Ranking Taylor Swift’s Ex Boyfriends Based on Songs Written About Them // Nena Shelby

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1 тис.

  • @yoursapeng1592
    @yoursapeng1592 3 роки тому +5397

    My thought: Taylor Lautner could've been the best ex of TS since he was the only man who TS wrote an apology song. Plus it was Back to December, one of her most beautiful and underrated song.

    • @cherrybelle5794
      @cherrybelle5794 3 роки тому +54

      I wonder who is That's When all about though! It's a really beautiful song about forgiveness, too ❤️

    • @KK-pj1us
      @KK-pj1us 3 роки тому +309

      I think getaway car was also an apology song. In a more twisted way she apologies herself to Tom Hiddleston for rushing the things and knowing from the beginning that he wasn’t her endgame, but still she went for it. “And a circle ain’t a love story, and now we’re both sorry”. They were such a cute couple, just like with Taylor Lautner or Harry styles, too bad for the wrong timeline

    • @meghansullivan6812
      @meghansullivan6812 3 роки тому +23

      Truueee u can just hear the regret n sadness in her voice!

    • @sarahhiggins1515
      @sarahhiggins1515 3 роки тому +85

      She didn’t write any bad songs about Harry. Their break up seemed more mutual. She broke Taylor’s heart so that’s why he gets an apology.

    • @sarahhiggins1515
      @sarahhiggins1515 3 роки тому +33

      @@KK-pj1us its less of an apology and more of a “well what did you expect?”

  • @cassynedelisky796
    @cassynedelisky796 3 роки тому +3432

    I'm not a huge Harry fan but I love how chill he has always been about Taylor. Like he was the only one who understood that when you date an artist, they will write about you.

    • @accioloki1151
      @accioloki1151 3 роки тому +376

      probably because he’s a songwriter as well as just being an overall kind person tbh

    • @cherrybelle5794
      @cherrybelle5794 3 роки тому +174

      Exactlyyyyyy!!! John didn't have that maturity even though he's kinda like a veteran in music industry 🥴 And let's not talk about that Calcium guy!!! He's just something else 🤣🤣

    • @c.shadou1897
      @c.shadou1897 3 роки тому +225

      Taylor Lautner is cool about it too. In an interview he revealed Back to December is about him and he’s chill with it saying “she writes songs, that’s what she’s good at doing”

    • @karenrogers1896
      @karenrogers1896 3 роки тому +61

      I love how harry and taylor support each other even after all they seem to still have great friendship. There was just a 12 yr difference between taylor and john Mayer. Maybe tay just wasnt ready for that. John writes good music he seems authentic guys always bad rap.

    • @accioloki1151
      @accioloki1151 3 роки тому +122

      to add to this harry has also said this in his behind the album film - “to have been part of a moment that means something to someone enough for them to write a song about it is a huge compliment.”

  • @karolinefoss9322
    @karolinefoss9322 4 роки тому +1884

    "can anyone even live without all too well?" oof i felt that

    • @NenaShelby
      @NenaShelby  4 роки тому +58

      for real😂

    • @gloriadoudoukjian9603
      @gloriadoudoukjian9603 3 роки тому +47

      POV: you’re here after all too well 10 min version

    • @taliw7736
      @taliw7736 3 роки тому +1

      Great song! Hoping to see the 10 min short film

  • @rowanshoemaker
    @rowanshoemaker 3 роки тому +1404

    Harry Styles isn’t problematic for having a fandom that attacks Taylor’s.. Something that people don’t understand is that people can’t control their fans/fandom.

    • @sasusakuuchiha12
      @sasusakuuchiha12 3 роки тому +75

      Glad someone freaking said it! Harry is like one of the least problematic guy ever! As part of the fandom, I can admit they were getting too much every time the boys had a relationship and especially Harry, but he doesn't control and he's not responsible for our actions and words. He was always respectful, kind and understanding with everyone, so I really don't get where the "problematic" came from.

    • @IgoLtothat
      @IgoLtothat 3 роки тому +21

      Guys! She didn't mean it like that... All she was saying was that Taylor got some difficulties while dating Harry, he had nothing to do with it... We love Harry but she was using him to talk about the problems the DIRECTIONERS had with Taylor, not that he was problematic... Smh yall gotta chill a bit :)

    • @taliw7736
      @taliw7736 3 роки тому +1

      Agreed

  • @brabzray8516
    @brabzray8516 3 роки тому +495

    I love the fact that Taylor wrote complimentary songs about harry (style) and never wrote something that insult him. She only wrote about their crooked relationship which is mostly because of the toxicity of their fanbase, media, and paparazzis who invaded their privacy. They could've worked out if they're not both in the spotlight ;(

    • @Sofianova17
      @Sofianova17 3 роки тому +6

      Wait I thought I knew you were trouble was about him THIS WHOLE TIME?! 😭😂

    • @brabzray8516
      @brabzray8516 3 роки тому +27

      @@Sofianova17 the song was not about him. But the monologue and the mv are inspired cause they already broke up when she filmed that. she made the guy put on a 'ship' tattoo on his biceps like harry.

    • @anam1097
      @anam1097 3 роки тому +15

      @@Sofianova17 i knew you were trouble is speculated to be either about jake or john mayer

    • @FellDownTheCornHole
      @FellDownTheCornHole 3 роки тому

      She said he was a bad kisser but besides that she’s never said anything that bad.

    • @brabzray8516
      @brabzray8516 3 роки тому +18

      @@FellDownTheCornHole she has never said that either, all she implied was his bad driving lmao

  • @lorelizers
    @lorelizers 3 роки тому +1785

    My ranking of boyfriends/ ex’s (very bias)
    1. Joe Awyn (duh)
    2. Tom Hiddleston (wishes it had work but doomed from the beginning. Such sweet things said after it ended)
    3. Harry Styles (got 1989 from that)
    4. Taylor Lautener
    5. Joe Jonas (seemed cute, but quite teenage)
    6. Connor Kennedy (cute, but forgettable)
    7. Calvin Harris (forgot she dated him lol)
    8.John mayor/jake gylanhall (great music made, but terrible relationships)

    • @NenaShelby
      @NenaShelby  3 роки тому +198

      this is 13/10 accurate 👏💜

    • @jen6294
      @jen6294 3 роки тому +48

      yes but switch Tom and Harry for
      Me

    • @Andyyoureastar
      @Andyyoureastar 3 роки тому +2

      Agree 1000%

    • @idontevenhaveapla7224
      @idontevenhaveapla7224 3 роки тому +132

      John is worse than Jake imo. Dear John shows a much more toxic dynamic than All too well. Harry is her best ex. She didn't lie when she said they never go out of style considering the recording academy randomly posted video of them talking at the grammys 2021 lmfao

    • @distortiondaisiras
      @distortiondaisiras 3 роки тому +1

      TRUE !!

  • @1714nancy
    @1714nancy 3 роки тому +874

    You can't mention her frequency of dating British guys without saying "You know I love a London boy" 😂

    • @mystery1317
      @mystery1317 3 роки тому +95

      Maybe “But god, I love the english” wasn’t a cheeky declaration about Joe but was actually the haunting realization that she has a type and that type is ✨british✨ 🤔😂

    • @1714nancy
      @1714nancy 3 роки тому +2

      @@mystery1317 not maybe, im pretty god damn sure it was 😂

    • @ainaubeda5975
      @ainaubeda5975 3 роки тому +4

      @@mystery1317 I mean I do have the same type so can we blame her????

    • @ginanadifah2950
      @ginanadifah2950 3 роки тому +1

      Bufffdd mindblow, i just realized it

    • @aubreybell1150
      @aubreybell1150 Рік тому +1

      I was litterly thinking the same thing 😂

  • @amoe163
    @amoe163 3 роки тому +1290

    You also missed...
    Conor Kennedy: She did write two songs directly about him- Begin Again and Everything Has Changed, especially bc EHC's secret message is Hyannis Port, where the Kennedy Compound is. That means the last three songs on Red (these two along with Starlight) are about him/his family!
    John Mayer: The Story of Us is about him, when she saw him at the CMT awards in 2010 and they avoided/ignored each other all night (the secret message is literally 'CMT Awards').
    Taylor Lautner: Sad Beautiful Tragic is speculated to also be about him (or Jake but he has so many songs already so let's give Taylor this one lmao).
    Harry Styles: I Wish You Would is 100% about him too, as confirmed by someone who went to Taylor's 1989 secret sessions. After they broke up, Harry moved into a house in the same neighborhood and he accidentally pulled up to her house all the time, and thought about just getting out of the car and seeing her, and meanwhile she was sitting in her room wishing he would do exactly that.
    Jake Gyllenhaal: She wrote so many songs about him lol it's hard to keep track but The Last Time ft. Gary Lightbody is also about their relationship; to me it feels kind of like WANEGBT's more emotional sister.

    • @quelteless
      @quelteless 3 роки тому +84

      omg i didn't know about the story behind i wish you would that's so sad and dramatic

    • @Brigitte_GL
      @Brigitte_GL 3 роки тому +20

      Whoa did not know that about I wish you would - how crazy!

    • @joshuaramon123
      @joshuaramon123 3 роки тому +11

      Ikr Everything has changed being about Connor is basic knowledge because it's literally in the hidden message.

    • @llucila
      @llucila 3 роки тому +11

      wasn't begin again supposed to be about will anderson, parachute's lead singer? i don't remember exactly, but i think she was seen with him in late 2011, which was approximately 8 months after she broke up with jake (so "i've been spending the last eight months..." would make sense)

    • @Cutiemaan
      @Cutiemaan 3 роки тому

      SleepyHead what’s the hidden message

  • @d.n.9957
    @d.n.9957 3 роки тому +875

    "Taylor Swift likes those Brits
    *Taylor writes a song about liking British boys* (London Boy)

  • @islandrebelmakeup4653
    @islandrebelmakeup4653 3 роки тому +278

    Better man is not about Calvin. Better man is most likely about jake. It was written during the writing sessions for red. Same with babe.

    • @anisanurraudah8383
      @anisanurraudah8383 3 роки тому +8

      Really? Cause reading the lyrics, the narrative sounds a lot like a long-term relationship turned bitter cause the man in the relationship is abusive and toxic and in the end, the narrator chose to run away instead. Based on that, it matched Taylor and Calvin's relationship back then rather than the short-lived, on-and-off relationship she had with Jake.

    • @islandrebelmakeup4653
      @islandrebelmakeup4653 3 роки тому +44

      @@anisanurraudah8383 well it was written about 3 years before she and Calvin dated. It’s going to be on RED TV as a vault track, which means it was probably written between the years of 2010-2012 (no later than summer of 2012). I’m not positive who it’s about but since most of the songs on RED are about Jake it makes sense. But there’s no way it can be about Calvin.

    • @margaretanjeliellorico1276
      @margaretanjeliellorico1276 3 роки тому +20

      I agree with Better Man being most likely about Jake G. Especially since Better Man is one of the song from Red's The Vault. haha.

    • @Alan-tk4dy
      @Alan-tk4dy 3 роки тому +6

      I agree with your comment. In fact after listening All too well 10 min is obvious how impactful relation with Jake was to her. There are few songs in other albums that I can see clear clues pointing to Jake. A pretty obvious one to me is "The One" in folklore. There are many clear references to him in the song, and It feels she has a sort of second thought for saying "NO" to Jake attempt to get back together after not "Showed" in her 21 birthday and the sadness of "end of greatest love of all time". Also it looks to me another song "this is me trying" where she is expressing regret of her past harsh words as a shoot to kill when she is mad, is for him. Taylor said, long time ago, that she wrote "we never getting back together" when she was mad at her ex (Jake) and wanted to make him crazy, although later she said she made that comment in a bad day. In another part the song comparing the memory of the person as a film in theater (maybe another reference to Jake as an actor).

    • @loverglow13
      @loverglow13 2 роки тому

      @@anisanurraudah8383better man is now on red tv so it was written for red

  • @randomnesswitheva6063
    @randomnesswitheva6063 4 роки тому +704

    Nena: we're going to be spilling some swiftie tea
    Me: don't you mean swiftea?

  • @nicmcgrade5533
    @nicmcgrade5533 4 роки тому +1004

    Honorable mention to owl city for enchanted. The ex that could have been

    • @NenaShelby
      @NenaShelby  4 роки тому +93

      soooo true

    • @jem4712
      @jem4712 4 роки тому +84

      The only Adam that matters, the other Adam can rest beside his failing career 💅🏻💁🏻‍♀️

    • @evacull
      @evacull 3 роки тому +1

      it’s about emma roberts

    • @luciaurquizahermo9112
      @luciaurquizahermo9112 3 роки тому

      EvaDeva413 12 please explain that sounds interesting

    • @sarahreynah2359
      @sarahreynah2359 3 роки тому +26

      I was ALWAYS think of this!!!! Adam was soooo in love with her lol
      But it's just not meant to be i guess.
      I'm happy for her with Joe now for doing their own thing, and for Adam too for doing his own thing and they just move on. With respect from one musician to another.
      Adam Young is the only Adam we stan in this house.

  • @geanpierre13
    @geanpierre13 3 роки тому +216

    Now we can also add "Mr. Perfectly Fine" on Joe Jonas list

  • @kerennoyman1988
    @kerennoyman1988 3 роки тому +176

    By the way, Better Than Revenge is written as a response for a song Joe Jonas wrote called "Much Better" about how his new girlfriend is "so much better" than Taylor!

    • @thvf2381
      @thvf2381 3 роки тому +29

      oh that makes sense since there's a line "so much better yeah?"

    • @kerennoyman1988
      @kerennoyman1988 3 роки тому +38

      @@thvf2381 Yes exactly! In Joe Jonas's song he says "Now I'm done with superstars, and all the tears on her guitar" something like that

    • @imawakemymindisalive13
      @imawakemymindisalive13 Рік тому

      @@kerennoyman1988the line was country stars 😭😭 he changed it to now i’m cool with country stars

  • @NenaShelby
    @NenaShelby  3 роки тому +213

    hi friends!! just a little disclaimer that these are just my opinions, i welcome you to share yours as well just please do so kindly lol. and yes looking back there are many things/songs i missed haha 💓 (and YES I KNOW BETTER MAN IS NOT ABOUT CALVIN NOW LOLLL)

    • @marye.9306
      @marye.9306 3 роки тому +2

      In terms of rating them by the songs they gave, I'm pretty sure you have the exact same ranking as me. But in terms of the people, Harry tops the list, because I love him and his music to the moon and to Saturn. 💗

    • @stellabenihime908
      @stellabenihime908 3 роки тому

      Tom Hiddleston too. As written in getaway car he was her way to escape that POS. He always seemed very loving and genuine and even if he was as over passionate as people say that doesnt mean he was shitty. Just right people wrong time kinda situation

  • @khyatipareek7354
    @khyatipareek7354 3 роки тому +209

    I was a Haylor shipper... but I love how theyyyyyyy are still friends and never dissed each other, contrary to popular belief (NO THE AMAs SPEECH WASN'T ABOUT HARRY STYLES). I am both a Directioner and Swiftie! I love both of themmmmmm!💓

  • @Famicx
    @Famicx 3 роки тому +700

    The title: ranking EX BOYFRIENDS
    my brain: expecting her current boyfriend for number one 👁👄👁

    • @tejaswini3355
      @tejaswini3355 3 роки тому +25

      😂😂😂😂that was me the whole time

    • @nettie.lauren12
      @nettie.lauren12 3 роки тому +17

      Yea but Joe's not an ex

    • @sophie4877
      @sophie4877 3 роки тому +10

      @@nettie.lauren12 I think that was the point of the comment lol

    • @astronomyseldom4854
      @astronomyseldom4854 2 роки тому +3

      LOLL! He'd never be an ex don't worry about that 😉

    • @redsucculent
      @redsucculent Рік тому +3

      ​@@astronomyseldom4854 hi from future 🙂 yk things changed

  • @yourfriendlyneighbourhoodr8924
    @yourfriendlyneighbourhoodr8924 3 роки тому +62

    Ya know how Taylor loves cats and it’s a common phrase that cats have 9 lives. Taylor has had 8 exes and now she’s with joe who we all think is her true love. Coincidences are awesome

  • @abbeywelchmusic6678
    @abbeywelchmusic6678 4 роки тому +298

    Okay, in Gorgeous when she says “I have a boyfriend, he’s older than us/ He’s in the club doing I don’t know what” who do you think that’s about?? I always thought Calvin Harris since he was a DJ like it makes sense that he’s in the club and obviously he’s older than both Taylor and Joe. But I wanted your opinion bc some people think it’s Tom. I know like timeline wise, Tom makes the most sense but idk I just really feel like it’s Calvin.

    • @lanainmydreams
      @lanainmydreams 3 роки тому +47

      I think gorgeous was about Tom and the "boyfriend" was Calvin. But she never confirmed anything, just said all the songs from rep are about Joe, but that can't be true

    • @jasmine46231
      @jasmine46231 3 роки тому +52

      i always thought gorgeous is about Joe and the boyfriend was tom

    • @jenniferhalder8345
      @jenniferhalder8345 3 роки тому +165

      Tom hiddleston is not the kind to leave his girlfriend and go party in a club

    • @romiorg
      @romiorg 3 роки тому +16

      I think "that boyfriend" is Tom, and the song is about she liking Joe.

    • @abbeywelchmusic6678
      @abbeywelchmusic6678 3 роки тому +55

      @@jenniferhalder8345 I agree, that really gives me Calvin vibes

  • @tristanneal9552
    @tristanneal9552 3 роки тому +65

    "Like over half of her boyfriends were British!"
    Well, I've heard she likes a London boy

  • @idfk5853
    @idfk5853 3 роки тому +97

    "Taylor Swift really likes those Brits"
    yea have you heard london boy

  • @isabellawright4031
    @isabellawright4031 3 роки тому +60

    You said "That's why he's in the middle of the pack" about Taylor Lautner. 11:10 This is a huge reference even if you don't get it. It refers to when he played Jacob Black in Twilight 2008-2012. He was a werewolf.

  • @jasmine46231
    @jasmine46231 3 роки тому +127

    everybody thinks I Knew You Were TRouble is about Harry but its not! they werent even together yet

    • @__Kimberlyyyyy
      @__Kimberlyyyyy 3 роки тому +3

      And people think “I knew you were trouble” was about him😭

    • @Labyrinthine_Complexities
      @Labyrinthine_Complexities 3 роки тому +5

      I know, it's about Matty Healey and Glastonbury. I left the comment on her page and she hearted it.

    • @Naomimvl
      @Naomimvl 3 роки тому +1

      Harry and taylor were together for a lot longer than yall think. I do think I knew you were trouble is about him because of the vma's diss. Yall need to the research but basically they had a thing in the beginning of 2012 (before she dated connor) then they broke up, that's when she probably wrote the song and then they got back together in October or something.

    • @Labyrinthine_Complexities
      @Labyrinthine_Complexities 3 роки тому +1

      @@Naomimvl you mean the British Awards, where they both were.

    • @Naomimvl
      @Naomimvl 3 роки тому +1

      @@Labyrinthine_Complexities theres that too but the moment I was referring to was the 2013 vma's, they were also both there and Taylor won an award for the ikywt music video. But the 2013 brits must've been pretty crazy for her, singing about him right in front of him lol I love them so much and I'm so glad they are friendly today.

  • @tarunimasinghsanawar9721
    @tarunimasinghsanawar9721 3 роки тому +34

    OMG you fangirling over All Too Well fits today so perfectly! Taylor just released her 10-minute version of the song, mentioned in an interview that it was her favorite songs of the album, AND released a short film on it too!

  • @yomnaislam948
    @yomnaislam948 Рік тому +12

    watching this after the news that taylor and joe broke up is a different level of pain

  • @chameleon5376
    @chameleon5376 3 роки тому +150

    It's sad that everyone forgot about Lucas Till, another unproblematic ex beside Taylor Lautner. He confirmed that they did briefly date but it didn't work because they felt that they worked better off as friends. They were believed to be dating not long after Taylor and Joe Jonas' relationship ended. And I believe that Today was a Fairy Tale was about Lucas not Taylor Lautner because the song is like telling us about a new better person that came to her life after a terrible relationship since she just broke up from Joe Jonas in which the lyrics said "you were the prince, I used to be a damsel in distress" and there's also a picture of them with fans which pictured Lucas wearing dark grey T-shirt and Taylor wore a white dress. Also we got The Way I Loved You, the romanticizing of toxic relationship but we love it lol. The Way I Loved You is believed to be a song about both Lucas and Joe Jonas. The song hinted that despite Taylor dated Lucas Till at the time (which a way better man than Joe Jonas) but Taylor missed the messy relationship with Joe instead of being content with the healthy one she got with Lucas and you guys can actually perceive it from the lyrics. I actually would rank him before Taylor Lautner. Anyway, this is such a good and fun review!

    • @chameleon5376
      @chameleon5376 3 роки тому +7

      @Gigi Bonet yes he is! i believe the music video was shot before they were dating. you could watch the behind the scene and clearly see they were flirting here and there and both kinda had crush on each other, it was cute tho lol. i lost count on how many times i’ve watched it back then. there’s also literally an interview with him in which he said that they were briefly date but didn’t work. i’ve been a swiftie since 2009, so i’ve been keeping up with taylor ever since. i don’t know if those stuff are still available on youtube, there might be some articles on google but idk if there’s still any on youtube.

    • @chameleon5376
      @chameleon5376 3 роки тому +1

      @Gigi Bonet oh and also, again, idk if there’s still a video on youtube but back then there are so many videos which showed lucas till came to her concert to support her and can be seen he got along with her parents well and it aligned with the lyrics “he’s closed with my mother, talk business with my father” on The Way I Loved You

    • @Xmastermqnng
      @Xmastermqnng 3 роки тому +7

      is it just me or he looks a bit like young joe alwyn

    • @chameleon5376
      @chameleon5376 3 роки тому

      @@Xmastermqnng omg yeah he kinda is tbh

    • @chuakooleenashley3282
      @chuakooleenashley3282 3 роки тому +2

      They never dated omg stop assuming.

  • @Samantha-sr5ne
    @Samantha-sr5ne 3 роки тому +71

    Thank you Jake for giving us All Too Well 10 minute version 💀💀

  • @cassynedelisky796
    @cassynedelisky796 3 роки тому +30

    Taylor and Harry DEFFINITELY happened. How is that a question? Also, so true about We are Never Getting Back Together. Totally about Jake

  • @heidiwangelin
    @heidiwangelin 3 роки тому +73

    Red freaking saved my life! I had my own Jake that was the most awful ex boyfriend and now my fiancé is my Joe Alwyn but yeah Red inspires me so much about what I don’t want in a relationship and it is such a passionate album.

  • @SarahAtHeart
    @SarahAtHeart 3 роки тому +628

    So fun! Do we think "I Forgot That You Existed" is about Calvin Harris?

    • @quelteless
      @quelteless 3 роки тому +30

      I think it is

    • @iexist8276
      @iexist8276 3 роки тому +73

      I think it is about kanye

    • @almondbyalba
      @almondbyalba 3 роки тому +80

      @@iexist8276 but “i thought that it would kill me but it didn’t”, forgetting about Kanye wouldn’t kill her, she didn’t felt anything for him

    • @chaigneau6981
      @chaigneau6981 3 роки тому +93

      It’s about leaving behind the reputation era and all the drama, she has said it

    • @ninja012612
      @ninja012612 3 роки тому +32

      @@almondbyalba the original lyrics were supposed to be “I thought that I would miss you but I didn’t”. definitely not kanye vibes but I also think she changed the lyrics to include more of a kanye tilt to the song

  • @charlotte-hb7jg
    @charlotte-hb7jg 3 роки тому +33

    just a note from a harry fan: i’m literally also a swiftie and i honestly think that a bunch of fans literally were horrible to taylor! idk why people can’t accept that they dated

    • @Danielle-ft6es
      @Danielle-ft6es 2 роки тому

      most fans of harry who think they never dated are actually fans of taylor

  • @uhmokay5995
    @uhmokay5995 3 роки тому +15

    Harry and Taylor's romance is like the epitome of how THEIR industry could affect and eventually ruin one's relationship

  • @mac8827
    @mac8827 4 роки тому +98

    I heard that better than revenge was also a response to Much Better by the Jonas Brothers. I’m not 100% sure if that is true but the lyrics in the songs do match. Since, in the song Joe Jonas says his new gf is much better and he mentioned a girl with tears on her guitar and dating super stars. Additionally, In the Swift song, she says “show me how much better you are”.

    • @uhmokay5995
      @uhmokay5995 3 роки тому +1

      Lmao that time is WILD WILD.

  • @theyluvstrawbs
    @theyluvstrawbs Рік тому +3

    When you’re here a year later and Taylor Swift and Taylor Lautner filmed the I can See You MV together and were “reunited” 💜✨

  • @lucypreece7581
    @lucypreece7581 3 роки тому +54

    I always thought I Forgot That You Existed was about Calvin. because of the lines "I would have been there front row, even if nobody came to your show" cus of him being a DJ and like the "then you showed who you are" and all the references to him enjoying and joining in all the hate she was getting during the Kimye drama."you brought out some popcorn as soon as my rep started going down"

  • @cassynedelisky796
    @cassynedelisky796 3 роки тому +42

    Lautner was a sweetie. Also, agreed Today Was a Fairytale was totally about him

  • @edpotter1170
    @edpotter1170 3 роки тому +88

    My rank as of now (after Red TV) is:
    1) Taylor Lautner - "you gave me roses and i left them there to die"
    2) Harry Styles - they might be just playing around knowing it's not gonna work, but i like the mutual respect between them as ex-lovers and fellow musicians.
    3) Joe Jonas - breaking up in 27 seconds over a phone call, that was really bad but his current friendship with Taylor (especially with his wife Sophie Turner) is cute so he's high up.
    4) Tom Hiddleston - he's a great guy/actor for sure. But when it comes to his terms with Taylor, he's kinda pitiful lmao only got 1 song about being a rebound.
    5) Connor Kennedy - tbh idek who he is lmao
    6) Jake Gyllenhaal - All Too Well 10 minutes version really brought him down here
    7) John Mayer - other than the age gap, i didn't like his response to Dear John, when he made fun of Taylor's lyrics.
    8) Calvin Harris - I Forgot That You Existed just gave me the "you're such a total waste of time" energy, and he was the rudest among all exes post-breakup.

  • @ntree1337
    @ntree1337 Рік тому +14

    I couldn’t help myself from singing “home is where the heart is, but God I love the English” when Nena pointed out how many brits Taylor dated

  • @nicmcgrade5533
    @nicmcgrade5533 4 роки тому +43

    Nena: *aggressively stirs tea*

  • @loveandcupcakes100
    @loveandcupcakes100 3 роки тому +16

    Every time I play Getaway Car, I have to whisper "Tom, I'm so sorry. Look away!"
    Taylor was sick for making it a "top 5 songs to bop to." She knew what she was doing to the Loki fandom! 😭

  • @MomLifewithKristen
    @MomLifewithKristen 3 роки тому +34

    I’ve always loved Taylor and Taylor! Their relationship was like so pure and cute! I really hoped they would have lasted but I love her and joe she’s so happy with him!

  • @brijkishorsinghparihar9994
    @brijkishorsinghparihar9994 3 роки тому +35

    "They say home is where the heart is but god I love the English"
    THAT'S WHY THEY'RE ALL BRITISH AGSGHSSJJ

  • @ElectroSocketBlues
    @ElectroSocketBlues 3 роки тому +55

    Better Man may have, arguably, been re-dedicated to Calvin as a kiss-off since it was released the year he and Taylor broke up, but it was originally written for Red, so he didn't inspire the actual writing of the song in any way lol

  • @madelynbass4998
    @madelynbass4998 4 роки тому +26

    Taylor Lautner & Back to December CMONNNN

  • @Amandasbarros
    @Amandasbarros 3 роки тому +82

    Omg she and Joe wrote Betty, and Taylor danced with Tom on Met, where she and Joe met 2!!!!
    So that part that James saw Betty dancing with someone else can be about tha

    • @caitlinb35
      @caitlinb35 3 роки тому +17

      Its interesting bc i hear people talk about how James might be Taylor (or Joe and Taylor both are James??), Betty might be Joe and August might be Tom. You can definitely tell there are some real life influences in Betty

    • @Amandasbarros
      @Amandasbarros 3 роки тому +1

      @@caitlinb35 yess!

    • @NenaShelby
      @NenaShelby  3 роки тому +4

      oooo i love this concept

  • @lifeisgoodll
    @lifeisgoodll 3 роки тому +31

    I absolutely *adore* Tom Hiddleston and was actually sad when they broke up. I didn’t really care much about any of her other boys, except I will probably always despise Jake G & John M. Just wanted to put this out into the universe lol.

    • @Dayahhsn97
      @Dayahhsn97 3 роки тому +1

      👀 omg im include CH haahhaha

    • @Jellybeansatdusk
      @Jellybeansatdusk 2 роки тому +1

      I mean I don’t care about Joe but I love them for each other they’re thrivinf

  • @TATIANABUTTS
    @TATIANABUTTS 3 роки тому +59

    Begin again is about Connor lol, he should’ve been above frightful Adam

  • @erfii148
    @erfii148 3 роки тому +71

    So I really liked your video and all the cool stuff you shared and everything.. but just to tell, taylor's ex boyfriends get credit for her broken heart and not her art. Jake didn't give us all too well, Harry didn't give us 1989, none of the men above gave us nothing, Taylor did!

  • @lanainmydreams
    @lanainmydreams 3 роки тому +88

    I think Cruel Summer is about Tom Hiddleston and Joe Alwyn at the same time. Reasons:
    1. Their relationship was in the summer
    2. She was with Tom, but was harbouring feelings for Joe.
    3. "He looks up grinning like a devil"
    There's photos of Taylor and Tom kissing in Rome (I don't exactly remember the place), and after kissing Tom looks up grinning at the sky, and Taylor is looking at him.
    4. "I love you ain't that the worst thing you ever heard"
    The first "you" refers to Tom and the second "you" refers to Joe, in my opinion.
    5. And like you said, Hiddleswift was a fever dream sort of relationship, a rebound. It ended as quickly as it happened. "Fever dream high... Bad bad boy shiny toy with a price" we know Hiddleston was shooting for Thor Ragnarok at that time, and he was playing Loki, the God of Mischief

    • @monalisadebbarma5275
      @monalisadebbarma5275 3 роки тому +11

      I have to respectfully disagree. In my opinion and I wholeheartedly believe that the particular lyric, " he looks up grinning like a devil" is about Joe. Cruel Summer refers to the summer of 2016, "cruel" because all the drama that went down that summer, but also because how she was in the initial dating phase with Joe and kind of seeing where things will go but was falling hard for him in the process so "breakable heaven" it is. And she proly thought her saying " I love you" can take a turn for the worse and break the heaven she was in, so she sings/asks , "ain't that the worst thing you ever heard?". But turns out Joe feels the same way so he looks up and grins at her like a devil (someone who has given her a hard time(in a good way lol) with her feelings because she was so much in love with him. Also, I personally like to think Joe was standing below Taylor's window as she sings, "killing me slow, out the window, I'm always waiting for you to be waiting below" and "looks up grinning like a devil" when she says I Love you.

  • @elliekitabjian2069
    @elliekitabjian2069 3 роки тому +12

    The perfect/style mashup is my favorite thing to listen to ever…

  • @transcendentallll
    @transcendentallll 3 роки тому +6

    Tay adds a sprinkle of shade to each song which is what I love

  • @valen-l2m
    @valen-l2m Рік тому +3

    watching this after her breakup with joe and all the songs on midnights hits different

  • @kimzw
    @kimzw 4 роки тому +83

    Totally went to stop the video every time to listen to the songs you mentioned, haha.

  • @irisroy1108
    @irisroy1108 3 роки тому +12

    Are we really crediting Taylor Swift's ex boyfriends for her music? Seriously? I think Taylor Swift is the one who made her music based on what happened to her. That's the talent. That's the credit. The guys maybe just gave her a horrible time. I'm not saying everything was horrible but there must be a devastating reason why each of her past relationships ended right? No hard feelings to them but all I'm saying is that Taylor is the who channelled those feelings into art. I really don't think we should be thanking the exes, I mean cmon!

  • @luzbarrionuevoo
    @luzbarrionuevoo 3 роки тому +10

    Begin Again was about Connor and Everything has changed, when you look at the original lyrics of that one she talks about green eyes, freckles and gemini star sign

  • @kathrynaston6841
    @kathrynaston6841 Рік тому +3

    I absolutely believe that she and Tom Hiddleston met too early. They are actually perfect for one another, but she needed to be a little olde with less baggage, he needed to be a little more established in his own career. I wish I could drop them both on a desert island.

  • @lanainmydreams
    @lanainmydreams 3 роки тому +35

    Do you think exile is written from Tom's perspective (like Taylor created a fiction about his perspective when she broke it off, of course she wouldn't know what would be his true perspective)? It could be just fiction but then, "those eyes add insult to injury" really make me think.

    • @caitlinb35
      @caitlinb35 3 роки тому +19

      Honestly I think the song written from Tom's perspective is August. There's some good threads out there about it but it aligns a lot, the whole summer love, and the "teenage love triangle" thing with James and Betty. Also in Betty, there's the lyric, she [August] said, 'James get in, let's drive', kind of seems a reference to Getaway Car, which adds a little fuel to the idea August could be Tom. Exile was written partially by Joe, right? I think Tom is in the peripheral of that song, like he is the one "with his arms around your body". Exile seems to be about the misunderstanding/angst/pining between Joe and Taylor, in my opinion, just a theory though lol

  • @bridielawler3474
    @bridielawler3474 3 роки тому +27

    "taylor swift likes those brits"
    you know i love a london boooooy

  • @AllySheehan
    @AllySheehan 3 роки тому +4

    it makes me SO happy that mean of all songs was what got you hooked in!

  • @thatchelseagirl89
    @thatchelseagirl89 4 роки тому +39

    Begin Again was about Conor Kennedy -- he was the first guy she dated after Jake G. The Story of Us is also about John Mayer, when they were both at the CMA (or CMT?) Awards.

    • @paulosumalinog9390
      @paulosumalinog9390 2 роки тому

      I think the story of The Story Of Us is about a awkward encounter between Taylor Swift and John Mayer after their breakup.

  • @emma-di5ly
    @emma-di5ly 3 роки тому +27

    Harry, Tom, Taylor Lautner, and Joe Jonas are my favorite exes of hers because there's clearly no bad blood between them. Obviously there was some with Joe but there isn't anymore. Also they're all incredibly talented outside of being great people. Harry is one of my favorite artists, Tom is one of my favorite actors (if not my favorite actor), and I'm not a fan of the Jonas Brothers, but they're definitely very talented and I like some of their music.
    Music-wise, it has to be Jake, John, and Harry though. Tom would be up there if he had more songs because "Getaway Car" is a masterpiece, but he doesn't have more.

    • @commentslol1415
      @commentslol1415 3 роки тому

      So you forgot Taylor Lautner???

    • @emma-di5ly
      @emma-di5ly 3 роки тому

      @@commentslol1415 Shoot I did let me edit my comment

  • @cerealsareawesome
    @cerealsareawesome 3 роки тому +6

    i love joe (jonas) and taylor’s relationship like they’ve both grown so much and are kind of friends now.

  • @tomasalcorta7402
    @tomasalcorta7402 3 роки тому +16

    I was all the time expecting you to mention Mr. Perfectly Fine and then realised the video was recorded before that song was released haha.

  • @justinmahadeo4976
    @justinmahadeo4976 3 роки тому +12

    what's crazy is the "Mr. Perfectly Fine" is about Joe Jonas as well, and I think there is an Easter egg about Calvin Harris in "I Forgot That You Existed"

  • @natashalawely2900
    @natashalawely2900 3 роки тому +21

    joe alwyn gave us folklore and evermore too bc he co wrote some of the songs

  • @TheManiaTC
    @TheManiaTC 3 роки тому +20

    I think the most *wrong* associated song with harry is I knew you were trouble instead of we're never getting back together

    • @e_intelligence2487
      @e_intelligence2487 3 роки тому +1

      Yeah, I actually thought that song was about him cuz I read it somewhere

  • @evepenfold8758
    @evepenfold8758 3 роки тому +7

    Better Man is about Jake tho, it was written during the Red era but realeased YEARS after and that's why everybody thought it was about calvin

  • @makayla9057
    @makayla9057 Рік тому +8

    watching this after joe and taylor broke up…😭

  • @saumyapandey04
    @saumyapandey04 3 роки тому +12

    She ranked them on the basis of their impact on her music not on the basis of their personalities or what they did to. Otherwise Calvin Harris would have been pretty high up on the list. He did badmouth Taylor after their breakup which is such an indecent thing to do

  • @hyleearth
    @hyleearth 3 роки тому +25

    I think Story of Us is also about John Mayer

  • @swiftiesvsselenators7464
    @swiftiesvsselenators7464 3 роки тому +98

    I really like all of her exes because they inspired Taylor's masterpieces (just a joke)
    But seriously I really like Harry because he was the only ex bf of hers that didn't critizise, but praised her songs about him.
    And most importantly they even had a little chat at the grammys this year🎇🎇

    • @sammy181
      @sammy181 3 роки тому +16

      Yeah but tom never said anything bad about her either so i don't think harry is the only one here..

    • @yutisima
      @yutisima 3 роки тому +7

      @@sammy181 yeah honestly love them both

    • @Alan-tk4dy
      @Alan-tk4dy 3 роки тому

      You know that Harry himself talked about his long time "ambiguity in his sexuality". So I am pretty sure a smart girl like Taylor knew what is going on. This is not easy decision for some celebrity, It took long time for Anderson Cooper to feel comfortable to not hiding in the shade anymore.

  • @nicky6344
    @nicky6344 2 роки тому +1

    this is even before the 10 min version,so imagine now, im so gratefull for this relationship

  • @kaye1581
    @kaye1581 4 роки тому +55

    I Love You by Alex & Sierra was written by Harry and it has parallel lyrics with Come Back Be Here and IKYWT (even August). lol also Olivia vs Clean. Imagine having an artist as your ex. You would live forever in their art

    • @DannyNoLove17
      @DannyNoLove17 3 роки тому +8

      isn't IKYWT about Jake?

    • @anishadas389
      @anishadas389 3 роки тому +3

      Ikwyt wasn't about Harry, they weren't even together when RED released check the time line *smh*

    • @idefkatp
      @idefkatp 3 роки тому +1

      ikywt isn't about harry lol

    • @kaye1581
      @kaye1581 3 роки тому +1

      Since I'm getting notifications about this, I just wanna clarify that I never said IKYWT is about Harry, it's just that the lyrics to I Love You has parallel lyrics to IKYWT and CBBH. "I didn't come back and I wasn't there, I won't trouble you no more" & "while we lay there on a soft warm ground for a week and 13 days". soft warm ground in contrast with cold hard ground.

  • @lilyt7868
    @lilyt7868 3 роки тому +23

    I was at the Rose Bowl Stadium too and I cried when she sang All Too Well 😭

  • @Sherlocked.Loki-Swift
    @Sherlocked.Loki-Swift 3 роки тому +17

    TBH.... Tom deserved so much better. I LOVE Taylor but Tom is my favorite celebrity and what went down with them was very upsetting in my opinion.

    • @not.so.social
      @not.so.social 3 роки тому +1

      What happened with them? Can you please explain? Btw i love them both.

    • @Sherlocked.Loki-Swift
      @Sherlocked.Loki-Swift 3 роки тому +1

      @@not.so.social Not too much is known because they both are really quiet about it. But judging from "Getaway Car" Tom was pretty much a safe person to run from Calvin Harris with. But she was simultaneously starting to fall in love with Joe at the time so Tom was a rebound guy that low-key (pin intended) got used.
      Now I would also say that the paparazzi, and yes, even Swifties and Hiddlestoners also made the relationship really really hard because everyone was always up in their faces 24/7. So I think it was a perfect storm of Taylor getting out of a bad relationship, Tom being a really great person, the paparazzi not leaving them alone, and Joe being more Taylor's type.
      I just love Tom he's my favorite male celebrity so it's hard for me lol. But I love Tay, I love Tom, and they're both happy now so I think it turned out ok. Taylor hasn't ever said anything bad about Tom and Tom has never said anything bad about Taylor.

    • @not.so.social
      @not.so.social 3 роки тому

      @@Sherlocked.Loki-Swift oh! Poor Tom didn't deserve all this💔. Anyways, thanks for explaining.

    • @uhmokay5995
      @uhmokay5995 3 роки тому +1

      @@Sherlocked.Loki-Swift yeah. Good people, bad timing.

  • @abbyamara
    @abbyamara 3 роки тому +11

    im a part of the harry fanbase and im a swiftie but it still shocks me how people in the harry/one direction fanbase think they were a stunt like um no they were real 😭😭

    • @lavie7358
      @lavie7358 3 роки тому

      But dude swities hate him for some reason 🥺

  • @adorinabebla875
    @adorinabebla875 4 роки тому +10

    Well done👏🏼 the tea was truly spilled!

  • @noitsbecky13
    @noitsbecky13 2 роки тому +2

    13:31 - “god i love the english”
    -taylor swift

  • @cyntheriaboafrostella1539
    @cyntheriaboafrostella1539 3 роки тому +4

    Red album is the album who actually made me decide to finally stan Taylor. Red came the moment I really needed it... So I really can't imagine a life without that song

  • @ibelieveinyourgalaxy07
    @ibelieveinyourgalaxy07 2 роки тому +2

    It never felt this good learning about someone's love story.

  • @Kenziesmidnights
    @Kenziesmidnights 3 роки тому +23

    Can you just imagine if her and Taylor Lautner got married lol Taylor Lautner and Taylor Lautner

    • @back-upacc9490
      @back-upacc9490 3 роки тому

      lol that's pretty cool

    • @asafoetidajones8181
      @asafoetidajones8181 3 роки тому

      Easy. Just hyphenates. She can't give up her name with all that fame and money it's worth as a trademark. So she'd Be Taylor Alison Lautner-Swift and he'd be Swift Lautner Alison-Taylor. No problem

  • @taliw7736
    @taliw7736 3 роки тому +4

    Here to hopefully learn about which ex inspired some of the coolest songs so glad Taylor uses her experiences to put into great and iconic songs. Also I don't fully know who she's dated, but definitely Joe is a great match for her and it's lovely they write songs together and support each other.

  • @jensenkansas567
    @jensenkansas567 3 роки тому +8

    Not an ex, but she wrote Enchanted for Adam from Owl City. And it's the biggest what if that still haunts me up to this day. At least, we got enchanted tho. One of my favorite songs of all.

  • @sydneysbooks
    @sydneysbooks 3 роки тому +13

    Since Better Man was written for the Red album (confirmed with Red TV's tracklist) we can assume it's about Jake and not Calvin. I also read this fun analysis where Everything Has Changed is about Connor Kennedy! He's one of my favorite exes because we know so little about why they broke up and we just have her love for his grandma lol
    But my favorite ex is absolutely Taylor Lautner.k

    • @lulabell-rr6px
      @lulabell-rr6px 2 роки тому

      Not an analysis. It is about Calvin due to the description of the album. And yeah it would be impossible for Better Man to be about Calvin. lol

  • @봄보라
    @봄보라 3 роки тому +4

    Watched this because I got so intrigued with the new all too well short film. 🤭 She ate it up and I get how all of you say it's y'all fave song

  • @terryblair966
    @terryblair966 Рік тому +1

    You are great at talking about Taylor and I love how you put everything together. Great work!

  • @wildestdreams7721
    @wildestdreams7721 3 роки тому +6

    My ranking:
    1. Harry Styles (the only relationship which the two wrote beautiful songs about each other. They were cute and respectful for each other, and didn’t cause any drama/hate after break-up)
    2. Taylor Launtner: they were sooo good and she wrote an apologizing song about him!! Back To December is brilliant!)
    3. Tom Hiddleston: beautiful couple, sad ending. And don’t forget Getaway Car
    4. Jake Gyllenhaal: fine. Though through her songs the relationship ending must be so heart-breaking for her, make it doesn’t really good
    5. Connor Kennedy: they were cute, good and happy. The only thing is we don’t have any information
    6. Joe Jonas: they are on good terms now, which is totally great, but breaking up with an 18-year-old girl through a 27-second-phone call is horrible.
    7. John Mayer: just look at the heartbroken and diss songs she wrote. He was such a player.
    8. Calvin Harris: the one who she dated for over a year without any songs written? Not to mention the messy, disgusting drama that left her cancelled
    Edit: I put Jake at number 6 after Red Taylor’s Version... 😭😭Poor Tay

  • @majutavares1579
    @majutavares1579 3 роки тому +14

    is it just me or champagne problems could be abt tom? i mean theres so much we can talk over this song that matches to the context

  • @__Kimberlyyyyy
    @__Kimberlyyyyy 3 роки тому +12

    I’m sooooo sorry on behalf of directioners that they were being so problematic…they tend to do that sometimes. Side note I absolutely love this video!!!

    • @lavie7358
      @lavie7358 3 роки тому

      As a harry fan I think swifties have given us a hard time too

  • @TheRmolle78
    @TheRmolle78 Рік тому +1

    Jake reacting to the all too well 10 minute movie is CLASSIC! He looked so uncomfortable it was hilarious!

  • @julianunes3419
    @julianunes3419 3 роки тому +4

    You even sound like her! You blow my mind, this was the video I needed

  • @Karensmusic292
    @Karensmusic292 Рік тому +2

    Hi, here are sone facts: "Everything Has Changed" is about Conor Kennedy. Liner notes say - Hyannis Port - which is where the Kennedy compound is.Also, Taylor wrote "Better Man" in 2011 during her Red era. It's not about Calvin Harris. I think it's about Jake.

  • @biancalowe1767
    @biancalowe1767 Рік тому +3

    I wander if she’s rethinking this after Midnights 3am?

  • @sarafayad7835
    @sarafayad7835 2 роки тому +1

    3:47 she reminded me to the moment when I'm judging celebrities' outfits wearing a pj 😂

  • @IAMTFNY
    @IAMTFNY 3 роки тому +8

    i thought Dancing with Our Hands Tied was about Calvin? 🥺 the saddest part of their relationship is that we lost out on probably soooo many amazing happy love songs because of their super toxic fall out

    • @Shastabear88
      @Shastabear88 3 роки тому

      I always thought 'I did something bad was tied to Calvin Harris because of him being a jerk, she told about her writing his song under the alias. The part 'if a man talks sh*t, then I owe him nothing' - I always thought was like...well you ran your mouth Adam, I don't owe you to not tell that secret. Which I am here for. ✋️

    • @strawberrihearttt
      @strawberrihearttt 2 роки тому +1

      isnt dancing with our hands tied about joe alwyn

    • @IAMTFNY
      @IAMTFNY 2 роки тому

      @@strawberrihearttt I was thinking because she talks about being 25 and the locket Calvin gave her! Also because the whole song seems to be about a doomed relationship

  • @joannekg4301
    @joannekg4301 4 роки тому +39

    omg YES. Jake's photo somehow popped up on my feed and I was like literally screaming those lyrics inside my head. I laughed so hard checking the comment section !!! 😂😂😂

  • @dianabasangan3900
    @dianabasangan3900 3 роки тому +7

    really a swiftie. i enjoy your vlog! Thank you for posting this. 💛

  • @DoveCalderwood
    @DoveCalderwood 3 роки тому +2

    Better Man isn't about Calvin. She wrote it during the Red era (hence why it's gonna be on the new version of Red). It's about Jake. The only song I see being inspired by Calvin, however minimally, is Tolerate It

  • @elenamartin6894
    @elenamartin6894 3 роки тому +12

    Harry Styles has also some songs on Red: I Knew You Were Trouble and Come Back, Be Here. In fact, Taylor did the cover for the April issue of Vanity Fair magazine in 2013. In that issue, she was supposed to give an interview, but she decided that some of her closest best friends answered the questions in her place. According to the interview (which you can still read online), at the beginning of 2012 there was "this boy" who wanted to meet her. They finally met each other at an awards show in March 2012 (the secret message in IKYWT is "when you saw me dancing" and there is in fact a video of Taylor dancing in the crowd along with Selena Gomez while One Direction was performing on stage). Her friends continue telling how they started dating after that and how she even flew to London to spend some time with him. But then, one night at a party, he literally disappeared and left her alone in a foreign country. She decided to go back home to the US and suddenly this boy sent her a message to "warn her" about some pictures that were going to be released in which he was caught kissing another girl. He said it was a misunderstanding, but she broke up with him. According to her friends, this boy kept chasing her and asking her another chance for almost the whole year, until she gave in at the end of 2012 and they got back together (Out of the Woods and How You Get the Girl). Red was released October 2012. However, she felt as if he was always looking at every woman who passed by. Her friend highlight how he was the one chasing her for almost a year just to break up months later because he felt "pressured". Changing the subject, Taylor herself said that Better Man was written for the Red album, so it cannot be about Calvin Harris. I also wanted to mention that Adam from Owl City was the inspiration for one of her best songs: Enchanted. And Alexander Skarsgard (the actor with whom she filmed The Giver) was the inspiration for another masterpiece: Wildest Dreams. She filmed that movie in Africa and she had to wear a black wig, which is exactly the Wildest Dreams music video (two actors have a fling while filming a movie together in Africa and she wears a black wig). SHE IS A SAVAGE.

  • @lahomabiswas755
    @lahomabiswas755 Рік тому +2

    Better Man was about Jake. It's from the Red era, now we know.