Thomas Tuchel: Does it matter that the England manager is German? | ESPN FC

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 88

  • @dziobusz
    @dziobusz День тому +5

    That headline in the mail is embarrassing!

  • @stephenhill545
    @stephenhill545 День тому +3

    Our rowing team was trained by a German. Nobody complained about that. British cycling coaches train other nations. It's the world.

  • @sni6941
    @sni6941 2 дні тому +8

    He is a good choice, he is a tournament manager more than league manager. He can do both job good. But he is good at tactics in one single game to win. Pep is good at league titles over 9 months. But Tuchel is good in a must win game. Just look at how he did with Bayern against Real in UEFA semi finals, 5 min away from the title !

  • @scottipippen6554
    @scottipippen6554 2 дні тому +5

    Dear english patriots: name me one english manager, who has won an international trophy in the past? I have one for you: Alf Ramsey. Since then...nobody!! Name me one english manager on club lever, who has won any major trophy in the last years? I can`t remember one! Alex Ferguson i scottish!
    You just had a larger than life german coach at Liverpool. Tuchel won with Chelsea. Pep with City. Arne Slot is manager at Liverpool right now. Any english manager on a top job in the permiere league? Oh year: nobody!
    It is the year 2024. Get used to it. And support Tuchel!
    All the best for you. Oh year, i am german. And yes, we untill this day, had only german managers with the Nationalmannschaft. Just look up our record in international tournaments, to remind youself, why that is.
    Greets.

  • @bas6628
    @bas6628 2 дні тому +6

    Having a foreign coach isn't a disgrace because the great Brazil have been chasing Italian Carlo ancelotti

  • @ktom5262
    @ktom5262 2 дні тому +7

    Why should it matter that he's German? Even the British royal family is German (Sachsen-Coburg), and it doesn't bother anybody.

    • @leedscity6881
      @leedscity6881 2 дні тому +3

      The Royal family are English/ British, yes if you trace back they are German, but why did you stop there? Why not go back to when they were, Greek, French, Danish, Norwegian etc why cherry pick

    • @ktom5262
      @ktom5262 2 дні тому +1

      @@leedscity6881 Well then, Tuchel being German is an unimportant detail, in the scheme of things.

    • @NicholasWarnertheFirst
      @NicholasWarnertheFirst 2 дні тому +2

      ​@@leedscity6881So why worry about a German manager?

    • @leedscity6881
      @leedscity6881 2 дні тому +1

      @@NicholasWarnertheFirst probably because he isn't English...

    • @NicholasWarnertheFirst
      @NicholasWarnertheFirst 2 дні тому +1

      @@leedscity6881 and if he doesnt sing the national anthem, coz I wouldnt and I English?

  • @BillyBob-e3p
    @BillyBob-e3p День тому +1

    Why is there a lingering resentment that we lost on pens in 1990 and 1996?
    Germany bagged all their penalties and we missed. They were close matches but you cant feel resentment because they are better at pens.

  • @chrischarnock6656
    @chrischarnock6656 2 дні тому +2

    I can think of a lot more darker days in English football such as the fighting at euro 96, drug taking before the euro 2020 and chaos in the stadium during the final between England and Italy, David Beckham over reacting in the papers that caused death threats and I remember a noose around a dummy neck, Sam alladyce and Svens scandal and I can go on and on, tuchel is a great manager and he's better than any English manager we have at the moment

  • @seandixon9321
    @seandixon9321 День тому +1

    Does it not feel a bit odd to be having this conversation in 2024?

  • @martinB68
    @martinB68 2 дні тому +2

    If this was Klopp there would be no problem. Who cares when we win games or a World Cup. Its 2024 not 1945 for Gods sake!

  • @stephenhill545
    @stephenhill545 День тому

    No. It doesn't matter at all. Very happy, that he's got the job.

  • @rotheryberlin7772
    @rotheryberlin7772 20 годин тому

    If Germany is playing against England,
    you'll see, Tuchel is singing both anthems.
    I've not a problem about that.
    Kind Regards from Germany

  • @robdorr1
    @robdorr1 2 дні тому

    Tuchel should pick up the phone and call Jesse Marsch, Canada’s men’s national team manager. He’s an American managing their neighbor to the north. Similar to Tuchel’s situation in England, many Canadian football pundits, indeed many Canadians, were aghast that Canada hired an American coach especially given the rivalry across many sports between the two countries. But, the similarities don’t end there. Just like Tuchel, this is Jesse Marsch’s first foray into international football. They have both managed in the Bundesliga as well as the Premier League and prior to their current appointments, they both had interest in the national team jobs of their home countries. Marsch has completely embraced the Canadian men’s national team job. They had an amazing run at Copa America and in the three games they have played subsequent to the fourth place finish at COPA, Canada has yet to lose a match. Now, obviously results matter in terms of public perception, but let me tell you, the Canadian public has fallen in love with Jesse Marsch. He has embraced what it means to be Canadian, including learning and singing the Canadian national anthem for all 12 matches where he has been in charge.
    I know it sounds stupid, but winning the trust of the supporters is a big part of this job and singing the national anthem will go a long way towards that goal. Tuchel needs to call Marsch ASAP and then just follow the blueprint that Jesse has drawn up because knock on wood, but it’s been hugely successful so far.

  • @AM2K2
    @AM2K2 2 дні тому +10

    England has the best league and the best national team...they should have the best manager!

    • @StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming
      @StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming 2 дні тому

      La liga is the best Hala Madrid

    • @noke258
      @noke258 2 дні тому +2

      ​@@StevieCEmpireofUnitedGamingla liga is farmers league calm down.

    •  2 дні тому +5

      England's league is mostly foreign-owned teams, with foreign managers and foreign players. The only English thing is the fans.

    • @StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming
      @StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming 2 дні тому

      Most of the players are English. La liga is clearly a superior league because of Madrid @.

    • @StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming
      @StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming 2 дні тому +1

      @noke258 if it was a farmer league why do teams like Liverpool always lose to RM?

  • @Chiefquimby007
    @Chiefquimby007 2 дні тому +8

    It 100% matters that he is German and not English........because if he goes and wins the world cup that's the only thing that will be remembered

    • @TerribleEnglish
      @TerribleEnglish 2 дні тому

      And remembered by Germans if he beats Germany along the way

    • @10from10
      @10from10 2 дні тому

      Other teams have to knock out Spain, Argentina, Germany , France and Brazil, so Tuchel can play for example Slovakia, or Costa Rica in the wc final, yes this would be the scenario of England winning.

    • @TerribleEnglish
      @TerribleEnglish 2 дні тому

      @@10from10 That sounds like a Southgate scenario

    • @aaropajari7058
      @aaropajari7058 2 дні тому

      Not even close.

  • @aaropajari7058
    @aaropajari7058 2 дні тому +1

    No. Next question.

  • @fethryduck
    @fethryduck 2 дні тому

    The Clock's in England run always a bit slower .

  • @Ultimate-Deadpool
    @Ultimate-Deadpool День тому

    Question should be does it matter if tuchel is foreign, not signaling out being German, that should not matter at all

  • @davegoodwin1950
    @davegoodwin1950 2 дні тому +4

    Wed all prefer an English geezer but they're all shite

    • @garyh1572
      @garyh1572 16 годин тому

      And the players aren't good enough.

  • @Ultimate-Deadpool
    @Ultimate-Deadpool День тому

    Non of these people would care if klopp another German manager got the job would they !!

  • @SmithyInWelly
    @SmithyInWelly 2 дні тому

    Why's Jimmy the Journo so focused on how good Southgate was at every job (politician, chief exec, policy adviser, pr guy) other than managing a football team to win comps?... very odd.

  • @jamesjukebox2386
    @jamesjukebox2386 2 дні тому +3

    NO! the England team are non winners they need the next level, he is a proven cup competition winner, anyone winging are all supporting ENGLISH, Premier league teams with Foreign players, coaches and owners, Wilkommen Tuchel.

  • @JamesR5
    @JamesR5 2 дні тому +8

    Why should Thomas T sing the English National anthem.
    He wants to watch the games & not find himself falling asleep just before it.
    Yawn, yawn, yawn lol 🫏🫏🫏

  • @Flashkoch
    @Flashkoch День тому +1

    I can finally see the problem why the brits won nothing since 1966: It's more important what a coach says to the press and about world problems then what he is doing on the pitch. As a german, good to know, now you have a coach who produces results, but was a catastrophe when talking to the media. This will be...interesting. :D As a Bayern fan I can say withouth the shadow of a doubt that Tuchel was the worst coach we had since a very long time. The good thing for him is he sounds different/more sympathetic in english, but you already know how thinn his skin is, with all of his flaws, he is still the best coach you guys had in a while. I mean, my dog could have produced Southgates results with that ugly thing he calls football. I think England will be a contender next world cup, but too bad that we have the better german coach. ;)

  • @leeturton9254
    @leeturton9254 День тому

    That back page dosent represent me that's for sure...Thomas is a fantastic appointment and the fact he's German only enhances him...everybody knows Germans are winner's when it comes to football...long term England fans know it only too well lol

  • @davegoodwin1950
    @davegoodwin1950 2 дні тому

    He's gotta be better than southgate

  • @weeddegree
    @weeddegree 2 дні тому +1

    Nobody is bothered ffs

  • @andrewpyo
    @andrewpyo 2 дні тому +6

    What a pathetic discussion… they went for Guardiola first because he’s English did they? 😂😂

    • @TerribleEnglish
      @TerribleEnglish 2 дні тому +1

      Do Brazil have an Argentinian coach?

    • @kadarabdullahi
      @kadarabdullahi 2 дні тому +1

      ​@@TerribleEnglishThey were going after an Italian 😂

    • @TerribleEnglish
      @TerribleEnglish 2 дні тому

      @@kadarabdullahi Italy isn't a rival of Brazil in the same way as Argentina

    • @yanni2737
      @yanni2737 2 дні тому +1

      ​​@@TerribleEnglish sorry to disappoint you dude but in the German eyes ,Netherlands is their biggest rival not England.

    • @dominrina1943
      @dominrina1943 2 дні тому

      ​@@TerribleEnglish😂 Whats the fuss in appointing a foreign manager, Tuchel is a known name, can't stand some delusional english fans and ex player pundits, stop being xenophobic. As long as your nation is progressing, it shouldn't even matter. Supposedly if it was your club's foreign manager taking over the job, regardless of the ethnicity, you wouldn't have been bothered with the appointment.

  • @hoerstle6636
    @hoerstle6636 День тому

    Well if you are used to buying good trainers from whatever country for your league you shouldn't wonder if you can't find good homegrown trainers....I mean, how can you expect having good trainers in your country if you do nothing about developing them.....

  • @bas6628
    @bas6628 2 дні тому

    I would have went for Graham potter. Eddie Howe can be selected for euro 2028

  • @MrCharlieC23
    @MrCharlieC23 2 дні тому

    I'd be a bit more worried about the millions of people from vastly different cultures flooding our country than having a German football manager.

    • @NicholasWarnertheFirst
      @NicholasWarnertheFirst 2 дні тому

      @@MrCharlieC23 you havent got any "culture" being a thickheaded little englander so why worry?

    • @ontheturningaway
      @ontheturningaway День тому

      Wow! so there’s *millions* of people coming into England! Too bad facts and statistics prove otherwise little dimbulb

  • @Flashkoch
    @Flashkoch День тому +2

    PS: Dear Brits, you are all basically nothing more than not-so-distant relatives of us Germans. Even your language is of German descent, as well as your Royal Family, so deal with it. 😁✌

  • @Publicistvideos
    @Publicistvideos 2 дні тому +6

    What’s the point of international football? To represent your nation! What’s fun about international football? Rivalries! It shouldn’t just be a cutthroat mercenary thing like a club. It’s honestly kind of embarrassing what England is doing. Can you imagine Brazil having an Argentine manager or vice versa? Not in a million years! Where is England’s pride?

    • @StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming
      @StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming 2 дні тому +2

      Fact is Germany have 4 world cups to England 1. If we cant beat them we recruite them.

    • @Publicistvideos
      @Publicistvideos 2 дні тому +1

      @@StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming I get it, I just think that one of the things that makes football so interesting is that each nation has a different style and tradition. I prefer seeing each nation play its particular way. It just makes me a little sad, especially for a football nation with so much heritage. I also honestly consider the manager to be part of the team, maybe the most important member, it always made sense to me that the manager should have to follow the same citizenship rules as the players. But I know I'm in the minority.

    • @StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming
      @StevieCEmpireofUnitedGaming 2 дні тому +1

      @@Publicistvideos I'm just happy it wasn't Lee he wasnt good enough
      . I understand your point. Thomas has spent enough time in England to comprehend the way English football is played

    • @10from10
      @10from10 2 дні тому +1

      Brazil waited, desperate for Ancelotti for months.

    • @Publicistvideos
      @Publicistvideos 2 дні тому +1

      @@10from10 Yeah I know... but I'm sure some Brazilians would be depressed about having a foreign manager. The thing is you could say that Germany might be England's number one international football rival so it makes it a bit weird.

  • @richiestockton
    @richiestockton 2 дні тому

    this guy you got speaking for the rest of us yeah needs to have tad more authority in the words he speaks the fence sitter

  • @albionmyl7735
    @albionmyl7735 2 дні тому

    🤔No germans are very close to the english....

  • @richiestockton
    @richiestockton 2 дні тому

    absolutely disgraceful that is !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Irisishunter
    @Irisishunter 2 дні тому

    Stevie Nichol should of got the job

  • @hashimrahman51
    @hashimrahman51 2 дні тому

    Has a foreign manager ever won the WC?

  • @michaelmoran1964
    @michaelmoran1964 2 дні тому +2

    Wokey wokey oh dear.👎👎
    Just goes with the narrative I fear.

    • @NicholasWarnertheFirst
      @NicholasWarnertheFirst 2 дні тому

      What is your point; do you sing the national anthem? Saddo. Id rather be 'woke than dead from neck up.