They are not boycotting because he was awarded the Sangita Kalanidhi. They are boycotting the conference he is presiding. Their stance is that he has avoided the music, artistes and composers so he has lost the moral ground for presiding over a conference of Carnatic music. That is a valid protest
I am a Malaysian and even I know that: 1. Sri Dusyanth is not a carnatic musician 2. Ranjani - Gayathri cannot be referred to as 'she' 3. The award is Sangitha Kalanidhi and not Sangitha Kalamani. That said, I am also a staunch Hindu and a carnatic music rasika. While I may not agree with TMK's views, I have to admit that he is one fine musician.
There's a subtlety that's missing here. Sri Dushyanth knows immensely the 'sahitya' (lyric) of carnatic compositions, which is an integral part of carnatic music. He may not be a performing singer, but is definitely an important stakeholder. Thanks!
@@perseusvlasov367 shut the fxxk off... The main essence of the shastriya music was violated and he is no great musician ,what did he do anyway to receive it?? Nothing..
Kudos to all the eminent artists who have raised this issue. They did the right thing by voicing their opinion in this matter of great importance. All rasikas and astikas are with you.
Rasika and astika can have sex orgasm with each other. Music doesn't have caste, religion, nation.. Who the hell are you brahmins to decide what language and arts should be like.
To me as a Carnatic singer, the main issue is that he has insutled esteemed stalwarts who have laid the foundation of our system of music and also pays no heed to the sahithyas/lyrics. It is not one-sidedness that leads to a healthy society, but equality. Destruction of one group is nowhere to help. I myself have listened to his music, but he is just acting like a drunk man.
Whatever he is! I can't accept anymore attacks on our culture and music..who r they ??dare they bring an incestuous sec craze mf'ker in this divine place ?mm
Madras Music Academy has given the award to him tio plese the likes of DMK Stalin and leftist owners of the The Hindu. Need to ensure that Music academy is boycotted by sponsors and DMK and its ilk are driven out of Bharat
News correspondents- please educate yourself!! Ranjani & Gayatri are 'they' (they are 2 people) and not "she' and Dushyanth Sridhar is not a 'performer' but an erudite scholar
This teaches us to be more careful about who we allow in future to be the Chief in Music Academy. Hitting the soft targets in Hinduism seems to be a trend. Carnatic Music is nothing but an extension of the Bhakti Movement in music. Like Sri Ramakrishna said, one must necessarily choose one path to travel. Though the others may be equally useful, he says, we can't walk all the paths at one time. It is clear that Carnatic Music is an integral part of Hinduism especially in its Bhakti. It's meant only for Hindus who believe completely in Sanatana Dharma. That's why garbling it to suit one's political or social agenda, to prop up our eclectic religious choices or our societal concerns don't wash. We take recourse to Carnatic Music to hear Hindu Gods' names and to enter a world of Bhakti and Silence, not to continue the tensions and noises outside in the political or social spheres, for the goal of Hinduism, in its essence, is Jeevan Mukti. We want to keep our music, as our Dharma, to ourselves. A strict "No" to the entry of egoistic or self-opinionated or self-styled rebels and reformers, however accomplished they may be. That's why we must reiterate the need to select our Chief and other important officer-bearers with great care. If we can keep out from top office persons exposed to the US or to any other western "democracy" and who are self-styled or secretly "left liberals", it'd be less likely that we'd go wrong in our choice of virtuosos for big Awards nor would we allow the Wokists (alerady being discredited in the US), from taking over our hallowed institutions like Madras Music Academy. Perhaps, Sri Shankaracharya of Kanchi should nominate the Chief to head the Music Academy in future, as strict adherence to Sanatana Dharma is a prerequisite to practising Carnatic Music. We must take our Music back closer to its source, Atma. What has happened is an attack on Hinduism, not simply on Hindu Carnatic Music. No mistake. This is how the recent incident of mis-awarding of the title of Sangeeta Kalanidhi should be viewed and confronted.
TM Krishna recently had a concert overseas where he sang about humans clearing human waste… Had he sung it in front of politicians and administrators in countries where humans still carry out these tasks, it will probably get the officials to act on it! Why he sang it on stage in a country where this is not happening is beyond one’s comprehension. His actions are confused and wrongheaded.
There is no place in iconic Music Academy of Chennai where many stalwarts like Ariyakudi Ramanuja Iyengar Chembai Vydyanatha Bhagavathar,M.L.Vasanthakumari,MS Shbbulakshmi and many more. This fellow has no place who hates God and believers .But the secret behind the award is this award is being given by Journalist Murali who is the brother of N.Ram and the award is being given to him by none other than the mother in law of Kalanidhi Maran.The whole iconic name of the Academy is being tarnished .
Music academy is having dharmic responsibility, it cant act like a irresponsible group of people. Its should respect the sentiments of people. TMK openly insulted Shanathana dharma.
@@perseusvlasov367😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂? You so called almighty all knower don't you dare interfere here.. We have no more intentions in being secular... Music is truly for all.. But Carnatic music is sanatanam dharma.. Why it should be only us to sacrifice all ?? And fyi dear ,Carnatic music has many renowned faces from other caste.. Don't teach us.. 😂
@@meghanath5045 why should be tolerate an unjustified criticism. Let others talk bullshit and you expect us to keep shut. We never abuse or talk ill about any other sect of people. If people are interested in music let them learn and show their skills. Simple talking like a lunatic make no sense n cause disrespect.
@@meghanath5045😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂go to afg if you got an issue.. Look dear none are your punching bag anymore... Enough is enough... So , get lost if you got some respect
தியாகராஜ சுவாமிகள் ராமனை போற்றி உருகி எழுதிய பாடல்களை கற்று பணம் சம்பாதித்து வளர்ந்த T M. கிருஷ்ணா ராமபிரானின் உருவ படத்திற்கு செருப்பு மாலை அணிவித்து, சீதா தேவியை ஆபாசமாக சித்தரித்த E V ராமசாமி நாயக்கரை பெருமை படுத்தி பாடும் பாடல்களை பாடியது சங்கீத ரசிகர்களுக்கு மிகவும் வருத்தத்தை தந்தது. சங்கீத வித்வான்கள் ஜாதி வெறி பிடித்தவர்கள் என்று குறிப்பாக பிராமண சமூகத்தை சார்ந்தவர்களை குறை கூறினார். ஏன் இவர் அரசு கவின் கலை கல்லூரியில் ஆசிரியர் ஆக சேர்ந்து இவர் விரும்பும் அனைவருக்கும் சங்கீதம் சொல்லி கொடுக்கலாமே. இவர் M S அம்மா அவர்களை பற்றி குறிப்பிட்டது விஷமத்தனமானது. அகாடெமி சம்பிரதாய சங்கீதத்தை வளர்ப்பதற்கு துவங்கப் பட்ட ஒரு அமைப்பு. இதில் மற்ற கலைகள் இடம் பெறுவது சரி இல்லை. The Music Academy lost its prestige by this action.
He has ridiculed the Academy and hasn't performed for a few years now! He has abused the icons of the fraternity, divine composers but use their compositions in his concerts. The MA trust like other academia is now full of left liberals. TN people even fear that the Academy will go into the hands of DMK guys and some other construction will come up there. Justified fear knowing how the DMK has taken overbt the real estate in TN.
She can't even pronounce Sangeetha Kalanidhi... she keeps saying Sangeetha Kalamani... and she reads from the same tweet that the other journalist read from. Same content... repetition or redundancy?
He is a good human being. Kudos to TM Krishna for unifying all Hindus regardless of caste and all indians regardless of Religion and Language and unifying India Jai bharat Mata
This award decision is such a defame to this divine art form. The person who has no respect to the saints and legends who grown this divine art form. Actually these kind of people need to be disregarded in the society. Carnatic music indeed grown under the shadow of hindu temples and saints. If this person indeed cannot be honoured. It had been a trend of sometime back, people who spread hate on Bharat and hindu faith get rewards and recognition. Now TN starting again that filthy custom. So sad to see such news
The list of muslim Gharanas in north: 1.Quawali 2.Dilli 3.Agra 4.Kirana 5.Jaipur 6.patiala 7.Bhendibazzar 8.Rampur 9.Indore Etcetc. Can we apply the same logic you apply for brahmins in tamilnadu.
I love TMK music and put all his other acts in dust bin. Nothing wrong by other musicians protest against TMK since he spoke against Lord Rama where all Carnatic musician can not earn their livelihood without praising Lord Rama (Thiyagarajar) . Both sides are having their freedom to express their feeling. Mr. TMK is from a rich family and other carnatic musians who are against TMK should not boycott his friends(other musicians.. (Friends concert) which will affect their livelihood
I have a doubt, should Carnatic music be learnt only by individuals belonging to certain caste or religion, or anybody can learn it. It’s a genuine question
Hatred for Brahmins appears to be in the genes of this awardee musician. Yes, he is a genius and highly talented musician. But, genius and talent will not give any licence to hate Brahmins and Brahmin greats. Before hating Brahmins this guy must know that talent and greatness, godliness, and divinity of music is above every thing and IT IS ONLY INCIDENTAL THAT BRAHMINS NURTURED AND LOVED MUSIC FOR CENTURIES AND GENERATIONS. ALL OTHERS CAN IMBIBE THE MUSIC INTO THEIR BLOOD JUST AS BRAHMINS DID. DMK etc. are born to hate Brahmins and sanathana dharma. This hatred will not give any esteem to music. For politics and votes hating Brahmins has become a fashion.
First the TV anchors need to sensitise them be aware of the nuances of various art forms instead of merely reading from Wikipedia. They need to understand the fundamental differences between the Hindustani and Carnatic music or Bharatanatyam and Kathak. The Hindustani classical music or Kathak dance which is a fusion and subject matters range from love to diivine love dominating more than divinity. Bhajans take care of the divine music among Hindus Carnatic music is out and out a Hindu musiic and traditional music has been preserved across centuries. Ditto with Bharathanatyam. It has been patronized in the courts of Hindu Maharajas . And in the temples and simple households where emphasis is on sanctity and preserving the culture. They didnot monetize their musical knowledge. And this musical knowledge was also helpful in Sama Veda traditons. Because of this it has been the target of evangelists and neo cons who are trying to destroy these traditions with a view to hurt Hinduism. The current awardee is a specimen who has gone with the above crowd in the name of creating islam fusion music or making anti Hindu rhetorical statements. His approach has been rejected by most of singers, rasikas and Carnatic music lovers across the world. However the Swamp insists on rewarding the iconoclast and the public are protesting
As many comment states here, just b'coz we opposed TMK's dirty remarks on our GODS ,on our GUrus we are RWings now.. So better be it... We have got no intention in being the old punching bag anymore.. Don't mess with our culture.. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH
Boot is the other leg. If krishna can air his obnoxious views, others too have a right to air their views and protest. They can boycott their concerts too. India is a free country. Krishna can urinate whereverver he wants. You can stay away and avoid the stench.
@@subramaniyamshankaran770 Tm Krishna is the latest pig immersed in the gutter water of dravida beliefs, he is not a singer , but a prostitute of dravidian agents!
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to spreading Carnatic music far and wide? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your efforts to include non brahmins in your troop? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your effort to stop political forces from controlling Chennai Music Academy? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your contribution to make life safer and better for women after ME TOO cases? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your inputs to prevent linking Carnatic Music to Brahmin hatred? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your contribution to all the poor Carnatic musicians who went without income during Covid times? Nothing Maharaja TMK speaks about all changes, but he himself initiates no social change. Hypocrisy of highest order...ROFL
If other renowned and musicians who really have excellence yes we can agree. But how come dushyant sridhar who also insults Sriraama. How dare he spelled false statements against our beloved God ShriRama's food practice which is not even mentioned by Valmiki bhagwan in Srimad Ramayana or in Kambar whose Ramayana kaavya was accepted by Sriranganatha. TM Krishna was called as drunkard few years ago but I don't know the real fact but i don't have any interest to listen his tone even 🤢.
It is quite acceptable ti want all genres of the Dravidian ie Carnatik siyth of the Vindhyas to be equally honoured at the prestiegregious Music Acadummy. That is so far as the folk and urban artistry is within the domain of NAMES SYMBOLS REMINISCENCES FROM THE VEDA AGAMIC and THE SANGAMIC GENRE. For these are iconic pauranic labels that co exist with dharma of live and let live. Monotheistic imports carry labels symbols historically connected with forcible conversion, scandalous blood bath etc. Do we need to mix oil and water.
If this singer cashed in on the greats of Karnatic vocal music praising Rama and Krishna.. He has the wrong name being a Leftist.. He should change his name Krishna to Vladimir or Boris. after all his Boss CM of Tamil nadu is Stalin nidhi??? The un initiate in karnatic music will assume he is a Krishna Baktha
People who don't know about the abc of what the issue is all about and zero knowledge of music want to join the conversation and add their two cents. This news coverage is absolute rubbish and needs to be consigned to the dustbin
Tm Krishna is a hypocrite.....he should refuse the award for singing Praise pf Lord Krishna amd Lord Rama whom he does not believe.....should sing only on the ideolgy he believes in...
@@srikanthsv79 and?? U hate our dharma,u hate our culture.. So better as well stay away.. Look none obstructs you .. But you have to pay proper respect to the artists to the gurus .. If not don't come here.. ICONOCLASM is no more
TM KRISHNA is undoubtedly an accomplished and erudite vocalist about whom none of his detractors have any thing adverse to say about his music credentials. His singing is devotional, soulful and mesmerising and he praises the Lord and his avatars with all reverence like any other musician. Awards are given on the basis of the merit of a Person's excellence in his field and not based on his personal views which may be anti traditional . Many of the music stalwarts had a nasty , tarnished and sullied personal morality in their lifetime and their personal integrity is debatable . Yet they were honoured ! The opposition is only to Krishna's modern views against conventional Carnatic heritage and customs, and its Brahminical mode of adherence to age old tradition.. Unlike the other musicians who have become famous because of their talents only , TMK stands as an intellectual colossus with an analytical mind to study the dynamics of Carnatics music. Hence he has been awarded the prestigious Magsaysay Award. His rational view about the Mridhangam having cow skin with leather straps, and his views about the legendary MS having been born in a Dasi family of non Brahmins are true and factual. These are irritating data to the Gomatha and Hindutva fanatics who are RSS BJP stooges . However a large section of the music lovers are behind TM KRISHNA and because of this episode are going to vote against the BJP. If Carnatic Music is so sacrosanct why are they bothered about criticism against it ?
His talent is acquired from gurus and a whole lineage of musicians. If we wanted to bring a change, he should act on it. Take a 100 of kids don't see their caste or creed , teach them carnathc music and promote music among all. Instead he choose to degrade the system from he earned lots of money.
@nerdsheldon7843: you are absolutely right. Krishna is a cut above the rest. Krishna is a genius, should have been awarded Sangitha Kalanidhi a decade earlier
Yes I agree with MeenakshiJayaraman.He has been voicing his opinions for more than a decade now,but has not done anything substantial on those lines.Instead he is finding fault with the system. He has also spoken derogatorily of Bharathratna MS Subbulakshmi,herself a Sangita kalanidhi
They r not against giving award to him . They don't want to attend the conference which is presided by him. It's their right to participate not to participate. Why media is peak about it is a question ...
Stfu... How did he get the award if he demonised our GODS,our gurus the stalwarts of this art.??? NO More ICONOCLASM is accepted. No more secularisation of our arts is acceptable.. We ain't the punching bags
Rajani , Gayatri sis liars .E V R Periyar spoken many things , father's Proparty share to get even for woman,equal rights to get even for woman , widow must get secound marriage ( not sathi putting in the fire )education for all even woman must get. He spoken and wrote betterment of womans life .
@@hephzibahdoss9235 I know your upbringing mr.doss. half kg rice bag got your family this name. My upbringing is sanatana dharmam and I understand its music in purity. It is not church Carol singing!!!!
@@krishnaswami346This shows you arrogant and corrupt mind. He is stating your use of foul language in the comment section and you see his name and discriminate him by mentioning his religion.Have some decorem. Mocking somebody by their religion is this what Sanatan Dharma has taught you. No Hindu values has said to speak ill of other religions. Iam a Hindu too. Are you a music scholar what's your knowlege about western music?
@@BharathRaj-si4wk you are a hindu as you said and you are tolerating insult against the icons of sanatana dharma by that poromboku how did your blood not boil???? Will a muslim or a chrirtisn accept insults against his religion?. Be a man. Anyone tolerating insults against oneself is not a man.
😂 so the elite upper caste communities cant tolerate any criticism against them or any criticism against the power structure of the institution dominated by privileged communities. Carnatic music is dominated by Brahmins, that's why he had criticised it as ucs are known for promoting their dominance through favouritism. These folks are crying as he supported periyar but these same communities glorify upper caste freedom fighters who were against dalits from getting basic human rights. Ucs doube standard are at the peak
T M Krishna is no doubt a great classical musician but he should not be awarded the Sangeetha kalanidhi.He has made and making is living singing songs of thyagaraja dikshitar and shyama shastri but then he has no moral values and goes against the brahmanical community following the footsteps of DMK.he should himself decline thd award
Everybody has their own perception towards the society what's bothering you ? The Award is for his musical expertise and his dedication towards karnatic music. Why do you bring up his political views here. Don't mix Art with politics
he has used the compositions Carnatic trinity and doyens of carnatic music😢 to make a hearty living and in the end vilified them to grow and gain popularity… shame on him.. cheap uncouth ungrateful traitor.. we’re politicizing it because the award is thoroughly politicized . though talented, his musical expertise does not make him deserving of the award anyways
You may differ from his politics views, not like his music ,even say he is not talented but can't say he is ineligible to receive the award for his radical views despite having high musical expertise and dedication
💩 . That’s how we can identify the dump people and shit side leaning news channels. The people of Tamilnadu will celebrate TM Krishna even though an award is given or not, his humanity is beyond that. Music is not given granted as their father’s property to anyone ( so called communities) . We live the life of nature and social equality, the evil always will try to destroy that but eventually perish . Not any new. 🕊️✌🏾
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to spreading Carnatic music far and wide? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your efforts to include non brahmins in your troop? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your effort to stop political forces from controlling Chennai Music Academy? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your contribution to make life safer and better for women after ME TOO cases? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your inputs to prevent linking Carnatic Music to Brahmin hatred? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your contribution to all the poor Carnatic musicians who went without income during Covid times? Nothing Maharaja TMK speaks about all changes, but he himself initiates no social change. Hypocrisy of highest order...ROFL
Just a award has been announced to him by the academy. If he agrees with your ideology and remains as an average upper class elite you would have been silent , just because he is radical you yell at him.Everybody has their own perception towards the society what's bothering you ? The Award is for his musical expertise and his dedication towards karnatic music. Why do you bring up his political views here. Don't mix Art with politics. Did you question any of these to those who received this award previously?
@@BharathRaj-si4wk : Absolute hypocrisy in your statements. His political views can be different from ours. No issue. But he idolizes EVR. EVR wanted genocide of Iyers and Iyengars. Thanks to MGR and Kamaraj, Iyers and Iyengars got away. Else it would have been KASHMIR HINDU genocide type outcome. So obviously we feel emotional about it. Many left leaning so called Libards initiated AWARD WAPASI few years back for some lame reasons. The HINDU HATING gangs called it brave and morally upright action. What was that? The award has been provided to TMK by a group which is heading MA now. That group is associated with DMK. More than his music , his anti Hindu views is being awarded...lol Left wing Award returning is normal and morally upright, when others return its kiddish and immoral. Grow up!
TM Krishna is a multidimensional artiste of the highest calibre and most deserving of the Sangeeta Kalanidhi award. While his views on both music and the society which is nourished by it may be variously polarising and endearing, it speaks to his honesty and willingness to step out of his confines and call out the sanctimony which marks much of the Carnatic universe. By doing what they have, all those protesting this much delayed recognition of his music and the immense contributions he has made to it, only confirms what he has underscored as a disabling discordant note in an otherwise melodious world.
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to spreading Carnatic music far and wide? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your efforts to include non brahmins in your troop? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your effort to stop political forces from controlling Chennai Music Academy? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your contribution to make life safer and better for women after ME TOO cases? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your inputs to prevent linking Carnatic Music to Brahmin hatred? Nothing TM Krishna what has been your contribution to all the poor Carnatic musicians who went without income during Covid times? Nothing Maharaja TMK speaks about all changes, but he himself initiates no social change. Hypocrisy of highest order...ROFL
@@VdbailDo you mean to say everybody who has previously received this award had made their contributions. You think the judging panel of the academy should consider about his political ideologies, his contributions, women safety. Only his Art is examined not anything else
@@BharathRaj-si4wk : His highness TMK has not performed in the Music Academy December season for the last 10 years. So on what basis is the award given by Music Academy? So what is examined here? TMK supports EVR who called for genocide of Iyers and Iyengars. This is not normal. TMK was born as Brahmin, received training from Brahmin, most of his audience are Brahmins. But he loves EVR who wanted ethnic cleansing of Brahmins. This is totally unacceptable. Add to this is constant tirade against other performers and their culture. Civilized people do not do this. Giving musical award to such a miserable person will send bad signal to future generations. Art cannot be looked in silo.
@@Vdbail I agree Periyar was brutal and everything he said was'nt true and ethical but people who follow him also oppose him in his statements like this and mainly his atheistic views. But Periyar's core ideology was inclusivity and oppose the caste based Varna system constructed by the brahmin community it made a discriminative structure where someone is considered superior because of his birth. Even Lord Krishna says "Our deeds define our character not our birth " . Just because someone is radical and believes in Periyar's thoughts should not be disrespected despite having necessary musical expertise. Did he ever say he agrees with Periyar's brutal staments like genocide of brahmins. TMK is itself a Brahmin wouldn't he kill himself if he agrees everything about Periyar. He thinks rationally and knows what is good and bad . Its better you neglect the bad and focus on the positive part which is good for the society . Don't mix Art with politics. Even the political parties in Tn is based on Periyaristic ideologies but they clearly say they are not against brahmins but against brahminism. We have Mr Raghuram Rajan who is currently in the chief economic advisory committee of Tn , J Radhakrishnan IAS they are all brahmins too
In south most of Brahim learn classical music, dance and vocal, in their childhood! Sridhar is a Vedic scholar, it doesn't mean he doesn't know carnatic music!
@@msnadar5637 what is his excellency in veda if so Rig or yajur or Sama? He is just religious orator and may be learnt few slokas, ithihasa puranas and commentatory works of those. He may be reverred for his knowledge in vedas but he is not a vedic scholar. Sometimes he used to conflict his own words. Many real vedic scholars and excellent orators who knows how to tell the truthful statements that even a common man can understand.
Majority not but still South Indians who are living in Northern part and people who sings Purandaradasa keertana, thukkaram bajans know very well about EVR and his stand against Indian independence, hindu gods.
He’s used Hindu saint musicians to build his empire while eulogising the naastikas like EV Ramasamy who abused Lord Rama and Vinayaka.
Shutup.
TEVR came into the picture because of the oppressors in the first place. Same with Bharathiyar
They are not boycotting because he was awarded the Sangita Kalanidhi. They are boycotting the conference he is presiding. Their stance is that he has avoided the music, artistes and composers so he has lost the moral ground for presiding over a conference of Carnatic music. That is a valid protest
I am a Malaysian and even I know that:
1. Sri Dusyanth is not a carnatic musician
2. Ranjani - Gayathri cannot be referred to as 'she'
3. The award is Sangitha Kalanidhi and not Sangitha Kalamani.
That said, I am also a staunch Hindu and a carnatic music rasika. While I may not agree with TMK's views, I have to admit that he is one fine musician.
There's a subtlety that's missing here. Sri Dushyanth knows immensely the 'sahitya' (lyric) of carnatic compositions, which is an integral part of carnatic music. He may not be a performing singer, but is definitely an important stakeholder. Thanks!
Exactly. Who the hell are these people to decide he shouldn't get an award? Because he's against their political views? That's pathetic and bigoted.
@@perseusvlasov367 shut the fxxk off...
The main essence of the shastriya music was violated and he is no great musician ,what did he do anyway to receive it?? Nothing..
@@perseusvlasov367 get lost pathetic sh*t bag
Thanks ma'am.
Kudos to all the eminent artists who have raised this issue. They did the right thing by voicing their opinion in this matter of great importance. All rasikas and astikas are with you.
Yes as the oppressor castes can't tolerate any criticism against them
Rasika and astika can have sex orgasm with each other. Music doesn't have caste, religion, nation.. Who the hell are you brahmins to decide what language and arts should be like.
@@meghanath5045so called oppressed caste and oppressor caste all opportunistic politics and power and money grab
@@anandsubbarathnam6662 hahaha you said the right...
This so-called wokes needs some slap
Better give him a sangita karunanidhi or sangita udayanidhi award instead.
People by now would have guess how TMK was chosen.
Mount Road Mao N Ram and his Brother N Murali, the President of Madras Music Academy.
To me as a Carnatic singer, the main issue is that he has insutled esteemed stalwarts who have laid the foundation of our system of music and also pays no heed to the sahithyas/lyrics. It is not one-sidedness that leads to a healthy society, but equality. Destruction of one group is nowhere to help. I myself have listened to his music, but he is just acting like a drunk man.
Whatever he is!
I can't accept anymore attacks on our culture and music..who r they ??dare they bring an incestuous sec craze mf'ker in this divine place ?mm
You are absolutely wrong. No one is protesting his award. Only that they will not be performing when the coference conference presided over by him.
It is not good to award this subversive musician who vilified tradition and hindu dharma itself.
True
Award is for music, stupid man made religions have no awards
He is the most talented of all the worthless lots out there.
@@perseusvlasov367nonsense
@@perseusvlasov367 nonsense
Madras Music Academy has given the award to him tio plese the likes of DMK Stalin and leftist owners of the The Hindu. Need to ensure that Music academy is boycotted by sponsors and DMK and its ilk are driven out of Bharat
Rightly said
Exactly
Very true
Absolutely
Exactly
Music academy has covered itself in muck. The academy has destroyed the reputation it built over a century
A telling comment.
True
News correspondents- please educate yourself!! Ranjani & Gayatri are 'they' (they are 2 people) and not "she' and Dushyanth Sridhar is not a 'performer' but an erudite scholar
Correspondent also called it “Sangeetha Kala mani awArd a few times “
This teaches us to be more careful about who we allow in future to be the Chief in Music Academy.
Hitting the soft targets in Hinduism seems to be a trend.
Carnatic Music is nothing but an extension of the Bhakti Movement in music.
Like Sri Ramakrishna said, one must necessarily choose one path to travel.
Though the others may be equally useful, he says, we can't walk all the paths at one time.
It is clear that Carnatic Music is an integral part of Hinduism especially in its Bhakti.
It's meant only for Hindus who believe completely in Sanatana Dharma.
That's why garbling it to suit one's political or social agenda, to prop up our eclectic religious choices or our societal concerns don't wash.
We take recourse to Carnatic Music to hear Hindu Gods' names and to enter a world of Bhakti and Silence, not to continue the tensions and noises outside in the political or social spheres, for the goal of Hinduism, in its essence, is Jeevan Mukti.
We want to keep our music, as our Dharma, to ourselves.
A strict "No" to the entry of egoistic or self-opinionated or self-styled rebels and reformers, however accomplished they may be.
That's why we must reiterate the need to select our Chief and other important officer-bearers with great care.
If we can keep out from top office persons exposed to the US or to any other western "democracy" and who are self-styled or secretly "left liberals", it'd be less likely that we'd go wrong in our choice of virtuosos for big Awards nor would we allow the Wokists (alerady being discredited in the US), from taking over our hallowed institutions like Madras Music Academy.
Perhaps, Sri Shankaracharya of Kanchi should nominate the Chief to head the Music Academy in future, as strict adherence to Sanatana Dharma is a prerequisite to practising Carnatic Music.
We must take our Music back closer to its source, Atma.
What has happened is an attack on Hinduism, not simply on Hindu Carnatic Music. No mistake.
This is how the recent incident of mis-awarding of the title of Sangeeta Kalanidhi should be viewed and confronted.
TM Krishna recently had a concert overseas where he sang about humans clearing human waste… Had he sung it in front of politicians and administrators in countries where humans still carry out these tasks, it will probably get the officials to act on it! Why he sang it on stage in a country where this is not happening is beyond one’s comprehension. His actions are confused and wrongheaded.
There is no place in iconic Music Academy of Chennai where many stalwarts like Ariyakudi Ramanuja Iyengar Chembai Vydyanatha Bhagavathar,M.L.Vasanthakumari,MS Shbbulakshmi and many more. This fellow has no place who hates God and believers .But the secret behind the award is this award is being given by Journalist Murali who is the brother of N.Ram and the award is being given to him by none other than the mother in law of Kalanidhi Maran.The whole iconic name of the Academy is being tarnished .
Helllo.....TM Krishna Karma is back...Enjoy
Music academy is having dharmic responsibility, it cant act like a irresponsible group of people. Its should respect the sentiments of people. TMK openly insulted Shanathana dharma.
People include all castes, not just brahmins ot hindus. There is no dharma for music. Music doesn't have clutches of religion caste nation
@@perseusvlasov367😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂?
You so called almighty all knower don't you dare interfere here..
We have no more intentions in being secular...
Music is truly for all..
But Carnatic music is sanatanam dharma..
Why it should be only us to sacrifice all ??
And fyi dear ,Carnatic music has many renowned faces from other caste..
Don't teach us..
😂
Not Sangeetaa/ संगीता Kalaanidhi/कलानिधि but sangeeta/संगीत Kalaanidhi/कलानिधि!
Krishna should be taught a lesson
What stupid u
TM krishna seems to be pacifying DMK govt and since this award needs to be given n he seemed to be the right person fitting DMK ideologies. Simple
No wonder these upper caste won't tolerate any criticism against them but love to be a critic of so called Brits
@@meghanath5045 why should be tolerate an unjustified criticism. Let others talk bullshit and you expect us to keep shut. We never abuse or talk ill about any other sect of people. If people are interested in music let them learn and show their skills. Simple talking like a lunatic make no sense n cause disrespect.
@@meghanath5045😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂go to afg if you got an issue..
Look dear none are your punching bag anymore...
Enough is enough...
So , get lost if you got some respect
The news reader doesn’t know that Ranjani Gayatri is actually Ranjani & Gayatri
very evident, better they have a south correspondent who can convey the news report with proper emotion and also with decent knowledge
Nor does the reporter know the correct name of the award! Sangitha "Kalamani" is her own invention!! 🤭🤭🤭
And they think it is Sangeetaa Kalanidhi!
Ignorance regarding South is a must in North Indian media.
Are these sisters thinking that they are the authorities. Fools they proved. It is not their property. TMS a genius.
Now i have great respect for T M krishna
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yeah you have ...
Nepos
Fraud respects Super fraud.😅
@@silverghost5752 yes bro i respect modi and amit shah too..
@@homebox7922 Like attracts like! 😉
@@homebox7922 Like attracts like!!😉
தியாகராஜ சுவாமிகள் ராமனை போற்றி உருகி எழுதிய பாடல்களை கற்று பணம் சம்பாதித்து வளர்ந்த
T M. கிருஷ்ணா ராமபிரானின் உருவ படத்திற்கு செருப்பு மாலை அணிவித்து, சீதா தேவியை ஆபாசமாக சித்தரித்த
E V ராமசாமி நாயக்கரை
பெருமை படுத்தி பாடும் பாடல்களை பாடியது சங்கீத ரசிகர்களுக்கு மிகவும் வருத்தத்தை தந்தது. சங்கீத வித்வான்கள் ஜாதி வெறி பிடித்தவர்கள் என்று குறிப்பாக பிராமண சமூகத்தை சார்ந்தவர்களை
குறை கூறினார். ஏன் இவர்
அரசு கவின் கலை கல்லூரியில் ஆசிரியர் ஆக சேர்ந்து இவர் விரும்பும் அனைவருக்கும் சங்கீதம் சொல்லி கொடுக்கலாமே.
இவர் M S அம்மா அவர்களை பற்றி குறிப்பிட்டது விஷமத்தனமானது.
அகாடெமி சம்பிரதாய சங்கீதத்தை வளர்ப்பதற்கு
துவங்கப் பட்ட ஒரு அமைப்பு. இதில் மற்ற கலைகள் இடம் பெறுவது சரி இல்லை.
The Music Academy lost its prestige by this action.
He has ridiculed the Academy and hasn't performed for a few years now! He has abused the icons of the fraternity, divine composers but use their compositions in his concerts. The MA trust like other academia is now full of left liberals. TN people even fear that the Academy will go into the hands of DMK guys and some other construction will come up there. Justified fear knowing how the DMK has taken overbt the real estate in TN.
She can't even pronounce Sangeetha Kalanidhi... she keeps saying Sangeetha Kalamani... and she reads from the same tweet that the other journalist read from. Same content... repetition or redundancy?
3:19 She’s saying Sangeetha Kalamani! It’s not Kalamani.. it is Kalanidhi! please read carefully before reporting the news
When N. Ram's brother is Music Academy president, what else can be expected. A disgrace
He is a good human being. Kudos to TM Krishna for unifying all Hindus regardless of caste and all indians regardless of Religion and Language and unifying India Jai bharat Mata
This award decision is such a defame to this divine art form. The person who has no respect to the saints and legends who grown this divine art form. Actually these kind of people need to be disregarded in the society. Carnatic music indeed grown under the shadow of hindu temples and saints. If this person indeed cannot be honoured. It had been a trend of sometime back, people who spread hate on Bharat and hindu faith get rewards and recognition. Now TN starting again that filthy custom. So sad to see such news
Indeed
The list of muslim Gharanas in north:
1.Quawali
2.Dilli
3.Agra
4.Kirana
5.Jaipur
6.patiala
7.Bhendibazzar
8.Rampur
9.Indore
Etcetc.
Can we apply the same logic you apply for brahmins in tamilnadu.
Any number of Hindus following these styles now. Don't communalise music.
Same thing holds for karnatic music@@silverghost5752
Any number of others follow karnatic music@@silverghost5752
Unique decision 👍
Sangita kalamani award.😂 When you can't name such a prestigious award correctly, don't come on tv.
and, Dharini says "Sangita Kalamani" 😂
Sangita kalamani ?
I love TMK music and put all his other acts in dust bin. Nothing wrong by other musicians protest against TMK since he spoke against Lord Rama where all Carnatic musician can not earn their livelihood without praising Lord Rama (Thiyagarajar) . Both sides are having their freedom to express their feeling. Mr. TMK is from a rich family and other carnatic musians who are against TMK should not boycott his friends(other musicians.. (Friends concert) which will affect their livelihood
It is not kalamani. Look at the name properly
I have a doubt, should Carnatic music be learnt only by individuals belonging to certain caste or religion, or anybody can learn it. It’s a genuine question
Have you tried learning. 🙄
Please give the sangitha kalanithi to Mr. modi, all will be happy....😂
I support this boycott as well.
Hatred for Brahmins appears to be in the genes of this awardee musician. Yes, he is a genius and highly talented musician. But, genius and talent will not give any licence to hate Brahmins and Brahmin greats. Before hating Brahmins this guy must know that talent and greatness, godliness, and divinity of music is above every thing and IT IS ONLY INCIDENTAL THAT BRAHMINS NURTURED AND LOVED MUSIC FOR CENTURIES AND GENERATIONS. ALL OTHERS CAN IMBIBE THE MUSIC INTO THEIR BLOOD JUST AS BRAHMINS DID. DMK etc. are born to hate Brahmins and sanathana dharma. This hatred will not give any esteem to music. For politics and votes hating Brahmins has become a fashion.
First the TV anchors need to sensitise them be aware of the nuances of various art forms instead of merely reading from Wikipedia.
They need to understand the fundamental differences between the Hindustani and Carnatic music or Bharatanatyam and Kathak.
The Hindustani classical music or Kathak dance which is a fusion and subject matters range from love to diivine love dominating more than divinity. Bhajans take care of the divine music among Hindus
Carnatic music is out and out a Hindu musiic and traditional music has been preserved across centuries. Ditto with Bharathanatyam. It has been patronized in the courts of Hindu Maharajas . And in the temples and simple households where emphasis is on sanctity and preserving the culture. They didnot monetize their musical knowledge. And this musical knowledge was also helpful in Sama Veda traditons.
Because of this it has been the target of evangelists and neo cons who are trying to destroy these traditions with a view to hurt Hinduism.
The current awardee is a specimen who has gone with the above crowd in the name of creating islam fusion music or making anti Hindu rhetorical statements.
His approach has been rejected by most of singers, rasikas and Carnatic music lovers across the world.
However the Swamp insists on rewarding the iconoclast and the public are protesting
True ..
We are no more the punching bags anymore...
Even Jaffer sait Ganja Mafia is good in Karnatic music, our music academy will honour. It's what academy try to say
tm Krishna 🎉 🔥
TN elections very soon. Electoral bonds details are out. Connect the dots everyone
New name for brahminical hegemony is hindu dharma
As many comment states here, just b'coz we opposed TMK's dirty remarks on our GODS ,on our GUrus we are RWings now..
So better be it...
We have got no intention in being the old punching bag anymore..
Don't mess with our culture..
ENOUGH IS ENOUGH
If they have the right to protest, then T M Krishna also has the right to present his opinions and views. This award is for his talent and dedication.
Boot is the other leg. If krishna can air his obnoxious views, others too have a right to air their views and protest. They can boycott their concerts too. India is a free country. Krishna can urinate whereverver he wants. You can stay away and avoid the stench.
@@subramaniyamshankaran770 Tm Krishna is the latest pig immersed in the gutter water of dravida beliefs, he is not a singer , but a prostitute of dravidian agents!
Exactly.. Very well said..free speech , dissent , criticism works both ways..
😂😂😂😂 yes why not??
Bring that d*ckhead ..
He may be a good mudician, but he has insulted thinking he is supreme. We don't respect or like his music.
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to spreading Carnatic music far and wide? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your efforts to include non brahmins in your troop? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your effort to stop political forces from controlling Chennai Music Academy? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to make life safer and better for women after ME TOO cases? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your inputs to prevent linking Carnatic Music to Brahmin hatred? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to all the poor Carnatic musicians who went without income during Covid times? Nothing
Maharaja TMK speaks about all changes, but he himself initiates no social change. Hypocrisy of highest order...ROFL
Secretary has gone false
If other renowned and musicians who really have excellence yes we can agree. But how come dushyant sridhar who also insults Sriraama. How dare he spelled false statements against our beloved God ShriRama's food practice which is not even mentioned by Valmiki bhagwan in Srimad Ramayana or in Kambar whose Ramayana kaavya was accepted by Sriranganatha. TM Krishna was called as drunkard few years ago but I don't know the real fact but i don't have any interest to listen his tone even 🤢.
Not kalamani but kalanidhi
Every action has equal n opposite reaction. That is nature's law... So when one throws muck at others they should be prepared to receive the same..
It is quite acceptable ti want all genres of the Dravidian ie Carnatik siyth of the Vindhyas to be equally honoured at the prestiegregious Music Acadummy.
That is so far as the folk and urban artistry is within the domain of NAMES SYMBOLS REMINISCENCES FROM THE VEDA AGAMIC and THE SANGAMIC GENRE. For these are iconic pauranic labels that co exist with dharma of live and let live.
Monotheistic imports carry labels symbols historically connected with forcible conversion, scandalous blood bath etc.
Do we need to mix oil and water.
He serves this..uncouth
Hatred is bad for the society in any manner so do not glorify it and encourage it.
Yup tell that stupid PM to not hate muslims
Don't mix music and politics. It is the mischief of N Murali and N.Ram of The Hindu paper to get some votes for DMK . Looks like it backfired
If this singer cashed in on the greats of Karnatic vocal music praising Rama and Krishna.. He has the wrong name being a Leftist.. He should change his name Krishna to Vladimir or Boris. after all his Boss CM of Tamil nadu is Stalin nidhi???
The un initiate in karnatic music will assume he is a Krishna Baktha
T.M Krishna has no locus standing in art and music world
Kudos to.TMK for missing off a bunch of RW bigots!
Allambb sangeethanjan... Insulting brahmins is not good... Its shameful for carnatic music
Dusyanth S please stay away. We are tired listening to you .
People who don't know about the abc of what the issue is all about and zero knowledge of music want to join the conversation and add their two cents. This news coverage is absolute rubbish and needs to be consigned to the dustbin
Tm Krishna is a hypocrite.....he should refuse the award for singing Praise pf Lord Krishna amd Lord Rama whom he does not believe.....should sing only on the ideolgy he believes in...
Song lyrics are such that's all, just because one sings the lyrics can't mean one has to believe in such bronze Age kings
@@srikanthsv79 and?? U hate our dharma,u hate our culture..
So better as well stay away..
Look none obstructs you ..
But you have to pay proper respect to the artists to the gurus ..
If not don't come here..
ICONOCLASM is no more
@@TreeShakura well anything stupid has to be questioned & hated just like how you hate islam
@@TreeShakura so what's wrong in hating stupid Hinduism?
TM KRISHNA is undoubtedly an accomplished and erudite vocalist about whom none of his detractors have any thing adverse to say about his music credentials. His singing is devotional, soulful and mesmerising and he praises the Lord and his avatars with all reverence like any other musician.
Awards are given on the basis of the merit of a Person's excellence in his field and not based on his personal views which may be anti traditional . Many of the music stalwarts had a nasty , tarnished and sullied personal morality in their lifetime and their personal integrity is debatable . Yet they were honoured !
The opposition is only to Krishna's modern views against conventional Carnatic heritage and customs, and its Brahminical mode of adherence to age old tradition.. Unlike the other musicians who have become famous because of their talents only , TMK stands as an intellectual colossus with an analytical mind to study the dynamics of Carnatics music. Hence he has been awarded the prestigious Magsaysay Award.
His rational view about the Mridhangam having cow skin with leather straps, and his views about the legendary MS having been born in a Dasi family of non Brahmins are true and factual. These are irritating data to the Gomatha and Hindutva fanatics who are RSS BJP stooges . However a large section of the music lovers are behind TM KRISHNA and because of this episode are going to vote against the BJP.
If Carnatic Music is so sacrosanct why are they bothered about criticism against it ?
I can see how much backward thoughts you guys are having just by your comments and hatred towards TM Krishna sir. Just so shocking
Award is for the talent and not for the ideology. Unwanted controversy. Did not expect this from a well learned person like Dhushyant whom I admire.
His talent is acquired from gurus and a whole lineage of musicians. If we wanted to bring a change, he should act on it. Take a 100 of kids don't see their caste or creed , teach them carnathc music and promote music among all. Instead he choose to degrade the system from he earned lots of money.
@nerdsheldon7843: you are absolutely right. Krishna is a cut above the rest. Krishna is a genius, should have been awarded Sangitha Kalanidhi a decade earlier
He is an active member of dismantle hindutva movement
Yes I agree with MeenakshiJayaraman.He has been voicing his opinions for more than a decade now,but has not done anything substantial on those lines.Instead he is finding fault with the system. He has also spoken derogatorily of Bharathratna MS Subbulakshmi,herself a Sangita kalanidhi
They r not against giving award to him . They don't want to attend the conference which is presided by him. It's their right to participate not to participate. Why media is peak about it is a question ...
Another Godi media… learn about periyar first before talking
This award is for his music and not for his opinion on some other issue why these people over reacting😂
Stfu...
How did he get the award if he demonised our GODS,our gurus the stalwarts of this art.???
NO More ICONOCLASM is accepted.
No more secularisation of our arts is acceptable..
We ain't the punching bags
Rajani , Gayatri sis liars .E V R Periyar spoken many things , father's Proparty share to get even for woman,equal rights to get even for woman , widow must get secound marriage ( not sathi putting in the fire )education for all even woman must get. He spoken and wrote betterment of womans life .
TM Krishna 🤮🤮
Right 😂
This again working of brahminism
Rotten rogue. Certainly a foul bird that shits in its own nest fouling it.
Tm k🤮🤮🤢🤢🤢
He is a poromboku. Samajne wale samaj Gaye.
If this is your upbringing, woe to the clan of musicians
@@hephzibahdoss9235 I know your upbringing mr.doss. half kg rice bag got your family this name. My upbringing is sanatana dharmam and I understand its music in purity. It is not church Carol singing!!!!
@@krishnaswami346This shows you arrogant and corrupt mind. He is stating your use of foul language in the comment section and you see his name and discriminate him by mentioning his religion.Have some decorem. Mocking somebody by their religion is this what Sanatan Dharma has taught you. No Hindu values has said to speak ill of other religions. Iam a Hindu too. Are you a music scholar what's your knowlege about western music?
@@BharathRaj-si4wk you are a hindu as you said and you are tolerating insult against the icons of sanatana dharma by that poromboku how did your blood not boil???? Will a muslim or a chrirtisn accept insults against his religion?. Be a man. Anyone tolerating insults against oneself is not a man.
Those who are blinded by religion and caste and have forgotten the basics of humanity are boycotting... nothing good is expected from such hypocrites.
We should support TMK
😂 so the elite upper caste communities cant tolerate any criticism against them or any criticism against the power structure of the institution dominated by privileged communities. Carnatic music is dominated by Brahmins, that's why he had criticised it as ucs are known for promoting their dominance through favouritism. These folks are crying as he supported periyar but these same communities glorify upper caste freedom fighters who were against dalits from getting basic human rights. Ucs doube standard are at the peak
T M Krishna is no doubt a great classical musician but he should not be awarded the Sangeetha kalanidhi.He has made and making is living singing songs of thyagaraja dikshitar and shyama shastri but then he has no moral values and goes against the brahmanical community following the footsteps of DMK.he should himself decline thd award
Everybody has their own perception towards the society what's bothering you ? The Award is for his musical expertise and his dedication towards karnatic music. Why do you bring up his political views here. Don't mix Art with politics
he has used the compositions Carnatic trinity and doyens of carnatic music😢 to make a hearty living and in the end vilified them to grow and gain popularity… shame on him.. cheap uncouth ungrateful traitor.. we’re politicizing it because the award is thoroughly politicized . though talented, his musical expertise does not make him deserving of the award anyways
You may differ from his politics views, not like his music ,even say he is not talented but can't say he is ineligible to receive the award for his radical views despite having high musical expertise and dedication
💩 . That’s how we can identify the dump people and shit side leaning news channels. The people of Tamilnadu will celebrate TM Krishna even though an award is given or not, his humanity is beyond that. Music is not given granted as their father’s property to anyone ( so called communities) . We live the life of nature and social equality, the evil always will try to destroy that but eventually perish . Not any new. 🕊️✌🏾
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to spreading Carnatic music far and wide? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your efforts to include non brahmins in your troop? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your effort to stop political forces from controlling Chennai Music Academy? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to make life safer and better for women after ME TOO cases? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your inputs to prevent linking Carnatic Music to Brahmin hatred? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to all the poor Carnatic musicians who went without income during Covid times? Nothing
Maharaja TMK speaks about all changes, but he himself initiates no social change. Hypocrisy of highest order...ROFL
Just a award has been announced to him by the academy. If he agrees with your ideology and remains as an average upper class elite you would have been silent , just because he is radical you yell at him.Everybody has their own perception towards the society what's bothering you ? The Award is for his musical expertise and his dedication towards karnatic music. Why do you bring up his political views here. Don't mix Art with politics. Did you question any of these to those who received this award previously?
@@BharathRaj-si4wk : Absolute hypocrisy in your statements. His political views can be different from ours. No issue. But he idolizes EVR. EVR wanted genocide of Iyers and Iyengars. Thanks to MGR and Kamaraj, Iyers and Iyengars got away. Else it would have been KASHMIR HINDU genocide type outcome. So obviously we feel emotional about it.
Many left leaning so called Libards initiated AWARD WAPASI few years back for some lame reasons. The HINDU HATING gangs called it brave and morally upright action. What was that?
The award has been provided to TMK by a group which is heading MA now. That group is associated with DMK. More than his music , his anti Hindu views is being awarded...lol
Left wing Award returning is normal and morally upright, when others return its kiddish and immoral. Grow up!
TM Krishna is a multidimensional artiste of the highest calibre and most deserving of the Sangeeta Kalanidhi award. While his views on both music and the society which is nourished by it may be variously polarising and endearing, it speaks to his honesty and willingness to step out of his confines and call out the sanctimony which marks much of the Carnatic universe. By doing what they have, all those protesting this much delayed recognition of his music and the immense contributions he has made to it, only confirms what he has underscored as a disabling discordant note in an otherwise melodious world.
He’s like a paper flower. A flower that has no softness no smell.
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to spreading Carnatic music far and wide? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your efforts to include non brahmins in your troop? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your effort to stop political forces from controlling Chennai Music Academy? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to make life safer and better for women after ME TOO cases? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your inputs to prevent linking Carnatic Music to Brahmin hatred? Nothing
TM Krishna what has been your contribution to all the poor Carnatic musicians who went without income during Covid times? Nothing
Maharaja TMK speaks about all changes, but he himself initiates no social change. Hypocrisy of highest order...ROFL
@@VdbailDo you mean to say everybody who has previously received this award had made their contributions. You think the judging panel of the academy should consider about his political ideologies, his contributions, women safety. Only his Art is examined not anything else
@@BharathRaj-si4wk : His highness TMK has not performed in the Music Academy December season for the last 10 years. So on what basis is the award given by Music Academy? So what is examined here?
TMK supports EVR who called for genocide of Iyers and Iyengars. This is not normal. TMK was born as Brahmin, received training from Brahmin, most of his audience are Brahmins. But he loves EVR who wanted ethnic cleansing of Brahmins.
This is totally unacceptable.
Add to this is constant tirade against other performers and their culture. Civilized people do not do this.
Giving musical award to such a miserable person will send bad signal to future generations. Art cannot be looked in silo.
@@Vdbail I agree Periyar was brutal and everything he said was'nt true and ethical but people who follow him also oppose him in his statements like this and mainly his atheistic views. But Periyar's core ideology was inclusivity and oppose the caste based Varna system constructed by the brahmin community it made a discriminative structure where someone is considered superior because of his birth. Even Lord Krishna says "Our deeds define our character not our birth " . Just because someone is radical and believes in Periyar's thoughts should not be disrespected despite having necessary musical expertise. Did he ever say he agrees with Periyar's brutal staments like genocide of brahmins. TMK is itself a Brahmin wouldn't he kill himself if he agrees everything about Periyar. He thinks rationally and knows what is good and bad . Its better you neglect the bad and focus on the positive part which is good for the society . Don't mix Art with politics. Even the political parties in Tn is based on Periyaristic ideologies but they clearly say they are not against brahmins but against brahminism. We have Mr Raghuram Rajan who is currently in the chief economic advisory committee of Tn , J Radhakrishnan IAS they are all brahmins too
Dushyanth Sridhar is not a carnatic musician! 😂
He is a BJP hack
In south most of Brahim learn classical music, dance and vocal, in their childhood! Sridhar is a Vedic scholar, it doesn't mean he doesn't know carnatic music!
@@msnadar5637 what is his excellency in veda if so Rig or yajur or Sama? He is just religious orator and may be learnt few slokas, ithihasa puranas and commentatory works of those. He may be reverred for his knowledge in vedas but he is not a vedic scholar. Sometimes he used to conflict his own words. Many real vedic scholars and excellent orators who knows how to tell the truthful statements that even a common man can understand.
North indians doesn't know what is periyar actually. They know, what BJP propofanda said about Periyar. It is not real.
Good Joke. EVR supported violence on Hindus.
The maximum people speaking against EVR are south Indians. EVR sonna kandravi engaleke tariyum.
Everybody knows who periyar is don't think people are foolish
Majority not but still South Indians who are living in Northern part and people who sings Purandaradasa keertana, thukkaram bajans know very well about EVR and his stand against Indian independence, hindu gods.
T M Krishna will now be conferred Grammy, Nobel Awards. Advance congratulations to him.
What more required for colonised Indians?