One mistake is that you say George Harrison did not like experimental music. Of course that is untrue. He later worked with Lennon on Revolution 9 and also an early solo album of his was Electronic Music
@@jamesschwartz3837 Wonderwall Music came first (1968, Apple), it was the soundtrack to the movie of the same name. Then came Electronic Sound (1969, Zapple). Wonderwall's not bad actually.
@@MilesTippett An AI generated YT channel not acknowledging an AI generated hit from last year? And alleging parts of songs have not heard the light of day, while playing those very unheard parts? There's a glitch in the sim LMAO!
@@victorr9166 Now and Then isn't AI-generated. It's all real audio. The "AI" element is an audio separation software used to extract John's voice from a distorted cassette.
'Colliding Circles' might well have been 'Circles', the George Harrison demo from the White Album era. It was released on the 2018 expanded White Album. There's also a solo version from Gone Troppo in 1982.
@@beatlemangle1712 Indeed. Just to clarify, "might well have been" doesn't necessarily mean something was. It's somewhere between a simile and a metaphor 😉
'The Palace of the King of Birds,' is not a George Harrison song it's a Paul McCartney one. It was released on Paul's Rupert cartoon video with a slightly changed title: "The Castle of the King of Birds." The song, "Pink Litmus Paper Shirt," that you played, was a widely circulated bootleg, the title of which is, "Peace of Mind," and it's already been well established that it's not the Beatles. "Madman," gradually changed into, "Mean Mister Mustard" (on Abbey Road) and "Now and Then" has already been released. So basically, your 7 NEVER before ... etc. is a load of crap.
I(t is possible that Colliding Circles is basically the George Harrison song "Circles", which he re-recorded for Gone Troppo in the early 80s, and the official Kinfauns version has been significantly cleaned up.
The Beatles generally agreed that Carnival of Light is pretty crappy, and that's why we haven't heard it. Fans will be disappointed if we ever get to hear it. It's not a psychedelic masterpiece. It's noise. But, yeah, of course I want to hear it too!
It's also NOT a beatles song. It's a Lennon demo that became a McCartney project. Lennon didn't approve of it, Harrison didn't want to do it and probably isn't even on the finished track. Ringo did not want to do it either. This was another Paul McCartney project to relive the Beatles. I'll give Free as a Bird a pass and Real Love because at least all three surviving members participated. They were actually two pretty good Lennon tracks. And it just felt right and exciting in the mid 90's to do that. Doing the same idea 30 years later with George dead and Ringo not wanting to do it... sorry, this is just a Paul project and does not count as a "Beatles song". (technically Real Love and Free as a Bird don't count either, but I think they get a pass... don't water it down Paul with ANOTHER one that's worse)
I'd like Apple to release the nearly 27 minute version of "Helter Skelter" ,"Madman" (as briefly heard in the "Get Back" documentary) and "Brian Epstein Blues".
Aw, man! It's hard to pick just one thing to object to. But I'll say that "Pink Litmus Paper Shirt" and "Colliding Circles" were never Beatles track. A reporter made them up and has long since admitted it.
I've had The Palace of the King of Birds for maybe 20 years. I have all the recordings from the Get Back sessions so, there's probably a few others there that never saw the light of day, other than those sessions. I haven't heard them in at least 10 years so, I'd have to sift through, again. "Now And Then" was released about a year ago. If George didn't like experimental music, why did he do most of the way-out psych tunes and the "Electronic Sound" album?
Many Beatles fans have poured over hours and hours of unreleased material on a number bootlegs... Most of the unreleased stuff never got released for two reasons, it's similar to something else or it just wasn't good enough... I've heard tons of unreleased material, the good stuff is what got released, Anthology had a few tracks that were interesting, some demos that were given to BadFinger or Mary Hopkins, but the hidden gems aren't really out there anymore...
There are dozens of songs (complete or partial) and jams sessions over the years that they were together that are still unreleased. But Pink litmus paper shirt and colliding circles are not valid songs. They were made up titles in an article in 67 in what today would be considered clickbait.
I'm sure there are days and weeks worth of songs, on tape, somewhere in a vault that we will never get to hear, since they will be tied up in Paul's and Ringo's estates for decades AFTER they are both gone!...At 73, I'm not going to stress over missing it, since I got to be there from the beginning!...Just sayin'!
Etc. was considered for Anthology 3 by George Martin so a demo does exist . The Let It Be song “Kingdom of the birds” was used in Paul McCartney& Wings unused Rupert The Bear soundtrack as isnt much different than the Get Back / Let It Be version
From what I've heard about "Carnival of Light", it isn't a song at all, but an avant garde audio collage. I would say the same thing about "Revolution Number 9". You can only stretch the meaning of the word "song" so far.
Colliding Circles doesn't exist. I have the article from USA Today. A writer started that rumour. George Martin was quoted as saying he wish he had a Quarter every time someone asked him about that.
So McCartney masterminded 13 min of chaotic noise, distorted sounds & random shouts? Isn't that pretty much what John's "Revolution #9" was? Makes you wonder why, then, Paul & the others tried to keep #9 off the "White Album."
Paul and the others tried to keep #9 off the white album because it's crap. Just because Paul made "13 min of chaotic noise" doesn't mean he meant it as a beatle track
I didn't like "Carnival of Light", but I loved "The Palace of the King of the Birds". "Now and Then" was great! The rest presented here I had not heard before, but maybe for the best. However, recently I found close to two albums worth of rare tracks that The Beatles either gave away or just never recorded on an official record. There are many other rare hidden Beatles tunes. Check out the live BBC sessions and search UA-cam for other tracks, like Lennon's 1968 "Child of Nature". Familiar melody?
You have not heard «Carnival of Light», because it has never been released. But only a fan-made version is out. That’s made by a fan. The original has nobody heard.
@@Elias_Veine_Wiig Somebody has heard it, perhaps not officially, for the song can be found on UA-cam. It sounds as bad as Revolution #9. Which is probably the only song that I ever hated by The Beatles. A noisy mess. Not even psychedelic.
@@bobmessier5215 Carnival Of Light CANNOT be found on UA-cam (or anywhere else on the internet)...the only ones out there (& on here) are fan made fakes...and btw...rubbish
@@bartonbishoff Well, I'd like to think that's it's actually on UA-cam (!), but I don't believe it, sorry, and with the "Blue Meanies" with their Algorithms working overtime on UA-cam, IF "Carnival Of Light" in Apple's bank of tracks to check for, it would get found pretty quickly & pulled down. However, It's such a rarity, I really doubt it's actually contained in their list of tracks/songs to check for, so maybe it's on UA-cam somewhere, but understandably, I'd like proof, so unless someone can show the link, it's existence on UA-cam will have to remain unsubstantiated. When there was serious debate over whether or nor not Lennon said the "He's not even the best drummer in the Beatles" quip (which he did not)...there was a guy online who claimed to have a tape of John saying it, so those who didn't believe it where getting shouted down, purely because someone said he had a recording, which turned out to be utter nonsense, as it was on a UK radio comedy show in 1983. My personal UA-cam "Blue Meanies" example, I put up a "Private" access family vacation video, just for the immediate family (with links) to view, with "Hey Jude" playing in the background (in a pub scene) & it was very quickly pulled/taken down.....I had to silence that whole section just to to re-post it...
I remember reading in the early 90s that "What's the Next Mary Jane?" was one of the most famously elusive Beatles songs - multiple times slated for release as a single or B-side, but it never left the vault....(the song was finally released on "Anthology 3" in 1996)
it's "what's the new Mary Jane " I think and not "what's next Mary Jane" ? we could find it on bootlegs in the 70's , I have it on an LP called " live at shea stadium 64" ( which is not shea stadium but Hollywood bowl in reality) on a dutch label and on the B-side of this record after live songs there is two christmas songs ( fan club christmas songs ) and the song "what's the new Mary Jane "
@xavierp4097 You are correct. Sometimes, I overlook the predictive completion of words on Android. And, sometimes the words filled in make no sense. At any rate, I have heard parts of the song and, parts are all I could really listen to. I think what he. John, had done on the song was not Beatles worthy. I felt the same about Not Guilty, a George sing that Jackie Lomax had a minor hit with. Most, but not everything they did, was very good to great. Another that both John and Paul thought highly of, because it was different and "fun" to record is You Know My Name (Look Up The Number). It might be okay as a novelty song, but, imo, even Brian Jones guesting on sax doesn't save it as Beatles quality.
Hmm... not sure why Now and Then is included here, when you even included snippets of the recent official video. McCartney supposedly has the only copy of Etcetera. The Palace of the King of Birds was Paul's, not George's, used in the Rubert the Frog cartoon. I often wonder if Colliding Circles was really referring to Circles, written by George Harrison during The White Album period.
"Madman was recorded in 1965". No it wasn't (try 1969). "Palace of the King of Birds was by George Harrison". No it wasn't. "Pink Limit Paper Shirt written by John Lennon in 1967. No it wasn't - it doesn't exist it was a name made up by a journalist. "Lennon later dismissed the song". No he didn't, because it didn't exist. By Hell you've done a bang-up job with this, haven't you?
Mad Man can actually be found online, and was recorded in 1969 during the recording of the Get Back project, not in 1965. Now and Then was released back in 2023. Colliding Circles and Pink Litmus Paper Shirt don't actually exist, they were created by a humorist named Martin Lewis.
Too many mistakes! 'Madman' was recorded during the Get Back sessions in 1969, not in 1965! And 'Palace of the King Of The Birds' is a Paul doodle. He recorded it properly for 'Rupert'. 'Pink Litmus Paper Shirt' is a hoax, it doesn't exist.
I really liked the quick snip of Commonwealth in the Get Back movie. Is that all there is of it? Ha ha, I wish Paul would try to do something with it now.
The Beatles have issued every single piece that was worth listening to... With the notable exception of George's songs, probably overlooked... A lot of unreleased songs weren't that good, before being reshaped for their solo albums. Let's mention Jealous Guy, that, rewritten, ultimately found its way out and became this hit that we all sing
Your narration says Now and Then hasn't been released, but the visual footage shows footage from the Now and Then video, so clearly by the time you made this video the song had already been released. So, why is it included?
Also, don't forget The Beatles looOoOOoooved them some of that ol' Mellotron Keyboard. A number of tracks had that playing in it, such as 'I am the Walrus.' ;)
@@beatlemangle1712 I know, that's why I 'reacted' to "1965" (a tiny dash of irony, there). I have the bootleg where the jam came out the first time, and it's very obvious that it is from early 1969. Strange to think about now; when I got that boot LP, it was recorded only nine years earlier...
One of these songs really did catch me by surprise. This video was put up 13 days ago but claims that Now and Then is an unknown and unheard single but it was released last year as the last Beatles song ever. There are even clips from the official Now and Then video included here. Is this video a re-upload or is this channel so out of touch that the producers are actually unaware of a song that brought the whole world to tears yet they are somehow aware of the video? This is a HUGE fail.
I know the release of the anthology series canceled out a lot of bootleg records and things, but you know back in the vinyl collecting days of my youth. I used to have some really killer beetle records, like I would love to see them re-issue rarities, even though anthology nullified that still from, a collecting standpoint that would be great. Why can’t we get releases of some of their concerts on CDs even though the quality may not be the best from historical standpoint there’s so much out there why not release Shea Stadium on DVD and CD along the weighted concert that we’ve all have been yearning forabout releasing the old I can’t remember the name of the series, but I used to have a bootleg LP set of all the let it be sessions
Obviously this narration was made before Now and Then was released. Odd that clips of the music video were shown. Just remove the section about Now and Then all together. I wonder if anyone actually reviews these videos before they are posted. So many of these types of videos are poorly made.
Was it really ' The Palace of the King of The Byrds'? ie Roger McGuin.The 'palace' in questuion was little more than a nondescript bungalow off an unpathed alleyway in Laurel Canyon a
I heard a Beatles song on December 9th 1980 on WMMS out of Cleveland Ohio calle State of Mind it was a poor recording .I have found nothing on it since but I do have it on a cassette sone where as I recorded it off the radio that day.
You're probably remembering "Peace of Mind," which has been widely bootlegged (in fact, a brief excerpt of it is heard in this video). But it's been very firmly established that this recording is NOT The Beatles.
Is where and how this video uses actual audio of now and then at the same time pretends like now and then it's still unreleased I mean don't get me wrong there are legitimate stuff that I didn't know before but to use now and then but acting like it's unreleased
Flaws - The Palace of the King of the Birds was a McCartney written instrumental, seen in Get Back documentary and recorded by Paul for the Ruport The Bear project. Madman was not mid 60's at all. It was written at the same time as Mean Mr. Mustard in India and the recording you play of it is from the Get Back sessions at a fast speed. Pink Litmus Paper Shirt was written and recorded by the same bootlegger that recorded Peace Of Mind (12 Candles Burning). Since it was obvious the first song was fake Tobi Milo bootleggers never used the other songs on the guy's tape. Thanks to a fake late 70's clainn that Pink Litmus Paper Shirt was an unreleased Rutles song and Neil Innes's poor memory, he'd borrow the song title as part of the lyrics in the Rutles Archeaology song Unfinished Words. Last flaw is Colliding Circles. That was a wrong title for the song Circles that George Harrison demoed for the White Album.
The Beatles needed someone like Brian Eno for their experimental phase. George Martin was good for them in the beginning but by the late 60's early 70's they needed someone who can grow with them instead of stunting them. George Martin understood ambient and experimental music but it was not in his wheelhouse. I think the Beatles break up was not one thing, like Yoko Ono entering the scene, but rather running out of direction as a group and they needed a break and many other factors. They all sought separate paths and had very successful solo careers. After a 10 year hiatus they really should have reformed as the Beatles or under another name just so they could redefine themselves. Unfortunately history has proven what was fated.
Thanks for watching! Let us know below what topics or videos you’d like us to make next. 🔥👇
"Now and Then" has been released and went to number one.
Now And Then was released last year.
Yeah he’s acting like it’s a song was never released while playing the song and music video with photo saying stuff like “The Last Beatles Song” 😂
He said as a demo.
He was wrong about a few things. The Palace of the King of the Birds was Paul's song,, not George's.
Now and Then is up for a grammy this year...
One mistake is that you say George Harrison did not like experimental music. Of course that is untrue. He later worked with Lennon on Revolution 9 and also an early solo album of his was Electronic Music
Right and add to that his two early solo albums, Electronic Sounds and Wonderwall Music
@@tagoldichone of those were the first release on Zapple. I don't remember which one came first.
Also “what’s the new Maryjane”.
@@jamesschwartz3837 Wonderwall Music came first (1968, Apple), it was the soundtrack to the movie of the same name. Then came Electronic Sound (1969, Zapple). Wonderwall's not bad actually.
He also recorded the LP Wonderwall as well as recorded arguably the most experimental tracks on Beatles albums.
Pssst… you might want to take out that part about “Now and Then“. Or haven’t you heard? 🙄😏
Must've heard, because some of the official video is used!
This is clearly AI generated...
@@MilesTippett An AI generated YT channel not acknowledging an AI generated hit from last year? And alleging parts of songs have not heard the light of day, while playing those very unheard parts? There's a glitch in the sim LMAO!
@@victorr9166 Now and Then isn't AI-generated. It's all real audio. The "AI" element is an audio separation software used to extract John's voice from a distorted cassette.
'Colliding Circles' might well have been 'Circles', the George Harrison demo from the White Album era. It was released on the 2018 expanded White Album. There's also a solo version from Gone Troppo in 1982.
No, it isn't. It was a made-up title in the list of unreleased Beatles songs in 1971.
@@beatlemangle1712 Indeed. Just to clarify, "might well have been" doesn't necessarily mean something was. It's somewhere between a simile and a metaphor 😉
'The Palace of the King of Birds,' is not a George Harrison song it's a Paul McCartney one. It was released on Paul's Rupert cartoon video with a slightly changed title: "The Castle of the King of Birds." The song, "Pink Litmus Paper Shirt," that you played, was a widely circulated bootleg, the title of which is, "Peace of Mind," and it's already been well established that it's not the Beatles. "Madman," gradually changed into, "Mean Mister Mustard" (on Abbey Road) and "Now and Then" has already been released. So basically, your 7 NEVER before ... etc. is a load of crap.
Except for Carnival of Light
@@ervbefelnareik7604 I heard it wasn't a song but an abstract improv like Rev 9, made as an ambient soundtrack to an art show.
So it was
@@ervbefelnareik7604 which, as I said in another comment, isn't a song.
@@thomasferranti6736 exactly.
I(t is possible that Colliding Circles is basically the George Harrison song "Circles", which he re-recorded for Gone Troppo in the early 80s, and the official Kinfauns version has been significantly cleaned up.
The Beatles generally agreed that Carnival of Light is pretty crappy, and that's why we haven't heard it. Fans will be disappointed if we ever get to hear it. It's not a psychedelic masterpiece. It's noise. But, yeah, of course I want to hear it too!
ME TOO!
Mad Man sounds like a winner. Hope it comes to light soon.
There is a version on tape recorded during the ' Let It be ' sessions.
Someone had a go at putting an AI version together: ua-cam.com/video/vXaYBtDahW8/v-deo.htmlsi=fvwLGhA2awLugv1-
"No one has ever heard 'Madman'"
*'Madman' plays in the background*
McCartney recorded "The Palace Of The King Of The Birds" in 1977 and was on the unreleased soundtrack, "Rupert The Bear".
Yes, it's a McCartney's song or tune. That's one of some errors in the video.
5:23 "Now & Then" did finally surface in 2024 with a digital extraction stereo version of "Love Me Do" on the B-side of the 45rpm single.
"Palace" was written by McCartney, and is on the Get Back soundtrack, as well as various bootlegs.
Now And Then has been released and went straight to number 1. McCartney even performs it live!
It's also NOT a beatles song. It's a Lennon demo that became a McCartney project. Lennon didn't approve of it, Harrison didn't want to do it and probably isn't even on the finished track. Ringo did not want to do it either. This was another Paul McCartney project to relive the Beatles. I'll give Free as a Bird a pass and Real Love because at least all three surviving members participated. They were actually two pretty good Lennon tracks. And it just felt right and exciting in the mid 90's to do that. Doing the same idea 30 years later with George dead and Ringo not wanting to do it... sorry, this is just a Paul project and does not count as a "Beatles song". (technically Real Love and Free as a Bird don't count either, but I think they get a pass... don't water it down Paul with ANOTHER one that's worse)
McCartney =\= Beatles
@@ShoeGazer so Wings = Beatles? Everything Paul does is beatles?
Ya, it was erroneously released as a Beatles track. It's a Paul McCartney track where he borrowed Lennons vocals.
I'd like Apple to release the nearly 27 minute version of "Helter Skelter" ,"Madman" (as briefly heard in the "Get Back" documentary) and "Brian Epstein Blues".
Aw, man! It's hard to pick just one thing to object to. But I'll say that "Pink Litmus Paper Shirt" and "Colliding Circles" were never Beatles track. A reporter made them up and has long since admitted it.
Wish I had that kind of imagination.
Yes, both were the invention of Martin Lewis.
@@MattMonro Oh, Ok
As big a load of rubbish as all the rest .
To be fair, R. Stevie Moore recorded songs with those titles years later.
I've had The Palace of the King of Birds for maybe 20 years. I have all the recordings from the Get Back sessions so, there's probably a few others there that never saw the light of day, other than those sessions. I haven't heard them in at least 10 years so, I'd have to sift through, again.
"Now And Then" was released about a year ago.
If George didn't like experimental music, why did he do most of the way-out psych tunes and the "Electronic Sound" album?
Many Beatles fans have poured over hours and hours of unreleased material on a number bootlegs... Most of the unreleased stuff never got released for two reasons, it's similar to something else or it just wasn't good enough... I've heard tons of unreleased material, the good stuff is what got released, Anthology had a few tracks that were interesting, some demos that were given to BadFinger or Mary Hopkins, but the hidden gems aren't really out there anymore...
There are dozens of songs (complete or partial) and jams sessions over the years that they were together that are still unreleased. But Pink litmus paper shirt and colliding circles are not valid songs. They were made up titles in an article in 67 in what today would be considered clickbait.
Watching rainbows is a good one
I'm sure there are days and weeks worth of songs, on tape, somewhere in a vault that we will never get to hear, since they will be tied up in Paul's and Ringo's estates
for decades AFTER they are both gone!...At 73, I'm not going to stress over missing it, since I got to be there from the beginning!...Just sayin'!
Etc. was considered for Anthology 3 by George Martin so a demo does exist . The Let It Be song “Kingdom of the birds” was used in Paul McCartney& Wings unused Rupert The Bear soundtrack as isnt much different than the Get Back / Let It Be version
How do you explain Now and Then being released last year, if nobody has ever heard it? I'll take your word about the other six songs.
And the video actually features excerpts of the song to boot.
VERY INACCURATE CLICK BAIT MATTERIAL.
Amen, this video is more of a lesson on how to spot bad AI generated content.
Still waiting for the 25 minute Helter Skelter Song.....
From what I've heard about "Carnival of Light", it isn't a song at all, but an avant garde audio collage. I would say the same thing about "Revolution Number 9". You can only stretch the meaning of the word "song" so far.
"Madman" became and is "Mean Mister Mustard."
Colliding Circles doesn't exist. I have the article from USA Today. A writer started that rumour. George Martin was quoted as saying he wish he had a Quarter every time someone asked him about that.
An LP of alternate takes would be okay. I'd buy it.
Box sets already out there, and anthology cd's as well
'Kingdom of the Birds' originated with Paul, I think. Not aware George helped develop it, but I could be wrong.
So McCartney masterminded 13 min of chaotic noise, distorted sounds & random shouts? Isn't that pretty much what John's "Revolution #9" was? Makes you wonder why, then, Paul & the others tried to keep #9 off the "White Album."
Paul and the others tried to keep #9 off the white album because it's crap. Just because Paul made "13 min of chaotic noise" doesn't mean he meant it as a beatle track
@@mongo312 or did he its recorded
That's a fair comparison, except that Paul never tried to put "Carnival of Light" on a Beatles album.
@@PFNel only Paul knows the answer he talks about it
Not Harrison he's on Rev 9
I didn't like "Carnival of Light", but I loved "The Palace of the King of the Birds". "Now and Then" was great! The rest presented here I had not heard before, but maybe for the best. However, recently I found close to two albums worth of rare tracks that The Beatles either gave away or just never recorded on an official record. There are many other rare hidden Beatles tunes. Check out the live BBC sessions and search UA-cam for other tracks, like Lennon's 1968 "Child of Nature". Familiar melody?
You have not heard «Carnival of Light», because it has never been released. But only a fan-made version is out. That’s made by a fan. The original has nobody heard.
@@Elias_Veine_Wiig Somebody has heard it, perhaps not officially, for the song can be found on UA-cam. It sounds as bad as Revolution #9. Which is probably the only song that I ever hated by The Beatles. A noisy mess. Not even psychedelic.
@@bobmessier5215 Carnival Of Light CANNOT be found on UA-cam (or anywhere else on the internet)...the only ones out there (& on here) are fan made fakes...and btw...rubbish
@@bartonbishoff Well, I'd like to think that's it's actually on UA-cam (!), but I don't believe it, sorry, and with the "Blue Meanies" with their Algorithms working overtime on UA-cam, IF "Carnival Of Light" in Apple's bank of tracks to check for, it would get found pretty quickly & pulled down. However, It's such a rarity, I really doubt it's actually contained in their list of tracks/songs to check for, so maybe it's on UA-cam somewhere, but understandably, I'd like proof, so unless someone can show the link, it's existence on UA-cam will have to remain unsubstantiated. When there was serious debate over whether or nor not Lennon said the "He's not even the best drummer in the Beatles" quip (which he did not)...there was a guy online who claimed to have a tape of John saying it, so those who didn't believe it where getting shouted down, purely because someone said he had a recording, which turned out to be utter nonsense, as it was on a UK radio comedy show in 1983. My personal UA-cam "Blue Meanies" example, I put up a "Private" access family vacation video, just for the immediate family (with links) to view, with "Hey Jude" playing in the background (in a pub scene) & it was very quickly pulled/taken down.....I had to silence that whole section just to to re-post it...
I remember reading in the early 90s that "What's the Next Mary Jane?" was one of the most famously elusive Beatles songs - multiple times slated for release as a single or B-side, but it never left the vault....(the song was finally released on "Anthology 3" in 1996)
It was on bootleg for years before Anthology.
Should have remained in the vault, imo, as most of these songs should have.
it's "what's the new Mary Jane " I think and not "what's next Mary Jane" ? we could find it on bootlegs in the 70's , I have it on an LP called " live at shea stadium 64" ( which is not shea stadium but Hollywood bowl in reality) on a dutch label and on the B-side of this record after live songs there is two christmas songs ( fan club christmas songs ) and the song "what's the new Mary Jane "
@xavierp4097 You are correct. Sometimes, I overlook the predictive completion of words on Android. And, sometimes the words filled in make no sense. At any rate, I have heard parts of the song and, parts are all I could really listen to. I think what he. John, had done on the song was not Beatles worthy. I felt the same about Not Guilty, a George sing that Jackie Lomax had a minor hit with. Most, but not everything they did, was very good to great. Another that both John and Paul thought highly of, because it was different and "fun" to record is You Know My Name (Look Up The Number). It might be okay as a novelty song, but, imo, even Brian Jones guesting on sax doesn't save it as Beatles quality.
Sour Milk sea?
Ok. Songs we’ve never heard. SO LET’S HEAR THEM then!!!
That's why I gave a thumbs down for this waste of time.
Wow, I thought I'd heard every Beatles song there is!
Hmm... not sure why Now and Then is included here, when you even included snippets of the recent official video. McCartney supposedly has the only copy of Etcetera. The Palace of the King of Birds was Paul's, not George's, used in the Rubert the Frog cartoon. I often wonder if Colliding Circles was really referring to Circles, written by George Harrison during The White Album period.
A hopeful mention that fans hope McCartney will eventually revisit "Now And Then"....over footage from the music video for "Now And Then".... 🧐
Yep, that’s AI for you! We basically got suckered
"Madman was recorded in 1965". No it wasn't (try 1969). "Palace of the King of Birds was by George Harrison". No it wasn't. "Pink Limit Paper Shirt written by John Lennon in 1967. No it wasn't - it doesn't exist it was a name made up by a journalist. "Lennon later dismissed the song". No he didn't, because it didn't exist. By Hell you've done a bang-up job with this, haven't you?
Now and Then could not have been recorded in the late 70s because the Beatles had broken up well before then.
I'm sure they'll turn up when sir ringo and sir paul need another wing on the villa.
Mad Man can actually be found online, and was recorded in 1969 during the recording of the Get Back project, not in 1965. Now and Then was released back in 2023. Colliding Circles and Pink Litmus Paper Shirt don't actually exist, they were created by a humorist named Martin Lewis.
Madman is just an improvised song and it has been widely heard (not only snippets).
Palace of the King of the Birds shouldve been given to the Greatful Dead or Phish to finish up and play live for 30 minutes
Too many mistakes! 'Madman' was recorded during the Get Back sessions in 1969, not in 1965! And 'Palace of the King Of The Birds' is a Paul doodle. He recorded it properly for 'Rupert'. 'Pink Litmus Paper Shirt' is a hoax, it doesn't exist.
If this is there dission so be it.but bless them all for the great things they did.i miss their music all of them.😢😢😢😢
I like Paul’s song about his dog, Eddie. With the new noise cancelling technology they could filter out the background sounds.
I really liked the quick snip of Commonwealth in the Get Back movie. Is that all there is of it? Ha ha, I wish Paul would try to do something with it now.
The Beatles have issued every single piece that was worth listening to... With the notable exception of George's songs, probably overlooked... A lot of unreleased songs weren't that good, before being reshaped for their solo albums. Let's mention Jealous Guy, that, rewritten, ultimately found its way out and became this hit that we all sing
Your narration says Now and Then hasn't been released, but the visual footage shows footage from the Now and Then video, so clearly by the time you made this video the song had already been released. So, why is it included?
Simply amazing !
Also, don't forget The Beatles looOoOOoooved them some of that ol' Mellotron Keyboard. A number of tracks had that playing in it, such as 'I am the Walrus.' ;)
“Now and Then”s artwork is shown, so how is it on the unreleased list?
"Madman" recorded in 1965? Really? I've always thought that it was a loose jam in 1969 ending up as "Mean Mr. Mustard"?
No, it's a jam recorded during Get Back sessions in January 1969.
@@beatlemangle1712 I know, that's why I 'reacted' to "1965" (a tiny dash of irony, there). I have the bootleg where the jam came out the first time, and it's very obvious that it is from early 1969. Strange to think about now; when I got that boot LP, it was recorded only nine years earlier...
So George was not into experimental pieces ?
What about his 1969 " Electronic Sound" LP on the Zapple label ?
The first solo album by a Beatle, sort of .
There's also:
Watching Rainbows - great rocker
Suzy Parker
..off the top of my head.
Suzy's Parlour
Colliding Circles was finished by George Harrison solo.
One of these songs really did catch me by surprise. This video was put up 13 days ago but claims that Now and Then is an unknown and unheard single but it was released last year as the last Beatles song ever. There are even clips from the official Now and Then video included here. Is this video a re-upload or is this channel so out of touch that the producers are actually unaware of a song that brought the whole world to tears yet they are somehow aware of the video? This is a HUGE fail.
You can get some of these on youtube!
Any student of the Beatles is familiar with all of these songs.
There's a reason those songs are in the vaults. It's just the Beatles making a bunch of noise.
"Palace of the king of the birds" was a McCartney song.
Also the no.1colliding circles don't play also.
Seriously, who cares already? The boys put out a catalogue to last a lifetime. Get a grip.
I know the release of the anthology series canceled out a lot of bootleg records and things, but you know back in the vinyl collecting days of my youth. I used to have some really killer beetle records, like I would love to see them re-issue rarities, even though anthology nullified that still from, a collecting standpoint that would be great. Why can’t we get releases of some of their concerts on CDs even though the quality may not be the best from historical standpoint there’s so much out there why not release Shea Stadium on DVD and CD along the weighted concert that we’ve all have been yearning forabout releasing the old I can’t remember the name of the series, but I used to have a bootleg LP set of all the let it be sessions
chasing rainbows is missing from this list
No news, good news
Howzabout 'Pinwheel twist', 'Winston's Walk', 'Thinking of linking'?
Seven songs we still haven’t heard.
Imagine , John is in Heaven with George.
Or burning in hell for John abandoning Julian and his mother
You mean Billy Shears not Paul because he was killed in 1966.
How bad is a song if revolution 9 made it on and Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da made the record
Why they don't play. The no.7 and number 6 songs
don't worry guys even mozart released a composition after 250 years , There is hope that these songs shall be released.
I will admit I hadn't heard of "Etcetera," so... 1 point, anyway.
Obviously this narration was made before Now and Then was released. Odd that clips of the music video were shown. Just remove the section about Now and Then all together.
I wonder if anyone actually reviews these videos before they are posted.
So many of these types of videos are poorly made.
Was it really ' The Palace of the King of The Byrds'? ie Roger McGuin.The 'palace' in questuion was little more than a nondescript bungalow off an unpathed alleyway in Laurel Canyon a
I thought 'Colliding Circles' was a possible title for an LP which they then rejected?
I heard a Beatles song on December 9th 1980 on WMMS out of Cleveland Ohio calle State of Mind it was a poor recording .I have found nothing on it since but I do have it on a cassette sone where as I recorded it off the radio that day.
You're probably remembering "Peace of Mind," which has been widely bootlegged (in fact, a brief excerpt of it is heard in this video). But it's been very firmly established that this recording is NOT The Beatles.
Derr I listened to now and then loads of times
I like how you included a released song in your list of unreleased Beatles tracks. 🙄 You even played part of the song and the music video!
Apple Studios hasn't existed in decades.
But I have heard some of these songs. Can you please change the misleading title to this video?
So Lennon ripped off Carnival of Light for Revolution 9?
Is where and how this video uses actual audio of now and then at the same time pretends like now and then it's still unreleased
I mean don't get me wrong there are legitimate stuff that I didn't know before but to use now and then but acting like it's unreleased
Sir you mentioned George Harrison but forgot to mention George Martin who overlooked all recordings he also had a say in whats good and whats not!!
NOW AND THEN was finished......good research.
Colliding Circles sounds a bit like Colidescope, doesnt it?
colliding circles = crop circles in british countryside.
Flaws - The Palace of the King of the Birds was a McCartney written instrumental, seen in Get Back documentary and recorded by Paul for the Ruport The Bear project. Madman was not mid 60's at all. It was written at the same time as Mean Mr. Mustard in India and the recording you play of it is from the Get Back sessions at a fast speed. Pink Litmus Paper Shirt was written and recorded by the same bootlegger that recorded Peace Of Mind (12 Candles Burning). Since it was obvious the first song was fake Tobi Milo bootleggers never used the other songs on the guy's tape. Thanks to a fake late 70's clainn that Pink Litmus Paper Shirt was an unreleased Rutles song and Neil Innes's poor memory, he'd borrow the song title as part of the lyrics in the Rutles Archeaology song Unfinished Words. Last flaw is Colliding Circles. That was a wrong title for the song Circles that George Harrison demoed for the White Album.
You guys lost me on "Now And Then". You claim "Now And Then" was never released, but you show clips from the music video. Absolutely laughable.
The Beatles needed someone like Brian Eno for their experimental phase. George Martin was good for them in the beginning but by the late 60's early 70's they needed someone who can grow with them instead of stunting them. George Martin understood ambient and experimental music but it was not in his wheelhouse. I think the Beatles break up was not one thing, like Yoko Ono entering the scene, but rather running out of direction as a group and they needed a break and many other factors. They all sought separate paths and had very successful solo careers. After a 10 year hiatus they really should have reformed as the Beatles or under another name just so they could redefine themselves. Unfortunately history has proven what was fated.
This has got to be a troll video, right? I mean, you had to actually TRY to get as much stuff wrong. What's the point?
From what i heard " Madman" sounded like Oasis
There is a fast rocky version of madman on you tube
I'm only a casual fan, but even I know there's a lot wrong here. So I can't trust anything new to me. Neither should anyone else.
Now and Then..better if they had left it unheard. None of them put real effort into it and it shows.
Why did you "NOT" play a few bars or 20 seconds of the songs while you have brought them in this video???
and you still don't hear them
That’s debatable