if you just looked at the lyrics to this, you'd think it's a simple love song, but between the drums and her delivery it just has this almost frightening energy to it... like she can't decide if she wants to sleep with this guy or eat him alive. I love it.
This was so much better than "Fetch the Bolt Cutters", which sounds like one, looooong, experimental, thesis project. Still, somewhat pretty, like Fiona.
My girl showed me this the other day and I just stared at this on the screen as I saw one of the most genuinely artful performances I've ever seen in my entire life. She excites me! =)
"He makes my heart a cinemascope screen showing the dancing bird of paradise" A very beautiful and unique phrase. No artist in this world would ever have use it.
You'd be surprised how many "children's songs" actually ARE witches' chants...our few remaining vestiges of pagan tradition fly under the radar as innocuous kids' games.
The evolution of this lady since I first started listening to her way back in '94 has been incredible. Some artists fade or refine as they get older: Fiona distilled.
+Mike F She doesn't stop exploring and every album is something that builds upon itself in musicality and poetry... a true genius especially in today's watered down definition of genius.
I've just discovered this and to me it's an existential mic drop. If I'd managed to create something of this quality I'd have retired said 'I've done my bit, your turn' and walked away.
So was Barry Manilow, Luther Vandross, Andy Williams but that doesn't mean they have a commercial success in life now. I was essentially saying it'd be amazing if she received more credit as there's plenty of plain lazy artists out there that receive waves of fans.
That’s how I used to feel when I was younger like Why isn’t X and Y bigger bands/artists? Waaaa!! Now if I discover some smaller indie band or smthing, I’m cool w/ them not blowing up. It’s like my little secret
Owen Price 2019, and I’m still listening to The Idler Wheel Is Wiser Than the Driver of the Screw and Whipping Cords Will Serve You More Than Ropes Will Ever Do, in addition to When the Pawn Hits the Conflicts He Thinks Like a King What He Knows Throws the Blows When He Goes to the Fight and He'll Win the Whole Thing 'fore He Enters the Ring There's No Body to Batter When Your Mind Is Your Might so When You Go Solo, You Hold Your Own Hand and Remember That Depth Is the Greatest of Heights and If You Know Where You Stand, Then You Know Where to Land and If You Fall It Won't Matter, Cuz You'll Know That You're Right. But I never go wrong with the debit album of the siren that Fiona in Tidal.
I really like the simplicity here. He captures the intensity and passion behind the music while keeping it totally digestible. He doesn't try and cover the song with a narrative he compliments the music with the imagery.
Paul Thomas Anderson nails something vital about Fiona Apple in this video. Above all - beyond her complex persona, daring self-deprecation, record label battles etc - she is one of the great singers of her era. Technically sound, riveting & inventive, with startling range. PTA's camera reveals her soulful intensity & dynamic vocal ability, unobstructed. Cool to see this odd couple forge a working relationship that illustrates what may have drawn them together the first time. 2 rare talents.
Truley amazing song. Brilliant jamming, almost classic orchestra feel, classic choir feel. I'm blown away. Haven't listened to Fiona since the late 1990's. She knows how to craft music, a true genius.
I love when a great music video comes out a long time after a great album comes out. It's like waking up for a little while early in the morning and then going back to sleep for a couple of hours. A reminder of how much you liked the album the year before, and an excuse to listen to it a whole bunch again.
I think she wrote this song with PTA in mind. "He makes my heart a CinemaScope, he's showing the dancing bird of paradise." Also the fact that she doesn't look into the camera gives it a special touch, she's singing her heart out but if she looks into the lense she'll melt like hot butter!
I've been a fan since the 90's , I was today years old when I discovered there was a video for this ! Love it! If only someone had a TV station that played nothing but music videos to promote the music industry...
Fiona Apple has the exquisite ability to outdo herself every time that she releases an album, it’s her still, her soul bare but yet it’s a new her, there’s evolution but within her ... Fetch is another great album , she has yet to disappoint me !
I think this is my favorite song by her, idk why exactly. It's definitely not lyrically the most interesting. I just really like the drums and piano. & her and her sister's voices are just awesome layered like that. It'd be cool if a good like college acapella group did this haha.
No, but they used Fiona Apples _"Every Single Night"_ in Season 3 Episode 7. It's a deliciously surreal song XD. It brought me here to sample Fiona's discography and I'm just astounded by her! I can't believe I'd never come across her before. Handmaids Tale is always introducing me to cool quirky music ; )
@@garychap8384 I discovered fiona through "Every single night" too! It kept coming up in my recommendations untill I finally clicked and fell in love with the so'g and video. But as incredible as fiona is, I can't seem to find other songs of hers that I like as mush as thses two.
The same song was featured yesterday on HBO's Euphoria. I've loved her ever since Tidal, but it's awesome to see that others are continuing to discover her. She's brilliant, right?
This is the first day I heard it 1. *know the whole song by heart* 2. *Watched the video about 12 times today* 3. *Committed a crime of looking depressed* 😭😭😭
GodDAMN has there ever been a music video that so perfectly captured the song it was made for. Fiona Apple and PT Anderson are like artistic soulmates. The song is obviously astonishing in any context, but this visual accompaniment is poetry.
This is sooo sooo sooo wonderful... how I love Fiona and her music. Today Mountain Man released their cover of this song which too is great. But dang I love the beats banging in this original Hot Knife song
Wow. The rhythm and silence and singing and synced song. Beautiful. The piano is key to the drums. It adds character and charm. If I'm butter he's a hot knife. If I'm butter, well welcome to margarine. Cheaper. And all I can afford. This song is brilliant. Takes me to places I wish I could be.
This song has been on my iPod for months. Its so raw, powerful and punchy. This music video captured it so amazingly well. Paul is such a genius. He sure missed working with Fiona, after all these years.
The first couple times: "Maybe he could teach me something, maybe I could teach him too. Even just to show that he, really, got over you." The last few times: "Maybe he could teach me something, maybe I could teach him too. It's not impossible to show that he, really, got over you." And that gives the song a different spin...
This might be my favorite song of her's. It's simple yet complex at once. It's fun but still emotional. It's the type of song that gives way to a very good video. Of course, it's entirely different than anything she's done.
This is the founder of the Free Fiona campaign back in 2004. I am *so thrilled* to see she's putting out material again. I'm going to wait to watch this until I have my headphones with me and can really experience it distraction-free. I can't wait! Hey Pitchfork, thanks for putting this up.
THIS IS SO AMAZING. I love it so much. It perfectly mirrors the response one has when listening to this song alone, on headphones, layers coming in one at a time and building a crescendo... love Fiona and PTA!!!
Thank you for never selling out and for creating some of the most dynamic and creative music that I’ve been lucky enough to have been listening to - from the 90’s through to today, and imho, your music just keeps getting better! When I listened to Tidal, it was a revelation. I thought it impossible that anything could come anywhere close to the perfection that is Tidal. Until When the Pawn... and then Extraordinary Machine... and then the Idler Wheel. Album after album of ‘next level’ musicality, creativity, with lots of love and more than a little rage, you sing the song of my soul, and as the years slip by, my love and gratitude for you and your music only grows! So please keep the music coming...because nobody else does it like you do, Fiona! Genius, pure and simple.
Love this video... "The Idler Wheel..." was hands down my favorite album of 2012... I hope Ms. Apple is working on new material and we won't have to wait another 6 or 7 years... I truly don't think it's gonna be that long... Since releasing " The Idler Wheel..." she's released " Dull Tool" ... Contributed the theme for The Affair... Worked with Blake Mills... Contributed to the Watkins family album... She's been busy since her last album... I LOVE U FIONA APPLE!
Kevin Patrick fast forward to 2018 and it's been _long_ , no sign of new music too, but she's obviously doing much better now and her health is the most important thing :)
+Antonio Martinez Me either! the video is directed by Paul Thomas Anderson, the guy from Magnolia, There will be blood, Boggie nights, Across the universe, Daydreaming of radiohead... and a ton of shit more than i formerly don't know... Nice colaboration... Check out the other videos directed by Anderson, impecable taste.
She really embodied "a cinema scope screen showing a dancing bird of paradise" here. The way she sings, the drumbeat like a heart racing. It's energizing and incredible
I’ve been absolutely in love with this woman since the release of Tidal back in the day. I was fortunate enough to see her 3 times in concert in 1996-1997 and actually got to talk to her at Lilith Fair as she was signing autographs. Super cool girl.
If I'm butter, if I'm butter, If I'm butter, then he's a hot knife, He makes my heart a cinemascope screen Showing the dancing bird of paradise. If I'm butter, if I'm butter, If I'm butter, then he's a hot knife, He makes my heart a cinemascope screen Showing the dancing bird of paradise. He excites me Must be like a genesis of rhythm I get feisty Whenever I'm with him If I'm butter, if I'm butter, If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife, He makes my heart a cinemascope screen Showing the dancing bird of paradise. I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter. If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that He's never gonna need another, never need another. If I'm butter, if I'm butter (I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife) If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife (I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter) He makes my heart a cinemascope screen (If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that) Showing the dancing bird of paradise (He's never gonna need another, never need another) If I'm butter, if I'm butter (I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife) If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife (I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter) He makes my heart a cinemascope screen (If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that) Showing the dancing bird of paradise (He's never gonna need another, never need another) He excites me Must be like the genesis of rhythm I get feisty Whenever I'm with him. If I'm butter, if I'm butter (I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife) If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife (I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter) He makes my heart a cinemascope screen (If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that) Showing the dancing bird of paradise (He's never gonna need another, never need another) If I'm butter, if I'm butter (I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife) If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife (I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter) He makes my heart a cinemascope screen (If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that) Showing the dancing bird of paradise (He's never gonna need another, never need another) I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter. If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that He's never gonna need another, never need another. I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter. If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that He's never gonna need another, never need another. He excites me Must be like the genesis of rhythm I get feisty Whenever I'm with him. [7x] If I'm butter, if I'm butter (I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife) If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife (I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter) He makes my heart a cinemascope screen (If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that) Showing the dancing bird of paradise (He's never gonna need another, never need another)
+Megan Coyle And you can And you can relax around me Maybe he could teach me something Maybe I could teach him, too Even just to reach is triumph Now, I really got a hold on you
What I hear is: "Maybe he could teach me something Maybe I could teach him too Give him just a little teensy tiny piece And then I'll even get a hold of you"
if you just looked at the lyrics to this, you'd think it's a simple love song, but between the drums and her delivery it just has this almost frightening energy to it... like she can't decide if she wants to sleep with this guy or eat him alive. I love it.
+hail satan those two desires are not mutually exclusive.
hail satan is on for dudes.
okay but that’s ur personal opinion
I see it deeper than sleep could provide
It is absolutely eat him alive.
I love how this was the direction she went in for Fetch the Bolt Cutters.
YES! I said the same thing. The vocal layering and the percussive noises. LOVE IT
Yes!
Absolutely!
This was so much better than "Fetch the Bolt Cutters", which sounds like one, looooong, experimental, thesis project. Still, somewhat pretty, like Fiona.
My girl showed me this the other day and I just stared at this on the screen as I saw one of the most genuinely artful performances I've ever seen in my entire life. She excites me! =)
How can just drums, a sprinkling of piano, and her multitracked voice produce all this intensity? She is fantastic.
her sister also sings on this track!
Because it's Fiona Apple
Not even drums, just drum!
The lady Fiona is singing this duet with is Maude Maggart, her sister.
@@RandomDudeOne you can hardly call it a duet, Maude is just providing harmony vocals.
This song never fails to leave me pumped. It’s almost 2 am, I just finished a painting and imma go punch a wall.
Yes dude yes
its 4 am here and im doing exactly that, finishing this painting and punching walls.
Lol
Damn your imagination VIVID 😯😯❤️🤘
Show us the painting
this song is so cinematic, surprised it hasn't been used in a film
This video was directed by PTA
+QBoyVids PRAISE OUR LORD AND SAVIOR PAUL THOMAS ANDERSON
+discojack Gorgeously shot video. I agree, surprised it hasn't been used in a film.
It would overwhelm the film.
He directed some of her best videos and broke her heart so she could write some amazing songs about it. Hes the best.
"He makes my heart a cinemascope screen showing the dancing bird of paradise"
A very beautiful and unique phrase. No artist in this world would ever have use it.
The only person that could is Regina Spektor. The more I listen to apple the more I see the similarities between them
@@stalecornchips9968 I like Regina Spektor but no, Regina's lyrics are more simple.
@@mitoproducer1075 definitely not the case, you must not have heard her older songs and her unreleased songs
You mean it’s not “cinnamon scones”? Lol
A gorgeous line, absolutely miraculous in its construction. And to the Regina Spektor group - I'd love to hear Fiona sing "All the Rowboats."
This is something between a playful children song and chants in a witches' ceremony.
You'd be surprised how many "children's songs" actually ARE witches' chants...our few remaining vestiges of pagan tradition fly under the radar as innocuous kids' games.
Jazz
@@iksaxophone what
😂❤
Children music for adults
The evolution of this lady since I first started listening to her way back in '94 has been incredible. Some artists fade or refine as they get older: Fiona distilled.
***** Eh - '96, then. Whatever, it was a long time ago. But thanks for pointing it out, I guess?
Mike F Perfect description of her musical evolution. I'm stealing it. ;)
With her, it's totally true. :)
+Mike F She doesn't stop exploring and every album is something that builds upon itself in musicality and poetry... a true genius especially in today's watered down definition of genius.
+Mike F I agree. The Idler Wheel... is literally the BEST Fiona album, and it's her fourth. Sadly, most artists can't even say that!!
Coming back to Fiona is like coming back to some comfort food after eating shit for a week straight.
atyourbest THIS. ya tore the words straight outta my soul,,,
feel da same jajaja
Word
Her delivery of this song is just so phenomenal it never gets old
It's exquisite with headphones.
I've just discovered this and to me it's an existential mic drop. If I'd managed to create something of this quality I'd have retired said 'I've done my bit, your turn' and walked away.
She should be way bigger, it's nuts how talented she is and how good and ranged her songs are.
So was Barry Manilow, Luther Vandross, Andy Williams but that doesn't mean they have a commercial success in life now. I was essentially saying it'd be amazing if she received more credit as there's plenty of plain lazy artists out there that receive waves of fans.
She doesn't want to be big, she has struggled with her mental health in the past. She was huge in 1996 with the release of Criminal.
She'll be remembered in centuries when most popular artists of today will be forgotten...
She's pretty much as big as you can get without being a popstar and from what I know of her she'd like to keep it that way
That’s how I used to feel when I was younger like Why isn’t X and Y bigger bands/artists? Waaaa!! Now if I discover some smaller indie band or smthing, I’m cool w/ them not blowing up. It’s like my little secret
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is how you build to a crescendo.
Paul Thomas Anderson and Fiona Apple is always going to be a winning combination when it comes to music videos. Two greats.
HE EXCITES ME
must be like the genesis of rhythm
I GET FEISTY
whenever I'm with him
🌹
YarrBr0
Awesome lyric😎
I love belching that verse haha!
"Maybe you could teach me something
Maybe I could teach you too
Even just to reach is a triumph
And now I've really got a hold on you"
-that last bit
And sometimes the SOME in something thing is on the down beat, sometimes it’s on the up beat.
@@scottboyan i noticed as well thank you for stating it =]
Sigh... here goes another day of listening to Fiona Apple over and over.
Another night for me, but yes same here, I could listen to most of her songs forever...
#relatable in 2018
Owen Price 2019, and I’m still listening to The Idler Wheel Is Wiser Than the Driver of the Screw and Whipping Cords Will Serve You More Than Ropes Will Ever Do, in addition to When the Pawn Hits the Conflicts He Thinks Like a King What He Knows Throws the Blows When He Goes to the Fight and He'll Win the Whole Thing 'fore He Enters the Ring There's No Body to Batter When Your Mind Is Your Might so When You Go Solo, You Hold Your Own Hand and Remember That Depth Is the Greatest of Heights and If You Know Where You Stand, Then You Know Where to Land and If You Fall It Won't Matter, Cuz You'll Know That You're Right.
But I never go wrong with the debit album of the siren that Fiona in Tidal.
And now 2020. Just waiting for the new album. I remember her saying early 2020. Ready when you are Fiona!
Not anymore ;)
Man she really is one of the best songwriters ever
A pure, genuine, musical genius.
I really like the simplicity here. He captures the intensity and passion behind the music while keeping it totally digestible. He doesn't try and cover the song with a narrative he compliments the music with the imagery.
It's a more mature PTA
Named my daughter Fiona and this is her song. I sing it to her every day. Simple, clever & upbeat.
lmao name her boyfriend shrek idiot
oof
You do not and never did.
The way she expresses herself when she sings can make me laugh or cry. Such soul. What a great artist.
Paul Thomas Anderson nails something vital about Fiona Apple in this video. Above all - beyond her complex persona, daring self-deprecation, record label battles etc - she is one of the great singers of her era. Technically sound, riveting & inventive, with startling range. PTA's camera reveals her soulful intensity & dynamic vocal ability, unobstructed. Cool to see this odd couple forge a working relationship that illustrates what may have drawn them together the first time. 2 rare talents.
They dated throughout the 90s...he knows her well
One of the best songs ever made
Truley amazing song. Brilliant jamming, almost classic orchestra feel, classic choir feel. I'm blown away. Haven't listened to Fiona since the late 1990's. She knows how to craft music, a true genius.
The harmonic choices make my brain go sideways. Her vocal ability is incredible. She's not just a great emale singer, she's a great performer.
Fiona's sister is in this video, woman on the left
Fiona's sister's stage name is Maude Maggart =)
Didn't know that!
I was wondering who that was.
@@Ellier215 Me, too! Finally found this comment after scrolling.
I love when a great music video comes out a long time after a great album comes out. It's like waking up for a little while early in the morning and then going back to sleep for a couple of hours. A reminder of how much you liked the album the year before, and an excuse to listen to it a whole bunch again.
I think she wrote this song with PTA in mind. "He makes my heart a CinemaScope, he's showing the dancing bird of paradise." Also the fact that she doesn't look into the camera gives it a special touch, she's singing her heart out but if she looks into the lense she'll melt like hot butter!
Masterpiece. Among her many masterpieces. Such worlds and talent contained in her tiny frame.
This is the first time I hear Fiona, just one word: amazing.
Gina Tomé You are.
I always love when I fall back into a Fiona Phase. She's phenomenal, and, whoooo maaaaan, can she capture a feeling.
The layering builds and builds--like climbing a tall staircase. Love to work out to this song! Fiona forever!
I've been a fan since the 90's , I was today years old when I discovered there was a video for this ! Love it! If only someone had a TV station that played nothing but music videos to promote the music industry...
PT Anderson films her like no one. He reveals her beauty in a striking way
OMG! I did not know the video for this song exists till now !!!
It's the last track on "The Idler Wheel ...".
@@BryceKatz but the real last track is "Largo". It fits and ends album absolutely great like a poignant farewell.
Fiona Apple has the exquisite ability to outdo herself every time that she releases an album, it’s her still, her soul bare but yet it’s a new her, there’s evolution but within her ... Fetch is another great album , she has yet to disappoint me !
I think this is my favorite song by her, idk why exactly. It's definitely not lyrically the most interesting. I just really like the drums and piano. & her and her sister's voices are just awesome layered like that. It'd be cool if a good like college acapella group did this haha.
***** shes the one that looks like an evil witch version of fiona. scary witch mole and all.
Bradley Holtan this comment made me laugh so hard
KAyA thanks, I try to amuse myself. Fiona's starting to look pretty scary witch version herself nowadays, :(
Bradley Holtan 😩😩😩😂😂😂🙊🙈😩
agreed. and in spanish or portugese.
Fiona and Paul Thomas Anderson = explosive! How I love all the videos you did together!! And what a songwriting, what a recording, what a voice!
AHHHHHH THIS SONG IS SO DOPE!!!!
This is the one I play to people who've never heard Fiona Apple before. Works every time.
This was my earworm for the day. A completely genius video for a completely genius song.
1:04 That smirk gets me everytime! LOVE THIS!
Approaches performance art. Harmonies here are manic gold. So good.
I've been in love with Fiona longer than any other woman in my lifetime. She's a bold, beautiful, musical genius.
How the hell am I hearing her for the first time in 2019?
Thanks Handmaids Tale, you never fail to expand my horizons.
They used this for the handmaid's tale?
No, but they used Fiona Apples _"Every Single Night"_ in Season 3 Episode 7.
It's a deliciously surreal song XD. It brought me here to sample Fiona's discography and I'm just astounded by her! I can't believe I'd never come across her before.
Handmaids Tale is always introducing me to cool quirky music ; )
@@garychap8384 I discovered fiona through "Every single night" too! It kept coming up in my recommendations untill I finally clicked and fell in love with the so'g and video. But as incredible as fiona is, I can't seem to find other songs of hers that I like as mush as thses two.
The same song was featured yesterday on HBO's Euphoria. I've loved her ever since Tidal, but it's awesome to see that others are continuing to discover her. She's brilliant, right?
@@garychap8384 The same happened to me! Amazing music! :)
This is the first day I heard it
1. *know the whole song by heart*
2. *Watched the video about 12 times today*
3. *Committed a crime of looking depressed*
😭😭😭
She's ALWAYS been SOOOOOO DAMN AMAZING!!!!.....(even in person!....she's so down to earth!!!) I will NEVER STOP LOVING HER!!!!)
I have loved this song for YEARS; how did I not know about this amazing - amazingly beautiful, amazingly simple - video?
GodDAMN has there ever been a music video that so perfectly captured the song it was made for. Fiona Apple and PT Anderson are like artistic soulmates. The song is obviously astonishing in any context, but this visual accompaniment is poetry.
For me Fiona Apple is the most interesting Artist of the past 20 years. Needless to say I'm a big fan :-)
Same. Who else has such a near perfect catalogue and has never once let anyone influence her art?
"Idler Wheel" is a FUCKING MASTERPIECE.
idler wheel is my favorite and i really don’t think it gets the love it deserves
To me this song perfectly represents Fiona Apple's unique place within our culture: she is a singular genius who delivers on her own terms
Fiona is a real artist, like Janis or Bjork. She creates her own sound, and doesn't need to copy. Brava sis and thanks for showing us the way.
This is sooo sooo sooo wonderful... how I love Fiona and her music. Today Mountain Man released their cover of this song which too is great. But dang I love the beats banging in this original Hot Knife song
Wow. The rhythm and silence and singing and synced song. Beautiful. The piano is key to the drums. It adds character and charm. If I'm butter he's a hot knife. If I'm butter, well welcome to margarine. Cheaper. And all I can afford. This song is brilliant. Takes me to places I wish I could be.
This is pure magic by a pure magician.
This song has been on my iPod for months. Its so raw, powerful and punchy. This music video captured it so amazingly well. Paul is such a genius. He sure missed working with Fiona, after all these years.
This is the coolest minimalistic love song!!!
love this album - again and again
The first couple times: "Maybe he could teach me something, maybe I could teach him too. Even just to show that he, really, got over you."
The last few times: "Maybe he could teach me something, maybe I could teach him too. It's not impossible to show that he, really, got over you."
And that gives the song a different spin...
plz explain
Esta mujer es increíble... no deja de sorprenderme desde la primera vez que la escuche. Es magnífica.
This might be my favorite song of her's. It's simple yet complex at once. It's fun but still emotional. It's the type of song that gives way to a very good video. Of course, it's entirely different than anything she's done.
This is the founder of the Free Fiona campaign back in 2004. I am *so thrilled* to see she's putting out material again. I'm going to wait to watch this until I have my headphones with me and can really experience it distraction-free. I can't wait! Hey Pitchfork, thanks for putting this up.
Makes me think that i am watching a 1920's Hollywood Movie with ward winning sound track. amazing!
I can't get over how beautiful this is... Her natural way is so intriguing. Amazing!
I love Fiona Apple. Wish I had the chance to see her in concert. When she is singing, you feel the emotion.
Her vocal delivery is otherworldly.
THIS IS SO AMAZING. I love it so much. It perfectly mirrors the response one has when listening to this song alone, on headphones, layers coming in one at a time and building a crescendo... love Fiona and PTA!!!
Thank you for never selling out and for creating some of the most dynamic and creative music that I’ve been lucky enough to have been listening to - from the 90’s through to today, and imho, your music just keeps getting better! When I listened to Tidal, it was a revelation. I thought it impossible that anything could come anywhere close to the perfection that is Tidal. Until When the Pawn... and then Extraordinary Machine... and then the Idler Wheel. Album after album of ‘next level’ musicality, creativity, with lots of love and more than a little rage, you sing the song of my soul, and as the years slip by, my love and gratitude for you and your music only grows! So please keep the music coming...because nobody else does it like you do, Fiona! Genius, pure and simple.
I can't get enough of this song, i'm so full but i need more
I remember her debut CD. Fell in love with her perfect blue eyes. And the disc was amazing.
This song is often described as "simple." Yeah, it is simple, but it's also the best song on that album imo
QUE VONTADE INSUPORTÁVEL E INCONTROLÁVEL DE CHORAR... DE ONDE VEM TANTA POESIA, QUEM DOTOU A RAÇA HUMANA DE TANTO SENTIMENTO...
Pure fantastic.
Simplicity done perfectly! PT Anderson is a master. Fiona is great too! Love her music.
Love this video... "The Idler Wheel..." was hands down my favorite album of 2012... I hope Ms. Apple is working on new material and we won't have to wait another 6 or 7 years... I truly don't think it's gonna be that long... Since releasing " The Idler Wheel..." she's released " Dull Tool" ... Contributed the theme for The Affair... Worked with Blake Mills... Contributed to the Watkins family album... She's been busy since her last album... I LOVE U FIONA APPLE!
Kevin Patrick fast forward to 2018 and it's been _long_ , no sign of new music too, but she's obviously doing much better now and her health is the most important thing :)
Her new album is coming this year!
I didn't jibe with this song at first. Then I listened a few more times and realized...it's incredible. Love this album
decided to leave a comment this time. I love her songs so much
Thanks Fiona!!! your music is pure art!!!....is a fresh air in this decadent period of music.......
I bought this album two years ago, I never even bothered to see if there was a video for this great catchy tune.
+Antonio Martinez Me either! the video is directed by Paul Thomas Anderson, the guy from Magnolia, There will be blood, Boggie nights, Across the universe, Daydreaming of radiohead... and a ton of shit more than i formerly don't know... Nice colaboration... Check out the other videos directed by Anderson, impecable taste.
+Ariel Copello Thank you Miss Copello,sorry for my late reply
+Ariel Copello He also used to date her, during the Magnolia period.
This is my favourite song from the album and honestly one of the most original song ever! I'm so glad it got a cool video
This song is sooooo good, Like probably my current favorite song ever. She lip syncs so well in this video too.
It's like she's lip acting!
because maybe she's not!?
She really embodied "a cinema scope screen showing a dancing bird of paradise" here. The way she sings, the drumbeat like a heart racing. It's energizing and incredible
Aaaaaaand now it's stuck in my head all day.
I’ve been absolutely in love with this woman since the release of Tidal back in the day. I was fortunate enough to see her 3 times in concert in 1996-1997 and actually got to talk to her at Lilith Fair as she was signing autographs. Super cool girl.
Absolutely amazing. Such a talent it gives me chills of goodness.
I never knew about this collaboration between Fiona and Paul!!! love them
this is probably the fourth time they collab
Did she write any songs about him/their break up?
If I'm butter, if I'm butter,
If I'm butter, then he's a hot knife,
He makes my heart a cinemascope screen
Showing the dancing bird of paradise.
If I'm butter, if I'm butter,
If I'm butter, then he's a hot knife,
He makes my heart a cinemascope screen
Showing the dancing bird of paradise.
He excites me
Must be like a genesis of rhythm
I get feisty
Whenever I'm with him
If I'm butter, if I'm butter,
If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife,
He makes my heart a cinemascope screen
Showing the dancing bird of paradise.
I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife,
I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter.
If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that
He's never gonna need another, never need another.
If I'm butter, if I'm butter (I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife)
If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife (I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter)
He makes my heart a cinemascope screen (If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that)
Showing the dancing bird of paradise (He's never gonna need another, never need another)
If I'm butter, if I'm butter (I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife)
If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife (I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter)
He makes my heart a cinemascope screen (If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that)
Showing the dancing bird of paradise (He's never gonna need another, never need another)
He excites me
Must be like the genesis of rhythm
I get feisty
Whenever I'm with him.
If I'm butter, if I'm butter (I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife)
If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife (I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter)
He makes my heart a cinemascope screen (If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that)
Showing the dancing bird of paradise (He's never gonna need another, never need another)
If I'm butter, if I'm butter (I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife)
If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife (I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter)
He makes my heart a cinemascope screen (If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that)
Showing the dancing bird of paradise (He's never gonna need another, never need another)
I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife,
I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter.
If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that
He's never gonna need another, never need another.
I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife,
I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter.
If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that
He's never gonna need another, never need another.
He excites me
Must be like the genesis of rhythm
I get feisty
Whenever I'm with him.
[7x]
If I'm butter, if I'm butter (I'm a hot knife, I'm a hot knife)
If I’m butter, then he's a hot knife (I'm a hot knife, he's a pat of butter)
He makes my heart a cinemascope screen (If I get a chance, I'm gonna show him that)
Showing the dancing bird of paradise (He's never gonna need another, never need another)
Do you know what the lyrics are for the line that starts with, "Maybe he could teach me something, maybe I could teach him, too...?"
+Megan Coyle And you can
And you can relax around me
Maybe he could teach me something
Maybe I could teach him, too
Even just to reach is triumph
Now, I really got a hold on you
Omg THANK YOU!!! I've been trying to figure that out forever!
What I hear is:
"Maybe he could teach me something
Maybe I could teach him too
Give him just a little teensy tiny piece
And then I'll even get a hold of you"
@@Shai_xu this is 2 years old but THANK YOU SO MUCH
What a music video. This is how you showcase such a unique song
This is a masterpiece song and video. Love Fiona Apple
I absolutely love this song, can't help replaying it over and over again.
this song is amazing
So excellent and great-So soul-like voice
when i discovered this song i was literally obsessed you don't understand
The mash up is great and omg when the piano kicks in its awesome.
If I'm butter, if I'm butter,
If I'm butter, then he's a hot knife,
He makes my heart a cinemascope screen
Showing the dancing bird of paradise.
This is my favorite song on her Idler Wheel album and the video is perfect, too.
I woke up with this song playing in my head. Catcy yet good.
Incredible writing. Such pure creativity.