Truly a magnificent combo from two different genres coming to together to mesh such an inspiring classic. Hard to believe this song celebrates its 20th year anniversary.
@@dariushlarijani8083 Whoever is not JEW is pagan. And most likely you too are pagan. Pagan = gentile. But nowadays, be we JEWS or gentiles, it matters not, for SALVATION is for all. Both, JEWS AND GENTILES can get saved and return home/heaven. You, soul, worried about nothing more then about only that - that you get right with GOD and saved, yea, worry you only about that.
True, too many singers change the lyrics, have trouble with breathing, struggle with high notes, instruments are completely different, etc. Everyone did an excellent job here.
The year is 2023 and this performance is still considered legendary! Chester's voice at the end of the song is chilling. Wherever Chester is I hope he knows he left an unbreakable legacy!
So true man, in a thousand years time I’m sure people will be shown videos like this as an example of how 2 completely things/genres can be mushed together, and turn out even better
I love how all these two different genres and cultures are able to connect people. Along with humor I believe that music is in universal language that we can all connect with despite our cultural and political differences.
@florbela 100%!!!! It goes back to when Run DMC and Aerosmith did Walk This Way....But you are right.... I love the mix between rap/hip hop and rock/metal!! It makes great music!!!
@@kosmicmarxman443 I don't think they know it is nu metal. Some people I've talked to regard Linkin Park as rock and emo stuff, which, while it is a big mistake, isn't quite something to be against.
The beauty of this collab brings me to tears. True respect when completely different artists respect each other and create this for us. We miss you Chester ❤
I am 28 years old, this is probably the first time in over 10 years that I am listening to this song. I can't even begin to describe the overwhelming feeling I am experiencing right now. How much has changed ever since this song first came out is just crazy
You are only 28. Wait until you get 40. You will be shocked how time goes by so fast. Enjoy your time and waste no time with idiots or doing something you don’t like.
@@sal4992 “The days drag on, while the years fly by.” Anyway, Linkin Park’s first album, I’ll never forget it. Heard it so much summer of 2001 that when I finally bought it later that year I knew the entire thing beginning to end.
I never realized how good Chester was at singing until i heard this! That man has some golden pipes, and now i'm gonna listen to Linkin Park all day now lol.
Chester, July 2022 5 years since you left us. I hope you’ve found some peace after a life of suffering and torment. Your music has brought and continues to bring happiness to millions, some of whom are going through their own struggles. Sadly you’re gone but you will never be forgotten. RIP brother.
It's so sad he became so numb to leave us I felt like that 2 years ago my sister helped me see the rainbow through the rain I'm still battling what I faced then but with her with me.eveey step of the way
Always get emotional when I hear Chester on that hook. Forever thankful that I got to live during this epic time in music history. Thank you for all the memories both Jay Z and Linkin Park.
It's hard not to well up , metal heath is such an untaked subject. Jay closing his shows with encore shows he cares and hopefully makes people be ok to talk about not being ok .
kurt cobain, Chester Bennington, Malcolm James McCormick, Jarad Anthony Higgins When the fuck people gonna realize we have been failing young men for almost 30 years…. Are we gonna stay in denial? All amazing souls gone but helped so many push through… they should get memorials as the young men did on Normandy they all fought for liberation and freedom
Jay-Z sounds incdredible here for a live performance. So rare for a rapper to sound so smooth just like the studio thing. Amazing talent. What a Godly combination of LP and Jay-Z!
Two completely different artists. Two completely different worlds. And they collided to make one of the best collaborations of all time.
The best collab in my opinion
shat up bro< not bro
pure musicians
it sounds ok, but how can someone support gangesters drug and guns sellers like jay z and his friends
True
All my 90's brothers and sisters, how are you guys doing? We are adults now. Those were really fun times. RIP Chester.
Respect from Russia 👍👍👍
Doing well from Canada .. how is everyone doing here? Stay safe 🙏.. R.i.p Chester 🙏
Y’all on a nostalgia trip to?
fun times старина , all right
@@christiannickens3080 oh yes! But obviously not alone, so i got that going for me ;)
JAY Z was rapping his ass off. Didn’t miss one word. Epic performance from two titans in their respective genres.
As he usually does, took me quite a long time to truly see how talented of a rapper he is... he's a perfectionist.
He's good
RIP CB
This song is fkn legendary ✊🏾✊🏾
amazing 🤩
Jesus that first highnote from chester just almost sent me in tears. Why the good ones always gotta be taken too soon man
When Hip-hop meets Rock. Greatest collaboration of all time.
@@VoidC13 yep. it's pretty rare, but when it happens (roughly once in a generation) it always epic
For sure!
Mmmm.... lots of rap/rock collabs but J was on his prime and in his time for the clowns.
Greate for sure! Bad ass as hell! But this is not rock, dude.
pff~ рок с рэпом до этого жалкого лайва эпично встречался не единожды.
Chester hit every single note - for me, he was a living idol and he turned into a legend.
😂❤
@@อนุชนหูถทธ์ Whats funny?
🇬🇧❤️
From Russia with love
Chester is Awesome Forevere😊
Besides being legendary, this song is one of the greatest collaboration and music crossovers ever. Still banging in 2022 and beyond.
Lets go!
let's go
Fk yes
Yass👐
I love how this cannot be duplicated... rappers aren't as skilled as Jay Z and Chester is one of one
No playback... No autotune... Real Music
Real Life…
Sounds amazing 😍😍
@HappyGilmore you’re being nostalgic. Happy Gilmore was my favourite film as a kid, watched it recently, it doesn’t hold up
Also no phones
Me despeinó toda esa fuerza. Un huracán de melodias
Every 90's kids was a big fan of Linkin park and Jay-Z .....
2004 kid here🖐️
'01 but I literally grew up listening to LP
Well that's simply not true.
me and my brothers listens most to jay z
My brother is 4 years older than me,a 94 kid. He showed me LP when i was 10 and since then im a big fan. I wish i was on a concert back then..
People just don’t understand how legendary this is
So true
It's been over 15 years ago and still, the hit is going strong.
Vdd
💯!
R.I.P. Chester 🙏 You're missed more than words could ever say, but You & your music will live on FOREVAH!! ❤
2️⃣4️⃣🙏💜🎗
L@@tressilva3095
Truly a magnificent combo from two different genres coming to together to mesh such an inspiring classic. Hard to believe this song celebrates its 20th year anniversary.
Both Jay-Z and Chester have the amazing ability to sound record-like live. Amazing. This concert must have been insane!
crowd is so dead to like wtf
True love = the love of God!
*God himself went to the cross for you out of love for you as a human being*
Philippians 2:5-8
Nah you mean better.
Cuz its not like studio version
I had tix to the show in Atlanta GA
@@rafflesfn6879 it was a long hot day
One of the best collaborations ever. Chester’s voice combined with Jay-Z… not to sound cliché but “music to the ears”
MUZYKA DLA USZU
Music 🎤
@@theharshtruthoutthere Romans were originally pagans
@@dariushlarijani8083 Whoever is not JEW is pagan. And most likely you too are pagan.
Pagan = gentile.
But nowadays, be we JEWS or gentiles, it matters not, for SALVATION is for all.
Both, JEWS AND GENTILES can get saved and return home/heaven.
You, soul, worried about nothing more then about only that - that you get right with GOD and saved, yea, worry you only about that.
@@theharshtruthoutthere I am a atheist to be honest but with a kind heart
Chester was one of a kind. Most artists can only dream of being able to perform live like he could. RIP you legend. A masterpiece of live music.
amen. only thing that redeems jay-z being on stage.
his voice was so raree and i think in this aspect chester was very similar to freddie mercury
Amen
Literally the best live perfromer I have ever witnessed. May his beautiful soul live on forever.
man had a powerhouse of a voice. thb the purest male voice of all time imho.
Warum schaffen heutzutage so etwas nicht. Es gibt soviel Musik Künstler. Bitte macht wieder so was .😊
Probably the Greatest collab of all time.... Born in 91 and this will always be legendary
music was so good in the 80 s- 90 s what happended
True .my age mate
Hard to argue with that but I still love Run DMC/Areosmith Walk this way. The original Rap/Rock collab.
C’est sa bro 💪🏼
watch the live of Steven Tyler (Dream on) and Eminem (sing for the moment) that is also historic in my opinion
This concert is so pure, just watch everybody at that time. Very few cams, no phones, no selfies, just enjoying the moment. Life was way more simple
Exactly Friend, but with Wet Eyes... :-(
Exactly, any way. Life must go on ❤️
Visit a Tool concert. Absolutely no cameras or phones allowed. If you get out your phone to film you get kicked out of the venue.
Quedo. Q00
So simple..people where real
The quality of this performance live is just astonishing. Amazing.
I saw Linkin park live in london ontario in like 2005 and it's to this day the best concert I've ever been to
it is insane! both jay z and chester were on fire that day
It sounds just the studio’s version. Truly amazing
*The ETERNAL GOD would do anything for you!!*
Even out of love for you he went to the cross as a human!!
Philippians 2:5-8
True, too many singers change the lyrics, have trouble with breathing, struggle with high notes, instruments are completely different, etc. Everyone did an excellent job here.
Chester's voice is a gift...very hard to find same voice like him... It cant be replace... Its like hear numb in another version
RIP Chester. You voice gives me chills listening to your singing. You will be thought of as one of the best
It's crazy to me to remember that this guy was blowing up when I was a kid
I feel like people forget now how good of a singer Chester is 😢
RIP man. I'm glad to see LP back at it, but Chester is missed.
Didn't know he passed.great singer
@patrickdupiton8953 yeah man he died of suicide back in 2016 I believe
chester’s vocals are perfect here. irreplaceable presence. i miss him so much.
A great loss🙌
@@godfire5090 p
@@callumaustin1508 m Iop
I’m I’m l I’m
L
But....
his voice is so diff than the video. ( Also no offense, i just became a linkin park fan, i was not really aware of the band )
all vocalis are irreplaceable..but i mis him too
The year is 2023 and this performance is still considered legendary! Chester's voice at the end of the song is chilling.
Wherever Chester is I hope he knows he left an unbreakable legacy!
My question is Jay and Diddy? Hmm did they weigh on or cause Benningtons death?
November 2024 anyone?
21 November from me
Otro más
Toda la vida
26 november
Toda mi pta vida
This song will never age, collaboration between two musical artist JayZ and Linkin Park, greatness!
So true man, in a thousand years time I’m sure people will be shown videos like this as an example of how 2 completely things/genres can be mushed together, and turn out even better
@@sampaget8928 I definitely agree
No auto tune . Chester ripping it and jay Z rapping it. Beautiful. RIP Chester. Always my favourite
Chester pure talent
Chesters vocals were always on point.
Cant believe it's already been almost 4 years since he left us.
Why
@@sumacoxX what do you mean why?
What happened to him? An incredible talent
@@dianawilliams8801 well he committed suicide in 2017
Das beste Album das ich je gekauft habe ....Meteora. Jemand der so singt, hat Leid ertragen. Genau wie Eminem❤
ich liebe dich bro
RIP chester 🥺
So sad isn’t it , died a very painful soul
🙂
Min nytk salma !??
How are you toma no seu cu
@@mariaalvina2676 I am good, locked down in the UK but good.. how r u ?
Chester's voice was like silk. He provided calm and comfort with anger and sadness. He reached out to us and we responded
The right description tbh. I am an afterclub man, born in the front eighties, but chesters voice can move my innerside, love every piece he sings ❤️
@@davybauwens6302 thats true!!
8ullliiiii8ìoo
I respond him even after his ....
But Chester's voice in Numb is so different than the Studio version
Hip-Hop and Metal together, a thing we don't see nowadays, this whole collab of Jay with LP is the best of its kind. The whole album is a banger.
I love how all these two different genres and cultures are able to connect people. Along with humor I believe that music is in universal language that we can all connect with despite our cultural and political differences.
Linkin Park isn't metal but I completely agree with your point
@@ya-silly-goose623 Nu Metal is still metal lol dont be a gatekeeper, bro.
@florbela 100%!!!! It goes back to when Run DMC and Aerosmith did Walk This Way....But you are right.... I love the mix between rap/hip hop and rock/metal!! It makes great music!!!
@@kosmicmarxman443 I don't think they know it is nu metal. Some people I've talked to regard Linkin Park as rock and emo stuff, which, while it is a big mistake, isn't quite something to be against.
RIP bro, the world misses your presence 😢❤
Quarantining by staying inside and watching old concert videos. Who is with me?
Yep me
Yep!
Me 🤙🏻 in quarantine since one week . Enjoy listening to this legendary music
Me !
Check out my Beats
I am!
It's November 2021 let's see how many legends are still listening to this.
sup
Rip Chester legen
Cool
FUCK THE ILLUMINATI
I will always love them❤... and Jay too💙...
Chester’s voice still gives me chills in 2023
Me too 👍🏼
same ;_;
Fact.
❤
But did this dude die
for those citing '90's kids' - I'm a 1970's kid and this still gives me chills. Amazing collab. RIP Chester.
The beauty of this collab brings me to tears. True respect when completely different artists respect each other and create this for us. We miss you Chester ❤
No phones, No cameras..best concert ever
0:10 literally a camera
MultiCathy33 you’re very easy to impress ;)
Linkin park is shit music. Talentless.
Have you ever watched Live in Pompei ???
So could you tell me what is recording them ? Human eye ?
@@1Tomaraya Linkin Park is shit? I think you born yesterday kid!
One of the best musical collaborations ever, 2023 and it hasn't aged 🌟
It has aged, but it aged well.
I AGREE❤
Can't stop listening since 2k. Best era in rock industry since 80'
I mean best rock era after 80's rock. Limp Korn Linkin and so on
"u kidding me; with this KILLUMINATI Bitch Shawn Carter"
My GF, was singing this song in 2005, i fell in love with it ever since
"Get 'em, Jay" and the beat drops! One of my absolute favourites.
Gone too soon, Chester. Miss you!💔
Gives me a chill every time…
i always thought it's "get MJ" , i mean they asking someone to get Michael Jackson. LOL
Gone when he wanted. Not many of us can afford…
I am 28 years old, this is probably the first time in over 10 years that I am listening to this song. I can't even begin to describe the overwhelming feeling I am experiencing right now. How much has changed ever since this song first came out is just crazy
Same Bro but its like a legacy we must give this to our kids
Same I am your age and man this is nostalgic
You are only 28. Wait until you get 40. You will be shocked how time goes by so fast. Enjoy your time and waste no time with idiots or doing something you don’t like.
@@sal4992 “The days drag on, while the years fly by.”
Anyway, Linkin Park’s first album, I’ll never forget it. Heard it so much summer of 2001 that when I finally bought it later that year I knew the entire thing beginning to end.
Don't give up we'll get it back bro
It's 2023 and this song still gives me goosebumps....
Omsim
Lendária demais essa música
indeed i still love this song in 2023
Me too 💯🙌🤍
clone not a cow, clone CHESTER!!!!!
October 24, 2024 still on love with this❤
It’s my birthday! Playing now 🙌🏼❤️
Это нельзя разлюбить ❤❤..❤❤..❤❤
We are here
My birthday as well
God, Chester’s voice still gives me chills.
Me too baby
Same... simply incredible.
💯
Who does not? 💕
Same here. Hearing Chester again made me tear up, his lyrics got me though some VERY tough times in my life.
Hey, Chester, it's almost "Our December" 2020, we are all still here for ever!
1111q1
Damn! I remembered that GMM episode
Yeah
Eu Brasil ouvindo as relíquias
Yessssss
Not many songs give me goosebumps but this duo is one of them. Just amazing from both of them . Rip chester
RIP Chester.
Iconic voice is truely missed.
Drives me crazy seeing people in the crowd not reacting to this performance, this was truly once in a life time
I thought the same!
Maybe that had to pee🤷🏽♂️
Can't blame them they didn't know it back then.
Maybe they were knocked speechless.
Usually “once in a lifetime” performances are only that when looking back.
JAY-Z rapping on a alternative rock beat really shows you how incredibly talented he is, also RIP Chester 🙏🏽 gone but will never forgotten.
Any good rapper can rap on anything
@@EgoCZ this is true but Jay is one of the best rappers of all time, not because of this tho. I could rap on this beat myself lol
I will never forget Chester who I love 💕 his 🎶🎵🎵🎶💕😘👍😋🤤💖
Encore was a rap song on a different beat from the black album before this collab if anything linkin park just made a beat that went with the vocals
Anyone still listening to this song in 2024........... Damn good ❤❤❤❤❤
the best version ever
One of the best collaborations of all time. Jay-Z and LP. Wish I was there.
Hey Chester, it's September 2020 and we're all still here forever
Always and forever ❤️❤️
PrimeTimeJprime he knows😔
@@JprimeWorld if u tried to be funny, welp u failed
👍🤘👆🇹🇭 i love Chester bingnington [Lqu] Linkin Park
J - [ZaY]
Saudades Chester, o Brasil amava esse cara
I never realized how good Chester was at singing until i heard this! That man has some golden pipes, and now i'm gonna listen to Linkin Park all day now lol.
Good for you
You've been living under a rock then my friend.
@@jabranelahi9456 Yeah pretty much lol.
Hahahaha. Happens. But it's sad he's not here with us anymore.
@@jabranelahi9456 Yeah it really is. I hope his family is ok.
yeah imma rockin on this song i am in 2024 still continue lisening this childhood song
Chester, July 2022 5 years since you left us. I hope you’ve found some peace after a life of suffering and torment. Your music has brought and continues to bring happiness to millions, some of whom are going through their own struggles. Sadly you’re gone but you will never be forgotten. RIP brother.
Such a good tribute...some of us are in tumoil
Do you believe he took his life?!!
The dead know nothing. cant feel, see or hear anything they are gone.
It's so sad he became so numb to leave us I felt like that 2 years ago my sister helped me see the rainbow through the rain I'm still battling what I faced then but with her with me.eveey step of the way
@@timothykyle6387 muita luz pra vc 🙏🙏
We will never see a collaboration like this ever again legendary shit here
My favorite is a fan mash up of lp, jz, Eminem and slip knot🫶🫶🫶
This shit is what our great grand children will see long after we pass
Poderia chamar o Ivo Rosário para fazer uma homenagem ao Chester ❤
R.I.P. Chester Bennington you had an amazing voice, and nobody could ever take your place and fill your shoes.
Actually his shoes sold at auction last month for $47 dollars and someone's is filling them as we speak
@@sk8rg33k whats next ?
@@aribuluk_ historically after the shoes they auction off other accessories such as hats, fingernails, and wristbands, but they won't go cheap
yeah therees some clips out there for chester and .... holy fuck that man had some range and stamina holy fuck RIP
Да уж, открыл Америку насчет этого) Лучше бы промолчал, умней бы казался)
Incredible voice , Chester was the best 😢 RIP 💔
Rest In Peace Chester. Straight up legend and he will always be alive through the timeless music. All legends here!
We here 2022 still listening to a masterpiece RIP Chester
@@steppa2801 ¹
can we appreciate the sound quality as well, most engineers fail to produce such quality for live events
I absolutely love this version. Sounds awesome live 😁🤙
99
I99
Exactly, the sound is perfect
Keep in mind this was way back🙆🏾♂️🔥🔥
Gives me those tingles every time, seeing Mike, Jay-Z and Chester perform, timeless. I love it 💔
Im Jennifer and I am an addict. I’m 3 years and 11 months clean. This song made me cry
Always get emotional when I hear Chester on that hook. Forever thankful that I got to live during this epic time in music history. Thank you for all the memories both Jay Z and Linkin Park.
I'm there with you. Can't stop the tears.
Well said man!
The more I listen to this performance, the more emotional I get. A masterpiece that hits you in the feels.
One of the best collaborations ever. These guys made some fucking awesome music together
yea, goosebumps. Better version ever!
Ola de peru los amo a todos gosalo algus dia no edtaremos gra c.s
It's 2024 and still love this song❤LP ❤
Chester...no one can replay you and your voice...RIP .my legend
yahhh,hes really really good voice
Chester is the best...
😭
Facts
Woow Chester's voice is giving me goosebumps and sending chills down my spine. This is an amazing song ❤️
To the people who are still listening in 2021 are legends!
me and you’re also legend
RIP Chester
Thanks
We've come this far, better, faster, stronger,
Show some loves❤❤❤
Escuchar esta música me remueve en lo más profundo del Alma ....
Chesters voice - just sends shivers down my spine, such a loss.
Still such an amazing Collaboration. Probably one of the best. Man, RIP Chester. So much talent, gone way too soon.
Chester and his vocals.... goosebumps every time I hear them. He might be gone but his music will stay in our hearts forever.
November 2024 who's listening? 😉🙌🫶
I'm always here we're still at war we won I forgave y'all now leave me alone I'll be compensated ✖️🌍🐕🦺 Poisoned 🗂️🗡️🍶🥛🍵💧👀🍲🍰🍕🍝🧪🤮✔️
Chester's voice is something that will be missed forever lp will never be the same.. and like the song says you can never replace him
This was the best fusion between Hip/Hop and Rock genre....much respect....R.I.P chester 🌹
DMC and Aerosmith.
Korn and ice cube
Brasileira apaixonada 🌹pela música dele gente sou Recife Pernambuco xd amor 🌹🌹🌹🇧🇷🌹🌹🌹❤❤💙💚🧡💛💜
Can't listen without tearing up. RIP Chester. Thank you for all.
It's hard not to well up , metal heath is such an untaked subject. Jay closing his shows with encore shows he cares and hopefully makes people be ok to talk about not being ok .
Hello how are you ?
He was murdered smh
Letting u adults know as a 13 year old, respect for Linkin park 💗
RIP Chester, all these years on and you still give me the chills with your beautiful voice. I'm sorry you didn't make it
We can't imagine what Chester been thru.. but every word he sings, gives a chill... Wherever he is... He is RIP ❤️🙏🏻
kurt cobain, Chester Bennington, Malcolm James McCormick, Jarad Anthony Higgins
When the fuck people gonna realize we have been failing young men for almost 30 years…. Are we gonna stay in denial? All amazing souls gone but helped so many push through… they should get memorials as the young men did on Normandy they all fought for liberation and freedom
Well said
I know what you mean. Every time I watch a Linkin Park video the tears come.
@@hermannityofficial528 0000⁰0⁰
His music kept me from going to a dark place during a bad relationship. R.I.P.❤
What an awesome collaboration. Chester sounded so good with Jay-Z. So sad he's gone. It's 2023 and this song still rocks.🤩🤘🏽
One of the rare exceptions where two ingredients shouldn't mix but came out amazing 😎
Jay and Chester were incredible in this live performance. RIP Chester🙏🏼
2005!!!
No phone.
No camera.
I was a kid
And
Lots of #LP song yet to come.
What a time!
Miss you Chester.
2005 i was a young¡¡..
2005 I was 21 😥😥😥😥
nothin will come from lp ma mate its over 😶
No camera? How did it get recorded?
@@NorwegianSun hahaa
Jay-Z sounds incdredible here for a live performance. So rare for a rapper to sound so smooth just like the studio thing. Amazing talent. What a Godly combination of LP and Jay-Z!
was just thinking the same thing
Exactly! So natural!
That's why he's one of the GOAT of rap!
@@Amquacktador woah calm down
Rare for talentless rappers like the “lil’s whatever”.
Dec24 2006 the last time i used drugs . It was my xmas gift to my family and never touch any kind of drugs ever again. Tha ks to them..
April 2024 anyone? ❤❤❤
NL
NL
We’re here bro
Jes bro
Есть живые
Perfect blend of rap, electronics, and Chester’s sweet vocals. Love you, LP
0
000000000000
000
llll
Yeah
Любимый исполнитель, как он выкладывается в каждое слово своих песен. Честер, ты всегда в наших сердцах!!!
А как он выступал! Там вообще крышеснос!
Родной Честер ты всегда будешь легендой лин Кин парк
Man, I'm in love with this band Linkin Park❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Salute to those singers. LP song always and forever my choice to listen when have a problem. R.I.P Chester.
Chester sang his heart out. RIP great vocalist.
He was great sad that he's not here anymore 😔
The ultimate crossover in the music industry
@L L Aerosmith and Run DMC
Maybe one of the cleanest cross-overs, but not the first, or most important. Which go to Run DMC and Chuck D respectively.
@@Lowgarr except Walk This Way was released in 1975 before they used Run DMC to cover the song
Imagine Dragons x Kendrick Lamar
Public enemy and Anthrax as well
Não se preocupe, você não é o único ouvindo essa obra-prima em 2025 💥
Честер это легенда, а линкин парк это образец стиля и образ жизни! Жаль что нет больше этого (((( честер ты в наших сердцах!!!
Да 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Amazing. Two incredibly talented people. And what a sad loss. RIP Chester x
“I came. I saw. I conquered.”
RIP Chester. You meant the world to the world.
there is absolutely NO COLLABORATION more legendary than this
you could never imagine this to ever happen ever, but we lived in the universe that did