Same guitar, 100 yr. difference (how do they compare?)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 лют 2024
- Today I have two guitars, of roughly the same body shape and style, but that span a difference of over 100 years. One is an 1890's Arion (Lyon & Healy), which I've had on the show a lot, and the other is a brand-new Fraulini made by Todd Cambio's son in 2023.
A lot of folks like to touch on things like bracing, tone woods, appointments, things like that. But to me guitars share something more than architecture. I'm hopeful that this vid helps connect the dots for ya!
----------------------------
SUPPORT KYLE ON PATREON:
/ kostringworks
FOLLOW KYLE ON INSTAGRAM:
/ k.o.stringworks
INSTRUMENTS FOR SALE:
www.kostringworks.com/used-in...
The tone of the old Arion...I got shivers when you started playing,so warm and beautiful ,I almost shed a tear.-.Very !
It’s a really really special guitar. Glad you dig it too!
Great job, beautiful guitars. I love the strait bridges. Thanks again
Thanks! Yeah I really favor the look of non-belly bridges too.
I have a 1910ish Lyon and Healey Colombus that really got me into parlor guitars. The better I get at playing the more I realize maybe it's not the easiest guitar to play and fret (past the 5th fret anyway) and gets kinda overwhelmingly muffled with big loud chords but you can't beat how it sounds fingerpicked and it's so beautiful. Bought it from some guy in Maine that restores old parlors. I wish I could remember his name
Nice dude! Yeah they usually need some serious love before they can take in anything past the 5th fret you’re right. No money up there anyway though 😂.
What a well presented and enjoyable topic to discover through my algorithm. Thumbs up! 👍
Awesome! Hope to see you around the comments more!
Another great video. Keep it up.
Thanks dude!! I sure will!
Always wanted a Fraulini 12 string. Had a chance to get a used one around ten years ago, but missed it... Now you say his son is making guitars? Man, time flies.
A few years ago I 'discovered' Waterloo guitars, made by Collings in Austin. A very special combination of vintage and new. I was lucky enough to wind up with several of them, but sold them all off recently. :/ No worries, I'm making do with a very nice 1910ish Washburn size 1, and a '63 Martin 5-16 Terz.
I'm getting old, and smaller is better these days...
Re: the pair being considered here today, I can hear how each of them would have its attraction, but I'd probably chose the Fraulini.
Great channel, new sub!
Crazy! Yeah waterloos are great. Can’t go wrong with them!
Stunning pair of guitars
I'm not too big on vintage guitars. I'm capable of basic maintenance and care, but anything beyond that I go to the pros. Love the sound of them.
Thank you, Kyle
Happy Saturday 🙏🏻🤍
Totally fair! That's kinda why I favor having both too. One for home, one for gigs!
Cool video and great guitars! New sub!
Awesome! Welcome to the channel!
Thank you! Some real talk for a change
Appreciate it!
Really refreshing content mate! Love the Arian. A more warm woody tone, almost muted even, but I love it. I bet the Fraulini would fit perfectly in a bluegrass number. Different styles indeed! I picked up a Japanese made Kimbara N73 from 1974 for £500 pounds and it is the best sounding guitar I’ve ever heard, and I’ve had the privilege of playing some real high-enders. It hasn’t even had any work done. Playability is astonishing too. Vintage can be a real treasure trove if you are open-minded.
Nice dude, I love finding old guitars that just "have it" that most folks are sleeping on. Congrats on that. Keep it!
I Been saving for a fraulini 12 string for awhile I'm about half way there, your looking about 3/4 grand but they are worth every penny if you ask me, heard a guy playing a leadbelly copy and my jaw dropped, you can get them made for about 2 from a couple of guys in the UK, I'm seriously tempted to go with a local maker but the 2 fraulini Iv seen have blown me away, I'll get that fraulini one day 🙏
Keep saving dude! My 12 is just outstanding.
@@kostringworks which do you have ?
@@cruelycruel1032 I have an Erma from 2008 and just got Charlie’s old 12 made a few years ago.
Nice, I been looking at that 12 string too, bit smaller than the ledbelly clones, still making up my mind what model to go for.@@kostringworks
New one' shrill as a pickled hogs knuckle
Old one' mellow as a marshmallow
That is definitely one way to put it!
Arion all the way on sound but I know what you mean. Keep ‘em coming.
Makes me wanna get this little oak guitar finished now though too!
Hey what is the demomstration song you played? Sounds nice
Just a little version of “going down the road feeling bad”. Check out Elisabeth Cottens!
The Arion ate the Fraulini up. What kind of bracing is in the Arion?
Transverse ladder brace!
I wish a Fraulini was 2k.
Right, kinda bad guitar to be giving this example, but I hope the sentiment was clear!
I think they both sound great in different ways, I prefer the newer one because it sounds crisp.
I’m curious about the age of the strings on both?
Totally, crisp is the word. And hey good point, I definitely could have been better about making sure are the variables were the same. All that to say, neither strings were new.
@@kostringworks what are the issues with putting steel strings on a 100 yr old guitar? Are they super light? Do you detune the guitar when not playing?
@@zzbronsonj it really depends on the guitar. I’ve strung this one up w everything. Steels, nylon and gut and honestly it likes steel the best. Very light gauge tho. I don’t de-tune because I play it everyday. If it didn’t I would tho.
I think the 1890"s guitar sounds better! It has a deeper, mellower sound.
I love that guitar so much.
Thanks for watching!
Another great video.
I know you don't actually review guitars but I'd really like to see a video on a carbon fiber guitar 😲...is it blasphemy or a legitimate good sounding instrument that thumbs it's nose at tradition?
I’ve had the same thoughts about it. But I think for me sometimes nostalgia and the poetry of things (wood and age) trumps the best innovations. That said, it did sound incredible.
@@kostringworks
In a thousand years after all the wooden instruments have turned to dust your great great great grandson will be doing videos comparing "vintage" carbon fiber guitars to the newer chrome vanadium models🫣
Clearly, you don't want to talk about guitars.
Sounds like the new one might have a little fret buzz going on
Nah that’s just my sloppy ass playing.
@@kostringworks hahaha still sounds good buddy and I will subscribe to your channel
The best high end, factory built, acoustic guitar I ever heard was an old Gibson . . . The worst high end, factory built, acoustic guitar I ever heard was an old Gibson,
Hahah, well put!!
More like a 133 year difference ?
Hehe, I was waiting for someone to do that math on that one! Shoulda had a prize.
Dude, show...the mike! No parlor guitar sounds like that. On this planet, anyway.
Amazing right? It’s an ear trumpet mic. Also I’ve plenty of videos on the channel using that guitar! Thanks for watching!
@@kostringworks Amazing! Thanks./
fraulini sounded so cheap compared to the old one
Let’s check back in 100 years! One thing that doesn’t translate in the recording is how focused and well balanced the notes project. It’s like a laser beam! It would sit in a mix so nice.