Calum Scott is my choice without a doubt. I am always impressed with the way he brings his own unique voice and style to any cover. His vocal range compares more to Adele definitely.
James for me, so much raw emotion in his vocals, he always makes covers his own in a unique way. He is a fantastic singer. James is also singing this live. Calum's has been done in a studio. So James wins my vote .
Surely James I prefer. He sings with more passion this song, with soul and he sings this song like an own version a little bit different from the original and well rythmed and is better for me
Just found this and I think it is silly to make comparisons as people are going to join who are already fans of one or the other and that is who they will vote for. If you are going to do a fair comparison make them both live and uncut or both studio versions.
Calum is the better vocalist. I'm not a huge fan of this rendition, and I prefer his live stripped vocals to studio versions that add reverb and other unnecessary effects, but if you're just comparing vocal ability, then it's pretty clear who the winner is. If this is about style/delivery, then it's apples and oranges. You have passionate/emotional with Calum and casual/soulful with Arthur. It's just about which vibes you're feeling.
No comparison here. JA is singing with no reverb or studio equipment. His vocal tone is different and unique. C is singing with reverb on and other studio equipment help which makes his voice sound more crisp. Can’t compare this unfair comparison! James is the better vocalist, storytelling and emotional singer. He is on a level of his own. Simply unique and one of a kind. C voice is angelic and calming. Totally two different vocalist which can’t be compared at all. I can go on for weeks comparing both artist but I will say that James won this battle. I do love both artist very much but for very different reasons. They are both phenomenal singers. ❤️☮️
Technically, Calum sounds better live, so this being a studio version actually hinders him. I'd say given that, this is pretty evenly matched. If you compare live vocals to live vocals Calum is the better vocalist by a mile.
@@wordcharm2649 Funny Ive been to both concerts of each. With all Respect, James is the best vocalist period. With this being said, Everyone has their own ear and opinion. To everyone their own. In my world, I stick to my original post. Peace out people☮️
This is like a comparing apples to oranges scenario. Just take into account the Calum Scott version is a studio version where James Arthur has a little unique spin that he puts on every cover that he does and it was raw live and uncut. I love Calum voice but I have to get this from the James simply because it's so raw and emotional for me
Both of these artists have such an unique voice, that is so versatile, and can really carry through every song, and make it their own. That's why I love them both so much😭❤️
Both are great at what they do... but James Arthur is dynamically genius. Calum has great pathos in his voice no doubt, but James is pure art. James is one of the best male singers (not vocalist) out there today. No one has more feeling.
If trying to compare the voice quality for this song, Calum is the best voice and nice to listen. But both of them are very talented and have different style.
![Passenger - Let Her Go (Feat. Ed Sheeran - Anniversary Edition) [Official Video]](/img/n.gif)
James Arthurs voice just touches my soul as soon as I hear it. I don't like to compare. They are both great in different ways. Thanks though.
Calum Scott is my choice without a doubt. I am always impressed with the way he brings his own unique voice and style to any cover. His vocal range compares more to Adele definitely.
James for me, so much raw emotion in his vocals, he always makes covers his own in a unique way. He is a fantastic singer. James is also singing this live. Calum's has been done in a studio. So James wins my vote .
James Arthur,we love his voice so pure and he sang it soulfully ❤❤❤
Your never get old precious them and precious now!
Pure chills with James....❤
Great performance!
Surely James I prefer. He sings with more passion this song, with soul and he sings this song like an own version a little bit different from the original and well rythmed and is better for me
Calum is totally magical!❤️🇨🇦
Just found this and I think it is silly to make comparisons as people are going to join who are already fans of one or the other and that is who they will vote for. If you are going to do a fair comparison make them both live and uncut or both studio versions.
Como James ninguno, es el mejor!!!!! ❤️
Calum and James would be beautiful couple!!!
Calium all the way I love his voice
James!! For sure!
Calum scott ♥️
♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Calum Scott forever 🖤🙏
JA no competition 👏💖
Hands down James Arthur.
Calum for me
Jamess❤❤❤
James, a thousand times James♡
Calum. Can sing high and low notes
Callum 👍👍👍
JA ❤💋
Oh … Calum , by FAR !!!
I am a JA fan
Although callum is really good too
James
Calum
Calum all the way no doubt.
James Arthur all the way
Calum is the better vocalist. I'm not a huge fan of this rendition, and I prefer his live stripped vocals to studio versions that add reverb and other unnecessary effects, but if you're just comparing vocal ability, then it's pretty clear who the winner is. If this is about style/delivery, then it's apples and oranges. You have passionate/emotional with Calum and casual/soulful with Arthur. It's just about which vibes you're feeling.
No comparison here. JA is singing with no reverb or studio equipment. His vocal tone is different and unique. C is singing with reverb on and other studio equipment help which makes his voice sound more crisp. Can’t compare this unfair comparison!
James is the better vocalist, storytelling and emotional singer. He is on a level of his own. Simply unique and one of a kind. C voice is angelic and calming. Totally two different vocalist which can’t be compared at all. I can go on for weeks comparing both artist but I will say that James won this battle.
I do love both artist very much but for very different reasons. They are both phenomenal singers. ❤️☮️
Technically, Calum sounds better live, so this being a studio version actually hinders him. I'd say given that, this is pretty evenly matched. If you compare live vocals to live vocals Calum is the better vocalist by a mile.
@@wordcharm2649 Funny Ive been to both concerts of each. With all Respect, James is the best vocalist period. With this being said, Everyone has their own ear and opinion. To everyone their own. In my world, I stick to my original post. Peace out people☮️
Sorry sir you can't hold a light
To my MAN Calum Scott no afence
OMG! We’re that being serious, I mean2 diff interpretations but emotionally and sorry Calum, vocally, idts
James Arthur's voice is unmatched, sorry Callum.
Cmon listen to Calum Scott his voice is just too much for James.
well im being biased here but i dont like R&B that much so i go for calum.
Calum is better than james😊
Listen to James singing makes me feel some type of way. His voice is so deep. It's like you can feel what he feels.
This is like a comparing apples to oranges scenario. Just take into account the Calum Scott version is a studio version where James Arthur has a little unique spin that he puts on every cover that he does and it was raw live and uncut. I love Calum voice but I have to get this from the James simply because it's so raw and emotional for me
Instead of battle. How about making it a duet
BL HO speaking facts
Both of these artists have such an unique voice, that is so versatile, and can really carry through every song, and make it their own. That's why I love them both so much😭❤️
But I gotta go with James☺️
Calum is way better for me on this one. Calums talent is from another world.
Calum Scott pure velvet sound such a unique voice.
Ohhh guys, I like both... Each one with their particular qualities
Yeah that's right.
They should stop comparing
Calum is my man but I'll give it to James because he added a little twist to the song. Just being fair
James' is raw and unedited, while calum's is a studio version... clear winner here!
james arthur is unmatchable
james for me.....
Calum Scott nailed it.
James Arthur
Love them both!!! But James....omg...so unique!
calum's tones are soulfull..
Calum for the win he is my favorite singer and his voice itself has meaning
Oh I love them both so much
They both have amazing qualitys in their voices. But I prefer James ❤️
I love them both
Calum Scott has such a hauntingly beautiful voice, definite winner for me 💕
Both are great at what they do... but James Arthur is dynamically genius. Calum has great pathos in his voice no doubt, but James is pure art. James is one of the best male singers (not vocalist) out there today. No one has more feeling.
Calum,by far
Calum all the way❤️❤️❤️
calum scott yeah great voice
Ilove calum scott but james is the emotional king 😍😍😍😍
Calum Scott gets my vote.
definitely Calum Scott ... love his voice so so much!!
Love Calum in a prerecorded setting but he is no match for James live!
Calum Scott by far!!!!
go calum scott
James ❤
Calum scott ofcourse
Nah nah nah, don't make me compare them because both are just amazing. Incredible voices.
Calum Scott amazing ❤
Calum
Calum 100%! But, like comparing a Ferrari and Lamborghini, no losers in this fight.
I can’t compare them two different voices both amazingly different
Calum Scott
If trying to compare the voice quality for this song, Calum is the best voice and nice to listen. But both of them are very talented and have different style.
Calum dom excepcional
james arthur of cause! xx
calum
calumn
James is the best 😍😍
#calum & #james ..... ♡♡♥♥♥
Zahoo Ma Yes! I agree
Calum
james arthur
Love James Authur
calum Scott😎😎
Calum that's very obvious! He got a unique voice
calum scott
I like both!! I really do ❤
Calum is better , James is good singer but here is little near Calum Scott
Robert Muszynski no, james the better
James Arthur ❤️
#CalumScott
I miss these 2. I cried everytime, #greatguys!
Why? Are they dead?
James
Calum of course!!!!
Silvia Zamora obvi!!
#calum
obviously
i mind calum he have a beautifull voice,james just won famous
Both are my favorite singers. 😘😘😘
I like both