I believe that anyone that has watched your progress in building your homestead can see that you are a steward of the land and your impact is very small, and likely positive for your area. Also, every tree you use for a building is a carbon sink for as long as that building lasts, and every new tree that comes up will gather far more carbon than older trees. Keep up the good work Shawn, you're one of the good ones.
Haha.. But, i must say - here in Austria we need this apartment houses. My country is to small for our 10 Million Inhabitants! If every Austrian would have own property and House, we would glue one on the other with our Houses. The Space for wood and agriculture would be to small in 20 Years... So, to safe the environment it is better to have our big apartment Houses with 20, 30 50 Families living inside! That`s the only way to safe our woods and the land for getting Food... And in my case, I couldn`t live off grid like Shawn James! I am disabled, can hardly walk, and i`m in constant pain! I am retired since almost 10 years now due to my health issues. For me it`s a painful job to maintain my apartment properly! Processing firewood? LOL...My dear damaged spine: Thanks to you, I am happy to get out of bed, and make a move or two... lol
I don't want to hear your smack talk. Every year thousands of Keebler elves are displaced by tree murderers like yourself. Soon there will be no cookies.
I have 50 acres on Vancouver island, it has been logged 2 times since being first logged of first growth in the late 1800's. Now I have it, every year I cut down 25 to 30 trees for my saw mill and 15 to 20 for firewood and you can hardly tell, most of what I take is from thinning. If I left it and cut nothing and did no thinning at all it will choke itself out or burn because it's so dense. In the area's I have cut and thinned the forest is now healthy. Most of the criticism is from unreasonable people who do not have a clue about what you're talking about and refuse to listen and learn.
I more worry about me than others I let God judge. I got stuff to do and not many people know Mr James is well educated and a lover of animals and nature.
Because the want to belong to an HOA and cite neighbors for allowing their hedge to sprout beyond the permitted amount so they can be fined and harassed.
Shawn, this was a dignified and considered response to some criticism that does not always necessarily warrant a dignified response. Frankly, your previous comments were sufficient justification for your actions - not that you are even obliged to justify yourself. You have done a remarkable job elevating the discourse on this subject. During the current COVID-19 crisis, a great many people on social media have done a spectacular job demonstrating how they can ‘race to the bottom’. I’d rather not cite specifics - I think we all know of some obvious examples. So, while so many exemplify what it means to appeal to the lowest common denominator, you have consistently taken the high road, and I commend you for your patience, humility, and good humour. You really are doing a spectacular job of entertaining, informing, and educating. Keep up the great work.
When you live off the land you will need to clear some land for gardens. Just being responsible & only clearing enough to help yourself survive is perfectly acceptable. Enjoy Shawn, you are a responsible person.
Wait, people are complaining from a desk sitting on a chair that are presumably both made of wood or metal which has a higher carbon footprint? Complaining on a computer and driving around without regard to the environment? Hypocrites
You inspired me about a year ago. Some stuff in my life fell all apart and I was just left wondering what the heck. Nothing I was doing made sense any longer and I needed to change. I was watching you build and basically living your dream. My dream is a little different looking, but I sold my house, paid off all debt, bought a truck (paid for) and Was moving towards my goal of creating my own indie film production business. Then March happened and I am on hold with everyone else for now, but I am free and working on my goal now. Living for me. Thanks for being around at the right time for me.
Those who criticize are jealous that they have neither the knowledge, ability nor the willingness to do it. At least you are using what is going to eventually fall and go to waste. You have to clear periodically to keep the growth strong. That also helps the forest remain strong and be less susceptible to disease. You are doing what our forefathers did and we appreciate you sharing it with us to teach us that you can most things by hand with minimal power tools. Never understood how those who criticize about this lifestyle use products and live in a house that used all these resources to make. Your carbon footprint is much smaller then theirs.
Showing everyone an alternative approach to living is inspirational, anyone criticizing your efforts lacks wisdom. Thank you for sharing so much knowledge.
Who would criticize this man, it's his land and if anything the years he's been filming has shown how much he cares for the environment! Just enjoy his videos or click away, this man is not destroying things, he seems like he's being a good steward of what God has given him.
Guy lives in the woods in a cabin, trying to raise his own food completely off grid... environmentalist stuck in their flat in sanfransico get mad because he cut down trees 😂
@Nathaniel Lovell Lol... im born and raised in San Francisco... there is definitely the more ignorant people here who masquerade as knowing the first thing about the environment and how forest stewardship works... i am fully aware of everything Shawn is discussing here, and stand behind his methods and understanding fully. I am a lefty, I am not immature, whiny or hypocritical (actually every one of us at some level).... i can introduce you to a 100 other friends of mine who are equally as educated and understanding of everything discussed here... SF and its politicians and policies are often hypocritical and idiotic but its still a place that has bred countless people who are invaluable to the world and the environment. THanks for all your information and content Shawn, much love and support to you in everything you do from here in SF. Peace and love to all of you
I have twenty acres that I had cleared fifteen years ago and not being around to maintain the property, the forest has reclaimed this area. It is fertile river bottom land, fertile land. I am almost smothered with growth. I can't see the river which is only 75 yards away. Incredible. Good to see and good to know that the forest has this capability. If you are looking for other examples, look at old abandoned farms. Their fields have been taken over by trees. If you leave the soil fertile when you are finished, what you are clearing now will be reclaimed by the forest when you abandon it. Clear cutting where these big industrial companies clear miles and miles of forest that's a different story. I've seen the devastation done there. It is really difficult to stomach when you look out and see miles and miles of cleared land.
Proof that mother nature knows wtf she's doing and that, as George Carlin has said tons of times but not an exact quote , " we are NOT a real threat to this planet. It's been the farrrr worse than humans have put it through long before humans were even a piece of sperm in the single ejaculation of oceans of time."
I don’t know about the birch, but maples grow like weeds. They are beautiful and very useful in many, many ways, but will take over if you don’t control them. They pop up in your bushes, vegetable and flower gardens, directly beside a building, in your cement driveway, and the spouting on your house. There is a need to control them or they will take over. They will grow healthy and strong if you thin them out and are not competing with one another.
Shawn, I an interested in every thing you encounter and explain. I was surprised when you mentioned adding urine to the usual things one adds to new planting compost. Would you mind sharing more about that?
You're a great spokesman for nature conservation and actually living not only on the land, but with it. Keep up the great videos and sharing your insights.
Stating, "...maybe I come around to a different way of thinking as I evolve as a person and evolve with my landscape here," is a tactful way of addressing your critics. You are not only skilled with your hands, but also skilled with words. I truly appreciate your videos and look forward to viewing them each week.
We have all just been schooled in how to turn criticism into education in the most humble and respectful way. The world needs more people like you sir!
Thank you sir for your channel. It is my comfort zone in a world gone mad. I am an 86 year old widow of a law enforcement officer. I am a retired nurse....still volunteering in my community. God bless you, and tell your critics to "go pound sand" PS I lived in Argentia, Newfoundland in the '50's when my husband was stationed tbere. 1st son born there.
Shawn, you sure were raised right. You handle all controversy with grace, dignity, integrity, and kindness. It sure is nice to see a grown man handle himself like this. Thank you for making your Momma and Daddy proud and tell them I said thank you!
Shawn, I live in 20 acres of woodland. When I bought the property it was so densely wooded you could hardly walk into it and after 20 yards you could become totally disoriented. The reason for this is that there was so many dead trees hanging up on each other (sometimes five trees leaning on one) that it was a dark and tangled mess. Healthy trees had been stifled and bent by the deadwood and many had developed disease and were sparse in foliage.I had some trees at 120 feet high that were not much more than 16" at the stump. Many of the Aspens were sick and hollow trunked and very dangerous, they sometimes had ant colonies inside them amidst the darkness of these areas was very little ecological diversity, yet in more open areas there is a profusion of wild flowers and berry bearing plants. Every winter several of these tall spindly trees would blow over as their root structures were inadequate. I have spent several years living on this land without major removals, then I started by removing hangups, widow, makers and trees that were laid dead and rotting in the forest floor. I coppiced vine Maples and have since noticed deer are glad to graze on the new growth, stunted Douglas Fir saplings are now producing new shoots and Paper-Bark Birch seedlings are growing. I have removed a lot of dead standing Birches as they are very dangerous, but I have left those frequented by woodpeckers. The Aspens act as nitrogen fixers and I have notice an increase of orchids in some areas where sick ones were removed. Also last year I noticed a much greater prevalence of butterflies. The point I am making is that cutting down trees should be done from a stewardship perspective in that the land owner should take time to observe and learn the ecology of the environment and understand how to maximize diversity of both flora and fauna. In time I intend to introduce a wider diversity of trees to the property, trees that will cohabit with existing species and add some benefit to the woodland and all its inhabitants. Thanks for your monumental effort in building such a wonderful and informative UA-cam Channel. WS, BC, Canada.
I cut down trees on my land. However, I bought the land when it was about to be logged. In other words, I bought land that was a tree farm and turned it into a natural forest over the past decade and I continue to buy land to do just that. The trees I do cut make room for new plants and wildlife to flourish, and the whole forest becomes a sustainable resource for myself, my family, and the surrounding fauna and flora.
In my book, when someone has the time to criticize us, it is because we are doing something right. ...Mr. James, hang in there, the majority of us like your art, this is the healthiest thing we have in this quarantine! Thank you, stay safe, everyone!
I have a woodlot that's about 4.5 acres. I selectively cut to keep it looking like a healthy forest. Everybody around me gathers firewood by clearcutting and leaving the branches as a mulch that restricts new growth and makes a fire hazard. And they try to convince me that I should do the same. I was told "Take what you need and let God take care of the forest" We do need to grow food, however. And a clearing is necessary for some crops.
What a fine example you set Mr. James. Take notice, viewers, how he engages with those who would criticize. We must rediscover and kindle our ability to have civil discourse without resorting to name calling. If we're ever going to improve as a people, it must be so. Well done Shawn.
seesfractals I was telling a buddy a couple months back that this CV19 thing was going to be a defining moment in society. Let’s see what that looks like when the dust settles. But as it appears it’s still the few that cause the masses problems. Looks like Canada needs to be more self sufficient and China has no intentions to help the world out by being just plain humane,responsible and respectful for the people of the world. Be safe
Always remember that there can be a baby laughing on UA-cam with a million laughs and 5 dislikes. Those 5 aren't disliking because of the kid or the laughing.... They dislike for attention and a dislike for their own lives so they want to make yours difficult. Keep doing your thing. You're an inspiration.
He has an awareness of the environment and people like you that say that call people dimwits people that like you say that shows total disregard for society and for wildlife and nature in general.,. not respecting wildlife or the timber or other people's thoughts and concerns for a society like what we have now that we are learning with a virus that's going around people just don't care if they spread it to other people they don't care if they get it them self but would they not realizing is this spreading it to somebody else you have that way of thinking you don't care about anybody else but yourself me me me me me me me Simon sinek on UA-cam why Leaders eat Last is the name of the video talks about people like you
I think Shawn has a great attitude in regards to the area he lives. He has the attitude all the greenies of this world need to adapt working close to the land as he does. We would not have the wildfires as we experience globally. Even the world aboriginal groups did have super methods of management of the land they live in. Along with less nomadic methods of living , then learn to provide food for his familiar is a great plus but when Shawn goes into selling produce to increase his life style then you greenies can step in. Ok with that? If you are not then the expression above fits.
Keep doing what you believe in. That’s why we watch. We appreciate your inspiration. We appreciate you.and what YOU DO You don't walk around with a bag on your HEAD DO take CARE of Family and SELF
I moved to Spain from San Francisco about 11 years ago. I love the fact that in Canada you can purchase land and make it your own, including cutting down trees to build your cabin, etc. Here in Spain, even if you purchase property, you are not allowed to cut down any pine trees. So that, even if we wanted to do what you are doing on your property, we are not allowed to do that here. I am so glad that you have that opportunity there in Canada. I love your videos. Thank you for all of your efforts and comments.
I'm from Germany... and I'm cutting trees down too. :-) As long as we plant more than we cut down, I think it is ok. Thank you for your explanations Shawn. Helps to teach people at least a little bit to rethink their point of view.
Chin up, Shawn. The way you have learned the land makes YOU a part of the ecosystem right where you are. Remember to trust yourself and your knowledge. Most of us know your intent and see your heartfelt authenticity week to week. Take care.
Same as people who blast the killing of animals who drive in a car, live in a house, wear clothes etc etc all this made with some sort of animal bi-product.
Perhaps genuine (you're too kind), but (in this particular case) misguided concern. You can best see it after observing what kind of a mess people leave after mass-gatherings for a political cause. They never live what they preach.
I appreciate the kindness with which you addressed the criticisms. Very gentlemanly. Not everybody understands sustainability, and looks like you're doing it brilliantly.
When I came to live 30 years ago in my small village, there was a mound 1 kilometer from my house covered with conifers. The place was wild and beautiful. Last year, everything was cleaned from top to bottom to settle a flock of sheep. So I was not happy with the situation BUT informing myself, the place in the past was not at all wooded but having not experienced the previous period for me this mound was a forest that had just been ransacked. Well no, you shouldn't judge too soon. In addition, by clearing the area, on the surface, earth defense barriers reappeared because this mound was used in immemorial times, as a fallback and defense zone in the event of an attack. They found also there some relics of those past times. Like what you should always educate yourself before making a personal judgment..
I've had to clear around two acres of my forest to plant fruit trees and have a garden. It was hard for me to see some very old trees fall. I even cried when the ground would shake with each fall but it's somthing that is very vital for my future food source and my children and grandchildren future. Anyone that would be critical must live near lots of grocery stores. Keep on keeping on! Your my inspiration!
Hey Shawn! Your response and thoughts on the criticism shows you are MATURE, INSIGHTFUL, and AWESOME. Most people receiving criticism try to combat it and excuse it and beat it back down. But your response is so appreciated. Thank you Shawn and you're great for being so understanding 😊
Shawn, I think you are doing a wonderful job and you always explain the reasons beautifully. I learn so much from watching both your channels as well as gaining inspiration for my own life and my own YT channel. No criticism but kudos and support from me. Thankyou so much Shawn for all that you do and share with us all. ❤
Brother, you use hand tools... Solar power... Eat what you hunt... And do not even have running water! You can cut down half a Forrest and not a viewer on here can even come close to your minimal carbon footprint! GODSPEED BROTHER... KEEP IT UP AND GOD BLESS
I woke up to my 13 year old son watching your videos and now I cannot stop watching! The skills that you are showing are dying out and it is people like you that will keep it all going. Your videos are educational and incredibly relaxing! I have subscribed! Thank you so much for your work! We need it especially in the times that we live in. Bless you! ❤️🙏
Love your channel. I am in my sixties, I am from West Virginia, and have purchased 50 acres of my great grandfather’s farming property which is now forest. You are correct I have had to selectively timber some of the property to allow the forest to improve its habitat for wildlife. Keep save and healthy.
People on youtube will always find something to say. I honestly believed this channel was free of those people. Theres no lack of trees where you are and you are doing things responsibly. Keep living the life you love ignore negativity. Take care!!
People are ignorant. By localizing your food supply you’re probably offsetting the carbon emissions vs a traditional modern means of getting food by a factor of 10.
You’re patience is unmatched. You’re using your property as you see fit. Love your posts. Keep posting & keep teaching us to act on our dreams. A true craftsman.
Forester here. Mother nature likes mature trees to be removed as it opens up the understory to make way for new seedlings. It may be aesthetically unpleasing to us but good for mother. Seans footprint is surely smaller than most. Trees reach a point of full maturity then go into decline. Its best to harvest them before they decay to utilize them for timber. Keep up the good work Sean. You are an inspiration to many.
At a time when some people on social media are so eager to shoot from the lip behind the mask of anonymity you show such grace under fire. You dont take the bait, or use these tactics as click-bait, but with patience and understanding treat this as a teachable moment. It's why you earn our respect and the following you deserve. Keep up the good work!
We planted a garden in our back yard today! We will see how much survives the birds, possums and squirrels ... and, of course, the Texas heat. Good luck on your garden too! I am sure ours is not as large ... it’s about 20 x 12 feet and will be plenty large for us. Black eyed peas, sweet corn, radishes, turnips, squash and tomatoes. Plus a goji berry and raspberry bush in others parts, as well as the various herbs throughout the front and back areas. We are excited!
...never apologize, and never explain...its a sign of weakness....now, that's the way to Express it. Shawn, you might think on that. Black fly season is rapidly approaching, have you rented an apartment in town for your wife to occupy away from the cabin yet? She will be on the run screaming, most likely....hmmm?
If I had the land and homestead I would be doing the same as you Shawn. Always have our family support! I would be using more power tools but we enjoy seeing your vision of what you want for you and your family! Cheers Shawn and Mrs. James!
As far as I can see, you have been making an effort to live harmoniously and sustainably within your surroundings. We own a "tree farm' in Maine that we bought just to have woods and not develop. We'll clear just a little for living and a garden, but preservation is the goal. Forest management does include thinning to make room for other to grow larger, too. You are definitely an inspiration!
I like everything you do and how you manage, one day in a few years I will have the chance to retire in the wild, thanks for everything you have taught me.
I read something recently that sums up the people criticizing you... " an empty barrel always makes the loudest noise". Keep on, keeping on Shawn. You know what you are doing, the complainers dont have a clue.
Shawn, I live in the Southern US and in our state we plant more trees than we cut. There is more forest land now than when I was a boy 50 plus years ago. With the amount of rain we get every year in our area we are I a near-jungle environment. As an example, a pine tree in our area grows to maturity in less than 25 years. An oak tree can grow from a tiny sapling to a tree 18 inches or more in diameter in less than 20 years. Selective cutting in our area benefits the forest and keeps them thriving. I understand your view and actually support it. My family lives in a 350 acre family forest and we enjoy the wildlife in the area. We have deer, foxes, rabbits, squirrels, turkeys, bobcats, coyotes and more on our property and we enjoy the wildness of our place here. We have been working from home for over three weeks now and honestly it has not been tough on us. While we are not self sufficient we are have always planned for the future. Because of where we live, we understand that the economy is at least as fragile as the natural disasters like hurricanes cause it to be. While we are not self sufficient we are, maybe we should say, self efficient. We always have some food stored in case there is a disruption in the supply chain. Our chickens supply us with eggs. We grow a small garden that I am enlarging this year and, thanks to my father, I am able to use my hands to build, repair and design the things we need when I either don’t want to buy them or just want to make something the way I want it. Thank you for your videos. They are an inspiration to me. Stay safe and stay healthy.
You are spot on! These tree huggers that are bitch ing about a man who is as environmentaly friendly as James is need to get a life. Geesh! I don't know why James felt the need to go into this long explaination is beyond me but I guess the haters really bothered him so he felt the need to pacify them. They'll still be mad cause that's how they all are.
That's the same thought that bring most people to dump tones of chemical pesticides on their lawn each years and cut down entire ancestral forest 🙄 It's a good thing he addressed it and educate people. We need more people like that.
@@RexySmith In my experience, most of these critics are merely grandstanding virtue signallers. If they have followed Shawn, they would know just how well he cares for the land. That is also forgetting that trees are a renewable resource, they grow back.
You wonder what people are thinking when they bought all that toilet paper in the last month, so much for thinking about cutting down trees. Some people are Hypocrisy when it comes down to what other people do on their own land.
From Central Ontario..... 12 years ago I cleared an area of about 5 acres intending to use it as pasture. We fell behind on our plans and now we are having to clear it again. People don't realize how quickly, even in our cold climate, trees, and everything else regenerates.
I think if you used any other materials it would spoil the character of the buildings. I enjoy watching, even my grandson started to follow you. He is eleven.
Mr. James, i think you have put back more than you have taken from ur land. The key word is "YOU'RE LAND" I think ur a great man and u should ha e so much pride in yourself for what u have created. People are just jealous of ur life, i know i am but in a good way. I would be proud to call u a friend anyday of the week!
Obviously, it's plain to see by anyone whos watched more than 2 of your videos, and has a couple of working brain cells, that you couldn't find a better steward of the land than you, Shawn!
1.32 M subscribers on your other channel and 156K on this channel. You’re doing something right! Keep at it and keep spreading your knowledge and obvious love for the outdoors and the environment.
Being from Maine, I can understand everything you are doing. People that are living in a city do not understand living with nature. Education is a key and Sir you are a great educator. Thank you
I believe that anyone that has watched your progress in building your homestead can see that you are a steward of the land and your impact is very small, and likely positive for your area. Also, every tree you use for a building is a carbon sink for as long as that building lasts, and every new tree that comes up will gather far more carbon than older trees.
Keep up the good work Shawn, you're one of the good ones.
I've learned that most of the people who don't approve of how I manage my acreage, are folks who live on the 3rd floor of an apartment building.
These folks need to get out those tall building ...and move or plant in their apartment!
Lol
This! THIS!
Haha.. But, i must say - here in Austria we need this apartment houses. My country is to small for our 10 Million Inhabitants! If every Austrian would have own property and House, we would glue one on the other with our Houses. The Space for wood and agriculture would be to small in 20 Years... So, to safe the environment it is better to have our big apartment Houses with 20, 30 50 Families living inside! That`s the only way to safe our woods and the land for getting Food... And in my case, I couldn`t live off grid like Shawn James! I am disabled, can hardly walk, and i`m in constant pain! I am retired since almost 10 years now due to my health issues. For me it`s a painful job to maintain my apartment properly! Processing firewood? LOL...My dear damaged spine: Thanks to you, I am happy to get out of bed, and make a move or two... lol
Lol that was funny 😆 have a great day.
Keep doing what you believe in. That’s why we watch. We appreciate your inspiration. We appreciate you.
This
I’d like to compare your carbon footprint with the people who are criticising you.
This. The piece of consumer electronics they wrote their criticism on alone probably hurt the world more than this guys entire cabin ever did.
Anyone bitching about cutting down trees has clearly never spent any amount of time in a forest.
Yup! Don't get why people care because the house they are living in is made out of trees too! 😂
Those same one live the modern life that is reportedly much worse than living the way we are meant to live.
@@forty1thousand Exactly
I don't want to hear your smack talk. Every year thousands of Keebler elves are displaced by tree murderers like yourself. Soon there will be no cookies.
@@ShushaSofia Hey you want to live like Amish people go for it. I was meant to be in AC and live vicariously through others.
I have 50 acres on Vancouver island, it has been logged 2 times since being first logged of first growth in the late 1800's. Now I have it, every year I cut down 25 to 30 trees for my saw mill and 15 to 20 for firewood and you can hardly tell, most of what I take is from thinning. If I left it and cut nothing and did no thinning at all it will choke itself out or burn because it's so dense. In the area's I have cut and thinned the forest is now healthy. Most of the criticism is from unreasonable people who do not have a clue about what you're talking about and refuse to listen and learn.
Mark Twain said never argue with an idiot, they will bring you down to their level and beat you with experience.
That is one of the greatest statements ever made in the history of mankind. 😜
😂
Just beautiful first time hearing that
OK, I won't argue with you then . . .
@@ShawnJames1 You are a good guy Shawn. I appreciate you. Vaughn
I think most people who criticize don't know anything about forest management.
Jonothan Doezer you could delete the last three words from your comment and would still be very accurate 😂
Forest management is a cover story brought to you by the forest industry.
The skip school like Gretta!
Drew
There is science involved in forest management, of course we all know, some deny science.
Water faucet-science AND history also show that forests were doing just fine before humans started “managing” them. If you cut a tree the plant two!
I appreciate your humble, educated and articulate response to criticism.
It’s worth remembering that people’s personal comments often say much more about them than it does about the victim of their comments.
That is so true!
WHY WOULD ANYONE CRITICIZE YOU!?!?!? You can’t please everyone but you bring MUCH JOY to many of us! Keep doing you! You’re an inspiration to many!
I more worry about me than others I let God judge. I got stuff to do and not many people know Mr James is well educated and a lover of animals and nature.
You are right! But I like to see Shawn actively supporting nature by planting tree-seedlings for every tree (nit underbrush). I like the channels!
👍👍👍👍
Sound Money SOOO VERY TRUE!
Because the want to belong to an HOA and cite neighbors for allowing their hedge to sprout beyond the permitted amount so they can be fined and harassed.
Shawn, this was a dignified and considered response to some criticism that does not always necessarily warrant a dignified response. Frankly, your previous comments were sufficient justification for your actions - not that you are even obliged to justify yourself.
You have done a remarkable job elevating the discourse on this subject.
During the current COVID-19 crisis, a great many people on social media have done a spectacular job demonstrating how they can ‘race to the bottom’. I’d rather not cite specifics - I think we all know of some obvious examples. So, while so many exemplify what it means to appeal to the lowest common denominator, you have consistently taken the high road, and I commend you for your patience, humility, and good humour.
You really are doing a spectacular job of entertaining, informing, and educating. Keep up the great work.
Ditto that!!
Well said. Shawn doesn't own an explanation to anyone.
Your focus and thought, for the impact on the land we have been blessed with is admirable. Thank you !
Well said, you have a great way with words.
100% agreed !
The world would be a much better place if the majority had your mentality! Stay safe Shawn.
Please. I love your videos especially now you know what you are doing so just keep it up
When you live off the land you will need to clear some land for gardens. Just being responsible & only clearing enough to help yourself survive is perfectly acceptable. Enjoy Shawn, you are a responsible person.
Wait, people are complaining from a desk sitting on a chair that are presumably both made of wood or metal which has a higher carbon footprint? Complaining on a computer and driving around without regard to the environment? Hypocrites
The same people who hoarded the toilet paper !
@@MrGuy-cp1gt ....😀😀😀😀😀👏👏👍
@@MrGuy-cp1gt Exactly...lol!
You inspired me about a year ago. Some stuff in my life fell all apart and I was just left wondering what the heck. Nothing I was doing made sense any longer and I needed to change. I was watching you build and basically living your dream. My dream is a little different looking, but I sold my house, paid off all debt, bought a truck (paid for) and Was moving towards my goal of creating my own indie film production business. Then March happened and I am on hold with everyone else for now, but I am free and working on my goal now. Living for me. Thanks for being around at the right time for me.
Much respect, sir! Trees are a renewable resource. Thinning actually helps forests in many cases.
Tthinning is not what he is doing, but I get what you're saying.
Those who criticize are jealous that they have neither the knowledge, ability nor the willingness to do it. At least you are using what is going to eventually fall and go to waste. You have to clear periodically to keep the growth strong. That also helps the forest remain strong and be less susceptible to disease. You are doing what our forefathers did and we appreciate you sharing it with us to teach us that you can most things by hand with minimal power tools. Never understood how those who criticize about this lifestyle use products and live in a house that used all these resources to make. Your carbon footprint is much smaller then theirs.
Such genuine care and passion for his environment, we should all be living more like him.
Showing everyone an alternative approach to living is inspirational, anyone criticizing your efforts lacks wisdom. Thank you for sharing so much knowledge.
"Responding to hatred is like trying to drown a dead fish." -someone
Haha perfect analogy.
Agreed!
@Gary Shack1970 or a Republican. Closed minds are sadly ubiquitous.
@@niemi5858 nice to see another open minded person
@Gary Shack1970 ~ WOOOOSH, right over your head. Wow.
I love to see a mature response to ignorance, rather then reacting you respond! I love what your doing too!
Who would criticize this man, it's his land and if anything the years he's been filming has shown how much he cares for the environment! Just enjoy his videos or click away, this man is not destroying things, he seems like he's being a good steward of what God has given him.
Guy lives in the woods in a cabin, trying to raise his own food completely off grid... environmentalist stuck in their flat in sanfransico get mad because he cut down trees 😂
@Nathaniel Lovell haha ! I live in commie calafornia canada . Bigger than GOD themselves 😉😉😉
He's in it for the money.
@Nathaniel Lovell Lol... im born and raised in San Francisco... there is definitely the more ignorant people here who masquerade as knowing the first thing about the environment and how forest stewardship works... i am fully aware of everything Shawn is discussing here, and stand behind his methods and understanding fully. I am a lefty, I am not immature, whiny or hypocritical (actually every one of us at some level).... i can introduce you to a 100 other friends of mine who are equally as educated and understanding of everything discussed here... SF and its politicians and policies are often hypocritical and idiotic but its still a place that has bred countless people who are invaluable to the world and the environment.
THanks for all your information and content Shawn, much love and support to you in everything you do from here in SF. Peace and love to all of you
Yes, stuck out of ignorance.
Imagine how many trees were burnt down each year in California.
To those being critical of anything Shawn does, I offer the distinct and noble true Canadian polite response... "Take off Eh!...ya Hoser!
I have twenty acres that I had cleared fifteen years ago and not being around to maintain the property, the forest has reclaimed this area. It is fertile river bottom land, fertile land. I am almost smothered with growth. I can't see the river which is only 75 yards away. Incredible. Good to see and good to know that the forest has this capability. If you are looking for other examples, look at old abandoned farms. Their fields have been taken over by trees.
If you leave the soil fertile when you are finished, what you are clearing now will be reclaimed by the forest when you abandon it.
Clear cutting where these big industrial companies clear miles and miles of forest that's a different story. I've seen the devastation done there. It is really difficult to stomach when you look out and see miles and miles of cleared land.
Proof that mother nature knows wtf she's doing and that, as George Carlin has said tons of times but not an exact quote , " we are NOT a real threat to this planet. It's been the farrrr worse than humans have put it through long before humans were even a piece of sperm in the single ejaculation of oceans of time."
I don’t know about the birch, but maples grow like weeds. They are beautiful and very useful in many, many ways, but will take over if you don’t control them. They pop up in your bushes, vegetable and flower gardens, directly beside a building, in your cement driveway, and the spouting on your house. There is a need to control them or they will take over. They will grow healthy and strong if you thin them out and are not competing with one another.
Haters will hate , I'm a liker instead.
"Shake it off! Shake it off! ..."
Kaizen...that is it, good man..
Definition of Hater..anyone who dares not agree.. Yeah Sure ! BTW I like Shawn's Channel but disagree with some of his premises. OH the Horror !
D-16RGT disagree all you like. It’s nothing to do with you and it won’t change a thing. 🤷🏻♂️😂
@@drewtube5031 👍👍
Well you won't hear me criticizing you for anything.
I take my hat off to you.
Amen, your videos are magnificent. Keep up the good work. Your family is beautiful and your beautiful dog.💖
Never apologize, or try to "justify" what you do. They will be used against you when you least expect it, like blood in the water.
"When you have no basis for an argument, abuse the plaintiff." --Cicero
classic and classy all in the same. thanks for the comment.
Shawn, I an interested in every thing you encounter and explain. I was surprised when you mentioned adding urine to the usual things one adds to new planting compost. Would you mind sharing more about that?
You're a great spokesman for nature conservation and actually living not only on the land, but with it. Keep up the great videos and sharing your insights.
They obviously don't understand that trees are a self renewing resource
when managed responsibly. Awesome channels Shawn
Stating, "...maybe I come around to a different way of thinking as I evolve as a person and evolve with my landscape here," is a tactful way of addressing your critics. You are not only skilled with your hands, but also skilled with words. I truly appreciate your videos and look forward to viewing them each week.
I'd like to be sure that people who criticize you for cutting rtees don't buy their furniture at Ikea...
🤣
We have all just been schooled in how to turn criticism into education in the most humble and respectful way. The world needs more people like you sir!
Thank you sir for your channel. It is my comfort zone in a world gone mad. I am an 86 year old widow of a law enforcement officer. I am a retired nurse....still volunteering in my community. God bless you, and tell your critics to "go pound sand"
PS I lived in Argentia, Newfoundland in the '50's when my husband was stationed tbere. 1st son born there.
Shawn, you sure were raised right. You handle all controversy with grace, dignity, integrity, and kindness. It sure is nice to see a grown man handle himself like this. Thank you for making your Momma and Daddy proud and tell them I said thank you!
Your own land, you can cut your trees when you want to .. Just do what you're doing.. that's why we watch your videos ... thanks for sharing
Shawn, I live in 20 acres of woodland. When I bought the property it was so densely wooded you could hardly walk into it and after 20 yards you could become totally disoriented. The reason for this is that there was so many dead trees hanging up on each other (sometimes five trees leaning on one) that it was a dark and tangled mess. Healthy trees had been stifled and bent by the deadwood and many had developed disease and were sparse in foliage.I had some trees at 120 feet high that were not much more than 16" at the stump. Many of the Aspens were sick and hollow trunked and very dangerous, they sometimes had ant colonies inside them amidst the darkness of these areas was very little ecological diversity, yet in more open areas there is a profusion of wild flowers and berry bearing plants. Every winter several of these tall spindly trees would blow over as their root structures were inadequate. I have spent several years living on this land without major removals, then I started by removing hangups, widow, makers and trees that were laid dead and rotting in the forest floor. I coppiced vine Maples and have since noticed deer are glad to graze on the new growth, stunted Douglas Fir saplings are now producing new shoots and Paper-Bark Birch seedlings are growing. I have removed a lot of dead standing Birches as they are very dangerous, but I have left those frequented by woodpeckers. The Aspens act as nitrogen fixers and I have notice an increase of orchids in some areas where sick ones were removed. Also last year I noticed a much greater prevalence of butterflies.
The point I am making is that cutting down trees should be done from a stewardship perspective in that the land owner should take time to observe and learn the ecology of the environment and understand how to maximize diversity of both flora and fauna. In time I intend to introduce a wider diversity of trees to the property, trees that will cohabit with existing species and add some benefit to the woodland and all its inhabitants. Thanks for your monumental effort in building such a wonderful and informative UA-cam Channel. WS, BC, Canada.
I cut down trees on my land. However, I bought the land when it was about to be logged. In other words, I bought land that was a tree farm and turned it into a natural forest over the past decade and I continue to buy land to do just that. The trees I do cut make room for new plants and wildlife to flourish, and the whole forest becomes a sustainable resource for myself, my family, and the surrounding fauna and flora.
In my book, when someone has the time to criticize us, it is because we are doing something right. ...Mr. James, hang in there, the majority of us like your art, this is the healthiest thing we have in this quarantine!
Thank you, stay safe, everyone!
I have a woodlot that's about 4.5 acres. I selectively cut to keep it looking like a healthy forest.
Everybody around me gathers firewood by clearcutting and leaving the branches as a mulch that restricts new growth and makes a fire hazard.
And they try to convince me that I should do the same. I was told "Take what you need and let God take care of the forest"
We do need to grow food, however. And a clearing is necessary for some crops.
What a fine example you set Mr. James. Take notice, viewers, how he engages with those who would criticize. We must rediscover and kindle our ability to have civil discourse without resorting to name calling. If we're ever going to improve as a people, it must be so. Well done Shawn.
seesfractals I was telling a buddy a couple months back that this CV19 thing was going to be a defining moment in society. Let’s see what that looks like when the dust settles. But as it appears it’s still the few that cause the masses problems. Looks like Canada needs to be more self sufficient and China has no intentions to help the world out by being just plain humane,responsible and respectful for the people of the world.
Be safe
Always remember that there can be a baby laughing on UA-cam with a million laughs and 5 dislikes. Those 5 aren't disliking because of the kid or the laughing.... They dislike for attention and a dislike for their own lives so they want to make yours difficult. Keep doing your thing. You're an inspiration.
I live in Ontario too , and I totally agree with everything you said . Be careful about the wild turkey , they are dangerous ...
Oh Shawn. Don't engage with dimwits.
He has an awareness of the environment and people like you that say that call people dimwits people that like you say that shows total disregard for society and for wildlife and nature in general.,.
not respecting wildlife or the timber or other people's thoughts and concerns for a society like what we have now that we are learning with a virus that's going around people just don't care if they spread it to other people they don't care if they get it them self but would they not realizing is this spreading it to somebody else you have that way of thinking you don't care about anybody else but yourself me me me me me me me Simon sinek on UA-cam why Leaders eat Last is the name of the video talks about people like you
@@clayguinard3651 Put the pipe down bro. You've had enough.
Well said Ryan Squires, I agree with your comment!
@@clayguinard3651 man, that's one hell of a run-on sentence.
I think Shawn has a great attitude in regards to the area he lives. He has the attitude all the greenies of this world need to adapt working close to the land as he does. We would not have the wildfires as we experience globally. Even the world aboriginal groups did have super methods of management of the land they live in. Along with less nomadic methods of living , then learn to provide food for his familiar is a great plus but when Shawn goes into selling produce to increase his life style then you greenies can step in. Ok with that? If you are not then the expression above fits.
Keep doing what you believe in. That’s why we watch. We appreciate your inspiration. We appreciate you.and what YOU DO You don't walk around with a bag on your HEAD DO take CARE of Family and SELF
God bless you Sir, the world be allot better if people would humble their selves and live more simple!
I moved to Spain from San Francisco about 11 years ago. I love the fact that in Canada you can purchase land and make it your own, including cutting down trees to build your cabin, etc. Here in Spain, even if you purchase property, you are not allowed to cut down any pine trees. So that, even if we wanted to do what you are doing on your property, we are not allowed to do that here. I am so glad that you have that opportunity there in Canada. I love your videos. Thank you for all of your efforts and comments.
I'm from Germany... and I'm cutting trees down too. :-) As long as we plant more than we cut down, I think it is ok. Thank you for your explanations Shawn. Helps to teach people at least a little bit to rethink their point of view.
Chin up, Shawn. The way you have learned the land makes YOU a part of the ecosystem right where you are. Remember to trust yourself and your knowledge. Most of us know your intent and see your heartfelt authenticity week to week. Take care.
I wonder how many of those people were sitting at a wooden desk or table or sitting on a wooden chair, or have a wooden door, or wood on the floor...
Or a house filled with plastic stuff , cause petroleum industry is so good for the earth🤗😂
@Leona Denson 😂
@Leona Denson want to be friend ? ❤️😂
Same as people who blast the killing of animals who drive in a car, live in a house, wear clothes etc etc all this made with some sort of animal bi-product.
@Gary Shack1970 Or driving their car made with animal by products...LOL
Perhaps genuine (you're too kind), but (in this particular case) misguided concern.
You can best see it after observing what kind of a mess people leave after mass-gatherings for a political cause.
They never live what they preach.
I appreciate the kindness with which you addressed the criticisms. Very gentlemanly. Not everybody understands sustainability, and looks like you're doing it brilliantly.
When I came to live 30 years ago in my small village, there was a mound 1 kilometer from my house covered with conifers. The place was wild and beautiful. Last year, everything was cleaned from top to bottom to settle a flock of sheep. So I was not happy with the situation BUT informing myself, the place in the past was not at all wooded but having not experienced the previous period for me this mound was a forest that had just been ransacked. Well no, you shouldn't judge too soon. In addition, by clearing the area, on the surface, earth defense barriers reappeared because this mound was used in immemorial times, as a fallback and defense zone in the event of an attack. They found also there some relics of those past times. Like what you should always educate yourself before making a personal judgment..
I've had to clear around two acres of my forest to plant fruit trees and have a garden. It was hard for me to see some very old trees fall. I even cried when the ground would shake with each fall but it's somthing that is very vital for my future food source and my children and grandchildren future. Anyone that would be critical must live near lots of grocery stores. Keep on keeping on! Your my inspiration!
Haters are gonna hate, no matter what you do. Please though, just keep doing you! You have many more admirers than the haters will ever have.
Hey Shawn! Your response and thoughts on the criticism shows you are MATURE, INSIGHTFUL, and AWESOME.
Most people receiving criticism try to combat it and excuse it and beat it back down.
But your response is so appreciated.
Thank you Shawn and you're great for being so understanding 😊
Shawn, I think you are doing a wonderful job and you always explain the reasons beautifully. I learn so much from watching both your channels as well as gaining inspiration for my own life and my own YT channel. No criticism but kudos and support from me. Thankyou so much Shawn for all that you do and share with us all. ❤
Hi Shawn, that garden you're creating, will it be ready for planting this year or next year? I'm going to do the same.
Much respect from Wales. Don’t change please.
Whales*
You'll never please everyone Mr. James, you keep doing what you do, I'll keep watching ✊👍
Brother, you use hand tools... Solar power... Eat what you hunt... And do not even have running water! You can cut down half a Forrest and not a viewer on here can even come close to your minimal carbon footprint! GODSPEED BROTHER... KEEP IT UP AND GOD BLESS
Well put, Adam. You keep doing you, Shawn James!
I woke up to my 13 year old son watching your videos and now I cannot stop watching! The skills that you are showing are dying out and it is people like you that will keep it all going. Your videos are educational and incredibly relaxing! I have subscribed! Thank you so much for your work! We need it especially in the times that we live in. Bless you! ❤️🙏
Love your channel. I am in my sixties, I am from West Virginia, and have purchased 50 acres of my great grandfather’s farming property which is now forest. You are correct I have had to selectively
timber some of the property to allow the forest to improve its habitat for wildlife. Keep save and healthy.
People on youtube will always find something to say. I honestly believed this channel was free of those people. Theres no lack of trees where you are and you are doing things responsibly. Keep living the life you love ignore negativity. Take care!!
Well said sir!
People are ignorant. By localizing your food supply you’re probably offsetting the carbon emissions vs a traditional modern means of getting food by a factor of 10.
Nobody respects nature as you do. Keep doing what your doing. Reep the benefits of your property.🥰
You’re patience is unmatched. You’re using your property as you see fit. Love your posts. Keep posting & keep teaching us to act on our dreams. A true craftsman.
Forester here.
Mother nature likes mature trees to be removed as it opens up the understory to make way for new seedlings. It may be aesthetically unpleasing to us but good for mother. Seans footprint is surely smaller than most. Trees reach a point of full maturity then go into decline. Its best to harvest them before they decay to utilize them for timber. Keep up the good work Sean. You are an inspiration to many.
At a time when some people on social media are so eager to shoot from the lip behind the mask of anonymity you show such grace under fire. You dont take the bait, or use these tactics as click-bait, but with patience and understanding treat this as a teachable moment. It's why you earn our respect and the following you deserve. Keep up the good work!
"so eager to shoot from the lip" I like that !!!
Who's criticizing you? You're awesome
Shawn that is the best controlled answer I have ever heard about fitting your self into a local .
Always the gentleman, that's why I admire and respect you, Mr. James. May you and your family continue to lead/live the clean life. 🕊👏🤗❤
We planted a garden in our back yard today! We will see how much survives the birds, possums and squirrels ... and, of course, the Texas heat. Good luck on your garden too! I am sure ours is not as large ... it’s about 20 x 12 feet and will be plenty large for us. Black eyed peas, sweet corn, radishes, turnips, squash and tomatoes. Plus a goji berry and raspberry bush in others parts, as well as the various herbs throughout the front and back areas. We are excited!
"Dont steal, dont lie, never apologize" Zeb Macahan
...never apologize, and never explain...its a sign of weakness....now, that's the way to Express it. Shawn, you might think on that. Black fly season is rapidly approaching, have you rented an apartment in town for your wife to occupy away from the cabin yet? She will be on the run screaming, most likely....hmmm?
Robert Wilson, I do believe the wife is aware of the bugs in the area , that’s why he built a screen porch😂
Speak softly and carry a large Bowie Knife.
White D, and we are back to Zeb Macahan , lol,
Teaching is love in action, and you my friend are a lover of many.
If I had the land and homestead I would be doing the same as you Shawn. Always have our family support! I would be using more power tools but we enjoy seeing your vision of what you want for you and your family! Cheers Shawn and Mrs. James!
As far as I can see, you have been making an effort to live harmoniously and sustainably within your surroundings. We own a "tree farm' in Maine that we bought just to have woods and not develop. We'll clear just a little for living and a garden, but preservation is the goal. Forest management does include thinning to make room for other to grow larger, too. You are definitely an inspiration!
I like everything you do and how you manage, one day in a few years I will have the chance to retire in the wild, thanks for everything you have taught me.
Hi again SHAWN
Good clarification. However you still don't deserve being under attack ...
Lots to look forward to!
I used to go camping and fishing at the french river when i was younger with my Dad, best times of my life!!!
I read something recently that sums up the people criticizing you... " an empty barrel always makes the loudest noise". Keep on, keeping on Shawn. You know what you are doing, the complainers dont have a clue.
Shawn, I live in the Southern US and in our state we plant more trees than we cut. There is more forest land now than when I was a boy 50 plus years ago. With the amount of rain we get every year in our area we are I a near-jungle environment. As an example, a pine tree in our area grows to maturity in less than 25 years. An oak tree can grow from a tiny sapling to a tree 18 inches or more in diameter in less than 20 years. Selective cutting in our area benefits the forest and keeps them thriving. I understand your view and actually support it. My family lives in a 350 acre family forest and we enjoy the wildlife in the area. We have deer, foxes, rabbits, squirrels, turkeys, bobcats, coyotes and more on our property and we enjoy the wildness of our place here. We have been working from home for over three weeks now and honestly it has not been tough on us. While we are not self sufficient we are have always planned for the future. Because of where we live, we understand that the economy is at least as fragile as the natural disasters like hurricanes cause it to be. While we are not self sufficient we are, maybe we should say, self efficient. We always have some food stored in case there is a disruption in the supply chain. Our chickens supply us with eggs. We grow a small garden that I am enlarging this year and, thanks to my father, I am able to use my hands to build, repair and design the things we need when I either don’t want to buy them or just want to make something the way I want it. Thank you for your videos. They are an inspiration to me. Stay safe and stay healthy.
I think most of us trust that you're doing the right thing Shawn.
You’re doing things and living the life that many of us would like to live...
Forget them. It is YOUR land.
He only has a title that grants him the right to use it under certain conditions. The land belongs to the Queen of England unfortunately.
You are spot on! These tree huggers that are bitch ing about a man who is as environmentaly friendly as James is need to get a life. Geesh! I don't know why James felt the need to go into this long explaination is beyond me but I guess the haters really bothered him so he felt the need to pacify them. They'll still be mad cause that's how they all are.
@@FreddyFuFu Shawn bought and owns his property "free and clear" - you are confused if you think he built his cabin on Crown lands.
That's the same thought that bring most people to dump tones of chemical pesticides on their lawn each years and cut down entire ancestral forest 🙄 It's a good thing he addressed it and educate people. We need more people like that.
@@RexySmith In my experience, most of these critics are merely grandstanding virtue signallers. If they have followed Shawn, they would know just how well he cares for the land. That is also forgetting that trees are a renewable resource, they grow back.
And if I remember correctly you were the fella that encouraged folks to plant trees last year
You wonder what people are thinking when they bought all that toilet paper in the last month, so much for thinking about cutting down trees. Some people are Hypocrisy when it comes down to what other people do on their own land.
From Central Ontario..... 12 years ago I cleared an area of about 5 acres intending to use it as pasture. We fell behind on our plans and now we are having to clear it again. People don't realize how quickly, even in our cold climate, trees, and everything else regenerates.
What’s the world coming to? This man is being criticized for improving the ecosystem in his own land.
If you use stone they will still criticize. While in the meantime they are living in sticks and bricks. Keep sharing your ultimate goals.
I think if you used any other materials it would spoil the character of the buildings. I enjoy watching, even my grandson started to follow you. He is eleven.
Funny how they b***h about him cutting down trees but the homes they live are mostly wood beams and studs. Where do they think that comes from?
Mr. James, i think you have put back more than you have taken from ur land. The key word is "YOU'RE LAND"
I think ur a great man and u should ha e so much pride in yourself for what u have created. People are just jealous of ur life, i know i am but in a good way. I would be proud to call u a friend anyday of the week!
Shawn, you are a rare human being who has his head on straight these days. You are a great role model.
Why would someone criticize this cool man ?
Obviously, it's plain to see by anyone whos watched more than 2 of your videos, and has a couple of working brain cells, that you couldn't find a better steward of the land than you, Shawn!
1.32 M subscribers on your other channel and 156K on this channel. You’re doing something right!
Keep at it and keep spreading your knowledge and obvious love for the outdoors and the environment.
Wtheck would criticize YOU??? City Folk no doubt...
...and folks envious of someone who actually follows his/her dreams.
I love this channel with it's man, wife, dog ads visiting daughter!!! 😘😘😘😘
*and
Being from Maine, I can understand everything you are doing. People that are living in a city do not understand living with nature. Education is a key and Sir you are a great educator. Thank you
Ignore those lounge ecologists. What you're doing makes sense, and your approach deserves respect. Keep going !