This tao priest views very diplomatic. That is not unusual because basic Tao principle is acceptance of all occurence as part of natural Tao. But he should have emphasized that any spirit which possessed the medium can claim to be a Mengpo and theres no way to verify. His previous video has already informed mediums that they should mediate and cultivate together with the spirit instead of acting like a problem solver for anyone else. The spirit which possess the medium can be a deity, a ghost, a fairy, a yakka, a wandering spirit. One should remember that as long as any soul isnt fully enlightened, they will seek betterment, even when they dont really know how to. With that, most of these spirits would want to gain merit through human supporters (building temples with idol worship). The easiest way is to go through a weak minded human body to communicate with the human world. Spirits would rather gain merit through "helping human" instead of through right view meditation. These spirits and mediums hold wrong idea that meditation itself cannot make merits. Which is why all these mediums always do half fucked meditation thinking they are meditating but in actual fact are just closing their eyes sweating it out to connect with whatever spirit assigned or passing by. In buddhism, christianity, islam, it is very clearly stated for human not to believe in the words of deities, spirits, ghosts. Because these unseen beings are not "enlightened", have not freed themselves from escalation or descend of realms of existence. Remember that deities, sames with ghosts and devils, all have one common thing similar to human and that is temper. The reason why Buddha Allah Jesus Confucius say "do not meddle with spirits" is simply cos spirits still have temper and human will never know when they are offended. Tao priest say mediums cannot control spirit possession of body. This is not true. While some have affinity with spirits, the possession can be sealed if the human has enough will to or seek external help. Accepting every possible phenomenon as part of Tao is what a logical, healthy, financially stable, educated person would understand of Tao religion. However, note that people who go to mediums are often those who are poor, ill health, taking to mediums as last straw to grasp before they jump off the building. Imagine that a believer of Mengpo would jump off the building after spending his last dollar on the "advice" of Mengpo which didnt work. Imagine believer number in multitudes. Would humanity then, still allow Taoist to use "tao nature" to negate and brush off deaths and misdeeds? If discernment of right or wrong works, if discernment against superstition works, ask why the world still requires of constitutional laws and recognition of orthodox religions vs cults. The "let it be" attitude of Taoists priests on mediums needs to be adjusted. Otherwise, there isnt a need to stop babies from putting things into their mouth. There isnt a need for traffic light or brakes built into cars. There isnt a need for doors to temples. Just let everything occur as they are. Another thing to look into is that the "temples" which house all these mediums, Mengpo and others, do "earn" money from the public. A lamp or a blessed note costing hundred and thousands times more than their actual material cost. Even top consultants dont earn as much. Fraud examiners and government should look into this segment of money laundering through religions. An example - The kingpin would establish temples under related party names. Ill gotten gains be then laundered through charity donation to temple. Tax is declared. Expenses to temple declared under weird ass expenses. Monies washed cleaned and goes back to kingpin. May weak minded stay away from all scammers. may there be real chivalry against evil.
You made some very good points, and there are some aspects we can discuss further: 1. We indeed need to meditate and cultivate with spirits, but it should be with our "own" spirit, which is the original spirit (元神). We do not support cultivation through any form of external spirits, as the only one who can truly have control is oneself. 2. Meditation is a method of self-cultivation and cannot bring about merits. However, these practices can foster wisdom within oneself, which in turn can assist others, thereby accruing merits. Therefore, meditation and cultivation are still necessary. 3. We often emphasize "human-centric", where any choice and decision are ultimately made by the individuals involved. No one can truly make decisions for others. Therefore, everyone should cultivate the ability to introspect and evaluate matters on their own, which is a form of cultivation. For believers, the very thought of "wanting to enter the temple to seek guidance from gods or fortune-telling" is already worthy of deep reflection. 4. Unfortunately, when people become passionately involved in something, it's almost impossible to pull them back, even with the strength of ten oxen. They only wake up to reality when they get hurt and regret their initial decision. Therefore, our promotion of orthodox Taoism firstly aims to prevent these individuals from experiencing secondary harm and to help them rebuild a correct understanding of religious beliefs. Secondly, it aims to enable those who haven't been hurt to learn the correct and verified traditions, from which they can find methods for personal growth. 5. "Commercial activities should serve religious goals". It must be a "process" rather than an end goal. What are the religious goals that the religious organizations you choose are working towards through their commercial activities? This can be one of the criteria for judgment. In the case of us, besides sustaining ourselves, our primary objective for engaging in commercial activities is to establish a "Taoist Academy Online”. We hope to change people's living conditions through knowledge and learning. 6. It is evident that you have watched the content of our videos attentively, thank you for your support.
感恩彭道長，感恩主持人的理性發言和分享🙇♀️
小女子就是此孟婆的乩身本人🥺
其實我收到的旨意是，孟婆不需要我跳童辦事，祂是希望我接令了以後能好好修行，直到有日能與祂通靈，並且借助祂的靈力來為民眾解憂～作為人鬼間的橋樑傳話，讓生者與亡者得以了結心結。
而說到降駕，每年寶誕都需要先擲筊看祂要不要來😊
坦白說我才剛剛開始，也不知道要修到何年何月才能有這個能力幫助到人...但我會嘗試努力看看🙏
常常有看無量觀的節目，讓我獲益匪淺🥰 往後還請大家多多指教，再次感謝道長以及主持人。 福生無量天尊🍀✨️
Hishiko，我相信你是一个强大的灵魂来承担现在的功课。
不要去管酸民怎么看，支持你的会继续支持你。有缘人也肯定会被你渡。
只要是劝世向善，我觉得都是在做功德。加油加油！
太極界與無極界
溝通的媒介
就是"本靈"
本靈沒修煉好
就會被識神參與
結果就會有誤差了。。
恭喜你
靈體快大成了。。
其实妳何必在意其他人怎么看跟怎么说呢？清者自清浊自自浊，网上的酸民大都吃饱撑着嘴巴痒何必跟他们一般见识.秉持着问心无愧好好做完自己的功课跟履行职责就好。相信你很快就会释然的，加油。那个吃大便的coco 就别管他了，他出名蹭热度博存在感已经不是一两天的事情了，还卖假药等等你跟这种小人计较又何苦呢，让他演猴子戏演累了就没人采他了你就别放在心上了吧。
我相信有些事是冥冥中安排好的，有些事只有當事人可以體會。別人怎麼說由他去，又不是殺人放火，也不是靠對方吃飯。面對自己天命已經很不容易了。清者自清，加油 😂🎉
加油hishiko!
我是天主教的，我教認為尊重別人的宗教是首要，而且被神明選中被降神的人都是替人間消災解難且也是導人向善，即使騙人都不是我們可以管的東西，那是天道因果的層面還是交給上天判定，因為我們人生很短暫，也人渺小，上天會給予人考驗，也會選出代言人，降神本是常有之事，如果所有人都是行騙為甚麼會有哪吒節，陰神誕，九皇誕這些盛會，只不過孟婆事件是因為那個當孟婆乩身的本來是明星而引發大眾討論，而道教的組織不承認是因為未見過，但未有齊天大聖，九皇，三太子降駕前對一般人來説其實都是跟今天的孟婆差不多，孟婆是遊走的神會降駕有甚麼稀奇？一年一度降神剛剛符合孟婆的工作時間表
我们信其他教，你们会不会视为异端
@@kennithpeng7178 不得不說天主教徒的包容性稍微強一些
@@kennithpeng7178 只要宗教導人向善便需要尊重，我們進入廟宇也會鞠躬，進屋也要叫人，這是禮貌，而且去到別人不同宗教的場合，如道教的亡者送行儀式，或拜祖仙儀式，我們雖然不會拿著香火，但也會隨其他人一起鞠躬
說得很棒👍🏻
很讚，不像有些真的很沒禮貌⋯⋯
道長講話溫柔且堅定的語氣，有點優雅地罵人的感覺🤣，希望自己也可以像道長一樣有智慧，而且充滿正能量
道長有智慧，講的有道理。不像某些人只會抨擊別人，以為自己就是真理。
善哉，無論信什麼，只要是勸人為善的都好
道長講得很實在，完全不以宗教或玄學的角度切入，而是以生活化腳踏實地的論點
拜拜本就是一種地方風俗，床母灶神、石頭公、旗魚神等等都聽過，信者信之，眾神形塑的世界觀，主要能帶給我們向善或給予心靈寄託，至於降駕不降駕，既不騙色也不騙財，勸世從善，何來神棍一說！
虽说是民俗，个人觉得乩身的发心和用心才是重点，天地有感，心正才能请正神。
👍這位 道長 講述…的 真好。客觀！正向思維！不怪力亂神。包含 主持人也 比喻的好… 因此；我們人 真的就是 管理好 自己的事情 自己的（心）心念 心靈！！才會是最重要啊！天下事 總無奇不有的……見怪不怪，對吧。感謝分享 🍎 📿
我完全get 到道長的意思～非常有意思的一個理論。謝謝
道长所言极是， 事不关己，何必执着。 佩琪， 加油！ 不管你做什么， 我们都与你同在。
道教需要人去傳承
人需要道教去故弄玄虛
只是相輔相成而生
修行千萬種，修得正果就是路
謝謝道長的說明😊说的比喻很有道理。。
不錯給我從另一個角度看東西。受教了。
100% Agree with you, thank you Master, felt relieved for Hishiko from Malaysia... ❤
雖然我是基督徒，感覺這位道長講得很實在
我也認同, 這位道長講得很實在. 我想是因為道長有站在道理的層次去看教化的現象.
各種正教都是在教化人心向善, 而各種教化其實都有共通的道理在.
明白背後的道理(呼應道長說的修煉), 自然能對教化的現象不去過度論辯.
以上是個人想法, 望不同見解者也多多包涵.
我也是基督徒，有同感！
讚！感謝道長的精闢分析。
「神鬼不可怕，可怕的是人心」
人在世上，要有自我判斷的能力。
我不會說孟婆降乩是神棍；
理由一，只是大家沒見過，
理由二，他沒有詐財騙色！
不管哪個宗教，都是勸人向善、在生活中有個心靈層面的安慰。
人有權力不信它，但也不用去批評它。
聽重點！ 道長說白了
8:48 “嘩草 孟婆都可以出來多好，那我是不是可以再製造幾個？嘩這寫動漫的材料啊 哈哈哈“
所以，每個人專注自己的修行，不隨波逐流、不瞎起鬨，才是重點。
孟婆的出現，可以分擔一下也是很好啊,還有人可以對答。對身為弟子的我來詮釋，我認為末法時期，很多 神明都熱心想要來救世，傳達 神明的精神，讓人領悟人生苦海的道理。
感謝道長分享😊
感謝道長的解析，本身靜的時候會靈動現象，謝謝道長的說明😊
感謝道長 無量觀
這位道長思想我滿認同的！
這位道長講得蠻有道理的啊
讚！ 聽道長一席話，真的開竅了
开悟了还不够，所以不关我们事了不看那些新闻（要行动），道长便有德了
謝謝 道長開示
道長吉祥，想請教一下為什麼到宮廟裡靜坐就會起來踏腳步就是所謂的靈動，但到佛寺去靜坐卻完全不會有所謂的靈動，為什麼走宮廟就容易卡到陰，走佛寺卻很少聽到卡到陰，還請道長慈悲開示，解惑。
宮廟裡大多是因人念想而有神靈或陰靈，而大多佛寺裡因佛教和佛經的教理是不念想和崇拜靈的
这道长，三观好正👍🏻
感恩道長的分享🙏
感恩道長。🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
真的，道長說的沒有錯
道长说话有智慧，吸收到❤
感恩道长讲解🙏🙏🙏
道長博學多聞啊！
句句是經典
道长四两拨千斤的解说，真的妙。
道长智言真语，真正修道者的智慧正当如此
keep low, and self cultivate . Take care always
感恩道長。主持人。說的很正確
师傅真是脑路清晰，解答我多年的疑问
喜歡道長的正觀❤❤
道長言知有理
之前以為拿香拜拜就是道教
原來裡面還有門道
謝謝道長們分享
最後的論點真的很正確👍
道长好有智慧哦。。我长知识了。感恩
這太有智慧了,真的讓我想起,如果我們可以解釋甚麼是道,就不是道了
常有常無，以觀其徼與妙
玄之又玄，衆妙之門
道長的觀念非常正確！
道長還是很明智的！👏
小小想法，因為有信念所以才有神明有傳承(不是無神，只是神的延讀不見得是神蹟)，不同的方式表達承現，信與不信還是在於人的信念與向善的心，同樣是否有神也是。孟婆的議題其實是先看到最帥乩童開始的，不論如何，如果是對人好的，不傷害他的人，為什麼不可以為什麼要說別的不好呢
5:41 说得好 深意
道長說的中肯
智慧的延伸，找出自已德性，道在其中
想听听何道长讲解关于修行的注意事项以及经文当中进行解惑传道，比如好比之前的“过往神灵莫听”就按照道长多说进行布置，等可以度善信以便更好修行，可能这方面的游览量并不高，但度人开悟得无上功德，很期待今后的频道内容，无量观。
經書要選哪一種經書來看，比較適合自己。什麼人適合看哪一種的經書，我家不適合貼念經書的那種紙，怎麼辦？
不用複雜了
感覺有所收穫的就是好書
如果您真的不知道唸什麼
可以來找我們請一本太上玄門早晚功課經
说的真好
那聲哇操，十分親民😂
太可愛了哈哈哈哈
沒有接觸過的人，就不要去批判，酸言酸語不會讓你比較好過，越鐵齒的人，就不要自己遇到…等自己遇到，看你怎麼說
现实与理想的那句最有意思。
很棒,一语道破
学到了..谢谢分享🙏🙏
大家别搞错重点了，孟婆事件是因为“直播”卖货金铜味太浓才给人批评。不是因为艺人或网红。
最近一堆網紅可以隨便請神，就覺得是裝神弄鬼了，他們是老幾
原來如此
有傳承資料是好但也會因個人領悟解讀不同有差異，但至少，有根據
正神不附體,附體非正神!
你说得很对。要问自己为什么要信？为何要去参和？要去排队？
谢谢道长，今天受教了😊🪷🙏🏻
世界這麼大，人的認知不到1%，神佛度人可以萬千種方式幫助人，只要是好是我覺得都無所謂，法無定法，太過於以自己的認知的教義來看待所有無形界的事情也是一種我執。
就像降神其實佛教也有降神的事情但他們是降護法神法藏法師也有特別回復過這種事情。
宗教潔癖本身也是一種執念
身為馬來西亞出生的我 ，真的感覺自己的國家丟臉，他門應該不知道 這些民俗，是從台灣帶入新加坡然後才帶入馬來西亞的。
民俗之所以是民俗
就是時間跨度很長
長到很多人都習以為常
所以 對錯 反而不是最重要的
我們不需要為任何狀況感到丟臉
這個道長說的很好
😂😂😂全真教道长真的一巴给马来西亚道教总会长
好事，因為馬來西亞道總不應該出來說話～
我是大马人。大马华人一部分素质很差。不尊重别人。还是道长说话有智慧。说的太对了
0:27 請問這個是甚麽音樂名字
正知正见❤
好奇什麼是跑靈山😅
你相信有就有，没有就没有。 不要伤害别人。神像是人通过想像或梦里 刻画出来的 要不然为什么每尊佛像都不一样呢
不好意思据我所知孟婆上来是有的，因我曾经有清眼见过。但是不跟这位网红孟婆上身的情况一样，因真正的孟婆上来是会一直哭泣的而且不能有光线，旁边会有一桶水而且水里的水温会较高而且还会有旋涡，可是这次的孟婆😅，我认为这次不是请到孟婆上来，而是好兄弟。不好意思我是实话实说，懂的人因该明白这就是事实，不知道的人需要多些请教专业人士。因她还没准备好就让她下场，也看出很多破绽真的害了这位网红，也导致很多人开始对于道教另种看法，所以最后要说的是(回头是岸)
是孟婆的分靈，也就是說孟婆是真神，分靈就是修煉孟婆能量的，真神不會降駕，正神可以降駕，就像很多三太子的分靈、還有觀音的分靈來降駕的意思是一樣的~祂們都是是修煉的精神跟能量的
完全赞同你所说的。很多人只是看到眼前或经历表面上的认识的一面。认为事件就是这样，刻板印象！其实最好还是要深入的去探讨灵界的复杂性。其实神明菩萨都是有很多分身灵，他们可能一直都在他们本身的维度里，根本没来过人类维度，但是他们可以通过他们的分灵来到此地。但是很多人都不知道。只要你做的事情是发自内心想要帮助别人的，即使不是正神，他也是以慈悲心来救济他人的。很多菩萨神明也不就是从人开始升格的吗？灵界的复杂性是我们一般人类无法可以去理解的。@@chantedv1114
其實，大部分的人比較不太懂分靈的概念，若用世俗的情景解說，警察署長就只有那一位，各地區警察就是身負這樣警務的成員，警察培育過程就是經歷考試資格（在世為人時，功過相抵，其德仍有達到標）確認是否能進入警察學校接受專長訓練，再依分數（修習與悟性）發派到各地（各地方宮廟擔任主神，或副駕）維持秩序，協助解答與指引當地百姓生活問題而指點迷津的，警察（如神明聖號）這個職稱的分身，各地方廟宇的神明便是如此，雖一樣稱警察，卻是用地方名稱區分是哪裡的警察，更各有其本身擅長的領域，更是代表其職務的精神
他們好兄弟都當分靈
这些东西不接触比较好，反正对人生没有帮助，对修行人更没帮助。
還有我創立了捻道灰派 連元始靈寶的徒弟都會擔心
總歸就是 一切無關其它，只在於自己的心境
万法由心照 时代变了 日新月异
不知道 不代表 没有
很多事情 是灵活的 不是死的啦
信就信 不信就无视 不信请尊重 而不是恶言酸语 修行人存好心 说好话 做好事
其实不管怎样 尊重最重要吧，信不信由你 但是请尊重
反而我不觉得是孟婆关系，我觉得是之前人与人的关系引起，当一起人家的事，若你越去注意它，表示下来人家就会关注你。
人家若有私人问题，我们不去理会他人的私事，未来你做自己的事，就不会回向因果效应。
讲明一点
若阿A在外有女人，你看不爽，就在评论大骂，直到后来，骂阿A的网民，自己一天也在网上放自己的视频时，请问阿A看到了，会不会反击你？肯定啊！
只要我们不事先针对人，人家就不会反应你。
只要是引人向善的管他是假的還是真的
做好自己就好
你的逻辑思维-管它是大便还不是小便，吃了再说。
應該是說，真假沒有意義
取其精華，去其糟粕
互通有無，為我所用
@@reborn5583是引人往正向的就好，正念ok
@@starsup3031 搞线上Facebook live点灯收费,正统的庙是在神明坛前点灯写名。何时神明开始用Facebook live。 🤣🤣🤣.其中一名美女乩童退驾后卖买开光福物。老黄卖瓜自卖自夸。这是拿民间信仰来赚钱。
精辟，谢分享😊
道长易理好厉害
思考一下啦，他上来干嘛，上来煮汤给人喝吗？还是教人煮汤 ?
你都不知头不知尾 去看她的影片 了解了再来讲煮汤
如何領悟修行全在個人
谢谢分享
道长有智慧
道长教诲👍🏻
有智慧
心正就好。金丹，舍粒同根生，佛道本来是一家
This tao priest views very diplomatic. That is not unusual because basic Tao principle is acceptance of all occurence as part of natural Tao. But he should have emphasized that any spirit which possessed the medium can claim to be a Mengpo and theres no way to verify. His previous video has already informed mediums that they should mediate and cultivate together with the spirit instead of acting like a problem solver for anyone else.
The spirit which possess the medium can be a deity, a ghost, a fairy, a yakka, a wandering spirit. One should remember that as long as any soul isnt fully enlightened, they will seek betterment, even when they dont really know how to. With that, most of these spirits would want to gain merit through human supporters (building temples with idol worship). The easiest way is to go through a weak minded human body to communicate with the human world.
Spirits would rather gain merit through "helping human" instead of through right view meditation. These spirits and mediums hold wrong idea that meditation itself cannot make merits. Which is why all these mediums always do half fucked meditation thinking they are meditating but in actual fact are just closing their eyes sweating it out to connect with whatever spirit assigned or passing by.
In buddhism, christianity, islam, it is very clearly stated for human not to believe in the words of deities, spirits, ghosts. Because these unseen beings are not "enlightened", have not freed themselves from escalation or descend of realms of existence. Remember that deities, sames with ghosts and devils, all have one common thing similar to human and that is temper. The reason why Buddha Allah Jesus Confucius say "do not meddle with spirits" is simply cos spirits still have temper and human will never know when they are offended.
Tao priest say mediums cannot control spirit possession of body. This is not true. While some have affinity with spirits, the possession can be sealed if the human has enough will to or seek external help.
Accepting every possible phenomenon as part of Tao is what a logical, healthy, financially stable, educated person would understand of Tao religion. However, note that people who go to mediums are often those who are poor, ill health, taking to mediums as last straw to grasp before they jump off the building.
Imagine that a believer of Mengpo would jump off the building after spending his last dollar on the "advice" of Mengpo which didnt work. Imagine believer number in multitudes. Would humanity then, still allow Taoist to use "tao nature" to negate and brush off deaths and misdeeds?
If discernment of right or wrong works, if discernment against superstition works, ask why the world still requires of constitutional laws and recognition of orthodox religions vs cults. The "let it be" attitude of Taoists priests on mediums needs to be adjusted. Otherwise, there isnt a need to stop babies from putting things into their mouth. There isnt a need for traffic light or brakes built into cars. There isnt a need for doors to temples. Just let everything occur as they are.
Another thing to look into is that the "temples" which house all these mediums, Mengpo and others, do "earn" money from the public. A lamp or a blessed note costing hundred and thousands times more than their actual material cost. Even top consultants dont earn as much. Fraud examiners and government should look into this segment of money laundering through religions.
An example - The kingpin would establish temples under related party names. Ill gotten gains be then laundered through charity donation to temple. Tax is declared. Expenses to temple declared under weird ass expenses. Monies washed cleaned and goes back to kingpin.
May weak minded stay away from all scammers. may there be real chivalry against evil.
You made some very good points, and there are some aspects we can discuss further:
1. We indeed need to meditate and cultivate with spirits, but it should be with our "own" spirit, which is the original spirit (元神). We do not support cultivation through any form of external spirits, as the only one who can truly have control is oneself.
2. Meditation is a method of self-cultivation and cannot bring about merits. However, these practices can foster wisdom within oneself, which in turn can assist others, thereby accruing merits. Therefore, meditation and cultivation are still necessary.
3. We often emphasize "human-centric", where any choice and decision are ultimately made by the individuals involved. No one can truly make decisions for others. Therefore, everyone should cultivate the ability to introspect and evaluate matters on their own, which is a form of cultivation. For believers, the very thought of "wanting to enter the temple to seek guidance from gods or fortune-telling" is already worthy of deep reflection.
4. Unfortunately, when people become passionately involved in something, it's almost impossible to pull them back, even with the strength of ten oxen. They only wake up to reality when they get hurt and regret their initial decision. Therefore, our promotion of orthodox Taoism firstly aims to prevent these individuals from experiencing secondary harm and to help them rebuild a correct understanding of religious beliefs. Secondly, it aims to enable those who haven't been hurt to learn the correct and verified traditions, from which they can find methods for personal growth.
5. "Commercial activities should serve religious goals". It must be a "process" rather than an end goal. What are the religious goals that the religious organizations you choose are working towards through their commercial activities? This can be one of the criteria for judgment. In the case of us, besides sustaining ourselves, our primary objective for engaging in commercial activities is to establish a "Taoist Academy Online”. We hope to change people's living conditions through knowledge and learning.
6. It is evident that you have watched the content of our videos attentively, thank you for your support.
言之有理, make sense
福生无量天尊
我需要孟婆湯配方！
我也需要😆
想要好睡一覺嗎？也可
哈哈哈，说的对，表演系不一样,对，为什么要围观，道长说的对，人嘛一多人就会很多人围观😂
道长你要知道她不是艺人，她只不过是区区一个youtuber而已，道长真聪明把话兜一个圈😂😂😂
他当纹身师和UA-camr之前是马来西亚艺人哦
@@angamanda3615 就是以前在演艺圈呆不下去啊，因为很多同行都对她很有意见
若见是相非相即见如来
如来者無所从来亦無所去
無为自然而自在無住故说是道即是非道故名是道。
🌞🌏♣️善哉
赞同道长说的，觉得如果是nobody又不是以盈利为主是不会有人去管那么多的
馬來西亞那位就是賺流量有盈利阿😂😂😂
只要導人向善，傳播正能量，不鼓吹迷信，為何不可呢？
套用
禪宗二祖 一言
慧可大師: 干你何事