Whistle Duel: PRR 3 Chime VS PRR Banshee Whistle Threshermans Reunion 2013 Rough and Tumble

[@vector6977]

Love the control on the Banshee whistle, "HOOOOOWEEEEEEEEEE"!

[@55theredengineproductions62]

I dont it sounds creepy

[@AnhNguyen-fm6nc]

@@55theredengineproductions62 U

[@seymoarsalvage]

@@55theredengineproductions62 i love creepy ;)

[@joenayrikafletcher738]

Prr three chime : singing .
Banshe whistle: HOWEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

[@christophercarey3232]

I'd like to hear an LNER 4 inch three chime whistle be blown with these two.

[@markusdude1]

That is definitely one of the best tuned 3 chimes!

[@josephignudo7405]

I love the sound of the banshee. Spine tingling

[@cjholden8991]

I love the sound as well as my dad does own a banshee with the original valve included as well

[@roccotoothycombs]

I live along the former prr mainline...im sure this is what i would have heard..

[@bhomas_real]

I shed a tear listening to this.

[@alexthesouthernpacificmt4879]

Sᴀᴍᴇ

[@steamgent4592]

Now that was a great show!!!! Shame they don't do stuff like that every year!!

[@mikediesel928]

0:20 rails unlimited PRR t1

[@Lindenify1010]

ah nostalgia when my grandpa used to take me to thresheries

[@diamondjubilee7754]

Question: Does the Lehigh Valley Railroad Single Chime whistle sound the same as the PRR banshee? Or is the LV whistle at a slightly lower note? The LVRR used a 3 chime whistle for passenger engines/mixed-traffic engines, and a shrill single chime whistle for freight engines.

[@cjholden2903]

DiamondJubilee I’m not really sure what LVRR used for passenger and freight, I know of two surviving examples of LV whistles. Both are Hancock, one is a flat top and the other is a steptop. They are both longbells of course.

[@diamondjubilee7754]

Single chime bell whistles similar to the PRR's own freight 'banshees' were used on switchers as well as some classes of road freight engines; others carried Crosby chime whistles.

[@ArkansasLocomotiveWorks]

What engine sported the 3 chime originally?

[@timothybarney7257]

ALW Productions not that it holds 100% true, usually, the banshee would have been on freight locomotives, and the 3 chime passenger on the PRR.

[@Leatherface123.]

PRR T1

[@justahillbilly7777]

@@Leatherface123. That or a K4.

[@Pianoman71213]

Hate to be ya'll's neighbor. Oh wait a minute, no I wouldn't.

[@atsffan-lm9ib]

Same

[@adamcartwright4542]

Thats the drugs I want to be addicted to

[@randomkid7164]

Prr Banshee whistle : destroy ear
Prr 3 chime whistle : ghost whistle

[@kkhagerty6315]

Most people have a knocker or a doorbell. These guys have a steam whistle

[@chrishinnant3924]

They're having a conversation with each other

[@TheSteamAndGasShowsAndMore]

Wish I could own a PRR Banshee

[@brianfalzon6739]

That's PRR 3 Chime sounds like MRSR 5's whistle and as for the Banshee Whistle, sounds like the one Strasburg 89 has it!

[@SuperFoxyRailwayProduction6702]

Or a K4

[@rhondanugent7648]

0:20. This whistle is featured as The PRR T1 whistle in rails unlimited 😍

[@cjholden8991]

I usually go up to central pa and railfan there

[@toysallyear]

0:23 what does that sound like

[@hbissonnette2577]

there goes my speakers

[@JOEMAMA_534]

The 3 chime sounds like the MTH Railking PRR 2-8-0 whistle (PS2)

[@SuperFoxyRailwayProduction6702]

Fun fact: this whistle was also used on R&N #425 in the 90s

[@SuperFoxyRailwayProduction6702]

0:20

[@Photonic64]

I'd pay to get actual drawings of these whistles... Machinists need to be able recreate these sounds accurately.

[@UnofficialATKProductions]

in my opinion the PRR 3 chime was the best sounding to me

[@That_One_Guy_In_A_Band]

Wow... I love the banshee whistle... But, what engine/ railroad is that?

[@cjholden8991]

banshee is on an aultman taylor 20-60. 3 chime is on the shay #4 at the r&t fairgrounds in kinzers pa

[@That_One_Guy_In_A_Band]

oh, it's a shay, huh? cool... I thought it was a little 0-4-0 or something...

[@cjholden8991]

nope

[@That_One_Guy_In_A_Band]

Beautiful engine, too... that whistle really suits her...

[@cjholden8991]

that is a PRR 3 chime. Me and my dad are looking for one of those, we have been looking for around 6-9 months.

[@steamlocomotive611producti5]

I wish this can happen again one day.

[@RailfanLoy]

I think I found the video of the whistle for the t 1 in Rails unlimited in Roblox

[@raymondleggs5508]

Good for bad neighbors who play music too loud.

[@victoriacyunczyk]

I do the same thing, but with recordings.

[@kindcake]

Where is that at

[@darknessfalls_hellfire2551]

Is that a t1or a k4 whistle on that steam engine at 0:20? If so i sure does sound like one..

[@SuperFoxyRailwayProduction6702]

K4

[@JinmeeBanana]

NO IS T1

[@ThatOneMichiganRailfan]

3 Chime wins by far!

[@roccotoothycombs]

Fenderfoamer would be proud

[@nssteampunk4865]

The banshee sounds like Mt. Rainier 0-4-0 #2 and the PRR 3-chime sounds like Mt. Rainier 2-8-2 #5.

[@cjholden8991]

hmm, intresting

[@nssteampunk4865]

CJ Holden The 3-chime is probably an Ashton since PRR/B&M/LIRR used them in service. That was the whistle that Mount Rainier #5 got as a gift from a rail fan that really cared about the #5 even though #5 originally had a 5-chime while in revenue service.

[@cjholden8991]

It belongs a close friend of mine, he got it at an auction

[@anthraciteproductions4732]

Erich Diebold I love the Pennsylvania railroad 3 chime

[@alexthesouthernpacificmt4879]

Hol up is that a real train wearing the t1 whistle?

[@CCXmas]

@Matthew Bacon IM MT4 IM SOUTHERN I READY TO FOR T1 TO COME BACK SO I SAY IT GROW

[@amtrakproductions-mx9ib]

Prr 3 chime wins

[@cjholden8991]

then show him

[@MasenMonster]

*1187 ALL THE WAY!!!*

[@TheMNrailfan227]

Banshee wins