@@warriorskitcat3859 had she not have given up her kits there might have been another brokenstar, I don’t think it was a bad decision personally, the kits Grew up happy (except moonkit rip) but moonkit dying couldn’t have been predicted. What makes it a good decision are the wagers, 1. Let your kids live a happy life, just without you and 2. Let your clan fall under a dictatorship which will end in mass bloodshed. And because of Crookedstar’s super edition we know thistleclaw would’ve been as bad as tigerxlawbc we saw him training in the dark forest
i like this book, don’t get me wrong. but god does it feel like it takes such a wrong turn as soon as….spoiler warning . . . . . . . . . as soon as raggedstar becomes clan leader, everything just goes to shit. FOXHEART being deputy? making BROKENTAIL a warrior before finishing final assessments? like bffr
my thoughts/theories/musings throughout this book =^w^= (spoilers for up to this book part and previous books in PUBLISHING order!) 0:00 (26/3/24 13.10) -raggedpelt will definitely become raggedstar in this part -maybe brokentail will become leader too? i doubt it'd happen this quickly though 5:12 -damn quicker than I expected ;--; 6:25 -oo i wonder who the deputy will be, since brokenpaw is too young -foxheart maybe? 18:24 -nepotism lolol -no but like half of warrior cats is like nepotism 24:28 -ok I'm headcanoning this (boulder liking brokentail) as a crush XD 31:44 -i feel so bad for nightpelt D: -are cat inhalers really all that much to wish for? 36:47 (14.30) -honestly I need a book from the POV of this world's rats -either these ones or the skyclan ones 42:48 -cloudpelt's body? :0 43:21 -ok i was wrong -but brokentail is still doing suspicious activities 50:19 -ok yellowfang's explanation for his name is really sweet actually 1:05:36 -noooooooooooooo cloudpelt :ccc -also brokentail >:( 1:09:21 -a medicine cat is SUPPOSED to question you 1:47:00 -:(( -i wonder how she'll find out it was brokentail that killed him?
Yellowfang and bluestar both had to give up their kits and mates for their clan..
I wish we got to see them be better friends 😭Yellowfang should have lived longer
both didn't want to in the end, one was forced, and the other was a bad choice
Which one was forced? And which one was a bad choice, I can’t remember lol
@@Claibornenice yellowfang was forced to and bluefur made the *bad* decision
@@warriorskitcat3859 had she not have given up her kits there might have been another brokenstar, I don’t think it was a bad decision personally, the kits Grew up happy (except moonkit rip) but moonkit dying couldn’t have been predicted.
What makes it a good decision are the wagers, 1. Let your kids live a happy life, just without you and 2. Let your clan fall under a dictatorship which will end in mass bloodshed.
And because of Crookedstar’s super edition we know thistleclaw would’ve been as bad as tigerxlawbc we saw him training in the dark forest
If anyone is to blame for what Brokenstar did, that would be both Lizardstripe and Raggedstar.
poor yellowfang her son too
And Yk brokenstar
Thanks for uploading this it's hard for me to find the books 😅
They are sold on Amazon or at a bookstore called Barnes n Noble!
it took me until page 401 of this book to realize runningnose is not female
i like this book, don’t get me wrong. but god does it feel like it takes such a wrong turn as soon as….spoiler warning
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
as soon as raggedstar becomes clan leader, everything just goes to shit. FOXHEART being deputy? making BROKENTAIL a warrior before finishing final assessments? like bffr
TO RIGHT !
classic nepotism
Who came first? The mudpaw or the mudfur? Hmmmm
I think that's an error because Mudfur was a warrior before he became a medicine cat.
1:36:41 running nose is such a precious Tom
she really warm him he no listing she
Bookmarks:
54:08
1:33:38
1:33:17
Bookmark
30:00
56:58
1:20:45
my thoughts/theories/musings throughout this book =^w^=
(spoilers for up to this book part and previous books in PUBLISHING order!)
0:00 (26/3/24 13.10)
-raggedpelt will definitely become raggedstar in this part
-maybe brokentail will become leader too? i doubt it'd happen this quickly though
5:12
-damn quicker than I expected ;--;
6:25
-oo i wonder who the deputy will be, since brokenpaw is too young
-foxheart maybe?
18:24
-nepotism lolol
-no but like half of warrior cats is like nepotism
24:28
-ok I'm headcanoning this (boulder liking brokentail) as a crush XD
31:44
-i feel so bad for nightpelt D:
-are cat inhalers really all that much to wish for?
36:47 (14.30)
-honestly I need a book from the POV of this world's rats
-either these ones or the skyclan ones
42:48
-cloudpelt's body? :0
43:21
-ok i was wrong
-but brokentail is still doing suspicious activities
50:19
-ok yellowfang's explanation for his name is really sweet actually
1:05:36
-noooooooooooooo cloudpelt :ccc
-also brokentail >:(
1:09:21
-a medicine cat is SUPPOSED to question you
1:47:00
-:((
-i wonder how she'll find out it was brokentail that killed him?
27:53
11:10
1:41:40
40:46
1:15:51