An odd coincidence that this video shows up *magickally” in my feed!! I’ve been comparing White’s and Nick’s for work boot. Inside wood-related work but almost always on my feet. I noticed that White’s just recently increased some boot prices by $15-25…
Adarsh Krishnan I really like these guys, they’re excellent people and I’m happy to support them. Being a UA-camr is a lonely job, and it’s always nice to offer a little kindness. Thank you for watching!
I had my Hawthorns for over a decade! My dad had his whites since 1984. I come from generations of wild land fire fighting and as long as you take care of your boots your boots will take care of you!
My husband goes through boots every 3-6 months. The soles thin out, the boot comes apart from the sole, the inside thins out so bad he feels the nails in the boots, etc. We have bought boots from Walmart countless times because it was the only thing in our budget. Then I started buying more expensive boots 100-200 range from Amazon, or other places. But still, nothing lasts. Thank you so much for all your valuable input. I am tired of buying so many pairs of boots for him because they just don't last with the type of work he does. He is always on his feet, and lets face it -he is not a young guy anymore. He's approaching 60, has titanium rods in both of his shins from a car accident and he really needs good boots to keep him going through the day. With all that being said, I really think these would be the best option for him to give him comfort while standing on his feet lifting heavy things all day on a cold concrete floor. With all of your input on quality of boots~ I watched both your other video comparing cheap vs expensive and this video and I would have to say I am convinced buying a pair of Nicks for him would really help. Thank you so much!
I’m so glad to hear that I’ve helped you with these videos! The benefits of good footwear can not be overstated, though I understand needing to stay within a budget. If you email the folks at Nicks you’ll find that they’re extremely helpful and really go the extra mile to make sure you’re happy and get the boots that fit you and your lifestyle.
I would also check out Franks Boots. They are owned by the guy who ran nicks for almost 2 decades. A good number of the craftsman from Nicks now work at Franks. I have Nicks and just purchased a pair of custom Front Range (built on the 55 last) from Franks. 10" rough out toe and heel walnut leather, toe cap, celastic toe, lineman shank, and Vibram 430 soles. I had the uppers custom made to my measurements because stock uppers wouldn't fit correctly. I think the quality is equal or better at Franks and they are a little less expensive. I will say my Nicks are great, also built on the 55 last (the Robert). I can work a trade show on concrete for 16 hours and not suffer knee or back pain. You can't go wrong with either Nicks or Franks. Both are better quality than Whites, in my opinion, and both are American made and owned.
did you ever go through with purchasing a pair of Nicks? wondered how they worked out for you. Nicks is the original and the best. they are the only ones. that offer a try on boot and I think thats a big deal.
I love my Frank's Hand Made Boots. I have a set of their Ground Pounders. I went with the full rough out leather as well. I also got a toe cap and padded collar. I paid about $580 with options. Definitely worth it in my opinion. Once you get a pair of custom fitted work boots you'll never go back. The only thing I'd change about them is the sole. I think when these are do for a resole I'm going with the Honey Vibram. Definitely a little more cushion and grip.
I agree, they’re a game changer. So far I like the honey Vibrams, some have said they wear down too quickly but I have about four months on these and they’re just fine.
Carl my man I honestly love you. Your presentation is great and there's not many guys out there who would destroy their own possessions for us: the people. I look forward to your videos every Friday. It really does help me decompress after a loooong shitty week. I appreciate you so much. You're the man!
Right back at ya man. Doing this is what keeps me going after a crappy day at work when nothing went right, I’m so proud to be a part of your “me time”. You made my day. 🍻
Your reviews are very well researched and communicated. Truly a top reviewer on the tube and I do go down many a rabbit hole so I watch my fair share. Kudos Carl. Very solid.
My moderate arch (what I like) try-on pair of Builder Pros are shipping back tomorrow, unchanged. I've never paid more than $150 for boots before (mind, I'm in my Sixties and have worn boots since I was 18 in the Army), and as near as I can tell what you get for $500 and a precise fit process is a pair of boots which don't fit like "boots," but fit like "socks." This is another level. Beyond my experience. Yes, other producers are this good; I didn't send them my money. I sent Nicks my money, and they've delivered.
I have both Nick's & Wesco. Both are fabulous. Expensive? Sure, they have to be given what goes into them. Worth it? Totally. I can't wait to put mine on in the morning. For people not familiar with this quality of footwear, do yourself a favor, bite the bullet and splurge on a pair. You'll be glad you did. They are A+ quality and will last forever.
I ordered a pair of these with the standard sole and the smooth leather, then I saw yours and really like them. I was able to change my order. I got the gum sole and rough out on the toe and the heel. I've had them since spring 2019 and love them. They fit great, my back doesn't hurt, nor do my feet.
Did you get a warning with the boots, not to stomp too many fires out.? The firefighter boots have a red tab on the sole. The material is harder than standard. It only starts to soften at 400 degrees Celsius and does not catch alight.
I have been anticipating this review!!! You NAILD it!!! I really enjoyed your review. As always you have top notch quality content. I own a pair of the builder pros and also did the fit sheet. Highly recommend the fit sheet. Takes a bit longer but in the end you will be rewarded. When i ordered mine i was coming out of redwing 2416s and had never had the massive logger style sole so i order mine with the mini lug vibram. I regret that choice. I wore them out very quickly. I went through the heel first and my local cobbler replaced the heel with the same vibram mini lug for $20usd. Then the toe part wore through and my cobbler could not stitch through the thick leather. He was able to cut off the old and add a glue on vibram sole for $75usd. Other then that they are absolutely the nicest boots I’ve ever owned. I am ordering a second pair soon so i can send them in for a rebuild and not go naked on my feet lol. Thanks again for what you do!
Another extremely well put together video. I learned a lot about Nick’s and the quality of the boots they produce. From what I’ve seen, I can’t think of any other boot which can compare to the apparent quality, craftsmanship, durability, etc. of the Nick’s boot. I’ve never owned a Nick‘ s boot, but I’ve learned a bit from you and reviewing their website. I always look forward to getting a notification of one of your new videos. Thanks for taking the time to help educate this community. Keep up the good work! By the way, we’ve finally broke through and above 0 degrees Fahrenheit. Enough of this arctic weather. I hope it’s warming up by you, as well.
Haha, it’s getting there... Once this polar vortex goes away. Can you believe it hit -25 in Chicago this week??? Anyhow, these boots are amazing. Not for the faint of heart but they’re extremely tough and well made.
Hey I have a farm boss too. Ive had mine for about 12 years. Stihl quit making them for awhile but its been the best chainsaw, im glad they brought it back.
So the first time I saw your vid I ordered my boots from nicks now that I have them and been wearing them for a bit they are the best boots I've ever owned there absolutely amazing. I went from timberland pros to chippewa to these and ill never go back
Well this video opens up a whole new side of you. Bobber, Mustang? Very good review on the Nick's! Like I said in your previous video. I own 2 pairs of Wescos and 1 pair of Whites... I'm not impressed with the Wescos. However the Whites are amazing. I've spent 23hrs straight in them and pulling them off is like a slipper. If your a working man the two things you spend the most time in are your Boots and your Bed! Don't skimp out on either of them. Have a great day. Really enjoy your videos. Keep up the good work.
I love that saying, though I can’t stand my mattress. My wife picked it out! Yeah man, I’ve been a gear head for a long time and those two projects have more money sunk into them than I care to admit.
In my opinion they're not built quite as well and their price point seems to start higher. I got my Wescos before I knew about Whites, Nicks, Franks and Jk. My next will be Nicks.
You mentioned in your video that you use a wool liner to keep your feet warm in the winter? Do they work? What kind of wool liner do you use? Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks. Love the videos
Hey Carl, just want you to know I really appreciate the work you put into these videos. Thank you for doing so much research, and being honest about your opinions.
I have worn rough out boots for years. They are not more durable. They conceal damage better but the damage is there. Additionally, sand and grit works its way onto the grain of rough out leather much easier and destroys it form the inside. It absorbs more water too and wet/ dry cycles destroy leather more reliably than anything else.
Good vid. I own two pairs of Nicks boots (8" Hotshot & 10" Contender) and I love wearing them. I also own a pair of older White's round toe Packers. Both are of equal quality and fit and both are the best boots I've ever worn.
Iron worker here with almost 3 years on a pair of hotshots . Just had them resoled . Without question the most comfortable boot i own. better even then becks boots from texas
My last Wesco custom builds were $889, but they wear like iron. I have buddies who work on the pipeline and think I'm crazy for spending the money but they drop $250-300 on Redwings, twice a year, so what's the difference, lol? I can offer a tip for the breaking in period, put plastic bags on each foot, put boots on and stand in the bathtub submerged in water. Get them soaked and wear them until they dry. They will form to the foot and be do much more comfortable to wear.
Great review, Carl. Appears to be an excellent work boot. I don't own any true work boots, but I have several pairs of Allen Edmonds and Johnston & Murphy dress boots. I like that they are made in the USA.
Hey Carl, what boots do you recommend specifically for mechanics? I'm not trying to balance anything. I just want some resistance and anti slip for the nasty fluids in the shop and, most importantly, let you stand on concrete for hours and hours. I'm an aircraft mechanic and can not escape concrete.
Damn, that’s a shame. Is it just too narrow? If you go the made to order route at Nicks they’ll make sure you get the fit you need, I’d mention your experience to them so they can build a boot to fit your needs. Nicks really go the extra mile to make sure you’re satisfied.
@@CarlMurawski I tried on all the locally available Whites Smokejumpers I could find, every one of them was too narrow for me. A Nicks 9EE is a LOT roomier in the toe box than any of the Whites I tried. YMMV.
I ordered basically the same pair but haven't received mine yet. The difference in what I got is that I did rough out only on the bottom part of the boot and I went for 8 in instead of 10 in. I'm really excited and can't wait to get them. Should be within the next couple weeks.
Hi Carl, I'm looking for a new pair of boots and I'm just after being in contact with Nicks, their boots look great. What color are yours? They look great. I'm thinking Walnut and I would probably be going for roughout just on the bottom and smooth on the uppers. Thanks in advance.
Great boots and great video. I love your videos. We don’t often see videos with men doing manly things and still being well dressed and well spoken. I think, even at 600 they well worth it and probably not much more than a pair of 150 dollar Carolinas with plastic welts. I have a shoe repair shop and people around here are cheap so I see the cheap ones all the time. Then their rationale for not investing in good boots is because they wear their boots out so quick! The other problem is they often think the 150 dollar boot IS the good boot. The other thing I see with hunting boots like Rockies with some type of tpu sole they just falls apart sitting in their closet because they only wear them 3 times a year. I explain that we can put on new midsoles and a Vibram sole and it’ll never deteriorate and I guarantee my work until they wear out so if in 8 years the sole starts coming off they bring it in and I fix it for free. It costs about 95 bucks for that and they say “But I can get a new pair for 150”. Sometimes it hardly seems worth explaining that for that 65 dollars more they’ll get an inferior sole that will fall apart before they wear it out and they’ll be lucky to get a 1 year warranty, which they won’t need just wearing them hunting but if they should need it it’ll cost 20 bucks to ship them.
Hey Carl, I’m a huge fan. I got 2 questions for you: 1.) I was wondering how long the honey vibram soles lasted on average *for you personally* before you had to replace them. 2.) I was curious about oils, grease, and other preservatives and their effect on the finish of the boot. I recently watched a Nicks video on boot leather and how they darkened when preservative was added. I wanted to know if this darkening was only temporary or if you were stuck with it permanently. What’s youre experience with this? Thanks in advance.
Hey man! I got about two solid years of work out of the honey Vibram soles. It may be more or less depending on your job. The Obenaufs LP I use definitely darkens the leather, but after a through Saddle Soap scrubbing they go right back to original.
@@CarlMurawski Thanks for the feedback! I got a quick follow up question though. Does that mean that one has to choose between keeping their boots properly conditioned or keeping the original color of their boots? If not, would it be possible to keep them oiled *and* keep their original color? Thanks
Thank you for the review; I'm looking here in about six months to get a pair of custom boots made. Either Nicks or JK Boots have been my top choice. Think Nicks might be the go to now!!
I think you said you own some White's Bounty Hunter boots too? Can we get a comparison between the two brands if so? I am stuck between the Bounty Hunter and Robert boot!
I have a pair of Danner power foreman boots that were $380. Most comfortable boots I’ve worn. I do sewer and water and whenever I don’t feel like putting on my rubber boots to stand in water, I use the danners and come out with my feet completely dry. They’re goretex lined and my only complaint is that they’re slippery in mud. Other than that, I highly recommend
Nice!! Great review! I will definitely consider these on my next boot run. The company should send you a pair! Lol a video this good shouldn’t be done for free!
Have you used the honey vibram and the standard soles while working on the railroad? I'm a train conductor. Just ordered a set with the standard soles but might change when they wear out. Also, how long did the honey vibram soles last?
I have a pair of White's Bounty Hunters and a pain of Nicks Builder Pro's . I love the Nicks, dont care for the Whites. My Builder Pro's are the same as their Hot Shots and I really love them.
I have a pair of White's Smokejumpers that I've worn basically daily for 7 years. They're well overdue for a 2nd resole, but I just can't go without them. I'm considering a second pair, and thinking Nick's this time. Any feedback to help me decide on either another pair of White's or try Nick's? Thanks!
Close man! This is a 1964 /2 but I hate saying "and a half" to people because they don't know what it means. Anyhow, I've been working on it for years and I'm hoping to be finished sometime in the next century!
I just ordered Nicks Traveler boots. I wear thorogood now in 13EE and ordered 12.5E in the Nicks. My speed hooks are too close on my Thorogoods which I could wear a 13E if offered by Thorogood. How does your speed hook distance compare to other boots you have worn ?
great boot, ive never had a pair myself but i have a pair of whites smoke jumper. its basically the same boot. best boot ive ever had going the distance and spending 5-600 on boots is def worth it ive been buying 2-300 boots once a year on boots that dont fit right. i werar a 7F no off the shelf brand makes that.... ive been wearing 10 1/2 E to compensate. again worth the 5-600 for 10 years compared to 200 every year. great vids keep em comin
Did your boots seem extra big when you first got them I have same pair with the comp toe it’s definitely a huge toe and the boots are definitely the biggest boots I’ve ever owned but they seem to fit my feet ok other than They hurt to wear but I’ve done my homework and I’m prepared for. A long break in
Have you done any videos on conditioning these boots? I have roughout also and when I put the boot grease on them, it really darkened and "flattened" out the fibers.
Well I used mine this winter and added a wool insole, and used wool socks. That kept me pretty warm but not as warm as an insulated winter boot would. These are like 90% of the time boots, when it gets really cold I break out the Baffins.
False tongue really isn't needed if you're using leather laces. I've used my white's for 4 years, 40 hours a week with no false tongue and there isn't a hint of damage. I think it protects more against nylon laces.
Carl Murawski Thanks for the reply. I’m in the fit sheet process right now. Do you feel you get enough arch support in the moderate last? I’m on the fence. I don’t really like the high arch aesthetic but Nick’s seems to encourage medium/high arch design. If you could do your order over again, would you change anything?
That’s the Carhartt Cryder jacket. It’s pretty awesome, with side stretch panels and gussets in the arms it allows for a huge range of movement. It’s also water resistant, so it’s great for working outside... this is starting to sound like a commercial. Anyway, I love it
Steel and composite toe boots often won't fit your toes correctly, there isn't much that can be done to fix or prevent this and it doesn't generally get better with time leather cloth and pretty much everything else in the boot can mold to your foot but impact rated toes don't.
They do, in fact you have several toe options: Regular leather, celastic (which is like a hard paper), composite, and steel. There may be other sub-categories but you get the idea.
Interestingly enough I went for a moderate arch with a bit of padding. I originally figured the high arch would be the perfect choice, but my try on boots were the moderate arch and so close that the fit specialist suggested modifying those. This is where the fit sheet option is totally worth it, I stand most of the day ranging from 8-12 hours on terrain that’s unforgiving. At the end of the day my feet are still comfortable and supported, even if the rest of me is less so!
Those look like chocolate but Nicks doesn't do the chocolate anymore. It's replaced with the 1964 which while not on their site they will do rough out.
However I've bought many pairs of these quality brands on Ebay for half the price. Many were barely broken in so I've saved a lot of $$ on Ebay. Albeit not custom fit but you get what you pay for.
I get this a lot when I snowshoe, and it’s mostly due to lifting up with your toes and flexing that front muscle. Otherwise it could be a pain they refer to as shin splints
Yeah, but I heard Nick's are a *horrible* snow boot though. Thoughts? That said, I plan to get a pair of nicks Roberts really soon for my work in engineering lab.
I guess it depends on what you need in a snow boot. If you mean insulating, no they’re not great. If you mean grip it will depend on your choice of sole. I got through the winter in mine by using some alpaca wool insoles, they do a nice job of adding warmth. When it got really cold though I grabbed my Baffin boots
They're much better than boots I've had in the past where the soles just become solid. I remember walking around an unfinished house in January in my old Timberland Pros sounding like wooden clogs. The only thing I did with these was add a set of alpaca wool insoles to help with insulation, and they're good down to about 30F degrees, after that I swap to winter boots.
![NICKS BOOTS [ The Robert ] [ The Boot Guy Reviews ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qCF7dfhMtmc/mqdefault.jpg)
Pick up some Nicks Builder Pros here: bit.ly/3T2FA8f
An odd coincidence that this video shows up *magickally” in my feed!! I’ve been comparing White’s and Nick’s for work boot. Inside wood-related work but almost always on my feet. I noticed that White’s just recently increased some boot prices by $15-25…
I grew 50% more chest hair after watching that into. Awesome vid
i finally found someone who balances ruggedness, working, practicality, and style!
Thats exactly what I'm attempting to do. Whether or not I accomplish it is another story! Thanks for watching man.
Practicality...those boots are heavy AF.
Carl you finally have boots as tough as you. Incredible work for a great product.
Thanks so much man! 💪🏼
@@CarlMurawski I like how you people support each other. It's nice to see you all in The Modest Man's videos as well. :)
They may be tough, but they are ugly.
Adarsh Krishnan I really like these guys, they’re excellent people and I’m happy to support them. Being a UA-camr is a lonely job, and it’s always nice to offer a little kindness. Thank you for watching!
Andy Uk then I have more in common with them than I thought! 😁
I had my Hawthorns for over a decade! My dad had his whites since 1984. I come from generations of wild land fire fighting and as long as you take care of your boots your boots will take care of you!
Absolutely!!!
Sold on the rough out! Im so proud to say my boots are older than my kids but think it's time to get these bad boys. LoL..
DAMN! That intro clip though! That could be a Carhartt commercial!
Hahaha, maybe they’ll hire me!
I thought it was 😂
I love that you walk the walk when giving reviews.
Thanks man, I think it means more when someone used a product for its intended purpose.
My husband goes through boots every 3-6 months. The soles thin out, the boot comes apart from the sole, the inside thins out so bad he feels the nails in the boots, etc. We have bought boots from Walmart countless times because it was the only thing in our budget. Then I started buying more expensive boots 100-200 range from Amazon, or other places. But still, nothing lasts. Thank you so much for all your valuable input. I am tired of buying so many pairs of boots for him because they just don't last with the type of work he does. He is always on his feet, and lets face it -he is not a young guy anymore. He's approaching 60, has titanium rods in both of his shins from a car accident and he really needs good boots to keep him going through the day. With all that being said, I really think these would be the best option for him to give him comfort while standing on his feet lifting heavy things all day on a cold concrete floor. With all of your input on quality of boots~ I watched both your other video comparing cheap vs expensive and this video and I would have to say I am convinced buying a pair of Nicks for him would really help. Thank you so much!
I’m so glad to hear that I’ve helped you with these videos! The benefits of good footwear can not be overstated, though I understand needing to stay within a budget. If you email the folks at Nicks you’ll find that they’re extremely helpful and really go the extra mile to make sure you’re happy and get the boots that fit you and your lifestyle.
I would also check out Franks Boots. They are owned by the guy who ran nicks for almost 2 decades. A good number of the craftsman from Nicks now work at Franks. I have Nicks and just purchased a pair of custom Front Range (built on the 55 last) from Franks. 10" rough out toe and heel walnut leather, toe cap, celastic toe, lineman shank, and Vibram 430 soles. I had the uppers custom made to my measurements because stock uppers wouldn't fit correctly. I think the quality is equal or better at Franks and they are a little less expensive. I will say my Nicks are great, also built on the 55 last (the Robert). I can work a trade show on concrete for 16 hours and not suffer knee or back pain. You can't go wrong with either Nicks or Franks. Both are better quality than Whites, in my opinion, and both are American made and owned.
did you ever go through with purchasing a pair of Nicks? wondered how they worked out for you. Nicks is the original and the best. they are the only ones. that offer a try on boot and I think thats a big deal.
I love my Frank's Hand Made Boots. I have a set of their Ground Pounders. I went with the full rough out leather as well. I also got a toe cap and padded collar. I paid about $580 with options. Definitely worth it in my opinion. Once you get a pair of custom fitted work boots you'll never go back.
The only thing I'd change about them is the sole. I think when these are do for a resole I'm going with the Honey Vibram. Definitely a little more cushion and grip.
I agree, they’re a game changer. So far I like the honey Vibrams, some have said they wear down too quickly but I have about four months on these and they’re just fine.
@@CarlMurawski I've heard that but it's a trade off I'm willing to take. I like the black Vibram lug soles but they are a bit slippery on oil.
Same here, and they get pretty stiff in the cold too. Plus we electricians always have issues with our knees so any help I can get is worth it.
@@CarlMurawski How did the honey vibram hold up ?
Carl my man I honestly love you. Your presentation is great and there's not many guys out there who would destroy their own possessions for us: the people. I look forward to your videos every Friday. It really does help me decompress after a loooong shitty week. I appreciate you so much. You're the man!
Right back at ya man. Doing this is what keeps me going after a crappy day at work when nothing went right, I’m so proud to be a part of your “me time”. You made my day. 🍻
You nailed it ! I have a pair of Builder Pro's and I love them. Most comfortable boot I have ever had on my feet.
Your reviews are very well researched and communicated. Truly a top reviewer on the tube and I do go down many a rabbit hole so I watch my fair share. Kudos Carl. Very solid.
shed a tear when you showed that cross-section! Great review, as always!
Hahaha when you make an omelette you’ve gotta break a few eggs!
My moderate arch (what I like) try-on pair of Builder Pros are shipping back tomorrow, unchanged. I've never paid more than $150 for boots before (mind, I'm in my Sixties and have worn boots since I was 18 in the Army), and as near as I can tell what you get for $500 and a precise fit process is a pair of boots which don't fit like "boots," but fit like "socks." This is another level. Beyond my experience. Yes, other producers are this good; I didn't send them my money. I sent Nicks my money, and they've delivered.
I have both Nick's & Wesco. Both are fabulous. Expensive? Sure, they have to be given what goes into them. Worth it? Totally. I can't wait to put mine on in the morning. For people not familiar with this quality of footwear, do yourself a favor, bite the bullet and splurge on a pair. You'll be glad you did. They are A+ quality and will last forever.
I have a Pair of 10” Franks, and Love them. Glad to see the Nicks are working out for you.
I ordered a pair of these with the standard sole and the smooth leather, then I saw yours and really like them. I was able to change my order. I got the gum sole and rough out on the toe and the heel. I've had them since spring 2019 and love them. They fit great, my back doesn't hurt, nor do my feet.
Did you get a warning with the boots, not to stomp too many fires out.? The firefighter boots have a red tab on the sole. The material is harder than standard. It only starts to soften at 400 degrees Celsius and does not catch alight.
I have been anticipating this review!!! You NAILD it!!! I really enjoyed your review. As always you have top notch quality content. I own a pair of the builder pros and also did the fit sheet. Highly recommend the fit sheet. Takes a bit longer but in the end you will be rewarded. When i ordered mine i was coming out of redwing 2416s and had never had the massive logger style sole so i order mine with the mini lug vibram. I regret that choice. I wore them out very quickly. I went through the heel first and my local cobbler replaced the heel with the same vibram mini lug for $20usd. Then the toe part wore through and my cobbler could not stitch through the thick leather. He was able to cut off the old and add a glue on vibram sole for $75usd. Other then that they are absolutely the nicest boots I’ve ever owned. I am ordering a second pair soon so i can send them in for a rebuild and not go naked on my feet lol. Thanks again for what you do!
Thanks for sharing your experience!
Another extremely well put together video. I learned a lot about Nick’s and the quality of the boots they produce. From what I’ve seen, I can’t think of any other boot which can compare to the apparent quality, craftsmanship, durability, etc. of the Nick’s boot. I’ve never owned a Nick‘ s boot, but I’ve learned a bit from you and reviewing their website. I always look forward to getting a notification of one of your new videos. Thanks for taking the time to help educate this community. Keep up the good work! By the way, we’ve finally broke through and above 0 degrees Fahrenheit. Enough of this arctic weather. I hope it’s warming up by you, as well.
Haha, it’s getting there... Once this polar vortex goes away. Can you believe it hit -25 in Chicago this week???
Anyhow, these boots are amazing. Not for the faint of heart but they’re extremely tough and well made.
Loved the cinematography in the into.
Thanks man, I’m trying to develop my technique!
Hey I have a farm boss too. Ive had mine for about 12 years. Stihl quit making them for awhile but its been the best chainsaw, im glad they brought it back.
Extremely accurate overview of these boots. Great job, Carl!
You've teased us too long about these boots, great to see the review. Looks like a solid investor for the working man
So the first time I saw your vid I ordered my boots from nicks now that I have them and been wearing them for a bit they are the best boots I've ever owned there absolutely amazing. I went from timberland pros to chippewa to these and ill never go back
I’m so glad!!! Congratulations!
@@CarlMurawski
Thank you!!
Well this video opens up a whole new side of you. Bobber, Mustang? Very good review on the Nick's! Like I said in your previous video. I own 2 pairs of Wescos and 1 pair of Whites... I'm not impressed with the Wescos. However the Whites are amazing. I've spent 23hrs straight in them and pulling them off is like a slipper. If your a working man the two things you spend the most time in are your Boots and your Bed! Don't skimp out on either of them. Have a great day. Really enjoy your videos. Keep up the good work.
I love that saying, though I can’t stand my mattress. My wife picked it out!
Yeah man, I’ve been a gear head for a long time and those two projects have more money sunk into them than I care to admit.
If you don’t mind me asking, what don’t you like about the wesco’s?
In my opinion they're not built quite as well and their price point seems to start higher. I got my Wescos before I
knew about Whites, Nicks, Franks and Jk. My next will be Nicks.
New favorite channel. Dang, where did my evening go!
You mentioned in your video that you use a wool liner to keep your feet warm in the winter? Do they work? What kind of wool liner do you use? Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks. Love the videos
Ever find out about the liners he used
Another great review! I really like the full rough out leather.
Thanks man! Me too, I’ve come to really love roughout and matte finish leather compared to the shiny stuff.
Hey Carl, just want you to know I really appreciate the work you put into these videos. Thank you for doing so much research, and being honest about your opinions.
I have been using the Chepawwa logger style everyday for the last 2 yrs.. And when I clean them n shine its when they look kool.
I have worn rough out boots for years. They are not more durable. They conceal damage better but the damage is there. Additionally, sand and grit works its way onto the grain of rough out leather much easier and destroys it form the inside. It absorbs more water too and wet/ dry cycles destroy leather more reliably than anything else.
I'm a longtime advocate of all handmade White's, Wesco, Hoffman, Halls, etc. There's no substitute bar none. USA craftsmanship
Great review and awesome boot. Thanks for the thorough breakdown. Very helpful!
Good vid. I own two pairs of Nicks boots (8" Hotshot & 10" Contender) and I love wearing them. I also own a pair of older White's round toe Packers. Both are of equal quality and fit and both are the best boots I've ever worn.
great video and detailed review brother! Those boots are ridiculously tough 💪🏼
Like a monster truck for your feet!
Thanks for the love Barron!
Iron worker here with almost 3 years on a pair of hotshots . Just had them resoled . Without question the most comfortable boot i own. better even then becks boots from texas
You outgrow Wranglerstar in term of cinematography and content, of course just in my opinion. Getting closer to 50K Carl!
Thanks so much man!
@@CarlMurawski This boots is gonna come handy in so many situations, especially during the harsh weather up in the North East right now.
You're not kidding, this whole polar vortex thing has me thrown,
My last Wesco custom builds were $889, but they wear like iron. I have buddies who work on the pipeline and think I'm crazy for spending the money but they drop $250-300 on Redwings, twice a year, so what's the difference, lol?
I can offer a tip for the breaking in period, put plastic bags on each foot, put boots on and stand in the bathtub submerged in water. Get them soaked and wear them until they dry. They will form to the foot and be do much more comfortable to wear.
Great review, Carl. Appears to be an excellent work boot. I don't own any true work boots, but I have several pairs of Allen Edmonds and Johnston & Murphy dress boots. I like that they are made in the USA.
Thank you! These may be a little bulkier than even a rugged boot like the Allen Edmonds Normandy, but then again it's not for everyone.
Hey Carl, what boots do you recommend specifically for mechanics? I'm not trying to balance anything. I just want some resistance and anti slip for the nasty fluids in the shop and, most importantly, let you stand on concrete for hours and hours. I'm an aircraft mechanic and can not escape concrete.
I’ve had the worst experience with my pair of whites smoke jumper steel toe. I’m hoping too get a pair of nicks soon.
Damn, that’s a shame. Is it just too narrow? If you go the made to order route at Nicks they’ll make sure you get the fit you need, I’d mention your experience to them so they can build a boot to fit your needs. Nicks really go the extra mile to make sure you’re satisfied.
@@CarlMurawski I tried on all the locally available Whites Smokejumpers I could find, every one of them was too narrow for me. A Nicks 9EE is a LOT roomier in the toe box than any of the Whites I tried. YMMV.
I ordered basically the same pair but haven't received mine yet. The difference in what I got is that I did rough out only on the bottom part of the boot and I went for 8 in instead of 10 in. I'm really excited and can't wait to get them. Should be within the next couple weeks.
Hi Carl, I'm looking for a new pair of boots and I'm just after being in contact with Nicks, their boots look great.
What color are yours? They look great.
I'm thinking Walnut and I would probably be going for roughout just on the bottom and smooth on the uppers. Thanks in advance.
I'm trying to find out the same thing lol. I want that color but not sure if it's Walnut. I think it is though
Yet another great video
Another great job Carl keep them coming
Thanks so much! I've gotta let the bank account recover after this one though.
Great boots and great video. I love your videos. We don’t often see videos with men doing manly things and still being well dressed and well spoken.
I think, even at 600 they well worth it and probably not much more than a pair of 150 dollar Carolinas with plastic welts. I have a shoe repair shop and people around here are cheap so I see the cheap ones all the time. Then their rationale for not investing in good boots is because they wear their boots out so quick! The other problem is they often think the 150 dollar boot IS the good boot.
The other thing I see with hunting boots like Rockies with some type of tpu sole they just falls apart sitting in their closet because they only wear them 3 times a year. I explain that we can put on new midsoles and a Vibram sole and it’ll never deteriorate and I guarantee my work until they wear out so if in 8 years the sole starts coming off they bring it in and I fix it for free. It costs about 95 bucks for that and they say “But I can get a new pair for 150”. Sometimes it hardly seems worth explaining that for that 65 dollars more they’ll get an inferior sole that will fall apart before they wear it out and they’ll be lucky to get a 1 year warranty, which they won’t need just wearing them hunting but if they should need it it’ll cost 20 bucks to ship them.
Hey Carl, I’m a huge fan. I got 2 questions for you: 1.) I was wondering how long the honey vibram soles lasted on average *for you personally* before you had to replace them. 2.) I was curious about oils, grease, and other preservatives and their effect on the finish of the boot. I recently watched a Nicks video on boot leather and how they darkened when preservative was added. I wanted to know if this darkening was only temporary or if you were stuck with it permanently. What’s youre experience with this? Thanks in advance.
Hey man! I got about two solid years of work out of the honey Vibram soles. It may be more or less depending on your job.
The Obenaufs LP I use definitely darkens the leather, but after a through Saddle Soap scrubbing they go right back to original.
@@CarlMurawski Thanks for the feedback! I got a quick follow up question though. Does that mean that one has to choose between keeping their boots properly conditioned or keeping the original color of their boots? If not, would it be possible to keep them oiled *and* keep their original color? Thanks
Thank you for the review; I'm looking here in about six months to get a pair of custom boots made. Either Nicks or JK Boots have been my top choice. Think Nicks might be the go to now!!
I think you said you own some White's Bounty Hunter boots too? Can we get a comparison between the two brands if so? I am stuck between the Bounty Hunter and Robert boot!
Can't beat the HONESTY OF A WORKING MAN
Real world experience trumps all! I’d love to see how men in other trades like these boots.
Great review. Also, the cleanest kit of Carhartt I’ve ever seen. 😉
I have a pair of Danner power foreman boots that were $380. Most comfortable boots I’ve worn. I do sewer and water and whenever I don’t feel like putting on my rubber boots to stand in water, I use the danners and come out with my feet completely dry. They’re goretex lined and my only complaint is that they’re slippery in mud. Other than that, I highly recommend
Excellent! Gore Tex is an incredible product and is especially useful in footwear
Upgrade to Nick's, White's or Frank's... They're even better😉
J Claydon nah. Especially not Nick’s. They don’t have a waterproof option. And they’re way too expensive. Besides, I love the boots I have
Great video as usual, really nice intro. Does somebody know what the music's name is druing the intro? Thank you.
Nice!! Great review! I will definitely consider these on my next boot run. The company should send you a pair! Lol a video this good shouldn’t be done for free!
Haha, I wish they would!!! 😁
Carl Murawski did they loan you the cut boot for your review?
Have you used the honey vibram and the standard soles while working on the railroad? I'm a train conductor. Just ordered a set with the standard soles but might change when they wear out.
Also, how long did the honey vibram soles last?
I have a pair of White's Bounty Hunters and a pain of Nicks Builder Pro's . I love the Nicks, dont care for the Whites. My Builder Pro's are the same as their Hot Shots and I really love them.
I have a pair of White's Smokejumpers that I've worn basically daily for 7 years. They're well overdue for a 2nd resole, but I just can't go without them. I'm considering a second pair, and thinking Nick's this time. Any feedback to help me decide on either another pair of White's or try Nick's? Thanks!
Can you review franks??
Love my nicks
68 Mustang? I miss mine had it from my 20-30 years old. A decade of great memories!
Close man! This is a 1964 /2 but I hate saying "and a half" to people because they don't know what it means. Anyhow, I've been working on it for years and I'm hoping to be finished sometime in the next century!
@@CarlMurawski nice, it's the first Mustang
I just ordered Nicks Traveler boots. I wear thorogood now in 13EE and ordered 12.5E in the Nicks.
My speed hooks are too close on my Thorogoods which I could wear a 13E if offered by Thorogood.
How does your speed hook distance compare to other boots you have worn ?
great boot, ive never had a pair myself but i have a pair of whites smoke jumper. its basically the same boot. best boot ive ever had going the distance and spending 5-600 on boots is def worth it ive been buying 2-300 boots once a year on boots that dont fit right. i werar a 7F no off the shelf brand makes that.... ive been wearing 10 1/2 E to compensate. again worth the 5-600 for 10 years compared to 200 every year. great vids keep em comin
Did your boots seem extra big when you first got them I have same pair with the comp toe it’s definitely a huge toe and the boots are definitely the biggest boots I’ve ever owned but they seem to fit my feet ok other than They hurt to wear but I’ve done my homework and I’m prepared for. A long break in
Have you done any videos on conditioning these boots? I have roughout also and when I put the boot grease on them, it really darkened and "flattened" out the fibers.
Are logger boots good for all around maintenance, pot holing, tree trimming, etc…
Wonder how those thick threads on the sole would wear on concrete? In the woods no problem but we don't all walk there all the time.
What kind of jacket or coat is that carhartt looks great!!
Does tapered heel really less worn and comfortable than block heel? I am in the process of choosing a Nicks but not sure which heel to go for.
“I don’t know who would cut a $500 dollar boot in half”
Rose anvil: 😳
Hey Carl, how about a vid on that Mustang
Oh man, car videos too?? That would be fun
great video, carl!
Thank you!
nice stang, my fav stangs are the foxbodies.
Love the Fox bodies, especially a notchback. They’re getting hard to find these days though, most people chopped them up to make drag cars.
Are they waterproof? Do they offer custom waterproof boots?
Idk about you but have the pants over the boots keeps the dirt out specially sand not tucking in the pants.
How do you think it would last in rebar?? That has been probable the hardest type of work on any pair of boots I've used.
Hey Carl! I'd like to ask, are those boots also warm? Because I'd like a work boot for winter conditions too. Thanks
Well I used mine this winter and added a wool insole, and used wool socks. That kept me pretty warm but not as warm as an insulated winter boot would. These are like 90% of the time boots, when it gets really cold I break out the Baffins.
Beautiful boots
False tongue really isn't needed if you're using leather laces. I've used my white's for 4 years, 40 hours a week with no false tongue and there isn't a hint of damage. I think it protects more against nylon laces.
You may be right. I've come to kind of like the look, but it's definitely a polarizing style.
Beautiful camera work
Nice boots!
Which last are your rough outs built on?
High arch, medium, or moderate?
Thanks
Those are the moderate arch lasts. 👍🏻
Carl Murawski
Thanks for the reply. I’m in the fit sheet process right now.
Do you feel you get enough arch support in the moderate last?
I’m on the fence. I don’t really like the high arch aesthetic but Nick’s seems to encourage medium/high arch design.
If you could do your order over again, would you change anything?
The rough out is the actual outside of the cow’s hide, like how it is on the animal, the hair side.
Oliver Allen no it isn’t
Hi Carl. What brand is your jacket you used when you cut the wood?
Thank you
That’s the Carhartt Cryder jacket. It’s pretty awesome, with side stretch panels and gussets in the arms it allows for a huge range of movement. It’s also water resistant, so it’s great for working outside... this is starting to sound like a commercial. Anyway, I love it
Thank you!
Btw, Keep up the good work!
I'll try. You keep watching, I'll keep making em!
Did you get toe rub with the composite at first??
Steel and composite toe boots often won't fit your toes correctly, there isn't much that can be done to fix or prevent this and it doesn't generally get better with time leather cloth and pretty much everything else in the boot can mold to your foot but impact rated toes don't.
Do these boots have regular toe nothing added like without the steel toe. I know it’s not what you said will they have it without
They do, in fact you have several toe options: Regular leather, celastic (which is like a hard paper), composite, and steel. There may be other sub-categories but you get the idea.
Hi Carl. Would you mind telling me what last option you went with?
Interestingly enough I went for a moderate arch with a bit of padding. I originally figured the high arch would be the perfect choice, but my try on boots were the moderate arch and so close that the fit specialist suggested modifying those.
This is where the fit sheet option is totally worth it, I stand most of the day ranging from 8-12 hours on terrain that’s unforgiving. At the end of the day my feet are still comfortable and supported, even if the rest of me is less so!
@@CarlMurawski thank you! I appreciate you taking the time getting back to me.
No worries man!
Hi! Just wondering if you chose the high arch or the 55 medium arch
I actually went with the moderate arch last. The high was pretty extreme for me.
Is that the chocolate or the walnut colour?
Those look like chocolate but Nicks doesn't do the chocolate anymore. It's replaced with the 1964 which while not on their site they will do rough out.
Do they make in insulated boot?
So thats the moderate arch?
However I've bought many pairs of these quality brands on Ebay for half the price. Many were barely broken in so I've saved a lot of $$ on Ebay. Albeit not custom fit but you get what you pay for.
If you could, please tell me what color you chose for the sole edging on these
That's natural.
What is a silastic toe?
Sounds like you need two pairs so you have a pair to wear while other is being redone. Double the price or wear a cheaper boot for a while.
Any idea if they make non marking soles
Do u ever get that feeling in your shins that burn and ache
I get this a lot when I snowshoe, and it’s mostly due to lifting up with your toes and flexing that front muscle. Otherwise it could be a pain they refer to as shin splints
Yeah, but I heard Nick's are a *horrible* snow boot though. Thoughts? That said, I plan to get a pair of nicks Roberts really soon for my work in engineering lab.
I guess it depends on what you need in a snow boot. If you mean insulating, no they’re not great. If you mean grip it will depend on your choice of sole. I got through the winter in mine by using some alpaca wool insoles, they do a nice job of adding warmth. When it got really cold though I grabbed my Baffin boots
Carl, are those chocolate or walnut?
If I remember correctly they’re chocolate. Walnut is a bit lighter.
What size are you
I wonder if I could get a pair with lineman shanks
You absolutely can, I know I saw that on the made to order list.
Carl Murawski PERFECT, I’m going to look into them
Try lacing a 16
How are the soles in winter conditions ?
They're much better than boots I've had in the past where the soles just become solid. I remember walking around an unfinished house in January in my old Timberland Pros sounding like wooden clogs. The only thing I did with these was add a set of alpaca wool insoles to help with insulation, and they're good down to about 30F degrees, after that I swap to winter boots.
@@CarlMurawski They sound excellent . I bought Bison wool insoles for my Thorogoods. Kinda thin but they did help a bit.