This is absolutely true ❤and I'm so guilty of it😢 I've got ADD, and have always been completely overwhelmed by housework, so it just had to get it over with whenever I did do it 😢 I wish I'd done the Montessori way ❤
Well,they also need to be far from the cancerous cultures of violence and chaos.. some people use those cultures to destroy powerful empires.. yes,it takes a while but it’s happening even now..not the first time though.
Makes sense. I think that ended with the industrial revolution where children were forced to work under truly horrible damaging conditions, then people justifiably wanted a ban against child labor. And then we overcompensated by removing everything that even remotely resembles "labor" from children. Even though doing a little bit may actually be good for them, making them do some chores (within reasonable limits) is not "child abuse", its actually natural and healthy. But it can be abused.
I know an awful lot of people who were worked hard as children and they suffer from trauma and personality disorders. Working as a child in and of itself does not give self esteem
@jenilynneful all things within reason. Too much labor is definitely child abuse. My parents are a good contrast. My mom grew up on a working farm. She had before and after school chores and worked all day when school was out. My grandfather gave the kids a share of the money from the crops and livestock when he sold them. My mom grew up to be a secure confident woman who knows how to do everything for herself. My paternal grandfather owned a grocery store. He expected my father to be there every minute he wasn't in school. They lived across the street from the store and my grandfather would go home when the store closed and leave my dad to work late at night doing all the after hours chores. If he made any mistskes he was beaten with an axe handle. My Dad was never paid for his labor and he was not allowed to eat anything from the store. He had to wait and eat at home. My Dad grew up to be a man with all the markers of a traumatized child. I didn't know what was going on with him when I was a kid but being his daughter was no fun. Abusers find a way to make everything abusive.
I can only speak with my experience here in the states but people have this insane desire to control everyone. When they become parents here they just see them as little dolls that want to make life difficult for you. Your kid wants to help and discover the world. Yes they will make a huge mess "washing" the dishes. Let them. I would let my oldest son help me with dishes before he could talk and was barely walking. He initially just played in the water and made a mess. He tried helping to dry up the floor afterwards but wasn't the best. Then he started pushing me away and saying, "me own." So I let him wash the dishes and clean the floor alone. I would say thank you when he was done. Now he's almost 3. He collects his dishes, puts them in the sink, sets up his step stool and happily washes his own dishes. He'll put all the dishes away too. His younger brother helps the best he can at 18 months and is learning from his brother as much as from me. I don't even take the trash out of his room anymore. They always pick up their trash and throw it away. If they find their bin stinky, which is often as they don't like the trash getting full, they dump it in the trash can in the kitchen. I have never asked them to help me. They offered, I accepted and said thank you. I treated them how I want to be treated. Yes they still throw tantrums. My toddlers still get mad because they didn't want milk until I put it away then want it then don't want it. I just stay calm. They're learning by how I act, by what I do. So I behave the way I want them to. It's hard but I try my best. Hunt, Gather, Parent is a great book about how to parent this way.
I wish I'd had made my daughters do more chores growing up. However, they had all these after school activities (gymnastics, music lessons, taekwondo, etc.). However, they still grew up to be very productive adults with good jobs who keep their own homes neater than mine!
How dare you assume their gender. How do you know they're not one of those trans or non-binary subsistence nomads? You know, gender identity is so important to people who have to work, raise and protect animals from predators, break ice from the river and eat raw frozen meat to survive.
@@joelleschachter2867she is not a teenager yet! Lol. Again… all the young people I know, including toddlers and teenagers, are a joy and asset to their families and communities. Toddlers in America love to help too! Leave our young people and their families alone and spare the negative judgment… or do something to actually engage with or enrich a young persons life. 🤷🏻♀️. These group shaming and judgment comments are getting old, boring, ridiculous… and telling… more about the commenter.
People have survived and thrived for hundreds of millennia with just love and wits. Folks that live on the land are not civilized, but their modest contribution is valuable and they are fully human in all regards, perhaps more so in some than us civilized folk. Just as we have a balance of liberal and conservative in civilization there must be a balance between rural and civilized in humanity as a whole.
@@davidpool8796yes, I was thinking about the little toddler girl across the street. She is sweet and helpful like Katya. Dear Lord, I pray for protection for all the little ones, their folks, and our Earth. Hallelujah.
I was a medical missionary there very healthy people absolutely rejected our western medicine actually saw an older gentleman with half of the top of his head gone, I panicked and said we must get him to Germany for immediate cancer surgery this man won’t last a month!!! After speaking with him I found out he was actually almost 14 years with advanced melanoma with no other medical issues!!! Most of the fingers there are purple from the iodine from walnut trees, but they actually TAUGHT MY ENTIRE MEDICAL TEAM so much, when I came back stateside I adapted some things I learned there!!! Very grateful for the experience and the wonderful albeit cautious nature of the people there!!! Spoceba!!!!
Alfred Adler the psychologist said that one of our most pressing needs as humans is to find a place to belong. And, to feel that we contribute something to society. The baby nails those.
Baby girl fully understands her living environment. She knows what is required and takes the initiative to help out. She is physically stronger than the teenagers who live in modern cities
Over generalization leads to misconceptions and preventable disasters. Some of those teens in cities are already murderers and violent offenders. I believe you are confused with middle class and upper-class teens who live life of pampered sheltered privilege.
Aww, this baby can't be older than 2, and is carrying loads, and carefully feeding the dogs😂. We gotta step it up. No smart phones in sight, and great for them!
If not for UA-cam, I would not know you exist. Now that I do and see you, I wish you health and a prosper future in the course of time, for young and old.
This 2 year old has so much personality. And she’s being raised by attentive, respectful parents. Bravo to great parent teachers- Allowing a child to be free to explore and learn while providing everything she needs to grow up.
I think it’s quite a stretch to say the child has been provided with everything they need to grow up. Some modern cleanliness standards and healthcare would definitely help.
@@susanlewis9351really. Babies need to be more robust in Siberia, but it seems you’re just trying to be nasty. Yes she looks very chubby but most children in Siberia have big round cheeks. It is the face shape of most siberians.
Such a helpful baby. And so chubby! I’m just about to have my fifth. And one thing I’ve noticed with all my children is right around a year they suddenly become very interested in what I’m doing and try to involve themselves in some way. Usually this manifests itself as them crawling into my pile as I’m sweeping and scattering it with their hands. And then when they can walk,, they notice the trash and start trying to throw everything away. It was fall when my oldest hit this stage, and instead of blocking him from the trash or discouraging it I decided to show him the things that he COULD throw away, mainly all the leaves he was tracking in. After, my house had never been so clean. He was so diligent! Of course he would still make mistakes and throw the wrong thing away. But instead of getting upset about it, I would calmly take it out and show him what he could throw away instead. Another thing I’ve noticed with all my children is that if I give them a holiday and let them play all day by the time it’s lunch they’re grumpy. I have to give them something productive to do to improve their mood.
Hi And although that baby was constantly around fires and even throwing sticks on them, her mother didn’t seem concerned about her safety, knowing the baby girl would only do what she saw her mother do! 😮We need that kind of closeness with our toddlers and kids! I don’t think she will be a ‘Rebellious teenager doing drugs’😮
My parents grew up poor in Mississippi. I asked them about growing up in The Depression they said they were so poor it wasnt noticeable. Life was like this for my grandma when I was little. She got her first indoor bathroom in 1986. When you work all day to eat and stay alive the kids happily help. I find it peaceful. It is a lot of hard work to live off the land.
I lived in this exact environment as a toddler (my people being of the Nenets tribe) and seeing pictures of myself from that time (taken by Russian father), I was cute and chubby-cheeked like this adorable baby lol. Thank you for posting this amazing and sweet video.
I am Finnish American now but I had chubby cheeks like hers too. I still have them. Uhg. LoL I have slanted eyes. I've been asked if I was Asian a few times
The ONLY peace in each of our lives is knowing the Savior of the universe : Jesus the Christ. He will change your heart, and give you peace. "For God so loved the world, that He gave His only Son, that whosoever would believe in Him would not perish, but have eternal life" John 3: 16 ( the holy Bible )
They have more peace than most people with the kids hooked up to a computer or a TV. Learning and bonding with mom, learning skills, in nature learning how to live off the land, truly a lovely experience. You can tell how well the mom teaches her, she’s an amazing little kid with great balance.
@@rogerdevero8726They have the Gods Nature,no need for the books of men. It would only confuse them from their clearly natural state, as it has you. Writing was created by Man to control, that's what the obelisks everywhere are about. This on the other hand was all from the hands of the divine, wouldn't you agree? I just think it's silly to think one God made this place alone. Have you ever seen anything of grandeur built by a single creature acting alone? I rest my case.
It touched my heart to see the two years old girl eagerly to lean and helped her mother. So when she grew up she would survive the cold and brutal weather just like her parents did. I pray for the family’s health and safety. ❤
@mariainezandrade3932 Exactly. Snd it's completely misunderstanding what humans are, what they are capable of, how they long to participate, to play their useful role in their group...
When you don't have to work to survive, a lot of enjoyment for life is missing. Nothing like this, but we boondock (camp with no amenities). Even those few weeks bond us, because we depend on others for basic needs and small achievements bring great pride. I remember my 4yo granddaughter working all day to start the fire. Flint & steel. When she succeeded, her self worth & her feelings of family unity grew by leaps and bounds. As I said, it's nothing like them, because if things went wrong, we could hike 10 miles to the vehicle and drive away.
@@UnscrupulousAgitator Western societies aren't without work. It's just not work that children can learn. And there's a prevailing belief that "kids should be kids," in other words, that they should be free to just play without responsibilities. Then we wonder why we get young adults who aren't prepared for work, don't fee responsible for contributing, don't have a sense of intrinsic worth, and resent adult direction.
This is why I try my best to let my 2 year old help around the house. They are so eager to help at that age and might even surprise you with their abilities. Its also good for them physically and mentally!
I came to understand how huge my country Russia is, how huge Siberia is in it.. Understanding how many indigenous peoples live in Siberia and they do not want to change their life, their culture.. they want to live the way their ancestors lived. I am also from Siberia, but I live modernly, in a huge city (the capital is Novosibirsk) and I have all the conditions for life. But I am very interested in how other people living in my country, in other Siberian places, live.
People regularly dont want to change for something they don't know. As in this case, parents are not going to try to teach the upbringing of their children for new fancy upbringing because then they couldn't live the natural kind of life they have live for centuries and obviously they are doing well. Look the 2 years old, she already can do so much and obviously she knows what to do perfectly, like feeding the dogs and the dog is fully aware that the two years old feeds them... The children are so beautiful, healthy and smart. God bless them all.
@@lsophial Yes, I was very amazed at what a girl does at her age. Whereas our city children, from whom their parents “blow away specks of dust,” do not know how to do anything except sit on gadgets.
I have such admiration for these beautiful people! The way they teach and raise their children is inspiring to see. A way that is missing from mainstream society.😌🇨🇦
i have been in Finlands nomades live in 80th. We brought salvia, they were so astonished, they gifted a rendeer fur back. Its a nature live, without our modern live. You must love it or leave.
Katya is adorable and very helpful😃 blessings to this beautiful family and hope this reaches them and those they love in great health and happiness❤️🙏👍👍 Love from America!!
I am so in awe of you and your family the way you bring up your children the hard work that you share with them and do daily. I have everything in hand and I feel so guilty when I look around and complain that I have nothing. I have learned this from watching your family. Thank you so much by humbling me enough to make me realize having too much is a sin
En effet cette façon d’être uni à la terre mere est aussi difficile qu’admirable pour nous, devenus si fragiles par l’abondance et le confort dans lequel nous baignons
Having too much isn't a sin 😊. It's just about good stewardship and whether or not something becomes an idol or distraction. The more you have, the more you are responsible for taking proper care of.
It can be a sin when we become wasteful. Ever seen or hear George Carlin skit on stuff? We become addicted to consuming. I remember a few years back, seeing a montage of different newscasters all repeating the exact thing on cyber Monday saying "Go ahead, it's okay to get yourself a little something. You've earned it."
because they’re raised outside then privilege and unnecessary sheltering of Western society and are taught from a young age that work is something important and necessary in order to survive, not something your mom forces you to do instead of playing video games
Or most adults these days. Here it is just sit in front of your TV and play videos games. I have a granddaughter who until she was 19, her only chore was to get the silverware out of the dishwasher and put them in the drawer. She is now 25 and will not do a single thing for anyone except herself and her boy friend. She has been in college for 8 years because she can't even decide what she wants to be and keeps changing courses and starting over. This is what we raise in the USA.
I KNOW LOL. I'm in awe. Then the dog walks right next to her - almost guiding her. Now I regret giving my children an allowance, for pulling their quilts over their beds. Lol
Look at the control of the dog . There is a basin full of food and it will not eat it, only if a human puts something in to its bowl. It will eat only that od uf it is given from a human hand.
It looks beautiful there, clean and pristine although I cannot imagine how cold it is. A full life of adventure for a child and you can tell Katya is loved and cared for. Thank you for sharing this way of life with us. Blessings to the family.❤❤❤
In the middle of this video an ad pops up - “choose from thousands of electronics”…. It was a relief to return to this film. How sad our consumerism lives have become.
Это да! По наблюдениям - множество людей просто томятся от безделия, маются, нарочито убивают время бесцельно шляясь по интернету, получая не пользу, а раздражение и угрюмость, а еще усталость и депрессию. Это касается и детей, и у них все еще более болезненно - тоска. Я не за крайности! Но жизнь должна быть наполнена движением, радостью, деятельностью, трудом , созиданием. Особенно в юные годы! Идет формирование устойчивой личности - кто я, какой я, что я могу и что я умею.
Such a strong and helpful baby. She is so adorable and even has time to have a chat with the reindeers. God bless her and her family always.❤❤❤❤❤👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
This video clearly shows how wrong it is not to teach our children that work needs to be done, and by this the child feels far more important and gets far more selfconfidence ❤️
Simple living but the best life in the world. All the time, you feel harmonious in every part of your body. 🌲☀️❄️ Greetings from northernmost of Sweden🇸🇪
they dont feel extra harmonious, they just live, everyday same. I had this live as child. To live in and with nature is necessary for good live. Everybody can decide. Why live in cities?
@@faragraf9380 You can never know what other people are feeling (or their sensory experience), so a more cautious way of expressing yourself is correct. I myself have lived both in cities and on the countryside (years in the forest of northernmost Sweden, in a tent), so I know very well what I am talking about (see my first post).
I remember being 6 and going with my grandfather to harvest honey. My job was to bring dry wood to make smoke, cover the box with the honey combs and if a knife or something fell in to a place my grandfathers hand (his left hand got amputated during war , when he was a vhild in 1943) couldn't reach in to , l had to take it out. I also was suppose to help pushing the cart my grandfather was pulling and watch if nothing was falling off.
She is not struggling, the kids learn trough example she is mom little shadow, and mom is there to show her and explain, that's how they learn, with someone willing to notice them and teaching. I work as a nanny, the 6 month baby smile every time she sees me, I'm in charge of her older sis , but I interact with the little one too, the parents bought like a pen with soft floor and toys , she is standing on her crib complaining while her father is doing something with the tv , I asked do you want me to put her there, his answer oh she doesn't like being there, no stupid, what she doesn't like is every time you put her there alone, or with you but you act like she isn't there, no talking,no holding her a little,no playing and show her things. Nothing, mom fortunately gives her more attention, but sometimes she is laying on the bed and the baby is suckling from her breast like she was a puppy, trying to hold on in 4 legs trying to eat, not holding the baby nursing her while talking to her making eye contact 🤦🏻♀️,
Humanity will survive. Society will fall as it always has. What we believe to be difficult in living in harmony, also means less confusion, less dis ease, and greater understanding of basic purpose. Thanks for sharing this. It’s a great reminder.
That hand washing station at 0:43 is genius, I would never have thought of it, never seen it, super convenient just strapping it to a tree, most of the ones I see include foot pumps and a stand of their own
It's a super popular device for Russian/post-Soviet villages. I'm not sure if they're still of great use but about 30 years ago it was still quite a thing even at "dachas":)
They're living the lives that we are far removed from, and I think there's is a much healthier existance than city slickers such as me 😊 I hope these kinds of people are around forever just like the First Nations people here in Australia who still live the same ways as their ancestors did. ❤
Healthier... Psychologically, sure, but apart from that, inhaling open wood fire smoke all day long + living in extreme cold conditions cannot be good for your lungs at all. Meat-based diet, no choice, not good either. I don't think life expectancy is high in such settings, but it is a life full of meaning.
@blahblahblah-o4z don't feel bad mate, a lot of Australians are unaware of it, these mobs speak no English and their kids don't go to schools, their school is the ancestors way of living and that fine with me bc I believe that should be their right as they were doing just fine, for 65 thousand years, until the English decided to classify this country as Terra Nullis! Had a white Kiwi from Queensland tell (whine) to me about it, so I decided to put her straight 😂😂😂🇦🇺....I was born in Europe and I've educated myself as much as possible on the black fella since our education system has sadly lacked in that department!
If you want to know where "native Americans" came from, this is where- the Siberian nomad tribes such as this one, of the north. An ancient land bridge, now long gone, made it possible for them to walk all the way to North America. So it's been said.
That child is more intelligent and more motivated than most of the people in the United States. She doesn't have to be told what to do. She sees what is needed and does it. The life is hard but i think that they enjoy life more than most people. No phone no computer no car . Only what they need. This is family real life family. Thanks for sharing your life with everyone.
Its so obvious they're related to the Natives of North America. During the last Ice Age there was a bridge connecting these continents. That brave baby here moved me to tears.
I think natives of North America came from Asia not Russia/Siberia. At least that is what the Navaho's told me when I lived with them for 7 years. Best wishes from upstate NY!!
@sierrachoco5271 They are related. Though the ones on this side also had the Polynesian addition. In fact if the Native American don't look more Asian like this folk they are probably not that Indigenous.
Wow what an amazing thing to see. This child will have no problem surviving. This is definitely better than giving your child an IPad to keep them occupied. I’m so inspired
So far i see a normal two year old. Cute as can be who wants to do what she sees everyone else in her family doing. Two year olds are much smarter than many adults think they are and can do a lot more than many adults give them credit. It is up to the parents (which obviously hers have), however, to instill a sense of contributjng to the "work" culture of the family. If parents expect it, children this age will work to the extent they are able to. Americans also used to do this (like any culture, western or otherwise) but that has changed with the softening of our lives. As a mother of two little ones myself, i plan on putting a pearing knife in my childs hand starting at the age of 4 or 5 depending in their maturity and put them to work helping me skin apples or potatoes for supper. Thus is what my mother did to me and i loved it as a child. Now i did cut myself the first time i held a knife but i learned how not to do that pretty fast. I love how the mother in this video encourages her child trying to pick up and carry the bigger pieces of wood. That is exactly what a parent should be doing.
I just keep thinking about this child and the beautiful way that she is growing up. Even though we live in America, I tried to raise my daughter a lot like this, with autonomy and the belief that life itself was a wonderful school. I believe this served her well. Maybe this is why I am so incredibly taken with this little girl from the other side of the world.
La bebé se comunica muy bien y es muy expresiva, además parece que ladra cuando quiere decir algo con fuerza, me impresiona...es hermosa y será fuerte en todos los sentidos ❤ una vida ardua y posiblemente dura, pero libre y hermosa!!
It is extremely healthy for this baby to have a healthy family life,fresh air and plenty of tasks to keep her fit! This is a much better life than my family has with having to have others watch our precious children while we have to work for cooperations all day.
Well, in Western civilization, if we would allow our children to do these things, the government would take them from us. What the world needs is balance. A gentle protective hand while still allowing our children to be independent and explore. We need to get the governments out of our lives
Here in the UK they over protect children, but our government appears to not care about them being abused and raped by grooming gangs, sick world or what?
This is what toddlers instinctively try to do. They copy everything from their parents. My son wants to do everything I do. Cooking, fishing, working with tools, cleaning, gardening, feeding animals. He does everything. It's tiring, but important for their development. Putting them in front of the tablet turns them into zombies.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Children are born with the joy of helping. We are guilty of not properly nurturing them to grow in their love and dignity of being useful.
We put them in a room full of toys to keep them out of the way but I see they will not be in the way and want to help like these little ones
👆❤️🙌🙌
This is absolutely true ❤and I'm so guilty of it😢 I've got ADD, and have always been completely overwhelmed by housework, so it just had to get it over with whenever I did do it 😢 I wish I'd done the Montessori way ❤
This is my favourite comment ever
@@hellybelle5 you did great and your kids love you
I've got the algorithm in just the right spot to recommend me a 16 minute video of a chubby Siberian baby doing chores.
I don’t really get why her being chubby needs to come into it but alright
Maybe because it's the cutest thing ever ? 😊
@@elmondo-s1e its just funny, no need to be offended
@@elmondo-s1e seed oils are probably your problem
foreal
Children who are given chores like that don't have self-esteem issues. They know they matter.
Well,they also need to be far from the cancerous cultures of violence and chaos.. some people use those cultures to destroy powerful empires.. yes,it takes a while but it’s happening even now..not the first time though.
Makes sense. I think that ended with the industrial revolution where children were forced to work under truly horrible damaging conditions, then people justifiably wanted a ban against child labor. And then we overcompensated by removing everything that even remotely resembles "labor" from children. Even though doing a little bit may actually be good for them, making them do some chores (within reasonable limits) is not "child abuse", its actually natural and healthy. But it can be abused.
So true!
I know an awful lot of people who were worked hard as children and they suffer from trauma and personality disorders. Working as a child in and of itself does not give self esteem
@jenilynneful all things within reason. Too much labor is definitely child abuse. My parents are a good contrast. My mom grew up on a working farm. She had before and after school chores and worked all day when school was out. My grandfather gave the kids a share of the money from the crops and livestock when he sold them. My mom grew up to be a secure confident woman who knows how to do everything for herself. My paternal grandfather owned a grocery store. He expected my father to be there every minute he wasn't in school. They lived across the street from the store and my grandfather would go home when the store closed and leave my dad to work late at night doing all the after hours chores. If he made any mistskes he was beaten with an axe handle. My Dad was never paid for his labor and he was not allowed to eat anything from the store. He had to wait and eat at home. My Dad grew up to be a man with all the markers of a traumatized child. I didn't know what was going on with him when I was a kid but being his daughter was no fun. Abusers find a way to make everything abusive.
I can only speak with my experience here in the states but people have this insane desire to control everyone. When they become parents here they just see them as little dolls that want to make life difficult for you. Your kid wants to help and discover the world. Yes they will make a huge mess "washing" the dishes. Let them. I would let my oldest son help me with dishes before he could talk and was barely walking. He initially just played in the water and made a mess. He tried helping to dry up the floor afterwards but wasn't the best. Then he started pushing me away and saying, "me own." So I let him wash the dishes and clean the floor alone. I would say thank you when he was done. Now he's almost 3. He collects his dishes, puts them in the sink, sets up his step stool and happily washes his own dishes. He'll put all the dishes away too. His younger brother helps the best he can at 18 months and is learning from his brother as much as from me.
I don't even take the trash out of his room anymore. They always pick up their trash and throw it away. If they find their bin stinky, which is often as they don't like the trash getting full, they dump it in the trash can in the kitchen. I have never asked them to help me. They offered, I accepted and said thank you. I treated them how I want to be treated.
Yes they still throw tantrums. My toddlers still get mad because they didn't want milk until I put it away then want it then don't want it. I just stay calm. They're learning by how I act, by what I do. So I behave the way I want them to. It's hard but I try my best.
Hunt, Gather, Parent is a great book about how to parent this way.
I hear you about the control thing...
Thank you for raising good human beings. Children really are the mirrors of there parents.
#thankyooouuu so much for sharing
I agree with you.
I wish I'd had made my daughters do more chores growing up. However, they had all these after school activities (gymnastics, music lessons, taekwondo, etc.). However, they still grew up to be very productive adults with good jobs who keep their own homes neater than mine!
The sweetest little child, smart, focused, wanting to help all the time, God bless her and her family
How dare you assume their gender. How do you know they're not one of those trans or non-binary subsistence nomads? You know, gender identity is so important to people who have to work, raise and protect animals from predators, break ice from the river and eat raw frozen meat to survive.
She is "educated.to help those kind of cultures did not have any teenager man made crises
@@joelleschachter2867she is not a teenager yet! Lol. Again… all the young people I know, including toddlers and teenagers, are a joy and asset to their families and communities. Toddlers in America love to help too! Leave our young people and their families alone and spare the negative judgment… or do something to actually engage with or enrich a young persons life. 🤷🏻♀️. These group shaming and judgment comments are getting old, boring, ridiculous… and telling… more about the commenter.
People have survived and thrived for hundreds of millennia with just love and wits. Folks that live on the land are not civilized, but their modest contribution is valuable and they are fully human in all regards, perhaps more so in some than us civilized folk. Just as we have a balance of liberal and conservative in civilization there must be a balance between rural and civilized in humanity as a whole.
It never ceases to amaze me how differently some people live on this earth! God Bless us everyone.
God bless us, every one.
❤️💯❤️🍀
and westerners insist that "their way" is the best way and only way... trying to indoctrinate all peoples of the earth
and at the same time, have so much in common
@@davidpool8796yes, I was thinking about the little toddler girl across the street. She is sweet and helpful like Katya.
Dear Lord, I pray for protection for all the little ones, their folks, and our Earth. Hallelujah.
I was a medical missionary there very healthy people absolutely rejected our western medicine actually saw an older gentleman with half of the top of his head gone, I panicked and said we must get him to Germany for immediate cancer surgery this man won’t last a month!!! After speaking with him I found out he was actually almost 14 years with advanced melanoma with no other medical issues!!! Most of the fingers there are purple from the iodine from walnut trees, but they actually TAUGHT MY ENTIRE MEDICAL TEAM so much, when I came back stateside I adapted some things I learned there!!! Very grateful for the experience and the wonderful albeit cautious nature of the people there!!! Spoceba!!!!
According to the rumors, adults existed in the past too.
Oh cool. Any examples of knowledge you picked up that you wouldn’t mind sharing?
So interesting! What did they teach you?
Yeah
GOD BLESS THE CHILDREN !
The dexterity and coordination of this child is impressive. Meanwhile my 2yr old throws a tantrum because I won’t let him eat the cat litter
lol😂
😂😢😮😢😢😮❤🎉
😃
What the hell, let em try it. You never know!!
😂😂😂😂
Alfred Adler the psychologist said that one of our most pressing needs as humans is to find a place to belong. And, to feel that we contribute something to society. The baby nails those.
Baby girl fully understands her living environment. She knows what is required and takes the initiative to help out. She is physically stronger than the teenagers who live in modern cities
Agreed!
Over generalization leads to misconceptions and preventable disasters. Some of those teens in cities are already murderers and violent offenders. I believe you are confused with middle class and upper-class teens who live life of pampered sheltered privilege.
@@Skitdora2010 No matter what class, these children have more motivation, happiness, & family loyalty than the majority of westerners
Aww, this baby can't be older than 2, and is carrying loads, and carefully feeding the dogs😂. We gotta step it up. No smart phones in sight, and great for them!
@@Skitdora2010 I second this. It's been there for some time im 47 came from there and I can see it's still there 47 years later.
If not for UA-cam, I would not know you exist. Now that I do and see you, I wish you health and a prosper future in the course of time, for young and old.
You just made me cry
I wish I could have been raised in that situation
How much happier most of us would have been.
imagine that was what it was like for little genghis
What a lovely sentiment.
Gosh this is just so beautiful and made me smile, god bless you too dearest and you make the world such a loved place ansd space
When kids play they imitate adults. When there's no toys, games or phones they literally imitate adults.
Called growing up quick
They can still play but their main tasks are productive and those are their priority which is natural
What a beautiful robust baby, with such an eager appetite! So sweet and so eager to help and pull her own weight.
This 2 year old has so much personality. And she’s being raised by attentive, respectful parents. Bravo to great parent teachers- Allowing a child to be free to explore and learn while providing everything she needs to grow up.
I love how they all let her blow out the matches 😄
I think it’s quite a stretch to say the child has been provided with everything they need to grow up. Some modern cleanliness standards and healthcare would definitely help.
The baby is so tiny but she's determined to be helpful
And she's adorable. Trying so hard to help her momma! 🤗🥰 We made stilts like that when we were children. The newborn caribou is precious too. 🙏🏼🙏🏽🙏🏾
Именно в труде, в миросозерцании и в взаимодействии с природой формируется ум, а одно лишь многознание уму не научает!!!
Tiny?
@@susanlewis9351really. Babies need to be more robust in Siberia, but it seems you’re just trying to be nasty. Yes she looks very chubby but most children in Siberia have big round cheeks. It is the face shape of most siberians.
Unlike Western kids
Such a helpful baby. And so chubby! I’m just about to have my fifth. And one thing I’ve noticed with all my children is right around a year they suddenly become very interested in what I’m doing and try to involve themselves in some way. Usually this manifests itself as them crawling into my pile as I’m sweeping and scattering it with their hands. And then when they can walk,, they notice the trash and start trying to throw everything away.
It was fall when my oldest hit this stage, and instead of blocking him from the trash or discouraging it I decided to show him the things that he COULD throw away, mainly all the leaves he was tracking in. After, my house had never been so clean. He was so diligent! Of course he would still make mistakes and throw the wrong thing away. But instead of getting upset about it, I would calmly take it out and show him what he could throw away instead.
Another thing I’ve noticed with all my children is that if I give them a holiday and let them play all day by the time it’s lunch they’re grumpy. I have to give them something productive to do to improve their mood.
Where r you from?
I wish I was brought up that way. My memories of childhood are being bored.
Hi
And although that baby was constantly around fires and even throwing sticks on them, her mother didn’t seem concerned about her safety, knowing the baby girl would only do what she saw her mother do! 😮We need that kind of closeness with our toddlers and kids! I don’t think she will be a ‘Rebellious teenager doing drugs’😮
Or getting lazy and fat by hanging out on laptop for hours and hours everyday!
@@toosiyabrandt8676 well said
My parents grew up poor in Mississippi. I asked them about growing up in The Depression they said they were so poor it wasnt noticeable. Life was like this for my grandma when I was little. She got her first indoor bathroom in 1986. When you work all day to eat and stay alive the kids happily help. I find it peaceful. It is a lot of hard work to live off the land.
Kids mimic what they see
What area were they from?
This isn't poverty, it's traditional life in nature
A lot to be said about our current society. Beautiful video thank you ❤
Yo, play cousin 😂 My entire family is from the 662. I live in DC now! Such lovely people 😊 and delicious foods
I lived in this exact environment as a toddler (my people being of the Nenets tribe) and seeing pictures of myself from that time (taken by Russian father), I was cute and chubby-cheeked like this adorable baby lol. Thank you for posting this amazing and sweet video.
I am Finnish American now but I had chubby cheeks like hers too. I still have them. Uhg. LoL I have slanted eyes. I've been asked if I was Asian a few times
@@liisabjork76 same with me everyone in the US thought my mom was 'Chinese' and I'm still asked "are you mixed" bc of my cheeks & eyes.
Those adorable chubby cheeks the beautiful baby has.😊❤
Beautiful children, beautiful family 👪 ❤💕💓💗
In her little blue and red hat.
Their genetic admixture is so interesting
Nature and hard work. The whole family pitching in! I hope you have happiness and peace in your lives.
The ONLY peace in each of our lives is knowing the Savior of the universe : Jesus the Christ. He will change your heart, and give you peace. "For God so loved the world, that He gave His only Son, that whosoever would believe in Him would not perish, but have eternal life" John 3: 16 ( the holy Bible )
They have more peace than most people with the kids hooked up to a computer or a TV. Learning and bonding with mom, learning skills, in nature learning how to live off the land, truly a lovely experience. You can tell how well the mom teaches her, she’s an amazing little kid with great balance.
@@rogerdevero8726Amen amen amen amen amen amen amen ❤❤❤
@@rogerdevero8726They have the Gods Nature,no need for the books of men. It would only confuse them from their clearly natural state, as it has you. Writing was created by Man to control, that's what the obelisks everywhere are about. This on the other hand was all from the hands of the divine, wouldn't you agree?
I just think it's silly to think one God made this place alone. Have you ever seen anything of grandeur built by a single creature acting alone? I rest my case.
It touched my heart to see the two years old girl eagerly to lean and helped her mother. So when she grew up she would survive the cold and brutal weather just like her parents did. I pray for the family’s health and safety. ❤
Então, hoje os filhos têm tudo, não produzem nada, não respeitam mais os pais e ninguém mais. Os adultos dizem: é só uma criança, perdoa ...
@mariainezandrade3932 Exactly. Snd it's completely misunderstanding what humans are, what they are capable of, how they long to participate, to play their useful role in their group...
@rheinhartsilvento2576 certainly
When you don't have to work to survive, a lot of enjoyment for life is missing.
Nothing like this, but we boondock (camp with no amenities). Even those few weeks bond us, because we depend on others for basic needs and small achievements bring great pride.
I remember my 4yo granddaughter working all day to start the fire. Flint & steel. When she succeeded, her self worth & her feelings of family unity grew by leaps and bounds.
As I said, it's nothing like them, because if things went wrong, we could hike 10 miles to the vehicle and drive away.
@@UnscrupulousAgitator Western societies aren't without work. It's just not work that children can learn. And there's a prevailing belief that "kids should be kids," in other words, that they should be free to just play without responsibilities. Then we wonder why we get young adults who aren't prepared for work, don't fee responsible for contributing, don't have a sense of intrinsic worth, and resent adult direction.
The little one staggering around carrying a couple of pieces of wood. Cute as a button and so determined. ❤
This is why I try my best to let my 2 year old help around the house. They are so eager to help at that age and might even surprise you with their abilities. Its also good for them physically and mentally!
Какая прелесть, какие хорошие люди. Тишина и покой, ребёночек просто чудо. Дай Бог им здоровья, долгих лет жизни, мирного неба
I've just watched the sweetest girl that was ever born on this planet.
❤
I came to understand how huge my country Russia is, how huge Siberia is in it.. Understanding how many indigenous peoples live in Siberia and they do not want to change their life, their culture.. they want to live the way their ancestors lived. I am also from Siberia, but I live modernly, in a huge city (the capital is Novosibirsk) and I have all the conditions for life. But I am very interested in how other people living in my country, in other Siberian places, live.
People regularly dont want to change for something they don't know. As in this case, parents are not going to try to teach the upbringing of their children for new fancy upbringing because then they couldn't live the natural kind of life they have live for centuries and obviously they are doing well. Look the 2 years old, she already can do so much and obviously she knows what to do perfectly, like feeding the dogs and the dog is fully aware that the two years old feeds them... The children are so beautiful, healthy and smart. God bless them all.
Slava Russia....♥️🇮🇪 Ireland
@@lsophial
Yes, I was very amazed at what a girl does at her age. Whereas our city children, from whom their parents “blow away specks of dust,” do not know how to do anything except sit on gadgets.
Your country is big enough indeed, wondering why you would destroy and kill people in their own country, that is Ukraine.Like yours is not enough?
their way of life is so natural...we can only envy them...
How sweet , the determination, that little girl is working hard to help out.
I love the way her mother tells her to take just one log, but she struggles to take two.
Her little voice and face are so precious. God in miniature form
Don’t want to be that person but you shouldn’t call a person God, but I agree she is beautiful❤️
bless her, she was determined to carry two logs
I have such admiration for these beautiful people! The way they teach and raise their children is inspiring to see. A way that is missing from mainstream society.😌🇨🇦
I’m a westerner and although I really appreciate the nomadic videos. I really appreciate and am most grateful for my western home.
Me too… I am lucky to live in this country 🇺🇸
i have been in Finlands nomades live in 80th. We brought salvia, they were so astonished, they gifted a rendeer fur back. Its a nature live, without our modern live. You must love it or leave.
I am just the opposite, I envy them.
@ well you can live there very cheaply.
@@jdezeeuw6540 of course without all, we prefer
I love that they let her blow out their matches. A loving gesture
God bless that little child. Such a lovely family. X
dont know, if they are lovely, they just workers.
@@faragraf9380obviously they are lovely, look how they love each other.
Katya is adorable and very helpful😃 blessings to this beautiful family and hope this reaches them and those they love in great health and happiness❤️🙏👍👍 Love from America!!
I am so in awe of you and your family the way you bring up your children the hard work that you share with them and do daily. I have everything in hand and I feel so guilty when I look around and complain that I have nothing. I have learned this from watching your family. Thank you so much by humbling me enough to make me realize having too much is a sin
En effet cette façon d’être uni à la terre mere est aussi difficile qu’admirable pour nous, devenus si fragiles par l’abondance et le confort dans lequel nous baignons
❤
❤❤
Having too much isn't a sin 😊. It's just about good stewardship and whether or not something becomes an idol or distraction. The more you have, the more you are responsible for taking proper care of.
complaining, as we do careless is, not estimate our gifts.
It can be a sin when we become wasteful. Ever seen or hear George Carlin skit on stuff? We become addicted to consuming. I remember a few years back, seeing a montage of different newscasters all repeating the exact thing on cyber Monday saying "Go ahead, it's okay to get yourself a little something. You've earned it."
That baby just did more work in this video than some teenagers i know do in months 😂
Edit: I said "some" teenagers that I know...not all of them.
you're right, we only raise " lazy bones" !
Not farm kids. I know.
FACTS 💯 😂😂😂😂
because they’re raised outside then privilege and unnecessary sheltering of Western society and are taught from a young age that work is something important and necessary in order to survive, not something your mom forces you to do instead of playing video games
Or most adults these days. Here it is just sit in front of your TV and play videos games. I have a granddaughter who until she was 19, her only chore was to get the silverware out of the dishwasher and put them in the drawer. She is now 25 and will not do a single thing for anyone except herself and her boy friend. She has been in college for 8 years because she can't even decide what she wants to be and keeps changing courses and starting over. This is what we raise in the USA.
なんて力強いお子さんなんでしょう。
家族の一人として、きちんと役目を補っている。
素晴らしいことです。
貴重な動画に、感謝します。
ありがとうございます。
Such a cute little girl, and such a loving mother! Thank you for making and sharing this video!
When the little girl fed the dog! ❤❤❤
I KNOW LOL. I'm in awe. Then the dog walks right next to her - almost guiding her. Now I regret giving my children an allowance, for pulling their quilts over their beds. Lol
She looked like she was feeding a wolf :)
OMGOSH, when I saw that it just made my heart smile! ❤
Look at the control of the dog . There is a basin full of food and it will not eat it, only if a human puts something in to its bowl. It will eat only that od uf it is given from a human hand.
@@anettee.1805the north dogs are special and yes, they come from the wolf's.
It looks beautiful there, clean and pristine although I cannot imagine how cold it is. A full life of adventure for a child and you can tell Katya is loved and cared for. Thank you for sharing this way of life with us. Blessings to the family.❤❤❤
What a busy little cutie ❤
In the middle of this video an ad pops up - “choose from thousands of electronics”…. It was a relief to return to this film. How sad our consumerism lives have become.
Это да! По наблюдениям - множество людей просто томятся от безделия, маются, нарочито убивают время бесцельно шляясь по интернету, получая не пользу, а раздражение и угрюмость, а еще усталость и депрессию. Это касается и детей, и у них все еще более болезненно - тоска. Я не за крайности! Но жизнь должна быть наполнена движением, радостью, деятельностью, трудом , созиданием. Особенно в юные годы! Идет формирование устойчивой личности - кто я, какой я, что я могу и что я умею.
When she got the dog water all on her own, it absolutely melted my heart ❤️
No false reality. No false algorithms. Just life as it comes. beautiful
Katya is delightful and her parents are very loving with her. Thanks for posting.
These children learn survival skills, Beautiful family.
Such a strong and helpful baby. She is so adorable and even has time to have a chat with the reindeers. God bless her and her family always.❤❤❤❤❤👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
. Those animals are imprisoned... Vile Exploitation & Killing of animals/Sentient Beings. The passing on of Abuse. Not ok'.
This video clearly shows how wrong it is not to teach our children that work needs to be done, and by this the child feels far more important and gets far more selfconfidence ❤️
Simple living but the best life in the world. All the time, you feel harmonious in every part of your body. 🌲☀️❄️
Greetings from northernmost of Sweden🇸🇪
That is true! ❤
No entiendo que puede ser tan armonioso de andar tan sucio
they dont feel extra harmonious, they just live, everyday same. I had this live as child.
To live in and with nature is necessary for good live. Everybody can decide. Why live in cities?
@@faragraf9380 You can never know what other people are feeling (or their sensory experience), so a more cautious way of expressing yourself is correct.
I myself have lived both in cities and on the countryside (years in the forest of northernmost Sweden, in a tent), so I know very well what I am talking about (see my first post).
@faragraf9380 agree
Such a good lil helper❤
So good to watch this for so many reasons, thank you for the post.
Your work is brilliant. It turns my world upside down!
Little girl is so cute... God bless this family...
I remember being 6 and going with my grandfather to harvest honey. My job was to bring dry wood to make smoke, cover the box with the honey combs and if a knife or something fell in to a place my grandfathers hand (his left hand got amputated during war , when he was a vhild in 1943) couldn't reach in to , l had to take it out. I also was suppose to help pushing the cart my grandfather was pulling and watch if nothing was falling off.
Das kind ist so süss ,gutes Mädchen 😊 bleibt gesund ihr lieben Familien ❤
Beautiful. They let the children struggle. That's how they learn.
She is not struggling, the kids learn trough example she is mom little shadow, and mom is there to show her and explain, that's how they learn, with someone willing to notice them and teaching. I work as a nanny, the 6 month baby smile every time she sees me, I'm in charge of her older sis , but I interact with the little one too, the parents bought like a pen with soft floor and toys , she is standing on her crib complaining while her father is doing something with the tv , I asked do you want me to put her there, his answer oh she doesn't like being there, no stupid, what she doesn't like is every time you put her there alone, or with you but you act like she isn't there, no talking,no holding her a little,no playing and show her things. Nothing, mom fortunately gives her more attention, but sometimes she is laying on the bed and the baby is suckling from her breast like she was a puppy, trying to hold on in 4 legs trying to eat, not holding the baby nursing her while talking to her making eye contact 🤦🏻♀️,
Humanity will survive. Society will fall as it always has. What we believe to be difficult in living in harmony, also means less confusion, less dis ease, and greater understanding of basic purpose. Thanks for sharing this. It’s a great reminder.
GOD BLESS THIS FAMILY 🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤
Not a single tablet at sight! God bless this people and the one who brought us this video forever. Amen.
That hand washing station at 0:43 is genius, I would never have thought of it, never seen it, super convenient just strapping it to a tree, most of the ones I see include foot pumps and a stand of their own
It's a super popular device for Russian/post-Soviet villages. I'm not sure if they're still of great use but about 30 years ago it was still quite a thing even at "dachas":)
This is real life, parents in charge. May the Almighty continue to bless them. Respect 🇬🇾
They're living the lives that we are far removed from, and I think there's is a much healthier existance than city slickers such as me 😊 I hope these kinds of people are around forever just like the First Nations people here in Australia who still live the same ways as their ancestors did. ❤
Are there still places in Australia where they do that?
Healthier... Psychologically, sure, but apart from that, inhaling open wood fire smoke all day long + living in extreme cold conditions cannot be good for your lungs at all. Meat-based diet, no choice, not good either. I don't think life expectancy is high in such settings, but it is a life full of meaning.
@@blahblahblah-o4z yes there are still small groups of First Nation people who still live in their traditional ways.
@CocoEmmet61 I never heard of that, and I live in Australia 😅
@blahblahblah-o4z don't feel bad mate, a lot of Australians are unaware of it, these mobs speak no English and their kids don't go to schools, their school is the ancestors way of living and that fine with me bc I believe that should be their right as they were doing just fine, for 65 thousand years, until the English decided to classify this country as Terra Nullis! Had a white Kiwi from Queensland tell (whine) to me about it, so I decided to put her straight 😂😂😂🇦🇺....I was born in Europe and I've educated myself as much as possible on the black fella since our education system has sadly lacked in that department!
Healthy homemade bread with no chemicals. I bet it's delicious.
If you want to know where "native Americans" came from, this is where- the Siberian nomad tribes such as this one, of the north. An ancient land bridge, now long gone, made it possible for them to walk all the way to North America.
So it's been said.
That child is more intelligent and more motivated than most of the people in the United States. She doesn't have to be told what to do. She sees what is needed and does it. The life is hard but i think that they enjoy life more than most people. No phone no computer no car . Only what they need. This is family real life family. Thanks for sharing your life with everyone.
These people have a much higher quality of life than anyone in Canada does. I like her quiet moments and conversations with the reindeer
I agree. She is adorable. Loved her talking to the riendeer.
What an encouraging, supportive mama!
Its so obvious they're related to the Natives of North America. During the last Ice Age there was a bridge connecting these continents. That brave baby here moved me to tears.
I think natives of North America came from Asia not Russia/Siberia. At least that is what the Navaho's told me when I lived with them for 7 years. Best wishes from upstate NY!!
@sierrachoco5271 They are related. Though the ones on this side also had the Polynesian addition. In fact if the Native American don't look more Asian like this folk they are probably not that Indigenous.
Siberia is in Asia @@sierrachoco5271
@@sierrachoco5271 Siberia is in Asia. Navajo were third immigration wave.
She is an adorable chunk. I love her face
Wow what an amazing thing to see. This child will have no problem surviving. This is definitely better than giving your child an IPad to keep them occupied. I’m so inspired
Precious babies, so sweet.
This kid’s done more physical labour than most Western kids have done in their first decade!
Depends which westeners, though. Many of the farmers' children in northern Europe are bought up very much like Katya.
Such a joy watching your family....God Bless you all
This family all looks so strong and healthy. It seems that hard work is a good life if not a very easy one. Beautiful family.
hard work is always good in nature. By this reason I have a piece of gardenforest to work in.
Healthier and happier with zero stress.
@@MelissaR784 Is there no stress when blizzard approach?
I just want to follow this little girl...can you make more videos of her please she is lovable
.
.❤ '❤
This is awesome teaching your child to become a good worker...and it makes her happy❤
So far i see a normal two year old. Cute as can be who wants to do what she sees everyone else in her family doing. Two year olds are much smarter than many adults think they are and can do a lot more than many adults give them credit. It is up to the parents (which obviously hers have), however, to instill a sense of contributjng to the "work" culture of the family. If parents expect it, children this age will work to the extent they are able to. Americans also used to do this (like any culture, western or otherwise) but that has changed with the softening of our lives. As a mother of two little ones myself, i plan on putting a pearing knife in my childs hand starting at the age of 4 or 5 depending in their maturity and put them to work helping me skin apples or potatoes for supper. Thus is what my mother did to me and i loved it as a child. Now i did cut myself the first time i held a knife but i learned how not to do that pretty fast. I love how the mother in this video encourages her child trying to pick up and carry the bigger pieces of wood. That is exactly what a parent should be doing.
Beautiful little one so helpful
Pure freedom. These are the people who will survive if there was ever a need to do so.....working with the land and what nature has given.
I bet they keep their teeth longer than we do, no sugar and sweets! they look very healthy, but it's a hard life for a woman.
Lovely that babies have the same babble language the world over.
i understand ger talking.😊
This is so beautiful and the way it should be! Love to all of the beautiful people xxx
Wonderful, loved this so much. Little girl is working hard like Mommy!
I just keep thinking about this child and the beautiful way that she is growing up. Even though we live in America, I tried to raise my daughter a lot like this, with autonomy and the belief that life itself was a wonderful school. I believe this served her well. Maybe this is why I am so incredibly taken with this little girl from the other side of the world.
La bebé se comunica muy bien y es muy expresiva, además parece que ladra cuando quiere decir algo con fuerza, me impresiona...es hermosa y será fuerte en todos los sentidos ❤ una vida ardua y posiblemente dura, pero libre y hermosa!!
Hard life. Self-reliant and real. Great respect to this family.
What a truly blessed family.
I feel such respect for the family, the wee girl is working so hard ….so cute
It is extremely healthy for this baby to have a healthy family life,fresh air and plenty of tasks to keep her fit! This is a much better life than my family has with having to have others watch our precious children while we have to work for cooperations all day.
This 2-yr old didn't just decide to help her Mum, nor reach thos level of dexterity by her own genius. HER PARENTS TAUGHT HER!
Kids will imitate their parents. That's how they learn to speak. They will also imitate what their parents do if permitted.
What a beautiful little girl I want to hug her
Fascinated by the reindeer people
Thank you for sharing this - I did not know about these folks but now I have been fortunate to learn about a different culture that is thriving.
Very strong child...congratulations
Well, in Western civilization, if we would allow our children to do these things, the government would take them from us.
What the world needs is balance. A gentle protective hand while still allowing our children to be independent and explore. We need to get the governments out of our lives
Here in the UK they over protect children, but our government appears to not care about them being abused and raped by grooming gangs, sick world or what?
totally agree with your conclusion !
its up to yourself how you decide to live and grow your kids. Not goverments fault or responsibility
What part of this clip would your government intervene?
@@312karen non. This is a different country with own habits.
What is their life expectancy? They work SO hard! Watching the little girl being so helpful and proud of her hard work is awesome!
Depends on the site. One said 50 yrs but most were 65 to 80 yrs. Not that much different from ours since ours in the west has lowered.
The dog obediently lets the child lead
They will live longer than westerners anyway
This is what toddlers instinctively try to do. They copy everything from their parents. My son wants to do everything I do. Cooking, fishing, working with tools, cleaning, gardening, feeding animals. He does everything. It's tiring, but important for their development. Putting them in front of the tablet turns them into zombies.
So peaceful way of life and best survivalist,and the lil ones, so cute 🥰
I would love to see more videos of these hard-working people!