates our Creator.
5 - there is more, but this is sufficient.
yes, i do believe there are many catholics who will be in Heaven and are sincere and God loving Christians.
unfortunately, they have been brainwashed (as i was) and haven't done as 1 Thess 5:21 dictates.
while they are sincerely brothers and sisters - the system they belong to is the most demonic on earth.
*Truth invites investigation!* ~ catholicism runs from It.
i appreciate your question.
follow up questions are welcomed and encouraged.
Austin - Thank you for being vulnerable and for your honesty. Most of all, thank you for sharing your journey with us. I don't watch with the hope or expectation you will either stay Protestant or join X church. That would be a form of triumphantalism, which turns you into an object or a pawn, rather than a beloved of God. I watch to truly accompany you from afar on your journey. Blessings to you!
Let's not crucify him if he turns out to be not convinced by fill in the blank's Christian tradition. Let's be understanding and prayerful.
I doubt he will be convinced, it takes a long time for protestants to let go of their cultural traditions and biases, & even then, their whole family & community will shun them, attack them, etc. It's a big leap that many take 10years to make, Austin in 1 year with a young new wife would never make that sacrifice. Like Jesus said, “Take up your cross and follow Me” - that' not easy for most of us. He would probably follow orthodoxy if ever, at least his community won't shun or ostracize him. Still better bec it has apostolic tradition though they're not united with the Body of Christ.
Thank you
Certainly.
I’m a cradle catholic but never really learned anything about the catholic faith. I actually left the narrow road for quite some time and it wasn’t until a few years ago I came back to the Lord. I started reading Scripture and listening to sermons and homilies from various sources but it wasn’t until covid came that allowed me to delve deeper into Catholicism.
I’m currently in a Bible study at a baptist/non denominational church and the guys in my group have misconceptions about Catholicism and I can tell the strong dislike they have toward it. Would I love to convert them? Yes. But I tell myself not to worry about that but to just try to clear up any misconceptions they may have and lead them to sources that will help them understand better over time. If they convert, great. If they don’t, that’s fine too because I know they love the Lord and do the best they can.
If Austin converts, great. If he doesn’t, that’s fine too. He’s still a genuine person who loves the Lord
@@nenabunena you can say the same thing about Catholicism
They’re not willing to let go of Mary
As a Protestant, I had the same thing happen when I stumbled across Orthodoxy, especially with their Western Rite! There was really a lot of moments I wished I had never opened that box, so I'm with you. But ultimately I'm so grateful that I did. Blessings on your journey!
You are walking a spiritual path, seeking truth, seeking to draw ever closer to God, loving him and loving others as you do so ... brother, this is a wonderful thing! Just keep going 🙏 thank you for all your contributions
Thanks for the kind words!
As a passionate traditional Catholic, I have mad respect for you. I hope you have courage to just keep walking the path in your own time and in your own way. God speed! Pax tibi!
THE TEACHINGS OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH ARE NOT IN THE BIBLE !!!!!!
THE TEACHINGS OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH ARE NOT IN THE BIBLE !!!!!!
@@bwayne448 one of the teachings of the Catholic Church is that Jesus is God. if you are a protestant you believe this too. be specific. don't ramble, giving me 100s of objections you have to Church teachings, give me your biggest objection, and we can go from there. in addition, i would like to know what led to to conclude the Church is not authoritative. sending your message in all caps and twice with great urgency suggest to me that you might have been raised anti-catholic. this means you may have severely misinformed.
There is always a lack of peace in these Protestants that interact with Catholics that way. I know exactly why I am Catholic I was at atheist that converted at 19 in 1988 after encountering Christ and became Catholic. I am never leaving. Please be loving and charitable to Catholics. Attacking devout Christians is not following Jesus.
*R Catholicism has nothing to do with God and His Words. R Catholic Church contradicts Scriptures in every possible ways!*
1. Catholics say Mary was sinless. But BIBLE says Mary offered a sinner's offering. She was a sinner. Bible says Mary needed a Saviour. Lk 2:23-24, Lev 12:6-8, Rom 3:10.
2. Catholics say clergies must be celibate. Yet BIBLE says Peter (supposed R Church first leader) had mother in law. Bible says celibacy is not a qualification for clergies. Mat 8:14-15, Mar 1:30-31, Luk 4:38-39.
3. Catholics say Mary was forever virgin. Yet BIBLE says Jesus had brothers and sisters. Mary was not perpetually virgin. Mk 6:3, Mat 13:55, Mat 27:56, Mar 6:3, Mar 15:40, Mar 15:47.
4. Catholics say confess to R priests in a box. BIBLE says nothing about confessing to priests in a box. Bible says confess to GOD only. 1 John 1:9, Mat 6, Romans 10:9-10.
5. Catholics say drink of the physical blood of Jesus. Yet OT and NT both say do not drink blood. Acts 15, Lev 7:26.
6. Catholics say pray to passed on Mary and "saints". Yet BIBLE says do not contact the dead. NT Church did not record a single case of NT believers asking passed on saints to pray for them. Deut 18:11, Isaiah 8:19.
7. Catholics make and bow down to statues. BIBLE says do not bow down to graven images (statues). Deut 4, Exo 20:4-5.
8. Catholics sprinkles “holy water”. But NT Church of the Bible mentioned nothing about “holy water”. There was no record of any Apostles sprinkling “holy water” on believers. Catholics claimed “holy water” came from OT. Yet Num 5:17 says “holy water” was water used to test adulterous women in OT temple. Hardly the same. Those were for Old Covenant Jews. Not New Testament Christians.
9. Catholics say Peter was pope - bishop of all bishops. Yet BIBLE says Peter was just a leader of the Jerusalem Church. Bible says nothing of the office of bishop of bishops. Gal 2:9, Mat 16:18.
10. Catholics say there is a seat of Peter. Yet BIBLE says nothing about it. Jesus said “not to lord over others”.
11. Catholics has clergy priesthood. Bible says clergy priesthood was done away with in New Testament. There is no clergy priesthood in NT. Heb 7:27, 9:12, 10:10.
12. Catholics preaches Works Salvation (faith + good works + partake R sacraments + submit to R pontiff + be in R Church + devote to Mary = to be saved). Yet Bible says “believe in Jesus to be saved”. Bible says Works Salvation is cursed. Gal 1:8-9. Acts 16:30-31, John 3:16, Romans 10:9-10.
13. Catholics says they must do Penance to atone for their sins. Yet Bible says repent, confess and sins will be forgiven. Catholic Bible changes the word “repentance” in NT into “penance”. Original Greek NT does not use or mean the word penance. Penance = work to atone for sins. Repentance = change of heart. 1 John 1:9, Mat 6.
14. Catholics say Mary went straight to heaven without dying. Yet Bible says nothing about it.
15. Catholics say Islam and Christianity have the same GOD. Yet Islam doesn't believe in death and resurrection of Jesus and Trinity.
It’s a journey for all us. Even as cradle Catholics. Know that we only want to share our faith with you and don’t want you to feel pressured if that’s how it comes off.
If I could like this 1000 times I would. This is the heart of it; zeal for Christ and His Church, not high-fiving or grandstanding for a political cause.
That’s so cool
I was married September 20, 2003 at St John Cantius
What a grace you were given to see the church
That must have been a beautiful wedding!
I enjoy listening to your channel and listening to your positive feedback. I am a convert/revert. I reverted back 5 years ago after learning about the church fathers and becoming deeply unsatisfied with not being able to reconcile my sins in the evangelical church that I was employed at (I also attended there).
Listening to your gentle discussions gives me some hope that maybe not all Protestants have a deep hatred for Catholics. That has not been my experience but it gives me some hope.
I love listening to your struggles because they are some of the struggles I have had . Prayer for you and your journey no matter which road you choose. 🙏
Once you 'see' the eucharist, you can never ever not love him.
We shall pray for one another, despite the differences.
Dont be pressured, just ignore it, when it's time it's time, when it isnt it isnt. Let's us give it up to the lord unite with his suffering and pray.
Yes exactly its also helping many others who have same doubts... Its our human nature that keeps pressing but gods higher ways sees the greater picture...
That is so true. If it is God's Holy Will He will grant all the grace necessary. We can share the truth with Austin but we have to respect his decision and love him just the same.
Great video! I am also a lifelong Protestant and have at different times seriously considered Catholicism and Orthodoxy. All the things you mentioned as not being fully convinced of in Catholicism are exactly the same for me. Though the Orthodox Church doesn’t have the papacy and though their teachings about Mary differ somewhat from Catholicism, I’m still somewhat stuck when it comes to Mary. Though I must say that after all my studies and visits to Catholic and Orthodox parishes, I do have a greater love for Mary and much more understanding and appreciation for her singular and unique role in salvation history. As much as I have at times so wanted to throw all inhibitions to the wind and dive in to one of these ancient churches, I realize that I am Protestant to the core but with major ancient church sympathies. I’m just not sure what God wants me to do with this. But one thing I know for sure: I love my Orthodox and Catholic fellow believers! By the way, have you read anything by the Orthodox theologian, Dumitru Staniloae? Very deep (for me, anyway) but, wow!
I'm currently what would be considered protestant with catholic roots, that I left upon becoming a believer. However recently I've been attending a bible study at a syriac orthodox church and I must concur, although I disagree with a few things like the eucharist and intercession of saints/mary, I too have developed a deep sympathy towards the ancient churches
I totally understand you!!! As an ex evangelical pastor that was ONE OF THE HARDEST THINGS to change and get over. But, It finally clicked and made sense one day. But was still hard to overcome for a long time. I felt I was doing something wrong venerating her for years. It takes time.
What also did it for me was learning and knowing that the early church did this and I was tired of the corrupted man made evangelicalisms and constant changes and “non-divineness” I kept seeing more and more from them. I wanted so bad to follow what Paul and Peter followed and to know, serve and worship and experience God the way they did.
I don’t think we are the only “real Christians”mentality. But we DO have the Fullness and complete picture and divine experience.
@Kiwi Connoisseur If i do change church traditions, it will be on the basis of truth, not because one is more or less 'departed' than the other. As long as we can all acknowledge that if we keep the faith we're going to heaven
@Kiwi Connoisseur Romans 10. 9 If you declare with your mouth, “Jesus is Lord,” and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. 10 For it is with your heart that you believe and are justified, and it is with your mouth that you profess your faith and are saved.
Austin, thank you for sharing your study and exploration. I was raised mainline Protestant, married a Roman Catholic, and went through an exploration together with my husband over 40 years ago. Although I am still a Protestant, it did give me an appreciation for the roots of the faith. I have more recently been blessed by the writings of Steven Weidenkopf on the history of the Catholic Church. His book on the crusades, “The Glory of the Crusades”, is particularly enlightening. I encourage you to any number of his books.
Keep exploring, and take your time! It is awesome to hear you take this exploration seriously.
Austin, God is patient 😁 i was born and raised a Catholic and walked away. I can honestly say that since coming back into the church your videos have truly helped.
The Eucharist made me a Catholic. A good read would The Lambs Supper by Dr. Scott Hahn a Presbyterian Preacher and professor who came to Catholicism through the study of the early Church Fathers.
I also recommend "The Jewish Roots of the Eucharist" by Dr. Brant Pitre , believe me brother you will be amazed. God bless you.
HAHN gives "foolish" NEW meaning! And so does light weight PITRE! Ok?
@@Reid-yy5nw your ability to debate theology is staggering. I am so now going out join the local acme church of Bob who has yet ANOTHER protestant/reformist take on Christian theology that totally contradicts each of of the other's
@@Reid-yy5nw He came into catholicism , and enlightened so called born and bred Catholics , his own imagined version of catholicism.
Catholicism is a lived experience , not an intellectual conception of a catholicism learned from a book.
Most catholics are likened to submarines , as they only surface twice a year at Easter and Christmas.
Hahn came along and convinced some catholics , that what some once believed was true and true indeed.
What most catholics know is foolish and discarded , once again is enlivened by his own study of the early Church fathers ( who lived in a flat earth society ).
@@faolanliath6687 Genesis 1 ;31 and Chapter 6; 6-7 is a contradiction about God in the Bible; also Genesis chapter1 and 2 are completely contradictory.
There is contradictions in all theology as there are contradictions within ourselves and other human beings.
I stumbled across your channel, and I have been inspired by your humility and your honest pursuit of truth. May God bless your walk!
This is my first time on this channel and I am in awe of how truly open you are! You are an inspiration to all in our spiritual journeys.
Welcome to the channel! Thanks for the kind words. God bless!
There are so many things I appreciate about you, Austin. I appreciate your intelligence, your curiosity, your openness, your humility, your charity, and most of all your love for God. That's why I come here and you exceed my expectations every time. You've helped me to grow as a Christian and to better understand my own faith. Pretty cool when a Protestant can teach a Catholic about his own church. You're my brother in Christ, and that's all that really matters. May God continue to bless you and your ministry.
Thank you so much
I could not have said it better
L Jones, as a another Catholic who greatly admires Austin for all the reasons you stated and more, I have to insist that fellowship among Christians is not all that really matters. We're in the business of working out our salvation with fear and trembling, and we know that this depends in part on holding true beliefs about God's revelation. Since Protestants and Catholics differ extensively and fundamentally on many such beliefs, it is of paramount importance to settle them, so that believing rightly we might be saved. Hence we Catholics should care a very great deal whether or not Austin converts, precisely because ultimate spiritual destiny is at stake. The same holds in reverse of course: if Catholicism is false and Protestantism true, then we must leave the former for the latter again for the same reason.
Pluralism is the very atmosphere we breathe in today; but we know that Christ, being undivided, founded only one saving faith in a single community. We must therefore resist any tendency in Christianity that would reduce it to the lowest common denominator.
@@ClassicPhilosophyFTW Most catholics are simply submarine catholics and only surface on special occasions like getting a baby done in baptism , or in marriage or
at a funeral. Easter and Christmas are also a popular time. Most catholics today are a confused bunch on not knowing what to believe.
Most of our certainties have now gone , because science has buried religion .
@@peterj6740 I don't know that I would say what you are saying applies to "most Catholics" but it certianly aplies to some. I am not among those. I strive to live my faith daily, it's not easy. Christ never promised us that living the Christian life would be easy, but He did promise that it would be glorious. While I appreciate what Just A Thomist is saying I cannot agree with it insofar as placing limits on God's Grace. None of us have the power to do that. Whosoever will may come and salvation is not limited to one particular church, or to any church for that matter. In the end, our savation is based on Christ, not on where we worship on Sunday mornings. By the way, I am a parishoner at St. John Cantius in Chicago.
As someone in the process of changing traditions, I can't fathom how difficult that would be to do IN FRONT OF THE INTERNET. You are brave for even showing a public interest in Catholicism and Orthodoxy. It has been hugely benificial for me. I am in the process of going from protestant to Orthodox and it is not easy even though I am not making the journey on UA-cam, and do not have a spouse/fiancee to complicate things. I have a rather simple scenario, and it is still crazy complex and hard. You are a brave person, take your time to make a decision one way or the other.
Right. I imagine putting yourself out there for everyone to see and follow your journey has to come with extra baggage and pressure. Regardless of where we all are, we should strive to help Austin not by pulling him every which way, but provide him with answers and perspective to the questions he is asking, as well as offer him more though provoking questions to discern, and pray that the Holy Spirit guides him to all truth.
This was great to watch, Austin. I love how genuine you are. God bless!
I really enjoyed this video in particular. You are so honest and candid about your thoughts, feelings and experiences, I know I can relate to the entire video. You are correct, whatever happens you can’t rush it, and you will take the necessary time, steps, prayer and consideration to hopefully get some firm resolutions in your searching. I too am going through this journey and I’ve probably never been this excited and intrigued in my life for my Christian journey. It’s been so much deeper and meaningful already, than perhaps what I experienced growing up in a non-denom church. Best to you, Austin.
Austin, I’ve really enjoyed all your videos from the beginning. As a cradle Catholic, I was naturally intrigued by the first video where you visited a Catholic Bible study 📖, and toured a Catholic Church. I appreciate how open-minded you have been throughout. I will go ahead and add my two cents by saying- take a deep breath and take time to digest it all. Let the Holy Spirit guide your journey.
THE TEACHINGS OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH ARE NOT IN THE BIBLE !!!!!!
@@bwayne448 you neither know the Catechism of the Catholic Church nor the Bible. Don't let your bias and hatred keep you in the dark.
Austin,
You channel has greatly impacted my life. The dialogues you have on here are so amazing. When I first began to consider Orthodoxy, I watched you Interview Orthodox theologians and that laid the foundation of my eventual conversion. God bless you!!
Glad the channel has been impactful!
Have you considered the Bible?
Have you considered understanding what other Christians believe, including the truth of the Bible?
Love that you’re consistently examining your motives 👌🙏🏼😇
The journey for truth continues! Love your videos, thanks for everything you do.
Austin, this grandma just loves your kind and humble spirit! ❤ I really enjoy your openness to different traditions and learn so much from your channel. God bless you! ~ Catholic convert
As someone who became Catholic (a few months ago) after a lifetime (43 years) of evangelicalism (including 5 years as an Anglican), I resonate DEEPLY with what you've said here. I get it. Truly. I've been so impressed with how you've taken us on this explorative journey and I'll continue to pray for you!
(Fun note: I was on the Cordial Catholic podcast this past week and Keith and I talked about you... the questions you've asked here on your channel helped me on my own journey as well, so thank you.)
I’ve listened to you at “The Cordial Catholic” podcast! It was a great interview! Thanks! From 🇧🇷 Brazil!
Hi Austin, I have to express my deepest gratitude for what you have done, continue to do, and your goals for this channel. I believe the complications segment you brought up in this video really hits the nail on the head in a profound way. God be with you my friend!
Thanks for the kind words!
Fascinating video! I am new to your channel and your video is refreshing, warm, hopeful, and faithful...peace of Christ be with you!
Hey Austin, I loved everything you shared! As a Protestant also investigating these things for close to a year now, I really related to all that you said and find myself thinking and feeling the same things. Thank you so much for putting yourself out there like that! It’s much appreciated!
Austin, Your humility, openness, intelligence are inspiring. May God continue to bless and lead you and yours.
Thanks for sharing your story. I can’t imagine going through my spiritual journey, while also sharing it with a wealth of people online. It’s not for the faint of heart! Hearing your story is a blessing and gift to soooo many people :)
I feel you on the ‘opening a can of worms’ statement 😅 I’ve asked myself that one many times before, but in the end I wouldn’t have it any other way. I grew up non-denominational/evangelical and now I’m a catechumen at an Orthodox Church in Canada. Still wrestling with many things, but the progress happens bit by bit.
Many blessings on your spiritual journey. God works all things together for our salvation.
PS, you and Eliza will be stronger than ever in unity having wrestled these things by each other’s side. My husband and I were married for 9 months when we starting asking our questions etc. It was tough at times, but we wouldn’t have it any other way!
Glad to hear an update on your journey. But I'm really digging your new haircut!!
It’s his decision not ours people this is not a game of winning a convert between Catholicism, Protestantism and Orthodoxy nor proof of how right or smart one is by his decision nor that his decision is right or wrong. But it should be of growth learning and the search for truth. It’s been a heck of a ride and we all should have learned a lot though his journey.
So what truth we are looking for? Im a Christian and believe that the protestant church of Rome is pagan . Is that the truth?
@@kronos01ful well sorry to disappoint but you’re a Protestant. There is no such thing as “protestant church of rome”. Christian is the umbrella term.
@@ays.939 the moment the church of Rome separated from all other churches she became the first protestant church in history
.Catholic is university, but Roman church is a different monster.
Well said Lil Wayne
Well said brother.
This was a great insight of how it looks and feels to be on the outside of Catholicism.
It’s really helpful to share these perspectives and experiences. You’ve always approached these things with a calm and humble heart.
Don’t take this one down. This is excellent.
Hi brother I just stumbled upon this video and would like to express thanks for putting this out with honest expression. As a Protestant seeking truth and exploring how different forms of the Christian faith may encapsulate that truth, I relate to your journey, albeit with less academic fervency. The dialogue of Catholics and Protestants on UA-cam, while assisting in opening up that Pandora’s box for me, overall I trust to be a blessing to me and many others in the body of Christ. You really hit the nail for me in your new found understandings of Catholicism, and also your still present hesitations. And with eloquence. God bless on your continued journey, and thanks for sharing it with us to the extent that God encourages you to!
Really appreciate your honestly. Keep up the wonderful work! I’ll pray for your discernment.
Thank you so much for your honest investigation into the Catholic and Orthodox churches! I truly love the loving way you deal with all of these apparently complex differences.
As a lifelong Protestant baptized into the Orthodox Church at the age of 66, I greatly appreciate you!
I have two beloved sons, one who with his wife and teenage daughters are wonderfully devout Catholic, and one son who with his wife and two daughters came into the Orthodox Church shortly after I did.
I am anxious for you next presentation on Orthodoxy. Again, thank you!
Austin, thank you so much for the update. I'm doing my masters degree in theology right now, so I definitely get not having enough time to look into things as much as you want to. I'll keep praying for you. God bless you as you continue this journey.
Love the honesty, integrity and thoroughness of your search. May God bless you and lead you!
I have so much respect for anyone willing to say "I'm not sure" or "there's more to learn". I went from being an Atheist to be being a traditional Catholic just 3 years ago and it's been quite a journey. There's still so much to learn, there's so much richness in the church. May God bless your journey, I'll be praying for you to find the answers you're looking for. 🙏
It’s been wonderful, a blessing, that you are sharing this journey. The Holy Spirit is working and it’s just such a wild windy adventure when He is leading. Lots of love, appreciation, and prayers from “grandma” ❤️🌹
You are SUCH a positive and lovely person. You are sooo good at managing to discuss the differences between us all in such a positive way. I'm so fed up with the hatred and suspension we carry around with us.
I’m catholic and I just enjoy your channel and you honest commentary.
I appreciate that
Great video! I appreciate your willingness to share your journey.
Austin, this was a wonderful video! As someone who has “investigated these things in silence” I certainly do not envy you, but I do admire you, especially your zeal for the conversion of poor sinners.
Keep praying for truth brother, especially through Scripture. Know that many are praying for you and wishing your good (and of course, for many of us, “your good” means your conversion).
God bless you!
Pax Christi
As a Catholic, I can totally see and understand why being inundated with “when are you coming to Rome” comments is a psychological problem, mainly because I have so many friends that aren’t Catholic and I put myself in their shoes as much as I can. I’d love to just tell those that ask, “She/He will come into the Catholic Church when God knows is best.”
I’ve so enjoyed watching your videos over the last year and a half or so, and I appreciate your openness and vulnerability in sharing your journey to learning more about Catholicism. Prayers for you, Austin! God bless 😊
That's a great quote to remember when helping our non-Catholic brothers and sisters understand, “She/He will come into the Catholic Church when GOD knows is best.” Surrendering to GOD for their understanding and conversion.
Hebrews 13:14 For here we do not have an enduring city, but we are looking for the city that is to come...I have always taken Roman Catholic apologists line "come home to Rome" as an affront to the above Scripture and a kind of twisting of it in their zeal to place Rome and Roman Catholicism in the superior and triumphalist place. This has always been a turn off for me as it strikes me as pretentious and over the top.
Hebrews 13:14 For here we do not have an enduring city, but we are looking for the city that is to come...I have always taken Roman Catholic apologists line "come home to Rome" as an affront to the above Scripture and a kind of twisting of it in their zeal to place Rome and Roman Catholicism in the superior and triumphalist place. This has always been a turn off for me as it strikes me as pretentious and over the top.
True, its annoying just like how orthodox constantly just respond, even in debates with "just come to one divine liturgy and you will see"
@@jonathansoko1085 I'm Orthodox and I agree with you.
I'm glad that your experience is going well. Thanks for sharing. God Bless
Such a pleasure listening to where you are one year later. Your journey, has been fascinating to me as a lifelong cradle Catholic. I’ve never doubted your sincerity in this endeavor, and no matter where you end up, you have given me a lot of joy just watching your enthusiasm on this journey. Of course; as a Catholic, it would be nice to have you join the church however, you are making a major life decision. I have no doubt that you will land exactly where God wants you to land and when he wants you to land there. God bless you!
May God continue to bless you on your journey of faith. It took my husband and I five or six years to eventually convert to Orthodoxy. We were able to research and digest and contemplate at our own pace without pressure from anything or anyone else, which was a huge blessing. Wherever you land, I pray your faith is strengthened and your love for Christ is deepened in the process. 💛
Hi Austin,
Just want to say THANK YOU for all that you do on your channel! I so appreciate your humbleness and open-mindedness throughout your videos. I'm currently trying to "work all this out" myself as well lol.
My pleasure!
Beautiful honest video. Our individual journeys are all in God’s time, no matter how much others or our own motivations want it to go one way or another. May God bless you on your mission and on your engagement and upcoming marriage too.
This is a big decision and will take time. Thank you for taking us on your journey. I'm praying for you.🙏😁
Hi Austin - long time listener, first time commenter. Up front disclosure, i myself am a cradle orthodox with no formal theological training but on fire love for God and his church. Just wanted to say, never thought you were meant to convert to anything. I saw and see the value of your channel as building bridges and tearing down caricature images of one another. Ignore the perhaps unintentional pressure to do anything other than produce content that makes us more accepting and loving of one another. Don't underestimate the enormous value of that. Take care.
I appreciate this video. I’ve been curious about what your thoughts were at this point. I’m eager to hear about what you think about Orthodoxy too. Thank you for sharing your journey with the world. It is a help to me & I’m sure to others as well. God bless!
This video was very helpful to me. Thank you. I know I am two years behind you, and I am wrestling with a lot of the same questions, and I’m currently in a very similar place! Pursuing the truth wherever it leads me!
Last thing: I'm not sure if you've heard of him, but Thomas Howard was really influential in my journey. I'd recommend starting with "Evangelical is Not Enough" Which he wrote as a Protestant. Then wrote "On Being Catholic" after becoming Catholic. Thomas Howard was the brother of the legendary Elizabeth Elliott.
I know it might be hard to get over, and I see your point about the evangelical ethos (I wish Catholics were more like that) it is important to remember that the people are not what makes a church true, it is the doctrine.
Side note: If you’re looking for zeal in Catholicism, try attending a latin Mass. The deep spirituality and rich reverence and worship of a TLM is unmatched by just about anything else.
I totally appreciate this video. It just proves that this particular journey is not straightforward. It’s a lot of back and forth and dealing with questions and doubts. When I was introduced to Catholicism, it opens up a whole other universe of questions. So much of what you are saying resonates with me. Thanks for sharing this, it helps me feel like I’m not alone.
God love u friend . Courage and felicitation on your engagement
I'm just now finding you, Austin, and I'm impressed by your intellectual honesty and genuineness in your search to be refreshing. Peace to you.
Thanks!
man, don't rush the process, take your time, read, meditate on the discoveries, think. The important part is that you're investigating the truth of the christian faith, the catholic faith, whatever place God puts you, I know that He will use your work to bring people in general closer to Him, it may be that He chose to put you in Peter's boat, or He may not. Pray, read and think and things will clear out. God bless
I am a cradle Catholic, so I especially appreciate hearing your thought and heart processes. I send you love and respect as you continue your journey.
Just remember you are going great! Plain and simple! Also your tone of voice is so calming.
Great video! Can't wait for your video on Orthodoxy as well. You have definitely shown interest and patience towards the Church. I'm sure that listening to your reflections on it will be both enjoyable and insighful!
All of the people who keep asking you to “come home” make up that “church on the ground” you referred to. That’s the zeal to spread the gospel you love. I’m sure it can make you tap the breaks, as you say. It’s the same feeling someone might get when they meet a zealous Protestant. It’s not a bad thing - just a synchronization thing. Keep up the good work. Your channel is awesome.
Dude, I appreciate your total transparency and messy confused thoughts on the whole thing. I’m with you. I think I can understand the turmoil. Just keep searching for truth and remember Gods Grace extends past just our sins but in our search for truth also.
Austin, just want to thank you for you brute honesty and vulnerability not just here, but along the way. Earlier you intimated that you've sought to "step out of the way" when you've interviewed folks, but i want to say that even in that effort, I think we've all witnessed your genuine inquisitiveness and seen the fruit of charity as you've engaged with perspectives you perhaps didn't agree with. Last year I reverted to the Catholic Church and know what you speak if in terms of the difference in cultural emphasis on evangelism and desiring for others to know the Gospel. It is one of the things that I feel the Lord is restoring to the Catholic Church through the conversion and reversion of many Protestants to the Catholic Church. Know that you have a brother in me, a Catholic, who is zealous for the joy of the Gospel to spread through the world, in and out of the Catholic Church.
I just think you’ve done a great job, really. You’ve been an excellent resource for me, as I see myself in you in many ways. For the past few years, I have also had a huge spiritual journey. I’ve spent a year attending an Antiochian Orthodox Church. I’ve spent over a year thinking I’m Catholic. I’ve gone “back home” to my childhood faith of mainstream Lutheranism. I’ve hopped next door to Anglicanism, and I’ve even had bouts of such extreme frustration that I walk away entirely for weeks. My journey still isn’t over, and like you said, it’s a “can of worms I sometimes wish I hadn’t opened” sort of thing. But man has it been a powerful experience.
You’ve been great at what you do, and I just encourage you to continue trying to strike that balance of personal wrestling and professional questioning. Keep up the endurance. As I always think back to, “Israel” translates to “he who wrestles with God.” These questions aren’t easy, and God fully knows that. Just continue to pray for guidance. Ask for guidance on properly addressing that can of worms, and patience in the meantime. God bless you, my friend.
Thank you for your humbleness and honesty, Austin. You've been such a blessing for your audiences around the world. At the end of the day, faith is not just a matter of mind, but also a matter of heart, and ultimately is a gift from God. May the Holy Spirit guide you wherever He wants to lead you. God bless!
Austin, through your honesty and humility, the Holy Spirit absolutely will render this video (and everything else you do) 'helpful' to those who need, and are open to, that help, however that looks in each individual circumstance. You are doing great work, and I keep you in my prayers.
Have just come across this, and loved hearing about your journey.. thanks for your honesty and sincere desire to bring others to Christ.. its so refreshing 😌
No matter in which way or your final direction, I appreciate more your journey of discovering. I love it bro, keep growing :)