I am a layperson, but in my opinion the story is a little more complicated. At the time of Soviet-Afghan war, US did supply arms and training to Afghan mujahideens using Pakistan. But they did so through many Afghan factions. There were relatively moderate Afghans also involved like what became later Northern Alliance. It was after Soviets left, that chaos ensued, facilitated by sinister Pakistan. They decided to further fund and support only those factions of Afghan mujahideens who were ultra fundamentalists and whom Pakistanis thought they could easily control. Further during Soviet-Afghan war Pakistan took in lot of Afghan refugees, including many orphans. Pakistan as a policy radicalized these orphans in their madarsas. So, US didn't have a direct hand in creating Taliban. They just provided support to all Afghanis to fight off Soviets (just like they are doing currently with Ukrainians). But Pakistan was the main driving force in transforming this support for their ulterior sinister motives. US could have forced or prevented Pakistan not to do so, but perhaps they didn't care. In case of Iraq, yes US was more directly involved. Saddam Hussein, despite being evil and brutal, was a stabilizing figure in Iraq. During Bush Jr's war in Iraq, US killed and disbanded most of Iraqi army officers, after Saddam Hussein was removed, there was a power vacuum. Again US didn't care much about how this vacuum would be filled, or perhaps they didn't understand the cultural dynamics of the region to predict what would happen in the future.
I don't believe Pakistan could have done this without US involvement. US gave fund and weapons to Pakistan to nurture militants and help them create a proxy war against Russia in Afghanistan. Later, Pakistani learnt this proxy war tricks and used same funds weapons and created same militants organisation to attack J&K and our Indian army.
Taliban are Pakistani equivalent of Tamil Tigers. Indian military trained and equipped Tamil Tigers and eventually ended up fighting a bloody war with them. Same is happening with Pakistan Military and Taliban. Moral of the two stories: What you sow, so shall you reap
It wasn't a bad policy to create and support talban but it was for pur own survival. If Soviets successfully captured Afghanistan then next was Pakistan
The ancient fight of Romans and Islamic Caliphate now came into modern era which is Europe and Middle East. Raj Bhai, I would request you to see a UA-cam channel of Dr. Israr Ahmed you’ll get things how Geo-Politics is working.
Not “Fel chuka” or Fainkna. Its Phel or Phainkna😂 secndly as per India’s Gay Friend US own investigation on 9\11. Plan was made in German City ie Hienberg..
I agree that Pakistan created the Taliban. But we only fight for our survival. At one side we were in war with india and on the other side a super war which has an alliance with india was ready to take over Pakistan. Russian clearly indicated and their aircraft violated Pakistan air space many times. Now what was the option left for us ? Later Pakistan backed off and this was a major mistake. Taliban on its own started to do many things against American interests. So america thought now we will win this area. Now it was again a problem for Pakistan so we fight for survival and again went to the Taliban leadership to work with us. The only mistake Pakistan made is that it left the Taliban on their own after Russian back off. Now they were available to be used. And other forces like India israel and russia created influence in taliban.
Dear you are very weak in history It was Mujahidin creayed in 1979 but not Taliban (as they made their own faction in 1994).. And it's not worldwide narrative but it's yours 😂
Pakistan help Afghanistan local citizen(Taliban) to get trained and fight against Russia and America supplied guns and other weapons because america is arch rival of Russia.
Bravo, the most daring and educated General of the Indian Army. 👏 I really appreciated your broadcast which I watched for the first time.
First indian jiski respect krta hu mai because he said genocide to what should be called genocide
Pakistan created Mujahideen against Soviets not Taliban first correct yourself
Taliban are those namak haram mujahids we protect them from americans too
These Mujahideen are called Taliban. He is absolutely right
@@najamsaqib3597 Mujahideen and Taliban are not same. Well, Mujahideen was also against Taliban in 90s
I don't believe it is jihad. Weapons and voilance@@najamsaqib3597
Who funded Mullah Omar then?
I am a layperson, but in my opinion the story is a little more complicated. At the time of Soviet-Afghan war, US did supply arms and training to Afghan mujahideens using Pakistan. But they did so through many Afghan factions. There were relatively moderate Afghans also involved like what became later Northern Alliance. It was after Soviets left, that chaos ensued, facilitated by sinister Pakistan. They decided to further fund and support only those factions of Afghan mujahideens who were ultra fundamentalists and whom Pakistanis thought they could easily control. Further during Soviet-Afghan war Pakistan took in lot of Afghan refugees, including many orphans. Pakistan as a policy radicalized these orphans in their madarsas. So, US didn't have a direct hand in creating Taliban. They just provided support to all Afghanis to fight off Soviets (just like they are doing currently with Ukrainians). But Pakistan was the main driving force in transforming this support for their ulterior sinister motives. US could have forced or prevented Pakistan not to do so, but perhaps they didn't care.
In case of Iraq, yes US was more directly involved. Saddam Hussein, despite being evil and brutal, was a stabilizing figure in Iraq. During Bush Jr's war in Iraq, US killed and disbanded most of Iraqi army officers, after Saddam Hussein was removed, there was a power vacuum. Again US didn't care much about how this vacuum would be filled, or perhaps they didn't understand the cultural dynamics of the region to predict what would happen in the future.
Your english and command over English language communication with extra ordinary analytical skills are The best. Love from Pakistan.
@@saqibkhan-fm8co Thank you bhai. Respect!
I don't believe Pakistan could have done this without US involvement. US gave fund and weapons to Pakistan to nurture militants and help them create a proxy war against Russia in Afghanistan. Later, Pakistani learnt this proxy war tricks and used same funds weapons and created same militants organisation to attack J&K and our Indian army.
Taliban are Pakistani equivalent of Tamil Tigers. Indian military trained and equipped Tamil Tigers and eventually ended up fighting a bloody war with them. Same is happening with Pakistan Military and Taliban.
Moral of the two stories: What you sow, so shall you reap
Pakistan ka Matlab kiya
لا الہ الا اللہ محمد رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ والہ وصحبہ وسلم ❤
Source trust me bro😂
I am from Punjab, Pakistan, and I agree with him,
When the bull fight crop suffer.
It wasn't a bad policy to create and support talban but it was for pur own survival. If Soviets successfully captured Afghanistan then next was Pakistan
The ancient fight of Romans and Islamic Caliphate now came into modern era which is Europe and Middle East.
Raj Bhai, I would request you to see a UA-cam channel of Dr. Israr Ahmed you’ll get things how Geo-Politics is working.
Very absurd.
Taliban came into late 90's. In 80's there were Mujahedeen who were supported by Pakistan.
Not “Fel chuka” or Fainkna. Its Phel or Phainkna😂
secndly as per India’s Gay Friend US own investigation on 9\11. Plan was made in German City ie Hienberg..
TLP 🇵🇸
😂
Great Work
Ye mukti bhani in ki SAALI ki larkay thay😅😊
Uncle ka intellectual level aik dum zero level ka lagta hai mujahideen or taliban ka background nai pata 😂
This Hindu even know about taliban😂😂😂😂, and the Afghan jihad, he's just seeking some money from his awful analysis😂😂😂😂
Bhai Tarabano 1996 Mein bane the
Ap keh rahy hain 20 year Amrica lar k haar k chala gaya tu shikast kis ne de Pakistan ne ye Taliban ne ????????
Apke saree batain Thek houngee per 9/11 statement is not true
Whata Joker 😂
3:15 wali baat sahi karlo warning
Nahi kar rahe sahi, kya kar lega ..... Jannat bhej dunga !
@@shekhartripathi4300 war rukwadi paw paw 😂
I agree that Pakistan created the Taliban.
But we only fight for our survival.
At one side we were in war with india and on the other side a super war which has an alliance with india was ready to take over Pakistan.
Russian clearly indicated and their aircraft violated Pakistan air space many times.
Now what was the option left for us ?
Later Pakistan backed off and this was a major mistake.
Taliban on its own started to do many things against American interests.
So america thought now we will win this area.
Now it was again a problem for Pakistan so we fight for survival and again went to the Taliban leadership to work with us.
The only mistake Pakistan made is that it left the Taliban on their own after Russian back off.
Now they were available to be used.
And other forces like India israel and russia created influence in taliban.
💯💯💯
@@Kataki50what did we sow noob
Tp phr app log isreal ki q support krty ho..unky peechy be ammerica britash neto
Dear you are very weak in history
It was Mujahidin creayed in 1979 but not Taliban (as they made their own faction in 1994)..
And it's not worldwide narrative but it's yours 😂
Sorry this systement is not true
Pakistan help Afghanistan local citizen(Taliban) to get trained and fight against Russia and America supplied guns and other weapons because america is arch rival of Russia.
Rehne de pakistani citizens also involved for dollar now they are biting back
Pakistan .... Super power hai
Ye baat yaad rkna❤
Armi.Air def..Navy❤❤❤❤
And young Ready to fighting Mujahideen (5,0000000)
Pakistan nishana tha Afghanistan bahana tha
Canda my ko terest bhaj raha hy
Free palestine
What about tamil Tiger same case study by Pakistan and Taliban
American senator said in American congress Pakistan is such a beautiful country they sell there mother and sister for Rs 20000 /
Tabhi toh rajiv gandhi ka jo hua woh hua. Now it will haut back pakistan in the same way.