Greetings from Brazil! 🇧🇷 I'm very grateful that you are enjoying our music and culture these days! Of course, Brazil is GIANT when we talk about the national music and culture, keep exploring! Obrigado, cara! TMJ
I couldn't agree more with your tier list! Little miss is too fire.. Especially the bonuses! AH!! But if i made tier list it would be.. first place 🥇: alive second place: little miss third: dystopia fourth: jeevan fivth: brazil sixth: the love seventh: sunrise eigth: alpha
They all give off their own vibes: Alpha feels like a small band stuck in older eras trying to get by, Little Miss feels like a sort of thing I'd hear in urban areas of New England (especially New York), Sunrise has a sort of modernized techno vibe to it, The Love is the most French part of Incredibox (can't tell if that's good or not), Brazil is as Brazillian as it can get for me, Alive's combination of intense and chill create a feeling of a trap remix of a childhood song, Jeevan relocates me into India, no matter my mood, and Dystopia is cyberpunk. Must I say more? All deserve amazing ratings!
My opinion: 1st: Little Miss. You can’t lie, these vibes brought me back to 2015 where I always used to go to big malls (like broadmarsh centre, you’ll be missed). 2nd: Jeevan. I like cultural types of songs and this is my favourite out of them. 3rd: Sunrise. True classic vibes. 4th: Brazil. Again. Cultural beats are my preferable tracks, but this one doesn’t have as cool vibes as Jeevan does, but it is more calm. 5th: Alive. I like it, but there is a few tweaks that are needed, especially with melody 5. 6th: Dystopia: Not bad. There’s just some sounds that I think could have more futuristic sounds to them. Voice 2 is the best imo. 7th: Alpha. Sure, some sounds don’t go well with others. The only thing I like is that it brings the memories of the original flash player version. 8th: The Love. Now… I know you’re gonna say I’m wrong, but let’s be honest. Some sounds don’t make sense to me. Examples include: Beat 5 sounding like an effect and Effect 2 sounding like a voice. That’s my opinion! Do y’all agree with me?
Alpha: honestly quite incredible: 8/10 Little Miss: Very the good: 9/10 Sunrise: Eh: 6/10 The Love: I wanna die: 4/10 Brazil: amazing: 10/10 Alive: its okay: 7/10 Jeevan: so underrated: 8/10 Dystopia: pyramid rotato: 8/10
Since I'm guessing you made this before Wekiddy, this would be my list. (Call me a warcrime all you want) 9. Alpha 8. The Love (only cuz I rarely play it) 7. Wekiddy 6. Alive 5. Little Miss 4. Jeevan 3. Brazil 2. Dystopia 1. Sunrise Judge all you want
Mine: 0. V9 (I feel like it’s gonna top all of them) 1. Jeevan 2. Dystopia 3. Alive 4. Little Miss 5. Alpha 6.Sunrise 7. The Love 8. Brazil 🥸🥸 you gotta put some clothes 🤗 4:31 Edit: I WAS CORECT V9 TOPPED ALL OF THEM
Here is Mine :o 1st: Jeevan 2nd: Sunrise 3rd: Brazil 4th: The Love 5th: Little Miss 6th: Alive 7th: Alpha 8th: Dystopia ^ - Dystopia is Different to me, so I don't really like it :P
My rankings 1st - Alive (Yes.) 2nd - Jeevan (I have really enjoyed the vibe with Jeevan) 3rd - Dystopia (It was almost a tie between Jeevan and Dystopia but if we aren't counting bonuses then jeevan beats Dystopia.) 4th - Brazil (Same reason as Jeevan, just not as much) 5th - Alpha (Very cool, just some sounds I don't really like that much) 6th - Little miss (Same as alpha but a few more sounds) 7th - Love (I only put it above Sunrise because of the swimming guy) 8th - Sunrise (Not a fan)
ranked based on my opinion 1. alpha 2. little miss 3. javeen 4. brazil 5. sunrise 6. wekiddy 7. alive 8. the love 9. dystopia ranked based on logic 1. little miss 2. javeen 3. wekiddy 4. sunrise 5. alpha 6. brazil 7. alive 8. dystopia 9. the love
My ratings (this comment is edited) 9:Brazil. I don’t hate it but I really don’t like it too much. It only has 1 loop and most of the effects are more related to beats than effects. But I think the Melodie’s and voices are good. 8:alpha: every once in a while I can enjoy some old school beatboxing. I think mixing is pretty fun on this version! But there are better 7:alive:if this was about bonuses, this would be top 3. But the mixing is probably the most repetitive out of any version and is only 1 loop. The voices are especially repetitive. But the beats, effects, and melodies are great! 6:jeevan:this is like a way better version of Brazil! It has 2 loops this time and I love that half the polos sound spiritual and the other half are catchy and fast paced! 5:the love: this version admittedly has some of the best sounds in the game! The bass, first beat, second melody, and 4th melody, are some of my favorite sounds in the game. But one thing. Why is “beat 3” a effect? 4:wekiddy:wekiddy is a banger! All of the sounds slap! (Except the furby and voice 4.) but I love so many sounds here! I love old school hip hop so it ain’t surprising that this version slaps. 3:sunrise: this version BARELY is better than wekiddy. But that’s because I just love the vibe of this song and I don’t have anything to say about the negative parts of this version. So yeah. 2:little miss. Bruh! Before I said this is number 6 but it really grew on me! This version is a banger. All the beats, effects, melodies, and voices are great! Almost all voices can change the song entirely and it is just amazing! 1:dystopia: this song is just incredible! Now I know some polos aren’t that good as the others but seriously, the ones that are good are masterpieces! Plus, there aren’t that much that are bad anyway.
In my opinion Dystopia is by far the best, followed by Wekiddy, and all the other ones are below it in a tie because the other ones just don't really stand out to me. I absolutely adore modded incredibox though, pretty much all mods are above the officials, except Airline, Invasion and _especially_ Azurite which all kinda suck bad
Alpha - 7/10, pretty good I have to admit Little Miss - 9/10, i love little miss a lot, also has one of the best whistle sounds in Incredibox Sunrise - 6/10, kinda hard to make mixes with The Love - 8/10, really good, it also has one of my favorite melodies from Incredibox Brazil - 6.5/10, there arent that much sounds to choose from which is an issue Alive - 7/10, same case as sunrise, kinda hard to make mixes with Jeevan - 7.5/10 same case as sunrise and brazik Dystopia - 8/10, the sounds here are really good, plus this version has the mostly heavenly choir in all of Incredibox history, but it suffers the same issue as sunrise
What I find quite amusing is that, before Wekiddy came out, your top 3 were actually my bottom 3! I don't exactly believe any are 'bad' exactly, rather just varying levels of likeability. Before Wekiddy, my ranking stood at... - 8th: Brazil: While I enjoy themed tracks, and I think it sounds very accurate to Brazilian music, I think the approach leaves a lot to be desired. For instance, the beats, except for Beat 1, are all marraca imitations, which isn't bad, but still a bit lacklustre in my opinion. Sure, it is Brazilian, but surely you couldn't get a rhythmic Brazilian carnival drum interpretation, perhaps something in rpeated triplets to break up the pacing? Further on, I don't think a lot works on its own, and you need to overload your pallet with lots of things to make it sound decent, to the point where it sound a bit overcomplicated and you'd just ask yourself why you don't just switch to another track. - 7th: Little Miss: Let me preface by saying that my opinion of Little Miss was certainly improved when I heard you argue your case for it, although I still personally don't favour it that highly. There isn't exactly a good way to put it other than I think it's really simplistic in terms of its actual content and I just don't find it that overall appealing. Some of the noises I also find particularly ear-grating, like that constant gravel-like effect produced by Beat 3. Like Brazil, that certainly doesn't mean it doesn't have it's good moments, like the Chorus parts and Effect 4 just elevating the overall quality of the mix, but still I personally just don't see the appeal when compared to the higher-ranking ones. - 6th: The Love: Overall, The Love is perfectly fine, and probably shouldn't be down this low for the content itself. However, it's a personal opinion of mine, and it may sound too music theory-esque, but, also effecting the ranking of Brazil (and the current ranking of Wekiddy), I far prefer tracks in minor tonalities than in major tonalities. I think The Love is better than Little Miss and considerably better than Brazil (and Wekiddy), as it captures a hardcore party boat-like vibe very well. Effect 1 absolutely drives it with that blasted bassline and Melody 2, Voice 1, and Voice 4 are all so damn catchy. But there are some weak elements, like Voice 3 just yeah-ing and bringing nothing else to the table. On its own, I think it's bopping, but when ranked, I don't think it's as good as its competition. - 5th: Alive: I don't dislike Alive persay, as it's a good idea and it was clear it was meant to be a bit 'out there', but I still do have some considerable issues with it. I think the concept is good, and lots of the tracks are interesting and unique, but if you measure it tonally, it really just all exists on a single note drone while other tracks follow chordal progressions which I think limits its creative capabilities. Furthermore, unique doesn't always equate to good, I'm particularly thinking of Melody 5 that just screams at vague pitch, and Effect 1 and Effect 4 which are essentially just repeats of each other. To be honest, The Love would probably be above Alive if it wasn't for Beat 3 being able to seamlessly carry the running progression of the mix on its back. Alive would certainly be lower on the list if not for Beat 3, and while there really is a lot left to be desired, I still think it can work if in the hands of the right mixer. - 4th: Alpha: Like you said, Alpha was the first, it doesn't exactly stand out on its own, and lots of the tracks are too individual and seperate from a central theme. However, in contrast to Alive, it sticks to fairly basic musical and percussive consistencies that, even if diverse, still work together incredibly well. Beat 1 is just so strong when starting out, providing a percussive-drive as well as a bass-drive seamlessly and just makes it so easy to make anything sound good on top of it. A similar shoutout goes to Effect 4 for the rocking bassline provided on top of such, and both the Chorus and Voice elements all just weave together so well. Plus, that groove, it's absolutely banging when you blast it at full volume as you cruise down the street. Of course it has its drawbacks, like Melody 1 which I think just sounds silly, but it's just a small few bumps in an otherwise really good track that is perfect to both start and continue on with. - 3rd: Dystopia: Honestly, ranking the top 3, Dystopia, Jeevan, and Sunrise, was painful, as I think they are all top-notch in their own individual ways. I think Dystopia clearly stands out amongst all Incredibox tracks due to its conceptual creativity, and is an improvement of the theming which I think was trying to be emulated by Alive. But beyond that, the elements you can mix with are all incredibly strong. While I can't deny elements are repetitive, I'm thinking Beat 4, Beat 5, and Effect 3, I think it still just carries the whole mix and gives a real sense of progression and movement to an otherwise much slower accompaniment, which shows musical technique and understanding. On top of this, Voice 2, Voice 3, and Melody 4 are just so atmospheric in their own right, and add such a unique imposing melodic progression that I don't think many other tracks are able to replicate. There are only a very few elements I don't really like, like Melody 3 which could've been executed much better to more clearly hear the harmonic consistencies. But, like Alpha, this is incredibly nit-picky when discussing an overall incredibly executed track, easily securing Dystopia in the top 3 for me. - 2nd: Jeevan: To put it simply, I think Jeevan is Brazil but better. I say such as in it was a take on a cultural/ethnic genre, yet executed in a much more effective way. The beats are diverse yet all work together seamlessly, and Effect 1 is just such a bass drop even on its own. Furthermore, the exact harmonics of the effects, melodies, and voices, are diverse enough to take the track in question in many different directions, I'm thinking of Effect 4 when compared to Voice 5. And we can't go without recognizing how much of a slap Voice 1, Voice 2, and Voice 3 is when combined. Even the stuff I ordinarily wouldn't like, such as the piercing drone provided by Effect 2 and Effect 3, are able to work so well if implemented into the grand scheme of something broader, something broader like that which Jeevan can broadly provide. Like I said, Jeevan is Brazil but better. - 1st: Sunrise: Now, I confess, I put Sunrise as number 1 partially because it was the first Incredibox track I listened to, and thus is important to me in that way. Although, you still can't deny it's still so good in many other ways, meaning it would probably be in my top 3 regardless. Not only are the beats varied yet come together so seamlessly, but they are unique and so distinctive, like Beat 5's slight inhale and exhale pattern making a high-hat-cymbal-like effect which just adds to the overall mix. Effects 1 and 5 also just carry the mix on so well, and I'm all for an absolute driving bassline like that. Thematically, I also believe that Sunrise finds that perfect balance between being just a bit out there without going off the rails, potentially playing into the electro-futuristic vibe. Everything's so different, yet it works so well somehow. While probably a bit outside of the mix itself, visually, the specific green-blue-red-yellow colour pallet divide in Sunrise appeals to me so strongly for some unexplainable reason. That is why Sunrise is top of the list for me, and why I think it's so underappreciated by the rest of the Incredibox community.
Wowie! You went way more in depth on this than my own video 😭! I like that ur perspective is like a 180’ compared to mine! Thanks for sharing your point of view 🙏!
How I'd rate them (this is as of V9 coming out) 1st: Jeevan: Good god, I love how unique these all sound 2nd: Dystopia: All of the sounds are astounding, it's so beautiful 3rd: Wekiddy: This is the type of hip hop I grew up with, makes me feel like a kid again 4-T: Alive & Sunrise: Both of these bring some chill vibes, the 2 versions that brought me into incredibox 6th: Brazil: Not horrible by all means, but, my main gripe is the specific sounds for some bonuses, example: Voice 5 isn't even used for bonus 1 7th: Little Miss: I every now and then play this one, too bad I don't feel the same groove as the others 8th: Alpha: a true classic, but, most of the sound effects in this version don't really fit at all 9th: The Love: I feel like most sounds in this version are all mixed up, like effect 2 being like a voice, beat 5 sounding more like an effect, Voice 5 sounding like a melody. and etc
Inglish Dystopia better Brazil?, yes. In my humble opinion Brazil is the worst version due to its poor beatboxers who only whisper are very bad except for the 3 beastboxer that is a little better than the others without counting the very horrible effects that we are version so poor the effects is good that they want to represent a country with their music, I do not know almost anything about the country of Brazil I hope its people do not get angry and let me say xd, I do not hate it for being Argentine (historical rivalry) but good is my opinion ... Español Dystopia es mejor que Brasil?, si. en mi humilde opinion brasil es la peor version debido a sus pobres beatboxers que tan solo susurran son muy malos a excepción del 3 beastboxer que es un poquito mejor que los demas sin contar los muy horribles efectos que nos esta version tan pobres los efectos esta bien que quieran representar a un pais con su musica,no coozco casi nada del pais de brazil espero que su gente no se enoje y me deje opinar xd, no la odio por ser argentino(rivalidad historica) pero bueno es mi opinion... a lo hize con traductor xd
1:39 Lil bro that's not an unpopular opinion, that's a goddamn war crime
agreed... i was shocked to see dystopia so low too! it just doesnt make sense to me to see a good one so low in a tier list
Alpha: 6/10
Little Miss: 10/10
Sunrise: 10/10
The Love: 8/10
Brazil: 8/10
Alive: 10/10
Jeevan: 7/10
Dystopia: 9/10
my tier list in my opinion :
8. you can't
7. rate
6. them all
5. because
4. they're all as equally good
3. Love
2. Sunrise
1. Little Miss
Missed Opportunity:
8. you can't
7. rate
6. them all
5. because
4. they're all
3. as equally
2. good
1. Little Miss
@@YeetmanTheTrue correct
I love the Jeevan Family idea. It’s actually super funny, and you definitely overdid it, which is hilarious.
Greetings from Brazil! 🇧🇷
I'm very grateful that you are enjoying our music and culture these days! Of course, Brazil is GIANT when we talk about the national music and culture, keep exploring!
Obrigado, cara! TMJ
Love your extended details to why you like the version although I rate Alpha as S tier
Insane vid Buchie!
Amazing video Buchie
I couldn't agree more with your tier list! Little miss is too fire.. Especially the bonuses! AH!!
But if i made tier list it would be..
first place 🥇: alive
second place: little miss
third: dystopia
fourth: jeevan
fivth: brazil
sixth: the love
seventh: sunrise
eigth: alpha
They all give off their own vibes:
Alpha feels like a small band stuck in older eras trying to get by,
Little Miss feels like a sort of thing I'd hear in urban areas of New England (especially New York),
Sunrise has a sort of modernized techno vibe to it,
The Love is the most French part of Incredibox (can't tell if that's good or not),
Brazil is as Brazillian as it can get for me,
Alive's combination of intense and chill create a feeling of a trap remix of a childhood song,
Jeevan relocates me into India, no matter my mood, and
Dystopia is cyberpunk. Must I say more?
All deserve amazing ratings!
I know I skipped Wekiddy, IT IS THE DEFINITION OF HIP HOP
Alive is based on japan
dystopia must go 1st or 2nd place bro, brazil and jeevan must go on top also BUT alive's bonus is godly
Great video! Here's my list (best to worst):
1: Brazil
2: Dystopia
3: Jeevan
4: Sunrise
5: Little Miss
6: The Love
7: Alpha
8: Alive
YES SIR BRAZIL NUMBER ONE
yeah,i can agree with that
sunrise and the love my fav
Trivia: Jeevan, The male princess has been Mistaken as a female due to his beautiful Tone.
"If you've never played this app, give it a shot!!"
Me: do I look like rich?
I agree with your opinion on v2
Cool unpopular opinions there, didn't expect Little Miss to get 1st!
Alpha: 5/10
Jeevan: 7/10
The Love: 7,7/10
Alive: 8,9
Brazil: 9/10
Distopia: 9,9/10
Surise: 10/10
Little Miss: 10/10
My opinion:
1st: Little Miss. You can’t lie, these vibes brought me back to 2015 where I always used to go to big malls (like broadmarsh centre, you’ll be missed).
2nd: Jeevan. I like cultural types of songs and this is my favourite out of them.
3rd: Sunrise. True classic vibes.
4th: Brazil. Again. Cultural beats are my preferable tracks, but this one doesn’t have as cool vibes as Jeevan does, but it is more calm.
5th: Alive. I like it, but there is a few tweaks that are needed, especially with melody 5.
6th: Dystopia: Not bad. There’s just some sounds that I think could have more futuristic sounds to them. Voice 2 is the best imo.
7th: Alpha. Sure, some sounds don’t go well with others. The only thing I like is that it brings the memories of the original flash player version.
8th: The Love. Now… I know you’re gonna say I’m wrong, but let’s be honest. Some sounds don’t make sense to me. Examples include: Beat 5 sounding like an effect and Effect 2 sounding like a voice.
That’s my opinion! Do y’all agree with me?
Alpha: honestly quite incredible: 8/10
Little Miss: Very the good: 9/10
Sunrise: Eh: 6/10
The Love: I wanna die: 4/10
Brazil: amazing: 10/10
Alive: its okay: 7/10
Jeevan: so underrated: 8/10
Dystopia: pyramid rotato: 8/10
Since I'm guessing you made this before Wekiddy, this would be my list. (Call me a warcrime all you want)
9. Alpha
8. The Love (only cuz I rarely play it)
7. Wekiddy
6. Alive
5. Little Miss
4. Jeevan
3. Brazil
2. Dystopia
1. Sunrise
Judge all you want
Mine:
0. V9 (I feel like it’s gonna top all of them)
1. Jeevan
2. Dystopia
3. Alive
4. Little Miss
5. Alpha
6.Sunrise
7. The Love
8. Brazil 🥸🥸
you gotta put some clothes 🤗 4:31
Edit: I WAS CORECT V9 TOPPED ALL OF THEM
It’s colors, not clothes
right as i saw dystopia at 7 i almost threw my computer across my room
My Top 4:
1: Wekiddy (V9)
2: Dystopia (V8)
3: The Love (V4)
4: Jeevan (V7)
My top:
9. The Love
8. Brazil
7. Alpha
6. Wekiddy
5. Little Miss
4. Sunrise
3. Jeevan
2. Alive
1. Dystopia
Here is Mine :o
1st: Jeevan
2nd: Sunrise
3rd: Brazil
4th: The Love
5th: Little Miss
6th: Alive
7th: Alpha
8th: Dystopia
^ - Dystopia is Different to me, so I don't really like it :P
Here this! ua-cam.com/video/a185q-l1ioI/v-deo.html
My ranking
1: Little Miss
2: Wekiddy
3: Sunrise
4: The Love
5: Brazil
6: Dystopia
7: Alive
8: Jeevan
9: Alpha
My rankings
1st - Alive (Yes.)
2nd - Jeevan (I have really enjoyed the vibe with Jeevan)
3rd - Dystopia (It was almost a tie between Jeevan and Dystopia but if we aren't counting bonuses then jeevan beats Dystopia.)
4th - Brazil (Same reason as Jeevan, just not as much)
5th - Alpha (Very cool, just some sounds I don't really like that much)
6th - Little miss (Same as alpha but a few more sounds)
7th - Love (I only put it above Sunrise because of the swimming guy)
8th - Sunrise (Not a fan)
Sunrise in the BOTTOM?!??
8. Brazil
7. Alpha
6. Alive
5. Jeevan
4. The Love
3. Sunrise
2. Dystopia
1. Little Miss
This is your best video yet
Wow nick forever comin for me ….
What abt the video we BOTHH made ??
@@akoshaperkins9744 as Z.W’s biggest fan, I say that
my list
1: wekkidy
2: dystopia
3: Brazil
4: the love
5: jeevan
6: sunrise
7: little miss
8: alive
9: alpha
9. Alpha
8. Jeevan
7. Wekiddy
6. The Love
5. Little Miss
4. Brazil
3. Sunrise
2. Alive
1. Dystopia
ranked based on my opinion
1. alpha
2. little miss
3. javeen
4. brazil
5. sunrise
6. wekiddy
7. alive
8. the love
9. dystopia
ranked based on logic
1. little miss
2. javeen
3. wekiddy
4. sunrise
5. alpha
6. brazil
7. alive
8. dystopia
9. the love
My top 3 are:
1. Sunrise
2. Alive
3. Dystopia
The mod I most like is…
0th: Wekidy
My ratings (this comment is edited)
9:Brazil. I don’t hate it but I really don’t like it too much. It only has 1 loop and most of the effects are more related to beats than effects. But I think the Melodie’s and voices are good.
8:alpha: every once in a while I can enjoy some old school beatboxing. I think mixing is pretty fun on this version! But there are better
7:alive:if this was about bonuses, this would be top 3. But the mixing is probably the most repetitive out of any version and is only 1 loop. The voices are especially repetitive. But the beats, effects, and melodies are great!
6:jeevan:this is like a way better version of Brazil! It has 2 loops this time and I love that half the polos sound spiritual and the other half are catchy and fast paced!
5:the love: this version admittedly has some of the best sounds in the game! The bass, first beat, second melody, and 4th melody, are some of my favorite sounds in the game. But one thing. Why is “beat 3” a effect?
4:wekiddy:wekiddy is a banger! All of the sounds slap! (Except the furby and voice 4.) but I love so many sounds here! I love old school hip hop so it ain’t surprising that this version slaps.
3:sunrise: this version BARELY is better than wekiddy. But that’s because I just love the vibe of this song and I don’t have anything to say about the negative parts of this version. So yeah.
2:little miss. Bruh! Before I said this is number 6 but it really grew on me! This version is a banger. All the beats, effects, melodies, and voices are great! Almost all voices can change the song entirely and it is just amazing!
1:dystopia: this song is just incredible! Now I know some polos aren’t that good as the others but seriously, the ones that are good are masterpieces! Plus, there aren’t that much that are bad anyway.
In my opinion Dystopia is by far the best, followed by Wekiddy, and all the other ones are below it in a tie because the other ones just don't really stand out to me.
I absolutely adore modded incredibox though, pretty much all mods are above the officials, except Airline, Invasion and _especially_ Azurite which all kinda suck bad
Alpha - 7/10, pretty good I have to admit
Little Miss - 9/10, i love little miss a lot, also has one of the best whistle sounds in Incredibox
Sunrise - 6/10, kinda hard to make mixes with
The Love - 8/10, really good, it also has one of my favorite melodies from Incredibox
Brazil - 6.5/10, there arent that much sounds to choose from which is an issue
Alive - 7/10, same case as sunrise, kinda hard to make mixes with
Jeevan - 7.5/10 same case as sunrise and brazik
Dystopia - 8/10, the sounds here are really good, plus this version has the mostly heavenly choir in all of Incredibox history, but it suffers the same issue as sunrise
What’s your opinion on Wekiddy, and what tier and number would it be?
What I find quite amusing is that, before Wekiddy came out, your top 3 were actually my bottom 3! I don't exactly believe any are 'bad' exactly, rather just varying levels of likeability.
Before Wekiddy, my ranking stood at...
- 8th: Brazil:
While I enjoy themed tracks, and I think it sounds very accurate to Brazilian music, I think the approach leaves a lot to be desired. For instance, the beats, except for Beat 1, are all marraca imitations, which isn't bad, but still a bit lacklustre in my opinion. Sure, it is Brazilian, but surely you couldn't get a rhythmic Brazilian carnival drum interpretation, perhaps something in rpeated triplets to break up the pacing? Further on, I don't think a lot works on its own, and you need to overload your pallet with lots of things to make it sound decent, to the point where it sound a bit overcomplicated and you'd just ask yourself why you don't just switch to another track.
- 7th: Little Miss:
Let me preface by saying that my opinion of Little Miss was certainly improved when I heard you argue your case for it, although I still personally don't favour it that highly. There isn't exactly a good way to put it other than I think it's really simplistic in terms of its actual content and I just don't find it that overall appealing. Some of the noises I also find particularly ear-grating, like that constant gravel-like effect produced by Beat 3. Like Brazil, that certainly doesn't mean it doesn't have it's good moments, like the Chorus parts and Effect 4 just elevating the overall quality of the mix, but still I personally just don't see the appeal when compared to the higher-ranking ones.
- 6th: The Love:
Overall, The Love is perfectly fine, and probably shouldn't be down this low for the content itself. However, it's a personal opinion of mine, and it may sound too music theory-esque, but, also effecting the ranking of Brazil (and the current ranking of Wekiddy), I far prefer tracks in minor tonalities than in major tonalities. I think The Love is better than Little Miss and considerably better than Brazil (and Wekiddy), as it captures a hardcore party boat-like vibe very well. Effect 1 absolutely drives it with that blasted bassline and Melody 2, Voice 1, and Voice 4 are all so damn catchy. But there are some weak elements, like Voice 3 just yeah-ing and bringing nothing else to the table. On its own, I think it's bopping, but when ranked, I don't think it's as good as its competition.
- 5th: Alive:
I don't dislike Alive persay, as it's a good idea and it was clear it was meant to be a bit 'out there', but I still do have some considerable issues with it. I think the concept is good, and lots of the tracks are interesting and unique, but if you measure it tonally, it really just all exists on a single note drone while other tracks follow chordal progressions which I think limits its creative capabilities. Furthermore, unique doesn't always equate to good, I'm particularly thinking of Melody 5 that just screams at vague pitch, and Effect 1 and Effect 4 which are essentially just repeats of each other. To be honest, The Love would probably be above Alive if it wasn't for Beat 3 being able to seamlessly carry the running progression of the mix on its back. Alive would certainly be lower on the list if not for Beat 3, and while there really is a lot left to be desired, I still think it can work if in the hands of the right mixer.
- 4th: Alpha:
Like you said, Alpha was the first, it doesn't exactly stand out on its own, and lots of the tracks are too individual and seperate from a central theme. However, in contrast to Alive, it sticks to fairly basic musical and percussive consistencies that, even if diverse, still work together incredibly well. Beat 1 is just so strong when starting out, providing a percussive-drive as well as a bass-drive seamlessly and just makes it so easy to make anything sound good on top of it. A similar shoutout goes to Effect 4 for the rocking bassline provided on top of such, and both the Chorus and Voice elements all just weave together so well. Plus, that groove, it's absolutely banging when you blast it at full volume as you cruise down the street. Of course it has its drawbacks, like Melody 1 which I think just sounds silly, but it's just a small few bumps in an otherwise really good track that is perfect to both start and continue on with.
- 3rd: Dystopia:
Honestly, ranking the top 3, Dystopia, Jeevan, and Sunrise, was painful, as I think they are all top-notch in their own individual ways. I think Dystopia clearly stands out amongst all Incredibox tracks due to its conceptual creativity, and is an improvement of the theming which I think was trying to be emulated by Alive. But beyond that, the elements you can mix with are all incredibly strong. While I can't deny elements are repetitive, I'm thinking Beat 4, Beat 5, and Effect 3, I think it still just carries the whole mix and gives a real sense of progression and movement to an otherwise much slower accompaniment, which shows musical technique and understanding. On top of this, Voice 2, Voice 3, and Melody 4 are just so atmospheric in their own right, and add such a unique imposing melodic progression that I don't think many other tracks are able to replicate. There are only a very few elements I don't really like, like Melody 3 which could've been executed much better to more clearly hear the harmonic consistencies. But, like Alpha, this is incredibly nit-picky when discussing an overall incredibly executed track, easily securing Dystopia in the top 3 for me.
- 2nd: Jeevan:
To put it simply, I think Jeevan is Brazil but better. I say such as in it was a take on a cultural/ethnic genre, yet executed in a much more effective way. The beats are diverse yet all work together seamlessly, and Effect 1 is just such a bass drop even on its own. Furthermore, the exact harmonics of the effects, melodies, and voices, are diverse enough to take the track in question in many different directions, I'm thinking of Effect 4 when compared to Voice 5. And we can't go without recognizing how much of a slap Voice 1, Voice 2, and Voice 3 is when combined. Even the stuff I ordinarily wouldn't like, such as the piercing drone provided by Effect 2 and Effect 3, are able to work so well if implemented into the grand scheme of something broader, something broader like that which Jeevan can broadly provide. Like I said, Jeevan is Brazil but better.
- 1st: Sunrise:
Now, I confess, I put Sunrise as number 1 partially because it was the first Incredibox track I listened to, and thus is important to me in that way. Although, you still can't deny it's still so good in many other ways, meaning it would probably be in my top 3 regardless. Not only are the beats varied yet come together so seamlessly, but they are unique and so distinctive, like Beat 5's slight inhale and exhale pattern making a high-hat-cymbal-like effect which just adds to the overall mix. Effects 1 and 5 also just carry the mix on so well, and I'm all for an absolute driving bassline like that. Thematically, I also believe that Sunrise finds that perfect balance between being just a bit out there without going off the rails, potentially playing into the electro-futuristic vibe. Everything's so different, yet it works so well somehow. While probably a bit outside of the mix itself, visually, the specific green-blue-red-yellow colour pallet divide in Sunrise appeals to me so strongly for some unexplainable reason. That is why Sunrise is top of the list for me, and why I think it's so underappreciated by the rest of the Incredibox community.
Wowie! You went way more in depth on this than my own video 😭! I like that ur perspective is like a 180’ compared to mine! Thanks for sharing your point of view 🙏!
7:03 y’all know that jeevan is a male princess 😅😅
My ears at the start tho .-.
How I'd rate them (this is as of V9 coming out)
1st: Jeevan: Good god, I love how unique these all sound
2nd: Dystopia: All of the sounds are astounding, it's so beautiful
3rd: Wekiddy: This is the type of hip hop I grew up with, makes me feel like a kid again
4-T: Alive & Sunrise: Both of these bring some chill vibes, the 2 versions that brought me into incredibox
6th: Brazil: Not horrible by all means, but, my main gripe is the specific sounds for some bonuses, example: Voice 5 isn't even used for bonus 1
7th: Little Miss: I every now and then play this one, too bad I don't feel the same groove as the others
8th: Alpha: a true classic, but, most of the sound effects in this version don't really fit at all
9th: The Love: I feel like most sounds in this version are all mixed up, like effect 2 being like a voice, beat 5 sounding more like an effect, Voice 5 sounding like a melody. and etc
Jeevan is the worst to me, even alpha sounds better
Here is my tier worst to best (with wekiddy)
9 Alpha
8 the love
7 alive
6 little miss
5 jeevan
4 sunrise
3 dystopia
2 brazil
1 wekiddy
wait till you see armed incredibox😈
i found it 1 month ago
V9 is sure SS tier
Fix for piss
mans got some pretty bad opinions ngl. However, i love the brazil one too
Inglish
Dystopia better Brazil?, yes.
In my humble opinion Brazil is the worst version due to its poor beatboxers who only whisper are very bad except for the 3 beastboxer that is a little better than the others without counting the very horrible effects that we are version so poor the effects is good that they want to represent a country with their music, I do not know almost anything about the country of Brazil I hope its people do not get angry and let me say xd, I do not hate it for being Argentine (historical rivalry) but good is my opinion ...
Español
Dystopia es mejor que Brasil?, si.
en mi humilde opinion brasil es la peor version debido a sus pobres beatboxers que tan solo susurran son muy malos a excepción del 3 beastboxer que es un poquito mejor que los demas sin contar los muy horribles efectos que nos esta version tan pobres los efectos esta bien que quieran representar a un pais con su musica,no coozco casi nada del pais de brazil espero que su gente no se enoje y me deje opinar xd, no la odio por ser argentino(rivalidad historica) pero bueno es mi opinion...
a lo hize con traductor xd
this video is a travesty among travesty sunrise is above alive and DYSTOPIA!!!!!!!! I am in pain. (just a Joke)
Alpha s
uhmm actually your opinion is incorrect and dystopia is legally the best one in the game
Uhmmmm actually no, he has an opinion, don’t hate on it. Just say I disagree. Also I disagree I think Wikeddy is the best