Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds - From Her To Eternity (Live 1989, Pro-Shot with well-balanced audio)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 234

  • @VuotoPneumaNN
    @VuotoPneumaNN 3 роки тому +103

    Can we take a second to appreciate what a (overtly underrated) hell of a drummer Thomas Wydler is?

    • @aprat
      @aprat 2 роки тому +8

      He seriously is what made this performance so memorable.

    • @lucylovic
      @lucylovic Рік тому +5

      Yes. Hear this all the time on youtube. Everyone is underrated

    • @imrichkotrba900
      @imrichkotrba900 Рік тому

      Switzerland...its normal😂

    • @heavenorhell2024
      @heavenorhell2024 11 місяців тому +1

      every drummer is underappreciated. thats the story

    • @VuotoPneumaNN
      @VuotoPneumaNN 11 місяців тому +3

      @@heavenorhell2024 Yeah but he is never really cited amongst great drummers, not even great post punk drummers.

  • @mervyourself
    @mervyourself 6 років тому +166

    I had to limit myself to only watching this twice a week.

    • @scottlebrun6782
      @scottlebrun6782 6 років тому +2

      I love you

    • @_epic_dyslexic_
      @_epic_dyslexic_ 6 років тому +12

      I hope you have stopped punishing yourself and watch this daily now lol

    • @nimusworks5475
      @nimusworks5475 5 років тому +1

      i know the feeling...im better now. once a month

    • @billevilman7379
      @billevilman7379 5 років тому +1

      I watch/listen to this daily, I cannot stop!

    • @sidarthur8706
      @sidarthur8706 5 років тому

      asceticism isn't the way

  • @kutani6670
    @kutani6670 15 років тому +57

    So incredible. Most performers these days cannot even come near this level of raw intensity.

  • @sichaar
    @sichaar 11 років тому +71

    Pure horror on a bright sunshiny day. One of their best songs.

    • @422Ruffian
      @422Ruffian 2 роки тому +3

      Love your description!
      Nick often does the same in his lyrics. Opposites which flow together somehow.

    • @miguelfreitas8694
      @miguelfreitas8694 2 роки тому +3

      Pure horror? It was a cloudy day...

    • @galetinm
      @galetinm Рік тому +2

      Yeah, I don't see the sunshine.

  • @Somiten
    @Somiten 7 років тому +113

    I love those atmospheric sounds that come from Blixa's guitar

  • @stuartfishman1044
    @stuartfishman1044 Рік тому +11

    Fractured, turbulent beauty with Nick Cave performing as if nothing could possibly hold him back. Wish I could have been there.

  • @ceedasun6148
    @ceedasun6148 10 років тому +124

    Unbelievably powerful and mad.

    • @422Ruffian
      @422Ruffian 2 роки тому

      The Cheshire Cat is grinning!

  • @chrisandersen5635
    @chrisandersen5635 12 років тому +31

    Yay for Blixa and his beautiful Jaguar. I do wish he would still play the guitar. His playing is so unique.

    • @markferguson3745
      @markferguson3745 5 років тому +5

      Think that's a borrowed Strat; much to the consternation of some, Blixa was fond of borrowing other's guitars, because he preferred their unfamiliar feel.That is genius.

    • @cmcbride
      @cmcbride 5 років тому +16

      @@markferguson3745 Kid Congo's on the Strat, Blixa's on the Jaguar. I'm sure I've only ever seen him play this Jag or his blue Mustang in any Bad Seeds video after about 1986

  • @jude999
    @jude999 5 років тому +75

    This is one of those performances, like Hendrix at Monterey, where the audience is in shock, not yet knowing what they have witnessed.

    • @yangro2s235
      @yangro2s235 4 місяці тому +2

      I was there, Werchter 1989, and it was exactly how you describe it. 😮

    • @effemaar
      @effemaar Місяць тому

      I was there 10 metres from the stage flabbergasted

    • @Blablz-n5u
      @Blablz-n5u 25 днів тому

      I was also there, i only found out 10 years later😂

  • @silvansky
    @silvansky 5 років тому +18

    Best "one chord song" ever!

  • @SSchvzophrenia
    @SSchvzophrenia 13 років тому +13

    Blixa and Cave together are one big God

  • @elmarcustransmission
    @elmarcustransmission 7 років тому +36

    this is what a live should be.

  • @tryfishin9
    @tryfishin9 10 років тому +38

    this is the best version ever, they never played it like that again. the seeds are on fire! wydler is right in the pocket.

  • @TtKKr
    @TtKKr 8 місяців тому +5

    Roland Wolf was a great musician. His piano playing is delightfully beautiful on the album 'Tender Prey'. R.I.P.

  • @jeffbrett7849
    @jeffbrett7849 2 роки тому +4

    best version ever!!!! Pure menace like early Stooges live....

  • @LSUOdyssey
    @LSUOdyssey 3 роки тому +9

    SOOOOOO DAMN GOOD! The definitive version. This song doesn't get better than THIS!

  • @SullenV.Hement
    @SullenV.Hement 11 років тому +22

    You'd think there would be more camera on Blixa playing guitar. Pretty intense though! Can't believe I saw them in 1984. Seems like several lifetimes ago...

  • @bertcornelissen6294
    @bertcornelissen6294 5 років тому +13

    Other artists that day: Texas, Pixies, Tanita Tikaram, Robert Cray, Elvis Costello, R.E.M., Joe Jackson and Lou Reed; best edition ever of Rock Werchter; But this was still the highlight for almost 18 year old me

    • @RuudLang
      @RuudLang 3 роки тому +1

      I was also there 😄

    • @herwig666
      @herwig666 2 роки тому

      @@RuudLang ik ook

  • @pauloaleixo6554
    @pauloaleixo6554 2 роки тому +4

    It is a pride and an honor to have been lucky enough to live at the same time as this great gentleman! God bless you, Nick!

  • @TheMagmagoblin
    @TheMagmagoblin 13 років тому +16

    Best performance of this song ever.

  • @marxman00
    @marxman00 5 місяців тому +2

    This is disgustingly perfect.

  • @buckleygeneration
    @buckleygeneration 12 років тому +11

    This is the best performance of what is possibly their best song.

  • @vegbloke
    @vegbloke 10 років тому +41

    Gosh this is good. i was thinking of playing this in the pub on Christmas eve; they're expecting a carol sing-a-long; fuck that.

  • @LucaGavilli
    @LucaGavilli Місяць тому

    Immenso NICK CAVE 🌹 irrangiungibile 🖤🖤🖤

  • @billking8843
    @billking8843 2 роки тому +9

    This was the best lineup of the Bad Seeds IMHO. They lost a fair bit when Blixa left and they lost too much when Mick Harvey left.

    • @billking8843
      @billking8843 2 роки тому +1

      So the lineup if I am correct is Nick Cave - vocals, Brian Tristan and Blixa Bargeld - guitar, Mick Harvey - bass, Thomas Wydler - drums, Roland Wolff - keys. I think Thomas Wydler is still in the Bad Seeds line up. Roland Wolff is no longer with us.

    • @Trundlecake
      @Trundlecake Рік тому +4

      @@billking8843 Do not forget Kid Congo Powers!

    • @billking8843
      @billking8843 Рік тому +2

      @@Trundlecake LOL, I listed him as Brian Tristan, which is what he was called in Gun Club. I expect his mum is the only person who calls him that anymore.

    • @Trundlecake
      @Trundlecake Рік тому +1

      @@billking8843 Excellent! I Did wonder if that was his birth name! Thanks for the clarity and big up the gun club. All the best

    • @billking8843
      @billking8843 Рік тому +3

      @@Trundlecake He's had such a wonderful career! Gun Club, Bad Seeds and The Cramps, along with others. He's a friend of friends and a great guy on top of all the rest of it.

  • @mesnais
    @mesnais 13 років тому +10

    Definitely ! Maybe one of the most interesting band of the last 30 years ! Look at them ! Fuck ! Pure energy ! Pure poetry ! The lyrics are spat to the face of the world..
    Great band, great poet (Nick), great orchestration (all the bad seeds..)
    [The lyrics - for this song - are from Anita Lane, I think.. I'm not sure..]

    • @styxcreek
      @styxcreek 3 роки тому

      I don’t think she wrote this but it’s probably about her.

  • @meravazur
    @meravazur 11 років тому +21

    Blixa Bargeld at its finest. Miss him so badly!!!!

    • @PatientenO.T.
      @PatientenO.T. Рік тому +1

      He’s been kicking ass with his own band since he left. Einsturzende Neubauten!

  • @brassteeth3355
    @brassteeth3355 2 місяці тому

    There were legends on that stage that afternoon. This is around the time my buddy turned me on to these cats.

  • @Horushu
    @Horushu 14 років тому +4

    Nick Cave is a true genius! A true genius on fire!!

  • @charlotteholmes3056
    @charlotteholmes3056 3 роки тому +2

    This is so f*cking awesome!!!
    I never have enough of this video...

  • @blixa3642
    @blixa3642 10 років тому +18

    perfection ! this is the best it's ever been done !!

  • @scott7521
    @scott7521 5 років тому +16

    Blixa's guitar at 3:50..... what a sound

    • @michelclarijs
      @michelclarijs Рік тому

      Fantastic discorded sound...but he sayd in an interview on tele he actually couldn't play chords. There you have it . Mick Harvey ,who is the best player here and Blixa ...

    • @ezkibela
      @ezkibela Рік тому +2

      ​@@michelclarijsdont forguet Kid Congo is there too

    • @marcellocostantini1159
      @marcellocostantini1159 5 місяців тому

      You Can not belive me but i ask in about that in Milan ... He said the Guitar do It by itself....with volume so hight The problem Is not about make noise but about how control noise ... That's the First rule of industrial music...

  • @ginap.9202
    @ginap.9202 4 роки тому +3

    The best of all!!Love you Nick & Blixa

  • @blixa9398
    @blixa9398 10 років тому +8

    when you hit your afternoon lull today, crank this up !!

  • @georgemoschopoulos1191
    @georgemoschopoulos1191 9 місяців тому +1

    Best version of From her to eternity

  • @vegbloke
    @vegbloke 8 років тому +5

    Thomas Wilder at his most energetic, lovely cymbal smashing

  • @chemicaljohn4248
    @chemicaljohn4248 7 років тому +5

    love the madness of this song!

  • @pedrofergia
    @pedrofergia 2 роки тому +2

    thomas wydler... what a drummer

  • @marlonquispe5566
    @marlonquispe5566 11 років тому +12

    "Out of her nightmare and back into mine"

  • @Stefano4393
    @Stefano4393 13 років тому +1

    Nick you was-are -will be =immortal in my -our souls-for ever.Thank you that you exist

  • @springbay1
    @springbay1 7 днів тому

    That moment in time when Australia and Germany were so musically intertwined that this song could had been a The Triffids as well as an Einstürzende Neubauten as wells as a Nick Cave song.

  • @aphroditearva176
    @aphroditearva176 6 років тому +10

    Ah wanna tell ya 'bout a girl
    You know, she lives in apt. 29
    Why? That's the one right up top a mine
    I start to cry, I start to cry
    Oh, I hear her walkin'
    Walkin' barefoot cross the floor-boards
    All through this lonesome night
    And I hear her crying too
    Hot-tears come splashin' on down
    Leaking through the cracks
    Down upon my face
    I catch 'em in my mouth!
    Walk and cry, walk and cry
    [Chorus]
    From her to eternity!
    From her to eternity!
    From her to eternity!
    [Verse 2]
    I read her diary on her sheets
    Scrutinizing every little piece of dirt
    Tore out a page and stuffed it inside my shirt
    Fled outta the window
    And shinning it down the vine
    Outta her nightmare
    And back into mine
    Mine! O Mine!
    [Chorus]
    From her to eternity!
    From her to eternity!
    From her to eternity!
    Cry! Cry! Cry!
    [Verse 3]
    She's wearing them bloo-stockens, I bet!
    And standin' like this with my ear to the ceiling
    Listen I know it must sound absurd
    But I can hear the most melancholy sound I ever heard!
    Walk and cry, kneel and cry!
    [Chorus]
    From her to eternity!
    From her to eternity!
    [Verse 4]
    Oh tell me why? Why? Why?
    Why the ceiling still shakes?
    Why the fixtures turn to serpents snakes?
    This desire to possess her is a wound
    And it's naggin' at me like a shrew
    But I know, that to possess her
    Is, therefore, not to desire her
    [Chorus]
    O o o then ya know
    That lil girl would just have to go!
    Go! Go!
    From her to eternity!

  • @kittenclaire
    @kittenclaire 13 років тому +1

    Damn it they rocked back then. F-ing brilliant.

  • @Koetoezov
    @Koetoezov 12 років тому +14

    Blixa Bargeld is cool

  • @mariannelaba
    @mariannelaba 3 місяці тому

    Mind blowing. One great song from a great film . And lively thats an understatement 😊

  • @malibumut
    @malibumut 13 років тому +1

    He is superb, the band is superb,,

  • @alainleclercq5831
    @alainleclercq5831 3 роки тому

    I Was 18 in 1989 and was there at wechter .Nick at his first song turned thé volume to the double. This song is about heroin what a wild time it was.Nick as always ,full of power is amazing.What a beast of concert he is.I am a great fan.Like him I managed to stop drugging and smoking for the better.What a grreat time it always is to see Nick live at a concert or festival.Hopw to see him again.

    • @balance1182
      @balance1182 Рік тому +3

      Not about heroin at all. It’s about a girl as you can hear in the first verse: “I wanna tell about a girl, you know she lives in room 29, the one right on top of mine…”
      Just because he was a junkie it doesn’t mean every fkn song of that era was about heroin.

  • @grahamfuray2106
    @grahamfuray2106 8 років тому +6

    proper nicc cave

  • @mesnais
    @mesnais 13 років тому +4

    @alund1306 Thanks Alund.. I wasn't sure for the lyrics (I read about the band many many years ago.. So..)
    I think that this version IS the best one ! The rhythm is perfect (fast but not "sloppy") : Wydler and Harvey impose the energy with their play, Kid pushes the sound to the limits (of saturation), Blixa.. is the dark side of the atmosphere ! I love the mesmerizing repetition of the same notes of the piano.. Pure masterpiece !

    • @post-crucifixion
      @post-crucifixion 3 роки тому

      Well put! This must be one of my most watched videos ever!

  • @kronik217
    @kronik217 7 років тому +2

    Favorite video on youtube

  • @jrkchannel37
    @jrkchannel37 5 років тому +1

    One of the best UA-cam clips. So primal !

  • @scottlebrun6782
    @scottlebrun6782 6 років тому +2

    Perfection

  • @matthewlane9874
    @matthewlane9874 5 років тому +4

    As Iggy would say... 'RAW POWER!

  • @malibumut
    @malibumut 8 років тому +3

    EXCELLENT.

  • @ivan2894
    @ivan2894 2 роки тому

    this is probably my favorite line up

  • @yelysaveta7381
    @yelysaveta7381 9 років тому +4

    SO FUCKING GOOD

  • @anklamer
    @anklamer 8 років тому +1

    Wow! Just perfect! Best of times!

  • @davidglow3
    @davidglow3 2 роки тому +5

    Nothing can beat the Wings of Desire version..but this comes close

    • @VuotoPneumaNN
      @VuotoPneumaNN Рік тому

      The Wings Of Desire version is just the studio version. They don't play live.

  • @sanjcez78
    @sanjcez78 11 років тому +3

    this's true art!

  • @k3raiko_u522
    @k3raiko_u522 5 років тому

    Genial... und immer wieder Spitze!!!!

  • @Gpoet6
    @Gpoet6 14 років тому +3

    nice trousers!

  • @rixhlilswerve
    @rixhlilswerve 5 років тому

    Cave and The Bad Seeds are one of the best ever to do it

  • @shannaka1001
    @shannaka1001 11 років тому +2

    This is before he joined the band. Blixa Bargeld and Kid Congo Powers on guitars. Warren joined in 1995.

  • @Shiva108
    @Shiva108 5 років тому

    Was there. Was great.

  • @RuudLang
    @RuudLang 3 роки тому

    I was there, in the summer heath. Surreal

  • @stooge63
    @stooge63 12 років тому +1

    Goosebumps

  • @veganvictor2123
    @veganvictor2123 7 років тому +1

    So cool.

  • @Planusdilater
    @Planusdilater 12 років тому +1

    incredible. insane.

  • @werkdabox
    @werkdabox 6 років тому +2

    it always amazes me how close he is to smacking his head against his knee in the beginning of the video.

  • @kennethanderson8827
    @kennethanderson8827 3 місяці тому +2

    Thoughts on attire and skeletal length: I’m 5’6”, and weigh a lean, yet boxy, 140lb.s. If I attempted to dress like Nick, I would look ridiculous~ thoroughly worthy of ridicule & mockery. Short, flip flops & t shirts work well on me. If Nick dressed like me, he would look equally ridiculous, and undignified. Stay dignified Nick Cave

  • @samybo_
    @samybo_ 7 років тому

    amazingly great quality for the time of VHS!

  • @ernestotoccalino4683
    @ernestotoccalino4683 8 років тому +4

    "I wanna tell you about the girl...."
    Y se desata el infieno!!

  • @mesnais
    @mesnais 13 років тому

    Probablement l'un des groupes le plus prolifique et inventif des 30 dernières années ! Un sens rare de l'orchestration, un goût prononcé pour les mélodies totalement improbables.. Quant aux textes, ils coulent de la plume d'un grand poète [écrivain par ailleurs. À lire "Et l'âne vit l'ange", grossière traduction de "And the ass saw the angel"..]
    Bref, du grand art !

  • @0001943
    @0001943 15 років тому

    QUALITY VIDEO AND SOUND....THANKS!

  • @9652ud
    @9652ud 13 років тому +1

    BRUTAL

  • @TheRD92
    @TheRD92 14 років тому +1

    Wydler is on fire.

  • @targus9027
    @targus9027 13 років тому

    THIS ONE ,NICK,JUST DRIVE ME INSANE.....TARGUS

  • @DotM68
    @DotM68 8 років тому +2

    I was at this.Got a bus from Birmingham.

  • @PatientenO.T.
    @PatientenO.T. Рік тому

    I wish I would have seen this in 1989, so I could’ve enjoyed the band longer.

  • @Mortslake
    @Mortslake 4 роки тому +1

    One of my top 10 YT clips..primal as fuck..

  • @Wiolshit
    @Wiolshit 11 років тому

    Thanks for your answers. Love to you all.

  • @DeftonesFan1982
    @DeftonesFan1982 6 років тому +1

    f**ing amazing!!

  • @cowboystitching
    @cowboystitching 15 років тому

    Awesome! Please post more!

  • @33brave33
    @33brave33 14 років тому

    outstanding!!!

  • @MicaelaDesrosiers
    @MicaelaDesrosiers 14 років тому +18

    fuck, i miss blixa.

    • @jacquesf73
      @jacquesf73 3 роки тому +1

      I love Blixa and respect him deeply, but kudos to Warren Ellis...

  • @tidusN1
    @tidusN1 10 років тому +26

    Didn't know Van Damme played the drums in the Bad Seeds.

    • @ceedasun6148
      @ceedasun6148 10 років тому +1

      Well he´s only in one of those itty bitty tiny little seeds, you know.

  • @Mortslake
    @Mortslake 4 роки тому

    Dreamteam with people from Cramps, Gun Club, Die Haut, Einstürzen , Birthday Party...on and on..

  • @Shiva108
    @Shiva108 9 років тому +1

    ah memories...

  • @trillyblack531
    @trillyblack531 5 років тому

    Pazzesco! Grandiosoooo💣👏👏

  • @atiostefony3760
    @atiostefony3760 Рік тому

    Fokin force of nature

  • @vegbloke
    @vegbloke 8 років тому +2

    Fuck it's Christmas. I walk and cry... I walk and cry...

  • @1979sterling
    @1979sterling 14 років тому +1

    OH HELL YES!!!!!!!

  • @vegbloke
    @vegbloke 10 років тому +5

    Oh alright. I'll play the usual stuff, but I will try and sneak this in

  • @davidklein4680
    @davidklein4680 2 роки тому

    I remember reading at one of the Lollapalooza concerts 1994. Somebody threw a mud at cave and cave left the stage and never came back on I hope that guy got a good ass kicking 🤓

  • @cidetoo
    @cidetoo 13 років тому

    hell, yeah! the energy!

  • @Siste4366
    @Siste4366 13 років тому

    I LIVE IN ROOM 29 TOO!!!! Mindblowin" tuneWHAT kind of INTENSITY!!!!

  • @Wiolshit
    @Wiolshit 12 років тому

    Thanks

  • @nunestunes
    @nunestunes 11 років тому +17

    kid congo should write a memoir.

    • @louise5665
      @louise5665 8 років тому +12

      +Jacks Smirking Revenge Twat

    • @styxcreek
      @styxcreek 3 роки тому

      7 years later he’s just announced his forthcoming memoirs

  • @was_music
    @was_music 15 років тому

    AMAZING!! thank you soulbreath

  • @KatLembo
    @KatLembo 3 роки тому

    Thomas Wilder on fire