In Defence of Resolution - Doctor Who
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 вер 2024
- We've only got a few episodes left of the Chibnall era of Doctor Who with Jodie Whittaker in the title role, the most airing being the third in the Chibnall Dalek trilogy. You guys voted 'Eve of the Daleks' as the best of the three on my community tab, but I'm thinking the first in this three-part saga takes the top spot.
#DoctorWho #Resolution #Daleks
Check out Amy and I's NuWho rewatch podcast here:
anchor.fm/kaste...
The editing choices in this vid were amazing btw, very digestible format of text clips and animations, good work rich
Glad you enjoyed it!
It’s funny that in a few years the young adult companion will have the perfectly acceptable reason to not know about stolen earth dalek events: they might not have been born yet
really hit the nail on the head as to why Resolution is one of the stronger doctor who stories for the whole series
I really love the concept of a lone dalek just wrecking sh*t up and being resourceful its a shame the dalek wasn't kept alive for a future episode or make it a recurring antagonist which I want to see in doctor who
You made a good case, Rich. In retrospect, there's far more 'Dalek' about Resolution than Eve.
Love the new visual animation style Rich!
Couldn't agree more - first chibnall story I actually enjoyed
Narratively I think _Resolution_ is fine. I’d have changed little about it (except the primary cast).
Edit - yeah, I agree that the Daleks’ affinity for ultraviolet light was initially badly portrayed (though it’s a good idea). The teleport concept was not well portrayed either and I found it confusing upon first viewing, not least of all because it felt unnecessary.
I’m missing your content. I hope you make vids more often when Who comes back. I really enjoy your take on the show.
I'm so loving this new format for the video. So much fun! More please! :D
Excellent video! I totally agree with your points on why resolution is actually a good episode
Yes, I've been waiting for this video since you promised it in... whichever video it was you promised it in :D
I do quite like this episode, it's one of my favourite from the last 3 seasons. But that might be because of Charlotte Ritchie more than anything...
Saying something is the 'best of Chibnall' is like saying that was the 'best' migraine I've ever had.
Yeah yeah, you're super edgy, we get it. Chibnall's Doctor Who is fine - it's just different to the previous show runner. Anyone who has watched it for a while should be used to Doctor Who changing.
@@MichaelJohnson-kq7qg We are used to Dr. Who, that's the problem. Don't pretend you like it.
@@allenrhys844 don't be silly.
@@MichaelJohnson-kq7qg Aha - you're really not a fan of the show are you?
I know...I've watched since the 70's here in the states. I just don't believe you can be a fan of what came before, and then of this without there being more to it. Don't dignify this Chibnall mess....ua-cam.com/video/PNwwK-pIy2M/v-deo.html
Here's where I stand with the Chibnall era. My hatred for Series 11 and 12 in terms of heat equivalency would be 100 stars going full supernovae right next to each other. I hated Resolution. I love Series 13. I love Jodie's, John's, and even Mandip's performances. I also love Revolution and Eve of the Daleks and the Sea Devils Specials.
I'd be so up for a new Dalek civil war. Would've been a lot more interesting than the Dalek civil disagreement we got for five minutes in Revolution
i like your 8 bit character, super cute. good essay Rich, take care and see you next time
could'nt agree with you more
I really enjoyed this episode. Never understood why it got so much hate.
Nice video.
What's with the avatar? Looks like a XS Spectrum generated video game graphic of the lead character from the 1978 dubbed TV series Monkey! 😂👍
Good to 'hear you' are back 👍
Yes to the animation! Cracking video.
Chibnal's dalek trilogy has been fun, but a part of me wishes Eve had some connection to the previous 2, so it continued the narrative.
Agree on the Daleks
Resolution should of been called resolution of the Daleks.. there I said it
Strong concept but with a naff pay-off is Chibnall to a fault! The reason why this is so far behind Eve is purely due to that pointless Ryan/Ryan's dad storyline, and the fact that the poor, old Skarosian (great word, btw!) was defeated by a bloody microwave. As you said; great set-up with a sadly ridiculous ending. LOTSD does look promising, though.... Two to go!
I enjoyed Eve of the Daleks better. I tend to like anything that Aisling Bea is in though, tbf. Would’ve like her to have stayed for a while.
Aside from her, I still enjoyed it. The Daleks are over-done at this point. They were stale before Chibs took over. They’re lazy villains.
The first Dalek episode (w/Eccleston) was superb and this reminded me of that, even though there were more than one. It was small and intimate.
The Time War was supposed to have taken the Daleks and Timelords out of the equation. One or two Timelords being around is ok and makes sense - not everyone would’ve been at the war. But the Daleks seem to still be everywhere. Despite the explanations as to how they got there it always seemed, well, stupid. The Time War clearly didn’t take them all out, there have been millions of them since the war.
They’re just boring. As are the Cybermen. Ugh…
I'll never understand people defending Revolution and Eve because Resolution is genuinely the best Chibbers Dalek story. And I didn't even vote because I never saw the community post 😂
I really like the chibs era and specifically I really like his 3 dalek stories. I'd say resolution was probably the best of the 3,but I think they are all great.
Then you're not a real Doctor Who fan!
@@MichaelM28 yeah because that's how that works. What a stupid statement. I like what I like. Moffats era is my fave along with Cartmel years. U like what you like, I like what I like
Are there any other episodes of Doctor Who that deserved more recognition than they got?
Evolution of the Daleks, Fear Her, The Time of Angels.
Not chibnall ones
Tbh I thought eve of the daleks had some of the worst dialogue of Chibnall’s era. Like I felt that it stood out to me the most in that episode.
I will always dislike the chibnall era. Since it's return this is the only era I gave up watching (haven't seen flux) but I will never hate the series new who will always be my favourite show and I can't wait to see where it goes.
I voted for Eve of the Daleks as the better one as it was an enjoyable episode through out. Every character was great there was barely a side plot and it was all relevant.
Resolution has probably Charlotte Ritchie's best ever performance. Was totally blown away. However the episode was let down by as usual Ryan's incredibly boring story and the doctor wasn't great either. And of course it's the episode where they end unit for some dumb joke
I so so much agree with you especially about Ryan's boring storyline. I found his character and that whole sideline very boring at it's best and unwatchable at it's worst. And yes I haven't watched whole segments after just seeing seconds into that plot thread. I never thought a companion could be more boring than Adric but the impossible happened. All your points on the Dalek stories ring true. Well argued and articulate thinking.
Without reading other comments first, I pretty much just put the same as you! I couldn't agree with you more. Ryan was totally pointless and the side-story about him and his dad was painful to watch. He was never a character about whom I could care, as he was just so incredibly dull. So to be entertained or enthralled by his relationship with his dad was never something that was going to happen. And that is why Resolution will never be a great Dalek story. (Still a million times better than the truly god-awful Revolution, though! :)
Really well said. I do not like the Chibnall era much at all. Three of four average episodes over three years does not stack up much.
Hi Rich. That's all😂
Well hi! 👋
@@pickupchangetoe hi! Great to see you again👋😀
Soon be over. Counting the days. Tired of making the best of a really bad situation. Dear God...
As with most Chibnall scripts, the concept is good but the execution is... lacking. Good idea, bad story, and the rest of the team on both sides of the camera doing their best to polish the turds.
"The Chibnall era hasn't been a dumpster fire in its entirety"
Yes it has
cry about it
I would agree - and I remember liking 'Resolution' - but I can't really say for sure as I didn't actually watch the most recent New Year's special. I have given up on Doctor Who for now and didn't watch series 13. The many reviews I read of it convinced me that series 13 was a confusing mess. I will stay away from the programme until the new Doctor arrives and we get a new show controller. It's a shame, because I have loved just about all of new Who since it came back in 2005, but Chibnall has done a poor job and spoiled it for me.
You're a bit late for April Fool's