Stihl BG 86C Vs Husqvarna 525BX Blowers. And The Winner is !! ( Part 2 )

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 106

  • @joshuabush2569
    @joshuabush2569 2 роки тому +7

    Having used both I can say that the husky is definitely more powerful, lighter and less vibration. Also the fact that the blower tube is centered makes it so much better.

  • @maxwellsgrasscuttingservices
    @maxwellsgrasscuttingservices 5 років тому +13

    Just starting up a grass cutting business in the North East of England, I was about to buy the Stihl, your video has changed my mind. The best reviews on you tube. Thank you and I look forward to more good stuff coming from you.

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  4 роки тому +2

      Hi Rob W. Many thanks for these nice comments. Cheers Calvin

    • @AlejandroP1980s
      @AlejandroP1980s 4 роки тому

      @@CalvinThomas05 what about echo vs husqvarna also for lawn mower tractor with ac

  • @savmarjanac1627
    @savmarjanac1627 4 роки тому +14

    Not a fair comparison, you weren't swinging the stihl as much as the husqvarna. And I would by the stihl over the husqvarna any day of the week.

  • @deang.7483
    @deang.7483 3 роки тому +4

    Great vid ! Got a 525 already. 4 years of daily use. Still going strong & starts like a dream. Love Stihl gear too but thanks for pointing out the pull to the side on the BG. Was tempted by the price diff on the Sthil but will definitely go a 2nd Husky. Keep up the good work !

  • @Catubrannos
    @Catubrannos 4 роки тому +19

    Do you realise you're swinging your left hand more? It would be better to do them separately using your dominant hand each time.

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  4 роки тому +3

      Hi Catubrannos. Sorry I didn't realise that when I was doing the video. I just thought a side by side comparison would show the power difference between them. Cheers, Calvin

    • @ctbt1832
      @ctbt1832 4 роки тому +1

      I was just about to type the exact same thing. If anything why don’t you just hold one blower at a time and walk straight through a pile of leaves with the blower it at the same height at separate times without swinging

    • @jesseryan4053
      @jesseryan4053 3 роки тому +1

      @@CalvinThomas05 can always tell when someone is a class act when they respond like this to comments. Some UA-cam creators berate people over the slightest criticism lol.

  • @caerleon87
    @caerleon87 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks for your review, Went out and bought a Husqvarna 525BX today. Very pleased with it, plenty of power, not too heavy, no torque reaction twisting it in your hand, very little vibration and surprisingly quiet. Very nice machine that i am well pleased with!!

    • @roadwarrior8560
      @roadwarrior8560 2 роки тому

      do you find it takes a while to build up pressure? takes mine maybe 3 or 4 mins sometimes before there's any blowing force from it.

  • @SupremeTycoon
    @SupremeTycoon 4 роки тому +12

    The husqvarna might have a little bit more power but it's a lot more expensive. The husqvarna equivalent of the bg 86 would be the 125BV not the 525BX. You did a great job keeping the test fair, but given the stihl held up ok against a much more expensive rival, I'm gonna go and buy the stihl.

    • @jackt6112
      @jackt6112 4 роки тому +5

      They are about the same price and both have a 2-year warranty. You can't sell a STIHL product without being able to do service on it, including warranty service. Husqvarna you can buy on Amazon. Husqvarna is a popular brand, nice name, and may have servicing dealers in your area. But can you get warranty service for a leaf blower locally? If you want to do your own repairs and buy parts from eBay, then either brand will work. With the STIHL BG 86 C-E you have the easy start and simplified controls. It appears from his test to knock over the jug, the Husqvarna 525BX has slightly more or at least more narrowly directed force. However, in his other tests, he clearly swung the Husqvarna 525BX more widely than he did the STIHL, so those tests were unusable.

  • @FantaLilt
    @FantaLilt 4 роки тому +6

    Stihl will always hold value much better. I only buy Stihl so if and when I need to sell them on it’s always quick n easy. But that’s just my opinion :)

    • @jp-us9rq
      @jp-us9rq 3 роки тому

      I bought a chainsaw weedeater and a blower about 7 months ago seems like when I use them and take a break go to start them their hard to start.but when they work their great now my huskey starts up in a couple pulls no matter what cold hot dont matter.nothing against stihl i think I'm gona try a different oil mix see if that makes a difference

  • @paulf2529
    @paulf2529 5 років тому +3

    Calvin, this is a blindingly good test. As you noticed from my reply to your first video, I totally agree with you.
    Personally I've found the same thing with the back pack blowers, husqvarna have the advantage, more power, better on fuel and no recoil on the wrist.
    The stihl machines will do the work but once you try the husqvarna you realise that one does the job better.
    I think it's the other way around with brush cutters mind there is a stihl fs410 in my van not a husquvarna 545rx.

  • @anthonywilliamson7323
    @anthonywilliamson7323 4 роки тому +6

    Just bought the husqvarna after watching your video 👍

    • @bossmoney3855
      @bossmoney3855 3 роки тому

      Did it work for you or wast it wrong buy

  • @Corvette1658
    @Corvette1658 6 місяців тому +1

    For me it still the STIHL because I just love STIHLs I been buying them for 10 years now. My first one was a BR350 backpack blower I got in June of 2014. Then a year later in July of 2015 I got a FS56 RC trimmer. Then in August of 2019 I sold both of them to my buddy before my big move from IL to SC. Then in October of 2019 I got a STIHL BGA57 battery power blower. Then two years ago I got a STIHL RMA 510 V battery power mower. And a FSA 60 R battery trimmer for my sister house. Then 4 months ago I got a STIHL BG86C for Christmas. Because as much I did liked the BGA57 I wanted to upgrade to something more powerful. Because not only I blow my house. But I also blow one of my neighbors house because she is in her 80s and her husband died 2 years ago. So I been helping her out with blowing her driveway plus her driveway is bigger and longer then my driveway is. Plus my BGA57 was a little underpowered especially when it came to big leafs and tree sticks. Plus my sister needed a blower for her house so I did give her the BGA57. So I have a total of 4 STIHL equipment including the 3 that are at my sister house.

  • @carlpaidra6123
    @carlpaidra6123 4 роки тому +8

    Australian pricing
    Husky 525 bx $549
    Stihl bg 86 $379

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  4 роки тому +2

      Hi Carl. Wow that's strange why the husky is so expensive over there. They are about the same money over here. Cheers, Calvin

  • @roadwarrior8560
    @roadwarrior8560 5 років тому +6

    Brilliant job Calvin, I fancied the husky anyway on price.

  • @callumfreeman1128
    @callumfreeman1128 5 років тому +4

    What about the leaf mulcher for the blower can you do a review on them please

  • @jackiewatson5665
    @jackiewatson5665 4 роки тому +1

    Thank you for taking the time to do this video. Run a gardening business and have had a husky, Honda and Stihl blowers. My stihl just packed in so I’m going back to husky. Thanks! 👍

    • @jameswyeth8223
      @jameswyeth8223 4 роки тому

      Hi Jackie, i'm thinking of buying the honda 4 stroke hand held blower is the power ok ?

  • @tgsgardenmaintenance4627
    @tgsgardenmaintenance4627 5 років тому +2

    Stihl backpackers are the dogs but in my experience the handhelds are not convincing! Saying that, the 86 vac is outstanding!

  • @carlpaidra6123
    @carlpaidra6123 4 роки тому +5

    Nice video you went all the way with testing much appreciation.
    My lawn and garden business use both. We upgraded to the Stihl bg 86 because of build quality and reliability. Plus it revs lower and quieter which is good on some jobs and it uses less fuel then the husky.
    Maintenance is easier and cleaning filters is less and they last longer.
    Plus the bg86 has gutter attachements and vac with shredder.
    Tomorrow im going to look at the fan difference (turbine) and quality you never showed that.
    I like my husky, but love my stihl and im really trying not to support china as much as possible from now on.
    Damn china.

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  4 роки тому

      Hi Carl. Thanks for the comments. Yes I see what you mean with the build quality and the points you say ( yes you are right ) But I feel the Stihl is trying to twist my wrist all the time other than that I would defiantly have the Stihl over the Husqvarna but until Stihl sort out that problem its not for me. Yes I'm sorry I missed the turbine bit. It is hard to say but I have some good stuff from china lol. Cheers, Calvin

  • @6548ww
    @6548ww 4 роки тому +3

    WoW I’m very impressed with the Husqvarna Blower 👍

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  4 роки тому +1

      Hi Walter. Yes I really think the Husqvarna is a good blower. Cheers, Calvin

  • @DunningsMillLawnCare
    @DunningsMillLawnCare 5 років тому +2

    Brilliant video, I have the Chinese Parker handheld leaf blower and the stihl bg56c and although the stihl has less vibrations the parker is more powerful, parker only cost me £90 and stihl cost £125. Brilliant machines!

    • @joshuabush2569
      @joshuabush2569 2 роки тому

      I had the Parker... Vibration was horrible.

  • @tgsgardenmaintenance4627
    @tgsgardenmaintenance4627 4 роки тому +3

    Bought the Husky 525BX and it wins hands down!!

  • @daleconklin5158
    @daleconklin5158 4 роки тому +4

    I really appreciate your review. However I decided to go with the Stihl. My best friend is a manager at an ace hardware store in NY. He said every timr somone brings a husky blower in for repair the technician groans and isnt too happy. However when a stihl blower comes in hes happy as apparently hey are much easier to repair.

  • @rusosure7
    @rusosure7 3 роки тому +2

    I love how that when he was done with the Stihl, he'd fire up the Husky with one pull.

  • @lovelawns
    @lovelawns 4 роки тому +3

    Hi mate, good side by side comparison thanks for sharing your thoughts. We use both in our business too and definitely agree with your findings here and always notice the Stihl trying to turn to the right in use especially after using the Husky. Great video 👍🏻

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  4 роки тому +1

      Hi Lovelawns. Many thanks for the comments. All the best, Calvin

  • @jacobditmer1369
    @jacobditmer1369 4 роки тому +5

    I prefer Stihl

  • @TheFullyChargedGardener
    @TheFullyChargedGardener 4 роки тому

    I use a battery leaf blower for most of our blowing work. The battery kit is fantastic for doing the work a Petrol handheld would do. Another great video chap 👍🏻

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  4 роки тому +1

      Hi. The Fully Charged Gardener. Many thanks for the comments. Yes I will get a cordless blower in the future. I'm really impressed with the cordless stuff. Cheers Calvin

  • @paulbugden8573
    @paulbugden8573 5 років тому +4

    good one calvin that's why I have a husky

  • @Pyridox
    @Pyridox 5 років тому +2

    I think you are right, the Husqvarna looks like a better balanced machine.

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  5 років тому

      Hi Pete. Yes I got to be honest I rally liked the Husqvarna. Cheers Calvin

  • @petermahoney636
    @petermahoney636 3 роки тому +2

    And Calvin wiith husky blowers . The big end bearings always are the first to drop there guts first .My bg86c is getting tired the rings are showing wear .New rings chucked in and she will be like a cut snake again the bg86c is the better blower over time with abuse mate hope your good no Chinese flu God bless you Pete Australia 👍

  • @tgsgardenmaintenance4627
    @tgsgardenmaintenance4627 4 роки тому +1

    I decided on the 525BX and I don't regret it for one second! Being good on paper is one thing, but being good in the field is something else!

    • @AlejandroP1980s
      @AlejandroP1980s 4 роки тому

      What about echo

    • @tgsgardenmaintenance4627
      @tgsgardenmaintenance4627 4 роки тому

      @@AlejandroP1980s what about Echo?

    • @tgsgardenmaintenance4627
      @tgsgardenmaintenance4627 4 роки тому

      @@AlejandroP1980s used many blowers over many years and think I've found the perfect combo, 525BX and a 580BTS!

    • @joshuabush2569
      @joshuabush2569 2 роки тому

      @@AlejandroP1980s I like Echo but they have really bad vibration... I recently brought the HC-2020 hedge trimmer and I ended up selling it because the vibration was really horrible. Husqvarna are really good at creating user-friendly, low vibration comfortable machinery I find.

  • @huraganbielany
    @huraganbielany 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks Calvin, i've watched your comparison between them both. Till today i was an owner of same stihl BG86C, unfortunately after 3,5 years of intensively gardening working the engine seized. But this time im going to make a switch and buy husqvarna. Your testing was very helpful to making the right decision.

  • @jaldeborgh
    @jaldeborgh 2 роки тому

    Excellent semi-quantitative review. I think both are quality tools so I’m not sure there is a wrong choice. I have both Husqvarna and Stihl products and would recommend both brands, in my mind it would come down to price and customer service.

  • @davt8615
    @davt8615 4 роки тому +1

    525bx is a beast mate, I've got the little 125b aswell as a backup was a fair few complaints about that and i cant see why mines into its 4th season and never missed a beat. Good content as always 👍

    • @alias-_unknown9999
      @alias-_unknown9999 4 роки тому +1

      @DavT hi mate I’m just about to purchase one of the three, I just wanted to know what you reckon between the 125b and the stihl? I know the 525bx is the champion but wanted to know if there’s a huge different between the 125b and the stihl?

    • @davt8615
      @davt8615 4 роки тому

      @@alias-_unknown9999 hey mate if its only going to get light use the 125b is a cracking little machine really light weight and well priced, has plenty of power. For work I'd get the stihl will take more punishment. Cheers.

  • @ParkersGardens
    @ParkersGardens 4 роки тому +3

    Really enjoyed your 2 part review. I have the Husqvarna backpack blower, the 570BTS, and it's cracking, absolutely love it. However I also have the handheld one you review here, the 525BX, and it's honestly been the worst handheld blower i've had in 10 years of being a gardener. Nightmare to start, takes all day pretty much to be able to use on full power, loads of stuff gone wrong with it and I only got it in March 2019. Next season i'll be going back to the BG86 which was far superior in my own experience. Keep up the great videos 👍

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  4 роки тому +1

      Hi Too Orangey For Crows. Many thanks for the comments. I'm Glad you enjoyed this review. That's bad news about the husky blower. I did like the build quality of the Stihl. It was just the twist of the wrist I didn't like. Cheers Calvin

  • @bigtexas7580
    @bigtexas7580 4 роки тому +3

    *On my stihl bg85 I ported the head and swapped the muffler out with an expansion chamber pipe like the ones used on dirtbikes and now this blower is very powerful and revs so smooth and crisp. It's stronger than the bg86 and every other handheld blower I've used and I find myself not having to pull out my backpack blower as much since I did the work on my bg85.*

  • @COC785
    @COC785 4 роки тому +2

    I had both of these and got tired of swinging them. I got smart and bought a Redmax EBZ8500 to replace them.

    • @friel71186
      @friel71186 3 роки тому

      I use to be Redmax 8500 guy myself until my girl got me the echo 8010t for Christmas and it blows my Redmax away

  • @thomasmccullagh8282
    @thomasmccullagh8282 4 роки тому

    Nice review Calvin, unfortunately I went for the stihl blower bought it the other week, I am still very pleased with it and is a decent bit of kit for my landscape business. But after seeing yr review I wish I waited and got the husqvarna. But will stick with what I have for now so still happy. Can always look at whats on offer next season.

  • @garrylarose1506
    @garrylarose1506 3 роки тому

    does the husky come with the flat end nozzle too? i imagine that would increase the velocity enormously for the stihl. because im pretty sure the stihl comes with the flat nozzle too

  • @jackt6112
    @jackt6112 4 роки тому +3

    We already saw the quality and design advantages of the STIHL in Part 1. I find it interesting that it is essentially a draw, and the Husqvarna costs $100 / 36% more. Now let's compare the STIHL BR 430, within $20, with the Husqvarna 525BX. Or compare the STIHL BG 86 C-E with the Husqvarna 125B since they are the same price. Either way, the STIHLs are far and away better performance and quality values.

  • @IfYouGiveUpYouLose
    @IfYouGiveUpYouLose 4 роки тому +1

    Very interesting and practical comparison! The last part that showed the tork of the machines was an eye opener for me. Makes perfect sense that it'd put stress on your wrist. I've got a Tanaka leaf blower now and I'm going to go give it your tork test. I'm looking at a Husqvarna 125BVX because I need the vacuum/mulcher. Excellent video. Thanks.

  • @andrewhills6535
    @andrewhills6535 3 роки тому +2

    Thanks Calvin , buying a Husky , Andrew in Brecon 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  3 роки тому +1

      Hi Andrew, Yes I'm with the husky all the way, Cheers, Calvin

  • @omaxman1
    @omaxman1 4 роки тому

    Thanks for the video... I was debating between these 2 and came across this review. 👍

  • @jonathanfierberg3807
    @jonathanfierberg3807 2 роки тому +1

    The build quality of stihl is unmatched

    • @joshuabush2569
      @joshuabush2569 2 роки тому

      older stuff was better... The quality of their plastic has degraded over the years.

  • @houghtongardenservices4362
    @houghtongardenservices4362 5 років тому +3

    Good review Calvin👍

  • @pawebb
    @pawebb 2 роки тому +1

    On the can knock over test you held the H still and with the S you wiggled it back and forth.

  • @tgsgardenmaintenance4627
    @tgsgardenmaintenance4627 4 роки тому +1

    I have the Stihl SH86C-E, it's a great vac but a bit gutless as a blower! My Makita hand held is far superior, thinking about getting a 125BVX. For big jobs, nothing beats a 580 Bts!

    • @jameswyeth8223
      @jameswyeth8223 4 роки тому

      Hi Trevor, is your Makita 4 stroke ? thinking of getting the honda 4 stroke just wondered about the power compared to 2 stroke ?

  • @JWNLawnCare
    @JWNLawnCare 5 років тому +2

    Interesting that your BG86 sounds a lot lower pitch than mine. Yours sounds like the smaller BG56 whereas my one is a bit higher pitched. Maybe emissions stuff has messed with how many revs they can give em?

    • @johnwalt3504
      @johnwalt3504 5 років тому

      probably still needs to break in

  • @yvonnemeredith4437
    @yvonnemeredith4437 5 років тому +1

    Great video Calvin. My choice aswell 😎🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

    • @CalvinThomas05
      @CalvinThomas05  5 років тому

      Thanks Yvonne. Yes I Really liked the Husqvarna lol. Cheers Calvin

  • @bluememory4359
    @bluememory4359 4 роки тому +1

    A picture speaks a thousand words

  • @exmoorfarmer4880
    @exmoorfarmer4880 4 роки тому +1

    Great review thank you very much. Husky it is then.

  • @jp-us9rq
    @jp-us9rq 3 роки тому +1

    im not crazy about my stihl machines i bought a husky and i really like it a lot better

  • @bumpkinrocks
    @bumpkinrocks 5 років тому +2

    I've got bg86's and even with moderate use they're uncomfortable, hadn't realised why but you made it obvious👍. Stihl obviously isn't bothered. Normally hold then base with left hand to stop it.
    I bet a fair chunk of that Stihl is made in China as well if not all!
    Maybe Husqvarna for me next then, love their saws😉

    • @johnwalt3504
      @johnwalt3504 5 років тому +2

      the stihl is made in usa the husqvarna in made in china

    • @joshuabush2569
      @joshuabush2569 2 роки тому

      @@johnwalt3504 Stihl are made in lots of different places...

  • @aucti0nman
    @aucti0nman 4 роки тому

    Thanks for this - helped a lot

  • @adsb4187
    @adsb4187 5 років тому +2

    Thanks for a good video really appreciate it!
    Husky might well have more power. But honestly I have used that stihl blower for years on my firm. And it isnt exactly well looked after. It always works no matter the abuse. Ones been ran over another fell of the back of a tipper van.
    Stihl in my opinion cant be beaten on durability and toughness. It just keeps working. That husky Im pretty sure is of a cheaper build quality. I know they are equally good if it sensibly used and maintained but things do go wrong and honestly first hand experience the stihl will survive anything! You will just have a bad wrist and lower bank balance!! But its worth it.
    But if leaves are your game, your better of with a backpack blower. Hand helds better for clearing up grass or hedge trimmings etc.

    • @JamesMcl
      @JamesMcl 5 років тому +1

      Ads B absolutly spot on. We use stihl and the build quality is so much tougher. The husqs just didnt last the duration compared to the stihls we had. Also like you said, use back packs for leaves. We only use hand helds for grass cuttings.

    • @paulf2529
      @paulf2529 5 років тому +1

      I found the opposite, my bg86 became a pain to start taking a lit of pills, also the engine cut off cable runs through due to poor design unless they have changed it.
      I got rid of my machine, a fluke perhaps but a estate machine that was purchased this year now has similar issues.
      So I found them irritating starters, low powered and uncomfortable to use.
      At under £300 I don't keep mine for years on end but I do want trouble free use and a comfortable powerful machine.

    • @adsb4187
      @adsb4187 5 років тому +2

      @@paulf2529 what blower are you using now?

  • @bigjohn9536
    @bigjohn9536 3 роки тому +1

    not really a good comparison..its comparing a dodge dually to a Ford ranger

  • @Валерий-м2ц4у
    @Валерий-м2ц4у 3 роки тому +1

    Привет чувак! Спасибо

  • @claudionarcis1
    @claudionarcis1 7 місяців тому +1

    you are fan Husqvarna !

  • @beefcakes27
    @beefcakes27 3 роки тому +1

    You would need to trade hands and repeat to eliminate your technique as a factor... Do it all over again..!!!!! lol

  • @cookiemonster3979
    @cookiemonster3979 2 роки тому +1

    i would say dont do a review on two products if they are not done fairly

  • @vette9305
    @vette9305 4 роки тому +1

    Stihl

  • @osman1129
    @osman1129 Рік тому

    top

  • @alexmatthews2332
    @alexmatthews2332 2 роки тому

    After a little under a year of use I really don't like my stihl. It runs like crap compared to my echo that started in 2 pulls for about 7 years of constant use never did anything wrong until the coil went out. I could've and should've fixed it. The stihl pulls hard to start and almost never restart with one pull. The performance is lacking and really just isn't that good of a blower besides the anti vibe that the echo didn't have.

  • @cookiemonster3979
    @cookiemonster3979 2 роки тому

    you weren't swinging the stihl as much as the husqvarna

  • @coreyjohnson660
    @coreyjohnson660 4 роки тому +1

    Clearly bias

  • @lynellemolzan7863
    @lynellemolzan7863 4 роки тому

    its got more blow to it haha