it's a japanese mv so it's no surprise the reactions got blocked, with their strict copyright law. Plus it's not to be published in any streaming sites but got leaked hence the many blocked reactions that time.
CMIYC was supposed to be a gift for their Tokyo Dome concert(they were gonna show the mv during the concert) but I guess it got scrapped after Jessica's departure and they rerecorded everything so that's probably why the mv itself was incomplete. I like the mv for OT8 more since the mv was definitely better and the choreography looks more refined too. Seohyun and Sooyoung got more parts with Japanese releases because they're the best at speaking Japanese, especially Sooyoung. I definitely understand your sentiments especially since their peak was during OT9 and one of SNSD's brands was their sister bond. Plus Jessica has been there for the first 7 years which was basically most of their active career.
Let's not forget that jessica was actually the first trainee under sm out of all the members. She trained for 7 years along with soo young (and hyo i think).
Jessica was a part of the group when most of us have gotten into them. She shared their sweat and tears and stood on the top of the world with them. Of course we miss her. We miss the golden age, the simpler times, theirs and our own youths. But it’s been a long time since the group became 8. They wiped off the tears they shed in Tokyo Dome and moved on. They proved they are still “it” as a group and they grew tremendously as individuals. They are not exactly the same group without her but they aren’t less either. It’s just a new chapter and it’s beautiful too. Personally, I like “Lion Heart” way more than “Gee”. And I do consider “Holiday Night” one of group’s best albums overall. Many of my favorite concert lives of theirs are also OT8 without Jess’ presence being a criteria. I’d lie if I said an OT9 comeback wouldn’t make my decade but it’s an unfair expectation to put on the girls who’ve done and proven so much after surviving a catastrophe. That includes Jessica.
I agree with this perspective that the girls all have moved on. We can't expect from them, as fans, to reunite when they already took care of all the sharp edges left after the break. They broke up. They moved on. An OT8 comeback would be way better than forcing Jessica back into a group she doesn't belong to anymore. But GG's time with her was iconic and I don't think anyone regrets it. And as fans supporting our favourite artists, we shouldn't either.
Taeyeon mentioned that they avoided to perform this song because they could taste blood after the performance (it like the feels after you exercise so hard) 😂
Me too. I'm an OT9 but I moved on. They are OT8 now. Every member is equally important to me. If a lead dancer left, I think the impact is still the same. If a lead vocalist left, still the same impact... They all have purpose in the group... And the OT8 Lion Heart album is really great. One of their best. Along with Holiday Night. But my Top 1 is still their japanese albums. Its all OT9 and all bops.
@@ghadamh1793 Kinda sad that they parted ways like this with Jessica... I just hope that we'll see them again as 9 even not on stage... But as just friends... :(
"They are not exactly the same group without Jessica but they aren't less either" I'm just reading some comment and saw this and I AGREE bigtime. OT8 worked their ass off to stay on top. They even won bonsang with just a short time of promotion with their Holiday night album. Their song Holiday even entered World chart (Billboard ) comparing to their other songs.
Surprised to see you react to the ot9 version too! I remember the day it got leaked and the fandom went crazy. Would love to hear what you think about some more of SNSD"s japanese songs specifically their slower songs like Divine, Time Machine and Indestructible!
I apologize if my thoughts on OT9 upset you. I will obviously continue to react to SNSD OT8 as well. I was just trying to explain that I miss Jessica in their newer songs. Feel free to let me know your thoughts. Hopefully I didn't upset anyone. Sorry guys! The video I reacted to with Jessica was cut off at the very end. This was my fault for not finding the right video to react to...but because this video was never officially released I just picked one on UA-cam - my bad!
I feel strongly about OT9. Like OT8 doesn’t even exist in my mind 😂 P.s. I also am not a big fan of the songs after Jessica, they just didn’t seem right.
no reason to hate the girls I am support all 9 I i still don't know y some people not keep all if you are really girls'fan you must love them all the same. + Jessica song name Big mini world English version is so Jessica tell her story and it's also the name of her 1st album.pls try
The full version feels very interesting because when the video starts, Jessica isn't there, then she appears, then by the end she's gone too. It always reminds me of her appearance in SHINee's "Sherlock" as the ghost girl. It's also emotional since there was a short clip of Jessica kind of "behind the scenes" and she was singing the "I'm going to find my heart" part to herself, and this was well before we knew the song existed. And, as Sunny was very close with Jessica, you can notice that Sunny smiles more in the Jessica ver. It's also emotional because Jessica actually had the most lines in this song, while comparing to their last OT9 title tracks "I Got a Boy" and "Mr. Mr.", it seemed like she was getting fewer and fewer lines than before, yet here she was supposed to have the most.
It's based on personal preferences. Holiday and All night is Iconic for me. They debuted as 9 and known as 9 members so obviously if one member left ( not just Jessica) they will never be complete again. Each member has their own charisma and contribution to the group. When Jessica left I still used to love their music because they are still that powerful but you will notice that there's something missing and that's jessica's voice. It happened to them sometimes where one or two of their members are absent during their performances so it through the absence of other members they still perform well but not as good when they are complete. It's a rare situation when Snsd needs to perform and Taeyeon is absent and their performance sounds so plain and not as powerful when Tae is there.
Jessica did a show with her sister before 930 events and she sang a bit of CMIYC during the show so we knew that she was part of this song so we thank our lucky stars to the person that leaked this video. I always thought Jessica's higher pitched voice was key to the GG sound which is why it doesn't feel the same.
Yeah, to be honest I don't get the same feeling from OT8 songs. I enjoy All Night and Lionheart but not to the degree of their older tracks. I actually think the group's sound made more sense as OH!GG (OT5) in Lil' Touch than it did in any of the OT8 songs.
I love OT9 so that's my favorite... Jessica was japanese favorite SNSD member, and that song was a gift for japanese sones in their upcoming concert. Also in Jessica's and Krista's reality show, Jessica hums this song 😁
I remembered I always thought how Jessica would look like with CMIYC outfits, and when the first images of her using those outfits came out, I almost died, she looks amazing :(
Yessss!! 100%. Sir austin you are gonna LOVE this. The girls and peace is OT9 and they harmonize insanely in the beginning. Taensic at its best. And then the ballad version at tokyo dome is a every sone’s must watch.
Honestly, I love both version but for me it's obvious that Korean version was more polished than Japanese version but Ot9 version is good thou since Jessica was there.
I'm a sone since 2008 and their performance when one member is absent was not so perfect unlike when they are complete. Not just Jessica but also other members. I remember the time when they perform without Taeyeon ( It's a rare situation) their performances became plain and not as powerful when Taeyeon was with them because obviously Taeyeon's voice makes their songs and live performances stronger. Each member has their own role in the group so when one member is absent they will never be perfect like when they were complete.
I love both versions, but hearing jessicas voice really hits me. I miss my girls. P.S. jessicas lines: First stanza (Yuri) 2nd stanza (Yoona) Bridge (Sooyoung) high note (Taeyeon)
I remember I was a SONE when i dive into KPOP. It made me heartbroken for years after that 9/30. I was binge watching all of their variety shows. From Hello Baby to Running Man to WGM
The Jessica version is so much better. Even if she only had the one part in the adlib section, her inclusion would still be worth it. The color change from Jessica --> Tiffany --> Taeyeon is PERFECT and a trip while Taeyeon --> Tiffany --> (back to) Taeyeon in the Sica-less version just doesn't make as much "sense" and the power of the moment is so much less.
I knew it. I knew that your opinion will open a debate between sones like what always happened. OT9 and OT8 are both Iconic. It's just that there's something weird when they were performing as 8 because we've known them as 9 members but they aren't less as what some people saying. They are still that powerful even after jessica left and we witnessed how they worked their ass off just to keep their spot on top while facing those haters who keep blaming them for jessica's daparture. I really love You think, Holiday and All night and the bsides on Holiday night album. Their performance in Tokyo dome and Phantasia as 8 members was one of the most Iconic concert that I've ever watched. We understand your preference sir austin 😊 It's just that it feels weird hearing you saying that they had no Iconic songs after Jessica left. Just ignore those hating you about your opinion. It's all about personal preferences after all. Just continue what you're doing as a baby sone. We will support you also on your videos ♥
I haven’t heard a lot of the OT8 songs yet! I’m just saying I didn’t really like Oh GG or TTS as much. I still love all 9 girls. I just miss Jessica’s voice sometimes.
@@SirAustin I understand where you coming from. We all missed Jessica's voice. Take your time for checking out Snsd stuffs. Some of Ot8 songs are my anthem. I wouldn't force you to like TTS songs because I don't like their title track that much either but their b-sides is a must. Thankyou for loving our 9 girls 😊
SNSD were at their peak around 2009-2012, which ended right about when 3rd gen Kpop started. They were definitely popular/relevant and remained at the top of a lot of charts as a girl group in their later years, but GG is mostly known for their earlier stuff. That being said, although their OT9 albums have a special place in my heart, I do absolutely love Lion Heart (the album) their 10th anniversary release. The bsides are amazing in my opinion.
Every member is the secret recipe in snsd Taeyeons powerful vocal Jessica delicate voice Sunnys sweet voice and aegyo Tiffany husky/deep voice Hyoyeons dancing skills Yuri sexiness Sooyoungs savageness Yoona visuals Seohyuns harmonization If one is missing not just jessica but also the other members, it feels incomplete.
SNSD’s songs are made for NINE. Their choreographies are complicated, their songs are hard to sing. Jessica was the main vocalist. After she left, SM give so many lines to Taeyeon because she’s more capable then others (ofc all girls can sing but Taeyeon’s and Jessica’s level is different from others) and then she hurt her voice. In Weekly Idol’s SNSD episode they did the random play dance challenge. Their formations are really difficult usually and guess what happened without Jessica. They changed those choreos to ot8 but that was more confusing I’m happy that they’re doing what they want. Hyoyeon is a professional DJ, Jessica have a successful company, she wrote a book, Taeyeon is focused on her solo music career, YulSooYoongSeo are focused on their acting career, Tiffany is trying new things (She is going to play in the CHICAGO musical as Roxie Hart), Sunny is relaxing, going to variety shows... BUT I wanna see them as NINE again. They don’t need to release music as nine, a selfie is enough for me
Correction- any Snsd songs made after 2014/Jessica’s departure are for ot8 + after she left, other members actually got a lot more lines than they used to, especially Tiffany and she is more than capable.
Even if not to react, you HAVE to watch their episode on running man during their party era. I've showed it to friends who don't even stan SNSD and they all consider one of the best episodes of the show they've seen! Plus it gives you a good look into their personalities! (ps: its the one with the mud obstacle course you've seen clips of a bunch before XD)
I like the CMIYC ot9 version more and yes I'm being biased because Jessica is my ultimate bias. But I'm not saying the ot8 version, is not good. It's great but you can't help it when something was made for ot9 and then reshoot for ot8 unlike Holiday onwards that is really meant for ot8.
*Sunny's smile in OT9 version vs OT8 without it still hits me hard how devastating is it to lose her bestfriend and she can't supress her emotions that time😢😢 although those bad days made them stronger now😊😊*
CMIYC was supposed to have a fierce/sorta sexy concept to it, so Sunny not smiling isn’t really odd in the Korean version. And while the OT9 version sounds stronger with Jessica’s voice in it, I really do appreciate SM giving this song a fairer line distribution with OT8. We almost never get to see the dance line get more than 1 measure of lyrics, so that was a huge treat to have.
Jessica was my bias in SNSD (my first ult bias since 2008) and the morning I woke up to the news that she left the group I felt like the whole world was crashing in on me, I was so devastated. What came after broke me even more, and to this day I regret her decision to write that damning statement about her departure. She burned the OT9 bridge and it saddens me greatly. But I guess my sadness was nothing compared to hers so I understand why she did what she did. Anyway, I guess post Jessica-gate the only song I ever liked was Holiday.
lmao why does Austin keeps on giving me a heart attack since last night. I was abt to sleep and then I got notification on NCT. Meanwhile, this morning I got notification on Chungha, Joy reaction and SNSD. What a blessing 😭
i feel a bit weird about saying 'everything's better with jessica', but i do see your point. i mean, i do totally agree that ot9 is ideal because that's how their legacy started and obviously jessica is awesome. but i don't think that ot8 is worse, per se. as you are a sone, i know you didn't mean this to minimize ot8's success or make them look bad, it's genuinely your preference in their music. however, if a non-fan would say that, it would've definitely been more upsetting. because while the height of their career was during ot9, ot8 was still iconic and they've made it past 10 years swimmingly. i've seen non-fans somewhere claim that snsd flopped when jessica left and it just makes me so sad because they're so incorrect :(( just wanted to point that out, i love your input and love to hear your opinions! it's fun as an older fan to watch new sones flourish :)
Sorry! The everything’s better with Jessica was supposed to be a light hearted joke because I love her voice. It wasn’t my intention to discredit the other 8 members. 🥺 I even said “if you loose any member it wouldn’t feel the same”. It’s not just about Jessica. I’m always sad when a group I love lose any members. 🥲. Jessica’s voice is just so unique.
@@SirAustin I believe they still made an Iconic songs after Jessica left. I'm a big fan of You think, Holiday and All night. And their b-sides on Holiday night album are out of the blue. And their live performances and concerts are all Iconic. You don't have to apologize. Like what you have said it's not only because of Jessica. We felt the same when one member was absent when they were performing. So obviously, when they were performing without the other members even though they still that powerful vocally there's still a weird feeling.Their Ot9 songs are made for 9 of them so basically without one of them it feel strange. But I will give credits to my 8 girls for pulling out all of their songs without Jessica. It's based on personal preferences after all. After Jessica left, my concern was who's gonna be the one who support Taeyeon through out their songs since Taeyeon and Jessica always lead their choruses. But that departure showed the hidden ability of Seohyun, Tiffany , Sunny, Sooyoung and Yuri. They give justice on covering sica's part. I will understand if your opinion may upset some of my co sone since we're protecting Ot8 from some of Jessica solo stan. And the way you said it on your own that after Jessica left they doesn't have an Iconic songs anymore, it feels like downgrading the girls without even watching OT8 MV's and live performances. They still Iconic even after Jessica left. Like what Tiffany said " We work our ass off for where we are now" I witnessed all their struggles for being 9 members to 8 members they really worked hard to keep sailing and to keep being Iconic even though some people throw them all the blame and labeled them as traitor because of jessica's departure. But some of us who's mature enough may understand your preference. Real SONE support OT9 and OT8 even OT5 and their Solo career. We all know that Ot9 reunion is really impossible since 5 of the members are still under SMEnt but seeing them posting and reacting about Ot9 stuff is such a dream come true. They leave a mark on Kpop industry and we witnessed their Legacy from how they started and how they become a living legend. By the way thankyou for reacting on Snsd videos. You're such a great baby sone
YES SIR I AGREE WITH YOU😆😆😆IF THEY ATLEAST REUNION AS OT9, IT'S ENOUGH FOR ME TO DIE PEACEFULLY BUT 'IF'(even tho it's impossible )THEY COMEBACK AS AN OT9 IM SURE IM CRYING AF HEARING THAT NEWS😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I prefer to pretend like the Jessica version of this song doesn't exist. it makes the song 'Divine' more fitting as a final song for Jessica. her lines in the song, like 'we are always one' and Taeyeon saying 'Sayonara wa iwanaide' (don't tell me goodbye)
Ikr! There's something about Jessica voice Jessica voice is magical for SNSD song Please make a reaction for SNSD Japanese ballad song -All My Love Is For You - Time Machine - Divine Thank you Austin Stay safe and healthy 💕
I love the fact that each girl generation member is like different version/era of Boa like if you go back to Boa music you kind of see each of the girl generation members style of music just a thought I had
Ooo yay! This song always gets soooooooo stuck in my head. Like ridiculous...... itll be stuck in my head for days 🤣🤣🤣 I cried when I found the leaked Jessica version. I miss them as 9..... :,(
The only good thing about remaking CMIYC after Jessica's departure is that they got a more fair line distribution... hahaha But I really have no idea why they did release Divine and stuff, but not CMIYC with Jessica...
@@mikanlin not to be rude tho, but jessica didn't really planned to leave snsd back then. That's why she was more upset that SM suddenly decided to leave her our of the group. That's why i don't think divine was supposed to be a mv that tributes for her
@@mikanlin not actually, the song had already been released but not the mv that would be another surprise for the best live a tokyo dome, and in fact the mv was never officially released, it was still leaked, the only official version was the story version.
Watch the Knowing Bros. episode when SNSD were the guests. You'll get a real good feel for the personalities of the members. Plus, Hyo is savage throughout the whole episode.
SNSD did not release a lot of music after Sica's departure from the group. I agree, it isn't the same without her. But I love the SNSD nevertheless. Their last full album is absolutely amazing! I hate the fact that Fany, Soo and Seo left SM before we got to see them perform those songs... Still hate the fact that SM didn't give SNSD the big 10th anniversary comeback they deserved or let them do one last concert as OT8 before the 3 members left SM... because of that, I haven't had closure lol.
For me after Jessica departure from SNSD only You Think and Lil Touch were and are still iconics. You Think blew SONEs minds at the time coz we were used to cute concept and Lil Touch showed us our queens having a more mature performance. Sadly Oh!GG weren't really well promoted even though they hit hard in the charts and with the top 1 views for a sub unit group
Omg!! Even tho SNSD started the photo card trend, older Kpop albums is a hit or miss whether it comes with one. We HYO biased are blessed!! My first comeback with them was The Boys and I also got a Hyoyeon photo card 🥺 my most prized possession I've literally paid double the price for their Japanese singles that had photo cards since they're so rare now 🥲
Also please do Why, and taeyeon's japanese MVs, voice and #Girlsspkout so you can embark your journey to her b-sides. You really missing the good things if you don't do her b-sides 🤧 (but actually i don't mind if you go directly to live performances of Why and Voice 😃) Let me give you the illustration. On that video of Taeyeon's 12 emotional singing that been highly requested, there are ONLY 4 title tracks in it out of 12 songs..that's how good her b-sides are 🤧
CMIYC was really a Japanese single (meant to promote their Tokyo Dome concert) that got a Korean release. There's an OT8 Japanese version, too. Vocally, the OT9 version sounds better because Jessica's voice was in it, but you can see how the video was unpolished and the choreography wasn't as sharp as the one that they released officially.
You are so lucky to get your bias photocard because i always fail to get my bias photocards 😂 Btw it's already 2021, im still waiting for ot9 reunion ❤️ Even though they are now 8+1, as a sone will continue support all of them, thanks for your reactions, thanks for loving Jessica as well❤️
I hope you get to see Hyoyeon's performances in MNET's Good Girl. Her vocals were really showcased there and I think you'd enjoy it! There's Cardi B's Press (dance perf), Blinding Lights, GG, and my personal favourite, Turl!!
to the one who leak the cmiyc version with Jess can you leak Jungsis album too ... it's been stuck in sm basement for a very long time now. Come on do something 😂😂
I will say though, the dancing in the OT8 version is much cleaner and sharper which makes sense because they had more time to practice it. Watching the dancing in the OT9 version I noticed some mistakes and some of the moves were a little sloppy. I'm more used to hearing the OT8 version with live stages and stuff but I also really like the OT9 version too.
many people say that they look like they're switching their positions as main vocal, main dancer, and visual lol yoona has so many lines (bcs she covers sica's parts) so she's the main vocal, taeyeon as main dancer and hyo as visual cause she's so so so so gorgeous in this era😍 i mean they all are, but hyo hits differently
Taeyeon's Top 12 emotional singing for Taeyeon Tuesday Sir Austin 😊
yaassss the live concert version pleaseee
I think Austin said he wanted to listen to more Taeyeon songs so he wouldn't spoil the songs with that video :)
Be careful to not get blocked, when the Jessica version was released and people were reacting SM was striking every single video
it's a japanese mv so it's no surprise the reactions got blocked, with their strict copyright law. Plus it's not to be published in any streaming sites but got leaked hence the many blocked reactions that time.
CMIYC was supposed to be a gift for their Tokyo Dome concert(they were gonna show the mv during the concert) but I guess it got scrapped after Jessica's departure and they rerecorded everything so that's probably why the mv itself was incomplete. I like the mv for OT8 more since the mv was definitely better and the choreography looks more refined too.
Seohyun and Sooyoung got more parts with Japanese releases because they're the best at speaking Japanese, especially Sooyoung.
I definitely understand your sentiments especially since their peak was during OT9 and one of SNSD's brands was their sister bond. Plus Jessica has been there for the first 7 years which was basically most of their active career.
Let's not forget that jessica was actually the first trainee under sm out of all the members. She trained for 7 years along with soo young (and hyo i think).
Thatits not true ... its false a lie spread for sones in 2014 . She talks in her books she never say that she wanna quit . She wass kick out
Jessica was a part of the group when most of us have gotten into them. She shared their sweat and tears and stood on the top of the world with them. Of course we miss her. We miss the golden age, the simpler times, theirs and our own youths. But it’s been a long time since the group became 8. They wiped off the tears they shed in Tokyo Dome and moved on. They proved they are still “it” as a group and they grew tremendously as individuals. They are not exactly the same group without her but they aren’t less either. It’s just a new chapter and it’s beautiful too. Personally, I like “Lion Heart” way more than “Gee”. And I do consider “Holiday Night” one of group’s best albums overall. Many of my favorite concert lives of theirs are also OT8 without Jess’ presence being a criteria. I’d lie if I said an OT9 comeback wouldn’t make my decade but it’s an unfair expectation to put on the girls who’ve done and proven so much after surviving a catastrophe. That includes Jessica.
I agree with this perspective that the girls all have moved on. We can't expect from them, as fans, to reunite when they already took care of all the sharp edges left after the break. They broke up. They moved on. An OT8 comeback would be way better than forcing Jessica back into a group she doesn't belong to anymore. But GG's time with her was iconic and I don't think anyone regrets it. And as fans supporting our favourite artists, we shouldn't either.
It feel so good when you said " yep" on jessica high note😁
Taeyeon mentioned that they avoided to perform this song because they could taste blood after the performance (it like the feels after you exercise so hard) 😂
Me too. I'm an OT9 but I moved on. They are OT8 now. Every member is equally important to me. If a lead dancer left, I think the impact is still the same. If a lead vocalist left, still the same impact... They all have purpose in the group...
And the OT8 Lion Heart album is really great. One of their best. Along with Holiday Night. But my Top 1 is still their japanese albums. Its all OT9 and all bops.
Yeah totally right, we love ot9 but we love & appreciate ot8 equally and all their solo careers too
@@ghadamh1793 Kinda sad that they parted ways like this with Jessica... I just hope that we'll see them again as 9 even not on stage... But as just friends... :(
@Mia Josh We all love the girls...
"They are not exactly the same group without Jessica but they aren't less either"
I'm just reading some comment and saw this and I AGREE bigtime.
OT8 worked their ass off to stay on top. They even won bonsang with just a short time of promotion with their Holiday night album. Their song Holiday even entered World chart (Billboard ) comparing to their other songs.
Surprised to see you react to the ot9 version too! I remember the day it got leaked and the fandom went crazy. Would love to hear what you think about some more of SNSD"s japanese songs specifically their slower songs like Divine, Time Machine and Indestructible!
Hyoyeon really is the best female dancer in Kpop 🤩
I apologize if my thoughts on OT9 upset you. I will obviously continue to react to SNSD OT8 as well. I was just trying to explain that I miss Jessica in their newer songs.
Feel free to let me know your thoughts. Hopefully I didn't upset anyone.
Sorry guys! The video I reacted to with Jessica was cut off at the very end. This was my fault for not finding the right video to react to...but because this video was never officially released I just picked one on UA-cam - my bad!
Please check out SNSD's Holiday & All night 😍. And Taeyeon's "Voice" live performance & her "Why" Mv ( I'm sure it's your style)
It's not your fault. There's no complete OT9 video. That's really just it :)
This is perfectly fine!!!! UA-cam has been slowly getting rid of the OT9 leaked version throughout the years.
I feel strongly about OT9. Like OT8 doesn’t even exist in my mind 😂
P.s. I also am not a big fan of the songs after Jessica, they just didn’t seem right.
no reason to hate the girls I am support all 9 I i still don't know y some people not keep all if you are really girls'fan you must love them all the same. + Jessica song name Big mini world English version is so Jessica tell her story and it's also the name of her 1st album.pls try
Btw, I don't really like the MV with Jessica cuz the choreography has many mistakes, but I just love the fact Jessica is there 🥺
I feel the same way. I like the video for OT8 better. But I think the actual song sounds better with Jessica’s voice.
Man...that white crop top, black pants and boots is just such a fine look. And Sunnys hair, damn. This is definitely up there for fav SNSD dance.
"Lost in Love" and "Lady marmalade" for TaeNy Tuesday
Yes I commented this a week ago so yeees please
UPPPPPP
Yesssss
yes please
Please🙏🙏🙏
The full version feels very interesting because when the video starts, Jessica isn't there, then she appears, then by the end she's gone too. It always reminds me of her appearance in SHINee's "Sherlock" as the ghost girl.
It's also emotional since there was a short clip of Jessica kind of "behind the scenes" and she was singing the "I'm going to find my heart" part to herself, and this was well before we knew the song existed. And, as Sunny was very close with Jessica, you can notice that Sunny smiles more in the Jessica ver. It's also emotional because Jessica actually had the most lines in this song, while comparing to their last OT9 title tracks "I Got a Boy" and "Mr. Mr.", it seemed like she was getting fewer and fewer lines than before, yet here she was supposed to have the most.
yoona goes off in this dance fr her fancam in one concert went viral bc she went CRAZY
SNSD without Jessica is like a drink without an ice..still good but not the best..they still need the ice princess..❤
It's based on personal preferences. Holiday and All night is Iconic for me.
They debuted as 9 and known as 9 members so obviously if one member left ( not just Jessica) they will never be complete again. Each member has their own charisma and contribution to the group. When Jessica left I still used to love their music because they are still that powerful but you will notice that there's something missing and that's jessica's voice.
It happened to them sometimes where one or two of their members are absent during their performances so it through the absence of other members they still perform well but not as good when they are complete.
It's a rare situation when Snsd needs to perform and Taeyeon is absent and their performance sounds so plain and not as powerful when Tae is there.
I think you have a sneaky soft spot for Yoona, you always seem to smile at her in reactions 😂
Also begging for that Hyoyeon on goodgirl reactions 🤣
Jessica did a show with her sister before 930 events and she sang a bit of CMIYC during the show so we knew that she was part of this song so we thank our lucky stars to the person that leaked this video.
I always thought Jessica's higher pitched voice was key to the GG sound which is why it doesn't feel the same.
Yeah, to be honest I don't get the same feeling from OT8 songs. I enjoy All Night and Lionheart but not to the degree of their older tracks. I actually think the group's sound made more sense as OH!GG (OT5) in Lil' Touch than it did in any of the OT8 songs.
CMIYC was surprising for us back then because the dance line sang the verses
I love OT9 so that's my favorite...
Jessica was japanese favorite SNSD member, and that song was a gift for japanese sones in their upcoming concert. Also in Jessica's and Krista's reality show, Jessica hums this song 😁
I remembered I always thought how Jessica would look like with CMIYC outfits, and when the first images of her using those outfits came out, I almost died, she looks amazing :(
Whenever Jessica appeared in snsd videos I always get emotional 😭 oh the ot9 that could've stay together forever. Imagine snsd ot9 comeback.. 😔😔
The fact on line distribution for this song she come the first 😭😭
I think you should react to "into the world [Girls & Peace] in soul" and "into the new world ballad version" it is a treasure I promise. ✨
yessss
Yessss!! 100%. Sir austin you are gonna LOVE this. The girls and peace is OT9 and they harmonize insanely in the beginning. Taensic at its best. And then the ballad version at tokyo dome is a every sone’s must watch.
Taeyeon's A Head of Destiny for Taeyeon Tuesday Sir Austin
One thing I love about this is Hyo getting the dance break center she deserves. 😍
Honestly, I love both version but for me it's obvious that Korean version was more polished than Japanese version but Ot9 version is good thou since Jessica was there.
I'm a sone since 2008 and their performance when one member is absent was not so perfect unlike when they are complete. Not just Jessica but also other members.
I remember the time when they perform without Taeyeon ( It's a rare situation) their performances became plain and not as powerful when Taeyeon was with them because obviously Taeyeon's voice makes their songs and live performances stronger. Each member has their own role in the group so when one member is absent they will never be perfect like when they were complete.
I love both versions, but hearing jessicas voice really hits me. I miss my girls.
P.S. jessicas lines:
First stanza (Yuri)
2nd stanza (Yoona)
Bridge (Sooyoung)
high note (Taeyeon)
I remember I was a SONE when i dive into KPOP. It made me heartbroken for years after that 9/30. I was binge watching all of their variety shows. From Hello Baby to Running Man to WGM
The Jessica version is so much better. Even if she only had the one part in the adlib section, her inclusion would still be worth it. The color change from Jessica --> Tiffany --> Taeyeon is PERFECT and a trip while Taeyeon --> Tiffany --> (back to) Taeyeon in the Sica-less version just doesn't make as much "sense" and the power of the moment is so much less.
GOD BLESS the worker that leaked it. NeveforgetJessicaaaaaaaaaaaaa
I knew it. I knew that your opinion will open a debate between sones like what always happened.
OT9 and OT8 are both Iconic. It's just that there's something weird when they were performing as 8 because we've known them as 9 members but they aren't less as what some people saying. They are still that powerful even after jessica left and we witnessed how they worked their ass off just to keep their spot on top while facing those haters who keep blaming them for jessica's daparture.
I really love You think, Holiday and All night and the bsides on Holiday night album. Their performance in Tokyo dome and Phantasia as 8 members was one of the most Iconic concert that I've ever watched. We understand your preference sir austin 😊 It's just that it feels weird hearing you saying that they had no Iconic songs after Jessica left. Just ignore those hating you about your opinion. It's all about personal preferences after all.
Just continue what you're doing as a baby sone. We will support you also on your videos ♥
I haven’t heard a lot of the OT8 songs yet! I’m just saying I didn’t really like Oh GG or TTS as much. I still love all 9 girls. I just miss Jessica’s voice sometimes.
@@SirAustin I understand where you coming from. We all missed Jessica's voice. Take your time for checking out Snsd stuffs. Some of Ot8 songs are my anthem. I wouldn't force you to like TTS songs because I don't like their title track that much either but their b-sides is a must. Thankyou for loving our 9 girls 😊
SNSD were at their peak around 2009-2012, which ended right about when 3rd gen Kpop started. They were definitely popular/relevant and remained at the top of a lot of charts as a girl group in their later years, but GG is mostly known for their earlier stuff. That being said, although their OT9 albums have a special place in my heart, I do absolutely love Lion Heart (the album) their 10th anniversary release. The bsides are amazing in my opinion.
I’ll have to check it out!
Every member is the secret recipe in snsd
Taeyeons powerful vocal
Jessica delicate voice
Sunnys sweet voice and aegyo
Tiffany husky/deep voice
Hyoyeons dancing skills
Yuri sexiness
Sooyoungs savageness
Yoona visuals
Seohyuns harmonization
If one is missing not just jessica but also the other members, it feels incomplete.
SNSD’s songs are made for NINE. Their choreographies are complicated, their songs are hard to sing. Jessica was the main vocalist. After she left, SM give so many lines to Taeyeon because she’s more capable then others (ofc all girls can sing but Taeyeon’s and Jessica’s level is different from others) and then she hurt her voice. In Weekly Idol’s SNSD episode they did the random play dance challenge. Their formations are really difficult usually and guess what happened without Jessica. They changed those choreos to ot8 but that was more confusing
I’m happy that they’re doing what they want. Hyoyeon is a professional DJ, Jessica have a successful company, she wrote a book, Taeyeon is focused on her solo music career, YulSooYoongSeo are focused on their acting career, Tiffany is trying new things (She is going to play in the CHICAGO musical as Roxie Hart), Sunny is relaxing, going to variety shows...
BUT I wanna see them as NINE again. They don’t need to release music as nine, a selfie is enough for me
Correction- any Snsd songs made after 2014/Jessica’s departure are for ot8 + after she left, other members actually got a lot more lines than they used to, especially Tiffany and she is more than capable.
Seohyun is technically around Jessica level, but yes her vocal color can't be replaced.
@@lasciemie6346 in my opinion seohyun almost there if she dont have a weakness whichis breathe control
youre officially a full blooded Sone.
Even if not to react, you HAVE to watch their episode on running man during their party era. I've showed it to friends who don't even stan SNSD and they all consider one of the best episodes of the show they've seen! Plus it gives you a good look into their personalities! (ps: its the one with the mud obstacle course you've seen clips of a bunch before XD)
Omg this brings back memories 😭😭😭😭😭 at that time it was sooo hard for me to get the leaked ver. with sica
Jessica was the most popular member in Japan
I got the Tiffany young RFYL photo book & the photographs are *chef’s kiss* I have it on my coffee table & I look at thru it when I need inspiration
You got all of the members, you now their name, i so happy for it
I like the CMIYC ot9 version more and yes I'm being biased because Jessica is my ultimate bias. But I'm not saying the ot8 version, is not good. It's great but you can't help it when something was made for ot9 and then reshoot for ot8 unlike Holiday onwards that is really meant for ot8.
*Sunny's smile in OT9 version vs OT8 without it still hits me hard how devastating is it to lose her bestfriend and she can't supress her emotions that time😢😢 although those bad days made them stronger now😊😊*
Woww, u got tiffany album 😍. I'm jealous.
IF SOMEHOW SM can MAKE OT9 REUNION, WITH JUST 1 SINGLE OR ALBUM...
BELIEVEEE MEEE SM STOCK WILL GO UUPPPPPP HIGHER THAN ANY COMEBACK THEY ANNOUNCE.
You and Hyo were meant to be 😂😂
Hyo was finally getting more lines
Facts: Sunny looks so happy in the ot9 version, in the ot8 version she is without facial expression, Jessica sings more in ot9 version.
CMIYC was supposed to have a fierce/sorta sexy concept to it, so Sunny not smiling isn’t really odd in the Korean version. And while the OT9 version sounds stronger with Jessica’s voice in it, I really do appreciate SM giving this song a fairer line distribution with OT8. We almost never get to see the dance line get more than 1 measure of lyrics, so that was a huge treat to have.
@@Lena-zn4remost of the lines in OT8 are shared, they didnt really sing more solos.
I Love snsd and i love austin!
Austin is keeping us fed!!!! I'm here for it 💜🤩
Jessica was my bias in SNSD (my first ult bias since 2008) and the morning I woke up to the news that she left the group I felt like the whole world was crashing in on me, I was so devastated. What came after broke me even more, and to this day I regret her decision to write that damning statement about her departure. She burned the OT9 bridge and it saddens me greatly. But I guess my sadness was nothing compared to hers so I understand why she did what she did. Anyway, I guess post Jessica-gate the only song I ever liked was Holiday.
Still the OT9 is better. There is always something magical about them and they shine the brightest when they are 9. As the girls said it.
I think the version with Jessica is better because is the original and her vocals 😍.
lmao why does Austin keeps on giving me a heart attack since last night. I was abt to sleep and then I got notification on NCT. Meanwhile, this morning I got notification on Chungha, Joy reaction and SNSD.
What a blessing 😭
Mr mr doesnt have photocards .. the album only include a sticker, that have 3 versions. But they have postcard sets but it was sold separately 😅.
i feel a bit weird about saying 'everything's better with jessica', but i do see your point. i mean, i do totally agree that ot9 is ideal because that's how their legacy started and obviously jessica is awesome. but i don't think that ot8 is worse, per se. as you are a sone, i know you didn't mean this to minimize ot8's success or make them look bad, it's genuinely your preference in their music. however, if a non-fan would say that, it would've definitely been more upsetting. because while the height of their career was during ot9, ot8 was still iconic and they've made it past 10 years swimmingly. i've seen non-fans somewhere claim that snsd flopped when jessica left and it just makes me so sad because they're so incorrect :(( just wanted to point that out, i love your input and love to hear your opinions! it's fun as an older fan to watch new sones flourish :)
Agree,...
Sorry! The everything’s better with Jessica was supposed to be a light hearted joke because I love her voice. It wasn’t my intention to discredit the other 8 members. 🥺
I even said “if you loose any member it wouldn’t feel the same”. It’s not just about Jessica. I’m always sad when a group I love lose any members. 🥲. Jessica’s voice is just so unique.
@@SirAustin I believe they still made an Iconic songs after Jessica left. I'm a big fan of You think, Holiday and All night. And their b-sides on Holiday night album are out of the blue. And their live performances and concerts are all Iconic.
You don't have to apologize. Like what you have said it's not only because of Jessica. We felt the same when one member was absent when they were performing. So obviously, when they were performing without the other members even though they still that powerful vocally there's still a weird feeling.Their Ot9 songs are made for 9 of them so basically without one of them it feel strange. But I will give credits to my 8 girls for pulling out all of their songs without Jessica. It's based on personal preferences after all. After Jessica left, my concern was who's gonna be the one who support Taeyeon through out their songs since Taeyeon and Jessica always lead their choruses. But that departure showed the hidden ability of Seohyun, Tiffany , Sunny, Sooyoung and Yuri. They give justice on covering sica's part.
I will understand if your opinion may upset some of my co sone since we're protecting Ot8 from some of Jessica solo stan. And the way you said it on your own that after Jessica left they doesn't have an Iconic songs anymore, it feels like downgrading the girls without even watching OT8 MV's and live performances.
They still Iconic even after Jessica left. Like what Tiffany said " We work our ass off for where we are now" I witnessed all their struggles for being 9 members to 8 members they really worked hard to keep sailing and to keep being Iconic even though some people throw them all the blame and labeled them as traitor because of jessica's departure.
But some of us who's mature enough may understand your preference.
Real SONE support OT9 and OT8 even OT5 and their Solo career. We all know that Ot9 reunion is really impossible since 5 of the members are still under SMEnt but seeing them posting and reacting about Ot9 stuff is such a dream come true. They leave a mark on Kpop industry and we witnessed their Legacy from how they started and how they become a living legend. By the way thankyou for reacting on Snsd videos. You're such a great baby sone
YES SIR I AGREE WITH YOU😆😆😆IF THEY ATLEAST REUNION AS OT9, IT'S ENOUGH FOR ME TO DIE PEACEFULLY BUT 'IF'(even tho it's impossible )THEY COMEBACK AS AN OT9 IM SURE IM CRYING AF HEARING THAT NEWS😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
IM DYING TO HAVE TIFFANY ALBUM!!! T--T
When I got my (only korean SNSD album) Holiday Night it came with my bias Taeyeon!! haahhaa
I didnt know ponytail flips is a thing or even a word but well...when u said it Sir Austin, YES I LOVE A GOOD PONYTAIL FLIPS TOO hahaha
Nice u got photocards and albums haha thanks for the reactions❤️
Im happy to see the albums you have 😭. Never too late to be a Sone
Huhu my OT9 heart 😭
I prefer to pretend like the Jessica version of this song doesn't exist. it makes the song 'Divine' more fitting as a final song for Jessica. her lines in the song, like 'we are always one' and Taeyeon saying 'Sayonara wa iwanaide' (don't tell me goodbye)
Please react "Divine" MV and performance on tokyo dome :(
Ikr!
There's something about Jessica voice
Jessica voice is magical for SNSD song
Please make a reaction for SNSD Japanese ballad song
-All My Love Is For You
- Time Machine
- Divine
Thank you Austin
Stay safe and healthy
💕
TaengSig were the perfect main vocal harmony of all time!
I love the fact that each girl generation member is like different version/era of Boa like if you go back to Boa music you kind of see each of the girl generation members style of music just a thought I had
Party, Lion Heart, Holiday, All Night was iconic as much as other title tracks before jessica left.
Ooo yay! This song always gets soooooooo stuck in my head. Like ridiculous...... itll be stuck in my head for days 🤣🤣🤣 I cried when I found the leaked Jessica version. I miss them as 9..... :,(
I love that u didn’t experience snsd with jessica but still prefer ot9. Im sone 10 years im still not over jessicas departure im always ot9.
It's nice to see that you can recognize all of the girls, so proud of you haha
I'm shocked that your wall is green screen. OH MY GOD, I can't wait for you to arrive at their 10th aniversary comeback
Miss jessicaaaa🥺🥺🥺🥺
The only good thing about remaking CMIYC after Jessica's departure is that they got a more fair line distribution... hahaha
But I really have no idea why they did release Divine and stuff, but not CMIYC with Jessica...
Because Divine is suppose to be the song dedicated to Jessica leaving. That's why she's still in it.
@JUST KPOP THING oh yeah, isn't the official version the story one?
@@mikanlin not to be rude tho, but jessica didn't really planned to leave snsd back then. That's why she was more upset that SM suddenly decided to leave her our of the group. That's why i don't think divine was supposed to be a mv that tributes for her
The official Divine mv was released before Jessica’s departure on The Best album dvd
@@mikanlin not actually, the song had already been released but not the mv that would be another surprise for the best live a tokyo dome, and in fact the mv was never officially released, it was still leaked, the only official version was the story version.
Watch the Knowing Bros. episode when SNSD were the guests. You'll get a real good feel for the personalities of the members. Plus, Hyo is savage throughout the whole episode.
SNSD did not release a lot of music after Sica's departure from the group. I agree, it isn't the same without her. But I love the SNSD nevertheless. Their last full album is absolutely amazing! I hate the fact that Fany, Soo and Seo left SM before we got to see them perform those songs... Still hate the fact that SM didn't give SNSD the big 10th anniversary comeback they deserved or let them do one last concert as OT8 before the 3 members left SM... because of that, I haven't had closure lol.
i'm excited to see what you'll think about this one!!
Yes!!! Hardcore SONE since their rookie days knows that TaeYeon and Jessica literally carried the group with both of their vocals..!
Everything is better with jessica jung 😌😌😌 BARS
“See through because of green screen”
My dumb ass thought that was your wall 😭 HAS IT REALLY BEEN FAKE THIS ENTIRE TIME?!
For me after Jessica departure from SNSD only You Think and Lil Touch were and are still iconics. You Think blew SONEs minds at the time coz we were used to cute concept and Lil Touch showed us our queens having a more mature performance. Sadly Oh!GG weren't really well promoted even though they hit hard in the charts and with the top 1 views for a sub unit group
????? Not you disregarding a whole ass iconic Lion Heart like that. That’s one of their most popular songs post Jessica’s departure !!
@@aqsah14 it's only facts. It may be iconic to you but after Jessica departure the majority remember SNSD Oh!GG coz of the impact
I envy for those of the GG albums ....😭😭😭😭...
My favorite SNSD song EVER💜✨
Omg!! Even tho SNSD started the photo card trend, older Kpop albums is a hit or miss whether it comes with one.
We HYO biased are blessed!! My first comeback with them was The Boys and I also got a Hyoyeon photo card 🥺 my most prized possession
I've literally paid double the price for their Japanese singles that had photo cards since they're so rare now 🥲
Everything it’s better when SNSD have Jessica TT
Yep, i’m OT9 Stan
Also please do Why, and taeyeon's japanese MVs, voice and #Girlsspkout so you can embark your journey to her b-sides. You really missing the good things if you don't do her b-sides 🤧 (but actually i don't mind if you go directly to live performances of Why and Voice 😃)
Let me give you the illustration. On that video of Taeyeon's 12 emotional singing that been highly requested, there are ONLY
4 title tracks in it out of 12 songs..that's how good her b-sides are 🤧
Jessica is the soul of their songs. Even taeyeon's highnotes, Jessica is helping her in recordings.
CMIYC was really a Japanese single (meant to promote their Tokyo Dome concert) that got a Korean release. There's an OT8 Japanese version, too. Vocally, the OT9 version sounds better because Jessica's voice was in it, but you can see how the video was unpolished and the choreography wasn't as sharp as the one that they released officially.
Pls react to SNSD’s farewell song to Jessica “ DIVINE “ !! Jessica’s WE ALWAYS ONE from DIVINE is really iconic and sad ending..
You are so lucky to get your bias photocard because i always fail to get my bias photocards 😂
Btw it's already 2021, im still waiting for ot9 reunion ❤️
Even though they are now 8+1, as a sone will continue support all of them, thanks for your reactions, thanks for loving Jessica as well❤️
I hope you get to see Hyoyeon's performances in MNET's Good Girl. Her vocals were really showcased there and I think you'd enjoy it! There's Cardi B's Press (dance perf), Blinding Lights, GG, and my personal favourite, Turl!!
Taeny Tuesday
High high high highly recommend
Taeny Lost in Love and their cover song Lady Marmalade
to the one who leak the cmiyc version with Jess can you leak Jungsis album too ... it's been stuck in sm basement for a very long time now. Come on do something 😂😂
I will say though, the dancing in the OT8 version is much cleaner and sharper which makes sense because they had more time to practice it. Watching the dancing in the OT9 version I noticed some mistakes and some of the moves were a little sloppy. I'm more used to hearing the OT8 version with live stages and stuff but I also really like the OT9 version too.
The Ot9 was a beta version it wasnt a finished product but a leaked unofficial version
many people say that they look like they're switching their positions as main vocal, main dancer, and visual lol yoona has so many lines (bcs she covers sica's parts) so she's the main vocal, taeyeon as main dancer and hyo as visual cause she's so so so so gorgeous in this era😍 i mean they all are, but hyo hits differently
A Hyoyeon stan?! Well you have a new suscriber here! ⚡
Sir try the live perf of Flyers or Way To Go(Himnae) pleeease???