The Jedi made a tactical error. Once the front lines were broken and the enemy was starting to come into the fort they should've stayed there. The enemy has to come into the fort via natural choke points (the doorways) that makes managing the enemy easier if you're a Jedi defender. Instead the Jedi decided to go outside the castle and spread their forces thin by taking on the horde head on. Was it brave? Yes. Was it smart? No.
@@neville3059 And put heavy machine guns on the walls alongside with the artillery inside the castle with howitzers too and using tanks to protect the 88!!
As it turns out, 6000 years of technology (god knows how many if you count the JEDI) doesn't change the simple fact that six million enemy troops is still a LOT of enemy troops. 10 to 1 odds is a tall ask, even for masters of the force.
@@ProPandaPlays yes, i know. The implication was that anything GREATER than 10 to 1 would be completely infeasible. Besides, the jedi didn't do ALL the fighting...
If you don't count the Jedi ("long, long ago") then where do you get "6000 years of technology"? Spartans, romans and Mongols are all from the Iron Age. The oldest of these (as depicted) is the Spartans and they can be traced back less than 3,000 years - just prior to the start of the Iron Age in that part of the world. Just sayin'.
@@smgdfcmfahIt was more referring to the 6000 years or so between the first age of Jedi's earliest lightsaber technology and the modern Star Wars era. (if memory serves.) Also, it's a little bit silly to try to chronologically compare Jedi to Spartans...just sayin'.
@@therealbahamut You specifically said you didn't count the Jedi in your original comment, so I assumed you were talking about all the non-fictional characters. Clearly I wasn't comparing Jedi to Spartans.
The Jedi could have easily stole a spartan tactic. “In that narrow passage, their numbers will count for nothing”. They should have stayed by the castle entrance. It would have taken hours but the Jedi would have won
it is always the corners in your videos - they need reinforcements. That is where the invaders break through. The more circular the defense, the harder to break, apparently.
Yeah, castle technology teaches that lesson pretty early; extended corners are open to fire from more sides with fewer defenders having to switch targets more often. Soon as I saw that spot in the formation I knew THAT was where it was going to break first.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems to me like the Jedi in the defensive positions outside the walls could have won the thing alone easily if they had gotten the attack order right in the first minute?
The strong visual appeal of a warhammer 40k battle (will we ever see a W40K mod?), the absolutely idiotic strategic sense of the Battle of Winterfell vs the Night King.
The placement of all those Nazi 88mm howitzers was so ignorant. Place them on top of the walls, and fire at will. When you really care and want to send the very best, send steel rain. King of Battle
This was cool! Those frontline Jedi lasted a lot longer than I expected. I wonder if you put the cannons on the Castle so they have a better downward angle if they would be more effective?
Ok here is the thing, modern field artillery, you would not have a modern howitzer that close in! A small howitzer M119 that fires a 105mm shell has a range of 7-8 miles. Get you 3 batteries with six guns each, 10 or so of the Jedi can hand back and play FIST (my old job forward observer) toss in a few rounds of Willy P (white phosphorus) to turn the suck way up, and thats just playing fair sure there are some not so nice gases that a 105 shell can bring in. And I have not even got to the big cannons or the Paladin, the mobile tracked howitzer. Artillery isnt called the King of Battle for nothing!
@@wrenmichael8471 Sure but those are 88s. They were often found close to the front lines as they became more and more about anti-tank and close infantry support weapons. They weren't used as artillery (other than anti aircraft artillery) and were often found in a direct fire support role. You'd still set them back as far as you could to make use of their long range for protection, but you need a line of sight to the front and sometimes that's just not very far if you're not in the desert.
Imagine that the commander of this great army promised his soldiers that if they take this fortress, they will receive rich booty - gold, slaves, and other valuables. But in fact, they got a heap of ruins and mountains of corpses of their comrades and enemies. If I were the commander of this horde, I would be worried ...
There should have been artillery mounted on the walls, tanks lining the fort from corner to corner, and more Jedi covering the entrances to ensure that no gaps were open.
The canons and riflemen should have been placed on the ridge with the jedis on the upslope before them. This would have greatly extended the range of both cannon and riflemen and forced the romans etc. to hit the frontlines running uphill. Bad tactical placement of troops.
The dude's with Lightsabers did their jobs! Just pushed back a huge semi circle. But I think people broke through. I don't know. I'm watching x2 on edibles. 😂
Speaking as an artilleryman, the artilery would tak out their own people the way they were deployed. The overpressure of the cannon blast would have killed or severely wounded several ranks of soldiers.
Я смотрю это видео и друге видео с канала, показываю детям, объясняя как работает иммунная система организма. И что происходит когда в бой вступают лекарства или антибиотики. Очень помогает детям в понимании. ☝️!
2 kiloton tactical nuke- launched just far enough away from the fort so as not to nock the walls down- then BOOM! fight is over. or carpet bombing with napalm artillery- same basic effect. remaining troops are alive? yes. 3rd degree burns all over. their backup behind them? VAPOR. pink dust. I'd like to thank everyone who showed up for this experiment.
the issue they miss is that killing all those attackers at roughly the same point would create a wall of dead bodies that would stop or slow the attackers
Yeah, I noped right out of there. I saw Spartans doing coke and hyping themselves up, and I cheered, then snuck out back. Also, this is the perfect chance to do napalm sorties all morning….. Because I love the smell in the morning 😅
Мне кажется если бы изначально стрелки стояли там же но просто выше . Было бы все по другому . Из за большого количества трупов у них не было линии обстрела
The soldiers dont have unlimited ammo so i think the romans will win more easy also the jedi has no shields so they are ligth troops romans are heavy troops
If they using archers and archers on horse , that battle was end* too fast. Becouse they dont have shild. And archers have chance to kill 1 soldier or jedi with 1 arrow
I thought this was interesting, but I don't understand how jedis = modern army and how the front line soldiers weren't dying from artillery shrapnel from the invading shields, armor, weapons, and body parts being blasted into them.
Meh. All the arty should have been deployed inside the walls. They could have still hit the middle/back rows. The army should have manned the walls and mined the hell out of the surrounding area. Still a good video;)
@ 2:21 imagine this shot if it were used for the Battle of Winterfell/or the Dark Night, or the Second Longest Night in GoT. I know itll cost bucketloads of cash, but the story leading up to it deserved a quality shot like this for the show, just to show the magnitude of what theyre facing
Кажется, что отправка джедаев в контратаку была неправильным решением, потому что лишила автора преимущества фортификации - эффекта бутылочного горлышка.
First of all, Jedi are not modern army. Second, a modern day army would have trenches, mines, and other things like barbed wires blocking the way. Finally, this was Game of Thrones level of bad position... ps: Much respect for the people that made the Battle Simulator, this level of quality for a simulation with such insane numbers is on another level.
Saya unlike dulu karena di depan penembak ada pasukan pedang yang itu adalah pasukan sama dengan zaman dahulu meskipun pedangnya pakai laser.. harusnya pasukan Romawi dll juga di beri panah atau bom sederhana
Lasers rays and also nukes should've been used then only we could say it's a win the in today's era modern army's main weapons are long range missiles and also nukes
The Jedi made a tactical error. Once the front lines were broken and the enemy was starting to come into the fort they should've stayed there. The enemy has to come into the fort via natural choke points (the doorways) that makes managing the enemy easier if you're a Jedi defender. Instead the Jedi decided to go outside the castle and spread their forces thin by taking on the horde head on. Was it brave? Yes. Was it smart? No.
But boy did it look good! :D
“We’re keepers of the peace, not soldiers.”
I thought the same they coud have defended easier if they just stayed in the walls
Chill, it was just for fun!
Yup…they would never do that
wonder how big of a difference the fight would of been if the jedi lawn mower was released earlier in the battle
Would "have" not would "of".
@@drygulched8084no one cares.
If only the Jedi had the high ground.
Pretty sure they have the moral high ground
If only moral high ground could be used on battlefield, alas...
hahahahahahaahahahahahah
They had the next best thing.
A fortified position but gave it up with a counter assault
I am always amazed at how the ancient soldiers can hit the front lines so easily while being shot at.
Artilllery to fort, jedis and riflers to gates = easy win.
Those artillery units should be on higher ground for continuously firings. Great video😅!
Or firing at a 45* angle down the line instead of straight ahead to maximize the carnage.
@@neville3059 And put heavy machine guns on the walls alongside with the artillery inside the castle with howitzers too and using tanks to protect the 88!!
Also organized in several lines to avoid being hindered by the mountain of corpses
As it turns out, 6000 years of technology (god knows how many if you count the JEDI) doesn't change the simple fact that six million enemy troops is still a LOT of enemy troops. 10 to 1 odds is a tall ask, even for masters of the force.
but its not 10 to 1 odds its 100 to 1 odds. 60 thousand vs 6 million is 100 times more LOL
@@ProPandaPlays yes, i know. The implication was that anything GREATER than 10 to 1 would be completely infeasible.
Besides, the jedi didn't do ALL the fighting...
If you don't count the Jedi ("long, long ago") then where do you get "6000 years of technology"? Spartans, romans and Mongols are all from the Iron Age. The oldest of these (as depicted) is the Spartans and they can be traced back less than 3,000 years - just prior to the start of the Iron Age in that part of the world. Just sayin'.
@@smgdfcmfahIt was more referring to the 6000 years or so between the first age of Jedi's earliest lightsaber technology and the modern Star Wars era. (if memory serves.) Also, it's a little bit silly to try to chronologically compare Jedi to Spartans...just sayin'.
@@therealbahamut You specifically said you didn't count the Jedi in your original comment, so I assumed you were talking about all the non-fictional characters. Clearly I wasn't comparing Jedi to Spartans.
The Jedi could have easily stole a spartan tactic. “In that narrow passage, their numbers will count for nothing”. They should have stayed by the castle entrance. It would have taken hours but the Jedi would have won
it is always the corners in your videos - they need reinforcements. That is where the invaders break through. The more circular the defense, the harder to break, apparently.
Yeah, reinforce the corners or rounding out the element as opposed to right angles would keep the lines from breaking.
Yeah, castle technology teaches that lesson pretty early; extended corners are open to fire from more sides with fewer defenders having to switch targets more often. Soon as I saw that spot in the formation I knew THAT was where it was going to break first.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems to me like the Jedi in the defensive positions outside the walls could have won the thing alone easily if they had gotten the attack order right in the first minute?
The strong visual appeal of a warhammer 40k battle (will we ever see a W40K mod?), the absolutely idiotic strategic sense of the Battle of Winterfell vs the Night King.
The placement of all those Nazi 88mm howitzers was so ignorant. Place them on top of the walls, and fire at will.
When you really care and want to send the very best, send steel rain.
King of Battle
what is a modern army doing being inside a medieval castle with their ancient Jedi warriors ?
Another dimension 😂
This was cool! Those frontline Jedi lasted a lot longer than I expected. I wonder if you put the cannons on the Castle so they have a better downward angle if they would be more effective?
Ok here is the thing, modern field artillery, you would not have a modern howitzer that close in! A small howitzer M119 that fires a 105mm shell has a range of 7-8 miles. Get you 3 batteries with six guns each, 10 or so of the Jedi can hand back and play FIST (my old job forward observer) toss in a few rounds of Willy P (white phosphorus) to turn the suck way up, and thats just playing fair sure there are some not so nice gases that a 105 shell can bring in. And I have not even got to the big cannons or the Paladin, the mobile tracked howitzer. Artillery isnt called the King of Battle for nothing!
@@wrenmichael8471 Sure but those are 88s. They were often found close to the front lines as they became more and more about anti-tank and close infantry support weapons. They weren't used as artillery (other than anti aircraft artillery) and were often found in a direct fire support role. You'd still set them back as far as you could to make use of their long range for protection, but you need a line of sight to the front and sometimes that's just not very far if you're not in the desert.
Imagine that the commander of this great army promised his soldiers that if they take this fortress, they will receive rich booty - gold, slaves, and other valuables. But in fact, they got a heap of ruins and mountains of corpses of their comrades and enemies. If I were the commander of this horde, I would be worried ...
Now we are waiting for the video with the battle of the Spartans against the terminators! 😆👌
if the jedi would have stayed at the openings they would have won
So this is exactly how spear-wielding dudes fight your tanks in Civilization!
There should have been artillery mounted on the walls, tanks lining the fort from corner to corner, and more Jedi covering the entrances to ensure that no gaps were open.
Good one.
If the Jedi held the pinch points, the outcome would have been different imo.
This is how the victory of the USSR over Hitler looks like
Под конец как тополиный пух сжигает огонь. 👍
Wow. Amazing to think that this is what it was really like.
Artillery officer needs to be court-martialed. Aiming that close to friendlies 🤨
The canons and riflemen should have been placed on the ridge with the jedis on the upslope before them. This would have greatly extended the range of both cannon and riflemen and forced the romans etc. to hit the frontlines running uphill. Bad tactical placement of troops.
The dude's with Lightsabers did their jobs!
Just pushed back a huge semi circle.
But I think people broke through.
I don't know. I'm watching x2 on edibles. 😂
Спасибо, было интересно!
That was a tough day lol. I felt a great disturbance in the force.
Imagine showing up to a battlefield with over six million other people and then walking away with under 100k.
Интересно какой комп у автора этого ролика?)
Speaking as an artilleryman, the artilery would tak out their own people the way they were deployed. The overpressure of the cannon blast would have killed or severely wounded several ranks of soldiers.
Я смотрю это видео и друге видео с канала, показываю детям, объясняя как работает иммунная система организма. И что происходит когда в бой вступают лекарства или антибиотики. Очень помогает детям в понимании. ☝️!
If the Jedis use the force, then this wouldn't have been a fair fight at all
Тактическая ошибка джедаев! Им надо было оставаться в форте и держать ворота!
So weird seeing the front-line Jedi hold a defensive position and not run all psycho into an army 10 times your size! 😳
Контратака джедаев захлебнулась. Без прикрытия стрелкового оружия было глупо атаковать армады.
Ох уж эти бесконечные патроны у солдат. Прям стреляют и стреляют без передышки. И оружие не клинит и перезаряжать не надо. мечта любого генерала.
Wow nice game 🎮
Was cool when you activated the jedi and they just went nuts
Excellent battle. Some nice camera
Great battle there Mate! ⚔️
and that's how the Soviets beat the Germans in WW2
Jedi can use light ziber hit sword and shield by don't have anything loss. But it just to be animation not real.
i love how the bullets from the very back row and every subsequent bullet from the rows in front of it goes through the people in front of them.
for the victor, the clean up is going to suck
2 kiloton tactical nuke- launched just far enough away from the fort so as not to nock the walls down- then BOOM! fight is over. or carpet bombing with napalm artillery- same basic effect. remaining troops are alive? yes. 3rd degree burns all over. their backup behind them? VAPOR. pink dust. I'd like to thank everyone who showed up for this experiment.
Every single musketeer should have been on the walls. Oh, and maybe actually use those cannons?
Imagine putting land mines in front , that would really take care of a lot of them
OMG!!! so cool!Thanks man.
the issue they miss is that killing all those attackers at roughly the same point would create a wall of dead bodies that would stop or slow the attackers
Здесь даже дружественный огонь не учитывается😂
What a battle .
This is insane ..
Pessoal das espadas azuis são brabo resistiram bastante 😮
Yeah, I noped right out of there. I saw Spartans doing coke and hyping themselves up, and I cheered, then snuck out back. Also, this is the perfect chance to do napalm sorties all morning….. Because I love the smell in the morning 😅
Thank you to those who fought the war
It's all fun and games until friendly-fire damage is enabled. Superiority in numbers makes up for a lack of technology.
this is much better at 2x speed. still awsome nonetheless
Мне кажется если бы изначально стрелки стояли там же но просто выше . Было бы все по другому . Из за большого количества трупов у них не было линии обстрела
SPARTAANNNSSS!!!⚔🛡
The definition of a pyrrhic victory.
I like the slow mo parts
Well done
Pc me Kel te ho
тут треба напалм ))))
The soldiers dont have unlimited ammo so i think the romans will win more easy also the jedi has no shields so they are ligth troops romans are heavy troops
lol interesting the romans would have never fought that way...
Why no shooters in the walkway on top of the castle walls?
Some MG42 and 50.cal would be good on the walls
6 million? do you have proof? looks more like a few hundred thousand
If they using archers and archers on horse , that battle was end* too fast. Becouse they dont have shild. And archers have chance to kill 1 soldier or jedi with 1 arrow
We can take them those are some BOLD WORDS FOR GRID CORDNETS
Jedi should call Future army 😂
nice video
ilk başta jedi leri aktif moda getirseydi daha erken biterdi
roman soldier: CHARGE!!!
jedi: hold my beer
нет на земле космическим пришельцам
well, quantity over quality well defined in ww2 hitler wanted quality and russia had quantity
Spartans Is Make Roman Solidarity Battle Greene 100 Years Later New Age Of War Here Do
It was like watching a wildfire burn
Skill wins batles, numbers win wars.
I could've defended this castle with 19 units of fire rocket samurai.
I thought this was interesting, but I don't understand how jedis = modern army and how the front line soldiers weren't dying from artillery shrapnel from the invading shields, armor, weapons, and body parts being blasted into them.
i was thinking the same .. so fake
Oddly satisfying
Curious...........can you do one using Anime characters?????????
Looks like Sparta won 🏆
Meh. All the arty should have been deployed inside the walls. They could have still hit the middle/back rows. The army should have manned the walls and mined the hell out of the surrounding area. Still a good video;)
I wonder if there is a mod That Makes the body pile realistic
@ 2:21 imagine this shot if it were used for the Battle of Winterfell/or the Dark Night, or the Second Longest Night in GoT. I know itll cost bucketloads of cash, but the story leading up to it deserved a quality shot like this for the show, just to show the magnitude of what theyre facing
i think it was more like 200,000, not 6,000,000
Shouldn't the Army guys be in front of the Jedi? Looks wrong to be shooting from behind 😂 Unless they were shooting down from a hill or something.
Кажется, что отправка джедаев в контратаку была неправильным решением, потому что лишила автора преимущества фортификации - эффекта бутылочного горлышка.
First of all, Jedi are not modern army.
Second, a modern day army would have trenches, mines, and other things like barbed wires blocking the way.
Finally, this was Game of Thrones level of bad position...
ps: Much respect for the people that made the Battle Simulator, this level of quality for a simulation with such insane numbers is on another level.
Saya unlike dulu karena di depan penembak ada pasukan pedang yang itu adalah pasukan sama dengan zaman dahulu meskipun pedangnya pakai laser.. harusnya pasukan Romawi dll juga di beri panah atau bom sederhana
Artillery and machine guns. I bet the defenders will win by a very wide margin. Now let's see how disappointed I'll be after watching this clip
Lasers rays and also nukes should've been used then only we could say it's a win the in today's era modern army's main weapons are long range missiles and also nukes
Эпичненько !!!
This is cool!
Who gonna clean up da mess?
Wish you had a counter to show how many barbarians were getting slaughtered.
I was for sure they would lose.
A few dozen more Jedi and it may have gone the other way… only 100k ish left of 6 mill right?
Jedi would have won if they had the high ground.
항상 잘구경하고갑니다 ^^