He'll probably end up as the Best,. He's much younger than the other prospects,. He has that IT factor,. But it would be best for him to go to a place he can sit at least half a yr~
I might be mistaken, but he strikes me as AJ McCarron 2.0. That said, he played at a Big School, had a lot of starts, won the Nati (though I would credit the defense and running game for UM’s success), and he is one of the bigger QBs in this draft class full of prospects that are less than prototypical sized QBs. I find it odd that his coach at Michigan, Jim Harbaugh, would brag on JJ as his ride or die QB, but then leaves the school for the Chargers HC job-A team that has a clearly superior QB that McCarthy will not unseat, even if his former college coach selects him, which I doubt he will despite the aforementioned praise. Some franchise will get tempted and draft him too high…I think that team will be sorry.
Exactly and when you look at his highlights hes just not throwing to wide open wrs and hes looking to throw when he runs and not just fully commited to running like Jayden Daniels. He reminds me of Brock Purdy.
@@mickee06 fair comparison.... all of these high recruiting teams are throwing bombs to 5 star recievers vs. 2-3 star DBs. Purdy's tape told the truth.... he anticipated, threw guys open, and was efficient. Anticipation and pocket prescence would be keys for me. I see big red flags for daniels.... these spy, underneath, and blitz zones destroy rookie QBs
Good stuff. I view him as the best QB fit for what Belichick (if he returns), and NE generally like at the position... and they did pretty well with the last tall, skinny winner from Ann Arbor.
He came in the combine at just under 220. And i tnink pocket presence is a plus for him too but i think he improved that abd footwork A LOT in the offseason.
If I were to guess, top 3-4 QB and possible first rounder, maybe second rounder. Third round would be a steal, and the right coach (like Jim Harbaugh was to JJ) he will develop into a great NFL QB.
I think he would probably be a guaranteed first-round selection. One of the main concerns about McCarthy across the media is that Michigan's offense ran through the run game for the second half of the year. McCarthy's got talent, he really does, and I think it would've shown more if he played in a QB-friendly system.
@@chasekellerjournalism I definitely agree with that. I think if Jim goes to Atlanta (which as a Falcons fan I am praying for) JJ goes there too whether they trade back from 8 or use the 2 second rounders to move back up and snag him at the end of the first round or even just see if he falls to round 2.
@@steadyxgang he folds under pressure alot look average without presnap motion and no play action he a game manager like goff with more talent less skill than goff and higher ceilings
@@DetroitEast presnap motion does nothing for the QB. All that does is create mismatches and seperation with WR. Does nothing for the QB. maybe expose man coverage. That's it. Nothing to where it alters a QB talent or skill. Not only is he mobile, he can create something from nothing. He can throw on the run(some mobile QBs can't). And idk what you're talking about folding under pressure. One game don't define a player. Y'all just stuck in your own thinking habits.
Anyone who thinks that this kid IS NOT a top prospect is clueless. Oh he didn’t throw it a lot. But when he did throw, he was on point. Our team was a run first team, with a running game that was hard to stop. He was coached by one of the best quarterback whisper’s of all. So you young guys don’t know 💩….. #GoBlue✊🏾💛💙
McCarthy goes through his progressions faster than any of the other first round QBs. It wouldn't surprise me if McCarthy goes in the top 15 which is a little high but QBs are often over drafted and he does have a lot of upside.
I got him slughtly behind Daniels but still graded nearly the same. Although Daniels has been more impressive Mcarthy does more things that translate to the NFL as a thrower than Daniels does. Im going to need that Spencer Rattler video bro. I think if he gets in the right situation like New Orleans and sits behind Carr for a year or two he can be groomed into a legit NFL qb.
Great analysis bro I agree with every sentiment and I honestly think McCarthy and Daniels can possibly be better then Williams and Maye at the pro level
He's going very high in this draft and may end up being the best of the lot. A few things you didn't note that NFL guys put a premium on. His qbr, completion percent & yards per completion under pressure rank 1st. He was coached to throw balls where only his receivers can catch it - look where most of his misses are. Also, his numbers didn't really change when playing better competition, while the others did. These are the things Harbaugh covets in his QB and why he thinks Mccarthy is actually the best of the bunch, when the pressure is greatest, the guy answers every time.
I tend to avoid production when making these detailed scouting reports, and I try to just give background information and then focus on the film, since film helps me determine what my positives and negatives are for that prospect. For example, let's just say McCarthy had the highest YPC under pressure. What if a lot of that was manipulated by YAC, and #2 on the list had less YAC? The statistics help me get a head start, but the film confirms different ideas.
JJ McCarthy would not be a bad quarterback to draft, but only if a few QBs are already off the board. With that being said, without a second-round pick I doubt it’s likely.
@@Mike-xj6pi Maye is my QB1 in this class, and while he would be amazing in Broncos Navy and Orange, he won’t fall that far nor will Denver trade up to get him.
I was gonna say wtf is this guy talking about, JJ's pocket presence and ability to extend plays was a big factor in a lot of their wins. @@gregschulte2953
I agree the bears need to trade away their first pick for more picks. Grab a WR and DE and get JJ with the pick from the trade... I think he'll go early 2nd round
@@NAT-turners-Revenge Yepp,.The Bears are in a PERFECT position to have Monster draft capital for Years to come,. But they'll fk it up and stand pat when Trading DOWN is easily the Best option for them.
One thing not being talked about enough is his age. JJ is only 20 years old. I expect that over the next year or two, sitting behind a good QB, he will put on mass. He will have to if he wants a longer career in the NFL,
He's verry YOUNG,.Just turned 21,. He definitely should sit for half a yr but he has ALL the tools. Could literally be the next Brady but faster,. Just needs to be brought along slowly and not thrown in the fire~
JJ will go in the first round hopefully to Denver. Sean payton will make him a star. He can put on 10 to 15 pounds in the weight room that will help him. Another positive is he is coachable unlike Caleb.
He’s not a, “Game Manager”, Cam Newton Jr….. I bet you know zero about him. Because if you did, you wouldn’t have said that B.S…. Michigan was a run team first, pass second. So he didn’t have to pass a lot. Game manager my arse…. #GoBlue✊🏾💛💙
@@jasonpeterson8 so his job was to manage the game. They were going to win primarily through the run game and his job was to make plays and not turn the ball over... as what game managers are supposed to do. Dummy you know nothing
Bryce Young obviously had frame concerns coming in, and guys will still have frame concerns while he's playing. They are a bit different though. Bryce Young stands at 5'10/204 and McCarthy is 6'3/202. Bryce Young's issues were more because of his height, but as you can see he does weigh more than McCarthy. And with McCarthy, his concerns are more for his lean frame. Being 6'3 is fine, but the average QB weighs 220-225.
@@chasekellerjournalism , sorry….. but I disagree….🤷🏾♂️ This kid learned from one of the BEST QB coaches of all-time…💯 And he was highly touted as a QB by many big time colleges…🤫 #GoBlue✊🏾💛💙
Yes, I know that he was a 5 star recruit and that Harbaugh has compared him to Luck, but I don't see any of that. To me, he's about the same as Dylan McCaffrey - good runner, good enough height, smart, decent arm, and understands situational football. In fact, Dylan might have beat him out had he stayed. I see JJ as a second day pick and an NFL backup. Not much zip, not many 'wow' throws, and not too many super accurate throws in tight coverage like say, Tua. To me, he's a good, smart leader with just okay talent and good legs.
Well, he bombed in the Pro Bowl QB Competition, but he led the league in yards and top 5 in completion percentage, so real world performance says he's an accurate and productive NFL QB.@@whosdatdude3570
I have no ide who this Chase Keller guy is, but it appears that anyone with a podcast is now an NFL draft expert doing "scouting reports". This kid looks like he's still in high school. It takes years to learn how to do draft analysis. Even the people who have been at it for decades get a lot of it wrong. Sorry...not buying that junior here is delivering a "scouting report" on JJ McCarthy. He needs to be doing his geometry homework instead of this.
What was that whistling noise you asked?? It was just Anthony Penix draft status falling at the speed of sounds. A injury prone crybaby head case of a QB. Oh wait he may go #1 and if not the Jets will take withtheir first pick.
Most overHATED prospect in the class
He'll probably end up as the Best,.
He's much younger than the other prospects,.
He has that IT factor,.
But it would be best for him to go to a place he can sit at least half a yr~
I might be mistaken, but he strikes me as AJ McCarron 2.0.
That said, he played at a Big School, had a lot of starts, won the Nati (though I would credit the defense and running game for UM’s success), and he is one of the bigger QBs in this draft class full of prospects that are less than prototypical sized QBs.
I find it odd that his coach at Michigan, Jim Harbaugh, would brag on JJ as his ride or die QB, but then leaves the school for the Chargers HC job-A team that has a clearly superior QB that McCarthy will not unseat, even if his former college coach selects him, which I doubt he will despite the aforementioned praise.
Some franchise will get tempted and draft him too high…I think that team will be sorry.
I love his skillset and he came from More of a pro style offense.
Exactly and when you look at his highlights hes just not throwing to wide open wrs and hes looking to throw when he runs and not just fully commited to running like Jayden Daniels. He reminds me of Brock Purdy.
@@mickee06 fair comparison.... all of these high recruiting teams are throwing bombs to 5 star recievers vs. 2-3 star DBs.
Purdy's tape told the truth.... he anticipated, threw guys open, and was efficient. Anticipation and pocket prescence would be keys for me.
I see big red flags for daniels.... these spy, underneath, and blitz zones destroy rookie QBs
JJ is without a doubt a first round pick if Kenny Pickett who is far less talented went first round JJ deserves to go in the first as well
10000%~
Good stuff. I view him as the best QB fit for what Belichick (if he returns), and NE generally like at the position... and they did pretty well with the last tall, skinny winner from Ann Arbor.
Well........that ain't happening.
He came in the combine at just under 220. And i tnink pocket presence is a plus for him too but i think he improved that abd footwork A LOT in the offseason.
I have the 1.10 in a 12 team SF PPR. Is he really worth the 1.10 if he falls to me? Or Nix if he fell?
Best QB in UM history. 27-1 record as starter is 3rd best in NCAA history.
...he'll be fine in the pros.
If I were to guess, top 3-4 QB and possible first rounder, maybe second rounder. Third round would be a steal, and the right coach (like Jim Harbaugh was to JJ) he will develop into a great NFL QB.
How do you think he would’ve faired if he was in a more qb friendly system like Caleb or JD?
I think he would probably be a guaranteed first-round selection. One of the main concerns about McCarthy across the media is that Michigan's offense ran through the run game for the second half of the year. McCarthy's got talent, he really does, and I think it would've shown more if he played in a QB-friendly system.
@@chasekellerjournalism I definitely agree with that. I think if Jim goes to Atlanta (which as a Falcons fan I am praying for) JJ goes there too whether they trade back from 8 or use the 2 second rounders to move back up and snag him at the end of the first round or even just see if he falls to round 2.
More mobile Goff with stronger arm
Lol, hell nah. I like Goff but JJ is way more consistent. There has never been a period when JJ made you doubt his abilities
@@steadyxgang he folds under pressure alot look average without presnap motion and no play action he a game manager like goff with more talent less skill than goff and higher ceilings
@@DetroitEast presnap motion does nothing for the QB. All that does is create mismatches and seperation with WR. Does nothing for the QB. maybe expose man coverage. That's it. Nothing to where it alters a QB talent or skill. Not only is he mobile, he can create something from nothing. He can throw on the run(some mobile QBs can't). And idk what you're talking about folding under pressure. One game don't define a player. Y'all just stuck in your own thinking habits.
@@steadyxgang it shows if it's man or zone presnap
@@DetroitEast that's what I said bro. And everyone does that for the same reason. NFL teams too. You're just bias
Hes a perfect fit for the broncos
A person after my heart. Love the Broncos and I think he will be there at 12
Sean peyton reportedly said to “love the guy” maybe we’ll see competition at qb next season or JJ gets to start day one🤷🏾♂️
Anyone who thinks that this kid IS NOT a top prospect is clueless. Oh he didn’t throw it a lot. But when he did throw, he was on point. Our team was a run first team, with a running game that was hard to stop. He was coached by one of the best quarterback whisper’s of all. So you young guys don’t know 💩…..
#GoBlue✊🏾💛💙
Is that a demarious Thomas photo in the background?
Yes it is!
@@chasekellerjournalism hell yah rip
Purdy was a good comparison. He could be a good manager in the right situation. If he's behind a bad oline I think he'll struggle.
Except he's BIGGER and Faster,..
He needs to sit one yr and the sky is the Limit~
Definitely alott of Brady-ish attributes~
Every QB struggles with a bad OL.
Are you gonna do a Bo Nix Report?
Friday.. 🤫
McCarthy goes through his progressions faster than any of the other first round QBs. It wouldn't surprise me if McCarthy goes in the top 15 which is a little high but QBs are often over drafted and he does have a lot of upside.
I got him slughtly behind Daniels but still graded nearly the same. Although Daniels has been more impressive Mcarthy does more things that translate to the NFL as a thrower than Daniels does. Im going to need that Spencer Rattler video bro. I think if he gets in the right situation like New Orleans and sits behind Carr for a year or two he can be groomed into a legit NFL qb.
Great analysis bro I agree with every sentiment and I honestly think McCarthy and Daniels can possibly be better then Williams and Maye at the pro level
He's going very high in this draft and may end up being the best of the lot. A few things you didn't note that NFL guys put a premium on. His qbr, completion percent & yards per completion under pressure rank 1st. He was coached to throw balls where only his receivers can catch it - look where most of his misses are. Also, his numbers didn't really change when playing better competition, while the others did. These are the things Harbaugh covets in his QB and why he thinks Mccarthy is actually the best of the bunch, when the pressure is greatest, the guy answers every time.
I tend to avoid production when making these detailed scouting reports, and I try to just give background information and then focus on the film, since film helps me determine what my positives and negatives are for that prospect.
For example, let's just say McCarthy had the highest YPC under pressure. What if a lot of that was manipulated by YAC, and #2 on the list had less YAC? The statistics help me get a head start, but the film confirms different ideas.
This is the QB the Bears should draft , nothing but a Winner wherever he has been !
Sitting a year on the giants would be amazing
I’m assuming your a broncos fan would you pick jj
JJ McCarthy would not be a bad quarterback to draft, but only if a few QBs are already off the board. With that being said, without a second-round pick I doubt it’s likely.
@@chasekellerjournalism I’d like Drake may but that’s just my preference
@@Mike-xj6pi Maye is my QB1 in this class, and while he would be amazing in Broncos Navy and Orange, he won’t fall that far nor will Denver trade up to get him.
@@chasekellerjournalism he’s a prototype qb love to see him in orange and blue
@@chasekellerjournalism broncos have the 12th pick
Always a clean pocket we don't know what he is under pressure and in the NFL he will be under tremendous pressure.
um...no, he was under pressure quite a bit - excellent at extending plays.
I was gonna say wtf is this guy talking about, JJ's pocket presence and ability to extend plays was a big factor in a lot of their wins. @@gregschulte2953
He’d look good in a Bears uniform. As a first and second year backup to Justin Fields, and then as his successor.
I agree the bears need to trade away their first pick for more picks. Grab a WR and DE and get JJ with the pick from the trade... I think he'll go early 2nd round
@@NAT-turners-Revenge Yepp,.The Bears are in a PERFECT position to have Monster draft capital for Years to come,.
But they'll fk it up and stand pat when Trading DOWN is easily the Best option for them.
One thing not being talked about enough is his age. JJ is only 20 years old. I expect that over the next year or two, sitting behind a good QB, he will put on mass. He will have to if he wants a longer career in the NFL,
Best of the best ever Michigan QB including 7up GOAT T12B
I think JJ will be grab by in the top of the 1st part of the draft four or five round
Needs to get better with some reads. Definitely missed some big plays Bc he didn’t get off his 1st or 2nd reads
He's verry YOUNG,.Just turned 21,.
He definitely should sit for half a yr but he has ALL the tools.
Could literally be the next Brady but faster,.
Just needs to be brought along slowly and not thrown in the fire~
JJ will go in the first round hopefully to Denver. Sean payton will make him a star. He can put on 10 to 15 pounds in the weight room that will help him. Another positive is he is coachable unlike Caleb.
I'm enamored with McCarthy on the Vikings. Tons of weapons and average offensive line.... Noice.
Reminds me of Matt Ryan I’m getting vibes of him
JJ to Patriots. Coach Harbaugh highly rates him
There is a lot..... I mean a lot to work with in this kid.
Game managers are not worth top 10 picks. JJ needs a good situation to succeed.
He’s not a, “Game Manager”, Cam Newton Jr….. I bet you know zero about him. Because if you did, you wouldn’t have said that B.S…. Michigan was a run team first, pass second. So he didn’t have to pass a lot. Game manager my arse….
#GoBlue✊🏾💛💙
@@jasonpeterson8 so his job was to manage the game. They were going to win primarily through the run game and his job was to make plays and not turn the ball over... as what game managers are supposed to do. Dummy you know nothing
Most of his negatives are coachable. And another of guys beef up in year two. I'm hoping Giants take him at 6.
JJ McCarthy for Commanders quarterback
His faults can be fixed by good coaching.
Seahawk
His frame???? WTH? If Bryce Young can play in the NFL, you know what…..! Never mind.
#KidsToday🤦🏾♂️
#GoBlue✊🏾💛💙
Bryce Young obviously had frame concerns coming in, and guys will still have frame concerns while he's playing. They are a bit different though.
Bryce Young stands at 5'10/204 and McCarthy is 6'3/202. Bryce Young's issues were more because of his height, but as you can see he does weigh more than McCarthy. And with McCarthy, his concerns are more for his lean frame. Being 6'3 is fine, but the average QB weighs 220-225.
@@chasekellerjournalism , sorry….. but I disagree….🤷🏾♂️ This kid learned from one of the BEST QB coaches of all-time…💯
And he was highly touted as a QB by many big time colleges…🤫
#GoBlue✊🏾💛💙
Forces throws? He had 9 turnover worthy throws in two years.
PFF says he had 24 in those two seasons, but I’m just going off what I saw on film, and I saw too many throws being forced to his first read.
Could literally be the next Brady but faster,.
Dude has ALL THE TOOLS~
Can't wait for JJ The Irishman to tear the NFL up
SKOL
Bro cooked
Yes, I know that he was a 5 star recruit and that Harbaugh has compared him to Luck, but I don't see any of that. To me, he's about the same as Dylan McCaffrey - good runner, good enough height, smart, decent arm, and understands situational football. In fact, Dylan might have beat him out had he stayed. I see JJ as a second day pick and an NFL backup. Not much zip, not many 'wow' throws, and not too many super accurate throws in tight coverage like say, Tua. To me, he's a good, smart leader with just okay talent and good legs.
super accurate throws in tight coverage like say, Tua? lmao found the Tua fanboy
Well, he bombed in the Pro Bowl QB Competition, but he led the league in yards and top 5 in completion percentage, so real world performance says he's an accurate and productive NFL QB.@@whosdatdude3570
What even is this comparison? Dylan McCaffrey is currently playing for Northern Colorado with no NFL potential.
I have no ide who this Chase Keller guy is, but it appears that anyone with a podcast is now an NFL draft expert doing "scouting reports". This kid looks like he's still in high school. It takes years to learn how to do draft analysis. Even the people who have been at it for decades get a lot of it wrong. Sorry...not buying that junior here is delivering a "scouting report" on JJ McCarthy. He needs to be doing his geometry homework instead of this.
He’s an amateur Kirk Cousins.😊
Can’t wait until he can shut the nae sayer’s up….💯
What was that whistling noise you asked?? It was just Anthony Penix draft status falling at the speed of sounds. A injury prone crybaby head case of a QB. Oh wait he may go #1 and if not the Jets will take withtheir first pick.
He only hands off the ball
Saved you 12min 50sec
He’s a bust to me
You're Trippin'~
Chances are much greater that he is the opposite of a "bust". The kid is plenty talented and has "it" by the truckloads. He is a winner for a reason.
@@mkwy8782 1000%~
We want him to stay one more year at MICHIGAN!!! 💪🏈💙🫶💙