Dr. Clarita Carlos sa kanyang pagbibitiw bilang National Security Adviser | The Mangahas Interviews
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 вер 2024
- "From the beginning my not being a military already was a point against me, even before I was sworn into office. That was because traditionally, being National Security Adviser
had always been given to a military person because of the perceived external threat beyond our shore. But I thought differently. Iyang mga gender biases na ‘yan ay nakakayamot, it’s just so abominable.”
Bakit nga ba nagbitiw bilang National Security Adviser si Dr. Clarita Carlos?
Ang ang kanyang pananaw sa maiinit na isyu tungkol seguridad ng bansa at iba pa, alamin sa panayam na ito ng The Mangahas Interviews.
#Nakatutok24Oras
Breaking news and stories from the Philippines and abroad:
GMA News and Public Affairs Portal: www.gmanews.tv
Facebook: / gmanews
Twitter: / gmanews
Instagram: / gmanews
GMA Network Kapuso programs on GMA Pinoy TV: gmapinoytv.com...
I love you Prof Carlos. Thanks for supporting PBBM.
Thank you Malou for interviewing the very intelligent Lady Prof Clarita Carlos. There’s nothing more satisfying than to hear directly from the Lady herself, the truth of some undesirable allegations of certain vloggers thrown at Prof Carlos. This interview gives me some validation of my personal observation of the First Lady Liza A. Marcos, that she is a humble person bereft of pretence & duplicity. Thanks again. 🇵🇭
Lola mo hindi niya kaya na maging NSA...Sinipa iyan dahil kausap niya ang mga Urban Operatives ng CPP/NDF/NPA. Ang NTF-ELCAC ay pinahina niya at pinalalakas niya ang kilusan kasama ang mga UP NPA professors na kagaya ni Carol Araullo.
F
Salamat po Dr. Carlos sa pagsasabi about the first couple.
Mabuhay ka, Prof Carlos! We applaud you for your kindness!
Lola mo hindi niya kaya na maging NSA...Sinipa iyan dahil kausap niya ang mga Urban Operatives ng CPP/NDF/NPA. Ang NTF-ELCAC ay pinahina niya at pinalalakas niya ang kilusan kasama ang mga UP NPA professors na kagaya ni Carol Araullo...Bwa! ha ha ha
Kaya gustong gusto ko manood ng mga interviews kay Prof Clarita eh, kase sobrang maiintindihan mo talaga ang bawat salita na lumalabas sa kanyang bibig. Mabuhay ka Prof. Clarita Carlos💙👏
I agree with you tungkol sa comment mo kay UP Prof. Clarita Carlos. Madaling masakyan ang sinasabi. SAYANG SI PFRMatcod, Jr. ay pinakawalan sa tamang position o pwesto ang Tama at mahusay na opisyal ng bayan. Hangarin na maitama ang mga Mali.
Mga retirado ng military men have no business in staying in the govt. Maraming qualified sa pwesto ninyong kinuhs. Bakit? Db si PFRMarcos, Jr. na Ang Pangulo?
Dapat NDI SUNUD-SUNURIN si P Marcos, Jr. . . . Ayan ang problema sa walang sap as t na karanasan.. Napapahamak lang ang bayan. . .
Salamat po sa interview ni Ms Malou and Ms Prof Clarita sa mga pag lilinaw sa lahat na tinalakay dito.
reply above.
Dr. Clarita Carlos is an asset for the government and the Filipino people! Extremely bright and articulate… madaling maintindihan kapag siya ang nagpapaliwanag sa mga issues na
complex na kinakaharap natin! Kudos!
Thanks Prof Carlos for the important informations about the first couple to clear the air of any destructive criticisms and allegations against them especially to our First Lady . God bless .
It’s a very cerebral discourse. I could listen all day without getting bored.
It's been a very informative moment to listen to the wisdom of Dra. Claire Carlos. Thanks for sharing.
Salute to Dr.Clarita sobrang smart and idol talaga 👏👏👏
With people like Dr. Carlos in govt.- eloquent, knowledgeable and sincere- there is still hope for this country
Nothing , only showy
Thank you Prof. Carlos for shedding light on the first couple, their work ethics and as a human being. You are indeed a credible source and obviously someone who will not allow anybody to put words in your mouth because you have so much integrity.
Zero integrity.
A very seldom govt official with such integrity Thanku Prof Carlos
Prof Carlos’ has wide knowlege of the Systems
integrity? reply above that patay gutom.
Zero integrity! Carlos is full of herself!!!!
A woman of integrity…mabuhay po kayo Dr Clarita carlos😍
Prof. Clarita Carlos, amazingly intelligent! Dami ko po natutunan sainyo.
ganun talaga pag nasa power na...you have to protect whatever shortcomings and demand respect, understanding, etc...
Kahit ano pang "first" ang idikit. Hindi siya suitable/effective humawak ng NSA at NTF ELCAC. Ganoon lang kasimple iyon.
SAYANG ang Service ni Dr. CARLOS as Security Adviser, Dapat kunin sya At Sundin ang kanyang mga Advises at Bawasan sana too much Politics in Governance.
It is always so enlightening to listen to Dr. Carlos. Her views and opinions on many subject matters are not only informative, but entertaining as well. She presents ideas so clearly and without fanfare or hysteria. Ms. Malou Mangahas is another gem. Because she is well trained, well educated and well informed, she makes for a very good interviewer. Good luck and Godbless to both of them. We need more people like you in the public awareness.
Lllllpp0
anggagaling ninyo, sa pagtatanong at pagsasagot, the level/s of proposition both the micro and macro approaches , congrarulations!
wow,galing talaga idol malou sa interview
RESPECTING YOU MORE SEC PROF CLARITA CARLOS .... SUCH A STRONG MESSAGE FOR OUR COUNTRY TO PROSPER... THANK YOU FOR PRONOUNCING U WANTED THE PRESIDENT TO SUCCEED FOR OUR COUNTRY'S FULLEST RICHES... THANK YOU FOR CALLING AND APPEALING FOR UNITY... GOD BLESS YOU....
MABUHAY ANG PILIPINAS🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭
LONG LIVE🙏🙏🙏🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🎉🎉🎉❤️❤️❤️
She did the right thing to resign because NSA is for people who have the experience on security issues which Dr. Carlos doesn't have the experience.
Only that Dr. Carlos seemed to be always bragging of her being intelligent herself. Everyone knows she's intelligent in her field of specialization. It's a good thing that Sec. Año replaced her.
Hindi siya nag resign tinanggal siya ni madam president dahil sa natuklasan niya sa onion smuggling dahil involve ang kapatid ni madam ni madam president araneta liza.
WHAT???????????????????????????????????????????
Paulit ulit na regardless na egnor Ng government.until PRRD 🙏 Ngayon Ang galing mag scientific mam Carlos. Elcac is been helping us on the bundok.
Thank you Malou for having Dr Clarita Carlos as a guest on your Chanel 👍🇵🇭🙏🏻🌺
Malou, Why is it our political leaders subordinate themselves to the views of military officers whose ideas are not practicable to consider.. Retired na sila pero gusto nila ay nasa serbisyo pa? Dahil ba gusto ng dating Amo nila? Since June 30, 2022 ay may bago na tayong Pangulo so PFRMarcos, Jr.,.
ANO BA YAN?
Sana our good Prof. Carlos can think well on how to amend the Omnibus Election Law para malayang maihalal ang gusto ng taongbaysn.
Please, give a good chance to the voting public with a ideal and good election law. . .
Thank you Dr Carlos...we salute you!
On the aspect of PNP resignation, I subscribed with you ma’am. You are absolutely CORRECT !
Those who maligned Prof. Clarita Carlos, accused her of being a traitor or being corrupt just for driving a posh vehicle only to find out that it was lent to her by a friend. Did these people ever apologize to her for putting her in such a defensive dubious position to the extent of persecution and then to gloat of her resignation as is they were patting themselves at the back, as if they had a hand in her leaving the NSA? Shame! Thanks for the share and Live Long and Prosper!
Topics discussed are so informational, thank you to both of you. Let's bring back the Glory the Philippines was.
she has the best intention and underrated approach to the root cause of the problem and the solution needs different approach talaga, para magbago ang result. think about this: "same tool, same result" why not ang ganito: "different approach, different results"
Nabigyan ya n ng budget sabi ni maharlika hahaha
@@marianakjima3237 in any individual leader and positions, na nabigyan ng positions. bibigyan talaga po dba. pero i do understand what u are trying to mean. kaya yung iba na dapat mabigyan sa specific department eh pumapalag sa idea nya at sa kanya. patas lang sa pag received ata ng budget, di po ba? sa context lang ng approach ng pagtratrabaho at goal aat objective, magkakaiba at dun magkakaalaman. so yes agree with you, i think nabigyan talaga ng budget ang department nya by law and rules.
Very fair magbigay ng decision si Prof. Clarita Carlos
I like clarita carlos she is right
Sayang, idol ko pa naman sya. N apakarunong sya. At broad minded pa. I salute her very intelligent idea of due process. Best of luck Dr. Clarita Carlos. NTFELCAC-only knows to accused those who don’t like as cpp-npa
A great interview..shedding light..
LMAO! What shedding the light are you blabbing about? She's lying, and she's so careless as well or probably doble kara as her LEAKED letter to Liza appears to have been intentional. And you cultist know nothing about this because you're busy devouring Marcos fake news.
Salute to you Ma’am Clarita Carlos, That’s why i never listen to those critics of yours … God bless you 🙏❤️
Salute to dr.Carlita Carlos.
Thanks for sharing
I love the discussions. Very informative.
Dr.Clarita Carlos is a woman of integrity,the reason why she resigned.She's not just nobody but a brainy political analyst.Congrats Dr.Carlos for your nice decision!
I agree to Prof. Carlos.
We salute you Dr Carlos a true warrior.
It's really important to know the other side of the story! I'm almost fell into the pit of wrong info..
HONESTY is the BEST POLICY..💯
MINSAN lng TAYONG MABUHAY sa mundong ito... Dapat MAGPAKATOTOO..🤔
Salamat maam carlos
Lalo akong bumilib sayo Dr. CARLOS. SALUTE TO YOU MAAM!
Very good.....
I feel smart in politics after listening to two very smart individuals.
BBM like her so much because he knows how clever she is, kya lng BBM didn’t realize na naging banta sa security ng bansa dahil madaming ayaw sa knya ( Prof Carlos) na mismong part ng NAtional Security program people ay ayaw sa knya. Good on you Prof. Carlos, and still nppakinabangan parin ng Pinas ang knowledge nyo.
Professor carlos I salute u madam
Good point yun: Sobrang dami na nating diplomatic protests (hundreds na) to China regarding West Philippines Sea bat walang result? Kung ang papalit na adviser is data driven siya yung policy nya, big clue yun na hindi gumagana ang approach. Tama si prof. dapat mag iba ng strategy. Kasi in the first place China is not recognizing the arbitration rule.
Aral sakin, "KUNG AYAW MONG MARUMIHAN (O MABUNGI KAMO), LUMAYO KA SA PUTIKANG KALABAW, DAHIL KAPAG PUMILANTIK ANG BUNTOT NYAN, MAPUPUTIKAN KA RIN."
ANG SISTE, SINAGPANG MO ANG JUICY NA PAGKAKATAON, HAYAN NABUNGIAN KA TULOY... AMININ...
Sinipa SI Carlos Ang tutuo
I LOVE PROF CLARITA CARLOS - MAY SARILING PAG-IISIP AT HINDI "kiss a**" PARA LANG "sakyan" ANG (seemingly) "popular opinion or leading questions". Si prof ang scholar na KAYANG IBABA ang antas ng usapan sa 'MAUUNAWAAN' maging ng ordinayong mamamayan. Yung ibang mga "ARÁL" (educated) kapag nadinig mo, duduguin ang ilong mo dahil hindi mo maintindfhan ang mga sinasabi... pero si prof, napakalinaw at walang "bs"... naalala ko tuloy si sen. Miriam Santiago... pareho sila ng kalibre.
LTF ELCAC has not stàbilized yet, so the task force still has to continue... Clarita is having that feeling of gràndiosity, very proud of herself being so intelligent... madam, you work on the ground huwag dada nàng dada
Di niyo yata naintindihan na halos naging tirahan niya ang airport dahil sa kabibiyahe para puntahan ang mga lugar at personal na alamin ang mga suliranin dahil walang maayos na transition from the previous head. Akala natin di nagtatrabaho dahil di siya nagsasabi sa media.
I don't think she's all talk.
we love you Professor CC ❣️❤️🤗😍 amping permi 🙏🏻
marami akong natutunan sa discussion nyo
Professor Carlos, I salute you madam...
such a gem~
I salute you Prof. Clarity Carlos. God bless.
Totoo ba na nagsubmit Ng resignation letter c Prof. Carlos or verbal resignation lang. Kc noong ina-point siya as NSA secretary ay written ngayon verbal resignation? Just asking
thank you so much for opening our mind regarding FL. ang hirap kc sa mga oinoy eh masyadong marites.
I LOVE YOU MAAM CLARITA CALOS
Mabuhay kayo 2, hangang gusto nyo
Its not tinapan po. It originated from Oplan Bayanihan. It started from Bohol focusing on the root cause of the problem: poverty. The whole of the government approach. Before identification of armed group components, its passes through varius information assessment cycle to identify the influenced barangays, then the counter action for the armed group component, winning the heart and mind to convince the members of the underground movement to surrender, then the rehabilitation and integration is the last part. Government intervention to led by the LGU heads to address poverty and the institutionalization, then the Internal Peace and Security Plan turn over to the civilian authorities, so the AFP can concentrate on external threat. Its success largely depends on the LGU head's good governance programs and practices.
Doctora bakit kasi nag resign kayo
Salute to Dr. Carlos!!!
Sinipa dahil di kaya ang NSA
Wow, thanks for the I formations
Yes intelligent policies are needed for security
Malou para Lang yan kung natanggap ka sa isang company.. you have a 6 months probationary period .. before ka maging permanent..
Sa mata ninyo di kayo ngsasabi ng totoo
🤣🤣🤣
I'm a great fan Dr. Carlos !!!
GODBLESS PO...
Inflation po ang ang reason na hindi mkatulog si pbbm kung paano mapa baba ang presyo ng bilihin at hindi ang china malou.
Totoo ba Yun generous allowance?
Maybe hahahaha
tanungin kaya natin cya
Napanood ko pa last month interview ni ka tunying sa kanya after umalis sa NSA.
hmmm! may nagsabi na pinatalsik ka maam ah!
For Clarita Carlos, tuta sya ni BBM noon, tuta pa rin ngayon. D bali na, na fired National Security Commissioner sya once before.
Tuta kapag nagsasabi ng totoo tungkol sa Pangulo? Anong gusto mo sabihin, masama ang Pangulo?
@@justmeamalia6231 Yon ang sinabi nya noong bago lang sya na fired. Ngayon lang ayaw na nya sabihin ang mga sinasabi nya noong presko pa sa balita.
i love prof. Dr. Clarita Carlos a true person, very bright. i wish i can have some talino of her.❤
A hero turned balimbing. Kawawa ang bansa, wala na tunay na bayani.
Sobrasobra nga ang usec and asec sa mga agencies. Tama si Dr. Carlos. Pasahod lang sa kanila ang laki pati pa ang staff nila.
Napakagaling po ni Dr. Carlos. Kailangan siya ng ating bansa.
Happy
If I’m in a dark cave and, in order to get out, I either follow directions from Sara or Liza…100% I will follow Liza Araneta Marcos!
2nd meriam santiago my prensipyo
So far itong interview ni mam malou mga interviews niya in general very objective. Klaro. The opinion of the interviewee nangangababaw.
TBH, boring at generic yung interview..
She didn’t even answer, ang criticism sa kanya with lack of action nya while NSA chief. Bakit nabawasan yung nTf-elcac budget.
Please go back and face SMNI criticism.. you guys are friends. Please reconcile.
Sumikat sya dahil sa mga smni interviews/exposure.
Major critics din nya smni.
So go back and face them. Settle your issues with them..
Pumayat na si Dra. Clarita Carlos. Dami problema talaga sya . Mabuti nman at madami ng trabaho ata. Inshaalah gabay ng Dios ay nasa inyo.
Matanong kolang po Sino po ang nagpahinto sa hearing ng Sibuyas Smuggling, Adviser po kayo Miss Clarita ni Martin Romualdez, sino po ang nagsabing ipahinto yung hearing.
Thank you Prof. Carlos, you are came from UP at sino ba ang batikos ng batikos sa gobyerno?
Mangahas was trying to paint Bbm admin in a bad light but Prof Carlos saw good things this administration
Magaling ka lang magpalusot.
Hindi kailangan maging military ka para maging Defense Advisor. Meron nga tinatawag na civil defense. Pwede ba yun militar lang?
At hindi mo pala alam lahat tayo may tungkulin na ipagtanggol ang bansa. Ika nga lahat tayo militar sa panahon ng digmaan o banta ng digmaan. Naka-standby lang tayo para makipaglaban kung kailangan. Exempted lang diyan yung walang kakayahan gumamit ng armas pero may pwede parin silang magagawa bilang support group.
Ang pambansang depensa ng tungkulin ng lahat yan maging sibilyan ka man o militar.
Wag ka na lang magpalusot halata naman kasing palpak yung advice mo kay Marcos.
Really.....
Sana hindi sya nag resign kung para sa kapakanan nang bansa talaga. Pa simula pa lang yung mga plans nya sa nsa.
You answer what is being asked ?
Tama lang na nag resign SI Madam Clarita Carlos bilang security advicer dahil nakakahiya na alam na alam mo Ang tungkol sa Smugglers tapos andyan kapa as Security Advicer .
Thanks for your resignation.
Promise Yan susundan Sila Ng katarungan ate milka balan sakit sa Ulo congressman briones good taste congressman
GENEROUS ALLOWANCE DAW.
Ang Department of Agriculture, yan i-right size.
So why refused to have a dialogue with LKAB and top former cadres who are exposing CTG atrocities? You are afraid to face the truth! The nation “ay walang utang na loob” to “tapatan” the atrocities of the NPA. All the LKAB hosts are asking you is to condemn the atrocities of the NPA which you “patay mali” na ayaw pansinin. Good riddance! Now Generals Anyo and Galvez will finish the job for national peace!! Mabuhay SMNI and LKAB!!
Na recharge po ako da usapan.... ang galing talaga ni ms carlos
What will happen if there is an emergency in our country and the heads of our defence have resigned?
The professor knows what she was doing, so who's saying that she never did anything?
I think their wisdom behind the resignation is so to "delete" whatever/wherever influence they may still have, that could hamper their intel...
Exactly thats the whole purpose. Nakaka disappoint na nag comment without knowing the nitty gritty of the said pronouncement.
Sinipa correction