LSD vs MLD vs Open differential comparison: Storme, Thar, V-Cross, Endeavour, Fortuner.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 216

  • @Thethirdeye09
    @Thethirdeye09 7 років тому +48

    to a student like me.. a layman.. this video just cleared all my doubts and confusions about diffrentials :)

  • @VishnuRajam4x4
    @VishnuRajam4x4 6 років тому +41

    Hi Anshuman, the Old gen Endeavour has a Torsen LSD which multiplies the traction at the spinning wheel and delivers it to the wheel with traction. Therefore if the grip at the spinning wheel is 0, the power delivered to the wheel with traction is also 0.The Fortuner also has a Torsen center differential so will work the same way. Thats why for the fortuner also there is no forward force generated. The multiplying factor for a torsen diff is anywhere between 2x to 3x. Torsen LSD is very good for distributing power on road but very poor for off road. Lots of sports cars have a torsen LSD.

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  6 років тому +5

      We just got Airlocker installed in Old Endy and we were shocked to see an open diff, only the 2.5 had the LSD, even the diff oil specs suggest the same.

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  6 років тому +6

      Pajero SFX's LSD is the only one I have seen that diverts some power to the stuck wheel.

    • @nyakuiralu419
      @nyakuiralu419 6 років тому +10

      Nicely put. Torsen diff. does not work when traction in spinning wheel is 0, like wheel in the air as in video. As long as there is little traction, it will work. Trick is to gently apply brakes to trick spinning wheel into thinking there is some traction. Then torque will transfer to other wheel with traction.

    • @bhabatoshsarkar5904
      @bhabatoshsarkar5904 5 років тому +1

      @Vishnu_R You explained it wrong. You told Grip 0 then Power 0. But in case of Fortuner in the video the grip 0 but power 100 to one wheel.
      To work the Torsen Diff the tire with grip should have to spin a little......but If it is Stationary the ratio between the two output wheel will become 0 like (0:5) does not exists mathematically. Torsen control the slip for no grip when both the wheel is rotating.
      In case of Fortuner as you told there is Torsen Differential in Central Differential..but the front wheels' shaft is stationary. So the ration between Rear Wheels' Shaft & Front Wheels' shaft become 0. And the Rear Wheels' shaft rotating and by the Rear Differential whole the power is going to the Wheel with no grip.

  • @shikharnigam1499
    @shikharnigam1499 7 років тому +85

    This video is the answer to all my queries!!

  • @yash-che
    @yash-che 7 років тому +61

    This video is how I made my gf motivated for Thar.

  • @pranavbhardwaj8471
    @pranavbhardwaj8471 7 років тому +6

    Lovely video sir,
    it enhanced my knowledge about the differential system in the off road cars and also acknowledges about the capabilities of SUV's in india.
    Great video
    Thank you sir.

  • @bishalthapa7883
    @bishalthapa7883 3 роки тому +1

    This is the best video on explaining Open Differential, Limited Slip Differential and Mechanical Lock Differential.

  • @divyshah9467
    @divyshah9467 6 років тому +12

    Only few will understand, but really informative video.

  • @Tblagbro
    @Tblagbro 6 років тому +6

    Great and informative video, thanks! It's great to see real world comparisons. My experience off road has been similar - limited slip differentials add little to no value over open. They do seem better on wet roads though.
    Thanks again

  • @Brian-mc4pd
    @Brian-mc4pd 7 років тому +6

    Like Shikhar says, it answer my questions as well. That's all I wanted was a side-by-side look - so good job fellas

  • @sourabh6482
    @sourabh6482 4 роки тому +3

    Superbly explained and demonstrated this is one of the best video for this topic please make more videos of this type so people gain more practical knowledge love it

  • @vivekarora4134
    @vivekarora4134 7 років тому +15

    Brilliant video sir I literally sat down with a pen and paper to note what exactly happens in which system. Thanks for the video and hope to see some more of this type :-)

  • @sweetandcuteguy
    @sweetandcuteguy 4 роки тому +3

    Very very important and nicely made video. Had to search through tonnes of BS videos to get to this! To the point and crisp video. Congratulations!

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  4 роки тому +2

      Glad it was helpful!

  • @nitesh744
    @nitesh744 7 років тому +9

    Great info & explanation.... I learned something new with your video Keep doing it....

  • @fighttowin055
    @fighttowin055 7 років тому +2

    this MLD system is really cool almost as good as manual locking differential assuming it's good at unlocking as well and doesn't remain locked when not needed

  • @mohitnautiyal2631
    @mohitnautiyal2631 4 роки тому

    Short, crisp, to the point. Brilliant job 👍

  • @alizeeshan1999
    @alizeeshan1999 7 років тому

    The Thar engages diff. lock when it senses wheelspin. When does it disengage the diff. lock. Also, why was it stopped at 2:55?

  • @spsingh4073
    @spsingh4073 7 років тому +17

    now i got why the fortuner failed in climbing ... 😎😎😎

  • @vishalhans5778
    @vishalhans5778 7 років тому +3

    Thanks a ton .. this video help me lot to understand about MLD.... going to have my MLD kit installed soon in my TUV 300.

    • @satyadas1981
      @satyadas1981 6 років тому

      vishal hans is it possible bro... If so den suggest me..

    • @Abhishek-150
      @Abhishek-150 5 років тому

      TUV300.. ? Are you serious?

  • @raghunandan2429
    @raghunandan2429 4 роки тому +4

    Simple and nicely explained.. 👍
    What happened to fortuner when you locked center differentil?

  • @jaganmangat1989
    @jaganmangat1989 6 років тому +3

    This is a very good video. It can be called as the part-1, make a part-2(if there isn't any) and include cars like gurkha,new endeavour,new fortuner and various german crossovers.

  • @the_lonerider
    @the_lonerider 7 років тому +2

    Thanx so much for teaching us the difference between all the differentials and vehicles it is very helpfull..and amazing as well.🙏

  • @kshitijkakade9631
    @kshitijkakade9631 4 роки тому +1

    LSD has never helped me off-road, fails to work all the time. TATA xenon!
    Don't know how to overcome this!

  • @pankajrane6263
    @pankajrane6263 7 років тому

    Thanks Anshuman for explaining with a practical demonstration.

  • @TheSkskitey
    @TheSkskitey 7 років тому +1

    Good video , now i know why a diiff lock is a must off road .

  • @ravikakhandki7594
    @ravikakhandki7594 4 роки тому +1

    Suprising and frankly dangerous. Why would manufacturers provide a LSD which doesn't divert power to the wheel with traction? The abs based wheel locking on awd softroaders work much better than this.

  • @sahilm85
    @sahilm85 4 роки тому

    Best explanation with marvelous illustrations.

  • @HimSafari4x4
    @HimSafari4x4 2 роки тому +2

    Hey bro, recently I've found that Storme doesn't have LSD even. It has open differential only. That's confirmed from my side. We actually opened the differential and checked, coz i was going to install MLD in it, which didn't work due to minor size issues.

  • @bhargavdas8647
    @bhargavdas8647 7 років тому +1

    thank you sir ..its a superb video.. always watch the notification of youtube for our new videos ...

  • @mahesh-jm9ow
    @mahesh-jm9ow 5 років тому +2

    Thank you Bhai.. explained well.
    You could have included the video of the last fortuner with central diff in locked mode too.. Thanks again 💕

  • @thejudge2163
    @thejudge2163 5 років тому +1

    Hi Anshuman, very informative Videos! Would you know any diff upgrades for Hexa 4x2 rear diff. Can it be upgraded to add diff locker?

  • @rocksta0999
    @rocksta0999 7 років тому +1

    Love your videos man
    Would love to see more of vcross and fortuner

  • @cutecubb
    @cutecubb 7 років тому +1

    God speed, a nice and basic video for new 4x4s'

  • @dmajumdar2059
    @dmajumdar2059 6 років тому +1

    Awesome video!!! Keep it up mate.

  • @anuj2006tomar
    @anuj2006tomar 7 років тому +1

    great job bro keeping posting such informative videos......

  • @nishokraj5910
    @nishokraj5910 6 років тому

    This video clears are my doubts. Now iam interested to fit in to my safari EX.

  • @jamesmiddleton5304
    @jamesmiddleton5304 Рік тому

    Yep, have open diffs on the truck I just bought. Sure miss my G80 auto locker. Made a world of difference as would any other factory locker.

  • @HisLostSheep
    @HisLostSheep 6 років тому +1

    An LSD is for performance vehicles. A Locker is for off-road vehicles. Simple.

  • @ihasagcga
    @ihasagcga 3 роки тому +1

    Mad video, got some good info , cheers

  • @RaviRaj_OM
    @RaviRaj_OM 7 років тому +1

    Thanks a lot for sharing... Very informative.. Cleared my misconception about LSD. MLD is the best.. But not suitable for front diff due to sudden locking with a jerk

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому +3

      Well the best one is selectable locker, MLD does not operate as required at time, but yes compared to LSD it is better for offroading.

  • @SankalpSinghEA
    @SankalpSinghEA 7 років тому +1

    Thank you for explaining it so beautifully!

  • @ZuhaibAhmedWani
    @ZuhaibAhmedWani 7 років тому +1

    a good teaching session, you got good skills to explain things. thanks. but why didn't you show us how the last SUV behaved.
    still a nice way of making a video. I'm impressed

  • @lijo055
    @lijo055 7 років тому +1

    AWESOME BRO, WELL EXPLAINED.

  • @abhisheksingh-ym6pz
    @abhisheksingh-ym6pz 7 років тому +1

    practicle knowlegde is always best...
    thankyu thankyu so much..

  • @kartikeyshinde4869
    @kartikeyshinde4869 5 років тому

    Nice video, Clears all of the doubts

  • @jaimahakalallindiatravel3241
    @jaimahakalallindiatravel3241 2 роки тому +1

    wow bhai kya bat h with proof

  • @rakishansh
    @rakishansh 7 років тому +1

    Whats torque on demand plz make a video illustrating different modes in new endeavour 3.2 Titanium

  • @abhirajparmar9937
    @abhirajparmar9937 7 років тому +1

    awesome elaboration sir.!! please try to bring the force gurkha if I can manage since it has locking differentails in both the axles .would love to see it

  • @rajasrinivasbharam65
    @rajasrinivasbharam65 5 років тому +1

    Excellent explanation sir

  • @imMavenGuy
    @imMavenGuy 2 роки тому

    Your video is the first search result on google for MLD

  • @StanDaManReviews
    @StanDaManReviews 7 років тому +6

    It's very surprising the Storme 400's LSD and Endeavour LSD did not work. Maybe try running them with 4WD and see, it may work.

  • @ikoostrips6298
    @ikoostrips6298 4 роки тому +1

    Very well explained ✌️👌👍

  • @Countrysideboy247
    @Countrysideboy247 5 років тому

    The vcross seemed like it can come out by seeing it's slight movement! That's nice ,I had a fight with one guy in UA-cam ,he was judging vcross for the reason that it has lesser torque than the safari ,but it can be clearly seen that the safari can't perform even with LSDs ,but still many Tata fanboys are like Tata is the best ,I don't know why are even trying to lower the fame of Isuzu,after all many of their masterpiece (especially the trooper) have been used in the places where even Land Rover defenders have conquered! Also another proof that why the vcross is a better off-road vehicle,it can be seen crossing most trails even better than the new fortuner! I don't know why but most Indians treat Isuzus like Chinese cars!

  • @firdous222
    @firdous222 7 років тому +3

    why LSD is not working in 2wd , is it only active in 4wd ?

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому +7

      +firdous pm LSD has no connection with 4wd system. I have no explanationation for why it does not work, this thing had me wondering for months.

    • @REVIEW_JUJUR
      @REVIEW_JUJUR 7 років тому

      in this video LSD is no difference with Open-Diff.

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому

      Active traction control is not available in Hexa, just Engine traction control, the pseudo modes are just to effect power delivery.

  • @abdulquaderkhan
    @abdulquaderkhan 5 років тому

    does these thar differentials are same as which comes in mahindra 550 first generation??

  • @Радж-с7н
    @Радж-с7н 7 років тому +2

    It's very surprising the Storme 400's LSD did not work.
    Is that possible to upgrade this with MLd, new generation??
    Should I buy safari or not?

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому

      MLD can be fitted to Storme.

    • @Радж-с7н
      @Радж-с7н 7 років тому

      क्या ये बहुत मंहगा पड़ेगा? कहाँ से करवाना चाहिए? मैं हरियाणा से हूँ।

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому

      Storme 4x4 is a capable vehicle even in stock form, first explore places where and if you find it lacking, only then go for upgrades like MLD. Contact Eaton Dealer in Delhi for the part and I dont know where to get it installed for Tata cars, for Mahindra dealers do install it.

    • @Радж-с7н
      @Радж-с7н 7 років тому

      Thanks for your help and advice

  • @off-roadingexplained8417
    @off-roadingexplained8417 2 роки тому

    Great video and I think you have a very accurate assessment. Looks like both BLD and lockers are WAY better than LSD. Toyota Atrac is probably better than LSD too.

    • @WhynotMinot
      @WhynotMinot 2 роки тому

      LSD works better on the road. I saw a video where this guy oiled up a steel bar, put one tire on it, and the open diff would spin on that bar, slowly moving forward or moving the bar. For LSD, the tire would spin fast to begin with, than start moving quickly. LSD seems to work better when there isn't a tire completely off the ground.

  • @abhisheklakhanpal1579
    @abhisheklakhanpal1579 3 роки тому

    Hello ansuman sir
    Any m locker for isuzu available in india.
    Can getaway's mld installed in isuzu.or any other options
    What will be their price for locker in rear

  • @PAVANPAVAN-hl8uo
    @PAVANPAVAN-hl8uo 7 років тому

    Hi! Nyc video. I want to ask how good is 4wd scorpio?

  • @manishsingh1026
    @manishsingh1026 7 років тому +2

    that's very informative....can we install after market locking rear differentials on scorpio 4x2 or 4x4 or v cross??

  • @sri198507
    @sri198507 4 роки тому

    but i think on tar roads d open differential is better?so MLD is gud only for off roaders, ryt?

  • @Kajenoel
    @Kajenoel 6 років тому

    Very good clears my doubts

  • @BhanuPratapSingh-fz8fl
    @BhanuPratapSingh-fz8fl 7 років тому +1

    Very nice explanation 👍

  • @Vikram_Adhikari
    @Vikram_Adhikari 7 років тому

    where do u shoot

  • @hitaishihs1847
    @hitaishihs1847 3 роки тому

    Does thar crde come with MLD as standard?

  • @inderjeetsingh9835
    @inderjeetsingh9835 6 років тому +1

    best practical done 👍. thanks sir.

  • @aatebhai
    @aatebhai 7 років тому +1

    Very well explained...

  • @djanu099
    @djanu099 7 років тому +1

    hey man good informative video.
    can you tell me about the ride quality and comfort level on the bench seat in isuzu dmax.
    im sure abot the front seats are comfy enough for a long road trips.

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому +2

      Rear seat is comfortable and has good space, just a bit too upright for my taste and it does not recline.

  • @Aksankhan
    @Aksankhan 5 років тому

    Where I can buy front diff locker for Pajero 1992 exceed?
    Your recommendations will be highly appreciated.

  • @ag135i
    @ag135i 4 роки тому +1

    Can I install 3 MLD on the three differentials in an all wheel drive?.

  • @warxfitindia
    @warxfitindia 6 років тому +1

    Nice one... informative.

  • @sachinfilinto
    @sachinfilinto 7 років тому

    Fantastic video. for close to 2 years i looked for details on how the thar MLD worked but no one i spoke to had an explanation as you have shown in your video. The mahindra guys too wont know details like this. if possible do post a video on how this is disengaged. ( i read you have to reverse it to disengage MLD)

    • @sachinfilinto
      @sachinfilinto 7 років тому

      Couple of questions:
      1) From your video it seems you are in 2WD - can you confirm this ? i ask because mahindra says this works only on 4WD which i believed until now.
      2) This MLD is present on front as well as rear differentials right ? or only rear
      In the 3 years i have owned my thar i have never heard the clank of the lock engaging. maybe i need to ask someone else to drive and i observe the locking from outside.

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому

      MLD is a mechanical system fitted in rear differential, it does not have any connection with 4x4 activation. If your Thar is 3 years old, chances are that your car does not have MLD, pre facelift Thar(with the old Black dashboard) did not have MLD.

    • @sachinfilinto
      @sachinfilinto 7 років тому

      You are right. I was confused between AutoLocking Hubs and MLD.
      Pity that mahindra makes such a poor job of documenting what is provided in the vehicle & the service chaps are even more poorly informed.

    • @sachinfilinto
      @sachinfilinto 7 років тому

      was wondering if it makes sense to have a diff lock on the front differential

  • @adnaanpardawala
    @adnaanpardawala 7 років тому

    Very Informative video. Thanks!!

  • @mohanmx682
    @mohanmx682 6 років тому

    Arent the LSD is safari and Endy brake actuated. A quick jab on the breaks will slight slow the slow wheel and send the torque to the wheel with traction. Can you test with that also. Eager to see the result.Thanks

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  6 років тому

      LSD is never brake actuated, it works on the basis of wheelspeed difference. Do not fall for online comments, in real life it does not work.

  • @KuntalGhosh
    @KuntalGhosh 6 років тому

    seems like open differential or worn out clutch packs on the storm!

  • @elitewarrior689
    @elitewarrior689 7 років тому

    Great, what about those vehicles with torque on demand 4wd & traction control? what kind of differential they have? If only we have one

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому

      Active traction control will work here in slow crawling, in back to back osbtacles the system will get confused, we experimented the same last week with Jeep Wrangler.
      Torque on demand is about front to rear power delivery, not sideways, sideways is handled by Torque vectoring.

  • @OneLivingLife
    @OneLivingLife 4 роки тому +1

    excellent video dada

  • @trevorthomas6043
    @trevorthomas6043 3 роки тому

    Speaking as a car tec,most lsd clutch’s last 10-to 30 thousand miles depending on use

  • @AdarshKookal
    @AdarshKookal 4 роки тому +1

    great video 👌👏👍

  • @parasahlawat27
    @parasahlawat27 4 роки тому

    I think a cheap and better way would be to slip brakes, as it will be easier for rear wheels. you can tie two wires to hand brake cables and just pull them when you get struck. I don't know about front wheels. but maybe maybe we can put a iron rod in Rim and chassis and stop wheel from spinning but we''ll have to remove it as soon as it reaches traction.

  • @AutoMatriX11
    @AutoMatriX11 7 років тому +1

    very well explained .....!!☺

  • @gauravjoshi9001
    @gauravjoshi9001 4 роки тому

    Nice examples given 👌🏻

  • @maniya6830
    @maniya6830 5 років тому

    Great video sir thanks for sharing!

  • @drsatindertravelandlifesty2613
    @drsatindertravelandlifesty2613 7 років тому +1

    very nice video lockers are good

  • @jomyjoy09
    @jomyjoy09 7 років тому

    @anshuman bishnoi Good video..however a couple of quick questions ( pardon my ignorance as I am not an expert in this)
    1. In practical use, with 4wd available..will someone ever get stuck in either of these vehicles?
    2. Also would you be able to check how a scorpio would behave under similar circumstance?
    Thanks in advance...

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому +1

      1. Even with 4x4 engaged, if one tyre from each axle does not have traction car will not move forward without difflock.
      2. Scorpio has open diffs, it will behave exactly like Isuzu V-Cross in this video.

  • @unofficial0007
    @unofficial0007 Рік тому

    Very useful information 👍👍

  • @MrHelperForever
    @MrHelperForever 7 років тому

    Very Informative Video , Thanks :)

  • @MubashirAlam27
    @MubashirAlam27 4 роки тому

    Informative content!

  • @vaibhavsharma9591
    @vaibhavsharma9591 7 років тому

    dear admin,how about xuv500..?? does it have MLD or LSD.And how good it is compared to others in its segment..??

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому

      XUV has open diffs, no LSD, no MLD, no Articulation. XUV 500 is good only for light offroading.

  • @akhilrocks1
    @akhilrocks1 7 років тому +1

    great video...

  • @suvi.fitness
    @suvi.fitness 7 років тому

    good explaination..liked it.

  • @ahmedpashamohammed1196
    @ahmedpashamohammed1196 7 років тому +1

    Awesome demo

  • @abyworld9289
    @abyworld9289 2 роки тому

    Superb video ❤❤❤

  • @tepusazopuyo9878
    @tepusazopuyo9878 6 років тому

    Sir, your show will be 100 times more entertaining, if you take your vehicles to some sort of rain forest type instead of always trying to climb hillocks in desert type terrain. Rain forest soils are much more slippery and so you can test the full potential of your latest generation SUV's.

  • @sachinrawat9036
    @sachinrawat9036 7 років тому +1

    Awesome video #brother

  • @_traveller_not_tourist_
    @_traveller_not_tourist_ 5 років тому

    Hi, thanks for clearing doubts, can you share details where can i get mld for scorpio.

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  5 років тому

      Find Eaton India distributor

    • @_traveller_not_tourist_
      @_traveller_not_tourist_ 5 років тому

      @@Anshyuman hi, i have checked with 4-5 eaton distributors listed on their site. But none of them deal in MLD, can you suggest any distributor where i can find one

  • @Gauravkumar-pw8my
    @Gauravkumar-pw8my 7 років тому +1

    heyaaa broda.. love ur videos.. but pls use a different font colour.. wid d black backkground nd red font it is not legible...

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  7 років тому

      Thanks, Will experiment with other colors in future videos.

  • @jerodoque
    @jerodoque 6 років тому

    Great video!

  • @nikhilt497
    @nikhilt497 4 роки тому

    Does thar come with diff lockers standard?

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  4 роки тому +1

      Only rear Autolocker(MLD)

  • @autotracer8795
    @autotracer8795 3 роки тому

    Dear
    New Thar have central differential
    Please reply your experience
    Thank You 😊

    • @Anshyuman
      @Anshyuman  3 роки тому +1

      New Thar does not have centre differential, its part time 4wd meaning only transfercase no center diff

    • @autotracer8795
      @autotracer8795 3 роки тому

      @@Anshyuman thanks bro

  • @sanketsarkar
    @sanketsarkar 4 роки тому

    Anshuman, is it possible to install MLD on Grand Vitaras?

    • @joydip29
      @joydip29 4 роки тому

      sanket Talk to EATON.