This is one of the few versions of this song live where Andi sings it in the original arrangement - he does a great job however as this song changed over the years to suit Andi’s voice, it got better. The Live on Three Continents version is the ultimate arrangement with Deris on vocals and has a different feel to the Kiske version.
Oh, and don't forget one more thing: During live concerts, neither Kiske - with his astonishing voice - could sing his songs, like the way he sang on the albums. And thats not suprising. These tunes are really, really hard to sing perfectly. Maybe this song (and all the others) was (were) recorded within a week or two, when the guys were in the studio, making the Keeper albums.
La escucho y no me canso. Que sea la version original o la de Deris, me da igual, esto es Helloween. Y esta fue la mejor formacion, con Grapow y Kusch !!!
Original,very nice,metal,sing!!! And very nice,original=play!!!! Super!!! Thank-you very much for the respecting,metal,rock consert in Korea!!! I`love you everybody!!! In Helloween in lovely,dear,spiritual-metal=germany!!!! VIVAT !! dears in respect =Helloween!!!
I like very much the "3 continents" version fo this song... there Andi really sing with a huge performance (and i like more that version than kiske in 93)
@@ltd9792 Really?... So you probably do not like and accept the voices of: Axel Rose, Sebastian Bach, Geof Tate, Robert Plant, Roy Khan, Kay Hansen, Ralf Scheepers, between other singers who use falsetto as a resources in a LOT of occasions. On the other hand, i want to hear you singing high notes, because if you say "it is not acceptable", i suppose you are a prodigy like a singer, or even you reach very high notes without falsetto. Hope you have an awesome new year!
@LightThePrince "[..] he is not Kiske, my friend." You forget one thing: Andi never wanted to be Kiske! Andi Deris is a damn good singer, and he sings all of the old ("Kiske era") Helloween songs in his interpretation. That's why he sings those songs well. And that is the most what ANY good singer could do.
i love this, obviously is not better than kiske, and none of them can sing this son in its perfectly way, but i actually love both HELLOWEEN FOR FUCKING EVER!
Andi is of course a great singer..no doupt about that..and i think people should compare ..its just a matter of taste..personaly i am fucked deep in the brain when i hear hansen singing..and i mean it the good way! each singer has really different good things ..hansen has the voice kiske the feeling and deris in my personal point of view a litle of both..if i had to choose as i said before and thats not camparing i would say hansen ..
방구석 여포인 그쪽이 진짜고 가짜고 논할 자격은 전혀 없는거 같은데ㅋㅋ락 보컬이더라도 각자의 개성에 맞는 스타일이 있는거고, 앤디 이 사람은 1대 보컬 키스케가 불렀던 곡들을 부른거고 당연히 그 사람에 맞게 작곡된 곡이니 안 맞을 수 밖에. 그럼에도 세계적인 무대에 앞에 어려운 여러 곡 부르고 또 이 곡을 부르니 목 상태가 얼마나 피로하겠음.
Go to the year 1993 listen to some Helloween, come back to 2015 listen to some Helloween. And what is up with you hating Andi, you propably don't even hate his singing, you just hate the fact that Kiske is not in the band.
***** Nooo ! Really? I didnt know that :S , probably i havent been in this planet all this time.... Ohh of course here is only helloween, but helloween is dead x)
In what universe Helloween is dead? Helloween is more successful now, with this formation. Who needs kiske? Many people know and love Helloween now. However, who know Unisonic? Who know kiske? If Helloween is dead now, then kiske never existed. Listen to Straight Out of Hell, great album from 2013.
![Helloween - A Tale That Wasn't Right (United Alive 2018) [Full HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fdI847ReWis/mqdefault.jpg)
![Helloween - A Tale That Wasn't Right (United Alive 2018) [Full HD]](/img/tr.png)
Humble, handsome & charismatic...with very unique voice...that's ANDY💕
This is one of the few versions of this song live where Andi sings it in the original arrangement - he does a great job however as this song changed over the years to suit Andi’s voice, it got better. The Live on Three Continents version is the ultimate arrangement with Deris on vocals and has a different feel to the Kiske version.
what a wonderful voice of roland grapow!!...😃
I love you ANDI DERIS ♥.....
Forever...y thích ANDI và Helloween. I love.....
Que temazo...lo escucho y lo escucho.
Oh, and don't forget one more thing: During live concerts, neither Kiske - with his astonishing voice - could sing his songs, like the way he sang on the albums. And thats not suprising. These tunes are really, really hard to sing perfectly.
Maybe this song (and all the others) was (were) recorded within a week or two, when the guys were in the studio, making the Keeper albums.
This is difficult song... Very high note and andy singing with his heart❤️ u're so handsome andy... Luv u ❤️
Thank you
I was here!!#!!!!! damnnn I wanna go back to that moment..
Papa Deris so handsome and charismatic ❤️
창법이 배에서 힘을 끌어올리고 가성에 비음을 섞어 샤우트로 쏟아냄 매력있음
No falseto..it is high voice
Is powerrrr
Luôn y quý tiếng hát a I Love ANDI DERIS♡♡♡♡♡♡♡.......
ANDI DERIS RULES!!!
lord
Guau sin duda son la Banda de powuer metal mas Rockmantica de todo los tiempos ❤❤❤
Lindo ❤️
I Love You Andi
La escucho y no me canso. Que sea la version original o la de Deris, me da igual, esto es Helloween. Y esta fue la mejor formacion, con Grapow y Kusch !!!
Weikath es el compositor de este tema, hecho para quien la interprete en voces.
Agreee....
Original,very nice,metal,sing!!! And very nice,original=play!!!! Super!!! Thank-you very much for the respecting,metal,rock consert in Korea!!! I`love you everybody!!! In Helloween in lovely,dear,spiritual-metal=germany!!!! VIVAT !! dears in respect =Helloween!!!
It makes me shiver...
essa música é demais!!
I love ANDI DERIS💖
I like very much the "3 continents" version fo this song... there Andi really sing with a huge performance (and i like more that version than kiske in 93)
Falsetto high notes, especially for rock vocals, are just not acceptable.
@@ltd9792 Really?... So you probably do not like and accept the voices of: Axel Rose, Sebastian Bach, Geof Tate, Robert Plant, Roy Khan, Kay Hansen, Ralf Scheepers, between other singers who use falsetto as a resources in a LOT of occasions.
On the other hand, i want to hear you singing high notes, because if you say "it is not acceptable", i suppose you are a prodigy like a singer, or even you reach very high notes without falsetto.
Hope you have an awesome new year!
Adoro tiao carnero
milujem!
@LightThePrince "[..] he is not Kiske, my friend."
You forget one thing: Andi never wanted to be Kiske! Andi Deris is a damn good singer, and he sings all of the old ("Kiske era") Helloween songs in his interpretation. That's why he sings those songs well. And that is the most what ANY good singer could do.
Grate
고등학교 다닐때 이 음악을 알았죠
완전 좋아 완전 좋아 너무너무 행복해
그 시간으로 돌아가고프다
가장 빛나던 순간
Please upload full HD video of this concert bro 👍
i love this, obviously is not better than kiske, and none of them can sing this son in its perfectly way, but i actually love both HELLOWEEN FOR FUCKING EVER!
❤
Andy Deris kaya wa agus almarhum kaka saya.. ganteng gagah keren..
Yes Gibson white must by played
Andi is of course a great singer..no doupt about that..and i think people should compare ..its just a matter of taste..personaly i am fucked deep in the brain when i hear hansen singing..and i mean it the good way! each singer has really different good things ..hansen has the voice kiske the feeling and deris in my personal point of view a litle of both..if i had to choose as i said before and thats not camparing i would say hansen ..
락보컬의 고음가성창법은 진짜 아님. 그것도 세계적인 락그룹에서. 어떻게 이사람이 헬로윈 보컬로 들어왔지.
방구석 여포인 그쪽이 진짜고 가짜고 논할 자격은 전혀 없는거 같은데ㅋㅋ락 보컬이더라도 각자의 개성에 맞는 스타일이 있는거고, 앤디 이 사람은 1대 보컬 키스케가 불렀던 곡들을 부른거고 당연히 그 사람에 맞게 작곡된 곡이니 안 맞을 수 밖에. 그럼에도 세계적인 무대에 앞에 어려운 여러 곡 부르고 또 이 곡을 부르니 목 상태가 얼마나 피로하겠음.
니 같은 방구석 백수가 뭘 알겠냐만 앤디는 키스케 탈퇴 이후에 침체된 할로윈을 다시 전성기로 이끌었고 세계 곳곳에서 높이 평가 받는 락 보컬임. 멍청한건 알겠지만 조금이라도 생각을 좀 하고 댓글 다시길.
О это древнее искусство хеви метала)
Great singer but will always prefer Michael Kiske 🤘🤘😍😍
내공
i bet 100$ with my friend that in the first 5 comments, someone would still be bitching deris vs kiske
i'm gonna buy bf4 now lol
It seems that he isnt strong enough to sing this song perfectly
Короче, мне вокал Энди , больше нравится, чем, Михаэля киске , почему он 64 а я86 го 😢😢
Esta rola se escucha mejor con Deris siempre.
Ja ja ja
kiske is the best .now helloween is dead fore my
Go to the year 1993 listen to some Helloween, come back to 2015 listen to some Helloween. And what is up with you hating Andi, you propably don't even hate his singing, you just hate the fact that Kiske is not in the band.
Helloween is a world famous rock group, but this vocal can not sing proper high notes, so he has to sing in falsetto.
no me gusta la voz de andi deris
Los coros se los hace grapow, suena desalineado eso es claro, al menos esta fumando menos y ahora con kiske no desgasta tanto la voz.
Solo kiske está hecho pa está canción
sorry aber man sollte deris das verbieten.. nicht mal hansen sollte sich daran versuchen..
Author originally is michael weikath.
Rusak dah ni lagu.....!
Andi Deris better than michael kiske.
Jozhepp Salgado The Berlim wall is down now. Stop to live in the past! Go and listen to your Unisonic. Here is only Helloween. :)
***** Nooo ! Really? I didnt know that :S , probably i havent been in this planet all this time....
Ohh of course here is only helloween, but helloween is dead x)
In what universe Helloween is dead? Helloween is more successful now, with this formation. Who needs kiske? Many people know and love Helloween now. However, who know Unisonic? Who know kiske? If Helloween is dead now, then kiske never existed. Listen to Straight Out of Hell, great album from 2013.
I'm with you.. :)
Andi Deris is better in his style.
DERRIS SO BAD SINGING THIS A SONG