Science Susan Speaks

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 135

  • @lilibetfellinger8641
    @lilibetfellinger8641 11 днів тому +15

    Well said, Ducking Stool, that woman is most annoying. Glad you confronted her nonsensical drawl.

  • @ShowalterdontlikeME
    @ShowalterdontlikeME 11 днів тому +24

    An Australian accent would go down well in a Kangaroo Court.

  • @KeithWilkinson-g7b
    @KeithWilkinson-g7b 11 днів тому +14

    Well done! Your videos are excellent. Not just because I feel Lucy is innocent too- I just feel the way you dismantle stuff like this is really good. I was an anaesthetist for 37 years, a consultant for thirty, and I regularly anaesthetised children and was an Advanced Paediatric Life Support Instructor for about 15 years, but I’d never dream of making a video and claim to be some kind of ‘expert’ in neonatology and saying stuff like this. It doesn’t matter any more what she thinks-to me- the truth is coming out now. Thanks to David Davis in Parliament, Mark McDonald’s press conference, The New Yorker article, Private Eye articles and videos from you, Mark Mayes, Accordinfg to Carl in the UK and others. Thank you.

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  11 днів тому +4

      @KeithWilkinson-g7b really kind of you, Keith.

    • @KeithWilkinson-g7b
      @KeithWilkinson-g7b 10 днів тому +5

      You are very welcome. I’ve been reading and watching stuff on true crime for over fifty- five years and I still attend murder trials and have a particular interest in miscarriages of justice-Birmingham Six, Carl Bridgewater case, Maguire Seven, Stefan Kiszko etc. To me this one is a very clear miscarriage, with so many things coming out showing this is very likely. I’m hoping the appeal can be re-opened and the convictions are quashed. I know appeal court judges are very reluctant to do this but however reluctant they might be I can’t see how they can ignore the mass of evidence currently being amassed for them and by Mark McDonald- and his many experts(all having offered their services for free). I hope that is the case anyway!

  • @ginnythwaite
    @ginnythwaite 11 днів тому +22

    Shamelessly dishonest, and shamelessly devoid of critical thinking.

  • @hopeisthething1965
    @hopeisthething1965 11 днів тому +12

    Thanks so much, The Ducking Stool. Your videos are brilliant. I love your commentary - it's spot on. And I really value the wider references you give and comparisons you make. And so much significant analysis, and details!

  • @TashaCreatesStuff
    @TashaCreatesStuff 11 днів тому +9

    I love your videos. You are a natural conversationalist so hope you keep making more.

  • @Wizthings
    @Wizthings 11 днів тому +12

    I saw this and though who is this mad woman! Who claims to be a scientist! So pleased you picked up on this.

  • @kennethnormanthompson2740
    @kennethnormanthompson2740 11 днів тому +22

    "I am a PhD Scientist (and a silly cow). I think that you sheep should stay in the sheep pen,take your vaccines, drink your fluoridated water and let us clever people stitch up Lucy Letby for our own nefarious purposes.

    • @daver9505
      @daver9505 9 днів тому

      Bingo

    • @Jdjustsaying
      @Jdjustsaying 8 днів тому

      100%
      Thank you for being a ‘right think’ master.

  • @williamhallett327
    @williamhallett327 11 днів тому +23

    I have a PhD in a pure STEM subject. My career though has been as a healthcare scientist mainly in medical research. That’s far more helpful to understanding the Letby case than the PhD. Her PhD in itself means very little for all the reasons you give and the way she tries to cash in on it really rather pathetic

  • @r.a.b.1978
    @r.a.b.1978 11 днів тому +14

    Glad you zoomed in . The original suggested video came up on my feed.
    It makes me so frustrated when UA-cam channels like that come up total misinformation and biased on her guilt. The bigger channels have near a million views and I suspect most of the viewers believe what they are told in their content.
    I know from experience how health care professionals throw less qualified employees under the bus
    Seen it first hand. These Dr's are rotten in my opinion. And how on earth have her colleagues she got on well with have been gagged . Not one person she worked with went on oath to defend her. That makes me wonder who has prevented that

  • @hopeisthething1965
    @hopeisthething1965 10 днів тому +5

    Listening to this brill video for a second time - really is quality! And scrolling through the comments - which are FIRE! some wonderful stuff below. Our game keeps raising!

  • @cupofteawithpoetry
    @cupofteawithpoetry 11 днів тому +11

    This is a brilliant video and you speak so well. Like you say, Dr Susan Oliver's phd is in nanoscience - she's not a neonatologist!

  • @idi0tdetectioninprogress
    @idi0tdetectioninprogress 11 днів тому +16

    Mystic Meg should get some help, just can't take her seriously at all.

  • @ginnythwaite
    @ginnythwaite 11 днів тому +29

    My Brother and his wife have PhDs coming out the wazoo. Neither have any common sense, and have zero critical thinking. Their abject stupidity offends me.

  • @MelanisticMarble
    @MelanisticMarble 11 днів тому +13

    There's nothing scientific about any of her assertions. She seems like a fraud to me ... although I only have a BSc.

  • @BernieRowlands-d4o
    @BernieRowlands-d4o 11 днів тому +11

    The way at the beginning of her vids she points out that Cindy is a dog must be very helpful to some of her followers.
    Can't wait for Lucy to be exonerated just to piss her off.
    Another great video.
    Cheers.

  • @RabJ208
    @RabJ208 11 днів тому +9

    Good stuff 👊

  • @pavlaorm-n6192
    @pavlaorm-n6192 11 днів тому +19

    1) Anyone who can Cheshire Cat grin their way through a talk on such a serious and emotive subject is not on the side of compassion, reason or truth.
    2) A propos, that’s why the Sciences need the Humanities - people with or without PhDs who have been raised and educated to understand and critically assess ethics - justice, discourse - subsets of Philosophy and Theology. There are plenty of Scientists’ names in the ranks of genociders - Assad is an medical specialist, for example! Since when did Science alone result in ethical outcomes in human history? This woman is a good example of why we cannot allow people to monopolise the public perception of truth on the basis that Science trumps all other disciplines.
    3) As you correctly point out, the Science actually does point to Lucy’s innocence. So much for a PhD in Science anyway!

    • @turquoiseblue228
      @turquoiseblue228 11 днів тому +5

      Excellent points thanks 👍
      Cheshire Cat grin, absolutely!

    • @ginnythwaite
      @ginnythwaite 11 днів тому

      Assad is not the villain that the mainstream media have painted him as. That is what his enemies want us to think.

    • @williamhallett327
      @williamhallett327 11 днів тому +7

      On your last point Private Eye’s MD reports on a new study of air embolism (that has a number of well known non-malicious causes) that discounts a moving rash as a sign. There is just no evidence for it. In making it up or imagining it later (it’s not in the contemporary notes) the doctors have shot their own theory in the foot

    • @pavlaorm-n6192
      @pavlaorm-n6192 11 днів тому +3

      @@williamhallett327 Yep, the Science is an inescapable force for truth when it’s represented by by ethically conditioned Scientists. This women seems to be neither ethically-minded nor scientific.

    • @ginnythwaite
      @ginnythwaite 11 днів тому +1

      Assad has been vilified by the mainstream media. I've followed Vanessa Bealey's work for years, she tells the truth about Assad. Fauci may be a better example to use.

  • @jar942
    @jar942 11 днів тому +11

    Another gem I was able to dig outta thirwall and another reason for their concerns consultants to be scared of baby o and P parents…..prior to birth mom concerned about delivering triplets at COCH….they talked her into it, telling her that each baby would get 1 to 1 nursing care….that never happened
    The father was really upset afterwards….made a lot of inquires…..why was there a lack of communication surrounding the investigation and bereavement support to them…very angry there was a root cause analyse done on 1 of the babies death and they were never to,d, grandma found out about it after seeing it on the news, in a letter to the medical director stated ….
    At no point had anyone contacted us to inform us this investigation into our son’s death…..felt that the trust did not respect our grief enough to go to every possible length to inform us about this investigation and this added to the distress of our family….they demanded a meeting with the medical director….unfortunately the medical director was on leave and do meeting had to be postponed…..meeting cancelled eventually because someone had gone to the police and do couldn’t comment…
    Apparently once the matter was referred to the police, the trust had no further contact with the families, from then on only the police had contacts with family 😢😢😢😢😢

  • @tasha24-7
    @tasha24-7 11 днів тому +11

    I think it pays more to be on the prosecution side!.... I wonder what she thinks of the other 50 global experts....?

  • @asheshsen1
    @asheshsen1 11 днів тому +13

    Her strategy is clear - she wants to create controversy so that she gets enough views to start being relevant to this case. I personally have chosen to stay away from her videos. She deletes comments and doesn't play fair.
    She is totally irrelevant to the case. Her credentials doesn't matter if she is trying to assert her authority on a subject she knows little of. Her opinions on this case have no weight.

    • @asheshsen1
      @asheshsen1 11 днів тому +4

      ​@@Dontstandinthepark Oh, look who decided to step up with an actual question instead of just regurgitating the usual. You must be Mrs. Dewi Evans herself or one of the consultants’ loyal entourage.
      The difference here is that this video represents an individual's personal take-take it or leave it, everyone's on equal footing. But your precious doctor? She’s out there throwing around her so-called authority on a subject she clearly isn't qualified to touch. It's not just laughable; it's unethical and a complete misuse of science.

    • @asheshsen1
      @asheshsen1 11 днів тому +1

      ​@ Who says I want to achieve anything? Im just expresssing my views.

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  11 днів тому +2

      ​@Dontstandinthepark is that a fact? He seemed pretty successful with Dr Proudman the other week.
      Anyway, your persistent nonsense is tiring
      Are you not feeling tired? Of yourself?
      Please respond to my comments re the 'hit piece' I have apparently made

  • @JulieLevinge
    @JulieLevinge 10 днів тому +6

    This woman’s persona really irritates me so much!
    She thinks she can get clicks from this, even though she knows absolutely nothing about this case!
    Assuming innocence is outrageous to her yet in law in the UK, you must start by assuming innocence??
    She appears to do the complete opposite!
    Uses zero evidence to push her ridiculous claims!
    Then rubbishes world renowned neonatologists!
    Whist possessing O neonatal knowledge herself.
    3 pathologists gave autopsy results of natural causes on 6 of the 7 babies.

  • @johnnyramblefinely2430
    @johnnyramblefinely2430 11 днів тому +6

    Back to the Lie-nce. Just look at her. Look at how she is

  • @nickdandel5314
    @nickdandel5314 11 днів тому +13

    Hello everyone! You are invited to see my comments on that channvel that have caused a lot of reactions by her followers but received a lot of likes from many others.
    She has made a false equivalency between those who think LL is innocent and antivaxxers. Her arguments are based on ad hominem attacks and much of it are strawman arguments. She also claims that people are LL 'supporters' bht that's not true because it could have been anyone in her case who was accused and then convicted in the absence of evidence. There is no evidence that LL is guilty.

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  11 днів тому +5

      @Dontstandinthepark I'm gonna have to respond to your comments at some point. Youve appeared in almost all the few vids ive done making some special statements

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  11 днів тому +4

      @Dontstandinthepark always feel like butthurt is a strange dis. Half laughing at blokes who've been s*xually assualted and half genuinely homophobic.
      Maybe I'm the only one who thinks that but it just seems both infantile and gross to me

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  11 днів тому +6

      @nickdandel5314 to be fair, like with any kind of pigeon chess, there's only so long you can sit around while the defecating and strutting goes on. They might call it a win, but, who actually cares? I don't

    • @questionit-e4v
      @questionit-e4v 10 днів тому +3

      Nick you did an excellent job in holding your own when the Susan's/Jon's CS2C cult dogpiled on you. She deleted my comment that just simply presented what Dr. Taylor actually said about the report on Baby O at that press conference. Dr. Breary, in attempting to aspirate excess gas from the baby's stomach, inserted the needle on the wrong side. He perforated the baby's liver (pushed down from yet another traumatic resuscitation) causing fatal haemorrhage.
      This kind of community (like any I guess) has seriously bonded over LL's guilt. It is now a 'Case Closed' cult. Doesn't matter that the evidence, based on the Imaginarium of Dr. Dewi, has been outed as unreliable and is unsafe. The ingroup belief trumps that. They have found validation, love, identity here and so it must be protected no matter what. It infects and distorts.
      So no, they can't see it when you try to present facts. They will continue see a 'monster' punching or kicking Baby O in the liver, which is absolute nonsense, rather than accept a more resonable, logical deduction that iatrogenic error damaged that poor baby's liver.

    • @nickdandel5314
      @nickdandel5314 9 днів тому +1

      ​@@questionit-e4vthanks very much! My comments have caused a lot of upset there and many reactions but I continued to refute and debunk their religious arguments that were mostly based on faith and not on facts. The channel has been deleted by UA-cam as you may know by now.

  • @nickdandel5314
    @nickdandel5314 10 днів тому +6

    Hi Ducking Stool and take a look at this one! I have posted this on various channels and it shows why retrials should happen within 1-2 years after the conviction
    A huge development on another case which shows our justice system needs a complete overhaul.
    From the BBC article today.
    "Wrong man is in prison, says murder victim family"
    This is unbelievable! The family of the victim wants the convicted
    man out of prison. This is what the family of the victim said:
    "This conviction is an insult to reason and fairness, and every day the Criminal Cases Review Commission delays action deepens this failure."
    Jason Moore convicted for murdering Robert Darby in east London, in 2013

  • @JulieLevinge
    @JulieLevinge 9 днів тому +3

    This woman that even calls herself a doctor, reporting on a medical case, when’s she’s not a medical doctor is very dishonest.
    Just a poor attempt to make money from what is a tragedy.
    Dr Evans dismissed the findings of 3 pathologists at Alderhay.
    Many thanks for highlighting this obnoxious woman.✊❤️

  • @mazdodd4145
    @mazdodd4145 6 днів тому +1

    Australia tends to jail true whistleblowers. We also jail women wrongly over the death of babies - Lindy Chamberlain & recently released Kathleen Folbigg.
    The COCH consultants were not whistleblowers while Lucy did document problems, even her own, on Datatix or Incident forms -that have to be investigated.

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  6 днів тому

      @@mazdodd4145 I wrote about Lindy Chamberlain just after Letby's conviction. Maybe I'll do a video when I have time. It bears many similarities

  • @Mervyn-wj1bi
    @Mervyn-wj1bi 9 днів тому +2

    Some of my LL videos are a little off the wall and I live a very very solitary lifestyle, is very interesting to hear opinions that match my own so closely.

  • @nickdandel5314
    @nickdandel5314 10 днів тому +5

    I was trying to see who else posted in my thread on the 'Back to the science' channel and it says the video no longer exists as the account associated with it has been closed down!
    It seems Dr Oliver closed down her account. It's a shame because I left so many comments, I created so many threads, and I made the posting life of her followers so difficult by asking simple questions and refuting the nonsense, the ad hominem attacks, the strawman arguments and the false equivalencies that Dr Oliver and her followers made.
    I hope this isn't permanent and she comes back with more videos so her unsubstantiated claims and the unsubstantiated claims and assertions of her followers can be refuted for once more. My posts clearly caused a lot of reaction and received a lot of attention and a lot of likes even if it was a hostile environment. I sincerely hope the channel comes back so we can listen to more of these wonderful arguments and the false equivalencies between those who think LL is innocent and antivaxxers-cranks-conspiracy theorists.

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  10 днів тому +3

      @@nickdandel5314 it's been removed

    • @jonathancoe4529
      @jonathancoe4529 9 днів тому +1

      Please keep going with your comments on pro guilty videos and responses to replies! I'm trying to do the same.

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  9 днів тому

      @jonathancoe4529 I just looked at your channel and could only see guitar vids - have you done Letby vids?

    • @jonathancoe4529
      @jonathancoe4529 9 днів тому +1

      @@Ida_Dunne_Moore not yet. I'm not brave enough yet. I need a makeover before I go on camera again. But I'm very active on Facebook and the UA-cam comments sections. I've spoken on the phone with Mark McDonald, Carl Parkins and admins of pro Lucy Facebook groups.

    • @jonathancoe4529
      @jonathancoe4529 9 днів тому +1

      @@Ida_Dunne_Moore I actually took part in a LBC radio phone in which is featured on one of Carl's recent videos.

  • @keithbessant
    @keithbessant 11 днів тому +4

    If that's a scientist, something about her reminds me of the witch out of 'Paulus the Little Gnome'. Funny that should come back to me after all these years😂See how her lips are turned down the whole time, even when she's smiling. She's not averse to joining in with witch hunts herself.

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  11 днів тому +6

      @keithbessant I hate to turn to aesthetics but there's definitely something to that. I think the still upper body and windshield wiper arm gestures are quite incongruous too, which adds to it.
      Just saw on X/Twitter though, she shared a pic of her as a bunny girl in 1983. So fair dues, as the aussies say, she looks great. It's just a shame about the content. And ideas. And misrepresentation etc

    • @JulieLevinge
      @JulieLevinge 10 днів тому +2

      @@Ida_Dunne_MooreFind it hard to believe she was ever a bunny girl?Only in Australia😉

  • @jar942
    @jar942 11 днів тому +8

    Thru Thirwall, able to see the actual notes from baby Os crash and who was there….fyi the crash call Dr for that day was Dr B, she didn’t arrive for 40 minutes…..Dr brearey and Dr Gibbs also there along with “ middle aged, dweeb looking boyfriend Dr”…….i was also able to see who did what……Dweeb doctor was maintaining airway and couldn’t have done anything that could have harmed the liver…….br b was very upset after the autopsy report was released, it stated the chest compressions could have caused liver bleed, she didn’t arrive the compressions, we know why Dr brearey is concerned, Dr Gibbs was there and he has a history of problem IV insertions ( see baby G, took 7 sticks for him)…..maybe he out the UVC catheter in wrong ? Lucy did do a Datix report that they lost iv access during recess…..funny the dweeb Dr got a really spiffy job as a consultant right after this baby ……..hmm wonder why ? Wonder who played a part in getting him that job? Oh wait it just a coincidence, nothing to see here

    • @karenwall8643
      @karenwall8643 11 днів тому +3

      Jar, re: the baby O crash notes, the note entry that states Brearey inserted the needle into McBurney's point and withdrew blood and sent this for blood cultures, does that note entry state which member of staff documented this clinical note?

    • @jar942
      @jar942 11 днів тому +1

      @ no it doesn’t….i wondered myself who documented…..my gut tells me it was the anonymous consultant, but not sure

    • @jar942
      @jar942 11 днів тому

      @@karenwall8643reason I think Dr V did the notes….she was crash consultant on that day……Gibbs helped with intubation then left. Then came back later in the resus

  • @jackieemslie
    @jackieemslie 4 дні тому

    Absolutely says more about them than Lucy supporters. Why would you want that so badly. I just accepted the news until I heard and saw Dewi Evans speak. Smelled a rat straight away and have been following supporters ever since. Thanks for your work here❤

  • @jar942
    @jar942 11 днів тому +10

    Love the Magdalen Berns vibe, please keep it up….oh what I wouldn’t give to have had her opinion on the Lucy stuff…..question though, explain the pic u use with the duck faced man….i know what a ducking stool is and what it was used for…..just wondered if this illustration has another meaning …..clueless American here

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  11 днів тому +4

      @jar942 it was just something that an AI image creator came up with and I liked it

    • @jar942
      @jar942 11 днів тому +5

      And I like it also….

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  11 днів тому +2

      @@jar942 it's just really odd, and the others were either very naff or almost great but some minor detail off...

    • @jar942
      @jar942 11 днів тому +3

      @@Ida_Dunne_Moore sorry American here, I speak English not British…..not sure meaning of the word naf……however I do know your word for football is SOCCER….. just kidding, well maybe 😜

    • @jar942
      @jar942 11 днів тому +4

      @@Ida_Dunne_Moore but curtesy of Magdalene berns….this American knows what the word wanker means 😂😂😂😂 miss her humor

  • @mazdodd4145
    @mazdodd4145 6 днів тому

    Good that he was predisposed to see Lucy as he did, when the media did the exact opposite & probably muddied the water horribly for any jury members before the trial.

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  6 днів тому

      @mazdodd4145 yes. Someone starting from a presumption of innocence is kinda positive!

  • @kennethsimmons2029
    @kennethsimmons2029 3 дні тому

    That evidence gathering process will deliver the verdict required Who required it ? Who is the main suspect for the 5 acquittals?

  • @VICNCRAIG
    @VICNCRAIG День тому

    I refuted one of her assertions (delicately, I might add) in the comments section of one of her videos. Her response misquoted me, such that it completely changed the context of my response.
    It's hard to reconcile being a credible scientist of any kind whilst interpreting and handling information as poorly as she does.

  • @lindalaw5466
    @lindalaw5466 5 днів тому

    This woman is a sado……

  • @fredneecher1746
    @fredneecher1746 5 днів тому

    I've seen this woman before in another context. She is a grifter, trying to climb on the popularity of highly successful UA-camrs. Ignore her.

    • @Ida_Dunne_Moore
      @Ida_Dunne_Moore  4 дні тому

      @@fredneecher1746 as Carl Perkins pointed out. Yes, I agree. I do enjoy examining conflicting views tho so will continue to do that